Elvik v. Williams et al
Filing
5
ORDER RE: INFORMAL SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS. Parties encouraged to engage in settlement discussions. Copy of this order and complaint shall be provided to Ds' counsel by Clerk of Court. ( E-service 4/30/2012; 4 Complaint via NEF regeneration. ) Signed by Magistrate Judge Valerie P. Cooke on 4/30/2012. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)
'
-> --
.
!
'
.
.
,
.
.
.
qEcEl
vEn
FtE
lp
.
(TRD
NEC'
. S R DDN ;
E VI
éU SUPRISQ R C D'
C N E ATE F EQR .
'
1
.
AFq''2 1 1 '
'' 22
3
5
4
UNI S
TED TATESDITRI
S C
.
.
DI
STRI OF NEVA
CT
Y E X D RW O UR
Y
YT I
T
nt l-oFv.ns .
rqtr %
v
r .,
,
# .'
uuv ..- ....... ...''-*.. pr
, ....*'.'.'' 'v*.'f . v
éu
' .
.
''
.
e'
5
6 PETER QUI ELVI
NN
K,
.
7
8
Pl ntf,
ai if
vs
.
9 BRJ W I AM S,SR.e a.
AN LLI
, t I,
1
0
Def nt.
enda s
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
3:2- 01 5 ECR (
1 CV- 7 VPC)
ORDER IE:I
t NFORM AL
SETTLEM ENT DI
SCUSSI
ONS
11
1
2
Thi c s wilnotber en'df f m al
s ae l
ef e or or mediton.Howe r gi t na u eoft cli t
ai
ve , ven he t r
he a ms he
1 Cour hmspe m it d t pr e t e Cour tndst t p te wilb ftfom i or dic so
3
t
r te o oce d, h
ti
hat he ari s l ene i r nf mal s us i ns
1 i a e f t o s te t sc s The Cour e our gest pa te t enga i s h di c s ons Fort s
4 n n f or t etl hi a e.
t nc a
he r i s o
ge n uc s us i .
hi
1 r as a c t s c oft sor a t c pl i s lbe pr de t de e nt 'c
5 e on, our e y opy hi der nd he om a nt hal
ovi d o f nda s ouns by t
el he
l Clr oft eCour.l t pa tesa ea et s tl t cà edu i t eni t da say,he$350. flng
6
ek h
t f he ri r bl o e te he s rng h nep y t t
00 ii
l f e n d no b pai Howev ,i t e pari a e una e t s tl t t Cou twilr
7 e ee t e d.
er f h
tes r
bl o e te, hen he
r l econsde t
i r he
1 mo int p o e d if r
8
to o r c e n o mapau rs(FP , h panif lh v t p yte$ 5 .0tl f ei f l
pe i I ) a d li tf wil a e o a h 3 00 ii e n ul
ng
1 et ri
9 ihe mmedit y(fl sat i dene ori i rf sbyaut tcdedu i fom hi I s
ael i FP t us s id) n ncenent
omai
ctons r
s yion
20 tus a count(fI sau i grntd .
r tc
i FP tts s a e )
21
I I SO ORDERED.
T S
22
jj
tf
.
Dat d; Apr l30,201
e
i
2.
23
2
4
25
26
27
28
'
.
I
'
h
' %o
UNI
TED STATES M AGI TRATE J
UDGE
.
:
.*?.
. .
'
.
1
I orm alSe t e ent
nf
t lm
Fr que l As O ue tons
e ntv ked
si
2
1.
W hati t pur e of i or als t l e di cus i f i at Se i 1
s he
pos
nf m
e tem nt s s ons or nm e cton 983 c e ?
as s
3
The goa Qf i or s tl ntdic sons i i ae Sec i 1 ca e i t a l t pari an
l nf mal e teme
s us i n nm t
ton 983 s s s o low he tes
4 opporuniy t wor t et rt r a a r ms bl r olton t t rc e be or t pari be n
t t o
k og he o e ch e ona e es u i o hei as f e he tes gi
di c r
s ove y.
,
5
2.
Dot parisne d t r portt t j
he te e o e
o he udgewhathappe d i s tl
ne n etementdic si ?
s us ons
6
N o. Se tem e di c s onsa e c i nta an ne t rpa t s oul r tt t D i ti tJ
tl nt s us i
r onfde i l d ihe ry h d epor o he s rc udgeort
he
7 M a sr t J
gi t a e udge a s gne t yourca e t r s t ofs tl e di c s ons The pa te s lnots nd
si d o
s he e uls e tem nt s us i .
r i s hal
e
ofe sand c e - f r t t c t Theonl i onna i t c t l r cei i wh hert c s
fr
ount rofe s o he our,
y nf
ton he our wil e ve s et he a e
8 s te
etl d.
9 3.
W hathappe i t par i r ac a s t l ent
ns f he tes e h e tem ?
1 I t pa te s tl t ca e i d put a t ne ge al lpr pa eawrte s tlmenta e men f
0 f he ris e te he s , he e y tor y ner wil e r
itn e te
gr e t or
t pa te t sgn.Onc t pa tesr viw andsgnt s te
he ris o i
e he ri e e
i he etlment e m e , si a i i s bmitd 1
agr e nta tpulton s u te
11 t t c r t e t ca e
o he ou t o nd he s .
l 4.
2
W ha happe i t par i s don' s te t ca e?
t
ns f he te
t et l he s
1 I t ca e doesnots tl t r i no ne tve c s quen t t paris. Se teme dic sons
3 f he s
e te, he e s
ga i on e
ce o he te
tl nt s us i
sm pl pr dea o
i y ovi n pporuniy f t pa test me ta dicus how t y m i r s vet c s l
t t or he ri o e nd s s
he ght e ol he a e. f
1 t r i no s tl m e t cm e w il oce d.
4 he e s
e te nt he s l pr e
'
1 5.
5
W hy do parte i ltgaton at e pts te ent as oppo ed t a t i on t m er t ?
i s n ii i
tm
et l m , .
s o r al he
is
l Seteme i i or a t pa tesha a opporuniyt b hea d a t he rt opposng pa t s '
6
tl nt s nf mal nd he ri ve n
t t o e r nd o a he
i
ry'
poi ofvi snc pa test c l don' s k t one a he e eptt oug a t n ys a lga '
nt
ew, i e ri ypialy
t pea o
not r xc hr h tor e nd e l
1 flngs Se te talo alowst e pa te who ha ongoi r l i hi t pr s e i by havi a
7 ii . tlmen s l
h ris
ve
ng eatons ps o e tn' t
ng
dic son r he t n e
s us i at r ha ngagi i a a r a i pr e di
ng n n dve s ral oc e ng.
1
8
Setlmentas ofer t pa tesmor te biiy t r ol t rdiput The pa te c n expl e a
te
lo f s he ri
e l xi lt o es ve hei s e.
ris a
or
1 vare yofwa t r ol e t ca e a t eyha c tolove t out ome.
9
it
ys o es v he s , nd h
ve on r
r he c
20 6.
Ar t eot bene ist s tl e dicus i , ve i t cas doe nots tl
e her her
ft o e tem nt s sons e n f he e s
e te?
2 l Setl m ent di cu s ons alow t pa te t opp t t t s eak hc s l w ih one anot i an
te
s si
l he r i s he
oruniy o p
me ty t
her n
i or ,contden i e r
nf mal
i tal nvionme . Even i t c s i no s tld,t p oc s c n be ve y hepf t
nt
f he a e s t e te he r e s a
r l ul o
22 t pa te i unde sa n t i c am sa def e i t c s wha dic r an motonsmi htbe
he ris n
r t ndi g he r l i nd ens s n he a e, t s ove y d
i
g
nec s ar andt smays et pa testmea mone Sometme pari r alz t at rai cli
e s y,
hi
av he ri i nd
y.
i s tes e ie h ce t n a ms
23 orde e esc bedim is a t y ar mor e fcinti Itgatng t c e. n a ton,s ulme
f ns an
s s ed, nd he e e fi e n ii i he as l ddii e e nt
dic sons ofe ope t doorf f t e r s uton a t c s pr ee .The be tri or d t
s us i
tn ns he
or u ur e ol i s he a e oc ds
te nf me he
2 parisa ea
4
te r boutt i c e,hebe trpr par t ywil i ltg i and i e orng f u eoptons
her as t
te e ed he l be n ii aton
n xpl i ut r
i
f s t l ent
or e tem .
' ''
25
26
27
28
2
.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?