Amarilla v. Mar

Filing 5

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that the Clerk shall detach and file the 1 Complaint, which is DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE AND WITH LEAVE TO AMEND. FURTH ORD that P shall be granted 30 days from the date of entry of this order to file and serve upon counsel for D an amended Signed by Magistrate Judge Robert A. McQuaid, Jr on 12/15/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - PM)

Download PDF
y ukur y, .s . ..(yJ .: ;, j,.; t ' l ; ;jjz) (, ..j(, (.,, ,.j ;y )j , ,. . ., . , . .. . . . .. .. . j r' l . ,p :. ; I j ; ..... . ..y . : l 2 ( (- ggsy : )g ; g g ! p ' j @ i , ! I ' k. .-. . ( - -. ) .' - .. -. . . '' - . .. - . . j - ' , - s.,I... ., , . .....: . : ... t . p . T ; j 4 5 UN I ED STA T E S D I TR I T C O U R T T S C 6 7 DI TR I T OF NEVADA S C 8 J LI ANTONI AM ARI LA, UO O L 9 Pli tf, a n if l vs 0. 11 DAVI M AR,e a1, D t. 1 2 13 Dee da t. fn n s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) / 3: 0- v- 5 2- RH - A M 1 c 05 L R ORDER 1 4 Befr teCour aeDee da tsPettonf rRe ova ( oc et/1,Pli tf sPr Se oe h t r fn n ' ii o m l D k /) an if o 1 Ci iRi hsComplit( oc e /1 Exhi iA)a dDee da t'Sttme tofRe oval( ocke /5, 5 vl g t an D k t /, bt n fn n s ae n m D t/) 1 a dDee d nt'Re o a SttsRe or ( oc e /3 . 6 n fn a s m v l au p t D k t/) l7 1. Amarilla v. Mar R em ovaloft i A cti n w as Proper hs o 18 Pl i tf ,a i m a e a N orhe ' N e a a Cor e tonalCe t r fl d upr s c vi rght a n if n n t t t l n vd rci n e, e o e i li s Doc. 5 1 co pl i ti t e Seve t J di ilDiti tCo r oft e St t ofNe a ai t eCount ofW hiePi e. 9 m an n h n h u c a src u t h ae vd nh y tn 20 Def nda tM a wass r e on o abo tAugus 1 , 0. Def nd nt fld aNotc ofRe ova i en r evd ru t 0 201 e a s ie ie m ln 21 t i Co r o S p e b r9 2 1 ( o k t/1.l edsrc c u t s al a eo ii a j rs ito o hs u t n e tm e , 0 0 D c e /) s- itit o rs h lh v rgn lu idcin f -h 22 a1ci ia tonsunde t eConsiuton,a s orte te oft eUnie Stts' 28U. . .j 1 31. l v l ci rh tt i lw , rais h td ae .' SC 3 23 Pl i t f ha a l ge a vi l ton ofhi rght unde t e U . . a n i f s le d oai si s rh S Cons iuton. D e e da t ap r pra el tt i f n n s p o it y 24 rmovedt eaci nt t i Co r purua tt 28U. . .j 1 41 a t i Cour ha o iia j rs iton e h to o h s u t s n o SC 4 , s hs t s rgn l u idci 25 ove t e c ai sr i e i t e c m pl i t r h l m a s d n h o an . 26 Dockets.Justia.com 1 l. I Sc ee i g oft eCompl i t r nn h an 2 Thec mpli tmus besr e e purua tt 28U. . .j1 1 A .Fe ea e ursmus o an t cen d s n o SC ' 9 5 d rl o t t 3 conduc a p e i i a y s r e i g i a y ca e i whi h a p i one s e s r dr s f om a gove z e t l t r lm n r c e n n n n s n c rs r e k e e s r n m na 4 e tt orofi e ore plye ofagovenm e tle tt . e28U.. .j 1 l a) I isr viw,he n iy tc r m o e r na n iy Se SC 9 5A( .n t e e t 5 c ur m us i e tf an c gni a l c a m sa d dim i s a y cl i s t a a e fi ol us m alc o s f i t o t t d n iy y o z b e l i n s s n a m h t r rv o , ii u , a l o 6 sat a cai u on whi h r le ma begr n e ors e m onear r le fo ade e da twho i te lm p c e if y a td e k t y eif r m fn n s 7 i munefo s c r le . U. . .j 1 15A( )1,2) Pr s pla igs ho e e,mus belbealy m r ' m u h eif 28 S C 9 b ( )( . o e e d n , w v r t i r l 8 eo sr ed.Balsr r v Pacjc PolceDe t 901F.d696, (tCi.988) Tosaeacli n tu ite i . lla i p t , 2 699 9h r1 . tt am 9 unde 42U. . .j 1 aplitf mus alget oese ta ee e t:( )t a arghtscuedbyt e r S C 983, anif t le w s nil lm n s 1 h t i e r h 1 Consiuton orl wsoft e Unie St tswa vi l td,an ( )t a t eale ed vi l ton wa 0 tt i a h td a e s o a e d 2 h t h lg oai s 11 c m m it d by ape s n a tng unde t ec l rofsa el w . We tv At i s 487U . . 48 o te ro ci rh oo tt a See s . k n , S 42, 1 ( 988) 21. 1 3 I a dio t t esre igrq ie e t u d rj l 5 , fd r l o r mu tds is n d t n o h ce nn e ur m n s n e 91 A a e ea c u t s im s i 1 aprs ne ' cli s i t ea lga i n ofpo e t i untt , ori t e a ton i fi ol usor 4 io rs am ,f h le to v ry s rl ' f h c i bs rv o e' 1 malci us' aist saea cai on whih r lefma begr nt ds orts e sm one a' r lefa ans 5 i o r l o tt l m 'f c ei y a e ' e k ' tl ei g i t y 1 ad fn a twhoi i m u efo s c rle ' 2 U. . . 1 5 e( ) 4 U. . . 1 9 ec () ( ) 6 ee d n s m n r m u h eif ' 8 SC j 91 ()2 ; 2 SC j 9 7 ()1 ,2 . 1 D im i s lofa c m pl i tf rf iur t s a e a c ai upon w hi h r lefm a be gr nt d i pr vi ed f r 7 s sa o an o a l e o tt l m c ei y aes od o 1 i Fe ea Rul ofCi iPr c dur 1 ()6 , teCour a ple tesm esa dar whe r viwig 8 n d rl e v l o e e 2 b () and h t p is h a tn d n e e n 1 t ea equa y ofac m pl i to ame ded c m pl i t 9hd c o an r n o an . 20 Re iw unde Rul 1 ( )6)i e sntalyar lngonaquesinoflw ,SeeCha pe ve r e 2 b ( s se i l u i to a pl 21 v Labo atr Cor .o Ame ia,23 F.d71 ,723(t Ci. ) Dim is lf rfiur t saea . r o y p f rc 2 3 9 9h r 2000 , s sa o al e o tt 22 c ai i pr pe onl i i i c e rt a t e pl i tf ca notpr ve an s toff c s i s ppor oft e cl i l m s o r y f t s l a h t h a n if n o ye at n u t h am 23 ta woude ttehi o he t rle Se Ai re r Wale ,1 F.d756,759( t Ci.1 9) I h t l nil m r r o eif e o ly . k r 75 3 9h r 99 . n 2 ma i gt i deer i a i n, heCour t kesastu a lal ga i nsofm a e i lf c saed i t e 4 k n h s t m n to t ta r e l le to t ra a t t t n h 25 c m pl i t a dt eCour consr e t e i t e lghtm os f vor bl t t epl i tf. Se War haw v o an, n h t tu s h m n h i t a a e o h a n if e s . 26 Xo aCor .74F.d 955,957(t Ci.1 96) Ale ai nsi apr s c mplitaehel t ls m p, 3 9h r 9 . lg to n o e o an r d o e s 2 1 srngen sa da dst an f nnalpl a i gsd afe by lw ye s Se Hughe v Rowe 449 U. .5, ti t tn r h o e dn r ld a r. e s. , S9 2 ( 9 0 . ie v Ke n r 4 4 U. . 9, 2 - 1( 9 2 +e c ra ) 1 8 ) Han s . r e , 0 S 51 5 0 2 1 7 ) r u im . , 3 I t ei sa tc m pli t pli tf alege t a hehaspr vi usy bee e am i e by n h n tn o a n , a n if l s h t eol n x nd 4 s e i ls s i c u i g a or h pa di d c orw ho a 1c nc ude t atpl i tf r quieskne s r e y. H e p c a it , n l d n n t o e c o t 1ol h a n if e r e ug r 5 f rt eralegest att e def ndanthasr fused t ar ange f rt e s r er ort t ke any acton f r uh l hh e te or o h ug y o a io 6 s c s r ey. Pli tf a lgest i f iur t a tc nsiu e delbe aei dif r nc t as rous u h u g l ' an if le h s a l e o c o tt t s i r t n fe e e o e i ' 7 m e i a ne d vi l tng hi rght unde t e Ei ht a d Foure n h A m e d e t . d c l e oai si s rh g h n te t n m ns 8 A pr s ne ' cl i ofi a eq at m e i a c r doesnotc ns iu e c uela d u us al io r s a m n d u e dcl ae o tt t r n nu 9 pu ihm e tu l s t e m i tea m en rs st t e l velofi elber t i dif r nc t s r ous m edi a ns n nes h sr t t ie o h e i ae n fe e e o e i d cl 1 ne ds' Esel v Gambl, U..97,1 6( 976) Thed lbert idifrnc 'smz a divoles 0 e . tle . ' e 429 S 01 . iei ae n fee e't d r n v 11 a obeci eandas b e tveprng.Fis,t ealge de rvainmus be i ob e tvetr s n j tv u j ci o rt h le d p i to t ,n j ci em , 1 t ufiinty srous'Far erv. e n n,511U..8 5,834( 994)(ii gWis nv Setr 501 2 fce l ei . m s ' Br n a S2 1 ctn lo . ie , l U. . 298( 991) Se o d,heprs nofiilmus a twihal ufiintyc la l saeof 3 S 294, 1 ). c n t io fca t c t t tce l u p b e tt s 1 m i d,' c e tismor t a m e eneg i e c ,b tl s t a c nduc unde tken f rt ever 4 n 'whih n a l e hn r lg n e u e s h n o t ra oh y 1 pur os ofca sng ha m .Far e v Br nn n,511U. .a 837. A prs n o fcaldoe notac i a 5 pe ui r mr, e a St io fi i s tn 1 de i e a e y i dif r ntm a ne unl s t e ofi i li now sofand di r ga dsa e c s i e r s t 6 lb r t l n f e e n r e s h tca k s e r n x e sv ik o 1 i m a e he lh ors f t . f . 7 n t at aey' # ' 1 8 Pl i tf f is t i entf how t e f iur t a r nge f rt e kne s r e y hase pos d a n if a l o d iy h a l e o ra oh e ug r xe 1 hi t an e c s i e rs t hi he lh or s f t , He d esnoti f r t e c u tort e de e da t of 9 mo x e sv i k o s a t aey o nom h o r h fn n s 20 wha wilhap e i hei no gi e t es r e j. M e ede i lofs r e y i i s fii ntt sae a t l p n f s t v n h u g r, r n a u g r s n u fce o t t 21 c am .Thec m pl i ts a lbedim is d wih lavet a e d. li o an h l s se t e omn 22 I I TH E R E F O R E O R D E R E D t a t e Cl r s a ld t ch a d f l t e c m pl i t TS h t h e k h l e a n ie h o a n 23 (ocke #1 Exhii B) whihi DI M I SED W I H OUT PREJUDI E AND W I H LEAVE d t , bt , c s S S T C T 2 TO AM EN D . 4 25 I I FURTHER ORDERED pl i tf s a lbe g an e t it da sfo t e d t of TS a n if h l r t d h ry y r m h a e 26 e tyoft i or e t fl a d s r eupon c uns lf rt ede e d nta ame ded c m pli ta dr s i g nr h s d r o ie n e v o e o h fn a n n o an d e sn 3 1 t e de i i n y no e her i . Fa l r t fl t e a ende c m pl i ti a tm e y m anne w ilr s l i h fce c t d e n iu e o ie h m d o an n i l r l eu t n e tyo j d me ta dt eco u eof hsa to . nr f u g n n h l s r t i cin D A TE D : D e e be 1 ,2010. cm r 5 U N I ED STA T E S M G I T R A T E J D G E T S U 4

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?