Pratt v. Minnix et al

Filing 4

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that plaintiff's 2 Motion/Application for Leave to Proceed in forma pauperis is GRANTED. Plaintiff has paid the initial installment fee of $4.60. Even if this case is dismissed, the full filing fee shall be due. the NDOC shall pay the Clerk 20% of the preceding month's deposits to plaintiff's account in month's that the account exceeds $10.00 until the full $350.00 filing fee is paid. The Clerk shall send a copy of this order to Albert G. Peralta, Chief of Inmate Services, NDOP (ack'd). FURTHER ORDERED that the Clerk shall file the complaint [2-1]. FURTHER ORDERED that plaintiff's claims MAY PROCEED. FURTHER ORDERED that defendants' shall file an a nswer/response to the complaint within thirty (30) days following the early inmate mediation. If the Court declines to mediate, the answer/response shall be due within thirty (30) days following the order declining mediation. FURTHER ORDERED that t he parties shall detach and file the attached Notice of Intent to Proceed With Mediation form within thirty (30) days. Plaintiff shall serve defendants with all pleadings. (See Order for specifics. Copy of Order sent to Finance, LV.) (Notice of Compliance is due by 1/16/2011. Responses due by 1/16/2011.) Signed by Magistrate Judge Valerie P. Cooke on 12/16/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

) 1
l

k) y.1uFE' ik t z tl
'
.

,

' ..

l
2 2 : E ! ;
4 5

! ;
'

. .

c - - .. l ; .y t . - , ,. -; ()J$r 7lfku : ;():1 2'' . . r '- '$;.; (yt ) u.l ' .. . - . .. . -T '

r. -) l ..
f

. J

,
f ! ! )
l.v ,r a

g s:sg: k Eg g
l j j-.-.... j .-- .'- ..''7E1 .l .-.-;r' 1I iu. ..:.-, l. ' .. . . 1 -.. $ (,...' :..-, .-... ë .' : i tL .$wiu p. .1 )
. .
-. .... . . . - -. . - -. .

!
1

j
h ;

î . =-- == '' =

' '

u.= ; . s

h' .r ?.Cf .- -u . .7 l -u

6
7 8 9 10 U N I E D STA T E S DI T R I T C O U R T T S C

D I TR I T OF NEVADA SC

11 1 2

J COB RAM I PRATT, A E #88 1 83 Plitf, an if

l vs 3. 1 MI NI ,e al, 4 N X t. 1 5
1 6

Dee da t. fn ns

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
/

3:0-v- 0615- CJVPC 1c0 RORDER

1 7
-VPC Pratt v. Minnix et al

Thi i a prs ne cii rght a to fldpurua tt 42 U. . .j 1983.Plitf s s s io r vl i s cin ie sno SC an ip
Doc. 4

1 a piaint p o e d i f r apau e i i g a td( o k t/ ) Ba e o teif r ainrgadn 8 p lc to o r c e n o m p rs s rn e d c e / . s d n h n o m to e r ig 2
1 pl i tf slna c a s a usi t e A p lca i n t Pr c e i Fo m a Pau e i ,p a n ifi r quie t pa 9 a n if i n i l t t n h p i to o o e d n r p r s l i tf s e r d o y

20 a iiilisal e tofteflngf eplrua tt 28U., ,j1 1 n n ta n tlm n h ii e zs n o SC 9 5. 21 Thegr ntofi f r apau e i sausadusstemnou toft eflngfet a plitf a n om p rs tt j t h n h ii e h t an if
22 mus prpl - pl i tf ha ale dypr pad hi i iili sal entof$4.0, nse d o ha i gt pr pa t c y - an if s r a e i s n ta n tlm 6 i ta f v n o e y 23 t e f l $35 tlng f e f r t i aci n. The e tr $350 flng f e wil howe e ,r m a n due fom h u l 0 ii e o h s to n ie ii e l, vr e i r
24 pl i tf, ndt ei siutonwhe epli tf i i c r e a e wilc le t a n if a h n tt i r an if s n a c r t d l o l c mone t war t ep y e toft e yo dh am n h
25 f l tlng f e whe peii ne ' i siu i nala cot tha a s f ci n baa ce,puruan t 28 U . . . u l ii e n tto r s n tt to c m s u s e t ln s to SC

26 j1 15.Thee tr $350slngfewilrm an duea dpa a l,andwilbec le tdfom plitf s 9 n ie i e le i n y be l o lce r anip

Dockets.Justia.com

1 i s iutona ac oun r ga dl s oft e ou c m e oft i a ton. The c ur now s r e s t e c m pl i t n tt i l c t e r e s h t o h s ci ot c e n h o an . 2 1 Scr e i g St ndar . enn a d

3

Purua tt t ePrs ne Lii ai nReonn Ac ( LRA) fdealc ursmus dimisa s n o h io r tg to f tP ,e r o t t s s

4 prs ne ' cli s e ft e al gai n ofpove t i untu ,'ori t eaci n ç sfi ol usorm ai i us' io r s am , t h le to i ry s r e ' f h to ç rv o i lco ,'
5 ûf ist s at acl i on w hi h r lefm ay be gr nt dr' ls eksm onet r r lefagai stadef ndantw ho ta l o t e a m c ei a e 'or çe ay ei n e

6 i i munefom s c r lef' 28U. . .j 1 1 ()2) A cam i lgalyfi oluswhe i lc san sm r u h ei . ' S C 9 5 e( . li s e l rv o n t ak
7 a g a l ba i eteri lw ori fc , ez ev Wilams 490U. . 9,3 5( 989) Thec ur ma , r u be ss ih n a n a t Nitk . li , S 31 2 1 . ot y
8 t e e or ,dim i sa ca m asfi ol uswhe ei i bas d on a i diputbl m e il s l ga t e r or h r f e s s li rv o r ts e n n s a y rte s e l h o y 9 wher t e f ct a co tntons a e c e ry ba e e s 1 .a 327.The c iia i q iy i whehe a e h a u l ne i r la l s l s . d t rtc l n u r s tr 1 c nsiuto a cli ,howe e i a tuly plade ,hasa a gua l l ga and f cua ba i.SeeJac s n 0 o tt i n l a m v r n rf l e d n r be e l a t l ss ko

11 v Arion ,885F.d 63 , (tCi.1 8 ) . za 2 9 640 9h r 9 9 .
1 2 Dim i s lofaco pl i tf rf iur t sa eacai upon whi hr lefm a begr nt di s sa m an o a l e o tt l m c ei y ae s

1 pr viedf ri Fe erlRul ofCiiPr c dur 1 ( )6) a dt ec ur a ple tes mesa da dunde 3 od on da e v l o e e 2 b ( , n h o t p is h a tn r r

1 Secin 1 1 ()2)whenrviwigtea e ua yofac mplitora e de c mplit Reviw un e 4 to 9 5 e( e e n h dq c o an m n d o an , e d r l Rul 1 ()6)i e s ntal anzigonaquesinoflw.Se Cha pe v. abor tr Cor .fAme ia, 5 e 2 b ( s s e ily ln to a e p l f aoy p o rc 1 232F.d71 , ( t Ci.2000 .A c mplitmus c nti moet a aGor uli rcttonoft e 6 3 9 723 9h r ) o an t o an r h n ç m ac e iai f h
1 elm e t ofaca s o a toni i m us c nt i f ct a alegai nss fi i n t ç aie a rghtt r lef 7 e ns u e f c i ' t t o an a u l l to u fce t o ç s i o ei ' r 1 a ove t e s ec ltve lvel' Be lAtantc Cor .v.Twombl ,550 U. .544,1 7 S.Ct 1 55,1 8b h p uai e . l l i ' p y S 2 .9 965

1 ( 007) Gf epla igmus c nti s m ehi gmor .. a .. sae entoffcst a merl ceaesa 9 2 . ç' e dn -h t o an o t n e.h n.a ttm t a t h t ey r t 20 s s iin l f algal c gnia l rghtofa ton, f .I r viwigac m plitunde t i sa da d, u p to o j e ly o z be i ci ' # n e e n o an ' r hs tn r
21 t e c ur mus a ce tast l t e ale a i ns oft e c m pl i ti quesi n,Ho pialBl g.Co.v Re h o t tc p n e h lg to h o an n to st d .x

2 Hos ialT u te ,425 U. .738,740 (976 ,c nsr et e pla i g i t e lghtmos fvo a l t 2 p t r se s S 1 ) o tu h e dn n h i t a r be o

23 plitf a dr s l ealdou t i teplitf sfvor Je kisv Mc kihe , U. . 1 421( 969) an if n e ov l b s n h anif a . n n . h t n 395 S 41 , 1 ,
24 A le a i ns i a pr s c m pl i t ar he d t l s s rnge t s a da ds t a f nnal l g to n o e o a n e l o e s ti n t n r h n o

25 pla i gsdr fe bylwye s SeeHu hesv At c 449U. .5,9( 980 ;Haie v Ke ne ,404U. . e d n a td a r. g .p , w S 1 ) ns . r r S

26 51 , 2 - 1( 9 2 @e c ra ) s ealoBa ite i . c c Po ieDe ' 9 1F.d 6 6 6 9( t 9 5 0 2 1 7 ) r u im ; e s lsr r v Pa @ a lc p t 0 2 9 , 9 9h ,
2

1 Ci.1 90 .A1orpatofac mplitfldbyaprs ne ma bedimisds as ont,howe e,i te r9) 1 r o an ie io r y s se u p e v r fh
2 prs ne ' cli slck a mgua l basset eri 1w ori f d . Thi i cl de cli sba e on l g l io rs am a n b e i ih n a na s n u s am sd ea

3 c ncuso st a ar untna l (..cam sag is defnda t whoaei mun fom s iorcli sof o l in h t e e be eg li an t e n s r m e r ut am 4 ifi g me tofalga itr s whihcla l doe note it, wela cli sbasdo fnciulfcual n rn e n e ln ee t c e ry s x s)as l s am e n a f at 5 algains(. .a tsi ordelsona s e a is.SeeNeiz e, U. .t327- 8; e aloM c e v r le to eg fna tc u i l c n ro ) tk 490 S a 2 se s K e e 6 v Blc ,932F.d795, ( t Ci.1 91 . . ok 2 798 9h r 9 ) 7 Tos sai anacin u de s cin 1 aplitf mus s ow ()ta teconduc ut n to n r e to 983, an if t h 1 h t h t 8 c mplie ofwascommitd b ape s n a tng unde c l rofsaelw ;a d ()tatteco duct o an d te y ro ci r oo tt a n 2 h h n
9 d prved t e pl i tf ofa f de alc ns iutona ors a ut r r g t' Hydr c v H unt r 466 F. d 676, ei h a n if e r o tt i l t t o y i h . ' ik . e, 3

1 689(tCi.2006 . 0 9b r )
11 I . Ins antC om pl i t I t an

1 2

Plitf, i ic r eaeda E1 Stt Prs n(ç SP', ss e c re tonal fc r an if who s n ae rt t y ae io <E ' ha u d o rci ofies )

1 M i ni , r i s Hor ly,De ds Posm a ,a d Doe 14,Pli tf cli st ef low i g:on J nua' 3 n x Pe k n , se e, tnn san if a m h o l n al y
1 31 201 of i e sf r e uly e t a t d anum be ofi m a e f om t e rce l w ho w e ei vol e i a s r e 4 , 0, fc r o c f l x r c e r n t s r h i ls r n v d n eis

1 ofi m a ep o e t .Du i gt epr t s, e da tofie sa dot e ofie se ta t dpli tf fom hi 5 n t r t s s rn h o e t def n n fc r n h r fc r x r c e an if ' r s 1 ce l M i ni lnedu ofier o t i epl i tf sc l a di snzt dPe ki st t nlof t evi e ca er , 6 l. n x i p fc s u sd an if e l n n t c e r n o u fh d o m a 1 whih he di . The e t r d pl i tf ' c l a d us d c e ialag nt,a d a trpli tf wa f ly 7 c d y n e e an ifs e l n e h m c e s n fe a n if s u l

18 r sr i e ,punc ed hi r pe t dl sbr ke hi nos ,c thi lps s as e hi hea on t e foora d e ta n d h m e ae y o s e u s i , m hd s d hl n
1 aga ns w als r pe t dl ,and r m m e hi he d i t s ve als lypor do r . A t s m e poi tM i ni 9 i t l e ae y n d s a n o e r al t o s o n nx

20 at c e adogl as t pl i tf sc fsa dpuled i f r e uly t r ugh t e f od soti pl i tf sc l ta h d e h o an if u f n l toc f l h o h o l n a n if c l

21 d o ,c tig hi am s Pli t fs fee ij re icu ig c nc si n s oln e e ,l s h a i o r ut n s r , an i u frd nu is n ldn o u so , w le y s i , e vl f p y 22 br ie fce,br ke nos ,los ne teh,a d ç ij itd'tngesa d tum bs M ini prve td us d a o n e o e d e t n ç son e 'i r n h d . n x e ne
23 m e i a pe s nnel r m r nde i gas itnc , i efo wi i gs m ebl odfom pl i tf sf ce.W he dc l ro fo e rn ssa e asd r m p n o or an if a n

2 pl i tf wasr t r e t hi c l, ol Doe#4, hes ni rs it fc r i nor dhi r quessf rm e i a 4 an if eu n d o s e l J m t e o h f ofi e , g e s e t o d c l
25 at nton a d as ow e . He a ke t efoorofi e f ra me ialkiea d wa t l lt e s ni rwilno te i n hr s dh l tc r o dc t n s o d ûh e o l t 26 1tmegi eyou a yt i g, Pli tf r c i e no me i a ai f rfveda s Pl i tf co tnuest s fe e v n h n ' a n if e e v d ' dcl d o i y . a n if n i o u fr

3

I

1 fom s ve e hea a hes bl red vii n a d lghts nstviy. Pli tf cai s t a de e da t us d r er d c , ur so n i e ii t an if l m h t f n n s e 2 e c s i ef r eag i s hi a d we edelber t l i dif r n t hi s rousm e i a ne dsi vi lton x e sv o c a n t m n r i aey n fe e t o s e i dc l e n oai
3 ofhi Ei ht Am e dm e trght . sgh n ni s

4

W ih r s e tt pl i tf se c s i ef r ecli s t eEi ht Ame dm e tpr hi ist e t e p c o an if x e sv o c a m , h g h n n o bt h

5 i poston ofc ue a d unus a punihm e t a d te bodi sbr a a d i e lsi c nce t ofdi niy, m ii r ln ul s n s n tm e o d n d a itc o p s gt

6 cv l e sa d r s h m a i a dd c n y'Esel v Gamb e 4 9U. . 7, 0 ( 9 6 .ûMrh n v r iii d tn ad , u nt n e e c . tle , z y ' l, 2 S 9 1 2 1 7 ) G l e e e g 7 prs nofi il sanda c s do usnge c si ephysc lf rei viltonofheg iht Ame dmenl io tcas t c u e f i x e sv ia o c n oai t E g h n t,
8 tec r j diiliquiyi ... t e f rewasa pledi ago d-aih ef r t manti orr so e h o e u ca n r s wheh r o c p i n o f t fo t o i an e tr 9 dicplne, m alco syands ditc lyt c us ham . Hu s nv Mc ilan, U. .1 6- ( 99 ) s i i or iiu l a sial o a e r ' d o . M li 503 S , 7 1 2 ; ' 1 s ealoWhilyv Ale s 475U,.31 , 21( 986) Watsv Mc ine , 94F.d71 , 1( tCi. 0es te . b r , S 2 320- 1 ; t . K n y 3 3 0 71 9h r 1l 2005) Mari e v St nor , F.d 11 8,11 4( tCi. ) Mar ue v Gute rz,3 2F.d68 , ; tn z . af d 323 3 7 8 9h r2003 ; q z . ir e 2 3 9

1 6 19 ( tCi. 0 3 ; e e t . me , 98F.d8 8 9 3( tCi. 00 )Jfe sv Go e , 6 F.d 2 9 - 2 9b r 2 0 ) Clm n v Go z 2 3 9 , 0 9h r2 2 ; efr , m z 2 7 3 1 895, ( tCi. )+e c ra )Sc we kv Harfr , 04F,d 11 11 ( tCi. 0)Robis 3 90O 9h r 2001 r u im ; h n . lo d 2 3 87, 96 9h r200 ; n 1 v. e c am,60F.d 1 36,1 41(tCi.1 95)fcg v Kic ele 794F.d457, (tCi.1 8 ) 4 M eh 3 4 4 9h r 9 ; r . n h o , 2 460 9h r 9 6 . 1 W h nd tr iigwh te tef rei e c sie t ec u t h ul l o t t eç xe t f nu y. .t e 5 e eem nn eh r h o c s x e sv ,h o r s o d o k o h ç tn o ij r .,h e
1 ne d f rapplc ton off r e t e r l tons i bet e n t a ne d and t ea ounto f r e us d, het r a 6 eo iai o c ,h e ai h p w e h t e hm f oc e t het 1 ee s na l pe ce ved by t e r s ons bl of i i l , and ç ny ef o t m a e t t m pe t e s ve iy ofa 7 ra o b y r i h e p i e fc a s ' a f r s d o e r h e rt

l8 f ref l e pons .'Hu s n, U. , t7( uoig Whily, U..a 3 19 eealoM arie ,323 o c u r s e'' d o 503 S a q tn te 475 S t 2 ) s s tn z
1 F.d a 1 4.Alhough t e Supr m eCour hasne err quied as o i gt a a e e ge c st a i n 9 3 t 18 t h e t ver h w n h t n m r n y iu to
20 e i t d,l he a s nc of a em e ge c m a be pr batve of w he he t e f r e w a i de d i fi t d x se t t be e n r ny y oi t r h oc s n e n lc e

21 maiiusyo s d sial. J r a , 8 F.da 1 2 n.; e as Jfe- 2 7F,da 91 ( eieae lco l r a itc l ' o d n 9 6 2 t 5 8 7 s e lo cfr , 6 3 t 3 d l rt y' ç b
22 i dif r nc sa da d a ple whe et e e i noto goi gprs n s curt mea ur ' ; n fe e e t n r p is r h r s tn n io e iy s e ' Johns n v Le i, ) o . ws

2 21 F.d7 6, 3 ( tCi. 0 0 .Mo e v r t eei n n e f ras o i go sro sij r a ars l 3 7 3 2 7 4 9h r 2 0 ) r o e ,h r s o e d o h w n f eiu nu y s e ut
24 oftef re, tt elc ofs c ij r i rlva toteiquiy.SeeHu s n, U. .t7- ; arie . h o c bu h a k u h nu y s ee n t h n r d o 503 S a 9 M tn z
25 323F. datl1 ' hwe k, 4F. da 1 96.Pl i tf sat sEi ht Am e dm e t xc s i ef r ecam s 3 84, Sc n 20 3 t 1 a n if t e g h n n e e sv o c li
26 a a ns de e d nt . g i t fn a s

4

,

t

1

W ih r s ec t pli tf sm e i a cl i ,ade aneeorprs ne ' cai ofi ad q ae t e p t o a n ip d c l am ti io r s l m n eu t

2 medi a ca edoe no c nsiut c u l ndunus al s m e t e st em ite t en rs st t el v l cl r s t o tt e r e a u punih n unl s h sr a m t ie o h e e 3 ofç elbe aei dif r nc t s rousme i a ne ds' I a 1 6.Theçde i e a ei dif r nce' t nda d l i r t n fe e e o e i d dcl e . d t 0 ' ç lb r t n fe e 'sa r

4 i v l e a o j ci ea das b e tv p o g. rtt ealg dd p iainmus b ,no j cietnn , n ov s n b e tv n u j cie r n Fis,h le e e rv to t e i b e tv e s
5 ûs fi inty s rous'Far e v Br nnan,511U. .8 5,834 ( 994)( ii g Wis n r Setr,501U. . bu fc e l e i .' m r . e S2 1 c tn lo . ie S

6 2 4 2 8( 9 1) Se o d,h p io otca mu t c wihaç u tce tyc l a l saeof n s whih 9 , 9 1 9 ). c n t e rs n fi il s a t t t fi inl up be tt mid' c s '
7 e t ism or t an me ene lge c pbutl s t a c nd ctund ra en f rt e ve y pu pos ofca sng n al eh r gi n e es h n o u e tk o h r r e ui 8 hann. Far e ,511 U. .a 8 7. A prs n ofii ldoesno a ti a delbe ael i dif r ntma ne mr S t3 io fc a tc n i r t y n fe e nr 9 unl s t eofi ilûk ow sofa d dir ga dsan e c s i e rs t i m ae he lh ors f t . f . e s h tc a tn n se r x e sv ik o n t at a ey ' # ' 1 0 I a pl i g t i sa da d,t eN i t Cic i ha hed t a be or i ca be s i t a a n p yn hs tn r h nh ru t s l h t f e t n ad h t

11 prs ne ' ci i rgh sha ebe n a rdge ,t hei dif r nc t hi m e ialne dsm us bes bsa ta . io r s v l i t v e b i d i n fe e e o s d c t e t u tnil 1 M e e Kndif r nc s t e lge c , o i e ialmal r c i e'wilnots ppo tt i c us ofa to .' 2 r i fe e e ' n g i n e ' r m d c p a tc l u r hs a e cin '

1 Br ughtnv Cute Labo atre , 2F.d458, 0( t Ci. 98 )cii gEsel, U..t1 5- 6. 3 o o . tr r o is 62 2 46 9h r 1 0 , tn tle 429 S a 0 0 1 :AJcomplittataphyscanha b e ne lge ti dig osng o te tngame ia c ndiin doe 4E I an h ii s e n g i n n a n i r rai d c l o to s
1 no sa eava i c am of e i a m ite t en unde t eEi ht Am e dm e t M e ial pr c iedoe 5 t tt ld l i m d c l sr a m t rh g h n n . d c mal a tc s

1 notbe o eac nsiutonal olton mer l be a s t evitm i aprs ner' Es e l v Gambl , 6 cm o tt i vi a i ey c u e h ci s io .' t le . e 429

1 U. .a 1 6;s ealoAndes n v Cou t o Ke n, F.d 1 1 ,1 6( t Ci.1 95 ;McGu kn v 7 S t0 e s ro . ny f r 45 3 3 0 31 9h r 9 ) ci ,
1 Smih,9 4F.d 1 50,1 50(t Ci.1 9 )( v r uldonotergr unds,lr.tTec s,I c v. le , 8 t 7 2 0 0 9h r 9 2 o e r e h o ) 'Af- h . n . Milr r. z;

1 1 4 F.d 11 3,11 6 ( t Ci.1 97)e ba c . Even gos neglge c i i s fi intt esa ls 9033 3 9h r 9 (n n ) r s i n e s n u tct o tb ih
20 dei eaeidifrnc t sro smedia ne ds SeeWoo v Hous wrght 90 F.d 1 32,1 3 ( t lb rt n fe e e o eiu cl e . d. e i , 0 2 3 3 4 9h

21 Ci.1 90) A prs ne ' meediagee e twihdignossorteame tdo sno s ppor acai of r 9 . io rs r s r m n t a i r t n e t u t l m 22 dei eaeidif rnc .Sanc e v Vid, F.d240,242( t Ci.1989 . lb rt n fee e h z . l 891 2 9h r )
23 Dea of or i trer nc wih, m e i a te t ent ca alo a ou t t delb r t ly , ne f e e t d c l ram n s m n o ieae

24 idifrnc .Se Jetv Pe ne , 9F.d 1 91 1 96( tCi, n fee e e t . n r 43 3 0 , 0 9h r2006) Clmentv Gome , F.d898, ;e . z 298 3 25 905(tCi. 9h r2002)Halet . o gan, 6F.d732, 44(tCi, ; ltv M r 29 3 7 9h r2002)Lo e v. t, F.d11 2, , ' p z Smih 203 3 2 26 11 1( tCi.L g6llaco'nvM cnts , F.d330, 32(tCi.1 96 ; 3 9h r g i l o . l o h 90 3 3 9h r 9 ) McGuc i v Smih, 4F.d kn . t 97 2
5

t

1 1 5 ,1 59(tCi.1 9 )overue onote gr undsb I'/ Te hs,I c v M ilr 1 4 F.d 113 , 0 0 0 9h r 9 2 r ld hr o y IA. c . n . . le , 0 3 Y 3 2 ( tCi.1 97 (nbanc ;Huthis n v Unie St ts 8 8F.d 390,394( t Ci.1 88 .W he et e 9b r 9 ) e ) c n o . td a e , 3 2 9h r 9 ) rh
3 prs ne i ale i gt a dea ofmedia te t e te i c sde i e aei dif r nc , io r s l g n h t ly c l r a m n v n e lb r t n fe e e howe e ,heprs n r v r t io e

4 mus s o t a t ed lyldt f rhe ij r .Se Halt 2 6F.da 7 54 ; Gu kn 9 4F.da t h w h th ea e o - t r nu y e l t 9 3 t 4 - 6 Mc c i, 7 2 t u e, 5 1 60;Sha ly v Nev Bd.O st t PrionComm 's 766F.d 404,407( t Ci.1 85)( e c ra ) 0 pe . . f ae s r' , 2 9h r 9 p r u im .
6 Pl i tf s a e Ei h h A m e dm e tm e i a cl i s a a ns de e da t M i ni a d J l D oe #4. a n if t t s g t n n dc l am g i t fn n s n x n om
7 111 Concl si n . uo

8 I I THEREFORE ORDERED ta pan ifs a piain t p oc e i f r a TS h t litf p lc to o r e d n o m 9 pau e i ( oc e #2)i GRANTED.Plitf J c bRa i Prt,nm at No. 3,wil pe nitd p rs d k t s anif a o m e a tI e 8881 lbe n te
1 t m ant i t i aci n t c ncuson wihoutpr pa m e toft e f l tlng f e. Pli tf haspai an 0 o i a n h s to o o l i t ey n h u l ii e an if d 11 i ii li sal e toft e slng f ei t ea o mtof$4. 0. Pli tf wilnotber q ie t pa f esor n ta n t lm n h i e nh m t 6 an if l e u rd o y e

1 c ss ote t a tetlngfe orgies c rt t eeor Thi Or ergrntngi f r apau e i saus 2 o t, h r h n h ii e , v e u iy h rf . s d a i n o m p rs tt
1 s a lnote t nd t t e is a ce a d s r i e ofs bpoe a a g ve n e te pens . 3 hl x e o h s u n n e vc u n s t o rm n x e

1 4

I I FURTHER ORDERED t a ,e e i t i a ton i dim is d,ori ot env s TS h t v n f h s ci s s se s h ie

1 uns c e sul t e f l llngf es al silbe due purua tt 28 U. . .j1 1 ,a a e de byt e 5 u c sf , h ul ii e h l tl , sno SC 9 5 s m n d h
1 Prs nerLii a i n Re or Ac of 1 96. 6 io tg to fm t 9

1 7

I I FURTHER ORDERED t a, s a tt 28U. , ,j1 15,a a e de byte TS h tpuru n o SC 9 s m n d h

1 Prs ne Lii a i n Ref nn Ac of1 96, heNe a a De a t en ofCore tonss al pa t eClr of 8 io r tg to o t9t vd p rm t rci h l y h ek
1 t eU nie St t sD it i t 9h t d a e s rc Cour, i ti tof e a a, tD s rc N v d 20% oft ep e edi g m ont ' de os t t pl i tf s h rc n h s p is o a n if

20 a c unt(nmonhst a t eac oun e c e s$1 .0)untlhef l$350flngfeha bee pai f rti co i t h th c t x e d 00 , it ul ii e s n d o hs
21 ac i n. The Cl r s al s nd a c py oft i o de t A l e tG . r la,C hi fofI m at Se w i e , to ek h l e o hs r r o b r Pe a t e n e z cs

22 Ne ada De ar m e tofPrio s P. .Box 7 11, s n Ciy, 89702. v ptn sn , O 0 Car o t NV

23

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta teClr s al tc a dfl t ec mplit( oc e TS h th ek h ldea h n ie h o an d k t
I I FUR T H E R O R D E R E D t a pl i tf ' cl i s M A Y PR O C E E D . TS h t a n ifs a m

24 /2-) / 1.
25

26

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta defnda ts s alfl a ds r ea ans e orot e TS h t e n t) h l ie n e v n w r h r
6

,

t

1 r s ons t t ec mplitwihi t it ( 0)daysf lowigtedaeoft ee ryimaeme iton.I e p e o h o an t n h ry 3 ol n h t h al n t d ai f 2 tec ur de lnest me it ti c s , na s e orote rs ons s al duewihi t i t ( 0)days h o t ci o d ae h s a e a n w r h r e p e h lbe t n h ry 3
3 f low i g t e o de de lni gm e i to . o l n h r r ci n dain 4 I l FUR TH ER OO E% D t a t epM isSHALL DETA CH , O M PLETE , N D TS h th e C A

5 FI E teatc e Notc ofItntt Pr ce dwihMeditonfr onorbeor t it ( 0)daysfom L h ta h d fe n e o o e t ai o m f e h ry 3 r
6 t e dae ofe ty oft i o d r ht nr hs re.
7 I IS FU R T H E R O R D E R E D t a he c f r h, ai tf s al s n ' upon de e da t , , T h t n e o t pl n i f h l e e f n n s or

8 i ara peaa c hasbe nmad byc uns lupont erat r e t) ac pyofe eypla i g, in, f l p rn e e e o e, h i to n y s, o v r e dn moto or
9 ot e doc m e ts b itd f rc nsde a i nbyt eCour.Pl i tf s a lncl dewiht eorgi a pa e h r u n u m te o o i r to h t a n if h l i u t h i nl pr 1 s bm it df rflngac ri caesai gt edaet a atueandc rec cop o t edoc m en wasmaied 0 u te o ii e tt t t tn h t h t r i or t y fh ut l
11 t t e de e da t o c uns lf rde e dant . I co ns lha e t r d a no i e ofa pe r nce, he pl i tf o h fn ns r o e o fn s f u e s n ee tc p aa t a n if

1 s aldie ts r ie t t ei di i ua ato neyname i t enotc ofa pe r nc , t ea dr s s ae 2 h l rc evc o h n vd l tr dnh ie p a a e at h d e s t td

1 teri .TheCour maydir g r an pa e r c i e byadititj dgeorama itaej dg ta ha 3 h en t se a d y p r e ev d src u g sr t u e h t s
1 notbee f l d wih t e Cl r , nd a y pa erw hi h f ist i c ude a c r i ca e s ow i g pr pe s r i e 4 n ie t h e k a n p c al o n l e tf t h n o r e v c .
15

1 6 1 7
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

N DAT D ti/. dyo E hs / a f z

,0 0 2 1.
1 1 D STATES M A G I TRATE J D GE . + U

26
7

1 .

1
2

3
N am e 4

Prs n N um be io r
5

A ddr s es
6
7

8
9

U N I ED STA TE S D I T R I T CO U R T T SC D I TR I T OF N EV A D A SC

1 0 l v. 1 l 2 l 3
14

Plitfl anif

Dee da t. fn n s

5) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

Cas No. e NOTI E OF I TENT TO C N PROCEED W I H M EDI TI N T AO

1 5

Thi c s may be r f r e t t e Diti tofNe a a' e ry i m ae m e i ton pr g a . The s ae ee rd o h src v d s a l n t d ai o rm pur os oft i notc i t as e st e s ia iiy oft i ca e f rm e i t o . M edi ton i a pr c s by p e h s i e s o s s h u t b lt hs s o dain ai s o e s 1 whih t e pa tes m e t wih a i pa ta c ur- ppoi td me it r i a e f r t brng ab uta 6 ch ri e t n m ri l o ta n e d a o n n fo t o i on e pe intr s l ton t a i s tsa t r t al pa te . x d e e o u i h t s aif c o y o 1 ris 17 l . D o you w ih t pr c ed t ea l m e i ton i t i ca e s o o e o ry d a i n h s s ? Yes No 1 8

2.

l no,plaesaetera o t)youdonotwiht pr ce dwih me iton? f e s tt h e s n s s o o e t d ai

19 20 21 22

3.

Litmz andal c s s i cudi gt ec s nu be ,ha pli tf ha fld i f de al saec ur sy l a e , n l n h a e m r t t an if s ie n e r or t t o t

23
24

i tels tveye r a dt enaur ofe c c s .Ata haddiina page i ne ded . n h a ti a s n h t e a h a e ( tc to l s f e )

25 26

8

Lita y a d a 1c s s i cl di g t e ca e nu be ,t a a e c r e ty pen i g o a y pe di g s n n l ae,n u n h s m r h t r urnl dn r n n n

gre a c sconc r igis esorcai sriedi ti c s .Ata h a diina page i n e e ) iv n e en n su l m as n h s a e ( - c d to l s f e d d . t
3

5

5.

Ar t e ea y o he c m m e t youwoul lket e pr s t t ec ur a outwhehe t i ca ei e hr n t r o ns d i o x e so h o t b t rhs s s s ia l f rm e i ton. You m a i cude a bre sa e e ta t why yo bei vet i c s i u tb e o d ai ynl if t t m n s o u le h s a e s

s ia l frme ito ,( ta haddiina pa esi ne de ) utbe o d ain A tc to l g f e d .

11

Thi f r s al bcfld wiht eClr eft eCour onorbe or t it ( 0)day:fom t e s o m h l ie t h e k h t f e h ry 3 rh
dat oft i or er e hs d . C ouns l f r def nda t :By s gni g t i f r you a e ce tf i g t t e c ur t a you ha e eo e ns i n hs o m r riy n o h o t h t v nn tc p i n cons le wih a r pr s nt tveoft eNe adaDe a t e tofCore to sconcer i g pari i aton i u t d t e e e ai h v p rm n rcin
m edi ton. ai

D at d t i e hs

da of y

,20

.

Si nat r g ue

N a eofpe s n whopr pa ed or m ro er hel e pr pa e t i doc m en p d e r hs u t

9