Center of Hope Christian Fellowship, Local, Church of God in Christ v. Wells Fargo Bank Nevada, N.A. et al

Filing 15

ORDERED the TRO is EXTENDED until 5:00 pm on March 23, 2011 . FURTHER ORD DENYING 11 Motion to Dismiss. FURTHER ORD parties are ORDERED to binding arbitration. P must initiate arbitration within 30 days. FURTHER Ds will submit a proposed Preliminary Injunction order by 3/23/2011. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

Download PDF
r : : % # l * , . a ggg yyaa jg a sjjg . ytyo , rinj gjjy yy g s C IS E/ AF IS( R 7 a : OJC I I E ) E ;8 T F , . . i 1 - gAg yj vgj gj 2 . I i a 4 5 . cj nxp apz lzc lr s s s ac ot n - s; y nj cy oFjz o: syal pm ' -' p p jy g tr . . ! ' E 6 7 8 UNI TED STATES D I STRI CO URT CT D I RI O F NEV ADA ST CT l 9 FELLO W SH I , LOCAL, CHURCH OF GOD I ) P N . CENTER OFHOPE CHRI AN STI CHRI ST, ) ' ; E r ! l 0 11 l 2 1 3 1 4 15 i i ) ) Pl nit aitf ) ) vs . ) ) W ELLSFARGO BANK NEVADA, A. ta. ) N. e l, ) De e ant, f nd s ) ) 3: lcv001 3- 1 - - 7 RCJVPC ORDER , : Thi case ars outoft f ecl e ofa chur s morgage. The Cour hasgr ed a s ics he or osur ch' t t ant 1 tmpor yrsr ni or ra she t apr i nayij nci he rn Thec r t 6 e ar e tai ng de nd c duld elmi r nu ton a ig. uren : I be Gc ar oft e m o t ge ha alo Gl d a m o i t dim i s Fort r a on gi he e n, he 7 ne i y h rga s s e ton o s s . he e s s ven r i t Doc. 15 . -VPC Center of Hope Christian Fellowship, Local, Church of God in Chris...o Bank Nevada, N.A. et al i l cour e e t e t p a y r s r ni or eran d e t ' m oton t di m is 8 t xt nds h em or r e tai ng d d eni s h e i o s s. ' 1 1 9 . ; FACTSAND PROCEDURAL Y STORY Pl n ifCe e ofHop Chrs i n Felows p,Loc l Ch c ofG od i Chrs ga ai tf nt r e i ta l hi a , ur h n it ve 20 ' i 21 In w elsFar Ba Neva a, A.(' l Fago'a$50 000pomis yn e(he e der l g8 nk d N. twels r ' ) 0, r sor ot t 2 t t',scue byade oftus (t ',op c s ralpopet a 1 Pya d Wa 2 $ e' e rd No ) ed r t tDOT' t urhae e r ry t 327 rmi y, ) 23 SpaksNV 8 (he'Prpe t ).s eNot l Fe 21 200 ECFNo.I2, tI DOT,Feb r , 9431 t ' o ry' Le e , b. , 2, - a 2; . ; ; 2 21 2 ECFNo.l2,a 22 .TheNot wasaGfy-i tmo h,Gxe rt noea 7.%,wih 4 , 002, - t ) e t egh- nt d-ae t t 5 t ' 25 ffy-ev r gulrmon hl pa nt of$4 an aGnal lo pa it s en e a t y yme s 635 d ba lon ymen e tma e a t si t d t . Dockets.Justia.com . . i j ' i ' l $ 0 ,5 .9d eo J n ay 1 2 0 (e Noel.An s ueo e teNoei abta l o 4 37 75 u n a u r , 0 7,S e t ) y ip t v r h t s r i be n r ' ) ! E 2 de ndofeih pa t ( eNot 3) Thetuse un t DOT. sAmerc Se urte ma t er ry. Se e . r t e der he wa ian c iis : . ' 3 Compa ofNev da(C ny a E ASCN' .DOT l.An diput ov t DOT i aloabir l on '( ) ) y s e erhe s s r tabe .. 4 d ma do ete p ry L eDOT 6) e n f i r at se h . i : 5 Thea t al c u amou du o J nu r I 2007wa $399, 0 si ty Is t n nt e n a a y , s 463.9, lgh l e s ha i 6 a i p t d. ( ntci a e Compl! l Fe 22, 1 , . 2, b. 20 l ECFNo.1 la 2 .I i no cla i orwh Pl ntf -,t ) ts t erf en ai if 7 de a td on t orgi l e butPl nifale s :l rort tepa ntoft b l f ule he i na Not, aitf lge,tpli o h yme he aloon E : 8 pa t( ihwa d eJ n ay l 2007 a pus an t teNot Pl nifco ace DCR ymen whc s u a u r , ) nd ru to h e, aitf nt td 9 Morgag (tDcR',pr uma yt I ns r c r andi rda ou e en n rne n t e (' , es bl he oa evie) nquie b t xt dig, e wig, ) 1 a / rfna i t Not &(#. 1 .DCR a e dt wai tebaio pa nta c i 0 ndor ei ncng he e. f ! 3) $ gre o ve h lon yme nd ontnue ; ! ll t a c trgul mont yp me so $46 (#..Plitf r er t t sa e ta t o c ep e ar hl ay nt f 35.f ) anif ef s o hi gremen s he I 2 ' Amen dNot ' b t r i n c y ofa s h d me i t r c d. Se i ) M a ie de e, ut he e s o op ' ny uc ocu nt n he e or ( e d.. urc 1 Wahn tn tesno pso o tec uc ,tet ta iwa aoa a re n bt e Plitf 3 sigo ,h e ir atr fh h rh a ssh tt s rlge me t ewen ani l f : ' . ' . 1 a DcR.( ew ahi onAf. 8, b.l ,201 ECFNo.13 a 2) Te monhsltr DCR 4 nd se s ngt f! Fe 8 0, -, t . n t ae, l n iidPl ntf h tRCH LoanSevie (' 'wa tn w st c .1 ) Pli if 5 otfe ai ifta r cr 1 RCH' s h e ewier(d.. antf ) : I 1 c i dt mak pa nt t RCH f an hert ry- nemo hsu iAprl 0.f ! 1 . 6 ontnue o e yme s o or ot hit ni nt ntl i201 (#. 4) I 7 OnMar 25, 1 ,Aci Forcl ur Sevie,l (t ton'e cue aNoieof ch 20 0 ton e os e ' c s nc.l i ' xe td r Ac ) tc ! 1 Def t(t 8 aul ' NOD' a nitt e Pr pe t pur tdl a W elsFar stuse und t DOT, ' ga s h o ry, pore y s l go' r t e er he ) 1 I l whc irc re o Mac 2 , 01 .S eNODS r2 , 0l ECFNo. -,t3 ) Acin 9 ih teod d n rh 9 2 0 (e Ma. 5 2 0, 12 a 3. to 20 b s d teNOD on adeful i t a ae h a t n he moun 0f$48 587. asofM a c 25 201 ( ee .l .The t 8, 04 r h , 0. S t ) f 2I NOD idi td a u d prncpa baa eof$ 43 50dueonJ nu ' 1 2007 pl i e e t n cae n npai i i l lnc 464, 9. a al , y , us ntr s, ' . 1 I 22 f e , d tuse sc t . Se i 4 Be au ei c ierd t Gln oft NOD t b abr a of e s an r t e' oss ( e d.. c s t onsd e he ig he o e e ch z3 t orlmo scai t t xot,pIi tf soppe ma ng pa t ('eCompl! 1 8) he a di ton o he e anif t d ki ymen s se . ! 7-1 . , 24 OnJ nu y 27, 1 Pl n ipsator ey, y M .Pa op ,s ntbot W e l Fa goan DCR a ar 20! , aitf t n Tor nk f e h ls r d i i ! 25 d emand f rbi ngar tatonun rt Not, bu n t rDee n r pond d.pan s o ndi bir i de he e t eihe fnda t es e ( kopf . Page2 of 9 i i i ' i ' i I De .( Feb.1 2 I ECFNo.14,a 2 .Thcne d y, tone c e aNotc o cl!2, 8, 0l , - t) xt a Aci xe utd ie f 2 Tr te, Sal (C ,) whihirc de onFe uay l 201 ,Se NOS, a 28, l1 ECF use s e <NOS,, c t e or d br r , 1 ( e J n. 20 , . 3 No 12,a 38 .Actonsttes l f Fe u y24, 1 ( eNOS 1. - t ) i e h ae or brar 201 .Se ) . ! ! ; ! 4 . Pli ifs e Def da si saec r f ij ciea de aaor r ifonFebr r antf u d en nt n tt out or nun tv nd clrt y ele uaz 5 22,2 1 Pl nifdeman bidi ar tatonoft Not an DOT a anij tona i t 01 . aitf ds n ng bir i he e d nd nunci gans i 6 f e l ur i t meantm e ( Compl ! 23 ) Alhoug Pli ifa a st brngno or c os e n he See . ! -28 . t h antf ppe r o i . ; 7 s at cl m f br epar e ai or each ofcontact i alegest GIng t N OS aferi i isdem and t r ,t l hat i he t gnorng t o i l ' 8 ar taet diput c tt e abr c ( ei 124) Ialoal est tAci sGln oft birt he s e onsiutd ea h.Se d.1 . t s leg ha ton' ig he 9 NOD wasabra hofteor modiiai ofteNot.('ei.! 1 ) Thesaec tis da e c h al tc ton h e ve d 7. b tt our sue 1 tmpor r r tani or (t ' on Fe u y 23, 1 whihwa t ls f Gfe n da or 0 e a y esr i ng der ' TRO' ) br ar 201 , c s o a t or te ys 1 untlt c l i oft pr i nayij nci h a igonMar l 201 .Dee nt 1 i he oncuson he elmi r nu ton e rn ch 0, 1 fnda s I r m ove on M ar 7, I b s d on di r iy ofcii e hi Pl n ifGl d a Ex Pa t M oto 2 e d ch 20 I a e ve s t tz ns p. ai tf e n re in ' I3 f Tem por y Res r ni O r ,w hi t Courtgr ed unt lt dat oft pr tnt or ar t ai ng der ch he ant i he e he es i I i ; 1 ' prlmi r ij ctonh rng Mar 1 20ll 4 ei nay nun i eai , ch 5, . 1 I. 5 I 1 6 LEG AL STAN DAR DS TheN i t Cic ti t pa ts tf t t s par t s t ofcrt ra f de e m i ng n h r ui n he s e orh wo e a e e s ie i or t r ni I wheh rt grn pelmi r ij ci r if 7 tc o a t r i nay nun tve ele : l 8 Unde t e ta ton t s,apl n ifmus s ow:( )asr lkei oodofs c s r h r dii al e t aitf t h 1 tong i lh uc e s ontemeis ()t posi lt ofirpaa eij yt pl nifipr i nayr if h rt,2 he sbii re rbl nur o aitf f elmi r ele y i no gr tdr()abaa eofh ds psf orngt pl ntf, d( a nc me s t ane . 3 lnc ar hi av i he ai ifan 4) dva e nt oft p i lt r s (nc ra nc e ) Th ale nai t s r quie t tapl n if he ublc n e e t i e ti as s . e t r tve e t e r s ha aitf de onsr t ei r a c bi ton of pr a e s c s on t m e is a t e m ta e t he om na i ob bl uc e s he rt nd h 1 9 ; ' 20 2l ! I ; ! ' p siii o irp rbeij r o ta s ro squ sin aer ie a dteb ln e o sb l' f re aa l nu y r h t e iu e t s r asd n l aa c t y o a ofhar hi tps s pl i hI f . ds ps i har y n s avor i 22 Ta orv We t 488F. l1 l ( hCi. ) tl s t f multo r esntt yl . sl y, 3d 97, 200 9t r2007. t- e wo or ains epr e wo -he 2 p it o asiigsaei whc terq i dd ge o ie aa l h r ice ssa te 3 ons n l n c l n ih h e ur e re fr p rbe am n rae sh d e r 24 pr obabiiy ofs lt ucces decr es., f s eas , #. 25 I Th supr cour r e l rieae howe rt tapl nifse nga ij ci e eme tec nty etrtd, ve,ha aitf e ki n nun ton 2 i I j ' ' l 1 mus de taet tirpaa eh r i Ikeyy n j s posi e.Witrv NRDC,1 S.Ct t monsrt ha re rbl am s 'i l ' ot u t sbl ne . ' 29 . 2 365,3 6( 08 (ee tn teNit Cicutsat naieS i n s e'et.TheNit 74-7 20 ) rj cig h nh r i' ler tv dig cal'ts) sl nh ; ' . ; I 3 Cic ih se piiyrc g ie ta i t o sb ly'e t sl e iiv l rftd'n Witr rut a x l t e o nz d h tt f siii 'ts wa fnt ey eue 'i ne , cl sp t d i 4 a t t (lepr rlgal tndadf pelmi r ij nci r ifrquie apa t t nd ha th ope e sa r or r i nay nu tve ele e rs ry o 5 de on ta e tha h i lk y t s c e on t m e is t the i lke y t s f rir r bl h m m s r t t t e s i el o u ce d he rt , ha s i l o uf e repa a e ar 6 i t abs. ofpr i i y r i ,t t bal n he ence elm nar elef hat he ance ofequii tps i hi f ,and t an tes i n s avor hat u ! ! 7 ij nci i i t publci ee t' St mans I .v Selcy,586F.d 11 ,l1 7(t Ci. nu ton s n he i ntrs.' or , nc . e k ' 3 09 2 9h r 8 2009)( i Wi e 1 9S.Cta 37 (e ri adititc su eofteNi hCicui' quotng ntr, 2 . t 4) rvesng src oud' s h nt r ts 9 pr Wi e , ldi - c l 'san r an r ma ng f a ia in oft pr rsa da d) z- ntr ' i ng s ae' t da d d e ndi or pplc to s he ope t n r . 1 0 Ar ecentN i h Cicui r i r yi I gel on t di entng opi on i W i erpar ed nt r t ulng el ng ar y he ss i ni n nt s i lI t e l ngu ge or w i t ran s bs qu ntx i t cic tr i gsan de er i d t tt e s i ng h a a ne d u e e n h r ui uln d t m ne ha h ldi I2 scal t tr e es emai vi e w hen t e i a l ershow i ofIkelhood ofsuccesson t m eris ns abl her s ess ng i i he t i 13 amountng t ts i ques i ,' butnotw hen t e i a l sershow i oflkelhood of i o t erous tons ' her s es ng i i I I i i 1 i 1 irp rbeh r S eAlin e o teWi Ro ke v Cotel6 2F.d 1 4 , 0 2 5 (t Ci. 4 re aa l am. e la c f r h l c is . t l 2 3 0 5 1 5 - 3 9h r d r , 1 2 0 'si c s p e e ss disoul i lgh ofwiuran prorxit cicui c s s To 5 01) r s a e r s nt ome f v n i t n d i nh r t ae . 1 t ext Cotrel ' i er et i of Wi er i i 6 he ent t ls nt pr aton nt s nconsi entw ih Sel y,Sel k cont ol M ll st t eck ec y r s. .er l . . ' l v Gammi 335 F.d 8 8 ( hCi.2 ( n ba )( ol ng t t i t a e eofa 7 . e, 3 89, 99 9t r 003) e nc h di ha, n he bs nc n 1 it r nig su e cou t cii , onl t en banc cour m ay overul a deci i n by a 8 n e ve n pr me r de son y he t re so 1 t e -ud pa ) I a c s ,t Supr Cour sae i Wi ' t t()pl nifs e nga 9 hrej ge nel. n ny a c he eme t ttd n nt ha qa aitf e ki er i : ! ! I ! j 2 p ei n r ij n t nmu t sa iht a h i l eyt s c e dontemeis ta h i l eyt 0 rlmiay nu ci o s e tbl h t e s i l o u c e h rt,h t e s i l o s k k 2 I s f r ir pa a e ha m i t a e e ofp elm i r r i f t att ba a e ofe te tps i hi ufe r e r bl r n he bs nc r i na y ele , h he l nc quii s i n s 22 f l a , t ' a ij ctoni i t publci ee t'Wi e ,1 S.Ct a 37 ( tn Munfv vorand ha n nun i s n he i ntrs. ntr 29 t ' . t 4 ciig a . , 23 Ge e I S. . 7,22l -I ( )Amoc Pr Co.v Gamb l,48 U. 53I 5 r n, 28 Ct220 8 9 2008* , o od. . el 0 S. , 42 24 ( 987 ;Wnbek v Ro r Barel 456U. 305 3ll 2(982) (mphaesa ed) The 1 ) i rer . meo- c o, S. , -l 1 ) e s dd . ' ' % ' 25 ts i pr e e a af rpatc j ciets, a ayourfcorb a i ts,a dtewor et s esntd s ou- r onun tv etnot s r -a t alncng et n h d I ' . ' I i ; Page 4 of 9 i ; ! l i i ' ' I : 2 teirp rbe h r p o g,I rj cigtesiig s aetk,i WitrCo r s e iial h re aa l-a m r n n ee t h l n -c l e ttl ne u t p cfc l n d l y - 1 tlkel 'm odii t s ti y' fes he uccess on-he- ispr i exacty t sam e way i s at y m odii - t mert ong n l he t epar el fes . 3 emp sz d t f c t tt e wor Slkey'modii st ir pa a e ij ypr s ei a 375, ha ie ht a t ha h d ti l ' fe he re r bl nur ong, e d. t 4 and t wor modii t succes on- he- ert pr t s he d fes he s- t m is ong he ame way,i at374. I disent d. n s , . ! I i I I ! 5 J tc Gis g opiedt a s di notbel vet eCour wa aba doni t e r et ati was usie n bur n h t he d i h e t s n ng h ul h t . ! E I 6 per s i et t wadtpr i nayij cie rle b e onaIwe Ikelh ofham whe misbl o : r elmi r nun tv ) eif asd a o r i iood r n 7 t e lke ioodofs c s i ve y hih. I at39 ( n b g, . dis ntng) ButJ s ie h i lh u ce s s r g ' d. 2 Gis ur J, s e i . ' u tc 8 Gi nsbur , l t maort di n a es whehe s beive rle c l begr tdwh g i he j i d ot ddr s t r he l d eif oud ke y, e ane en i ! i ! ; : 9 t e c n ofs c s wa ls t lkey.A Sowe lk i od'i sil omeIke iood. W ea e h ha ce u ce s s e s han i l t r ielho ' s tls l i lh r 10 l tw ih t I ef t he anguage oft t ,whi r r t chance ofsuccesson t mert t be atI t he est ch equies he he is o eas 1l :l1(l,'' .i:)). ! ; 1 ; 1 2 I s mma y,t s tsy Wi e , mov tmu ts t a he i S i y'o s c e ont e n u r o a if ntr a an s how h t s d kel't uc e d h l i ! ! i 13 m eris. tLi y' m eansthavi a hi pr t ' kel , t ng gh obabiiy oroccur i orbei tue., lt rng ng r ' I 1 M eri 4 ram-w e t Ditona hup:ww . ram- bserc diton lkey. Blc s bser c i e, / / meri we t .oe c i al/i l a k' . : 1 d- - h-.,kelh oss c es- -hemeists, elninl s-Ejex l h taltg t , s- -- -i iood- -u c sont - rt et-mor e e tya kth eta iian 1 whos e E elmi r r in mus s ow :ras abl pr bii ofs ces...'Bl k'14. 6 e ks pr i nay ele th e on e oba lt uc s . ac s 5 y ' l Ditonat 1 2( h e 20 .TheCour mus rcon l t c s by it m r i t Co tel 7 ci y. 01 9t d. 09) t t e cie he a es n e etng he tr l 1 ls rousque ton ' r quiem e t b i ha m on w ih t W i e l ec y Slk i od' s a r 8 te i s i s ' e r nt o e n r y t he nt r sel k li elho ' t nda d, i . I ! ! ! ! I 1 n a b ng i c 9 ot s ei n ompe ii wih i.t i qu si goig t t emert'mus mea t tt r tton t t t ous e tons n o h ser is' t n ha he e 20 i a l a t r s bl pr a lt ofs c s on t m e is :Rea ona j pr babiiy, appear t so s t e s a ea ona e ob biiy u ce s he rt . : s b e o lt ' ! k i ! i ; ! 21 b tcmo te in p sto o tesiigs aeta c ns t f terq rme t f'iey'' e h s Ine t o i n n h l n c l i t a ai y h e ui n o tk l i d y s e l . 22 1 . 11 AN ALYSI S : ! i 1 i 23 Th Cour wilgr taprlmiar ij ton Iapp ar lkel t tt: f e os ewa e t l an ei n y nunci t e s i y ha je orcl ur s . 24 sat orl pr t ut iy operbutt t ar taton cl hat he bir i auses i t Not and DO T ar vald and t Pl ntf n he e e i hat ai if I i I ! i 25 h sma ead ma dt a btae l i as ce rta irp rbl h r tes l o ra a d e n o r i t. ts lo la h t re aa e am l ae f e l r a Pa 5 of 9 ge ! i i ! : : l ! ! i 1 pr ery wiloc uri teabsnc ofapr i n y ij nci Thee te tpi fvo of op t l c nh e e elmiar nu ton, quiis i n a r 2 Pl ntf.Alh gh W elsFa g cli i i owe al t$5 00 i i n cla i i e il t ai if t ou l r o ams t s d mos 00, 0, t s ot e r t s ntted o ! E I 1 ! i 3 t ebalo pa h lon yment b c et a lg d or modiia i by DCR ma ha wave i.The , e aus he le e al fc ton y ve i d t 4 . I i uesher ar notyetcom pl el cl and m us be ar tat i any case. Pl ntf w il egal ss e e et y ear t bir ed n ai if l I I i : 5 ha ls aIofispa nt a i ttePr erya ttet tePr et uponf e os e. ve o t I t yme s gans h op t nd il o h op ry orcl ur 6 Alo pl ntf com m uniy ofwor p may di ol upon r ecl ur Fi l i i i t s , ai irs t shi ss ve or os e, naly, t s n he 7 publc i er tt pr i nt es o eventt i pr he m opersal ofr pr t . e eal opery 8 DCR hasr esponded and moved t di i I addii t t Compl nt N ot DOT, o sm ss. n ton o he ai , e, . i i ! l i ! ! i ' E 9 N O D,and NO S,DCR adduces t assi ent and t s tt i wo gnm s wo ubs iutons. Fist on Oct r, ober24, lo 2003 w els Far assi l go gned t oo T and al docum ent connect t t I t A tantc he l s ed o he oan o l i i i Il Amerc M o t geSub I(s l i' .( As i n , t 2 2003,ECF No.1 5, t2 . ian rga t antc' See sgnme t Oc , 4, At ) 0- a ) . ! i I 1 Nex , on Decem ber27,2006,Atantcas gned al i er ti ta DoT and l docum ent t 2 t l i si l nt es n le oan so ! i i I I DCR.Se Asi men,De .27, ,ECFNo.1 6,a 2) DCR s bsiutdAci astut 3 ( e sgn t c 2006 0- t . u tt e ton rsee 1 on M ar I , 201 ( esu tt i M a ,I 201 Eclxo.1 7,a 2) Fi ly,w elsFa go 4 ch 6 0.se bsiuton, r 6, 0, r 0- t . na l l r . E ! l i j ; i . I alo s tt e Ac i a tuse on J a y 2 2011 ( e Subsiuton,J n. 4, ll ECF No. 5 s ubsiutd ton s r te anu r 4, . S e tt i a 2 20 , 1 6 17 1 - 71 t9 . 0 a ) Thes docum ent t t s e s end o how a sat oriy pr t ut l operf ecl e. W elsFar t orgi or osur l go, he i nal 1g l enderi 2002, pr l assi n opery gned t N ot oo' and ot I document t Atantc i 2003, he e, r, her oan so l i n I who t pr l assi 9 hen opery gned t hem t DCR i 2006. DCR pr l s tt ed Acton as tusee o n opery ubs iut i r t i : i 20 on M a c I 201 a d Acton Gl d t e N OD ni da I t ron M ar h 25,2 I Th r h 6, 0, n i e h ne ys a e c 0 0. e 1 j : ) i , i 21 f e os e t r f eap ar t h ve b e saut iy pr r' orcl ur he e or pe s o a e n t t orl ope . 22 . ' ' l els Far appear t lave been a stangert t l att spoi , and need nothave w I go so a r o he oan hi nt 23 pur t u t s tt e Acton astus eeagai i 20ll. I dent l A cton was pur tng t pore o ubs iut i r t nn nci aly, i pori o : ! I 24 Acton Gl d t c N OD i 201 , i wa i de d t e tuse b t e b nefci r w a DCR. Ac i s i e h n 0 t s n e h r t e, ut b e i a y s ton' 25 h a tasw el Fago- tuseewhe isldt xoo,whiha ast ha be nicore .whe c ls r s r t n t e he c ppe r o ve e n rct n c usono rt spoba ydi n afc isrgh t f e os un tesaut DCR woul onf i ve hi r bl d.ot fe tt i t o orcl e der h tt e. d a sa digt obe tt Aci sf e os ea t be s ofapatben l ays ha Wel ve tn n o j c o ton orcl ur the het s etcir uc s ls F g a n tDCR' wil snc DCR a t e p e entb efcir h t ergh t ee tf e os r ar o gais S l, i e s h r s en i a y as i i t o lc or cl u e i Page 6 of 9 . ' ' I ; I I i I t ; i 1 i ! . : i ' . I . . The diput m us be ar tat how ever D CR ar s e t bir ed, . guest t ar taton cl esexcl hat he bir i aus ude l I ! 2 f e os e fom t rs e. The Cou tGndst tt e do n . The a bir ton cl u e i t or cl ur r hei cop r ha h y ot r ta i a s n he 3 DOT r eads i r evantpar: n el t . i 4 5 6 Len ra ea h pa t t t sag e m e he e a ee up de a b an pa t de nd c ry o hi r e nt r by gr , on m nd y y ry, t subm i any Di e t bi ng ar taton i accor o t sput o ndi bir i n dance w ih t t ms of t s t he er hi A r ta i Pr a . A S iput 's li l a diput ,cl m orcon r ver y bir ton ogr m t s e' hal nc ude ny s e ai D to s n t r n ontac ort t egal Ofany kid,whehe i c r t 'or, l orequiabl ,now exi i orher t t e stng eafer arsng, e a i i a wa t t A g e m e ora r a e a e m e i c por tng i i r l tng n ny y o be r e nt ny el t d gr e nt n or a i i ! d ! ' t sAr ta i Pr am (hei hi bir ton ogr t t me s',ora pa t pr en ,orf t r I ns Docu nt' ) ny s, es t u u e oa , 7 8 ta a tons c rcs a e me t,eltons ps ici nsorij isofa yki rnsci , onta ts gre ns r ai hi ,n de t nure n nd what soeverr atng t ori vi Busi sBanki com m uniy Banki orany el i o nvol ng nes ng, t ng, s ucces gr ordeparm entofLender sor oup t . i i I 9 ( 6.T iabtaincas ietmeytoog adso a itntabttaytp DOT ) hs ri t luesxr l hruh n hws nneto riae n ye ro e r I ofc tove s a ii outoft e morga DCR a g s h ver t ta he cau ee mp s 0 on r ry rsng h t ge. r ue , owe , ha not r l s xe t I1 r ecl es fom ar taton. Thatcl e r ,GThe ar taton r r entdoesnotlm i t or osur r bir i aus eads ' bir i cquiem i t he l rghtofan pat t ()frcl ea i tr lo pes al op t colaer .... se u i 2 i y ry o i oe os gans ea r ron pr ery lt al Thi xclson E ! l3 does notcons iut a w ai oft r ghtoroblgaton ofany pary t subm k any oi e t tt e ver he i i i t o ( sput o ! ; I 1 a bir to orr er c h r unde .... ( 4 r ta in ef en e e e r ' DOT 7) Thi cau ed no app ar asDCR ar s ' . s l s oes t e , gue , l t wai t ar taton r r entupon f ecl e. Rat ,i si pl m akes cl t 5 o ve he bir i equiem or osur her t m y ear hat 1 . 1 f e l ur i pr s r d a a r m e d s t t ar ta i r quie e . I d e n t a ta te 6 or c os e s e e ve s e dy e pie he bi ton e r m nt t o s ' me n h th r 1 Inde c nr derteabirtonclu eworhls t t borowe b smpl i taiga 7 e r a en h r tai a s t e s o he r r y i y niitn l f ec os e Th l nd m u ta bir t t s dipu e w ih Pl ntf upon de an I t I de 8 or l ur , e e er s r t a e hi s t t ai if m d. f he en r 1 w i i m ay s ilchos f ecl e as a r edy. Thatsal t scl e seem st s and t s 9 ns, t tl e or osur em ' l hi aus o ay, hi I I ! I ! ! ( c j lus y nd 20 i t r t i m a ss e. An a bir ton c a e i ade oftus w oul be om e il or a n em e aton ke ens r ta i l us n ed r t 2l one- ded i t I si f he endercoul cicum venti si pl by i tatng f ecl e becaus al d r t m y nii i or osur e mostever y I 22 diput ov a p omis y n es c ed b r a pr e t i Ikel t i vean alga i of s e er r s or ot e ur y e l op ry s i y o nvol le ton 23 def tr s tn i f e os e aul e uli g n or cl ur . 2 4 Th ne cl s DCR ivoke ra ,$?) Dip es alb s te t ar tai it e xt au e n s e ds $t0 s ut h l e ubmitd o birton fhe -1 orn ,b teb rwe lkel ha n sa n t obe ts l ga Aci wa i e t tu te. ot ut h oro r i y d o tndig o j c o on s ton s nd ed he rse . . 2 5 I l 1 ! l Pa 7 Of 9 ge . I ! ! i i i ' 1 I l D iput concer i s e ns ndebt ednes s ed diecty ori r l , i whol ori p r, a ral s ecur r l ndiecty n e n a t by ny e 2 pr t unl t hol oft m orgage, len orsecurt i er ts fcaly el s i w rtng opery ess he der he t i iy nt es pecii l ect n ii . I 1 i 3 t pr ee wiht abirton. (#..Thi clus a ast c rt prs tdiput o oc d t he r tai ' f ) s a e ppe r o ove he een s e. ' 4 Howev ,heclu ei s t tveyun ons on e, si ionesde Be aus t e ie ert a s s ubsani l c ci abl a t s -i d. c e he ntr ! I I i I 5 p ro eofh DOT i t s c r d b wi ra p o e t t se cu inca s wo l a nhlt up s te s o e ue e t t e l r p r hi x lso lu e ud n ii e h y, a 6 t e icar tatonclus a t s eoptonoft I de ors e entb fcar Tw her an he ntr bir i a e t he ol i he en r ubs qu ene ii y t e . I I 1 i 7 abirtona e nti c c n ,t a e me i gub tntv y u ons o eu es t r tai greme s on ered he gre nts s sa iel) nc cinabl nl s he 8 abtainrme yc nan a' dc m of i trly ''D. Hor on,z v.areen,96 p. r i to e d o tis mo iu - l e ai ' R. t ac. r ba t 3d . j ! i l ! ; 9 1l 9, I1 ( v. 4)( otn Tig v AT ' 31 F. II I 49( hCi. :.A c t 5 65 Ne 200 qu ig n . &T, 9 3d 26, l 9t r2003 our 1 0 i Nevada m ay i equiy r or a deed cont ni an unconsci n n t ef m ai ng onabl pr son.See Wai ght e ovii nwri l1 v. unseat , 21 p.I 04,1 ( v.1 ) Thecout lt rf ee t sve t s o h I 1 006 xe 923 . r wilheeor quiy e r hi l 2 . i ! ! : ' ! pr son f r t DO T. ovii o m he DCR al ar so guest t aleged or modii i i w ihi t sat e offaudsand f l hat he l al fcaton s t n he t ut r ais . 1 3 I k l i 1 t eunder The Cour need notexam i t s ar entdiecty,because t di e shoul be 4 her . t ne hi gum r l he sput d I5 ar tat . Howe r t a l e or lm o sca i a ea st be w ihi t e sa u e o r ud a bir ed ve , he leg d a di ton pp r o t n h t t t rr a s s I : ! i i 1 i 1 DCR a gue ,be a et eNot a o alya nde c dnotber pad wihi oneye ra t 6 r s c us h e s r l me d oul e i tn a t he 1 a e d m ont y r t ,a t e a e 7 gr e hl a e nd h gr emen t e ef e c d n by ist r sbe c pl t d w ihi one t h r or oul ot t e m om e e t n ! 1 I i i i l ye . eNev. v.Stt 51ll220() Idefniee o 8 arSe Re a. . l. n i t mplymen c rcsaeousdeoft t onta t r ti he 1 sa ue o fa be a et y ma betr i td a wil s e. ,z we/ v.5' .sec. 820 P. 9 tt t f r uds c us he y e m nae t l ee, g. d/ / w , 2d , 20 766, 7 9( v. 9 ) b t o t cs orp yd b aen temia ea wi b ete p r te 6 Ne 1 91, u c nr tt e a e t r o tr n bl t l y i r at hy a l h y; i 21 tr naeonl whe t de ti s ts d. stl,pl ntf m ay havea cl m f pr i or e mi t y n he b s a ise il ai if ai or om ss y i l i i i i 22 etppelobea j c tdbyt abirt . so t dudiae he r taor 23 CONCLUSI ON 24 I I HEREBY ORDERED t tt Te T S ha he mpor y Re tani Or eri EXTENDED un i ar sr i ng d s tl 1 I 25 5: p. onM a c 23,20lI 00 m. rh . Page 8 of 9 ' I I I ! ! ! i I ' . ' j j ?.' . ' ! i i I ! l I 2 I I FURTHER ORDERED t tt Motont Dimis( No 1 )i DE ED, TS ha he i o s s ECF 1 s NI . I I FU RTH ER ORD ERED t tt p r i a e O RD ERED t bi di g a bir to a T S ha he a tes r o n n r ta i n s 3 pr ded undert N ot and Deed ofTr . Pl ntf m usti tat ar taton w ihi 30 days. ovi he e ust ai if nii e bir i tn i 1 ! 1 I ! I 4 6 di 7 IIF T S URTHER ORDERED ta wi i s v n( ) a sc u s l o Dee d nswi h t t n e e 7 d y o n e fr fn a t l h l s s e a or a gume t cu s d t al r n. I I SO O RDERED. T S 5 s i, atr o sl t nwi c u slo Pani , po o e Pei n r Ijn t nore, s ubm t f c nut i e a o t o ne fr litf a rp sd rl ay nu ci d ra h f mi o 1 I I I ! ! i 1 ' 8 Dae t i 1 'd yof rh 2 I . td hs 5b a - c , 0 l Ma - . ' . q l 0 11 - . RO . T C. ON ES J Unie - at D i rctJudge t es sti 1 ! i . 1 2 I i i E ! 1 i i ! ! ! ! I 1 3 4 l 15 1 6 ! ! ; 1 7 ! ! i i 1 8 1 9 20 21 i : i I 22 23 24 i I ! i 1 25 i ' ! : Page 9 of 9 i

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?