National Railroad Passenger Corporation v. John Davis Trucking Company, Inc.

Filing 73

ORDER re 72 Case Management Report : The court vacates the Case Management Conference scheduled for January 20, 2012 at 9:00 am in Courtroom 1. Signed by Magistrate Judge Valerie P. Cooke on 1/19/2012. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

)

'

Case 3: 1- 004611 cvHDM VPC Document72 Fi 01/ 12 Page 1 of7
l
ed 18/

$
*.
<1

.
'

&
!
,

.

'
.
%
.

1
2
3

J 4 D . M OORE: Neva St e Ba No 8581
OlN
da at r
1
.

j mo r@s rn elu e a ac l
d oe pig ra v d .on

LAW O FFI
CES O F M I
CHAEL B.SPRI ER,PC
NG
9
628 Pr ot Cour
ot ype
t
Re N V 8
no.
9521

Telphone: ( )786- 445
e
775
7

.

4 Ato n y f rPlil an Cot e dp n a t
tr e s o an t d t r e d n
nt
.
NATI
ONXL RAI
LROAD PAS
SENGER CORP
ORATI a d Comtr eè d n an
ON n l e dj n a t d
5

Count r l mantUNI PACI C RAI
e cai
ON
FI
LROAD COM PANY

6

B.CLYDE HUTCHI SON,Calf St t Ba No.
N
i. ae r
0375
26

7

b h l l RANUCCI Calf.St t BarN o.184801
@ c p.
Jc 4N l l c
OI W . om
, i ae
j @ll cm
wr l l o
c p.

8

9
1
0

FL D
IE

VI
NCENT CASTI
LLO F Calf St eBa No.
i at r
2092
98

v atl ll .om
c sio@lcl c
l
p
LI SI M ENDOZA, l . aeBa N0.42 93
ZA U
Cai Stt r 2 4
f
lime d z@ l l c m
su n o a l l o
c p.

1
2

f

SRE O
EVD N

C U SIP TE FR C R
O N EJM ISQ E O D

J !j z j
AN
gj

LO M BA R D I LO PER & C O NA N T,LLP
m

l La eMerstPlzeet Suie 2600
l 1999 Harjt Sta , t
k r on ar
l

!

RE NE
CE D

EWR D
N E

CEITSDSFNEVC U T
LDKUCTORC NM R
R RI ITIT O
S

Oa ln ,: 9 6 2433kagne ( 1-5 1
d CA 4 0 3 42600
Telgh
e
5l )

B:
Y

-- -''
-

Fasml : ( 0 43 -69
cl i
e
51) 32 9

DP'
EIY
J
I
.

'

ï jk l Alo ny f rRAI t a dCo nedf n a t ORATI a dCou tr p n ntand
6 3 NATIes o Pli z n PASSENGER CORP
trONAL an
u tr ee d n
LROAD
ON n
n ede da
8.1: 1 Cou trl mam UNI P FI RAI
1
4
necai
ON ACI C LROAD COMPANY
:1!&
:'
.

: **h
.s

1
5

STEVEN T.J
AFFEs va Stt Ba No.007035
Ne da ae r

:!I!
1
K 8

1
6

s f @lwhcc m
j f a j.
ae
o
HALL JAFFE & CLAYTON,LLP

% 1
j
S

..

7 5WetWahigo Av n e Sut 4 0
45 s s n tn e u , i 6
e

'

1 La Ve a , 8 2
7
s g s NV 91 8
Tee h n : ( 0 )31 - l
lg o e 7 2 6 41 1
1 Fac l l
8
smie: ( 02)31 - 1
7
641 4
Ator ysf Dq
t ne or Rndant
1 J 4 DXVI TRUCKI COM PANY,I
9 OIN
S
NG
NC.
20

GARY E.DlGRAZI N e da St t BarNo.00 98
A, va
ae
01

21

g gCOa rEA.DIt eAZI COYLE & STANTON,LTD.
dirz @fo teneGRt A,
ai
nir .
n
GO I ECH

22

530 I ho Stee
da
r t
P. Box 1
O.
358
El NV 89801
ko,

23

24

'

Telgh
e qne: ( 738775) #091
Fa l l
csmle: ( 738775) 4220
Ator ys Countr l mant
t ne for
e cai

.

J 4N DAVI TRUCKI COM PANY,I C.
OI
S
NG
N

25
26

1

27
28
l 2 -0 9 LSM 6 6 0 .
3494 9 0
0 7 31

l

Cas No.3: lc 00 1HDM VPC
e
l -v- 46

J NT CASE M ANAGEM ENT STATEM ENT
OI

'

Case 3: 1- O0461 HDM 1 cvVPC Document72 Fi 01/ 12 Page 2 of7
l
ed 18/

1

STEPH EN C .
THO M PSON , r gon St t BarN o. 635
O e
ae
007 9

'

se e t-a o
tv @kplmc m
7
2 GEORGE Il LI Orgo Stt Ba No. 06 0
t R. N, e n ae r 0 2 46
g o g @ kp lw.o
e r e t-a c m
'
3
4

Kl c , THOM PSON & POPE LLP
Rl m
l 00 Yeon Buidi
l
l ng
5 SW 5t A ve e
22
h
nu
Porlnd,OR 97204
ta

'

5

Tel
eghqne: ( 222- 640
503) 1
Fa l l
csmle: ( 2275251
503) 6 Alo n y f rCo ne cama t
lr e s o u lr l i n

'

.

J HN D A VI TRU CK I G CO M PAN Y,I C.
O
S
N
N

7

8

.

.

'

9
U NI
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO U RT
CT
1
0
DI
STRI O F N EVA D A
CT
11

!

'

N ATI A L RA I
ON
LRO A D PA SSEN G ER

CaeNo 31-v0 4 1HDM VP
s . :1c-0 6
C

CORPORATI
ON,

J NT CASE M ANAGEM ENT
OI

.

1
2

k
'

: jj 1
3
8.k: 1
11
4
:.j,
I
v
.
*1'i )
,
j 5
.

8, j
1
g =!
'

1
6

.

1
7

% @
'

S
TATEMENT
Dae J n ay2 , 01
t: a u r o 2 2
Ti ; ko am.
me io .
ctm: 1
r

pli tfl
a n it

NY

J 4aNevadacoUCaton,C A ,
OI DAVST r oKF OMP
N I Rp r NG
I ,
NC.
i

Jdeagitat ndalvaeiPcoe
ug:Te urbe lr .ok,
hHoo e
e
U.. sr eJ g '
SM

.

De e d n ,
fn a t

:

.
l
8
1
9

J
OHN DAVI TRUCKI COM PANY,
S
NG
I C. a N e a Cor a i
N ,
vad
por ton,

20
21
22

23

C

ount cl m a ,
er ai nt

V.

*

N ATI
ONAL RAI
LROAD PASSENGER
CORPORATI
ON UNI PACI C
ON
FI

.

RAI
LROAD coûp
Axv, n ooEs 15
au
-,

24

25

Coun erDe en t .
t - f dan s

26

.

27

'

28

12 94 9 0I M 6 6 0 .
34 .: 9 - 0 7 8l
s

2

Ca eNo 3 l - v 0 46lHDM VPC
s . : lc - 0

J NT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEM ENT
OI

Cas 3. 1 c - 461 HDM e 1 - v 00 VPC Doc
ument7 Fi d 01 1 j page a o 7
2 l
e /j/ ;
f
.

l

TO THE HONORABLE VALERI P.
E COOKE,U. M AGI
S.
STRATE J
UDGE:

2

COM E N OW t pariswho ha a a ed i t sac i an d
he te
ve ppe r n hi ton d ubmi t e f l ng J nt
t h olowi oi

.

$

3

Cas M a gemen Stt mentptr ua t t M i utsoft Cou ifl d on Nove be 8,20l1
e na
t ae
ls nt o he n e
he r ie
m r

4

( 60)
Doc .

(

5
6

7
8
9

l
0

C A SE M A N AG EM EN T RE PO R T
Com p e i ofI pe ton a d C om m enc m e ofW rte D i c
l ton ns c i n
e nt
it n s ovea

Theparisi pe t d t l onl i son J r 5,201 i Chia a plnne The
te ns c e he oo otve
anua y
2 n c go s a d.
pari w ilbe e gi i wr te di c
tes l
nga ng n it n s over i t nextf w wee .
y n he
e
ks
t
I s s Pe t ni t Lo otve V i s a Eve Rec derDat
s ue rai nc o com i
deo nd
nt or
a

J Da sTr ki r ie t f l ng t is wihcouns lf Natonal lo
ohn vi uc ng as d he olowi wo s ues t
e or i Rair ad

11 Pa s rCor aton(ttmtak' onJ r 1 201 Howeve,be us c el orAmtak
senge por i s r ' anuay 7, 2.
z
)
r ca e ouns f
r
l
i
=

1
2

i e ged i an herca e i Fr no,Calf ni f t r
s nga
n ot
s n es
ior a, or he emai roft e wee t e pa te i end
nde
h
k, h ris nt

f

t

I

'

; jj 1 t frh rme t n c ne onteeis e o tewe kofJn a' 2 s 01 Th fl wigt
3 o u te e a d o fr h s su s n h e a u l 3 2 2. e ol n wo
y
o
8 1jz 1
!
'' 4
2
.

.

. . jj
*z

Z i';
:n5

1
5

.

is saea f l
sue r s olows:
.
I Loc i vi :J oa sTr ki compa s ekst torgi 'I omotve
omotve deos ohn vi uc ng
'ny r he ' i nal oc i
'
.

!!1
.!
!
K I(

l
6

vi o i
de mage be aus i cl mst e or i f
s c e t ai he nc pton onnati whi t we epr duc d t
n ch hey r o e o

1

; !
ï
S

1
7

ima e me nn u a ay i o tevd oi o sbl.Ac o d n t J h Da i
t k s a igf l n lss f h ie mp s i e ' c r i g o o n vs

1
8

Tr ng, he e r i s t r t ke ove a1 oper tons on t com put r t whi h
ucki t nc ypton of wa e a s r l
ai
he
e o
c

1
9

t vi dic i i t led a a a t
he deo s s nsa l nd ny temptt a yz t vi o i a sr s t i a
o nal e he de m ge e uls n n

2
0

er orm e s an t c s ton oft e pl y. J Da sTr ki cl m s t vi o
r
s age d he es a i
h a ' ohn vi uc ng ai he de

21

ca
nnotbesoppe an sa t fa b fameand t qhe e i no man ri whi h t
t d d t red r me y r
hatt r s
ne n c o

22

an yz t e s ee r ea whih t e i a swer r or d ora ebei plyed. l
al e h p d at t c h m ge
e ec de
r ng a
t

23

f t ca mst i ge qu iy oft vi osi poor pa tcu a l gi n t hi
urher li he ma
alt
he de s
, ri l ry ve he gh

24

r s uton qu iy oft e c e a s t m on- r t l om ptve . J Davi
e ol i
alt
h am r ys e
boa d he bc
i s ohn
s

25

Tr ki cl msc ii i orna i ab t poston oft cr sng ga e i not
uc ng ai rtcal nf l ton out he ii
he os i
ts s

26

vii e. l be i ve t e difc tesappe due t t e e y i s
s bl 't le s hes f i uli
ar
o h ncr pton ohwar i o w hi
e nt
ch

27

'

:
'

.

Amtak oriss ontacorplc t vi eo i a .'
r
t ubc r t a ed he d m ges

-

28

'

2. Eve Re or erDaa:J Da sTr cki Compa alo s ekst t i nal' vent
nt c d
t ohn vi u ng
ny s e
he l gi 'e
or
12 94 9 0L M 6 6 0 .
3 4 .0 9 S 0 : 8l

3

' Ca eNo 3: lc - 0 61HDM VP
s . 1 -v0 4
C

J NTCAS MANAGEME S
OI
E
NT TATEM@NT
1
)

.

,

Case 3: cv11- 0O461 HDM VPC Docum çnt72 Fi 01 18/ 2 Page 4 of7
l
ed / 1
'

..

1

boar
h oc
i
r c derdaa be us i beleve t e e ntr c derde ceon- d b0t I om otves
e or
t ca e t i s h ve e or
vi

2

ar ofatpeandmanufcur t r der t m s c jtbl t ma puai
e
y
a t e hat en s he us e i e o ni lton

3

.

Sl l Cour Rel e Ca e
ae
t at d s s

4
5

,

W ihr pe tt sat co 'c s ,tepa te ha complt a EaryCas Conf e e
t es c o t e ul a es h ris ve
t
erd n l e
ernc
pur ua t Rul 1 1oft Nev Rul sofCi lPr edur i t f l ng c es
s nt o e 6.
he
ada e
vi oc e n he olowi as :
;

6

o Lana D i e s v John D av s Tr ck ng and NalonalRair Pas e r
ck r on .
i u i
i
l oad
s nge

7

Cor aton,Se ond J c a Di t i toft St t pfN e da Cas N o. 11
por i
c
udi i l s rc
he a e
va , e
CV -

8

01
969,a
.nd

9

o Wilam Kno v JohnDavsTrfl n Se
li
x .
i lc f g, cond J ci Diti oft St eof
udi al srct he at

1
0

N e da Ca e N o. CV l1 01
va , s
:
- 992.

l1
R
-

=

ha be s r d a w ilbe a ea i i t f l i c s :
ve en e ve nd l
pp rng n he olow ng a es

f

.

ï jj l
3
8 1ms 1
!! 4
:7='
k!t
à :.; 1
!!,j
,
5
8 1'1
,j
>

o Ev lnJ hno v . h Da i Tu kn a dNain l lo dPa sn r
ev o s n .l n vs r c ig n lo a Rai a sege
o
q
copoat n se o dJdiil src ofh Sae( Ne a a CaeNo CV1 r r i , c n u ca Ditit te tt ? v d , s . 1
o
f

.

.
-

.

02674,a
nd

1

1
6
l
7

o Ronal Wer e hin v JohnDavsT kngandNatonalRair Pa s n r
d ck nt e .
i ruc i
i
load s e ge
Copo a i , Second Judi alDititoft Stt ofNevada,Cas No.CV 11r rt
on
ci src
he a e (
e
'

1
8

02673.
l

1
9
.

20
21
22

:

I addii Na i lRair Pas e erCom or ton a J Da sTr ki Com p
n
ton, tona
load s ng
a i pd ohn vi uc ng
any

1
2

K œ!
'
j

'

Furhe
t nuor J D a sTr ki h be s ve a w 11be a
e, ohn vi uc ng as en er d nd l
ppea i g i
r n n:
1

o Kkun Ran You,Rv g Won Par andA'lnPar v.
g
un
g k
ed k JohnDavsT kng
i ruc i
Compan Se
y, cond J di alDitctoft St t ofNeva Ca eN o.CV1 0008
u ci s i
he ae
da, s
29.

Thepa te ha bee i dicus i wih pl n if 'couns si t s c e f t
ris ve n n s son t aitfs
el n he e as s or he
l

23

pur e ofc di tn dic r efors I i e ctd t tmor ca e wilbe fld a or
pos
oor na ig s ove y f t. t s xpe e ha
e ss l
ie nd/

24

s r ed i t ne f m ont .
e v n he xt ew
hs

i

'

25
26

27

:

.

Re l tt Va at Cas M ana m e Conf e e
cues o c e e
ce nt
er nc

;
)

.

'

The p tes w ilc i t m ee an conf ron t e i s es di c s a
ar i
l ont nue o
t d
e
h su
s us ed bove. The pari s
te

l

I

si a et va at t Cas M ana mentConf e e s dul d f J nua y 20, 2 at9: a. .
tpult o c e he e
ge
er nc che e or a r
201
00 m

2 Sh ul tepa t sn t a l t rs leteis e a o e tepaye wiliea p o rae
8
o d h ri o be be o e ov h su s b v ,h ris l tl p r p it
e
12 94 9 0L 6 6 081
3 4 .0 9 SM 0 7 .

4

Ca eNo. : I c 00461HDM VPC
s
3 I - v-

J NT CAS MANAGEME S
OI
E
NT TATEMVNT

,

j

'

Ca e31 -v0 4 - s :1c -0 61HDM VPC Do u n 7 Fld0 /11 P g 5o 7
c me t 2 i 11 /2 a e f
e
l

m otons a a k t Cour t s edul a brefng s hedul an or lar e a ne s a y a
i
nd s he
t o ch e
i i c
e d a gum nt s ce s r nd

2

c
onvenintt t Cour' s dul
e o he
ts che e.

3

DATED t s l hda ofJ nua y 201
hi 8t y a r , 2.

.

4

LA W O FFI
CES 0 F M I HA EL B.SPRI G ER,
C
N
PC
5
6

.
/ John D .M oor
s/
e
.John D .M oor '
e
N e da St t Ba N o.8581
va
ae r

By:
7

8

9628Pr ot Cour
ot ype
t

9

( 7 )78 - 4
7 5 6 7 45
'
At r e s o b a ntf n Cou tr p n an
l n y f rpli t a d ne de d t
o
f

Re N V 8952 l
no,

1
0

NATI
ONAL. LROAD PASSENGER
RAI

CORPORATI andCountr fe ant
ON
ede nd

ll

and Coun e çai
t r l mantUNI PACI C
ON
FI

b

RM LROAD COM PANY

=

1
2

f

'

li
8I1p
1'11
I
:1'ö
S nj
1
'

.

à 1)!
m
% !
!
ï
S

14

DATED t sl t d yo Jn ay 2 1
hi 8h a f a u r, 0 2.

1
5

.

'

.
;
LOMBARDIIOPER, coxAx',
,r nuP
'
;
'

1
6

By
:

1
7

// cld Huc is n
s B. v e thn o
B. y eHuc ns n
cld thi o
Calf ni Stt Ba No.0375
ior a ae r
26

18

'

( 0)43 260
51 1- 0
Ato n ys o Pl n# an Co ntr e n a t
tr e f r ait d u e dp d n.

2
0
21

.

NATI
ONAL RAI
LROAD PASSENGER

CORPORAII andCoi e de ndant
ON
t r#
nt
and Countr ai
e èl manlI ON PACI C
JNI
FI

22

23

k

take M er itPl za
a
rt ' a
1 H a r w n Stee ,suie 2600
999 r i
r t t
o a and,CA 9461 3541
ki '
2-

1
9

RA I
LROA D /
COM PAN Y
t

DATED t s 18 h da ofJ nuar , 201
hi t y a y
2.

2
4

HALLJ F & CL
AF E
AVTON,
LLP

25

.

26
'

.

By:

?

//st ve T.J f
s e n afe
st n T. a f
eve
J fe
N e da St t Ba N o. 035
va
ae r
007
7455 W e tW as ngt A ve
s
hi on
nue,Suie 460
t
h v 891
l
28
La Vega ,
s
s

27
28

.

12949:L M 660 .
34-09 S 07 81

5

ù CaeNo. :!c -0 61HDM VP
s 3 l -v0 4
C
.

J NTCASE MANAGEME S
OI
NT TATEM/
NT

l

.

I

1

'

Cas 3: 1 c 0
e 1 -v- 0461 HDM VPC Doc
umen 72 Fi 01 1 1 Pag 6 o 7
t
l / é/ 2
ed
e f

1
2

( 0 )31 - l '
7 2 6 41 1
Ato n y f rDee d n
lr e s o f n a t
J 4 DZ I TRUCKI COMPANY,
OIN W S
NG
I C.
N

3

4

.

DATED t s 1 t da ofJ nual 20l
hi 8 h y a y
2.

5

.

,

j

GOI
COBCHEA,DlGRAZI COYLE &
A,
STANTON,LTD. (

6

7

t

By:

8

//Ga v E.Di a a
s r
Gr zi

Ga y E.DiGq zi
r
a a

Ne daStt l rNo.000l
va
a eBa .
98
. 530 l ho Ste
da
r et
P. Bbx 1
O.
358

9

1
0

El NV 8
ko,
9401
L j'qg gtpj
yyj / - j
. tr e s o Co ne cama t
Ato n y f r u tr l i n

,

1
l

!

J C. DAvl TRUCKI COMP
OI
d
N
b
NG
ANY,
I
N

1
2

v
'

j

; l. '
3
811: I
4
1G1:
I
8 I
*I., j
j
5j(
4
'

à' o!
1 ë
!
j
:

.

D ATED t s l h da ofJ nuar ,201
hi 8t y
a
y
2.

1
6

'

y

,
KI N THOMP & P LLP
RKLI
SON OPE
)
By
:

l
7

I

p
t
'
,

//Se h n' Th s
s to e c. omo on
Se h nC. o s n
tp e Th mp o
OrgonStt Ba No. 635
e
ae r 007 9

1
8

;

ll Ye Buidi
00 on l ng

5 2 S 5 lXve u
2 w t
p ne
1
9

Porlnd,OR 97204
ta

,

20

Tee h n : i ( 93 2 2 1 40
lp o e 5 ) 2 -.
6
Facl l ' ( 227- 251
smie: 503) 5
Ato ne forCountr ai
tr ys
e cl mant

.
.
p

21

J l N DA V I TRUC I N G C OM PAN Y ,
O4
S
U
I
NC
C

'

22
23

24

.

25

.

1

26

I
'

27

'

'
.
.

28

i
1 2 94 9 l M 6 6 0 .
3 4 -0 % . 0 7 8I
s

6

; ca eNo 3 ! -v 0 4 IHDM VPC
s . : lc - 0 6

J NTCASE MANAGEME STATEMVNT
OI
NT

)

l

Cas 3: cve 11- 00461HDM VPC Document72 Fi 01 18/ Page t of7
l
ed / 12

l

2
3

I O PO SED IO R DER
PR

Pert pa tesJ n Ca e M a mentStt t t Cour he eby va at t Ca e
he ri oit s nage
aemen , he
t r
c es he s
M a ge entConf e e s dul f J ar 20,20l at9: a.n. n Cou t oùm 1
na m
er nc che ed or anu y
2
00 1 i
'
rr
.

4

5

I I so ORDERED ,
T s

6

7 DATE
D:

ZXZ

g

L

9

.

By:

.

HE HON OM B
AL RI P.COOKE
E
UNI
TED STATES M AGI RATE J
UDGE

1
0
11

l
i
=

1
2

f

; jj
8œ1J:
.'
1Ij&
k :.ö
.5
8!'1
I
à =!
'
p !

1
5

1

l
7

-

l
3

'

l
4

'.

.

1
6

.

l
8
l
9
20
21
22

'

23
24

25
26
27

.

ag
I2 94 9 LS 6 67 .
3 4 .09 0 M 0 081

7

Ca eNo.3: lc 0046lHDM VPC
s
l - v-

J NT CASE MANAGEM ENT STATEM ENT
OI