WALKER v. RICCI et al

Filing 2

OPINION. Signed by Judge Peter G. Sheridan on 5/3/10. (DD, )

Download PDF
H- (12 d > 0 h < HCD d P3 it P3 H- H P3 CD HH H CD C) CL) Hit 4 C 1 tzI H tXI H `tJ H tzi x C) HCD H0 0 C) C) CD C) CD it 4--i HH C) Z t'l CD h M W CD 1H0 4- 0 HCD - CD (`I P3 P3 H 4i H- 0 Mi -- H i Hi it CD HC) it H- H C) Q P3 P3 CD it <CDJtij HCD 0 CJ it Q < i C) txI CL) H C) 0 HC) it HCD CD-. H -- C) -o HCD CD P3 CD it it 0 -D 4-- it P3 P3 H 4 f-zC 1CD Cii CDQMii i· CO it QWCDH 0frUi C) CD CD H C) 0 Mi it CD HCD CD C ii o 0 -- 0 C) 0 HCDc3 CD C) it 0 i CD - Co-<(12 H(r)HtCD CD it d it it H`-ii H- CD Mi 0 h P3 `ti C- H CD CD - CD Z it 0 CD C) CD Hi -- H- H- CD P3 0 CD it (Q CD H P3 0 P3 H CD it CD HCD H- o it H H CD C C- P3 it CD -- Q CD < Q C0 4 CCD ICD cC PJ13CxJ it ti CD- it HC) CD C-- CD `ti C LJ 0 CD CD it CD `-rjo HCD H-it CDHHWit H Htzj P3 (12 it CD it P3 it CD hCD CD < P3 CD Li. Cl çt CD Q HCD CD CD Cl CD C) t\) P3 -- CD H0 CD CD (Q S Co CD M Ui CD i CD H0 CD H-3 C4 si Cl H- H- it CD C) 0 0 1 C) P3 it CD 0 C) C) 0 it P3 CD it LI oi it it 0 CD H4- W o () P3 P3 Hit CD C) Mi P3 H H CD H- < CD C) C) 0 0 C) H trIcc CD CD H it i HHCJ CD 4--ti HCD H- H- 0 Cl Cy CD H `-C) `-.0 `-1) Mi H Ui P3 it it -- C) M CD < H- CD it P3 it CD HH H C4 H t'jc) C) Hit CD H CD -- it i Hit CD -- CD it P3 Cii S 4--h H- 0 Z CD C) it H- 0 i 0 HH 0 P3 CD H ) -.0 0 CD CD Mi 0 it CD II 4--ti C CD 4 C CD h Cl H- CD CD > CD 0 `d CD it CD C) < d CD it CD CD `--< CD it CD 4CD CD çt C) 0 it CD 0 Z CD 4CD -- P3 `I Hit H- it 0 t-- Cl P3 HH b `-< `-< it HI--'CD it H- 0 `-0 Ui CD H H P3 it CD Hit CD `-< P3 H CD it 0 H0 0 i it 0 it Hit Mi Ui Mi CD `TI `TI CD H H P3 it -) CD 0 P3 0 CD CD - 0 t- 5 0 P3 It) (Ci 0 H, CD t- (2 0 LO --] 0 Fl hj (2 P (12 CD C CD H 0 C)) F- `- i Ci) 0 - 0 PJ HHFt (12 C,) Ft CD 0 CX) 122 Ft `t CD (12 Q u u M d 0 H (1) Pi -- H Pi 0 P1 0 CD H 0 (3 H (2 CD H H CD p3 CD Ft Fl 2J H C!) CD Fl CD Ft Hfri] Q 0 P1 0 CD a H H CD C) H0 HC!) Ft 2 Ci) Cl) HCl) Ft -3 Fl < 0 Ft -- lCD CD 0 t3 H < U H Cl) H- -- CD Q P1 H CD ) 0 CX) --3 CX) CD p3 H CD H U] H C!) HHCD CD Cl) HH, Q Q 1 0 H, H, Fl H- ((3 CD d CD 0 P) 0 Ft H, Fl HCl) (3 CD CD ct 0 P3 Ft CD Hp3 Ft H0 Ft CD Fl CD Fl CD CD xj -· H HtJ CD C)) -- LQ Cn HHH, -- · ,- tJ CD Ft W P-) tC (12 HH, CJ Fl HFt CD Ft (2 (12 (2 H CD i 0 Fl F-j Q ) H- Q H0 0 (1) CD H `t5 Cl) CD H · 0 0 0 p3 --3 H Fl 93 J H, H H H H -< HFt H- Q (I) Ft HH H H CD Fl -- 0 Fl H, Cl] CD Ft CD P3 CD Cl) CD H HC!) 0 Q H1Q 3 Ft · 93 1 < b 0 · 0 P3 Ft H0 Q (12 CD H b CD i CD p3 Cl) Z CD LJ Ft Ft Ft CD CD CD H, CD Ft HFt HCD H HCD H, Fl 0 0 tJ H Cl) H H CX) HFt P3 i CD `-< H H H Ft 3 H E CD H, Cl) CD 0 Fl xi 0 Cl) CD CD P3 H CD Fl 0 i M t'J -- W 1 P3 < P3 Cn CD 93 Cl) 93 Cl) CD Fl Fl · H CD Cl) CD H H p3 LJ CD 93 Cl) t3 CD Ft HFt H- -- CD 0 Fl H93 H HH CD () Fl I -- HH CD P3 CD H- W Q CD Fl Cl) < P3 P3 Q HFt C!) Ft y' 0 CD Ft HFt H- Fl H1 H- H 0 Ft H- () HFl 0 · CD P3 (12 0 93 HCl) 0 0 C!) CD (2 Fl P_I HCl) CD H(3 C!) CD H- 1C (2 0 C!) (3 H- Fl Fl (12 Ft h HFt HFt H- Fl CD 0 C!) H Cfl 93 Ft H H 0 H 93 H0 0 (2 CD l- 0 < 0 Ft H- H, H CD -0 Ft HC ((3 Ft 93 0 P3 93 Ft CX) H CD CX) IQ (I) Cl) -- 0 9) LQ CD H, H H CD C CD Cl) H, HFl Cl) Ft CD -· Ft 0 -- HCl) 93 (1) Ft 93 (1) ç-t H, H (2 Ft H0 H 93 H- -. t CD C) 0 1 CD (1) (-Q Fl CD <: H CD LY d 0 Cl) U] H (xj Cl) Ft CD H H CD Cl) Ft p3 0 0 CD Fl H-- 93 CD Fl (3 i Q CD HCl) Cl) U] tO 0 Fl 0 H p3 HCl) H-- Cl) H0 Q P3 C!) Ft Cl) 9) Fl 1 Q HCC P3 LJ P3 Ft CD Cl) Ft P3 Ft CD < C) b' H CD P3 93 tO CD 0 -- U] H, -- C) C!) CD (3 HCD H, H, H0 93 Ft HH, H- CD Q -- -- -- 0 0 0 Cl · 0 CD H, H, CD HFt CD Cl · CD (3 l HCD H, H, 0 Fl CD Fl Ft 0 Pi H, H, P3 Ft CD s:i Cl) Cl) p3 P' CD p_I Ft C!) Ft P3 Ft Cl) Ft b CD CD · (Ci CD Ft H HFt H- CD 0 Fl < CD Ft P3 Ft CD CD CD -- H CD --3 tO ct H< H- Fl 0 CD 0 Ft HCD CD `xi C) Ft H() < CD Ft Co C) Z < HCD Cl) Ft Ft 0 Fl i CD i CD (2 Ft H- HFt HCD 5 0 -- CD CD Fl S H Ft < (3 · Cl) 0 5 0 Fl Cl Fl H, P3 Cl H CD 0 zi 0 Fl 0 0 CD CD H-U]C)Irt CD tI - Q HCl--, ICD d W H P) CD C) b Pi CD Mi TJ - -°Q-t<P Q (CT C) CD P1 H O Pi 0 Ft CD H CD C) (I) 0 - Mi CD H IH CD W c jw H Mit--i CDUiH--p1 HCD-- ttj CT) H- C) P1 CD -- > `1 -- frFt CD Ft P1 Ft CD CD Ft HclHCD CD CD Mi HtCD 0 P1 -D Ft Ft 51 -- Q H CD C) Cl- 5 CD H `--D H Z 0 C) h C!) Ft P1 Ft CD < CD j} < H CD CD 0 () 0 0 Mi P1 H t') H HCDr QFtHP1H H-CDFt--Jrt Ft CD < p1 CD C) h- 0 C) cS p1 CD >< 0 0 r--, ) tJ < p1 WhHCii.l<Cl- Mo 0 -- dlH0 Q 0 C) C) CD `t5 CD Ft HCD Ft II CD CD CD Ft C) 0 H H W CD CD C-t Cl) C) ClH- p1 Ft Cl) CD ClH- 0 pl 0 Mi · t-- Ft tCD CD --5 CD Ft H- -j Ft CD `-xl 51 d H5 - CD CD CD Cl- < 5 H O -1 0 -- HCD M 0 -- fr ClP1 Ft C--i Mi Hi-- -- H CD -- 0 CD k< Ft HClFt 51 0 C) CD CD CD Ui 0 CD C!) ClP1 Ft CD 0 CD --5 p1 `- S P1 H 51 Ui Ui CD H CD `-Ci H (f)HQCo`-` tM. CD HH---f)T'jHHCD-- QHC)Mi o5 P1CD CD )p1j FtoiHCl-Ft P151 CD CO3 çt Cl) CD 1-5 C H- P1 `-cl cl- CD H CD HH- -5 S 51 Ui Ui < --5 0 1-5 C-Q -- Cl- · M a) CD Ft CD 0 0 CD Ft CD · HCD C) --t Cl- Mi Mi CD C) Ft HMi H1-5 CD ClCD `-Ci 0 0 0 Cl) 1 Ft -- CD - oaMiCDUi--tJ) HMi MCDFC lHC)H- `-Ci I-- P1 ClC) Mi `--a -- -- H HC) HCD CD 1 CD CD CD CD 5 CD 1-5 H- Ui H W 51 W (CT 0 H CD CD CD >< p1 < Ft Ui Ui Ui H C-Q - W H- H J C-C) 51 CD 1-5 C) 0 HCD -- CD Ft CD 51 C) H1-5 - Ui C) C-a Mi CD M Ui H Ui -- CD Cl-- 51 0 CD H- CDHCDCD CD CDCD b4CDQCD `-Ci 5 HCD 1 CD `-Ci C) t-JLJco<Q C) 0 Mi HHCD ClCl- H1-5 H-CDCDHp1C) l-CDCiCl-CD -- dlHC) p1 H H CD CD ---1 5 X CD Ft H- CD 51 5 C) C) I-5 ClCD CD Ft CD --5 H CD -- p1 H(l * t-J3 -· `-< CD 1-5 P1 CD ClCD C) H CD CD --1 -- CD CD J CD H CD Mi Mi P1 CD CD 1-5 P1 H 51 51 51 C) H HFt HP1 H- 5 p1 1-5 Hdl- CD CD CDCD0(DCl-CDL) CD `-CiMi HCD 051 j CD HCDQCD-' CDPIH-CD C) CD C) ClMi P1 -- d 0 CD CD 51 `-Ci CD Cl- P1 CY -5 CD Cl- CD C) 0 CD p1 5 5 -· CD 0 Mi CDH(CD51HOCDCD CDFt 0 Mi CD Cl() `-Ci -5 M HFt CD C) C) CD ` CD 51 CD t Ft HFt H Ft `-Ci CD P1 H Ui Ui H 0 CD CD C) 0 CD F-5 CD 1--5 Ft CD - P1 CD CD CD 51 C) HCD pi CD 5 Ft 0 Ft 5 0 -- M Ui CD CD Mi C) CD CD b Ft MiFtQ HHC)C)HFtP1iH-" 51 Ft `- P1 C) < --Ft51 HC/) CD 5 HH0 Ft P1 P1 51 CD HP1 P1 CD Ii Ft HCD Ft Mi CD P1 H- CD p1 51 CD 5 - HCD CD -- P1 H < CD - Ft < p1 C) C) l--5 L'lCD CDI P1 H Ft CD Ft Ui Ft Ft HC) H `-d 51 51 -- H CD 51 P1 Ft H CD -- `-H-UiMiP1Z H CD Ci P1 CD CDUiH-° HtFt 0CDCD Ft H- C) 0 Ft CD 1-5 Ft Ui M CD CD 1-5 P1 HH P1 CD CD b 51 H HCD HFt W CD CD CDC!) 5 - - CD CD 1-5 CD ft (Cl ft t'J C) H- d C) ]J < ji Cl] ft H, (Cl Cl] ft P-' CX) `-0 (Cl H H- Cl Cl] (Cl -C b (1) (Cx Cl] (Cl 0 H, x-i H a (Cl W `-0 H, C) ft ft Cl] tJ (Cl h HC) Pi U Cl) 0 0 H- 0 1 (Cl h' C) Cl] C) H H pi ft (1) ft i ft (Cl (Cl ft Hft H0 S)) HH p3 Q 0 p3 H H C) W 0 (Cl (Cl H, C) 0 (Cl (Cl (Cl < ft 1 (Cl ( Cl 0 (Cl ft `rJ (Cl H H p3 ft (Cl H- ft U W W p3 H (Cl -- `d HHH, i -- (Cl Fj H (Cl Cl rt H- ft (Cl H (Cl (Cl (Cl 0 Cl ft p3 U] H 0 h p3 H (Cl (Cl t(Cl C 0 C) - 0 Cl) H, `rJ M ft CD (Cx ft C) H- 0 ( Cl l ( Cl hC p3 H (Cl ft H ft HC) p3 (Cl Cl] Y p3 -- >< (Cl ft Hft H- (Cl p3 Cl] HCl] 0 fr (Cl h --S 0 (Cl (Cl (Cl Cl] ft 0 C) ft (Cl Q Cl - (Cl c--) 0 H(Cl < 0 Cl] ft H 0 Pi ft (Cl W U] 0 U] ft p3 () 0 Cl (Cx C) CT) lft (Cl H Cl (Cl Cl ft P3 0 (Cl < (Cl X p3 Cl] çt (Cl ft H ft H- hC `Tj IH(Cl C) 0 i Cl] ft Hçt ft 0 (Cl H0 0 tft 0 H, p3 (Cl C Cl] ft H P3 -.o Cx) C) t- P3 H -- - (Cl ft ft (Cl (Cl -- (Cl ft Hft H- ft Hp3 H Cl] H0 (Cl - ft (Cl 0) `o pi < Cl] o 0 C) (Cl Cx) W Co C) Cl I--i (Cl (Cl H-- HC) 0 ft HCl] Hp3 H C) 0 Cl) ft H ft (Cx (Cl M Cl] (Cl (Cl ft (Cl o Q HM Cx) c-f Cl) c-I- (Cl p3 C) H p3 HHç-t < - CD ft · .Q --3 0 H p3 x) `-0 `-D --` 0 CD ( Cl < p3 C]) ( Cl H h ft (Cl H, p3 ft H- p3 H H < H Cl] ft -< b (Cl p3 --) C) p3 >< 0 H, CD U] C) P3 ft ft (Cx · C) C) H p3 H- C) H p3 H- `t) H- p3 H C) < (Cl Cl] --J U] Cl) ft H- (Cl P3 (Cl 0 ft < (Cl ft H- (Cl Cl ft C) H p3 HI- 0 C) (Cl Cl] Cl) ft h CD p3 C) ft P3 tY CD i CD CD · 0 i (Cl (Cx xo (Cl CD H- I- ft Cl 0 CD (Cx `tJ ICD < S CD Cl] ft HCl) CD Q HI-- H- CD ft 0 Cl) H- Cl -- 0 W CD H I-' H, C) H p3 Hft -- 4 C) H, CD 5 CD c ft 3 i H- ft p3 ft CD --` HCC Cl] H- ft ft CD fr P3 C) CD P3 ft CD I-j CD p3 H CD C) Cj ft CD T3 -J H CD CD Cl] CD CD -- H, Q HIIH P3 H- CD 0 Hft p3 ft CQ ICD M I-J U] 0 0 H, --· · H C) · -· C) p3 `-0 CX) CD $1 CD i P3 CD ft CD 5 CD Cl -- (Cx C) --3 h- H Cl -< Q CD Cl] P3 < -- ft 0 p3 HHCl] -- 0 -- C) `ti p3 ICl) Cl] Q HH CD Cl] ft (Cx CD CD 0 Cl CD < CD CD CD H- S H 0 Cl Hft 0 H, I- Cl] CD - Cl HCD P3 i 0 CD - H- P3 ft ft 0 Cl) CD Cl] CD ft CD l-- -< M tT Cl] ft HH CD i ft HCl] 5 U] CD C) ft `ZS P3 ft CD P3 HH p3 p3 CD lCD C) 0 `t CD ft Hft Cl] H, U] U] Cl] ft S Cl] Cl ft I. b ti `ti CD ft H0 HCl] ft P3 ft CD tY `< `t3 C) (I) `tT Cl] CD P3 ft CD H C CD --3 U] · P3 Cl] Cl] CD CD 5 Cl) co Co < 0 < · Cl] p3 H CD C) P3 C) ft ft d CD Hft CD CD Cl ft 0 < p3 H0 HH, CD H- 0 h' Cl] 0 CD 0 C) ft CD CD CD Cl ft Cl) H, P3 (Cx Hp3 `< Co o CX) 0 `Ci H HC) p3 CD ft Cl] 0 P3 H 0 Cl] -- Hft ft CD Cl 0 C)) p3 H H p3 ft CD ft P3 ft CD 0 IH- Cl] CD i ft H- ft H `-0 ft U 0 Hi HCD C) 0 () p3 H- CD H Hp3 HH, C) 0 p3 -- W C) C) ft Cl) CD --C 1 H CD Cl] Cl H H Hp3 p3 H H ft Cl] Ift Cl] HCl) Cl Cl `0 a H a fl Cj () 0 a a 0, - Hi H F-' Hi a n P1 it in F-' H E in H a S iv `0 iv Hin 0 it P1 H I.) tj 01 . o o H a in 0 H 0 . a D it a a ` itt F'H a it U no it orng it it I-' H H i--' H in a i-i 0 `e a w a 0' 0 F-' O'iv a F'- a n `0 F-' F'0 a g' a P1 a 0 0 4 P1 I-' Hin U U a o U Pb a in o'a it i-' H Hi Pb F' `0 H a a in fl0 a 1 in `0 in it a H a in a H a p D `4 Hi 0 0 HF'- a 0 in a F-' a 0 , 0 0 a P1 in it n H 0 o' H a `a `0 H it a F' 0.0 H- a n 0 it 0. in it Pa it a a r iv 0' in in nit P1 n ` a in U a `a a 0 H it H0 it n a it U a Pb 22 `0 a it Hit a 0 1 H in n P1 it a 0 0 Hit H- 0 0 - 4 it H- `o H 0 .0 0 Ha D 0' g it a -` Pa it at a F-' 0 , U 0 0 H a in it g a H H 0 F-' in 0 0 Hin H a it P1 Hin HH a H- it H in Hin Hin it a 4 H0 Ct H0 it in · a 0 Hi Hi a a a a 0' Ha in · U a in n a 0 H in itO U a a a 0 13 w it in C Hi Hi no a CI n · a F' a H H0 · I-in -· it U iv a H Hi F'0' in it a in ` P1 He a o a i-' it tn F-' 1 H H 0 `a a 0 `a I-' a ito a o iv ` a Hi F-''4 H aI-'in `4 0' U; Hin nit HH ,` a 0 in no in a 0 it 4 it in · in Hi U H 1-'it UED in Hi `·` a c iv sa pa o H it `0 a in HPa in E a a n o nit H · 0,0 nit 0 nit o a in r a a Hi i-'a F' F'a a 0 it 0 in it 4 Hi H a a a a a-'a C' , 0 F'a 0 HHi a H HHa in in 0 a it it it in H Hi HU a `4 it HHo a H0 0 a-' H in in 0 in H En a it `4 ito a P1 in U in P1 in in U `a H a a it , it a it W ø'H-H-n a Hit H a U H ED H HHI--' it in it Hin H0 H`a Ha in it in ` Hi a U a 0 apI 0' a 0' Hi H a 0 1 0 in 0 a 0 iH0 n Hi F-' 0.0 flit HH0 a H0 P1 H 0 nitn it 0' a H in `a 0. 0 it HU Hin · a He HU a H it it Hit H in H-in H H U it in P1 it H in P1 eP1 HH 0 H`0 a it it in `0 in HHH ` a Hi 0 Ha in a i it it En P1 in H`a 0' iv H-in C' it Z 0 H0 H CV it H fi in a U it 0 Hw w-a a in E a H`a a o H o 0 H it `a it H C4 a m it P1 0 U a a in U H-rn ` iv a itH n Hin C' Hin Ha H 4 n a in a a `4 P1 0 U a a it H0 in it a `4 WI it n 0 P1 it t .a --3 · a H Hi P1 `a a a H-a H a E a P1 in H H in a WE U a 4 F'0 H itt H it 0 U Hot i H `a a P1 H `J C Hrt rt hh U) (U H H() ) 0 H0 Hft )J C) 0 rt 0 U) ft pi i U) rt $)J LJ tH- o o Cl Cl CD rt Cl U) CD i Cl (I) ft lH CD ft Pi ft i P) çt C) CD ft H- CD CD CD ht t HM CO i Cl (X) i Cl CD ft H- C) C) CD Hhh H- Hft CD ) h 0 3 tY CD CD U) 5 ) l et HH, H- Pi CD U) H CD Cl t'J 0) CD U) U) U) C)) i CD U) C)) C) Cl Cl H Cl -- - CD TJ U) `ti CD H U] W < LJ 0 i hC H- ft H ft HH 0 H0') b C)) i CD ft CD U) Ft Cl C)) C)) H, tr -< Cl CD 0 S ft ft Q fJ CO · Cl CD CD H- C)) C)) b' 0 Cl --] C) ft U) H- ft tHU) HU) ft CD Cl) U) CD H- 0 0 HH, C)) C) ft C) C) CO H H- C) 0 H H CD CD fr C) · U) f-t U) `-< H- C!) II C)) U) C) 0 CD W 0 i H C) U) ft C)) C) ft f-f 5 0 C) C)f-t Ht0 C)) H ft C)) ft C) b H CD Hft CD ft 0 U) C) - ( `tI N) C) ft H -- 5 CD Cl C)) H Cl CD Hk) N) U] Ft HFt 0 C)) U) J C) 1 `t CD C)) C)) b 0 fJ tJ U] `t3 Li. CD h ft HH, H- h CD CD -- t 0 0 C) CD N) U) C!) H ft H- -- ft C) H 0 U) C!) C) CD Q W -- C) C)j ft Cl -` CD ft C)) CD ft `t1 C)) fI Li. -- 0 ft ft H- C)) ft Cl 0 C)) C) CD H W --` 0 CD U) 0 t-C ft C) -- -- HU C!) CD H C) CD H CD C)) fr C)) ft H- -1 U) ft H- CD ft H Cl CD 0 H ft 0 N) ft H- C)) 0 `d 02 H, CD N) , HH Hf-I`-< H, 0 - ft H- -- C)) ft H tQ 0 0 0 H, C) 0 Pi H, N) 5 f-t CD ft HFt C) CD CD Cl CD C)) U] U U) d 0 0 CD < -- 0 C) CD CD `ti CD ti CD HU) U) ,--, C) H, CJ C)) Cl C)) C)) ft 0 C) Cl U) H C)H- -- Cl -- `-` -j H- C)) U] U] H H HU) ft (1 U) Li CD i--b Ift HU) U) IHU) ft U) HCD ft HCD CD h `-$ H H- ft ft C)) 5 ft CD U) HU) C) 0 H, CD ft Hh Cl CD ft H- CD C)) CD C)) H- -- C) ft C)) ft U) U] CD C)) ft h -- 0 ft l- Cl 0 0 U) H 0 H C)) H C)J tY' HH Hft C) U) CD i Cl CD < -- ft i H CD U) U) L CD 0 ft CD CI U) ft HFt C) I- 0 CD U) CD N) Lf) C) 0 L) C)) C) 0 CD U) C) H< H, HU) ft U) HU) ft 0 h 0 U) H, `-< t-' C) H- C)i C)) C)) H, C)) ft N) CO CD > C) Ht- C) I-j t- -, HH H CD h ft C)) H U] H C)) C!) C)) U) H H, H HU) ft U) H- C)) HC) ft 0 C)tI CD IH C) Ft ` 0 Cl 0 U) C) 0 Cl H- CD C)) 0 H ft H- H ft HU) 0 C) 0 Ft C) 0 Cl H, C) U) ft U) CD H- Cl) C)) () C)) C)) `ti `d CD C) H H- ft C)) U) -Q ft - C) 0 C)) HI--i CD h Cl < CD H HU) U) ft Hft `Ci `Ci 5 CD Cl CD C)) Cl CD ,Q Li ` CO CD U) C)) S 0 H, 0 H U) U) CD C) C)) H (Q C)-' HCD U) C)) ft I-j Ci HU) 02 C)-I < ft H- C CD C) ft 0 0 Cl ft CD HCD CD H HC) C)) i H- C)) S U) i H 0 ft U) ft HN) N) U] ) ft Ci C) b CD H CD CD 0 lj Cl 0 Hi c-t Hi Hi C) CD - lxi $)J d CD rt H- rt CD CD `I C) H- 0 0 0 0 0 0 - CD rr Hct HCl) Hi CD Hi HH CD t `l 0 C) CD Q CD - CD rt 0 P3 Cr CD Cr CD >< CD C) CD hj rt HHi H() P3 CD H - CD Cr HCr 0 Hi HH H LJ Cr H- P3 CD 0 HH Q HCD Cr Cr CD f-r r CD CD CD C) H' Cr P3 0 0 0 HCD Hi Hi HC) HCD P3 Hi 0 Hi J `CI C HCD 0 CD CD H- HCr CD 1 P3 H C) CD i Cr HHi HC) P3 Cr CD HCD CD H- Cr H- - Hi P3 HH CD 1 HHi 0 0 CD CD P3 tQ Cr Cr t3 P3 CD CD P3 P3 CD ct jIxi Cr 13' CD P3 < < P3 < H h 0 P3 13 CD P3 13-' 0 i P3 0 HH Hi 0 Hi Cr CD CD CD P3 CD H P3 P3 0 Cr - P3 13 0 H Cl) CD < Hi P3 HH fl HH HCr CD CD P3 Cr 0 HCD CD Cr 0 CD H P3 tY HH HCr P3 `-1- h CD CD Cr Cr Z HH pJ HH H Cr C) 0 P3 P3 Q 0 HC) H ç-r HCD 0 ç) Q) < IL n l CD I H H H HCD CD CrLxJc, CD Cr P3 HCD CD IY H CD CD Q 11 CD CD Cr CD CD >< Cr j C) 0 P3 CD Cr CD D' 0 0 I Cr P3 CD IC!) IH 10 j Cr HP3 H CD Cr CD tT P3 0 Cr Hi Hj U Cr 3.( P3 Cr Cr to] 11) C) tO] CDlxJ H) HCr 0 Hj CD - CD HCD FCD C) i--J Hi Hj H CD Cr CD 0 Co Co Ui W M (71 j' CD Cr CD CD hj \S - 0 C) -- Hi Cr Co CD 0 ç-t Hi j 1 HCD CD C) j' P3 P3 hI CD tCD CD C) C) ct 0 P3 13' P3 CD CD 0 Li HC) Cr 0 Li P3 LI hI Cr H- 0 hI Cr P3 H t-- Cr H0 CD H C)) LI IC) CD CD CD HP3 H rCi) - j' P3 H H CD IC) CD P3 CD 0

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?