Ashdown v. Hyatt et al

Filing 10

ORDER RE: INFORMAL SETTLEMENT DISCUSSION - Courtesy copy of this order and complaint shall be sent to Ds' counsel. ( E-service 5/21/2012; 6 Amended Complaint via NEF Regeneration. ) If parties unable to settle, then Court will reconsider IFP and P will have to pay the full $350.00 filing fee. Signed by Magistrate Judge Valerie P. Cooke on 5/18/2012. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

;

' --'-

C
j
c -; i V.

F E;
I

'

-

RECEI
VED
SER ON
VED

ENTE D
RE

COUN UP TISOFRE
SE AR E
CORD

1
.

.

.

z

:Ay 2 12 1
22

3

C E K U DIm j cou y
LR S s u
q

4

INI S
J TED TATESDIT CTCO
S
DI
STRICT OF N

.

.

IT F EMA xpy
CO NV
uy
.-

-

-

.

5

6 PHI /B.
LLI AsHoow x,
7

Plitf
anif

r 8
vs
.
9 C/ KYAW >
C
1
0

.

Dee t
fndan.

)

3: 1cv- 6 - (
1 - 08 3 LRH vPc)

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

' '
ORDER RE:I
NFORM AL
SETTLEM ENT DI
SCUSSI
ONS
'
'

.

.

,
.

11

1
2

n i c ew ilnotb r er e f f
s ms l
e ef r d or onnal edi ton.H o e , ven t na u e oft cl m st
m ai
w ver gi he t r
he ai he

1 Cour haspe te t pr ce t e Cour f ndst tt pa tesw ilbe f tf om i onnaldi c s ons
3
t
nnit d o o ed, h
ti
ha he r i
l ne i r nf
s us i
1 i a e f tt s te t sc s The Cou t nc la s t pa te t enga i s ch di cus i . Fort s
4 n n f or o etl hi a e.
r e ot ge he r i s o
r
ge n u
s sons
hi

l r a on, c t yc oft sor rar t c
5 e s a oures opy hi de f he ompli ts lbepr de t de en ' cot elb t
d
a n hal
ovi d o f dants ms y he

1 Cl r oft Cour.l t çpa tesa ea et s tl t c edulngt ni y- ysa t $35 00flng
6
e k he
t f h ri r bl o e te he as i he net da ty, he 0. ii
l f e nee notbe pai How ev ,i t pa tes a e un e t -etl ' t Cour w ilr ons de t
7 e
d
d.
er f he r i r abl o s teyt
hen he
t l ec i r he
'

l mo int p oc e if r pa pe i (F , n panifwi ha et p yte$ 5 .0tln fei f l
8
to o r e d n o ma u rs 1 P) a d litf l v o a h 3 00 iig e n u l
l
1 eihe i dit y(fI sausi de e ori i eme sbya omai de tonsfom hi prs
9 t r mme ael i FP tt s nid) n ncr nt
ut tc duci r
s ion
20 tus ac
r t count(fI sau i grntd)
i FP tts s a e .
21

I I SO O R D ERED .
T S

22

.

Da e M ay 1 ,201
t d:
8
2.

2
4
'

'

.
.

A

U NI
TED STATES M A G STRATE J DG E
U
25
26

.

27

28

.

(
(

'

V wë.
k-

.
l

'

'

I or alSe t e e
nf m
t l m nt
Fr aue l As d O ue tons
e ntv ke
si

2

,

1
.

'

W ha i t purpos ofi or als tl
t s he
e nf m etementdicus i f i at Se ton 19 cas s
s sons or nm e c i
83 e ?
3
'
.
The goalof i or a s tl entdi c s ons i i a e Se ton l
nf m l e tem
s us i
n nm t c i 983 c es i t alow t pa tes a
as s o l he r i n
4 oppo t t t wor t t rt r c a r a ona e r s uton t t rc e b or t pari s be n
runiy o
k oge he o ea h e s bl e ol i o hei as ef e he te gi
dicove y.
s
r
'
'
5

6
'

2.

Do t parisne t r tt t j
he te ed o epor o he udgewhathappenedi s tl ntdicus i ?
n eteme s sons

'
'
N o. Setl m entdi c s onsar c i tal neiherpary s d r por t t D it i tJ
te
s us i
e onfden i and t
t houl e t o he s rc udge ort
he
7 M a s r t J dg a s g t yourc s t r ulsofs te e di cu s ons The pa te s l nots nd
gi ta e u e s i ned o
a e he es t
etl m nt s s i .
r i s ha l
e
ofer a c
f s nd ount r of e s t t c t The onl i f
e - f r o he our .
y n onna i t c r wilr e ve i w het rt c e
ton he ou t l ec i s
he he as
8 s tl
e ted.
9 3.

W hathappe i t partes r ac a s t l ent
ns f he
i e h e tem ?

l I t pa tess tl t c e, hedep y a t ne ge r w il e r a w rte s t l en ag ee entf
0 f he r i e te he as t
ut tor y ne al l pr pa e
it n e tem t r m
or ,
t pa te t s gn.O nc t pa te r ew and s gn t s te e a e m ent a s i a i i s it
he r i s o i
e he r i s evi
i he etl m nt gr e
, tpul ton s ubm ted
11 t t courtt end t cas
o he
o
he e.
1 4.
2

W hathappens i t par i s don' s t l t c e?
f he t e
t e te he as

1 I t c e doe nots l e t e i n n atv c e nce t t e pari . Setl m e dic s ons
3 f he as
s
etl , her s o eg i e ons que
o h
tes
te nt s us i
i y r de a opporuniy f t pa te t m ee and di c s how t y m i r s ve t c e. l
n
t t or he r i s o
t
s us
he ght e ol he as f
.s m pl p ovi
1 t r i no s tl m e yt ca e w il oc e
4 he e s
e te nt he s l pr e d.
15 5.

W hy do partesi ltgati at em ptset l ent as opposed t a t alon t m eris?
i n ii on t
tem
,
o' ri
he
t

1 Se te e i i onnal t pa te ha a opport iy t be he d and t he ' t oppos ng pa t s
6
tl m nt s nf
and he r i s ve n
tm t o
ar
o a he
r
i
ry'
poi Ofvi w ,s nc pa te t c l don' s ak t one a he e ptt ough a t ne and l ga '
nt
e i e r i s ypi aly
t pe o
not r xce hr
tor ys
e l
1 f lngs Setl m enta s alow s t e pari w ho ha ong ng r a i hi t pr s r i by h ng a '
7 ii . te
'lo l
h
tes
ve oi el tons ps o e e ve t
avi
di c s on r he t n e agi i a adve s alpr ee ng.
s us i at r ha ng ng n n
r mi
oc di
1
8
.
'
Se tem e al o of er t pa tes m or te biiy t r s ve t ei di put The pa te c e or a '
tl nt s f s he r i
e l xi lt o e ol h r s e.
ri s an xpl e
l vare y ofw a t r ol t ca e,a t y ha co r ove t out e.
9
it
ys o es ve he s nd he ve nt ol r he com

20 6.

Ar t e ot be ft t s tl
e her her ne is o e tementdicus i ,e n i t ca e doesnots tl
s sons ve f he s
e te?

21 Se tem e di c s ons alow t pari t oppor un t t s ak hone ty wih on a t r i a
tl nt s us i
l he tes he
t iy o pe
s l t e no he n n
i or ,c i nta e r e , Eve i t ca ei nots tldy hepr s ca be ve y hepf t
nf mal ontde il nvionm nt
n f he s s
e te t
oce s n
r l ul o
22 t p te i t r t ngt i cai anddef ns i t cas ,wha dic r an motonsmi be ,
he ari s n mde sandi her l ms
e es n he e
t s ove y d
i
ght

2 ncsaysn temasv te atsrem aeeftny Smeiistrcase.Iiehticrettc i j
3 odfneadbsiyaeh preai ord ici .n lii mep tseladditetnelms
r es a i mie
eesr,cnhds sdand they t n moetio tttng ai ranztaon,silm ent
i me
a a
en
ga
he e
,

dsuso sotno ested o fr ulerslt na tecs poed. eb t rifr dte 1
icsin f pn h o ro ftr eoui sh ae rce sTh et nome h
e
z
o
e

2 p risaea o th ic s,h b te pe rdte wil ei it ai a di e plrn ftr o to s I
4 ate r b u ter aete etr rpae h y lb n ii t n n x oig uue pin
g on
f r s t l ent
o e tem .

.

25

'

.
.

'
:

26
27

28

.

'

2