National Railroad Passenger Corporation v. John Davis Trucking Company, Inc.

Filing 76

ORDER GRANTING 75 Joint Case Management Statement. Per the parties Joint Case Management Statement, the Court vacates the Case Management Conference scheduled for 2/21/2012 at 9:00 am in Courtroom 1. Signed by Magistrate Judge Valerie P. Cooke on 2/17/2012. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

Download PDF
% ; k i *F ' 4, 1 : ï $' . I Case 3: - 00461-HDM 11 cvVPC Docum en 75 Fi 02/ / Page 1 of8 t l ed 16 12 ' ' I i 2 J 4 D. O O RE, e da St t Ba N o. l OlN M N ya a e r 858 j mo r@ s rn elwn v d .o d oe p ig ra e a ac m LAW OFFICES OF M I CHAEL B.SPRI NGER, PC 9628 Pr ot Cour ot ype t ) Ren NV 895 l o, 2 Telp e: ( 78674 e hon 775) - 45 4 Ator y orPl nt andCou e de n t nesf ait ntr jè dant NATI ONAL RAI LROAD PASSENGER CORPORATI an Cou e de n tan ON d ntr fe dan d 5 Cou e dai lUN I PACI C RAI ntr man ON FI LROAD COM PANY 6 B.CLYD E HUTCHI SO N,Calf St e BarNo.037526 N i. at $ 1 7 8 9 1 0 I l ' b h l l .om c@ l l c cp J OHN W ,RANUCCI Ca i. a eBa No.l 01 , lf Stt r 848 FL. IF D j @ l l .o wr l l c m cp ErRn NEE VI CENT CA STI N LLO,Calf St e BarNo,209298 i. at v atl @ l lpc m c sio l l.o l c LI SI M EN DOZA,Ca i.St t Ba N Q. 493 ZA U lf a e r 242 lime d z gl l .o su n o a l l c m cp R CE D E NE SRE 0 EVD couq ls' mE l c sF kF slFe ' FE8 1? 2 1 22 LO M BAR D 1 LO PER & CON ANT,LLP . Lak MerionSta t Suie2600 eHarrt flzee, t rit ar l 999 s O kl CA 9461 354 l and, 2- Ct M U S RC C R - SDIT IT OU T E DI RI ST CTOFNE XM ' V ! 1 Tee h n : ( 0 43 -6 0 2 a p o e 51) 32 0 l f 1 kë F c i l; ( ( 4 32 9 a smi e 51) 3 -6 9 ) l Alor ys orPl nt andColne dee ant 3 t ne f ai t ttr f nd NATI ONAL RAI LROAD PASSENGER CORPORATI an Cou e dfe anta ON d ntr e nd nd a' 7 a B Y DP 'j E , ' 1 ë 4 o necama l NI ACII L OAD OMP îJL! 1 C utrli n U ON P FCRAIR C ANY c 1ï î : o. 5 àj'ö I ! 51 ! l *8 1 'I 6 1 ! 1 7 , = l 8 1 9 S TEVEN T.AF Nea aStt Ba No 0 7 3 J FE, vd ae r . 0 0 5 srll j. m jf a co ae wh c HALLJ E < CLAYTON, AFF Q LLP 745 w es w a higt Ave ue sui 460 5 t s n on n , t e ua ve a, 8 2 s g sxv 91 8 ' 'el ho r eg ne: (02)31 - l 7 641 I Fa sm ie ( )3l - I 4 c l l: 702 6 4 I Ato ne f Dee t tr ys or f ndan J OHN DAVI TRUCKI COM PANY,I C. S NG N 20 G ARY E.DIG RAZI N e da St t Ba N o. 01 A, va a e r 00 98 2I gOgCOa fo teDeG e AZI ,CO YLE & STANTO N,LTD. dirz @ r n ir t t A ai n. n G I ECH EA, I R 22 530 I daho Steet r P. .Box I O 358 El NV 89801 ko, 2 Telgh : ( 5)7 - 091 3 e one 77 38 8 Fa smie: ( 5)73 4220 cl l 77 8- 2 At reso Cotlrii n 4 t ny f r t ecama t o n J OHN DA V I TRUCK I G COM PAN Y,I S N NC. 25 26 27 28 12 94 90LS 67 9 . 3 4 .09 M 07 6l j Ca:No.3: ) 004 1HDM VPC s I <v* 6 J NT CASE M AN AGEM ENT STATEM ENT OI ' ' f < ' % Case 3: cv11- 00461HDM VPC Doc ument75 Fi 02/ 12 Page 2 of8 l ed 16/ l ' 2 3 4 STEPH EN C.THO M PSON ,O r egon St e BarNo.0076359 at se e kp lw.om tv @ t-a c GEORGE KI N ,Or RLI egon St e BarNo.0062046 at g og @ kp lw.on e re t-a c r KI RKLI THO M PSON & PO PE LLP N ll Yeon Buidi 00 l ng 522 SW 5t A venue h Por l O R 97204 tand, 5 Telph e: ( 3)2 1 40 e on 50 22- 6 Fa smie: ( 3)227 525I ci l 50 6 Ator ys rCou e cai l ne fo ntr l mant J DAVI TRUCKI C/MPANY,I OHN S NG NC. 7 8 9 UNI S ' TkD TATES ol c' cotR' sTRl r l r 1 0 DI STRI O F N EVA DA CT Ii b Ca eNo.3: lc - 046lHDM VPC s 1 -v 0 J 1 NATI 2 CORP ONALRAIROAD P E ORATI L ON ASS NGER , I = 1i 1 3 il f l ! plit an 8Jï 1 , z 4 1Im v . J NT CASE M ANAGEM ENT OI S TATEMENT z Ti : 9:0am. me 0 . , a . 5 kj ö l ! 1 a! : ! a. g ; x ! ! l 6 Dae Fbur jzlz t: eray , l l Ctm: l r Jl?o vlTorCaton,c A , of va q I .aNe dac U KIG oup xy NC. A s Rpor N , i 1 7 Jdeagitrat ndgelv liFc oe u M hHooa ee . , U.g:Te eJ r e ar ' ok S. s u b oee d n. fn a t = 1 8 j 9 J HN DAV I TRUC KI G CO M PAN Y, O S N I C. aN evada Cor aton, N , por i 20 C ount cl m ant er ai , 2l V. 22 z3 N ATI AL RA I ON LRO AD PA SSENG ER CO RPORATI N ,U NI PAC I C O ON FI RAI LROA D CO M PAN Y,and DOES 1 5, - 24 2 5 Cou e - e a s nt r Def nd nt . 26 27 28 12949 L 6 79 1 34 .0 % sM 0 76. 2 Ca eNo.3: 1cv00461HDM VPC s l- - J NTCAS MANAGEME S OI E NT TATEME NY . o : ' Cas 3: - 00461 HDM e 11 cvVPC Docum ent75 Fi 02/ 1 Page 3 of8 l ed 16/ 2 l TO THE HON O RABLE VALERI P. E COO KE,U. M AG I TRATE J DGE: S. S U 2 CO M E NO W t e pa t sw h ha e a a e i t s a ton a d s i t e f l w i J n h ri e o v ppe r d n hi c i n ubm t h olo ng oi t 3 Ca e M a ge e tSt t m e tp s ntt t e M i t soft Cour Gl d on N o m b 8 20ll s na m n a e n ur ua o h nu e he t e ve er , 4 ( c6 . Do 0) 5 6 CA SE M ANA G EM EN T R EPO RT l uesPerai nz t Locom otve V i ss t ni o i deosand EventRecor Dat der a 7 On Januar l 201 couns f J Davi Tr ng Com pany r s t f l i y 7, 2, el or ohn s ucki aied he olow ng 8 t is swih c ns f Nai alRair d Pa s ng Cor or ton ($ r '. Bel i a wo s ue t ou el or ton loa s e er p a i $ ak' Amt ) ow s 9 des pton oft t isues and t rsat cri i he wo s hei t us: l0 l Locomotve Vi . i deos: 1l John Davi Tr ng Com pany see t torgi ' l s ucki ks he t i nal' ocom otve vi i ages becaus i deo m e 1 2 i cl i st e en r ton f m a i whi h t y w e e p oduc d t i mak s me ngf t a m h c yp i or t n c he r r e o t e ani ul 1 1ë l 3 S% ' l a ay i o tevdoi osbe Amta dsges F rh r r,codn t Jh n lss fh ie mp sil. rk ia re. utemoe ac rig o o n 8Jlz 1 . 4 eI!l DaiTukn ,h ecy t nsh r tks vr loeain o tecmp tro vs rcig te nrpi o waeae o e al prt s n h o ue t o o 5Im; 8 j whiht vi odici i t ld an a yat tt a yz t vi oi ge rs t c he de s s nsale , d n temp o nal e he de ma s e uls h = f l 5 éj l 'j 6 ! iaeomsgadhcstnfel Am trak disagrees.John Davis nnrreaent eaoot py r s e si h a . . j # ! ' * ' l 7 Trc igas camstevd oc n o b so p dadsatdfa b fa a dta u kn lo li h ie a n t e tp e n tre rme y rme n ht l 8 t r i no man ri whi h t a l e t s e r t a whi h t i eswe e he e s ne n c o na yz he pe d a e t c he mag r l 9 r c de orar b i plye I f t e cl m s t i a qu lt oft vi e i p , e or d e e ng a d. t urh r ai he m ge a iy he d os s oor 20 p t a l giente hi r oltonquaiy oft ec ari ry v h gh es u i cul lt h amer s tm on- r t e a yse boa d h 21 I om o i s J Davi Tr c ng cl i sc ii i or ton a tt e poston of oc tve . ohn s u ki a m rtcal nf ma i bou h ii 22 t cr si gat i notvii e. I belevest he os ng es s sbl t i hesedi cul esappeardue t t m ti o he 23 encr on sohwar i o w hi Am tak oriss ypti e nt ch r t ubcontact pl r or aced t vi i ages. he deo m = 24 . Amt ak diagr r s ees. 25 J Davi Tr na' Addii Cl m s: ohn s ucki s tonal ai 26 J Davi Tr ng cl ms t e i no w ay t verf t t vi i ques i i ohn s ucki ai her s o iy hat he deo n ton s 27 genui A mtak diagr ne. r s ees. I cl ms t encr ed copy pr ded t def t ai he ypt ovi o endant 28 i udes onl Am tak' I and t dat oft acci . I alo cl m si i ncl y r s ogo he e he dent t s ai t s 12940 9 L 6 79 . 34 . 9 0 SM 0 76l . 3 Ca eNo. l1cv0046IHDM VPC s 3: - J NT CAS M ANAGEM E S OI E NT TATEM E NT Case 3: c 00461 HDM 11- vVPC Document75 Fi 02/ 12 Page 4 of8 l ed 16/ l 2 ot e f t e ofi pora c ,s c a a f a - y- r s q oft e vi o a t tm e h r ea ur m t n t u h s r me b fame t dy h de t hi i s 3 pr ecedi durng,and f l i t i dent John Davi Tr ng f t cl mst ng, i olow ng he nci . s ucki urher ai he 4 di pr sc event any f ensi anal swhi coul det t perng i such hasoccured. s or c ysi ch d ect am i f r 5 Amt ak diagr r s ees. l ar t guest di pr ded by A mtak i nota vi Gl i any he sc ovi r s deo e n 6 r ecognàed f mat I i an '. 'fl t cont nsisow n sofw ar whi r t or , t s 'exe' ie hat ai t t o ch uns he 7 dic and super s sedest com put ' cont ol. I cl m sA mtak hast f r us t he ers r s t ai r hus ar ef ed o 8 pr de t vi fl fom w hi t encr ed di wasmade,ort vi da a as ovi he deo ie r ch he ypt sc he deo t 9 ' i possbl f a f ensi speci itt anal t vi f genui m i e or or c als o yze he deo or nenes orf any s or orgi l r ded by Amtak' on boar di t vi r der Accor ng t J i naly ecor r s d gial deo ecor . di o ohn 1 0 Davi Tr ng,t encr i pr ded t J Davi Tr ng was m ade on s ucki he ypton ovi o ohn s ucki II Novem ber l 2011,shor l ahert Cour ' or diectng t t vi be pr , ty he ts der r i hat he deo oduced. l 2 J Davi Tr ng cl m st neces ariy m eanst t encr i wasm ade fom ohn s ucki ai hat s l hat he ypton r 1 1j I 3 avd ofl i n tv fr whc c ud a ds o l, a ebe po u e .Acodn ie i h aie om ih o l, n h ud hv en rd c d c rig e îJ!' 1 mt 4 ! tJh DaiTukn, t encr ed dic w holy faist com pl w ih t o o n vs rcig he ypt s l l o y t he = f ' * I1T Z op !I j . l 5 e . 1 6 . àj 'j o 4 à j S rq imeto F CP3 ,at ual i I ho te20 Amed n teeo (e eur ns f R 4prclr n i t fh 0 6 nmethrt.Se e i y g ' t eOfi al h fci Comme a yt t tAme dmen . l ale st edicAmta pr c d i ntr o ha n t) t lge h s r k odu t s 1 7 o sc p or u ly ii i o sbet d tr n wh te teg tsweed wnf te f u h o q ai ts mp s il o eemie eh r h ae r o orh t 1 8 f lfve s c ul i e ondsm i m u tm e p e e n ar i oft tai a t e cr s ng a ni m i r c di g rval he r n t h os i , s 1 9 r r by'tder r aton. Amta dia e swih alt c t tona e. equicd f al egul i e rk s jr e t l he onen i bov 20 St us: at 2l A snot above,A mtak diagr w ih J Davi Tr ng' ass m entoft ed r s ees t ohn s ucki s ess he 22 l ocom otve vi i deo.N ot ihst ng,t par i have m etand conf r and ar w t andi he tes ered e 23 contnui t m eetand conf on t e i ues. Am tak i cur enty i tgatng i ng o er hes ss r s r l nves i i 24 w h t e t e i a b te qu iy v son oft e l c otv vi os i e sen e. Ba e e h r her s e tr alt er i h o om i e de n xit c sd 25 on t i or aton pr he nf m i esenty known t Am tak' couns $t l l o r s el he ocom otve vi camer i deo a 26 i s t r di s et o ecor magesat30 f amespers r econd. The m uli e copi oft l tpl es he ocomotve i 27 vi pr ded t John Davi Tr ng al di ay i agesat30 f am espers deo ovi o s ucki l spl m r econd. 28 Amtaki wilngt diplytevi ot t Cou t ot tteCour mayj ef r s li o s a h de o he r, ha h s t udg or 1294 9 0L 6 79 . 34 -0 9 SM 0 76I 4 Ca eNo. Ilc 004 IHDM VPC s 3: -v- 6 J NT CASE M ANAGEM ENT STATEM ENT OI ' ' Case 3' cv. 11- O0461- M - PC Docum ent75 Fi 02/ 12 Page 5 of8 HD V l ed 16/ I 2 and m or i poranty,concl vel showst t cr si gat wer dow n prort em t l usi y hat he os ng es e i o 3 t l l he ead ocom otve ent i t cr ng. G i t t John Davi Tr ng tact i erng he ossi ven hat he s ucki r or 4 sr ckt f t ta nc r(h s c nd c rb ndt t l omo ies, h I omotve tu he ourh r i a t e e o a ehi he wo oc tv ) t e oc i 5 m ount camer woul neverhave capt ed t i pactbecauset l l ed a d ur he m he ead ocom otve i 6 had cl ed t ough t cr si appr mat y 3- s ear hr he os ng oxi el 4 econds bef e i pact or m , 7 Nevert es A m tak i wor ng on obt ni an unencri ed copy oft l hel s, r s ki ai ng pt he ocomotve i 8 vi deosand has i or nf med John Davi Tr ng t i i wor ng on obt ni t s s ucki hat t s ki ai ng hi 9 copy. As t John Davi Tr ng' cont i r di FRCP 34,Am tak cont o s ucki s enton egar ng r ends 1 0 FRCP 34 does notappl asAm tak has notr ved any Reques f Docum ent fom y r ecei t or sr lI b = is ft qualt oft vi f age. A mtak cont t el he iy he deo oot r endst vi qualt i ver good, he deo iy s y John Davi Tr ng. s ucki 1 2 f he t gi al v nt or ' 2. EventRecor Dat J Davi Tr ng Com pany alo seekst S i n ' e e der a: ohn s ucki s g 1J I i 3 E !M . rc re d t bc ueib l v stee ete od rd vc o -or b t teIa a d eod r aa ea s t ei e h v n rc re e ie nb ad 0h h ed n e 1! 4 8JT 1 . j c t in lc moie aeo atp ta.rsset lt maiuain r l g oo t s r f yeht e ucpieo np lt . ai v a b o kjvö !j :, Stt s au : . . l 5 :!.! 1 ; : x! 6 . Thep rish veme a c tre ont sis ean t sis eha snc b en ate a t nd onf rd hi su d hi su s i e e j 1 7 rs v d.Amtakha pr de J nDa sTr ki a a tona c oft e n e ole r s ovi d oh vi uc ng n ddii l opy he ve t l 8 r derdat i pr ousl s ,butwih m et a show i t dat and tm e t ecor a t evi y ent t adat ng he e i he I 9 eventr derdat w er downl ecor a e oaded. p i 20 /// 2l /// 22 /// 23 /// 24 /// 2 5 /// 26 /// 27 /// 28 /// 12940 9 L 6 79 . 34 . 9 0 SM 0 76! 5 Ca eNo.3: 1tv00461HDM VPC s l- - J I CASE M ANAGEM ENT STATEM ENT O NT case 3: cv11- 00461- M HD VPC Doc ent75 Fi 02/ 12 Page 6 of8 um l ed 16/ I 2 /// Re s t Vac t Ca e M an e e Conf en e nue t o ae s aa m nt er c 3 The pa te s i a e t va a e t Ca e M a g m e Conf r nc s e e f Fe u y ri s tpul t o c t he s na e nt e e e ch duld or br ar 4 21 2 1 a 9: 0 a. . ,02 t 0 m 5 DATED t s l6t day ofFebr y,20l hi h uar 2. 6 LAW OFFI CES O F M I CHAEL B.SPRI GER,PC N 7 8 By: l0 / /John D ,M oor s e John D .M oor e N evada St e BarN o.858I at 9628 Pr ot Cour ot ype t Reno,N V 8952 I ll ( 57 7 77 ) 86- 445 Ator y orr//n/frntCou er # nd t nesf c/ # l / nt de ant ' 9 N ATI ONA L RA I LRO AD PA SSENG ER r b 1 2 a ' 1j 1 3 CORP ORATI a dCo nedf n a t ON n u tr ee d n and count eraai antt l pA cl c m m ox Fl RAI LROADCOMP ANY . 8J g 1 j' 4 1iï: z :- ö . S - I 5 1 1 7 . OATED t s 1 1 day orlebr s 2012. hi 6t, r uar Ii 1 !l 6 ! LuB RlLPR&cx xrup o Ao,OE o A ' L , ! = By: I 8 //B . Cl Hut nson s yde chi B.Cl Hut ns yde chi on Calf ni St e BarN o.037526 ior a at Lake M er itPl rt aza l999 Har ion Steet Suie 2600 rs r , t Oakl CA 9461 354 I and, 2- l 9 20 2l ( 0)4 - 00 51 3326 Ator ys rPl nt a Count de nd l ne fo ai t nd er # ant 22 NATI AL RA I ON LRO AD PASSEN GER CORPORATI andCou e de nd ON ntr # ant 23 24 a Colnt r l m antUN I P CI C nd t e cai ON A FI RA I LROA D CO M PA NY D ATED t s l h day ofFebr y,20l2. hi 6t uar 25 HALL J AFF/ & CLAYTON, LLP 26 27 . . B y: //St s even T.Jaf e f St even T.Jaf e f 28 12 940 Ls *7 9 . 3 4 . - M 7 61 6 CaeNo.3: lc 00 HDM VPC s l -v- 461 J N T CASE M ANAGEM ENT STATEM ENT OI ' Case 3: cv11- 00461 H DM VPC Docum ent75 Fi 02/ 1 Page 7 of8 l ed 16/ 2 l Nev da St t BarN o.0 a ae 0703 5 7455 W es W as ngt Avenue,Suie 460 t hi on t 2 La Ve s NV 191 s ga 28 3 Ato nysf Dee nt tr e or f nda (0 )3l- I l 7 2 6L l J OHN DAVI TRUCK I G CO M PANY , S N I C. N 4 5 DATED t s 1 h day ofFebr y,201 hi 6t uar 2. 6 GO I COECHEA,D1G RAZI CO YLE & A, STANTON ,LTD . 7 8 9 . By: / /Gar E.D iG r a s v azi Ga yE.Di a a r Grii 10 l l P. Bo 1 Q. x 358 1 2 ! N evada St e BarNo.0001 at 98 530 I daho Steet r (k ,7 88091 Elo NV 8 01 7 5 3 98 7) - f At r e s o Cou tr li n t n y f r ne cama t o 1 1i 1 3 îJ ' ! 1 1j w k,.3 ! I . J 4 DAVI TRUCKI COMP OIN S NG ANY, j xc. l 4 I 5 DATED t s l h day ofFebr y,2012. hi 6t uar 6j 6 sj 1 l j KRL TO PO &PPLP I I H M SN OE L KN l 7 l 8 By: //St ht C.Th p o s ep n om s n St ephen C.Thom ps on Or egon St e BarNo.0076359 at ll Yeon Buidi 00 l ng 522 SW 5t Avenue h Porl O R 97204 tand, 1 9 20 2l Telpho e ne: ( )222 l 40 503 - 6 Fa si l c mie: ( )227 525I 503 Ator e orCou e cai t nysf ntr l mant 22 J OHN DAV I TRUCK I G CO M P Y, S N AN I C. N 23 24 25 26 27 28 12940 9 L 6 79 1 34 . 9 0 SM 0 76. 7 Cl eNo. llcv0046lHDM VPC t s 3: - - J NT CASE M ANAGEMENT STATEM ENT OI . . * Case 3: - 11 cv 00461 HDM VPC Docum ent75 Fi 02/ 6/ 2 Page 8 of8 l ed 1 1 l 2 3 I PRO PO SEDIO RDER Pert pari Joi Cas M ana'em entSt em ent t Cour her vacat t Cas he tes nt e g at t eby es he e , he M anagem entConf ence s er cheduld f Febr y 2l 201 at9: a. .i Courr e or uar , 2 00 m n toom l . 4 5 I I SO O RD ERED . T S 6 7 DATED: / X 8 x 9 By: 1 0 ) HE HO NO RA BLE V A E P.COO KE UN I TED STA TES M A STRA TE JUDGE ll ! f ï 1x 1 2 I 3 . 8J!d ' . 1 ïz l j 4 ! zi,i x nj l 5 s! 1 I. d- ro l 6 ï a ! : ! = 1 7 1 8 1 9 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 !29 09 L M 679. 34. 90 S 0761 4 8 çfeNo 3l -v0 4 lHDM VP t . :lc -0 6 s C J N T CASE M ANAGEM ENT STATEM ENT OI

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?