WALKER v. RICCI et al
Filing 2
OPINION. Signed by Judge Peter G. Sheridan on 5/3/10. (DD, )
`1
--
frFt
CD Ft P1 Ft CD CD Ft HclHCD CD CD
Mi HtCD
0 P1
-D
Ft
Ft 51
--
Q H CD C)
Cl-
5
CD H
`--D H
Z
0
C) h
C!) Ft P1 Ft CD
<
CD
j} <
H CD
CD
0 () 0 0 Mi P1
H t')
H HCDr QFtHP1H H-CDFt--Jrt Ft
CD
< p1
CD C)
h-
0
C) cS
p1
CD ><
0
0
r--,
) tJ
<
p1
WhHCii.l<
(Cl ft Hft H-
(Cl p3 Cl]
HCl]
0
fr (Cl
h
--S
0
(Cl (Cl
(Cl Cl] ft
0 C)
ft
(Cl Q Cl
-
(Cl c--)
0
H(Cl
< 0
Cl]
ft
H
0
Pi
ft (Cl
W U] 0
U] ft p3
() 0 Cl
(Cx C) CT) lft (Cl H
Cl (Cl Cl ft P3
0
(Cl < (Cl X
p3 Cl] çt (Cl ft H ft
H-
hC
`Tj IH(Cl
C)
0
i Cl] ft Hçt ft
0
(Cl H0
0
tft
0
H,
p3
(Cl
C
Cl] ft H
P3 -.o
Cx)
C)
t-
P3
H
-- -
(Cl ft
ft (Cl (Cl
--
(Cl ft Hft H-
ft Hp3 H
Cl]
H0
(Cl
-
ft (Cl
0)
`o
pi <
Cl]
o
0
C) (Cl
Cx) W Co
C)
Cl
I--i (Cl (Cl H--
HC)
0
ft
HCl]
Hp3 H
C) 0
Cl) ft H
ft (Cx (Cl M Cl] (Cl
(Cl ft (Cl
o
Q
HM Cx)
c-f Cl) c-I-
(Cl p3
C) H p3 HHç-t
<
-
CD
ft
·
.Q --3 0
H p3
x)
`-0 `-D
--`
0
CD
( Cl <
p3
C])
( Cl
H h
ft
(Cl
H,
p3 ft
H-
p3 H H
<
H Cl]
ft
-< b
(Cl
p3
--)
C)
p3
>< 0
H,
CD U]
C)
P3 ft
ft (Cx · C)
C) H p3 H-
C) H p3 H-
`t) H-
p3 H
C)
<
(Cl
Cl]
--J U] Cl) ft H-
(Cl
P3
(Cl 0
ft
<
(Cl
ft H-
(Cl Cl
ft
C)
H p3 HI-
0
C)
(Cl
Cl]
Cl) ft
h CD
p3 C) ft
P3 tY
CD
i CD
CD
·
0 i
(Cl (Cx
xo
(Cl
CD
H-
I-
ft
Cl 0 CD
(Cx
`tJ ICD
<
S
CD
Cl] ft HCl)
CD
Q
HI-- H-
CD
ft 0
Cl)
H-
Cl
--
0 W CD
H
I-' H,
C) H p3 Hft --
4 C)
H,
CD
5 CD
c
ft
3 i H-
ft
p3 ft CD
--`
HCC Cl]
H-
ft
ft
CD fr
P3 C)
CD
P3 ft CD
I-j
CD
p3 H
CD
C) Cj
ft CD T3
-J H
CD
CD Cl] CD
CD
--
H,
Q
HIIH
P3 H-
CD
0
Hft
p3 ft
CQ
ICD
M I-J U]
0
0
H,
--·
·
H
C) ·
-· C) p3
`-0 CX)
CD $1 CD i
P3 CD
ft CD
5 CD Cl
--
(Cx
C)
--3
h-
H
Cl
-<
Q CD
Cl] P3
<
--
ft 0
p3 HHCl]
--
0
--
C)
`ti
p3 ICl) Cl]
Q
HH CD Cl] ft (Cx CD CD
0
Cl
CD
<
CD
CD CD H-
S
H
0
Cl Hft
0
H,
I-
Cl] CD -
Cl
HCD
P3 i
0 CD
-
H-
P3 ft ft 0 Cl) CD Cl] CD
ft CD
l--
-<
M
tT
Cl] ft HH CD i ft
HCl]
5
U]
CD C) ft
`ZS
P3 ft CD P3 HH p3 p3
CD
lCD
C)
0
`t CD ft Hft
Cl]
H,
U] U]
Cl] ft
S Cl]
Cl
ft
I. b ti
`ti CD
ft H0 HCl]
ft
P3
ft CD
tY `< `t3
C)
(I) `tT Cl] CD
P3 ft CD
H
C CD
--3 U] ·
P3 Cl] Cl]
CD
CD
5
Cl)
co Co
<
0
< · Cl] p3
H CD
C)
P3
C)
ft ft
d CD Hft CD
CD Cl ft 0
<
p3
H0
HH,
CD
H-
0 h'
Cl]
0
CD
0 C)
ft CD
CD
CD
Cl ft
Cl) H,
P3
(Cx Hp3
`< Co o CX)
0
`Ci H HC) p3 CD ft Cl] 0 P3 H 0 Cl] -- Hft
ft CD Cl 0 C)) p3 H H
p3 ft CD
ft P3 ft CD
0
IH-
Cl] CD i ft
H-
ft
H `-0 ft
U
0
Hi HCD
C) 0
()
p3 H-
CD H Hp3
HH,
C) 0
p3 -- W
C) C)
ft Cl)
CD
--C 1
H CD Cl]
Cl
H H Hp3 p3 H H
ft Cl]
Ift Cl]
HCl)
Cl
Cl
`0 a H a fl
Cj
() 0 a a
0,
-
Hi H F-' Hi
a n
P1 it in F-' H E
in
H a S iv `0 iv
Hin 0 it P1 H I.) tj 01
.
o o
H a
in 0 H 0
.
a D
it a a
`
itt F'H
a it U no it orng it it
I-' H
H i--'
H in
a i-i 0 `e a w a
0'
0 F-' O'iv a F'-
a
n
`0 F-' F'0
a
g'
a P1
a
0
0 4 P1
I-'
Hin
U U
a o U Pb a in o'a
it i-' H
Hi Pb F' `0 H a a in fl0 a
1 in
`0
in it a H a in a
H a p D `4
Hi
0 0
HF'-
a
0
in a F-' a 0
,
0 0 a P1 in
it
n
H 0 o' H a
`a
`0 H it a F' 0.0 H-
a
n
0 it
0. in it Pa it a a r iv 0' in in nit P1 n ` a in U a `a a 0 H it
H0 it
n
a
it U a
Pb
22
`0 a it Hit a
0 1 H
in
n
P1 it a
0 0
Hit
H-
0
0
-
4
it H-
`o H 0 .0 0 Ha D 0' g
it
a
-` Pa it at
a
F-'
0
,
U 0 0
H
a
in it
g
a
H H
0 F-' in
0
0
Hin H
a
it P1 Hin HH a
H-
it
H in
Hin
Hin it
a
4 H0 Ct H0
it in
·
a
0
Hi
Hi
a a
a a 0' Ha in
·
U a
in
n
a 0 H in itO U a a
a
0
13 w it
in C Hi Hi no a CI n
·
a F' a H H0
·
I-in
-·
it
U
iv a H Hi F'0' in it a in ` P1 He a o a i-' it tn F-' 1 H H 0 `a a 0 `a I-' a ito a o iv ` a Hi F-''4 H aI-'in `4 0' U; Hin nit HH ,` a 0 in no in a 0 it 4 it in · in Hi U H 1-'it UED in Hi `·` a c iv sa pa o H it `0 a in HPa in E a a n o nit H · 0,0 nit 0 nit o a in r a a Hi i-'a F' F'a a 0 it 0 in it 4 Hi H a a a a a-'a C' , 0 F'a 0 HHi a H HHa in in 0 a it it it in H Hi HU a `4 it HHo a H0 0 a-' H in in 0 in H En a it `4 ito a P1 in U in P1 in in U `a H a a it , it a it W ø'H-H-n a Hit H a U H ED H HHI--' it in it Hin H0 H`a Ha in it in ` Hi a U a 0 apI 0' a 0' Hi H a 0 1 0 in 0 a 0 iH0 n Hi F-' 0.0 flit HH0 a H0 P1 H 0 nitn it 0' a H in `a 0. 0 it HU Hin · a He HU a H it it Hit H in H-in H H U it in P1 it H in P1 eP1 HH 0 H`0 a it it in `0 in HHH ` a Hi 0 Ha in a i it it En P1 in H`a 0' iv H-in C' it Z 0 H0 H CV it H fi in a U it 0 Hw w-a a in E a H`a a o H o 0 H it `a it H C4 a m it P1 0 U a a in U H-rn ` iv a itH n Hin C' Hin Ha H 4 n a in a a `4 P1 0 U a a it H0 in it
a
`4
WI
it n 0
P1 it t
.a --3
·
a H
Hi P1 `a a a H-a H a E a P1 in H H in a WE U a 4 F'0 H itt H it 0 U Hot i H
`a
a
P1 H
`J C
Hrt rt hh
U) (U
H H() )
0 H0
Hft
)J
C) 0
rt
0
U) ft pi i U) rt $)J
LJ
tH-
o o
Cl Cl
CD
rt
Cl
U)
CD i Cl (I)
ft
lH CD
ft
Pi ft i P) çt
C)
CD
ft H-
CD CD
CD
ht t HM CO
i Cl (X) i Cl CD ft
H-
C)
C) CD
Hhh H-
Hft CD
) h
0 3
tY CD CD U)
5
) l
et
HH, H-
Pi
CD
U) H
CD Cl
t'J
0)
CD
U) U) U) C)) i CD U) C)) C)
Cl Cl
H
Cl
--
-
CD TJ U) `ti CD H
U] W
<
LJ
0 i
hC H-
ft
H ft HH
0
H0')
b C)) i CD ft
CD
U) Ft
Cl C))
C))
H,
tr -< Cl
CD
0 S
ft ft Q
fJ CO
·
Cl CD
CD H-
C))
C)) b'
0
Cl
--] C) ft
U) H-
ft
tHU) HU) ft
CD Cl)
U)
CD
H-
0 0
HH,
C)) C)
ft C)
C) CO
H
H-
C) 0
H
H CD CD fr
C)
·
U)
f-t
U)
`-< H-
C!)
II
C))
U)
C)
0
CD
W
0
i H C) U) ft C))
C) ft
f-f
5 0
C) C)f-t Ht0
C)) H
ft
C)) ft C) b
H CD Hft
CD ft
0
U) C)
-
(
`tI
N) C) ft H
--
5 CD Cl
C))
H Cl CD Hk) N) U] Ft HFt
0
C)) U)
J C)
1
`t CD C))
C)) b
0
fJ tJ U]
`t3
Li.
CD h ft HH, H-
h CD
CD
--
t
0 0
C)
CD N) U)
C!)
H
ft H-
-- ft C)
H
0
U)
C!) C)
CD
Q
W
--
C) C)j ft
Cl
-`
CD
ft C)) CD ft `t1 C))
fI
Li.
--
0
ft ft
H-
C)) ft
Cl
0
C)) C)
CD H
W
--`
0 CD U)
0
t-C
ft C) -- --
HU
C!) CD
H C) CD
H CD
C))
fr
C))
ft
H-
-1
U) ft H-
CD
ft
H
Cl CD
0
H
ft
0
N) ft H-
C))
0 `d
02
H,
CD
N)
,
HH Hf-I`-<
H,
0
-
ft H-
-- C))
ft H
tQ 0 0
0
H,
C)
0
Pi
H,
N)
5
f-t
CD
ft
HFt
C)
CD CD Cl
CD
C))
U]
U
U)
d 0
0 CD <
--
0 C)
CD CD
`ti CD
ti
CD HU) U)
,--, C)
H,
CJ C))
Cl
C)) C))
ft
0
C)
Cl U) H C)H-
-- Cl
--
`-`
-j H-
C))
U] U] H H
HU) ft (1 U)
Li
CD
i--b
Ift
HU) U)
IHU) ft U)
HCD ft HCD CD
h `-$
H H-
ft
ft C))
5
ft
CD U)
HU) C)
0
H,
CD ft Hh
Cl CD
ft
H-
CD C)) CD C))
H-
--
C) ft
C))
ft U)
U]
CD
C))
ft
h
--
0
ft
l-
Cl
0 0
U)
H
0
H
C)) H C)J tY' HH Hft
C)
U)
CD
i Cl
CD
<
--
ft
i H CD U) U)
L CD 0
ft CD CI U) ft HFt C)
I-
0
CD U) CD
N) Lf)
C) 0
L)
C)) C) 0
CD U) C)
H< H,
HU) ft U) HU) ft 0 h
0
U)
H,
`-<
t-'
C)
H-
C)i C)) C))
H,
C))
ft N) CO
CD
>
C) Ht-
C)
I-j t-
-,
HH H CD
h
ft
C))
H
U] H
C))
C!)
C))
U)
H
H, H
HU) ft U) H-
C))
HC) ft
0
C)tI CD
IH
C)
Ft
`
0
Cl
0
U)
C) 0 Cl
H-
CD C))
0
H
ft
H-
H
ft HU)
0 C) 0
Ft
C) 0
Cl
H,
C)
U) ft
U)
CD
H-
Cl)
C)) () C))
C)) `ti `d CD C)
H
H-
ft
C)) U)
-Q
ft
-
C) 0 C))
HI--i CD h
Cl
<
CD
H HU)
U)
ft Hft
`Ci
`Ci
5 CD Cl CD
C)) Cl CD ,Q
Li
`
CO
CD
U)
C))
S 0
H,
0
H
U) U) CD
C)
C))
H
(Q
C)-'
HCD U)
C))
ft
I-j
Ci
HU)
02
C)-I <
ft H-
C
CD
C) ft
0
0 Cl
ft CD HCD CD
H HC)
C))
i
H-
C)) S
U)
i H
0
ft
U) ft HN) N) U] ) ft
Ci
C)
b
CD
H
CD
CD
0
lj
Cl
0 Hi c-t Hi Hi C) CD
-
lxi $)J
d CD rt H-
rt
CD CD `I
C)
H-
0 0 0 0 0 0
-
CD rr Hct HCl) Hi CD Hi
HH CD
t `l 0 C) CD Q CD
-
CD
rt
0 P3
Cr CD Cr CD >< CD
C) CD hj rt HHi H()
P3
CD
H
-
CD Cr HCr
0
Hi HH H
LJ
Cr H-
P3 CD
0
HH Q HCD Cr Cr CD f-r r CD CD CD C) H'
Cr
P3 0
0 0
HCD
Hi Hi HC) HCD
P3
Hi
0
Hi J `CI C
HCD
0
CD
CD H-
HCr CD
1
P3 H
C) CD i Cr HHi HC) P3 Cr CD
HCD CD
H-
Cr
H-
-
Hi P3 HH CD 1
HHi
0 0
CD
CD P3 tQ
Cr Cr t3 P3 CD CD P3 P3 CD ct jIxi Cr 13' CD P3
<
< P3
<
H
h
0 P3
13
CD
P3 13-'
0 i P3 0
HH Hi
0
Hi
Cr
CD
CD
CD P3
CD
H
P3 P3
0
Cr
-
P3 13
0
H Cl) CD
<
Hi P3 HH fl
HH HCr
CD
CD P3
Cr
0 HCD
CD Cr
0
CD
H P3 tY HH HCr
P3
`-1-
h CD
CD Cr
Cr
Z
HH
pJ
HH H Cr
C)
0
P3 P3
Q 0
HC)
H ç-r HCD
0
ç) Q)
<
IL n l
CD
I
H H H HCD CD
CrLxJc,
CD
Cr P3
HCD CD IY H
CD CD
Q
11
CD
CD Cr
CD
CD
>< Cr
j
C)
0 P3 CD
Cr CD D'
0 0
I
Cr P3
CD
IC!) IH 10
j Cr HP3 H
CD
Cr
CD tT P3
0 Cr
Hi Hj
U Cr 3.(
P3 Cr
Cr
to]
11) C)
tO]
CDlxJ
H) HCr
0
Hj
CD
-
CD
HCD
FCD C) i--J
Hi Hj
H CD
Cr
CD 0
Co Co Ui W
M (71
j'
CD
Cr
CD
CD
hj
\S
-
0
C)
--
Hi Cr Co CD
0
ç-t Hi
j
1 HCD CD C)
j'
P3 P3
hI CD tCD CD
C) C) ct
0 P3 13' P3 CD
CD
0 Li
HC) Cr
0 Li P3
LI hI Cr H-
0 hI
Cr P3 H
t--
Cr
H0
CD H
C))
LI
IC) CD
CD
CD
HP3 H
rCi)
-
j'
P3 H H CD IC)
CD
P3 CD
0
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.