Noguera v. Smith et al

Filing 14

ORDERED the # 9 Motion for relief from judgment is DENIED. FURTHER ORD the # 11 Motion to Dismiss the Petition is GRANTED. The petition is DISMISSED. No Certificate of Appealability shall issue.. Clerk shall enter judgment accordingly. Signed by Judge Edward C. Reed, Jr on 12/13/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

'
(

FL
IED
ENTERED

R:cglEo
y
SE
RVEDCN
C NSE AR E OFRs
OU UP TIS
coap

1

pEs I# 2 j
gj

.

2

1

3

l
i'
:
iF'
*,

V

'*' '
*

I
cuRxu nsmlyc mr
s c ot
.

''
'

..

' '

'

'

*'
' *X* * * W ** '* *-* '
*

*-

r= ,,
mrx
w

5

.

6

UN I ED STATE S D I
T
STR I CO UR T
CT
DI
STRI OF NEVADA
CT

7

8 CARLOSNOGUEM ,
9

l
0
l1

1
2
1
3

)
)
Peii r
ttone,
)
3: lcv1 - 00428LRH- GC
W
)
vs
.
)
)
ORDER
GREG SM I etal,
TH, .
)
)
Res nd t.
no ens
)
Thi a tonpr e dsonaha scomuspeii purua t 28U. C.j2254br t
s ci oc e
bea
tton s nt o
S.
ough

1 pr s by pe ii r Caros No a Bef e t Cour i pe ii rs m o i f tr leffo t
4
o e
ttone , l
guer .
or he
t s ttone ' ten or te i r m he

1 j
5 udgme 's e ngr onsdeai ofteCour' deni ofcoms ( No. . smotons l be
nt' e ki ec i rton h
ts al t el ECF 9) Thi i hal

1 d ne Alope dn i a u o p s dmoint ds s t ep t in( No 1 )o teg o n sta
6 e id. s n ig s n n p o e t o imis h ei o ECF . 1 n h r u d h t
o
t
l i c a ns une
7 t ont i
xhaus e cl i s
td am .

1
8

De pie bei gi n no i t r
s t
ng ve tce h ough t Cou ts Or r ga di t r r ment of
he
r' der e r ng he equie
s

1 Kln l v. k rya Randv Rowl ( No.1 ,peii rha n oppos dt motona
9 igee Eienber nd
. and, ECF
2) ttone s ot
e. he i nd '

20 ha nots
s
oughta tonaltme fom t Cour t do s Loca RulsofPr tce( Rul 7- d) :
ddii
i r he
t o o.
l e
aci LR) e 2(
2 1 pr dest t..the f l e ofa op i pa t t f l poi s a a horte i r s
ovi ha , f aiur
.
t
n pos ng ry o ie nt nd ut ii s n e pons t a m oto
e o ny i n
22 s l c tt e a c e t t g antng oft m oton.
ha l ons iut ons nt o he r i
he
i '
'

23

Be a s , u s a tt 28U. C. 2 5 ( )1,h Co r i u bet e trant emeis
c u e p ru n o
S. j 2 4 b ( )t e u ts na l o n eti h rt

24 of c a m s r s d i t s Cour but n r i e be or t s a e c ts t m o i t dim i s m us be
l i ai e n hi
t
ot a s d f e he t t our ' , he ton o s s
t
25 gr nt
a ed.
26

.

l

I or rt pr e w ih an a alf om t scour,pettone m us r c ve a c r ii t
n de o oce d t
.
ppe r hi
t ii r
t e ei
e ttca e

!

2 ofa albiiy.28U. C.j2253()l.Ge r l apettone mus ma t s tntal howi of
ppe a lt
S.
c( ) nealy, ii r t ke $ ubsa i s ng
a
3 t de alofaconsiuton rg 't wa r tac riiat ofa a a lt 1 .n eSupr meCour ha
he ni
tt i al iht'o ran e yfc e ppe l biiy. d
e
t s

4 hel t t peii ert t
d ha a tton t demonsrt t tea on ej rsswoul fndt ditit ou tsase s nt
mus
tae ha r s abl u it
d i he src c r' s s me
5 oft c tttonalcli d at eorwr ' Sl kv Mc el529U. 473 48 (
he pnsiui
ams eb abl
ong. ac . Dani ,
'
S. , 4 2000)
.
6

The Supr me Cour f teril i t d t sa d f is nc ofa c tfc t of
e
t urh lum na e he tndar or s ua e
eriiae

7 a albiiyi MilrElv Coc r l,537U. 3 (
ppe a lt n le - . k el
S. 22 2003) TheCour sae i t tca e:
.
t ttd n ha s
8

9
l
0
l1
1
2

W e do no r quiepettone t pr
t e r ii r o ove, f e t i s
be or he s uanc ofa CO A, ha
e
t t

s mej rsswoudga ttep tto f rh b m c r s I d e : cam
o u it
l r n h ei n o a e s opu : n e d a li
i
c nb d b tb ee e to g e r ju s of e s nmih a re at rh
a e e aa l v n h u h vey ki t ra o g t g e , le te
CO A ha be n gr nt a t c s hasr c ved f 1c i a i t t
s e a ed nd he a e
e ei
u1 onsder ton, ha
peii erwil pr ai. wesatdi Sl ,twl r adititc t
tton lnot ev lAs t e n ack tt hee src our
ha rj cedtec tt i al ai ont me is t s wi rquied
s ee t h onsiuton cl ms he rt,he ho ng e r
t s tsy j2253()i srihtonvad:Thepettonr mus de tae
o aif
c s tag f r
ii r t monsrt
t ra ona ej rsswoul fndt diti c m ' ase s ntoft
hat e s bl u it
d i he srct ol s s s me
he

'

c tt i lcli debaabl orwr '
onsiutona a ms
t e
ong.'

1 I.at1 ( i Sl k,529U. a 484 .
3 d 040 quotng ac
S. t )
1
4

The Cour h c i r d t i s es r i ed by pe ii r w ih r pec t w he he t y
t as ons de e he s u a s
ttone , t es t o
t r he

1 s ts yt san r f ris nc ofac ri c t ofa alan t Cour de e ne t tnon m e tt t
5 a if he t da d o s ua e
r tt q e ppe , d he
i
t t nni s ha
e e ha
1 s a r A c or ngl t Cou twilde pe ii ra ce ttc t ofa
6 t nda d. c di y, he
r l ny ttone
rii a e ppea a lt
l biiy.

1
7

I I THEREFORE ORDERED t t motonf r iffom j
T S
hathe i or ele r udgmen ( No.
t ECF

1 9 i DENI
8 )s
ED.
1
9
.

I I FURTHER ORDERED t theMotont Dimist Peiin( No.11 i
T S
ha t
i o s s he tto ECF
)s

20 G RANTED.Thepe ii i DI I
tton s SM SSED.NoCe tfc eofAppeaabiiys lis TheClr s l
riiat
l lt hal s ue.
e k ha l

21 e tr u g n a c r n l.
ne j d me t c o digy
22

23

Dae ti ( d yo Dee e, 2011,
td hs 3 a f c mb r

24

25

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
26
2

$
'

.

g
.

1
2
3
4
5

6
7

8
9
10
11

1
2
13
1
4
15

1
6

1
7

j

18

1
9
20
2l
22

23
24

25
26

'
3