Bell v. Peery et al
Filing
60
AMENDED ORDER granting in part and denying in part 54 Motion (granting request for access to medical and mental health records, granting request to enable inmate assistant to review records with Plaintiff, and denying request for appointment of counsel), and denying 55 Motion to Appoint Counsel. Plaintiff to file response to "exhaustion" argument within 21 days. Paragraphs IV (3) and (4) are STAYED pending the filing of appropriate objections and subsequent review by District Judge Jones. (Amended Order to correct footnote 4 on page 5.) Signed by Magistrate Judge William G. Cobb on 10/5/2012. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - HJ)
'
i
.
.
q
'
!
:
i
1
:
.
)
I
;
;
E
E
'
:
!
i
:
I
!
'.
'
'
.
:
w
I
I
;
E
.
'
.
%
.
. .:
'C
' .. . 4.
1
.
.
'
.
:
.
.x
.
.$ .'' . . ' . ' $.
# ..
.
.
.. .
'
.
j
.
.
6
.
.
.
.
.
.
,
'
;
.
c.
l'
.:
'
.
'
'E
..
.
.
.
.
.'
'
.
..@ J . ' . '
.; .
'
'
:
!.
(
.
.
.
vx'
, sr
rso 'kvss m s,m cv.
r
covR'
r
7
. %
.
'
,
.
.
D I RI T O F N EV A D A
ST C
g
9
W I AM BELL
LLI
1
0
..
.
11
1
2
.
'
. Pl ntf;
ai if
.
vs
.
JOHN PEERY, /aI,
e .
1
3
Deen t)
f dants
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
3: 1c 00745- - GC
1 -vRCJW
.
. .
ANG NDEP ORDER
.
.
14
:
j
l
5
E
1
6
Alobeor t c taevai ot rmotonsa doc
s f e he our r rous he
i nd ument (haacerz heei astc ltrl
s c r t ied r n tolaea
:
1
7
is s' whih ha abe rng o how Pli ifwilbea et rs
s ue '
) c ve a i n
antf l
bl o e pondt Defndant'moton fr
o e
s
i o
i
1
8
s mmayj d me t ThsOr e a d e s st r s lto o tec ltrlis s bu n ttemo in
u r u g n . i d r d r se he e op i n f h ol ea sue , t o h to
a
:
1
9
f s
or ummazj
r udgme .At e e z s ii ofDef nt' i orsl r udgme ha bee
nt prs ntdiposton
enda s motonf lmma yj
nt s n
20
i br a l saye be aus o t colatr lis whi h havea iç he ei Thec lt r lis t
nt m ly t d c e f he l e a s ues c
rs n' r n.
ola e a s ues o
21
ber ol d by t sOr ra e:
es ve
hi de r
'
Bef et c ti Deenda s'Aprl23,2012M otonf Sul r J
or he our s f nt
i
i or nmay udpnent( #39)
Doc. .
I
;
:
.
22
23
A.W heh t c ts d ra Pl ntf a ge ala nt ntofco e ( s # 54,
ter he our houl nt ai if ner ppoi me
uns l Doc .
#5 ;
5)
24
B.W hehe hec t houl pant antf ati t 'ppoi me ofcot e f t ' 54)
t rt ours d
Pli if ç mied'a nt nt
l
ms lorDoc# '
. ,
25
C.n ea horz d e e ofPl ntf ' r vi ofhi m ediala m e alhe t r c dst
ut ie xtnt ai ifs s ew
s
c nd nt alh e or '
Doc.
i
2
6
!
27
i
.
#
28 me c r c dsr vj ( s # 4g, 54 )
dial e or e ew. Doc .
,
#s ) a d
4;n ,
D . The i ntf of t pe s who w ilbe a horzed t a s s Pl i i fw ih r s ctt hi
de iv
he r on
l
ut i
o s i t a ntf t e pe o s
.
i
j
'
.
2
.
.
'
'
'
1
;
2
ï
Thi Or rwil lor quiePl i ift r s
s de l a s e r antf o e pondt t te uyi '
o he txha ton'compone ofDe e nt '
nt
f nda s
moinf rs mmayj d me tt c #3 a 1 - 8 .Se ih' a p. (.
to o u r u g n ' . 9 t 6 1 ) e n a t 2)
Do
.
.
.
.
g
.
4
'
j BA C K G R O g ND
.
At a l r l vanttm es Pl ntf W ila Be lwas i t c t y of N e da De r m entof .
1 ee
i , ai if li m
l
n he us od
va
pa t
5
Coreci I
r tons NDOCIhous da No t r Ne Coreci lCe e (
, e t rhen vada r tona ntr NNCC) ( ' Co .Doc
. Pls mpl( .
6
#4. Plitf a os imae big ti ato pusa to4 U.. j1 8 .(d.' fn a tae' '
) anil pr e n t, rn s hs cin ru n t 2 SC. 9 j l 4Dee d ns r
l
7
K eih O wns , J t mb,
t
by ane La Davi Mar J l Pe a Sa aSni r (d. t13.
d , om eoz nd ndr de . 1 a - )
8
wihhi alegaint thewa f c dt t et a i yc i me c tonAbiiy.( r e ngOr
t s l to ha
s ore o ak he ntps hotc diai
lf Sc e ni der
11
( .#3)) Dee t ba move f su nrud e ,plmarl ont poundsDee t
Doc . fndans ve
d or tnma j m nt i iy he
fndans
1
2
wer no de i r t l i f e e t hi m e c ne ,e n as um i s h ne ds r e t t l ve of
e t lbe a e y ndi f r nt o s di al eds ve s ng uc e os o he e l
1
3
.
cam f
li ordelbeaei fee et as rousmedia ne dunde heEi hAme
i rt ndifrnc o ei
cl e
rt ght
ndme i c ci
ntn onne ton
1
0
(
On s re ng,t c tdeemi t tPl ntT sCompl nt( # 4)saesac orbl
ce ni he our tr ned ha ai i
ai Doc.
tt ol a e
9
'
bengç e i . Jaco'nv Mcntsh, F. 330,332( hCi.1 ( tng Wilamsv.Vi e ,
i t rous' l o . l o 90 3d
s
'
9t r 996) cii li
nc nt
1
4
508F. 5 ,5 - ( Ci.1 4:.t oc #39a 111 )
2d 41 43544 2nd r 97 ' .
D
t -2.
'
j
15
Pl ntf i taly r que td a45- y e e i oftmet r s
ai if nii l e se
da xt nson i o e pond t De e nt 'm o i f
o f nda s ton or
1
6
srmayj d me t ntego n sh t e a s h kileaeh mu teyo teassa c ofelw
un r u g n o h ru d ta b c ue e sltrt, e srl n h sitn e flo
i
1
7
i t t prpaehi rs e.( . 44. Thecou tgr tdPl ntf' motona Pli ifwa
nmaes o e r s e pons Doc # )
r ane ai ifs i nd antf s
1 p o ie t iJ l 2 201 t fl hsrs o s .( c #4 )
8
r vd d mtl uy , 2,o i i e p n e Do . 5.
e
1 .
9
Plitf di n t n h sn tildars o s t Dee d n s moi nf rs mmayj g n .
anif d o a d a o ie e p n e o fn a t' to o u r ud me t
20
I ta onJ l 201 Pl ntf ie at ques f aSus nso ofPr e n .'( . 46.
nse d, une 3, 2, ai iffld t
Re t or
pe in
oce digs' Doc # )
21
l or a e i t Pl ntf ' moton t s pe pr ee ngs wa a co pone t t t c t
nc por t d n he ai ifs
i o us nd oc di
s
m
nt ha he our
22
i emr t asb ngamotont a ntcot el (d. l a or rdatdApgu t30,201 t cou t
nt eed ei
i o ppoi ms . I j n n de e
s
2,he r
23
de e Pl ntf ' m oton f a poi ed co elba ed o Pl ntf ' a lt t a tc a e hi c ai s
ni d ai if s
i or p nt
uns
s n ai if s biiy o ri ul t s l m
2
4
(let t t ea ssa c o a ohe imae.( c #5 a 6 7)M o ei o tnl,h c u to n
ab i' h h s itn e f n t r n t) Do . 2 t - . r mp ra ty t e o r f u d
wi
25
26
l na to t t me c c r is e De e da t'mo i ( c. 3 ase t t e ote g o dson
i ddiin o he dial a e s u , f n n s ton Do # 9) s rs hre h r r un
whihDee da t c tn s
c fn ns one d ummayjdg n soul b e trdonteibe l:heElve t Ame n b r
r u me t h d e nee h r haft e nh ndme t as
27 Pl ntf' j 1 3 d ma ecamsa ai tDee nsi t ero fcal a ciis t eDee a saee ildt
ai ifs 98 a g li g ns fnda t n h i fii c pa te , h fnd nt r ntte o
quaIfed i muniy,and Pl ntf
ii m
t
ai ifhasnotpr l exhaust hi admi s r i r
opery
ed s
nitatve emedi . Asnot above,t
es
ed
he
28 cour i r quii Pl ntl t r pond t t Def
t s e rng ai i o es
o he endant exhauston ar ent
s'
i gum .
;
j
?
2
'
(
1
Pli ifha no e t ihe a Ikelhood ofs e s6nt m e is6fhi Ei h Amendmentcli .
antf d t sabls d i i
ucc s
he rt
s ght
am
2
(d.(cii Do . 37, 51. I t trgad,h co tsOr rpot t tadeer nai ha ar dy
1 4 tng cs# # ) n ha e r te ur' de ed ha t mi ton d lea
'
.
k
1
:
3
'
be m a i .t s c s .. n e u i Pl ntf ' ' i f a tm por r r jr ni
en
de p hi q e whe val atng ai if s moton or
e
a y e tai ng
.
ï
o d rp ei n n/nu cin( c. 5 t a f an if m n t e n tae alk l o o s c e so
r e/r lmia ij n to Do . ) h t@ itf h s o d mo srtd i ei d f u c s n
#
pi
ho
'
5
t mert. . oc. 37,Re t nd.econme ton,a 8.
he is' m #
'
por a R r ndai t )
.
'
.
. .
!
7
Aprl l1 201 (
i , 2. Doc.# 37. W ihout rieatng eveyt ng co ane i t Re tand
) t
etr i
r hi
nti d n he por
8
Rec
omme ato t plr r is prs ntdbypli ifsmotonf ijmci r i wa whehe
nd in,he ipay sue e e e
antf' i orn t tve elef s t r
9
Pl ntf
ai ifwasbe ng t or e 'b NDOC ofii st t ket a i y tc dr g Abiiy. t o # 4 a
i t c d' y
f
fcal o a he ntps cho i u
lf ' c.
D
t
1
0
34. Plitf c tnde hewm plce o t a ips hoi dr AbiiybyDefndant. (d.
- ) anif one d
s a d n he nt- yc tc ug lf
e
s 1)
1
I
.
.
Pl i ifa l ge t to Se e be 27, 1, wen t t N DO C m edi alofi e a w œst r ed
a ntf le d ha n pt m r 201 he
t o he
c
lc nd
t c
coe
1
2
i o t ki A biiy w ih t t e hew oul b pl c i m ent h lh s e ton i-: r f e * **
nt a ng lf t he hr at
d e a ed n
al ea t egr ga i jje e us d
1
3
Hecone e t tprs ofiil ma hi c i t ngAbiiy....'I )
tndgd) ha ion fcas de m ontnue aki
lf
'(d.
1
4
Bec us ofpli tf s e tonhewasbengf ce otkea tps cho i m e ca i
a e
a n irsa s ri
i or dt a nan i y tc di tonagans
i t
1
5
hi w il t c t c dul d anexpe t d he r ng on Pl i i f sm oton. A t hehe rng c
s l, he our s he e
die a i
a ntf '
i z t
a i onduc e on
td
1
6
De mbe l9, 1,
ce r 2O1 hqwev r t Pli ifa s d t c tt i no now tki Abiiy,
e , be antf dvie he our ' s t
he
a nc lf doesnot
1
7
wiht tkeAbiiy, ndt hi knowldge hasnott nAbiiysn eOcobe 25, 1. (d.a 1.
s oa
lf a o s
e ,
ake
lf ic t r 201 3 1 t )
5
1
8
Alo, p t iton yGe ea Nah nHmt sDee d ns c u sl rpee tdPlitf
s De uy tre n rl ta si , fn a t' o n e, e rsne anif
pg
1
9
ha not e t or e 'ot keAbiiya woul not r quie ot t media i unl st cou'
d be n t c d't a
f
lf nd
d be e r dl ake he
c ton es he l
t
20
weenotfedi a nc .( c.#37a 3.
r ii n dva e Do
t )
.
.
.
21
Spe fca l De e nt i t ropposton r pr en e t t
cii ly, f nda s n hei
ii e es t d ha :
22
AsofOc obe 25, 1 Pl i irhasr f e t t keAbiiy.Se Rrla eofLibiiy
t r 201 , antf
e us d o a
lf
e es
a lt
f Ref a ofM e c lTr t
or us l
dia eamentda e 1 25 11,
t d 0- - DOP 2523, ta heda Exhi tB t
atc
s
bi o
'
!
.
Thes m a t sa em o et r ll dicus ddi t sCour ' Re r a Re onunenda i of
e ter r r ho ougly s s n hi
ts po t nd c
ton
,
i
'
'.
.
6
'
!
.
23
t sOp ii Pli i sr evant i n e c lonRe or ( e She s as
hi poston. antT el ContnuigM diai c ds M d et) lo
s w t tPl ntf ha nott
ho ha ai if s
aken Abiiy snc Oct r 25,2011.Se Contnui
lf i e obe
e
i ng
M edi ton Re r f O c o rand N ove be 2011, O C 25
ca i
co ds or t be
m r
D
45+ 0P2564, ta he
a tc d
m Ex bi C,a C 1 1
s hi t t 30, 33. A s Pl i if i nott ng A biiy,a ha n t ke i,
a ntf s
aki
lf nd s ot a n t
snce Oc obe 25,20l1a t lt t a r que tf a or rt sop te t e wih
i
t r
t he a es, ny e s or n de o t r am nt t
A biiy i m oo ,
lf s
t
'
'
24
25
26
Pl ntf ' r ques i a s m ootbe us he hm ne bee f r e t t ke Abiiy. The
ai i f s e
t s lo
ca e
s ver n o c d o a
lf
27
28
2
Th hit yofh s h duigoft se pe tdhe rn i dicu sdi grae d tiih'a pp.1- 3.
e sor te c e ln hi x di . aig s s se n e tr ealn a t 11
e
3
1
p o e u ea dprt o g venn a imaesc n e ta do rf s lh r olt tk
r c d r n ooc l o r ig n n t ' o s n (n /r e u a te e t o a e
p y h to hc me iain i f u d i M e ia Die tv (
s c or p i d c to s s o n n dc l rcie MD)3 5,atc e a
0 ta h d s
2 . ' Exhi tD t t sopposton;a i Admi srtveRe ai l( 643,atche ms ,
.
bi o hi
ii nd n
nitai gultoi AR)
ta d
.
!
'
!
!
'
'3
:
' .'
.
Exhi tE t t sopposton.# # *l a c danc wiht spr edt e,Pl i i sDOC
bi o hi
ii
n c or e t hi oè t
r antc
c 25 c e a a e m e t t e t è . ih A biiy w a obt i d on J nua z 31 . .
96 ons nt nd p e nt o r a m ntw t
lf
s a ne
a r ,:
.
2008. Se Cons ntf ps hotophi M e c i DOC 2596,a tc a ' xhi tF
e
e or yc r c diaton,
ta hed sE bi
' . .. .
.
'
L . '' . .o t sojposton. I f c ,Pl i ifvol t rl t Abiiy daiy dtrng a .e tt
. ' t hi
.
ii n a t ' a ntf un a iy ook lf l li tlas he
'
E
t.
.
. .
'
m o hs of J nua y a M a c t ough M a 2009, J
nt
a r nd r h hr
y,
. anua y t o , Augu t. 0, .
r hr ug
h
s ,201 .
'
5 . ;' Odober 201 t ough J
' '
, 0 hr
anum' 2011 a M a c 2011t o mos' Se e r '
y,
) nd r h,
hr ugh
tof pt mbe ; .
20l Exhi tC,M e s e s n i consiut d a la t6 volmt r i t e of.'
1.
bi
d he t . s
tt e t e s 60 t a y nsanc s.
6
Pl ntf a ng A biiy a t rJ nua y 2009.
ai ift ki
lf fe a r
'
. '. t
. .
'
f
'
' ''
. .. .
,
'
7
'
l a or éc wihM D 305,medialsa fa s c
n cc da e t
c tf lo omplt Pli ifsDOP 25 f m
eed anif '
23 or
( biB)onOcobe 25, 1whe hede dedt rvokehi c e t keame
Exhi t
t r 201
n
ci o e
s ons nt o t nt
8
wih Abiiy. antf e t thi te t tw1. Abiiy wmsvolmt r andt the
t
lf Pl i ifkn w ha s r a men t3 lf
1
t a y,
ha
c d r f e t t ke t dr g. He ha pr vi l r us t t ke A biiy on
oul e us o a he u
d e ous y ef ed o a
lf
Se e b 27 a 2#,2011 Ex bi C,a C 1 .
ptm er nd
. hi t t 27.
9
1
0
.
( #9a 3- . f n es ciai a ex bisomitd.
Doc. t 4)( ootot , ttons nd hi t te )
.
.
.
11
The e l r i a M i e O r r i s d on D e e be 27,2011 be aus of Pl ntT s ea le
r afe , n
nut de s ue
cm r
, c e
ai i
ri r
1
2
s a e en s h wasnotb ng f r bl m edi t and ba ed on D e e
tt m t e
ei o ci y
ca ed,
s
f ndan s r pr s nt tonjt c t
t ' e e e ai
he our
1
3
w oul be a s d be or a s h pr edtr w e e unde t ke t cour opi ti lke y a
d
dvi e f e ny uc oc ze r
r à n, be
t ned tt i l ppea s t
r he
1
4
bmssm s td f t t
i sere or he emporr r kani or rpr i nay ij nci ha r ol d ....'t oc.
ay es i ng de/ elmi r n u ton s es ve
''
D
1
5
# 2 ) Asds u s d a o e t rq e tf rij n tv r le wm c n iee mo t Th c mpee
9.
ic se b v ,he e u s o nu cie eif s o sd r d o . e o lt
'6
l
gr
ounds ex es ed by t s c t f r com m e ng a de a of Pl ntf m oton f t m po a y
pr s
hi our or e
ndi
ni l
ai ips
i or e
rr
1 rsriigod rprl n i ijn td aestfrhi Do . 3 a p .8 1 .Che J d eJ e
7 etann re/ ei m nu cin r e o t n c # 7 t p - 1 if u g on s
mi
1
8
a o tdt eRe or a dRe o n aina d ne Pli tf moinf rij ncier l f ( c
d pe h p t n c mme d to nd e id anips to o n u tv ei . Do .
e
l
9
20
# 51.
)
21
m r
w r n
ou
o
Pl ntf t oton t Conduc Ea l D i c r ' f l d on N ove be 22,2011, he ei he s 'ghtt
ai ifs & i o
M
t ry s ove y ' ie
2
2
u etk tmme it ds o ey' ( c. 1 )Plitf wa tdt c n u t s o eyo s b e t h
nd ra e t dae ic v r . Do # 6. anif ne o o d c dic v r n u j cs e
i
'
2
3
c n e de wee g r n t h sr q e tf rij n tv rle ,many s cu n me iain rc r ,
o tn d r ema e o i e u s o n u ci e eif il e ti g dc to e ods
2
4
p y iins o d r a d PlitT sme tlh at e au to s ( c # 1 a 2. Heas . q se
h sca ' r es n an i
na e lh v l ai n . Do . 6 t )
lo r uetd
e
25
a s s a e ofi a e c
s it nc
nm t ouns li doi s Pl ntf ' r que t w e e a es e butnotdec ded att
e n ng o. ai if s e s s r ddr s d
i
he
26
' a i onDec mbe 1 2O11 m o # 23. Asme ine a
he rng
e r9
. c. )
nto d bove t c topi t tPli if'
he our ned ha antf s
27
be
r pr s nt tonshe ha no bee a wasnotbei f c d t t Abii y lkel r nder d m oott
e e e ai
d t n nd
ng or e o ake lf i y e e
.
Alo rl antt t an yssoftl c l ealis st c ili undet ng he en wa
s eev o he al i le olafr s ue he otr s
raki r i s
.
'
28
s b e tma t ofPl ntm smotonfrat
u j c ter ai i
i o emporr rsri ngor rpr i no 'nunci andt
ay etani de/ elmi ij ton, hus
4
'
'
1
r
; .
.
m i a s r nde Pl i if sm oton f e ry di c nr oo asw e l The c t ho eve ,want d t
ght l o e r a ntf '
i or a l s ove m t
l.
our , w r
e o
2
.
a iv rfc to &o Dee d ns c1mkll tNDOC ofcaswo l not.or e Pl ntf t t ke .
wat eiiain m fn a y' ( e ta
l k
fiil ud f c ai if o a
) , . lf .( tou me ng, s.. Flha KbO/ o fcll h dPo c d'P an if otk me iain :
. iy wih t ani t uggett ! .. fii s a f re ' litf t a e dc to l.
Abi
o
'
.
J
T..
.'
4 W h nt èc ur rc ie s c a sla c sf m Dee a t'c u s lLe Do s # 2 a d#2 ) i
e h o t e ev d u h ét n e m
r
fpd ns o n e s e c . 3 n 4 ,ie
.
'
..
.
:
.
.
.
.
.
:., ' .
, .
,
1
.
.
..
'
. .
'
.'
' '
'
l
'
5
.
k
.
.
.cu s e ntyf dt tba l f Pl ntf . in fre rydic r i moot' ( *;9
clrt ubs que l oun he ç ss pr ai irsmoto o al s ovey s
. Doc. 2
'
.
6
a 1.
t )
'
' .
i
,
'
E
(
.
7
..Thec tas not i isor rofDe embe 27,2011l6 ,t taSc dulngOr rha
our lo ed n t de
c
r
il ha
)
he i
de d
8
ar d b n is d onDe mbe 23,2011 whih s tadicoveyde i ofAprl5,201 (
lea y ee sue
ce r
, c e s r adlne
i
2 Doc.
9
# 27 .Thi s dulng or rt rbye e Pl ntf t unde t whaeve dic yhedee d
)
s che i de hee nabld ai if o
rake t r sover
me
1
0
n esay,whih woul pr umabl i ude t e s j t a e s i hi moi f eal
ec s r . c
d es
y ncl hos ubecs ddrsed n s ton or ry
11
di c r ' For t e r a ons Pl ntf moton f ea l dic r was not onl m oot bu
s ove y.
hes e s , ai ifs
i or ry s ove y
y
t
12
unnecess y.
ar
1
3
Anot ri s now be or t cour ars sf om t D e enda s co e i t tbec us oft
he s ue
f e he
t i e r he f
nt ' nt nton ha
a e he
1
4
s ii i or a i i Pl i i s m e a he lh r cor ,Pl i ifs oul notbe a f ded c pl t
enstve nf m ton n a nt&
nt l a t e ds a ntf h d
f br
om e e
1
5
a c st al ofhi r c ds pari a l hi m e al alh r cor .A t heD ec m be 1 2011he rng,
c es o l
s e or , tcul ry s nt he t e ds t
e r 9,
ai
1
6
t c t xp es e co e na
he our e r s d nc r bout e e nt p o ed r t i tonso Pl ntf ' ac es t hi r c ds
D f nda s' r pos es rc i
n ai if s c s o s e or
1
7
i t s m a t r The c tdi c s d t i t t s t t o na el w he he Pl i i fw asorw asnot
n hi te .
our s us e he nsan iua i n, m y
t r a ntf
1
8
fr e t tk a a tp y h tcme iain Th c u t u g se Plitf c ul b p eudc d b a
oc d o a e n n is c o i d c to . e o r s g e td anif o d e rj ie y
1
9
d al ac e st al m edi al e r i t them a not a e t a qua el a tc a e a o
eni of c s o l
c r co ds n ha
y be bl o de t y r i ul t n pposton
ii
20
t Dee d nt'mo inf rs mmayj d me twih u t eo po t i t a c s t hi me ia a d
o f n a s to o u r u g n t o t h p runt o c e s o s d c l n
y
21
m e a he t r or .
nt l alh ec ds4
.
22
At heDec m be . g, 1hea i , he c t e e e i g er l e m st sand d pa a e e s
t
e rl 20l
r ng t our r vi w d n en a t r he t ar r m t r
23
ofi a e a s sanc as a horze by N D OC . A c r ng t ' D O C polc i a esar notalow e
nm t s i t e
ut i d
co di o N
i y, nm t e
l d
24
a c st f l i t sme c r or .( #23a 2. Howe r t c r bele idi no go
c es o elow mnae' dialec ds Doc.
t )
ve ,he ou t ives t d t
25
3Tbe c ' under t ng i t Pl nts had underaken no dicover her n.
ourts
sandi s hat ai i
t
s
y ei
26
4 S e Or r( .# 5 a 2- , whih p i rl a drs e Plitœ s mo i f s s e in of
e de Doc 2 t 3) c rma i d e s d an i
.
y
ton or u p nso
27 pr di butal dicus ed t Pl ntf ' r
ocee ngs
so s s he ai if s eques f i a eas s ance i opposngDef
t or nm t sit
n
i
endant M otonf
s' i or
Summ a y Judgment compi e acces t hi medi and ment healh r ds,and i e assit
r
,
et
so s
cal
al t ecor .
nmat
sance i
n
28 r viw i hi me t lh al r c ds
e e ng s n a e t e or .
h
5
t
'
.
'
!
;
'
1
s f ra De e
o a s f ndant s s i h ropposto t pl nt& smotonf us i n o oc di t t
s ugge tnt ei
ii n g ai i
i ors penso fpr ee ngs ha
'2
f he c
t ouh ha ale y i c ed t ti woul notor rt tPl i ips'nmâ e a ssâ . alowe
t
s r ad ndiat ha t
d
de ha antf i t s it ntbe l d
'
'
3
.
.
I
'
.
i.
'
.
.
'
a ec nla'ot i r t sc tnii l dic s dt pa ameer ofi t as itnc , f l : ..
r r l he nquiy; hi our i taly s us è he r t s mna e ssa e as olows '.
t
6
8
W hiet courtdeni Pl ntf sm oton f her onss at above't cqur brety
l he
ed ai if'
i ort eas
t ed
, he
t il
a es e Pl i if j r
ddr s d a ntf ' eques f r i a e ms i t ce i c ec i wih r vi w i hi
t o nm t s s an n onn ton t e e ng. s
m edi al e or . ( eM i es t . 23.Plitfwu ad s dtat ec duiie
c r c ds Se nut a Doc # ) anif
vie h h oul tlz
t ms i t e ofa f low i na e f pum os s o r di a w rtng hi pl a ngsi
he s sanc
e l m t or
e f ea ng nd ii
s e di n
9
t sc e butt i t as itntwoul notbepe m itdt a a a hea i ora t
hi as ? he mna e ssa
d
r te o ppe r t rngs c
' sPlitf' at ne (d.Thec t onfr dt tac ewor rwoul bepemitd
a anlfs tor y.l j our c ime ha as ke
d
r te
.
7
'
'
1
0
l1
1
2
1
3
1
4
1
5
.
ta
o ppea w ih Pl ntf the i , one di a t e Dec m be 1 2011 he r ng,f
r t ai ifa arngs ms
d th
e r 9,
a i or
.
pupos ofhel ngPl ntf ot ertndwha i occ rngz(d.
r es
pi ai ift md sa
t s uri I )
.
.
( c. 52a 3.
Do # t )
H o e ,t c ta s que i i is o de t ti Pl ntf doe nothav t e a s s anc of
w ver he our l o
red n t r r ha f ai if s
e h s it e
c m s l ho woul Pl i tf abl
ol e , w
d a n ifbe e
t pr pa eam e ni f la gu e i opposton t D e e
o e r
a ng u r m nt n
ii o f ndan s' oton. n ot w or ,
t m i l her ds
i hi i a e a s s a i notalow e t t ke pa ti t m e c r cor r e ,how
f s nm t s i t nt s
l d o a
r n he di al e ds evi w
w ilPl i ifbe abl t i m or t wha he gl ns f om h s m e c r c ds r e
l a ntf
e o nco a e
t
ea r
i
di al e or evi w
w ih t n i a e as i t nti o a ari ul t l ga ar m e ? '
t he on-nm t s s a nt n tc a e e l gu nt
1
6
17
1
8
19
(d.a 8 9.
1 't - )
N
'
'
Def nt c rcl poi outi t i MotonfrSumm ayJ
enda s ore ty nt n her i o
r udgme ( . 39)t twhie
nt Doc # ha l
no pec f c l r l ct d i hem i t sof heD e e ber1 2011he i t c t s pr i i iy
ts i i aly çfe e nt
nu e t
cm
9,
arng, he our alo elm narl
.
a r s ed Def nda s a gum e t t Pl i if n be gi com pl t a es t hi m e al he lh
dd e s
e nt ' r
nt ha a ntf ot
ven
e e cc s o s nt
at
(
!
21
i
rc r s (d a 3n. . Th c r sae iwa n t c saiyp ru de b Dee da t' r u n ta
e o d . 1 . t l) e ou tttd t s o ne e s rl e s a d y fn ns ag me th t
f ri tt tona s u iy a Pl ntY sow n m e alhe t t tPl i ifs
o ns iu i l ec r t nd ai i
nt alh ha a ntf houl notbe a e t r e
d
bl o evi w
22
:
:
.
5
'
:
i
.
a iltrt 'litf sf i s
n lieaèP anifi acng ummayj me baedonmediila menalhe lh.è or Shi .
r udg nt s
è nd' t t at rc ds v th
!
'
ac és t Pli'ifsmedial e r (
c s o àntf . c r cö ds Doc. k (7 #48a 3. I t c e ofhila e;
'
#29)' . oc.
.1
'
t ) n àe ontxt t s' s wher
c
e
:. 4
.
'
:
'
(
g.l ofhi me a he lhrcodstat r gemanet t sc e n
l s ntl at e r h ae r
.
o hi as .
ec ti c tdi wasi lne t
our ndiae t
nci d o
23
o d t tPl ntf be alow e t r vi t m i he w e e r quie t oppos a m o i f s z r
r er ha ai i f
l d o e ew he f
r e rd o
e
ton or unm a y
24
25
j
udgme i t f ur pa tculryamoi e c e o Pli ifsme ca r or .(d. Thecou t
ntn he ut er ri al
tonprdiatd n antf' di lec ds 1 j
r
m a no de i tv r lng on t s i s ,but a s D e e nt t tt y woul ne d t pr de
de
fnii e u i
hi s ue
dvi ed f nda s ha he
d e o ovi
26
27
28
a tona s
ddii l uppor f rt i agume (. ,t tPl ntf notbe gi n a es t hi me a he lh
t o her r nt ie. ha ai if
ve cc s o s ntl at
r c r s u o fln amoinfrs mmayj d me t(d)No ta Dee d nsh v fldamo in
e o d ) p n i g to o u r u g n .1 . w h t fn a t a e i
i
e
to
6
'
!
1
i
'
2
.
f rs r r j d me t whc d si f c.e vi r l o Pl itf' me ia r c r s ta is ei
o umnay u g n , ih oe n a th a l ey n anifs dc l e o d ,h t su s
y
s r y bef r t cour.
qua çl
o e he
t
, .
.
:
!.. .... . 3
'. .: .
.
1.'
I'u.
r ,4
..
.
rao o hsia ii t.edo wrt, ihi t jp td ( c #6 a 8) Fanife rtrsae .
e sn f i n blt ora r ie whc smds ue . Do . 2 t . litf. le ttd
y
a
;
!.'. ;:.. .
: . . .' 5
,
'
hewane t havehi i t a ssan r e sr dia r c ds t hi n eDefndanso j ce
td o
s nmae sit t eviwhi he c l e or wih m.
e t b e td,
i
. .
'
.
.
.
. .Tbee e ta manne ofPli ilqm viw ofhi m edialr cor i f rt rcom plcat d by
.xtn nd
r antft
e
s
c e ds s u he
i e
.
x
6
satng i a e m edi lr c ds a e nott be s r d wih a ot ri a e i a c danc w ih N DO C
t i nm t
ca e or r
o
ha e t ny he nm t n c or
e t
7
p iy. ( c . 48 #5 . e NDUU M e ia Die tv 7 70 , 4. Dee a t ise dp o o e
ol Do s # , 6 s e
c
,
dc l r cie 0 .2- ) fnd ns n t a r p s d
11
8
t tPl i ifbe alow e t r vi w ce t i non- nt anm at y r c ds w ih t as i t e ofND O C
ha a ntf
l d o e e
ra n
i ll
or e or
t he s sanc
9
pe s .( #48at3- )
ronnel Doc.
4.
1
0
M or r c ty, De enda s ha a t m a i y s es e t t t cou tpr de Pl i tf a
e e en l
f
nt ve le tvel ugg t d ha xhe
r ovi
a n if
11
tlm ie appoi m e ofcot s y ie. a a t ne w h w oul be a
ti t d
nt nt
m el' . , n tor y o
'
d
ppoi e s e y t a s s Pl ntf
nt d ol l o s it ai if
,
1
2
wihrgar t t moinf s mmayj
t e d o he to or u r udgme .( #56at2- ) n i s gesi i dicuse i
nt Doc.
3. s ug ton s s sd n
E
1
3
gr a e d ai i-hm at 1 1 .
e t r et l n
pp. 4- 6,howev ,t c ti s ptca t tt spr a prs nt avi e
er he our s ke i l ha hi opos l e e s abl
14
s uton.
ol i
E
'
15
n ef e ngs
or goi umm azpr vi st lgal ndf t al r m e kt t e t t sco tsOr r
r o de he e a ac u fa wor ha l d o hi ur' de
1
6
l oc. 52)onAugu t30,201 Alhoug t ni pag or rdicuse t is esmor tor ughl
' #
D
s
2. t h hat ne e de s ss he s u
eh o y
17
t r i t or rge r ly r l
he e n, he de ne a l u ed:
1
8
()
1
Dee d ns moint s a Ex i i B t Dee d ns mo inf rs mmayj dg n ,
fn a t' t o e l h bt o fn a t' to o u r u me t
o
1
9
co itng ofva i pr e s nots fom Pl ntf ' m e ca fl ,s d be g antd. t
nssi
rous ogr s
e r
ai ifs di l ies houl
r e '
Doc.#52
20
a 5- .5
t 6)
21
(
2)
'
'
Pl ntm smotonfra n% ent ox s lwhiht cou toundt beacompone
ai i
i o ppoi
ofc ez c he r f
o
nt
2
2
o pan i ' mo int s s e dt c #4 a 12 , sd ne ( c #5 a 6 7. Th rto aef r
f lit fs to o u p n ' . 6 t - ) wa e id. Do . 2 t - ) e ain l o
f
Do
23
t de a ofa nt tofc elwasdicus e a
he ni l ppoi men
ouns
s s d bove, nl t tPl ntf dnotde o taed
mai y ha ai ifha
m nsr t
24
hi c ei undul c
s as s
y omplx ort lke i
e
he i lhoodofs c s wih r s c t hi ale i ofs c i 1
uc e s t e pe t o s lgatons e ton 983
25
la lt Fc r /v.Sr wc 935F.d 1 1 ( hCi.1 ) ( Doc. 5 a 6- )
ibiiy. r c/ c r,
2 015, 017 9t r 991.See
# 2 t 7.
26
(
3)
W hehe Pl ntf ca a c shi f tlheat r or wihoutr srcton,whehe
t r ai if n c es s nena l. ec ds t
h
eti i
t r
27
28
5 The s i ofsuch r ds, h ve ,i no g r e t t e diposto of t e c lt r li s s
ealng
ecor
owe r s t e man o h s ii n
h ol e a s ue
a
addr sed her n.
es
ei
7
.
l
2
'
'
',
.
.
.
'
.
.
.
.
.
a ssa e, orw het rPl ntf us r l on N D OC pers
s itnc
he ai i fm t e y
onnel w a t be a & e s by Pl i ifa
, so
d s ed
a ntf nd
'3
:
'
Pl i if c n utlz a t r i a e t a s s hi i r vi w i M s r cor a t s ope of t t
a ntf a ii e no he nm t o s it m n e e ng
e ds nd he c
ha
Dee nt i spari me a
fnda s n e ae. mornda. M ur s ci c l t c r diece t : test 'ubmi
e pe t aly, he ou t r td.he pari o s t
i
4
'
.
.
' e o andat 'se enbe . l' l r pohdi g t t ecour' c e nst at. .
m m r
by pt t rz ,20 2, es
n oh
ts onc r h :
5
..
6
'
7
..
..
'.
.
.
'
.
.
. .. , ..
.
.
...
.
. . .
'
.
.
.
.
,
.
.
, . .
'
.
''
... . :
.
.
Th c uti n w c nrne wi teis eo wh te Plitf' imaeassa t
e o r s o o fo td t h su f eh r aniis n t sitn
h
'
.
s oul bealowedt r vi Pl ntf ' m e c r cor al wihhi s t tpl htf . . ' .
h d
l
o e ew ai if s dial e ds ong t m o ha ai if .
ma pr r a r s e t De é n s M oton f Su nma y J
y epa e e pons o f nda t '
i or r r udgme ,orwhehe '. '
nt
t r '
NDOC' ( fe)t p o iePlitf sano -n t a ssa t orve tk noe
S o fr o r vd an ifwa
n imae sitn t e iw,a e ts
a c y des g t d m edi alr c ds i s t c e t
nd op
i na e
c e or s ufi i n .
8
9
1
0
The ei no di put r gar ngpl ntf ' i biiyt r adand wl t : e e or i i c e r
r s
s e e di ai if s na lt o e
i e n r f e, t s l a
t tPl i tf ilne d s em mm e ofas i t e i r vi w i h! m e ca r c ds i
ha a n i fw l e om
r
s sanc n e e ng s di l e or n
or rt a tcul t a pr pa eam e ni f r s
de o ri a e nd e r
a ng ul e pons t D e e
e o f ndan s m oton. co t
t ' i The ur
.. . has de e m i d t t i wilal o a f d t pa tes an op t t t pr e f rher
t r ne ha t l s f or he ri
poruniy o es nt u t
brefng and or m' enton t s i
i i
al gum
hi ssue.
11
1
2
1
3
1
4
15
1
6
17
1
8
1
9
20
21
Th c tha nothe r a r t la gu e f om Pl ntf * t r s c t N D O C '
e our s
a d ebuta r m nt r
ai i f . e pe t o
1
3
S
o f r t pr de hi wih a non- nm a e as i t tt twilr ad,t no es a c
f e o ovi
m t
i t s san ha l e ake t nd opy
d i td medialr c ds # * * Pl ntf s oul alo a les why a non-nma e
esgnae
c e or .
ai if h d s dcr s
i t
a s s a w oul be i uf i e .
s i t nt
d ns lci nt
M or over t c tr ques sD e e nt a e s w h he pr di t s non-mna e
e
, he our e
t f nda s ddr s
et r ovi ng hi
i t
woul alow Pl i ift pr pa e a m e ngf a gu enti oppos ton t Def nt
d l
a ntf o e r
ani ul r m
n
ii o enda s'
' o i i ot
m ton. n herwor , fhi i a eas i t nti not l w e t t kepa t nt m e c
ds i s nm t s s a s alo d o a
r i he di al
r or r viw,how wilPl ntf be a e t i omor t wha he gl a fom hi
ec ds e e
l ai if
bl o nc
ae
t
e ns r
s
m e ca r c dsr viw wiht enon-nma ems itnti oana tc at l ga ar ume .
di l e or e e
t h
i t ssa nt
riul e e l g nt
The c ti cogni a o N D OC ' r a i w hi p e nti a e f om a c sng
our s
z nt f
S egul tons ch r ve nm t s r
c es i
t m e c l r c ds of a t r i a e,but f t r r que t Def nda s t addr s
he di a e or
no he nm t
ur he e s s
e nt o
es
whet r blnd a r nce t t s r a i woul nec s rl ha r Pl i tf '
he i dhe e
o he e egultons
d es a iy mpe a n ifs
a lt t r pond t a di postve m oton unde t es c r s anc s
biiy o es
o s ii
i
r h e icum t e .
( #52a 8: 28,9:- )
Doc.
t 2515.
I . DI
I
SCUSSI
ON
A . Sum m ar oft Parte 'Po i i on C olat alI s s
y he
i s s t ons
l er s ue
2
2
'
As u t ttd,nDo . 5 a 9 tec u t r ee t ep rist a d e st e eis e i b if
j s sae i c # 2 t ,h o r o d r d h a t o d r s h s su s n res
e
'
23
t bes
o
ubmitd on o be or Se e r21 201 The c t urhe i caed t r n t tahea i
te
r f e pt mbe , 2.
our f t r ndi t he ei ha
rng
24
woul be s he l d by t e cour t a es t e is . A hea i g wm t r fe s tf a
d
c du e
h
t o ddr s hes s ues
rn
s be ea tr e or nd
2
5
p o e d do Se tmb r25 2 2.( . 5 .
r c e e n pe e , 01 D0c # 3)
I
.
l
26
Pl ntf ie hi r pons , ppar ntywiht m ssa eofi t PhilpAs
ai iffld s es e a e l t he s it nc
nma e li hdown, ntte
e il d
27
t iff Or Datd 828/2. ( # 54. Plitf' bre rquese auhorz i f Pli if
t e or der e / 1 ' Doc. ) anifs if e td t imton or antf
Br
5
28
t vi t nd co asnec s a y ...hi m e a hea t r co dsunr c e s he m a vi w t e a a
o ew ç
a
py
e sr
s nt l lh e r
eda t d, o
y e hm s
8
1
7
..
k
.
. .. . . .
'
.
'
..
hm i ve o hstxrodn nr ic msa csa dme tl eiin y' (d. t1/ Alen tv l,
i n iw f i : ta ria cru tn e n na d tce c . 1 a . traiey
e
'
.
: 3 ' Pl ntf as t c tt or rt the ç alow e t l c ofi a e.s it nc a ong. ih nur e .
.
ai if ked. our o de ha
he
ç l d he i ht nm t a s s a e l w t
be
s.
' .
.
...
'
'
whol . .' ( . 5 a 12. Pli ifalorque td, gai t ha c msla ntdt rpr e t
e . . Doc # 4 t - ) antf s e se a n,o ve ot e ppoi e o e es n
'
,. .
:
..
.
.
4 . r or s N ior( Nur eDav s M r Be lma f ryr e v t c nc t obt i t ; e s r
ec ds upe s bv s
e) o : l y ail ec i e he ha e o an henec s a y.
5 . e ie c i s p o to hi cam. (d. t3) Ac o dn l,Plitf g j ce t t Dee d n s
vd n e n u p r f s li ' l a . c r igy an if be td o he fn a t'
'
6 s g e to ( c # àa 3-) h v n a NDOC e o e rviw h s dc l n a h at r c r s
u g si n Do . 4 t 4 of a i g n
mply e e e i me ia/ tl e lhq o d .
me
e
7 wihhi (d. 4. Pli iff rhe cone d i hi bre,c r yt hi eale r prs nttonst
t m.1 at ) antf ut r tnàe n s if ontar o s rir e e e ai o
.
.
8
t c r,ha th wmsf c dt tkeAbiiybyt saf ndprs om ci sofN. O. .... (d.
he ou tt tte
ore o a
lf he t fa ion
al
D. C. ' 1
'
:
1
0
1
1
.Pl ntf as cli dt c tt ongf ly'va aç ahe rngonijmci r ifa t d
ai if lo ame he our t
wr ul ' c td a i
n t tve ele nd t
di
u fil ds s t e T. O.ij'cier l f'(d a 6 . n ec r wila d e ste e (ro e u )
n ary imis h R. nu tv ei i. t )
n
e
ou t l d rs h s e r n o s
'
1
2
c ai sbyPl ntf o e mi y. fr t hec t il lm m a i eDef nda s r pons ot c ts
lm
ai ifm m nt l But is t our w l s l r z
e nt ' es
et he our '
'
13
or r di bl i on t e isues.
der egar ng iefng
hes s
.
;
1
4
1
5
'
Thet e nt Re pons t teco tsOr rofAugus 30,201 ( # 52) o i t
l nda s' s e o h ur' de
Def
t
2 Doc.
,
' r n he
Alenai Re s f Addii lTi f Brei g,'( .# 5 ,a ttl not t t'li ca e
tr tve, que t or tona me or itn ' Doc 6) suey ed ha Ils s
t
1
6
pr ' t t hi l uni c r um sanc ofa i na e pl i ifwho hass ii e m e a h lh i s s
es s he gh y que i c t e n m t a ntf
en
enst v
nt l ea t s ue
1
7
(
doqume edi snstverc ds andwhoi iltrt ' (d.t1 (
nt n e ii e or )
s lieae. I a ) Empha i i orgi l)Deenda s
'
ss n i na. f nt
1
8
r og zet a t cour t i ty s e t mehod by whih Pl i irc m e ni f l r pond' t
ec ni h t he
t l gh l e ks he t
r
c antf an a ng uly es
'o
1
9
Dee nt'motonf s mmayj
fnda s i or u r '
udgmen.(d.a 12.
t l t -)
2
0
The De e nt as r cog z t qua y t c ti ntfe he e n,iï. a ilt r t
f nda s lo e nied he ndm' he our de iid r i . , n lie a e
21
i a e who ne a e st hi m e ca r c dsi or t oppos D e enda s' oton f s nm ar
nm t
eds cc s o s di l e or n der o
e f
nt m i or ur
y
2
2
j
udgme ,whi i lr me lr i prdiae onPl ntf me c rcor .Dee t'i tal
nt ch n age asze s e c td
ai ifs dial e ds fndans nii
23
pr alasno e a
opos ,
t d bove wast ha a NDOC of ii r viw Pl i ifsmedialr c d wihhi
,
o ve n
fcal e e antf '
c e or s t m
2
4
(ra la t h s rc r sDee d n ss b t an ifs o l b alwe t s e.( c #48a 3 4.
0 t e s t o e e o d fn a t u miPlitf h ud e l d o e ) Do .
o
t- )
25
D e e n ss gges e Pl i ifc d t b t er cor he s e t d f l t utlza i i sopposton
f nda t u
t d a ntf oul a hos e ds el c e or a er ii ton nhi
ii
26
t Dee
o f ndan s m oton. But Def nt do not de c i how Pl ntf w il be abl t t r afe
t'
i
enda s
s rbe
ai i f l
e o he e t r
!
i
:
'
27
28
.
6Pl ntf loGldaspaaemoton? a poit n o c nslDoc#55,hedip ii o whih
ai ifas e e rt i or p nme t f ou e ( . )t s oston f c
i dicus ed her n a pp.l3-l
s s s
ei t
4.
'
9
'
l
2
'
'
'
'
'
.
'
:.
'
.
i'
hec net rr a nbrwlt '
an ihe e d
ie.
'
'
.
.
'
. ...
. .
;
.
3
. fn a t bbe t h v n a te imaea ss Plitf m h h sr q e td:( c #.6) ''
Dee d n s jd o a ig noh f n t sit an if s e m e u se Do . 5 . '
.
:
' ''
.
'.
'
'
'
i or r t r cor whihhema i ntf bu whih hedoe notha pe s lpos es i i oabre
nc po a e e ds c
y de iy t c
s
ve r ona s son nt
if
'
4
q hec ti tc nia ';NDOC' r ai whi prve imaesfohla ce sngt me c ' .
' éur s toj z ntcf
r
S egultbns' ch e nt n t r c si he dial -
5
rc dsofa h i t '' . 'Doc.# 5 a 9. Thec ti as a et tNDOC rgulton '
e or
noter nmaer..' (
r '
2 t )
our s lo war ha
e ai s
'
.
. : . '' 6
.
pr bi a i a e f om pos é i hi m edi l r or i hi c l Howev , t ' cou t a ke
ohi t n' nm t r
s ésng s
ca 'ec ds n' s el.
er be. r s d
;
E
7
De e
f ndan s t add e s whehe t i a r e t t s r gu qi woul nec s r l hampe '
t o rs
t r t nd dhe enc o he e e l tons
bl
d es a iy
r
l
!
8.
Pl ntf' a lt t r po t adipostvemotonun t s cic tnc .'(d.
ai ifs biiy o es nd o s ii
i der he e rumsa es' 1 )
9
l r pons ,D e enda s s
n es
e f
nt ugges ,a t r Gr t a s r i t c tpr l de e Pl ntY s
t f e s s e tng he our opery ni d ai i
1
0
motonf poi ment c ms l( #5 a 2)t tt lmiedao nt ntofcouns ma bet
i orap nt of ot e Doc 6 t ,ha.a i t oùi me
ç
'el y he
11
m os ef i i a a oprat w a t ens ePl i i s a lt t r s
t fc ent nd ppr i e y o ur a ntm biiy o e pond t D e en n s di pos tve
o f da t ' s ii
1
2
13
moton i t sc e. (d j( pha i adde ) De en nt a r ntv c emnlt t t hi .to ne s
i n hi as ' I . Em ss
'
d. f da s ppa e l ont
a e ha t sa tr y'
x '' *
'
'
'*
-.
r e w oul be lm ied t r ew i D ef
ol
d
i t o evi ng
endant ,m oton, e m i ng Pl ntc s m e c r c ds a
s
i
xa ni
ai i
di al e or nd
1
4
p e ln a o p sto t Dee a t'moi nf rs mmayj d me t Alh u hDee da t d n t
rpai g n p o i n o fnd ns to o u r u g n . to g fn ns o o
i
l
5
ad e s i.pr s a y t s c ns w oul a s ha t r m a n i hi or he çlm ie r pr e aton
dr s t e um bl hi ou el
d l o ve o e i n s
r vi t d e es nt i
1
6
1
7
ca ciy't et obe torrs t a j cins whihmi betl wihr r t t scour'
pa t 'o iher j c, e pond o nyobe to , c ght ied t egad o hi t'
.
s
Rfp r a dRe o n aino Dee d ns mo inf rs mmayj d me t a c nc ia y a y
e o t n c mme d to n f n a t' to o u r u g n , nd o ev bl n
1
8
ap a o t Diti J
pe l n he srct udge' uli e diposton of t moton.De e
s tmat s ii
he
i
f ndant c t no a hort
s ie
ut iy
1
9
pe mitngalmieda nt ofc elat t courhasprvi l c uded( t whi te
r ti i t ppoi ment ouns fer he t
e ousy oncl
wi. ch h
h
!
;
20
Ditit ud c ure t t anirha no s
src l ge onc rd) ha Plitf s t hoWnalkei ofs ce sheenont meis one
i lhood uc s ri he rt,
:
21
o t m ai c ie i i eval tng a i na e pl ntf r ques f a
f he
n rtra n
ua i n m t ai irs e
t or ppoi ed c ns .p ( por a
nt ou el Re t nd
22
Re omme ton( c.#37) Or r( # 51 .
c
ndai Do
,
. de Doc. ))
r
l
'
E
!
!
'
!
.
'
q
'
23
Be or t ni t a r s uton oft cola er li s ,how e r t c tnee t c r cta
f e ur ng o e ol i
he l t a s ues
ve , he our
ds o or e
24
mipe c ptonunde whih Pli if- prpe ha mor a cur el Pli ifsi ea ssa , li
s re i
r c antf
r ps e c at y, antf ' nmat s it nt Philp
25
As
hdow n- a ar t be l i an t tr a est ho t c ta r s d and r s ve Pl ntf '
ppe s o aborng, d ha el t o w he our dd es e
e ol d ai if s
26
:
27
28
'
7Th is eofa I tda oit nt c s i dic s difr a s cto B ( a pp.1 - 6.
e su
i e pp n me of oun el s s us e n a t e in 2) t 4 1
mi
1(
)
'
.
'
'
1
.
7
.
moinf rtmp rr rsri igo d rp ei n r ij n to ( c #5 .
to o e o ay e tann r e/r l ay n u cin Do . )g
mi
Pl ntf' t iff Or r' l mst coti( )wr ul vp tdt he i f ij nci
ai ifsl e or de'cai he u 1 ongf ly cae he arng orn u tve
Br
I .. . '3 . rl fvn (lu ftl ds se teI R. i u t erl fb wrnjul msz n tePli tf,
,.
ei , d z.nary imisd h t O.r nci ei y g fly st g. a n if
e a
T.
j v e
mi h
.
:
!. . : .
.
.
'
; . .4.
. '
:
k
!
..
..
'
,.:
.5
.
ê
sei t e den ofhi me a hebt rc ds.'.. ( .#.4.f6. Pli ifr sst tthe
e ng he vi ce s ntl lh e or . ' Doc 5 a . ) antf equet:ha :
'
t
'
.
6 . r e frt dimis l f h T. o. nu cieReifber v re . :h twa wi n f lyis e b .
o d r o he s sa o t e R. / j n tv l
l
e e es d . ta s o g u l s u d y
.
'
7
.
.
.
t Diti tCour. (d.
he slc
t' 1 )
'
.
.
s
9
t r f e ap op i t n e r cor s r f e tt ton Oc obe 21,2011 Pli iffld amoton s e ng
he e or pr r a e.
e d e l c ha
t r
, antf ie
i e ki
1
0
ijmci r le prcudi Dee nt fom f cngx r t t Abiiy, pr crptondr whih
nt tve eif e l ng fnda s r ori hin-p ake lf a es i i ug c
11
i i cae f e al alhte t e .Doc. 5. Oi nt nat eofPli tf ' ms e tons t c t
s ndi td orm nt he t r am nt(
# ) ve he ur
a n ifs s ri ,he our
1
2
s tan a c e a e bre i s dul a s hedul d a hea i on t m ate f N ove be 28,201
e
c el r t d i f ng che e nd c
e
rpg
he
t r or
m r
1.
1
3
'
Pl i i shi t y oft c e i m i t ken, nd a brefhi t i al e e ofPl i tf ' m oton i
a ntT
s or
he as s s a
a
i s orc r vi w
a n i fs
i s
.
'
q
.
,M T Belz d no m onsr t alkelhood o s c son t melt o hi cli wihoutt c te r' .
. . l.
di tde
tae i i
f uc es he j s f s a m t
he our.ve
.
. .
.
'
t #1 )
'
Doc. 4.
..
'
:
'
.
1
4
1
.
5
Oppostont Plitf' M otonf aTe
ii o anifs i or mporr Re tai ngOr r ... ( ' 15a 1) Pl ntf
ay sr ni
de . ' Doc.
'
# t , ai if
1
7
cai hene dt a tona tmet s ur c t ndocu t ( lc a r tyi tgaedt
l med
ede he ddii l i o ec e erai
mens wiih ppaenl nsi t he
1
8
fln o Plitf' mo inf re ryd so ey( c # 1 )o t esmed t) I ra ty h v r
i g f anifs to o al ic v r Do . 6 n h a ae . mpo tnl, owe e ,
i
1
9
Pl i ifdi n s a e hene d t doc e st s
a ntf d ot t t
ede he um nt o how hew a bei I or ed't t keA biiy.I t d,
s ng t c ' o a
f
lf nsea
20
Pl i ifcli e he wa e t l t docum e s t woul s
antf am d
ntd o ocae
nt hat
d how lf r u i t sg a medial
tor ef sng o i,
n
c
21
wave or t t dr g Abiiyy he wa dici i d by bei c i d on t e occ sons i a
i r ake he u
lf '
'
s s plne
ng onfne
hr e a i
n
22
s grgae me t heat uri.'(d.a 2. l ohe wor ,i t smotonhewa s mi ynol r
e e td nal lh tt' I t ) n t r ds n hi i
s ee ngl onge
23
c am i
l i nghewasbei e r dt t ketlsm edia i r he , co e dhi housngwa ale edl
ngr quie o a li
c ton; at r he nt nde s
i
s lg y
24
E
rque t t c r gant m thea tona tmeoff t fve( da t r pondt teDee nt'
e sed he ou t r hi t ddii li
t
ory-i 45) ys o es
o h fnda s
1
6
.
Des t hav ng t ' pporuniyt ha a e died he r ng, onNove be 22, 1 Pl ntf
pie i he o
t t o ve n xpe t
ai
m r 201 , ai if
ale ed msa r ul ofhi r us l
tr
es t
s ef a .
2
5
l t er e p n et PlitT s to f r e o ayr srii gode/r lmi r ij n to ,
n h ir s o s o an i mo in o atmp r r e tan n r rp ei nay nu cin
26
'
27
s Bas on t handwrtng on Pl ntf e ler s isi i doès not a
ed
he
ii
ai ips ar i ubm s ons, t
ppear i e as sant
nmat sit
28 M r As wn wa wor n wih Pl n i u i r e ty a d,t r f r ,h ma n t be f m ii r wih p i r
. hdo
s ki g t ai tf ntl ec n l n he e o e e y o
a la t ro
pr
oceedi .
ngs
'
.
.
J'
j
!
:
.
'
!
.
:
!
!
k
j
'
I
1
2
Dee ntr e e tdia intFwu n bei ore ot eM yr tps hotcme c tons (
fnda s eprs ne tpl i
ot ngf c dt A
i yc i diai ,Doc.
'
#9. DepiePli i sar z nti hi b ift nome c r c dsWeea ia et tec t n
) s t antY gt
me n s re hat
dial e or r valbl o h ourwhe
i b ' ' 3 tec u t rl n rl c nsd rdPlit smoihfrij n t' rle Dee d ns o poiint
h o rpei ai o iee ani ' to o nu cie eif fn a t' p sto o
mi y
T
v
j ,'. . ' .4 .. anifsmo infrtmp r r rér iico d riïld d s me9lp g so me ia rc r s M t ,
.
.Plitf' to o e o a y e tann'' r e rcu e o
a e f dc l e o d , es .
E
:
''
'
.
I
i
..
.
I
I
j
i
l
i
j
.
'
'
..
. , .
.
.
5 . pr-y t rc ds-a noa yje1ms' ofla lt t -Ref s lotM e ca Trament f f lng
. es sem e or nd, tbl ' e és '-ibiiy br- u a - di l e t - br aii
(
'6 t tke Abiiy a ,r ommende t oc # 9 .t3- ,Exhi t ( -l. As a r s t of.he e
o a
lf s.ec
d; '
D
'
a. 4.
bis A)())
e ul . s
t
7 rprs nt ins a pr i nay r iw oft e r or Deen rt s mitd, and i 'i of
e e e ato nd elmi r eve
hos ec ds f dafs ub te
n lght
.
.
.
8
Pli tc sr que t or e e i noftme,hec ur dee ne t thei tal ge
a n i e s f an xt nso
i t o t tnni d ha t nii ur ncyms ocatdwih
s ie t
I
9
Plitf' rque tf ij tver ifnolnge exitd.( eDoc. 1 )
anifs e s or n unci ele o r' se Se
# 7.
!
I
1
0
i
I
1
1
t Plit/ smoinf r nt tv rle ( c. )Bec uj ofPli ifsmoton, t ra ons
o ani
t o ijmcie eif Do #17. a e antf' i and he e s
o
1
j
1
2
.
ou lne above t c tva a e t e
ti d
, he our c t d he xpedie N ovem be 28,2011 he i but s m ula ousy
td
r
arng
i t ne l
i
1
3
rs he e t he i onPl ntf' motonf ij tv rie a motonf e l dic r f
e c duld he arng
ai ifs i or n uncie eif nd i or ary s ovey or
ë
i
1
4
Dec mbe 1 2011 ( c. 21)Asrvi da , ai ifc e ldhi benga et unde tke
e r 9, . Do # .
e ewe bove Pl ntf ontnie s i bl o
ra
:
1
5
l a l di c r ' m ne es a y f hi t e t bls t bas sf hi m oton f e por z r t a ni
t r y s ove y'w s c s r or m o s a i h he i or s i ort m ay es r i ng
e
!
'
1
6
or r ( # 1 ) n ec tde me i a opraet a es Pl ntf' t motonsa tes
de . Doc. 6..
our e d t ppr it o ddr s ai ifs wo i t h ame
!
1
7
tm e.
i
l
!
I
i
'
!
.
.
.
'
Thec tgr ntd.li ifsmoton f re a ge e oftm et r pl t Def nda s r s ns
our a e p antf '
i o nl r m nt i o e y o e nt . e po e
'
.
1
8
Att De e r1 2011heai Pli ifi onne t c thewa nottki Abiiyan
he c mbe 9,
rng, antf nf d he our
s a ng lf d
1
9
had nott n i snc Ocobe 25,2011.( e M i esa Doc.# 23. Si lry,dee ecouns l
ake t i e t r
Se nut t
) mial fns
e
!
i
l
'
!
.
j
:
20 ' r tr tdt tPl ntf wa notbei f c t tkeAbiiyb NDOC.1 )Outofa a
eie ae ha ai if s
ng ored o a
lf y
(d.
n bunda of
nce
!
21
ca i de e e c
uton, f ns ouns l a e t pl ce a no i i Pl i i s m edi alf l t ti i a s be m e
e gr ed o a
tce n a ntV
c ie ha f t l o ca
!
22
nec s a y f Pl i ift be te t i vol a iy,t de y a t ne g r las i d t t sc e
e s r or antf o
r aed n untrl he put tor y ene a sgne o hi ms
2
!
23
24
s d beno ii i a nc s t t coul i t r notf t c t nd t c tc d hol a sat
houl
tfed n dva e o ha he
d n u n iy he our a he our oul
d t us
con er nc .
f e e
' '
!
25
t tt ba i f Pl ntf' moton f e ry dicoveywasmoota d edt moton.( i e
ha he ss or ai ifs i or al s r
nd eni he i M nut
!
26
!
i
!
(e Do s #2 , 2 #2 1) Asar s lo t i tl g tec u thee p nd tr n d
S e c . 3 # 4, 4- .
9
e ut f h s ii ,h o r t ru o ee mie
h
.
i
.
i
27
!
!
i
1
j
zg Plitf de lne orr f s dt t k t d ug( g ns hi do t s r c
an if c i d e u e o a e he r a ai t s cor' e omme ai s , f n n sa que c di
nd ton )De e da t c is e n
hi r f s b tr q rd Plitf osg ar la en ig h r f s d t mediai ( s # 9 #23 # 2 )
s e u al u e uie an ift in ee s otn e e u e he
c ton. Doc .
4.
.
1
2
'
;
!
!
I
:
'
)
'
Ag n De e da t ' stoni Pl ntf ha n e b e f c dt t k Abiiya i thi wil W h n
ai, f n n s po ii s ai if s ev r e n ore o a e lf gans s l. e
.
.
'
i
j
'
1
l
i
1
Or r 1 27 1 Doc. 29 a 1.1 To dae t c thasnotbee noiidby Defnda sofa
de , 2/ /2,
# t )9
t, he our
n tfe
e nt
ny
2
.
a t ptt f r i y m edi a e Pl ntf .
tçm o o c bl
c t ai if
'
.
!
!
(
.
j
!
'
'
. .
.
3
. ... .'4
'
:
. 'n
.
F
;
'
'
.
.
..
,
'
....' çeo e tec u t dn tt o g ul n u lwf l a act eh a i o ij n tv eif
:. .n rf r,h o rdi o t p f l d n > u l c t h e r rn u ci er l
'
t
wr
ya
yv
ngf
e
.as P1 i ifmset..Do ' 5 a 6.
., ant . s r
f
s ( c.# 4 t )
..
.
'
.
i
;
.
i t d,t c ta c
nsea he our c pmmo td Pl ntft r s f an
dae ai ifs eque t or
.
5
e e i .ftm e. r pl t Dee d n s rs o s t hsmpi nf ij ncieil f c nd ce a .
xt' oh. i t e y o fn a t! e p n e o i to or n u tv ' i , o u td
ps p
o
ee
.
.
6
pr m pthe ng on Pl i if sm otonsa e er d s e al de sw ih r s c t Pl i i f sr ue t
o
mi
a ntf '
i
nd nt e ev r or r t e pe t o é ntf ' eq s ed
7
'
r i.
elef
''
.
.
x
.
.
8
i
i
W ih t e pr lmi r m a tr s m ma ied a de c i
t hos e i na y te s u
rz nd s rbed,t cour wilnow t r t a
he
t l
un o n
9
(
E
a l s soft c l t a i s spr en e t t c ts nd r t D e e
na y i
he ola er l s ue es t d o he our eco a y o f ndan s m o i f s l m a y
t
tdn or im r
.
)
i .
l
0
j
udgme .
nt
E
11
B . A nal i o Colat r l s
ys s f l e al s ues
é
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
l
1
2
1 W be he t CourtShoul Gr a G e alAppoi m e ofCouns
.
t r he
d ant
ner
nt nt
el
I
:
;
1
3
j
1
4
i
2
15
# 54 at 5.)1How e r ot rt r f ni g t t xt a di r cic s a es' whi h Pl i tf t t
4- 1
ve , he h= e e n o t r or na y r um t nc ,' c a n i fs a ed
e
1
6
ai e &om hi ilt ac a i biiy t G om pr he t com pl tesofl w orm e c pr dur s'
ls s
s lier y nd na lt o t
c
e nd he
exii
a
di al oce e '
i
1
7
(ni imiywhc afe t al te r s ton1
a nfr t ih r cs mos ve y eci 983/r s l eltgan)hedoe not xpli how
0 e nmat ii t,
s e an
I
.8
1
t sc e i undul c
hi as s
y ompl orwhy he i lk y t pr valhe en. Thes t component a e t
ex
s i el o e i r i
e wo
s r he
i
r
( S #54, 55
Doc .
# )
Pl nt/ s Ble f Or r agani l da he r uetf a nt nt c e.( c.
ai i
i f or de
i ncude not r eq s or ppoi me of ouns l Do
!
;
.
!
!
.
!
.
1
9
rt i a c t us n es a iy r ol w he de di w he he t a ntc ns l
iera our m t ec s rl es ve
n ci ng
t r o ppoi ou e .
c
.
'
.
2
0
P an ifas fld asp rt moin fra pon me to c t e .( c. 5 ) Hi moin
litf lo ie e a ae to o p it n f oms l Do # 5. s to
i
21
a s rsalt nyofs tomi t ta f c am os e y i t ss c i 1 l ui,ie,Pl ntf
s e t ia
horc ngs ha fe t l t ver nma e' e ton 983 aws t .. ai if
:
i
7
22
c nnota l d c ms l Pl ntY si prs
a
fbr ot e, ai i m iomne lmishi a lt t ltga e Pli tf i of lmied
nt i t s biiy o ii t , a n if s i t
23
e a i tof m e c l l w ,'Pl i ir i de ed lbr nra es ,t t a ki wi1 i ve conf i i
duc ton t
di a a ' a ntf s ni i a cc s ha
al 1 nvol
lctng
24
t tmony,ec.Pl ntf' moton a s f ist a es t a i a ec ie i gover ng a n me
esi
t ai ifs i lo a l o ddr s he pplc bl rt ra
ni ppoi t nt
j
'
!
i
:
!
'
!
25
.
(6
2
.
!
I
:
;
i
j Asprvi l sae , s he uln o de wa e e e he enonDe e e 23 2 11( c #27)whih
,
e ousy ttd a c d ig r r s ntrd r i
c mb r , 0 Do . , c
s ender t moton f ea y dicover moot
ed he i or rl s
y
.
27 alo r
1 0 n Aug t 0, 01 t ec r de e Pl i tf ' e r i r qu s f a ok mentofcouns whi was
l
el ch
:E
!l
us 3 2 2, h ou t ni d a n ifs a ler e e t . pp nt
or
ac
ompo n ofhi rqu s ( c. 46)t ,s s e d,p oc e ng .( c # 5 )
ne t s e e t Do # o &u p n , r e di s Do . 2.
I
!
:
'
.
.
, '
.
'
!
!
i
.:
.
.
13
.
I
.
!
i
.
1
ofc e.z
ouns ll
2
.
A ltga i a c vi rght a ton do n .a aSi . Am e
ii nt n i l i s c i
es ot ve xt
h
h
ndm e rght o a
nt i t ppoi e c
nt d ouns .
el
1
h '.. ' . 3' So s t v.pel n 6 4F.d1 49 1 3(t ' 1 1.l v r l tdcruh tn e,fd rl' '
S ..' '
'
trel . lma , 5 2 3 , 35 9. C:. 98 ) n ey i e ic rsa c s e ea
i s
h
mi
'
.
..
I' . . . ' .
.
4
j
i
l
:
'
.
'
'
5
.
..
'
'
c rsaeémpowee t rquè t ét ne i rpr.e ani ge ci lii t R' cic sanc , :
ou t r
rd o e s anttor y o e es nt àdi nt viltgxn. he rum t es .
.
.
i whih. c twil a s h ar que t hbwy r'r e ee ngl r r ,a t c t l m aket
n c a our l gr nt ué e s ,
'
ve y e xc di y a e nd he our wil
a
he ':
'
.
I
1
l
I
1
i
i
l
i
' .
6 'rques unde onl e ror n ycr msa é .Unie atsv. . r sc and, F. 7 ' :
e t r y xta diar icu tnc s ' tdst e 3064Ac e /f 795 2d 96,
7 7 800( h ci 1 .wibor v Es de on,789F. 1 1 ( hci.1 .
99- 9t r 986) l n . cal r
,
2d 328, 331 9t r 986)
.
.
8
A sndi ors h e pto ore r or nm. c r um s a esr quiest t cou teva ua e
ng uc xce i nal xt a di y i c t nc e r hat he r
l t
9
bot t lkelhood ofPl ntf ' s cc s on t m e isand t Dr s lt g tsabiiy t a tcul e hi
h he i i
' ai if s u e s he r t
he o e ii an ' lt o r i at s
1
0
cli si lght t c
am n i of he ompl xiyoft l lis i vedaNet rf t .sc r lng;bot mus
e t he ega s ues nvel . ihe acori ontoli
h t
11
beviwe t t ri m a ng t tndi . Te r / v Sr wcr 935F. 1 5,l 7( h Ci,1 )
e d ogehe n ki he i ng r c/ . c ,
2d 01 01 9t r 991 ,
1
2
cii W ibor ,s pr 78 F. a 1 . H oweve ,t di ti tcou te c s s di c eton i m a ng
tng l n u a, 9 2d t 331
r he s r c
r xer i e s r i n ki
l
3
t s fndi ' .
hi i ng
i
I
I
1
-
.
:
I
I
1
4
The t ryi ca e pr s nt d by Pli if alhough ha ng ce t n uni a pec s i not
mde l ng s e e e
antf, t
vi
rai que s t , s
I
i
1
5
n c sa i o l ae pli tœ scom pl ntalegesua thewaso r edt t am ediaton agaist
e e srl mpi td a n i
yc
c
ai i
a
c o ake
c i
r
i
i
1
6
dial e s t r
hi w il Th ,t Pi ntf ' c a m of delbe a e i fe enc t a s rousme c ne d i neihe
s l. us he ai if s l i
i r t ndif r e o e i
1
7
com pl norc plc t d. Si ia l asdi cu s d a
ex
om i a e
m l r y,
s s e bove, ai i fha f l d t c
Pl ntf s aie o onvi et cour of
nc he
t
1
8
t lkei
he i lhood ofs e son t e me isofhi cli sort c
ucc s
h
rt
s am
he omplxiy oft l ga is si ve
e t
he e l s ue nvol d.
I
.
i
E
:
;
'
l
.
i
!
1
9
i
:
2
0
!
!
21
;
'
!
i
!
2
2
2
3
'
The e or , Pl ntf' rque tnhi t i f Or r'ora nt tof ms l Doc. 54)
r f e ai ifs e s i s : ef or de'f ppoi men cot e (
Br
#
a dhsM o inf rAp oit n o Co s l Do . 5 )aeDEM ED.
n i to o p nme t f un e ( c # 5 r
2.
W het t Cour Shoul Gr açti td'Appont ntofCouns ( #56)
her he
t
d ant çzmie '
i me
elDoc.
,
Dee a t, l o g ha igp e iusyo p e Plitf' r q e t o g n rba pon me
fnd ns at u h vn r vo l p osd an ifs e u s f r e e a p it nt
h
o c u s l Do . 8a 2 3 , r p et ec u t rn aii td: p oit n o c u s l
f o n e t c #4 t - ) p o os h o r g a t ûmi 'a p nme t f o n e:
l e
:
l
I
i
!
I
!
;
E
.
!
!
!
1
:
1
1
24
25
1 pl i tr ' motona a st b atf m'r qu s f c ns lo t whi h Pl i tf i t a ssan
2 a n if s i ppe r o e vor ' e e t or ou e n o c a n irs nma e s it t
h lns ren(ne fee ofdn a iit t aet cc stoto m)Pl'(i sna5aa1 ae tdeotereir liames'
as di
i u ega a lgain h edwrtnp h nra te st fec ti Doc #5 tndcdt nni o lb alsc ens
nc i ntd i difo nt a nil gr ha on hehr oura' & . me ) nrai al fmbe y hc stl
l tr
ofl op
snt
l h
r
z
n t e ofwhihis e aet s b e t Pli ifsc aita t sbe ndt epur iw oft sa ton.c
eih r
c s u s r he u j c of antf ompl n nd hu yo h ve
hi c i f,
De o ev He rn o 42F.d 4 471( t Ci.l ) a c dLite 3 Jo s 6 F. l ,I 0- 1( 0 h
v s . r igt n, 3 70, 8 h r 994 . c or tl z ne , 07 3d 241 25 5 1 t
,
.
27
Ci.2 1 ,Covn v Car s 60 F. 28 29 30 ( h Ci.201 ) Ome Wo l F t c v T an Word
r 0 0) li . u o, 5 2d 2, 9- 0 6t r 0 , ga rd rz / . r s l
.
.
v
28 Ailne,1 IF3 1 1 ( hCi.l 7)( pli i e kigij cier ifmus sow arlto hi bewe n
ri s 1 d 4, 6 4t r 99 a antfse n nun tv el
e th
eains p t e
t s betofamoi frij ncierle a tec ndu tas re i t c ait)
he uj c
ton o nu tv eif nd h o c setd n he ompl n.
26
.
.
1
4
.
.
:
i
.
'
!
I
1
.
.
.
.
. .
i
I.
2
.
.
Def nt s bmi t talm ieda nt e ofc
enda s u t ha i t ppoi m nt ouns l a bet mos e tc e ta
e m y he
t fi i n nd
a prae. t e ur Pl ntf ' a lt t r s nd t De e
ppm it way o ns e ai ifs biiy o e po o f ndant dipgsii
s' s tve
.
.
.
.
mo in i i sc s . S c n' d n a tid e s ul n tb a c mp e e sv
to n hi a e u h e ot nc n e d ho d o e o r h n ie
e
'
nt
o epr r
ai if q hi a ton.
s as s lea
ogr s e t
3 . .. '
appoi mqnlt r e ntPl ntf i t s.c i .Thi c e hm ar dy pr y s ds.
.
.
.
t ought c tss he i or ra t r i ape ngdipostvemo i bef r '
hr
he our' c dulng' de nd he e s ndi
s ii
ton o e
2 , .:
.
.. .: . .'.tec u t. h a p it n xu g se b Dee d nswo d'elmie t a sqigr . . ..)
4
. h o rkl e p onme tsg etd f fn a t ul b i td o sitn .
.
..
. , :
Pl i ifby r vi w l hl m e c a m ent he t r c ds oh hi b hal a t
a ntf
e e ng s di al nd
al alh e or
s e f nd hep
.
.
s nt ii / a tng s astöt a l Pli ift pr pa e a men ngf .: . . 1
y heszng dr fi o t . low a ntf o e r
t
ni ul7 .
'
; as itng L .
ssi i
n
..
,
5
'
agume i o ii . .'( #52at8 .Thi lm ie a nment dr i
r ntn pposton . . Doc.
) s i td ppoit ' woul eman
ort s
he
t
lne
6 , - .i compla eUi NDOC rgultonsa accountf heisuest cour hasouti d
n
inc +
e ai nd
t ./ wihou f cn t coutt r e o t nove is esa e s d b t
'
Doc /
52) t t orig he r o ul n hè' l s u ddrs e y he
1
.
7
i
8
.
.
.' ..
.
underl ng cicum s ances,
yi
r
t
( c #56a 2:4 2 )
Do .
t 1 - 4.
.
.
9
The pr e ns wih D e e nt s
obl f
t
f nda s' ugge ton a e m ul i e. Fis , he c r hmsale y m a a
si r
tpl
r t t ou t
r ad
de
.
1
0
d emi ton,i ac or nceWi. Deen nt'poston (
etr nai n c da
t f da s ii Doc.#48 a 2-).ha Plitf ha not
h
t 3 ,t t anif s
,
)1
s tsi t c r lngc ie i f a nt ntofc e (e dic son a
aifed he ontoli rtra or ppoi me
ouns l J c s us i bovea t sc r'
nd hi ou ts
Or rofAugus 30, 201 ( c, 5 at 7) l Pl nt fha not emonsrtdalkei
de
t
2 Do # 2 6- . f ai i s d
f
tae i lhoodofs c s
uc es,
!
1
2
1
3
l
4
De ç nt cienoaut iyf t pr ii t te n almie a n men ofcot el s
f nda s t
holt or he oposton ha ve i t d ppoi t t
ms i
1
5
1
6
a o it, riulrywheet c t sf agans Pl ntf t Ter lacor n ec ts
pprprae pa tc a l
r he our ha ound i t ai ifon he relf t s.
our'
r e r h,howe r hmsl atd onec e whe e ac r hm pr vi l de ed àgene a a n me
es a c
ve z
oc e
as
r ou t s e ousy ni
'
r l ppoi t nt
i
I
'
.
whehe t c tc npr e t a nte e ( t rt nea'orts ci ' a ali pr e i
t r he our a oc ed o ppoi ounsl eihe l rl' lpe al) t l s oblmatc.
ge
'
.
'
;
1
7
o c un e bu no eh ls a p o e al tda ponme tp c t e.Je ro v Pe e , 01 W L
f o sl t n tee s p r v d i e p it n f omsl yes n . r z 2 1
mi
:
1
8
1
9
4 6 7 6( D. . 01 )
7 0 9 E. Ca 2 1.
.
n ec u tnJe r o a p itdc t e fo at r b n p o't m ss t epanif o te
o r i fè s n p on e oms l r m l o o o o l o sit h litf f r h
p
'
!
.0
2
lmi dp mos o (caiy ig hi itn wi r s e tot er q psf r d si s. . whc t e
i t u e f tlrf gn j s n e t t e p c t h e ue t o a mison .' ih h
e
h
4
21
pl ntf da te (d. t2. Thecou tf ndpl ntf houl frtrc vet dofc e'wih
ai ifha dmitd. I a )
r ou ai ifs d is e ei t
ai ouns l' t
2
2
r s e top an ifstd e d' d sin . (d) n u ,t pp ast eso eo c n e' a tcp td
e p c t litf' t e me a miso s' I . s ia e r h c p f ou sls n iiae
t
'
2
3
a ssa c i Jfes nwa mu hn ro rta i woudb h r i a da ys c a p nme t ud
sitn e n e ro s c ar we h n t l e een n n u h p oit n wo l
2
4
2
5
id e b v r lmi d (d a 2 3.
n e d e ey i t . I . t - )
e
S c n , niet e c r / c ur' a albes t c o p ob n c t e,h r iu f ru aey
e o d u l h Jfe x n o ts v ia l ol e f r o o oms lt ee s n o tn tl
k
r
26
no po ofa t ne i t Diti tofNeva t whom t scour c n t n t a n couns li i
ol tor ys n he s rc
da o
hi
t a ur o ppoi t
e n .
27
pr s i ae s cton 1
o e nm t e i 983 l u t The c t doe not have t power tt m ak coe c v
aws i.
our
s
he
to
e
rie
28
a nme sofc el' Malar v.&.S.DilCou t,490U. 296,31 ( 989 .Thus t cou t
ppoit nt ouns .
' ld
s. r.
S.
0 1 )
,he r
.
15
.
:
1
:' '
s.
.
2
'
c na
a ppoi tcouns lo y unde e pt ona cic s a
n
e nl
r xce i l r um t nces Pal erv Val z 560 F. d965, ( h
. m
. de ,
3
970 9t
Ci.2009 c r.de e 1 0 S. .1 2 ( 0) l t tèionca e t c twa a et s ec a
r
) e / nid 3 Ct 28 201 ) n belq/t
s s , he our' s bl o el t n
hçr s or u el
he sic N
.to ne .q om ' 'cou tspr bo a t f yp re , I t Dititof evada,t e i unf t nat y
a tr yGr t
f
he r, o no tè ne àjl, n.
.
.
l ... '
: :' . .
' ).'.
. .
3
j ....
:6.
,..
1 IL'' '
. %.:.
- .
.
.
. . ..
;< . .. . .
.
. .
.
,
;
. .
. ' oç r b noa tr yp n l fo whiht l c 'r c ude fc e e aIpi da p i t n o c u s l.'
4 n ' o o tone a e' r m è hs o t o l 'e t v n i t p o nme t f o n e. '
p
'
u
f
l e
'
.
1 . t. .
. .
l
. . . ..
. .
. ..',
. !' .
''
'
.
.
'
5
j
'. .'.
.
.
.
.L .
,
t
,
':
.
.
.
.' ' ;
:
pr s pz bl woul b plc d i t posion ofha ng' c lva i atp ne km ki t a t ne t
eu â y
d.e a e n he ii
vi t al' rous tr ys's ng he tor y'o
o
!
7
as um e r pr s nt ton i a c s w he e t c thm a r a det m i t pl i ifi notlke y t
s
e e e ai n a e
r he our s l e dy er ned he a ntf s
i l o
:
8
pr va l n eato n y,i f ines ,s d f t rbe a s d. t a nt e ,f whi t è
e i.
tr e n ar s houi urhe
dvie t he ppoi m nt or ch he e
hat
9
woul b no c pe a i n,w oul ne es t t r vi w ofhundr ofpage of m e c a m en a
d e
om ns to
d c sia e e e
eds
s
di al nd
tl
1
0
h lh r c ds. n er pr e ato woul r quiec ulatonw iha i a c r t i aea . NCC.
ea t e or
e es nt i n
d e r ons t i
t n nc r e a ed nm t t
N
:
l
1
Th a tr e so l ainswo l as lk l i cu efln o j cin , rrs n e t o j cins t
e to n y' bi to
g
ud lo iey n ld i g be to s o epo s s o b e to ,o
i
.
1 ' t r por andr omm e tont c twile nt aly e e .conceva y, ouns lm i e be
2
he e t
ec
nda i he our l ve u l ptr
i bl c
e ght ven
,
'
'
!
I
l
.
i
.
j
l
3
o i a e t pr ec ean a a t t Ni h Cic t And a t e oft da t a t ne - i he
blg t d o os ut
ppe l o he nt r ui.
t he nd he y, he tor y f
l
'
1
4
or s l e t ca e - w o d pos i y be a def nda i a m al a t c ac i Thi i pus ng t
he os s be s
ul
s bl
e nt n
pr c i e ton.
s s hi he
1
5
e l on a ki a a t ne t unde t pr bono s r i e .
nveope
s ng n tor y o
rake o
e vc s
!
.
l
6
t a a be or t s c r, patculry i t matr i vi t at ne pr entd a t l e
o ppe r f e hi ou t ri a l f he te nvol dj hat tor y es e
t os
c
21
.
ç d as c eva yb plce i a a
oul lo onc i bl e a d n n wkwa dpostoni andwhe hea nt a t ne lt rwe e
r
ii f
nt ppoi ed tor y a e r
20
r
I
unde tket sti t a poi m e 'hec t y fnd is fIi
ra hi t mied p nt nt't our ma i tel lndebt t t ta t ne ''ec t
l
ed o ha tor y, f our
h
1
9
i
wiingt ac e s h a nt e s i t cour éontc e a a t e die tyt r que tt a t ne
li o c pt uc ppoi m nt ,f he
t a t d n tom y r c l o e s he tor y
l
8
1
l m uc a t e cou t sno poolofvol e rator ysi N eva who ar a ia e f a
nas h s h
r hm
unt e t ne n
da
e va l bl or nd
1
7
!
'
qu ton.'
esi '
,
,
.
'
.
2
2
Ac r ngl i doe nota art a lm ie a nt nt of c
co di y, t s
ppe hat i t d ppoi me
ouns l pr s s a vi e
e e ent
abl
23
at r tve. n eeo e Dee d nss g e to o aLi tdAp i t n ofCo n e ( c # 5 )i
le na i
rf r , f n a t u g sin f mie ponme t
u s l Do . 6 s
24
DENI
ED.
'
i
'
25
3. T he A ut i d E xt ntofP l ntf R e e o hi M edi aland M e a H ea t
hor ze
e
ai i cs vi w f s
c
nt l
Ih
'
.
.
' ' .l io dn l,e e i atirtd'a p nme twa a t rz d b lw,t d s . e c r
Ac r igy v n f trie ''p oit n. s uhoie y a o o o t ou t
c
l i
s
6
''
.
'
'.
.
26
Re ds( #54)
cor Doc.
'
'
;
2
7
Tob a et stsa t i o p eDee d ns moi nf rs r mayj dg n , an ifh s
e bl o aifcorl p os fn a t' to o u n r u me t Plitf a
y
ê
28
r quese a c st g1ofli me c andm e a he t r or wih nor ti tonson wha r c ds
e t d c es o J ls di al
nt l alh ec ds t
eslc i
t e or
1
6
'
'
i
I
.
1
I
j
'
!
1
l
I
.
.
E ; .. .
j
;.
j
i
.
.
.
l. : .
.
- m e alhea t or ot r s - w hi h he m a r e . Pl i ir s a es he n ds t s m e a hea t
nt
lh
he wi e
c
y evi w
a ntf t t
ee t
hi nt l lh
2
;
tie ir
ol nd e t d ore d ntaypumos s *..M rBel t a f de
e.
. lmus be foy d.
r c dsvi w a e a a w h e a unr dac e f
e or
e bl s
.
.
e l t t o ea r
ec
a ed a s w
s e ds ooc: .
g . r i apd unuas d (ppoluniyt gl q tueand çorr tand unbi s f c/ f m hi r cor '(
j a ar
,
.
.a
' xy
'
4
'
.
'
'
.. .
,
#54a . 4)(mphmsy. t oi nal) . ... ,.. . . . . ...- . .' :. ',- :..
t3- e
i i he lgi ..
.
n
. .
.
'.
'
. .. ., ' .
; '' .
,
;
..' oe e i nt h ot f s
frda s. i or umma' 'udcmen, tn.,ttst tpkru tt lheDe aaina ..
m on '
''i '' ta 1 sae ha ' ts an og'
nz '
t
t clrto pd.
'
' '
'
. .
ê
i . , ., . s
:
.
. ..
'
'
'
'
'
'
.
,
j ,.
!
.?
I
6
R e r ofDr J Har i ,
no t
. ohn rs onqofPl i i scu r tte i g m e ' l alh pr es i s ps c ogi t .
a nt T
r en r atn
nt he t of s opal/ y hol j s
a
I
.
7
atheRM F
t
8
,
j
aai
t c t tt or rt tt er c dsbem a a ia et Pl ntf.. + +, a euarrso eoj r ton
he our no o de ha hes e or
de va lbl o ai if
9
a pe r i t cour doc t s a ed,a D o 40- . W ihou di cl i t cont ntoft de a a i
p a s n he
t ke , e l s c. 1
t t s os ng he
e
he cl r ton,
1
0
Dr H a s gen a opi on i t t' aki t s r c ds a l bl w oul ha t s i lm m a or
. ni ' er l ni s ha '
m ng he e e or vaia e
d ve he e nfa
t y
11
n tvee f t'onPlitf.( .#40- a 5. .
egai fecs' anif Doc
1t )
. . .
gi s sc r i e,rel ed t pl ntm si vi
ves peci atonal
at o ai i ndi dualand cur entcondii ur ng
r
ton, gi
I
:
.
i
!
i
'
i
i
;
'
!
.
.
.
.
.
1
2
Thec t ppr c a e a r s t . a r s i a eva ua i W e e t r or g r a
our a e i t s nd e pec sDr H r i ' nput nd l ton. r he ec ds e m ne
E
1
3
t a hi o he t an a pot ntaly dipostve m oton,t cou tw oul be i i d t f l hi
o nyt ng t r h
e i l s ii
i he r
d
nclne o olow s
'
1
4
r c m e ton.l t i t nt a t r ho e r Pl i ifr cogni est r cor m a cont n a
e om nda i n he ns a m te , w ve , a ntf e
z he e ds ya ai dver e
s
!
1
5
i bnna i bu i w ilng t r c ve r t whi h a e nega i a
nt
ton t s li o e ei epors c r
tve bouthi . H e s a e :
m
tt s
i
1
6
l
i
I
i
1
7
1
1 ( c#5 a2 (mp ai. te rgn l Pani as asrs e udn t eteaieyi atd
9 Do. 4 t)e hssnh oiia. litf l seth wo l o b t gt l mpce
i
)
f o
n v
'
2
0
i
1
8
'
Pl i if wiinot b nega i l a f t d by s e ' opi on of hi ,m e ca l or
a ntf l
e
tve y f ec e
om one s ni
m
di ly
Ot wie.Nf. l knowshi ps c ogial ndii ve ywe l orhehmsde t t
her s r Be l
s y hol c co tons r l f
alwih
t m ex e i y a no i or a i w rte i hi m e a hea t r c dsw il f c or
he
t nsvel nd nf m t,&
on it n n s nt l lh e or
l af e t
<
c ge t s f c or ort ut .,..
han he e a t s r hs
b b iga et ve hi me ia/ ntl e l r c r s' (d. t3)
y en bl o iw s d c lme a h at e o d . 1 a .
h
'
!
:
'
x
.
21
Addii ly, tt Se e be
tona l a he ptm rzss 2he rng, antf w% c v% s
201 a i Pli i
r
edab poj i yGndi
out sbl
ng
22
23
der a or o ni a
og t y pi ons bouthi o
m rpes i i tcpr os so
s m s i ogn e rcha ac e i a i ofam e aly unba a ed
r t r z tons
nt l
l nc
.
pe s . Hea ee t a e t t ika w> ame et e cut ac e o wav ot t fc.
r on
gr d o cc ptha rs nd s nabl o xe i ons nt r iert ha efe t
ng
i
1
'
2
4
( C #5 .
D0 . 7)
25
.
f e
The e or , b c u eo t enau eo Pli ifsalg to si hsc mp an , a bec us o t
r f e e a s f h tr f ant ' l ain n i o lit nd a e f he
!
2
6
so eo Dee a t' t nfrl rj d n t ihi ld s u ru me tl e l eods,
c p f fnd ns moi o sl y u gmetwhc ncu e n meo s na h at c r )
o
mma
hr
27
t c twila l Pl ntf a ce s t e tit d,t a1 ofhi me ca a m e a he t r co ds
he our l low ai if c s , mr src e o 1
s di l nd ntl alh e r .
28
H ow e r Pl ntf w oul f r thave t e ut a w a ve ,c en o ot eragr e enta e a e t
ve , ai i f
d is
o xec e
i r ons t r h
em
cc pt bl o
E
!
I
E
i
j
'
17
!
l
i
I
I
.
.
I
;
1
l '
1' ' .. t 2
L
. .
I't' '
'
!, .
i
i
-
.
r
.
.
'
'
'
') 3 . ofDèf nd s a N D OC. : ' '
'e ant nd
..
.
'
.
;..4'
'.
'
.
'' :' :5
:'
:. ' '
'.
'
:.
. . . '' ' '
. .
' ' . ' .. ' ,
.' ' . ' '
'
E
.
'
.
I
Dee nt t NDOC)whe e Pl ntf woul a s a1rs atnda t hi beng pr de
fnda s and
r by ai if d sume l iks te nt o s i ovi d
c mplt a c s t h src r .Th f r a c ne t fs c . d c me two l b i t edicein
o ee c e s o i e ods e o m nd o ïn ' u ha b ù n ud e n h srto
o
.
.
!
'7
.. .
.
'
. .' Pli irsr s frc mplt ac s t hi r c dst c:#5 i GRANTED. .'. .
antf equet o o ee ce s è s e or 'Do .4) s
.'
4 T he Identt of t 'l erson A it zed. o A j st Pl ntif i H i M edi R ecords
iy' he.i
l hori t
ji
ai ' f n ' s
cal
'
I
6
.
:
.
.
t
.
Re e ( #54)
viw Doc.
'
.
!.
.
' '
'
t x
' .'
î
'
. ' .
.
.
. . .
'
..
.
.
Now t tt cou t sc l dPl ntf houl ha t ea ce st l ofhi r c ds t c t .
ha he r ha onc ude ai ifs d ve h c s og t s e or , he our '
i
!
1
8
no ha t as rai t m a ri w hi Pl ntf - who i ilt a e- wilb alow e t r vi w t m .
w s o ce t n he nne n ch ai i f
s lier t
l e l d o e e he
9
l t t r pec , snce t c r c ude a nt ntofc ms l(i td. oter s )i not
n ha es t i
he ou t oncl d ppoi me
ot e lmie or h wie s
I
i
1
0
a r r a e .heques i be om eswhet rt cou t ilm a Pl ntf e e t er c dsw ih an
pp op i t ,
t
ton c
he he r w l. ke ai ifr vi w hos e or
t
!
!
;
1l
1
2
NDoc-ppoi e e oy e(sDee ant pge)oral hi t dos wiht i t a ssan who
a ntd mpl e a fnd s r
lpw . o o t he nmae s it t
m
h be ni ve i Plit& sc e( c eva yb hi el wihou anymsit cewhas r
as e nvol d n ani as or onc i bl'y ms f t t
ssan
toeve)
13
A s, s s da
dicuse bove alhoughDef
,t
endans rs e( #56)prposdti pa a c d
t' e pons Doc.
o e hs r dox oul
1
4
s
uppos dl b r s ve by a lm ie a
e y e e ol d
i t d ppoi z ntofc m s l t c r h c ude t ss gesi
ntne
ot e , he ou t as onci d hi ug ton
15
i
:
snota vi bl s u i n.Pr ort m a ng t lm ied a nt e ofco el ugge ton,D e e nt
a e ol t o
i o ki he i t ppoi m nt
uns s
si
f nda s
ë
1
6
e ri rpr
a le opos lwast t I non-nm at i vi al il pr de t r ad t Pl i ift r cor t t
a
ha ta
i
e ndi du w l be ovi d o e o a ntf he e ds ha
I.
j
1
7
1
8
he pr pery r ques st i pe t * * *Tha i vi lw ila s u s s hi t t ke not he wi he t n,
o l e
t o ns c .
t ndi dua l l o i t m o a
es
s s ake
'
and as i tPl ntf t t g f co ng,t e r or whi h he de i at d,w hi h m ay be pr pe l
ss ai i f o a or pyi hos ec ds
c
s gn e
c
o ry
!
(
:
1
9
c pid. ( c #48a 3 4 ( onoea drf rn e o t d)
o e Do .
t - ) Fo t t n ee e c s mit .
q
I
!
;
1
i
i
I
i
E
k
.
,
v
20
21
i
:
i
22
1
23
:
2
i
'
.
i
'
i
I
.
24
25
. 26
!
-
n e c tnot d t pr e w ih t s a oa i isA ugu t30,201 Or er s a i '
our e he obl m t hi ppr ch n t
.
s
2 d , t tng:
'
M or ove , h cour r que t D e e nt a e sw he he pr di t s no
e r te
t e s s f nda s ddr s
t r ovi ng hi ni na e woul a l Pl i ift pr par a m e ngf ar e i oppos ton
m t
d low a ntf o e e
ani ul gum nt n
ii
' t De enda s'm oton. l o he wor ,i hi i a e as i t n i nota l w e
o f
nt
i
n t r ds f s nm t s s a t s
lo d
t t e pa t i t m edi al r r r vi w , how w il Pl ntf be a e t
o ak
r n he
c eco ds e e
l ai if
bl o
i om or t wha he glans fom hi m e c lr c ds r e wii t no
nc
ae
t
e
r
s di a e or evi w tl he ni a e as i t t i o a a tc a e l ga a gum e . The co ti c ni antof
nm t s san nt n r i ul t e l r
nt
ur s og z
N DOC' r gul tonswhihpr ve i t sfom ac s i h
S e ai
c e nt mna e r
ce sngt emediale or
c r c ds
of a he i a e butf t rr quess Def nda s t a r s whe he blnd
not r nm t ,
urhe e
t
e nt o dd es
t r i
a enc t t e r gul tons w oul ne s arl ha pe Pl i if s a lt t
dher e o hes e a i
d ce s iy m r a ntf ' biiy o
d t adipostvem oton und t s cic sanc .l
o s ii
i
er he e r um t es :
OS
POD
.
!
1'
27
!
;
i
h v ce r t a d i de e de t onsiuton cl i i t ec lt r t de y Pl i tf ' r q e ti t sp n ng
a eat pa a e n n p n n c tt i al a m f h ol we e o n a n ifs e u s n hi e di
s
r
28 a to t a hi i t a s sa h v a c s t hi m e c r c d u e h ec r u sa e s' ( . 5 a 9.
c i n h t s nma e s it nt a e c e s o s dial e or s nd rt es ic m t nc s ' Doc # 2 t )
l
I
i
!
1Th c t loak dDee d t t a 's i terrsonsv me a um wh t rPl nirmiht
3 e ouras se fn ans o ddr sn 1 i ep ie mornd
e
)
ehe aitf g
Defnd ns rs s ( c. 5 , owe erdi no s cfc l a drs t ss bet
e a t' epone Do # 6)h v , d t pe iial d es hi ujc.
y
18
i
I
1
.
i
!
I
.
.
1
i
'
.
:
1
( c # 5 a 8 9)
Do . 2 t - ,
!
!
.
.
.2
.
.
j
i: .
- ?
3
t u ra o a yc tlç ti efit p io o rto s Tu n rv S je j4 2U. 7 , 4- 5( 98 ) . '
o n e s n bl i ej c t l n o rs n peain . r e . a ly 8 S. 8 8 8 1 7 .
n
s
4
i
Thec ti s pstvçt t e s u iy ç r ofprs a i srton a t tac ti not . .
our s e ii p h ec rt once ns
ion dm nita i nd ha our s
The p obl m sa t nda t t i t q aer howe , yr r te biiyi prs ad i s r in . .
r e te nt o hç nsant t ,
m
vçr ma equie l xi lt n ion m nitato .
$
.
1:, :' . : 5 .no d rt a he e u tc h r i;Th c u t o s o ve t eNDoc-s itn s g sina av a l ..
.. .
:
i r e o c iv j sie een L e p r d e n t iw h
'
y ssa t ug e t s ibe :.
o
j
i
.
I
!
.
6. s u i t Pli i spe s
ol ton o antm
r onali lt t pr pa e a r s e t De enda t 'm oton.ors m a y
ngbiiy o e r e pons o f n s
i f .um r
'
.
t
'
1
7
j
udgme .Eve i t e iemedi lr or we r dt hi a e i Pli ifwer a et t
nt n f he ntr
ca ec ds m ea o m, nd ven f antf e bl o ag
!
8
a c c t i oft e r or , beng ilt r t Pli ifwoul pr bl notbe a et as i iae
nd opy era n hos ec ds i lie a e antf
d oba y
bl o sm lt
9
t m i oars i a g nt si lry,fh c nnotpr det erc dst hi i t ssa ,
he nt e ponsve r ume . mia l i e a
ovi hos e or o s nmaeasitnt
1
0
iwoul beamos i sbl prMrAs
t d l tmposi ef
. hdown( whoe rmi m ss Plito t prpar acoge
or
ve ght sit ani o e e
nt
11
1
2
mxum e i onpos ton.4
nt n
ii 1
'
'*
'
The c tnot N DO C r a i pr bi a i a e f om havi hi m e ca r cor i hi
our es
egul tons ohi t n nm t r
ng s di l e ds n s
1
3
c l ore n i t 1 w lbr r I t ad,t r c dsa e ke i t m e ca k t I t tr ga d,a t e
e l ve n he a i a y. ns e he e or r pt n he di l mi . n ha e r t h
1
4
Septm b 25, 2hea i t c r as De e nt'c
e er 201
rng he ou t ked f nda s ouns lhow heh ms l co dha pr e
e
i ef ul ve epar d
1
5
Defnda s'moton f s nunayj
e nt
i or u r udgmenti he di notha t me c r or avalbl fr
f
d
ve he dial ec ds ia e o
1
6
r f r nce n e f t i r s
eee .
orhrght e pons w ast ts h w oul a it dl pr en af m i e hur e eve
e
ha uc
d dm te y es t or dabl
dl
n
17
t hi as a t ai atorney. W hie t s com pl t confr s ever i at whos cas i ves
o m
r ned t
l hi
exiy
ont
y nm e
e e nvol
1
8
me ca r or ,i i m a fe e
di l ec ds t s gnii d xpone ily wih a i t who i iltr t
nta l t n nma e
s lie a e.
!
i
!
i
I
j
'
!
E
q
;
i
!
!
.
'
:
j
1
9
Acc di y,due t t u que f ct s oft s c e,t onl vi bl a t r' tve' c tc n
or ngl
o he ni
a or
hi as he y a e le na i t our a
he
20
pr pos i t tPl ntF si t m ssa as bea l
o e s ha ai i nma e s it nt lo
loweda e st andr vi w ofPli tf' medi l
cc s o
e e
a n ifs
ca
21
rc r st b a l t a ss Plitf i h sr s n et Dee a t' to f rsl r j d n.
e o d o e be o s it anif n i e po s o fnd ns mo in o l
mmay u gme t
i
22
Pr o he e o, e r Pl i ifw oul havet e c e abr d w ai rand c e t a l hi i at
i rt r t how ve , a ntf
d
o xe ut
oa
ve
ons nt o low s nm e
'
23
a s s a a c s t s h r cor ,a w el a a r c ton Pl ntf ms um esa1 r s ate ntt t s
s it nt c es o uc e ds s l s e ognii
ai if s
l i ks t nda o hi
;
24
pr ce e.A ddii ly, a n i si a e a s s a
o dur
tona l Pl i tT nm t s it ntwoul s ha oexe ut n a ee en
dal o vet
c ea gr m twhe eb
r y
;
i
25
he a r e hew oul notdi cl e t c e ofa ofPl i i s m e c r c dst a ot ri a e,
ges
d
s os he ont nt ny
a ntc
di al e or o ny he nm t
;
i
26
a t'tihe(hei t asitnt di s , h wo l p s il bes b e to1 t s n to sb tec u t
nd ha f t mnae ssa ) d o e ud o sby u j c t 7 h a ci n y h o r
0
1
@
i
27
i
28
I
i
:
:
j
!
.
'
1 Ther i alot pr em t t N DOC as santi af l empl
4
e s s he obl hat he
sit s elow
oyeeofDef
endant ,w hi pr
s
ch esent
s
c ranis e ofc l t '
e ti s u s onfi .
c
i
1
j
I
'
1
9
.
1
'
1
!
' '
'
2
'
.
j
'
'
.
: :. ..
i
,.
i' '
; ''
a e m e woul a s bea t dit e i oft De e nt and NDOC. .
gr e nt
d lb
t he s r ton he f ndé s
'
.
;
'
:' g . .
'
.,
.
jj'
y.EXHAUSTI ARGUV ENT :
.
ON
'
' .
.
'
'
'
.
: ' ' . ''. n ec i t sta Dee a t'moi nf rs mnl j t e !as .se t'sago n f r '
i 4 . ..
: .
.
oktnoe h t fnd ns to ' u e ùl n loa srs' ru ds o ' :
l
o
m
a
.
'
''
5 1'emi tonof intm sé tont t ai i ald. e bshi a nitai e di .( c: 39,
'tr nai pl i .ci ha pl ntffie t xha t s dmi krtverme es Do #
o
.
'
'
' 6
u
.
!
.
;
a'6 1 . Dee d nssaePlitf ie tr eif r l re n e r ltdt t eAbl yis e b t
t1 - 8) f n a t tt aniffld h e n o ma g iva c s eae oq
h if su s u
i
7
'
'
!
1
'
t
!
'
1
:
i
'
and a opra edicplnebyNDOC.'hef m a c e oft i t a ssa ' non dic os e
ppr it s i i
I or nd ontnt he nma e s it nts
'
s l ur
n erpur ue t m be
ev
s d he
yond t tlvel Asi wel esa ih apl ntf i r quie t c m pl t y
ha e .
s l t bls ed, ai if s e r d o o eel
8
e h u t ni siuin, g iv nc p i t c mme cn acvirg t a to o t a s b e t 4 U. C.
x a s a n ttto s re a e roro o n i g i l ih s cin n h t u j c. 2 S.
9 j l 9 e( ) Mc nne v Clry,311 F.d 11 ,119 ( t Ci.2002) l te isa tma tr
9 7 a ; Ki y . c
' n h n tn te ,
, 3 98 9 9h. r
.
.
1
0
.
a 1 - 8'Ex. ( 7 .
t 6 1 , F AR 40))
n eeor whl t is dicuse heei ar bei addrsedt ou t a oprat
rf e, ie he sues s sd r n e ng e s hr gh he ppr i e
cha l , t c t l r uiePl ntf'or pondt Def ndags l
nne s he our wil eq r ai ift es
o e r ' l usi a gume . Pl ntf
exha ton r
nt' ai if
'
.
1
5
!
I
a nika i pr es andt ba st sCo tsc i r ton ofPli 'fsCompl nt1 t c #3
dmi s tve oc s
hus r hi ur, onsde a i
antf '
i
ai 5 ' . 9
Do
1
4
I
11
1
2
1
3
'
De e ant c e Pli iff ld t purueMsg ivan st ough a1t e lvesoft NDOC
f nd s ontnd antf aie o s
re ce hr
1 hre e l he
s lfl a r s n et t t xh usi n' o o n wihi t nt - ne( )da o t ed t o
hal i e po s o he t a to 'c mp ne t t n we y o 21 ys f h a e f
e
e
1
6
t s O r ,ie ,by O c obe 24,
hi der . .
t r 2012.
.
!
!
!
i
!
1
1
7
I . ,coxctusl
v
- ox
.
1
8
I I HEREBY ORDERED:
T S
1
9
() Plitf' Re u s a dMoinfrAp onme to Co n e ( s#5 a #5 )ae
1 anifs q et n to o p it n f u sl Doc. 4 nd 5 r
20
. 21
D ENI ;
ED
2
2
( ) Dee d n ss g eto o aLi tdAp oi me to Co ns l Do . 5 )i DEM ED;
2
fn a t u g sin f mi
e p nt n f u e ( c # 6 s
.
( ) Plit fsrq et o c mpeea c s t h sme ia a dme tlh at rc r m o .
3 ani ' e u s f r o lt c e s o i dc l n na e lh e ods c #
f
'.23
24
5 i GRANTED;a
4) s
nd,
( Pli ifsrquett ena eli i t asitntt rviw hi r or wihPlitf,a
4) antf' e s o bl zs nmae ssa o e e s ec ds t anif nd
25
t utlzet r cor whieopposng t De e
o ii he e ds l
i he f ndan s moton f slnma .yj d me t Do . 5 ) i
t ' i or lr r u g n ( c # 4 ,s
26
GRANTED.
i
2
27
1 I i pos i ea concl i a s t Pl ntf t exhausi i ue may i
5 t s sbl
uson dver e o ai ifon he
ton ss
ndeed r
enderm oota1 of
I
28 t e i utsaddr se i t O r .
h ss
.
es d n he der
2
0
I
!
.
.
1
j
!
'
1
,
( ) Li td Sty o Or r
5 mie a f de
n ec utrc g ie ye u iu naueo t sore. cou yloroee d nsidiae
o r eo nzs h nq e tr t hi d r
'
ne
fn a t n ctd
3
I.. .
J. .
.
.
.
..
! .
- .
.
,
'. ' .
. .
'
.
.
.
hi or
s rc
Dqf nt woul lkel s k ( vi ofa las c rai compone soft s' der by D i t i tJudgc .
enda s
d i y ee ç ew
te t et n
nt
4
J s w hi h t s c tunde >f nds The epr,par aphsI .3)and.4)oft sOr rs e . .
one , c hi our
ta .
r f e' agr
V:(
(
hi de ar
.
.
. 5 .
STAYED p n i gtesln f p r p it j çin a ds bsq nv viw te e f n de iipb
e d n h ' igo : p o raeobe to s n u e ue ti e h ro a d cso y
a
'
r
6
DititJ d eJne. . . , .'.? . :
'rc u g o s . ,
s
.
..
7
DAT Oco e 52 1
ED: tbr , 0 2
.. .
.
.
'
: . .
. .
Q . . 2: C
4I .
-
-
8
.
'
1
I
!
,
i
!
1
!
!
:
9
'
1)
(
.
!
.
w I - A M o . co BB
I LI
U NI
TED STA TES M A G I
STRATE J G E
UD
11
1
2
13
.
.
'
1
4
.
15
1
6
'
1
7
-
l
8
l L ,t .
J ,: . '
..
1
9
.
:
!
'
.
20
al
'
22
'
23
j
'
24
'
25
26
27
zg
'
21
.
: 2 ..
t
. .
.
.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?