Luevano v. Reid et al

Filing 9

ORDER DENYING 8 Motion for Reconsideration. This action has been and remains closed. Signed by Judge Edward C. Reed, Jr on 10/15/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

$ .

#* !

1

2 3 4

5

UN IT E D STA T E S DISTRIC T C O U R T

6
7 J I E LUEV A N O , AM
8

D IST R I T O F N E V A D A C

P e ii ne , tto r 9
V S.

2: 0 cv- 0503- C R - A M 1- 0 E R

1 0 O R D ER 1 HA R R Y REI ,e al, 1 D t. 1 2
l3

Re pondent . s s

1 4

Thi cl sed pr se m andam us ac i n by a prsoneri cust dy i Texas comes bef r so o to i n on oe

1 t e Co d on pe ion rsmo i n ( 8 f rr c nsd r t n. Th tm e f rs e ig r l fun er 5h u t i e ' to # ) o e o ie a i t o e i o e kn e i d e
1 Rul 59 hasexpied, t e m otont er f r necessarl arsesunderRul 60oft e Feder l 6 e r and h i h eo e ii y e h a
1 Rul s ofCi i Pr cedur . 7 e v! o e

18
Luevano v. Reid et al

Pettoner Jai e Luevano fl d a petton f r a wrt of m andam us nam i g as ii m i e i io i n
Doc. 9

1 r spondent Unied St t s Senat r Hary Rei and ' l Paso, Texas, Entapm ent , 9e s t ae o r d i E r s
20 Coruptons,et ,aI' He soughta wrtofm andam us t com pel m uli ititI i aton panel ri c. ' i o a td s rc i g i t

21 t r ve alo hi c s sfld i o h r eder l d/ rsa e c u t an diqu lyt ej dg s i o e iw I f s a e i n t e f a an o t t o rs d s a i h u e n e f
2 t ose cases f rbi s, He i cl ded an al gaton t atf der l at t s and r l s needed t be 2h oa nu l i h e a st u e e ue o
23 r f r ed.Pet i nerf dher l gedt athewasunl w f l convit d i a crm i al oceedi g. e om io t u al e h a ul y c e n i n pr n 24 Hi c r underyi g chal nge was diect d t t e constt tonaly cft atc nviton. s oe ln l e r e oh iu i i t h o ci

25
27

The Coud dim ised t e acton wihoutpr j die due t t e mulil def ct i t e ss h it eu c oh tpe e s n h
Pet i ner subm i a Sept m ber 1 ,2010,com m i sar pur hase r cei t t at he io t t s e O sy c e ph

26 paper pr sent d. Judgmentwas ent r d on Augus 16 2010. se e ee t

28 m ai t i s dem onstat s t at he i unabl t pay t e fl g f e. The r cei t does not nan re h s eo h ii e n ep

Dockets.Justia.com

A .

1 under i e t e basi f r he prordi m isal Pettonerdi not t erpayt e r quied $350. 0 mn h sot i s s . ii d eih her 0
2 fl g f e orsubm i a pr pery com pl t d appl aton t pr ceed i f r a paupers on t e in e i t ol ee ii oo c n om i h
3 Cour' r quied f r f ra prsonerpauperapplcaton,wih aI r quied atachm ent and ts e r o m o i ii t Ie r t s

4 acknowl dgm ent .Subm isi n ofa com m i sal r cei tafert e di m i sal e s so s e p t h s s does notchange
5 t e f c t atpettonerdi notsubm it e r quied pauperappl aton and pr persuppori g h a th ii d th e r ii c o tn 6 fnanci lm at ral w ih hi paper i ii l . Norwoul a com m isar r c it c ns iut a i a ei s t s s n ta l y d s y e e p o tt e 7 pr pery- uppored pauperappl aton even i i had been subm i ed w ih t e paper i ii l . o ls t ii c ft t t th s nta l y

8

Pettonerf rherur es t atSenat rRei ' i m uniy can be waied. Pettonerci s ii ut gh o ds m t v ii t e

9 no apposi aut ort suppodi g,orbasi f r such an al ged waier The Senat rcl ar t e h iy n s o, l e v. o el y 1 has i m uni agai stt i ac i n,and t e r m ai i g r spondentnam ed does notconstt t 0 m t y n h s to h e nn e iu e

1 aj r ial sonsu j c t sut 1 u i c per d be t o i.
1 2 1 4 Pettoners r m ai i g cont ntons ar nons nsial and/ r f nciul i cldi g hi ii ' e n n ei e ec o a f,n u n s The m oton does notdiecty addr ss t e r m ai i g bases f rdim i sal The Cour i rl e h e nn o ss. t 1 al gatons ofa ' as m assie f m i rng m ob,i c. and an ' nt r rse ki gdom em pie, 3 li e 't v v a li y n' ' e e pi n r' '

1 f dher not d:( )t atneihert i Cour nora muli ititIiaton panelhas appel t 5u e ah t hs t tds rc ig i t le a 1 j rs it no er t ereder l dsat c udst is ew r sof dam usdiqu lyn j dg s 6 u id c i v o h f a an t e o o o s u i man t s a i ig u e f 1 f ral ged bis and/ rot er iediectng t e actons r quest d bypettoner and ( )t at 7ol e a o h ws r i h ie e ii ' , bh,
1 as pettoner was seeki g t chal nge t e val i of a c nviton t at has not been 8 ii no l e h it dy o ci h 1 overur ed,hi m andam uspettonwas bared byHec v. 9 tn s ii r k Hum phr y, U. . e 512 S 477,11 S. t 4 C.

2 23 41 29 L. d.d 383 ( 9 4) 0 61 E2 19 .
21 Bot t e i ii lacton and t e m oton f rr consi er ton ar w hol f iol us. Thi h h n ta i h i oe d ai e l rv o y s 22 acton has been and r m ai s cl sed. i eno

23

I THEREFORE I ORDERED t a t e mo in ( 8)f rr c n ier t n i DENI D. T S h th to # o e o sd a i s o E

2 4
25

D T D:() AE

1F, zo) , o

2 6 27
28

C
.

w.

Unied St t s Dit itJudge t a e s rc