Arredondo v. American Home Mortgage et al

Filing 26

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that the 2 Motion to Remand is DENIED. FURTHER ORDERED that the 12 Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART. All claims are dismissed except that for statutorily defective foreclosure. FURTHER ORDER ED that defendants will not transfer the Property or take any action to evict plaintiff or his tenants, if any, for one hundred (100) days. During this period, plaintiff wi11 make full, regular monthly payments under the note every thirty(30) days, with the first payment due 04/1/2011. FURTHER ORDERED that during the injunction period, the parties will engage in the state Foreclosured Mediation Program or private mediation. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 3/24/2011. FURTHER ORDERED that plaintiff's failure to make interim payments or to participate in mediation will result in the dismissal of this case. (See Order for specifics).(Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

'

E
: ' 4

i
!

V
. r%1

!
! :
;

FL q IE E4 f E) I 8( T

? C LD E EIE ' S CE ( E /D ) N zttlf l s (,qE tz) llsui s ) l ll h zul . c

:

.

2
: i 3

MAF 2 4 2 1 I 01
.

ZL F tS : S l2 : 'FC E K J l 1FtT J' I ! '

i
!
!

a
5 6

'

B%

OS'I C NE/ A II CF F V D 8

!EFt'f ) l p

l : :

U NITED STA TES DISTRI C OUR T CT

q
5 7 8 .

.
DlsTI ICT O F N EV ADA L

:
;

J ESUS ARREDONDO, 9
Pl ntf, ai if

I 0
vs .

jj
AM ERI CAN HOM E M ORTGAGE e al, t . I 2 Def da t . en n s

I 3
14 !
!
'

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3:0-v-0520- 1c 0 RCJVPC
ORDER

Thi i a sandar f ecl ur cas i vi one pr t The Com pl nti a f t ss t d or os c e nvol ng opery. ai s ory-

1 f 5 our page M El conspiacy t com pl ntIstng el ksr ype ai i i even caus ofacton,alhough t es i t he

l elven h i e r ous y l b e a t e f t e t The c s i notpa tofCa e No.2: - d6 e t s rone l a el d s h oure n h. ae s r s 09 m

1 !
i

I 02II J i t e DititofArz bu app a se i bl f ta f r A motont djm i and a 7 9- AT n h src iona 4 e r lgi e or r nse . i o s ss
Doc. 26

Arredondo v. American Home Mortgage et al

1 m oton t r and ar pendi bef e t Cour. Fort r onsgi her n,t Cour deni 8 i o em e ng or he t he eas ven ei he t es
.

1 t m oton t r and and gr st m oton t dim is i par. 9 he i o em ant he i o s s n t 20 1. TH E PR O PER TY
'

E

'

j

2I i
.

Pl ntf es Ared oga l de AmeianHomeMorga (s ia ' a ai ifl us r ond ve en r rc t ge I Amerc n' )

2 $ 00 pr sor n e,sc e b ade do tus (DOT ) t pur as pr erya 7 Tal 2 227, 0 omis y ot e urd y e f r t ,o ch e op t t 460 l

I

:

23 Grs Dr,Ren NV 8 (heCpr ry' .Se DOT, 23,20 ,ECFNo.1 8.Stwat as . o, 9506 t s opet ' ( e ) Nov. 05 2-) e r
2 Til ofNorhenNe datç ewaf'wast tuse ( ei j Pl nifdefule Fis 4 te t r va s st l l he r te.Se d.. aitf a td, rt
25 Am eri Til , a a tf Rec r t , A.fldan ieofd aul(NOD'.Se NOD, can te s gen or ontus co.N. , i e otc ef t $ 6 '(e )

!

:
! :

I

Dockets.Justia.com

.
> . '

'
. '

:

l June23, 20 ECFNo.I - 0 .M ERSs si tdRe ntus astuse f Stwart e d ys 09, 21) ub tt e co r t r te or e thre a u

i
!
!

2 ltr ( eSubsiui J e2 200 ECFNo.2 a 5.Re ntus s e e atuseess e ae .dc ttton, un 6, 9, 3, t ) co r t ch duld r t ' al 3 f Ocobe 1 ,2009.Se Notc ofTr tesSal (NOS ) Se . ,2009 ECFNo.l 11. or t r 6 ( e ie use e , pt25 , 2- )
4 I. I
5

ANA LYSI S
The f ecl ur waspot i l st ut iy i pr , becauset f ecl ng entt had or os e entaly at orl m oper he or osi iy

6 n ye be n s tt e i a tu tewh n i Gldt eNOD. eNev. v.Stt j l 08 2 ( ) ot t e ubsiutd n s r se e t e h Se Re a . ' 07. 0( )c .
E
;
!

7 The af imatve cl m sf lf r onsgi i ot subsantvel i i cases. N o nuances fr i ai ai or eas ven n her t i y dentcal 8 appeari t scase i t r d. n hi n hat egar

9

Pl n ifh s a s fl d a moto t r ai tf a l o ie i n o emand f l c off de alque ton o di r iy or a k e r - s i r ve st

1 j iditon.Tbeei b h.Pl ntf brngsnof rlc us ofa tondiecl bu h b igsa 0 urs ci r s 0t ai if i edea a es ci r ty, t e rn
l s a e cl m u rN RS s c i 6 370 whi i pr ie e iel on vi a i ofs a da ds I t t ai nde e ton 49. , ch s em s d ntr y ol tons t n r l t tgi rs t a i de de f d alc ai unde t Fai Deb Cole i Pr c i sA c 2 ha ve ie o n n pen nt e er l m r he r t lcton a tce t

l (I 3 S FDCPA' .Thi cai s olsfdea j rs ci f t f l n ra on . ' s l m upp ' e rl uiditon orhe olowig e s s ) t
1

1 4
(

Fis , h r ap a st b no prva e rgh ofa ton un rN RS s c i 649. 70, s t r t t e e pe r o e i t i t ci de e ton 3 ' o he

I cl i m us be c tue a a f er cl i diec l und FDCPA . S on e n a s i a 5 am t ons r d s ed al a m r ty er ec d, ve s um ng l prva e s a eca e ofa ton,a t h m os f de alque ton c e a e ba e on f r lc ai , 6 i t t t us c i lhoug t e r - s i as s r s d ede a l ms

l fder - e tonj iditonc bebae pur yonasaecl m i isrs utonn ce srl 7 e alqu si urs ci an sd el tt ai f t e ol i e saiy
1 r quie t e c s r ton off der l w : 8 e r s h on tuc i e al a
19 The r e i wel s ted t a sat cl m tari under'f alI ti t ul s l etl hat t e ai s ses ' eder aw 'f he com pl nt pr ai , operl pl y eaded,pr esent asubst i di e overt ef ectoff der s antal sput he f e al

20
! 2I

:
'

22
23
24

lw, dter ultr ont fdeal si 'Gui sovPa Fis Fe Sav a an h es tuns he e r queton. na s . csc rt d. . ' d foanAs ' 65 F. l 4,1 -66(t Ci.l I, er. nid, 5U. 1 r sn, 6 2d 36 365 9h r 98 )c /de e 45 S. 020, I S CtI I 72L. 2d1 8( 98 .The:vasmao i o c ssbr gjt nj 02 t t j rt f ae ou j u ter . 7 6, Ed. 3 1 2) y t ge rlfdea- si j rs ci oft fdealc rsaet e i whi ' he nea e rlqueton u iditon he e r ou t r hos n ch f er lw ce tste c us ofa tonlq'Mere/Dow Phar euial I .v ed al a rae h a e ci a' r / mac tc s nc . Tho on, U. 80 80 1 S. .3 323 92L.Ed.2 65 (1 6) but mps 478 S. 4, 8, 06 Ct 229, 2, d 0 98 ,
.

a c s m a alo a i eun f de al a t whe et vi c ton o a rght dersa e a e y s rs der e r 1 w t r he ndi a i f i un t tt

l t tdam ages' 'caus ofacton ' nortator sf 'appearanyw her i Chapt Neiher t 's e i ' t t ney' ees' en er 25 649 The Chapt pr desonl f crm i ' er ovi ' y or i nalpenali oradm i s r i Gnes.SeeN ev.Rev. tes nitatve .
:

St t jj649. 6 4 a. 435, 49.40.
p C 2 of 4 ag

!

1 2

lw n es rl t nl) s c tuci offdeala ' I.quoi Fr nc s a ec saiy ur s on ome onsr ton e r lw.' d ( tng a hie '
1'x Bd.v.Const i Labor s Vacaton Trust 463 U . 1,9,103 S.Ct 284 l Ft z ructon er i , S. , ,

284 77L.Ed.2d420( 9831. 6, 1 2

3

fe s 3 F.d422 423( hCi.1 4) I J ess ha teprs nton wh ete a on, 2 3 , 9t r 99 . n as uc s h e e e, er h
saecam die tyi or ae tes sa eoff er Iw,eeNe Re Stt 9649. a tt li rcl nc ports h ub tnc ed ala s v. v a. 370, nd

5 wh etesaecai r s sn fdea c ttton is s fdealquetonj idito e ss er h tt l m aie o e rl onsiui alsue ,c r - si urs cin xit
onl i t f all t i i por ed i o t sat cl m pr des an i y f he eder aw hat s ncor at nt he t e ai ovi ndependentf al eder cl m : ai I M err lD ow Phar n el maceutcal I v.Thompson,478 U. 804,! S.Ct i s nc. S. 06 .

3 2 ,9 L.Ed 2 6 0 ( 9 6,te Co l c n iee i d ti tekrn ilso 29 2 . d 5 1 8 ) h u' o sd rd n eal h icpe f t rmovalurs ctonwhenapple t awelpla dc ai t tr lsonasae e j idi i id o l- e de ompl ntha ele tt c u eo a to whc ic r o ae fd r la a o eofh ee nso rc v r . a s f cin ih n o p rts e ea Iw s n te lme t f e o ey
11 The Cour hel t i such a case,t st e cl m does noti ve a s t l t d hat n he at ai nvol ubs antai f alques i unl t f al l i por ed i t s at cause of acton eder ton ess he eder aw ncor at n he t e i pr desa f alprvat rghtofacton f isvi aton.f 1 S.Ct at3237'see ovi eder i e i i or t ol i #. 06 . ,

alo Ute v V i As oc, nc,8llF. *279( t Ci. ( ppl ngMer elDtwl s ly . aran s .I . 2d 1 9 h r) a yi rl / , c r.de id, 4U, 8 1 S. .89 98L. 2d50(987) e / ne 48 S. 24, 08 Ct , Ed. I .

Et i v Har orHou eRe t,86lF. 1 9,1 4n. (t Ci.I 8) Th FDCPA povi s hrdge . b s s. 2d 38 39 4 9h r 98 . e r de
aprv t rgh ofa i Se l U. C. 1 ia e i t cton. e 5 S. j 692k.I NRS s c i 649. 0 c ai d a tona f e ton 37 ont ne ddii l
s t i bas f Iabiiy apar f om FDCPA ,t such bas oflabiiy coul be i ubs antve es br i lt tr hen es i lt d nvoked

wih ce tngfdealque tonj iditon Bu s ci 6 370r er e l iel a d tout rai e r - si urs ci . t e ton 49. ef s xcusv y n
coext vel t FDCPA f is subs ance and pr des no basi f iabiiy apar f om t ensi y o or t t ovi s or i lt t r hat

pr vi d f i FDCPA ,u rwhi h a prva e f er rg ofa ton l . The Co tt r br o de or n nde c i t , ed al i ht c i i es ur he ef e fndst tev n i : prva e c us ofa ton I u rs c i 649. 0,s c a cl m w oul i ha e f i t a e c i i nde e ton ed 37 u h ai d

s por fd alqu tonj iditon. hrdge 861F. a 1 94n. up t e er - esi urs ci Et l , 2d t 3 4.
21 N ext Pl ntf i di se f om al pari cxceptSt , ai if s ver r I tes ewar, N o pl bl cl m les agai t t ausi e ai i ns

St war, he orgi t u t e, c us i i Fis Am t i a Til a d Re ontus ,n St wa t w h e tt i nal r s e be a e t s r t rc n te n c r t ot e r , o ar ale d t h ve f ecl e a t s i ob ousy t e c e ba e on r c d ofw hi h t Cour e l ge o a or os d, nd hi s vi l h as s d e or s c he t

I

ryaeuianteSwrwu hvbet poeetyooele n t jdi oc.t a ol aeenh rprnttf cs. a k cl i e t d e i ro
// / Page 3 of 4

1 I

'

* .

y

m .

1

i ! l E
I CO NC LUSIO N

2
!

I I HEREBY ORDERED t tt Moi t Reman ( No.2 i DENI TS ha he ton o d ECF )s ED. I I FURTHER ORDERED ta teM oi t Dimis( No.1 )i GRANTED i TS h t h ton o s s ECF 2 s n

E
'
;

3

4 par and D EN I i par. A l cl m sar di i ed exceptt f st ut l def i t ED n t l ai e sm ss hat or at oriy ectve 5 f ecl ur or os e.

;
:

(

6
i

I I FURTH ER O RD ERED t a De e an sw ilno tans e t Pr ry ort ke a T S h t f nd t l t r f r he ope t a ny

.

7 aci t e c Pli iforhi tna s ian fom t Pr ryf onehun e (00)da s ton o vit antf s e nt,f y, r he opet or - drd 1 y.
8 Durng t sperod,Pl ntf w i1m ake f l r arm ont y paym ent undtrt not ever t ry i hi i ai if 1 ul, egul hl s he e y hit
'

9 ( 0)da s wiht efrtpa 3 y , t h is ymen du AprlI 20I1 Th a t e i, . e mountofe h p ymen wil ac a t l be
! I a or n t t emont y p yme a oft edaeoft eNOD. Pl n ifne d no p y It f e or 0 cc dig o h hl a nt s h t h aitf e t a a c e s

I
;

l c r tee tr a u t fp s d fut thstmeb t yb rqurdi e ut t c r teetr l ue h nie mo n o at ea la ti i u ma e e i n q i o ue h nie e y
l p tdea ta ac dii ofa ftr pema en ij ci 2 as ful s on ton ny uue r n t nun ton. l 3 I I FURTHER ORDERED ta dui t ij ci pe i t pate wile ga i TS h t rng he nun ton rod he ris l n ge n
l t sat For osur M edi i Pr am ,i avaiabl I notavaiabl Def 4 he t e ecl e aton ogr f l e. f l e, endant w ilconduct s l
.

'
;
.

:

1 a prv t m e a i w ih Pl n ifi go f t The b fci r m u ts n a r pr s t i t 5 i a e di ton t ai tf n od ai h. ene i a y s e d e e en atve o l t e medi ton w ih a ua a hort t modiy t n e, t ugh a t lm odii a i i no 6 h ai t ct l ut iy o f he ot alho c ua fc ton s t
I7 r r Pl ntf ilpr de r equied. ai ifw l ovi equesed i or a i t Def t nf m ton o endant i advance oft medi i sn he aton

I ig ft 8 n ood aih.
I9 I I FURTH ER O RD ERED t Pl ntf f l e t make i erm payment ort T S hat ai ips aiur o nt i s o

20 pari i t i medi ton w ilr ul i di m is loft e c e. tc pa e n ai l es t n s s a h as
2I I I SO O RDERED . T S

22 Dat t s 24t day ofM ar 2O11. ed hi h ch,
23
;

'

.

24

: (

25

RO T C.J ES ON Unied at Dit i J t es s rct udge '

Page 4 of 4 @
ë

: