OCCIDENTAL CHEMICAL CORPORATION v. 21ST CENTURY FOX AMERICA, INC. et al

Filing 2286

SPECIAL MASTER DECISION granting in part and denying in part Small Parties Group's MOTION to Compel Plaintiff's Compliance with Court Order on Remand. Signed by Special Master Thomas P. Scrivo on 2/28/2023. (dam)

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 1 of 167 PageID: 65573

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

OCCIDENTAL CHEMICAL
CORPORATION,

Civil Action No. 18-11273(MCA)(LDW)
DECISION OF SPECIAL MASTER
GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING
IN PART SMALL PARTIES GROUP’S
MOTION TO COMPEL PLAINTIFF’S
COMPLIANCE WITH COURT ORDER
ON REMAND

Plaintiff,
v.
21ST CENTURY FOX AMERICA, INC., et
al.,
Defendants.

INTRODUCTION
This matter comes by way of an Order entered on March 10, 2022, by the Honorable
Madeline Cox Arleo’s (ECF 2005) (“Order on Remand”) remanding to the Special Master the
Small Parties Group’s (“SPG Defendants’”) Motion to Compel (ECF 1091) to determine the
context of documents withheld as privileged from Plaintiff Occidental Chemical Corporation’s
(“OxyChem”) First and Fourth Privilege Logs.
Following the Order on Remand, SPG Defendants filed a Motion for Miscellaneous Relief
(the “Motion”) seeking to compel discovery withheld as privileged from the same privilege logs,
which OxyChem has opposed. SPG Defendants seek an order compelling OxyChem to produce
documents: (1) identified in the privilege logs without an author, sender, recipient and a date;1 (2)
identified on the privilege logs that are not privileged as a result of periods of adversity between
OxyChem and Maxus Energy Corporation (“Maxus”) and Tierra Solutions, Inc. (“Tierra”); and

SPG Defendants assert that it has not received a response to its November Motion (ECF No.
1898). The November Motion seeks identical relief as the Motion and the April 28, 2022 Motion
for Reconsideration and Clarification, previously decided. For this reason, the decisions on the
Motion and the April 28, 2022 Motion, are responsive to the November Motion.
1

1

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 2 of 167 PageID: 65574

(3) referred to as H-2, which consists of a 66-page group of documents, also known as the “VE
Memo” (“VE Memo” or “H-2”). In opposition, OxyChem argues that: (1) the periods of adversity
between OxyChem and Maxus and Tierra ceased before any of the documents were exchanged
and OxyChem, Maxus and Tierra’s interests were all aligned at all relevant times;2 and (2) to the
extent that any privilege of H-2 was waived, H-2 was clawed back in accordance with Fed. R.
Evid. 502(b).
For the reasons set forth herein, SPG Defendants’ Motion is GRANTED IN PART and
DENIED IN PART.
STATEMENT OF PERTINENT FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
A.

Procedural History
On August 10, 2020, SPG Defendants filed a Motion to Compel the production of four

categories of documents withheld as privileged or protected in OxyChem’s First and Fourth
privilege logs. The categories of documents are:
Attached
Exhibit
H-1

H-2

Number of
Documents

Category
Entries from the
Drinker Biddle Log
Entries relating to documents
clawed back by OxyChem that
were previously produced
(also known as the “VE
Memo”)

Basis for Withholding

30,468

Attorney-Client Privilege
and Work Product

66-page
document

Work Product

H-3

Entries for communications with
federal and state regulators

157

Attorney-Client Privilege
and Work Product

H-4

Entries that are undated or
give dates that are inconsistent
with anticipation of litigation

732

Work Product

SPG Defendants’ first argument was separately addressed in the Special Master Decision of July
18, 2022 (ECF 2107).
2

2

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 3 of 167 PageID: 65575

On November 4, 2020, the Special Master issued an interim Order requiring OxyChem to
produce a sampling of documents from its privilege logs for in camera review, including H-2.
On March 18, 2021, the Special Master granted in part and denied in part SPG Defendants’
Motion to Compel, finding that OxyChem properly withheld H-2 (“March 2021 Decision”). The
Special Master found that the documents reflected attorney work product.
On June 29, 2021, the Special Master issued a Final Decision and Order (“June 2021
Order”), pertaining to the Special Master’s in camera review of a sampling of documents from
Exhibits H-1 and H-4, holding that the joint-client privilege and the community-of-interest
doctrine applied. However, not all documents contained in Exhibits H-1 and H-4 were, in fact,
privileged. After a comprehensive in camera review of hundreds of documents contained in
Exhibits H-1 and H-4, the Special Master determined that OxyChem’s privilege logs and
documents were lacking in certain respects.
On July 13, 2021, SPG Defendants appealed, inter alia, the conclusion that any privilege
of the VE Memo has not been waived.
On November 15, 2021, SPG Defendants filed a Motion to Enforce the June 2021 Order,
asserting that OxyChem had still not produced fully responsive logs and many entries failed to
contain an author, sender, recipient and date (“November 2021 Motion to Enforce”).
On March 10, 2022, the Order on Remand was issued, which contained two pertinent
instructions to the Special Master: (1) “to the extent documents were prepared by independent
counsel and the community-of-interest or joint-client privilege does not apply, the Court
remand[ed] to the Special Master to reconsider those documents and make specific findings,” and
(2) “remand[ed] on this issue and instruct[ed] the Special Master to make further factual findings
on the record regarding whether the documents at issue were clawed back in the Spill Act litigation

3

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 4 of 167 PageID: 65576

and, if they were not, whether any privilege is deemed waived as to the documents.” See Order on
Remand at 7 and 10.
On March 25, 2022, the parties met to see if they could agree on reasonable next steps in
light of the Order on Remand.
On April 4, 2022, SPG Defendants filed the Motion. In addition, SPG Defendants sought
briefing on the issues raised in the Order on Remand and suggested that the Special Master perform
an additional in camera review.
On April 19, 2022, the Special Master issued a Decision and Order (“April 2022 Decision”)
granting in part and denying in part SPG Defendants’ November 2021 Motion to Enforce. The
Special Master required OxyChem to produce undated work product as there was no evidence of
a temporal relationship to anticipated litigation.
On April 20, 2022, the parties conferenced with the Special Master. SPG Defendants
argued that there were times in which OxyChem and Maxus were adverse, and production of
documents from times of adversity are necessary. OxyChem, in return, asserted that SPG
Defendants have conceded that OxyChem established the community of interest and joint-client
relationships, and no additional documents need to be produced.
On May 13, 2022, SPG Defendants submitted two briefs in further support of its arguments.
On the same day, OxyChem filed opposition to the Motion. SPG Defendants submitted a reply on
May 27, 2022, and OxyChem opposed the reply on that same date.
B.

The Claw Back of the VE Memo
In the 1980s, the Lower Passaic River and surrounding properties (the “Lower Passaic

River Site”) became the subject of regulatory action by the New Jersey Department of
Environmental Protection (the “NJDEP”) and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (the

4

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 5 of 167 PageID: 65577

“EPA”). The NJDEP reported risks from mercury, copper, and other metals in Passaic River fish
and the presence of polychlorinated biphenyls found in fish tissue. Executive Orders were issued
regarding contamination detected at the Diamond Alkali Superfund Site, which includes the Lower
Passaic River Site and 80-120 Lister Avenue in Newark, New Jersey (the “Lister Site”). In 1984,
the EPA listed the Lower Passaic River Site on the Superfund National Priorities the EPA’s list of
sites of national priority among the known releases or threatened releases of hazardous substances,
pollutants, or contaminants throughout the United States and its territories.
In 1986, the EPA and the NJDEP issued several directives related to investigation and
remediation of the Lister Site, which Tierra and Maxus owned during the relevant period. Around
this same time, OxyChem’s affiliate purchased the stock of Diamond Shamrock Chemicals
Company from Maxus, which operated at the Lister Site. In 1988, the EPA notified OxyChem
that it was a potentially responsible party (“PRP”) under the Comprehensive Environmental
Response, Compensation, and Liability Act and it was to implement remedial action selected by
the EPA in the 1987 Record of Decision for the Lister Site.
In 2005, the NJDEP brought suit against OxyChem, among others, seeking response costs
and other alleged damages in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Essex County, in a matter
captioned New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection v. Occidental Chemical Corp., et
al., Docket No. ESX-L-9868-05 (the “Spill Act Litigation”).
From 1988 to 2016, Maxus, Tierra and OxyChem retained, at various times, the law firms
of Vinson & Elkins, LLP (“Vinson & Elkins”), Andrews & Kurth, LLP (“Andrews & Kurth”), and
Drinker Biddle & Reath, LLP (“Drinker Biddle”) and various consultants to assist in the defense
of regulatory actions and lawsuits against the Lister Site.

5

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 6 of 167 PageID: 65578

Between 2009 and 2012, documents were produced by Maxus in discovery in the Spill Act
Litigation. OxyChem and Maxus were both parties to this litigation. In February 2011, Maxus
produced the VE Memo, consisting of 66 pages of a three-million-page discovery response.
According to the parties, the total discovery produced by Maxus in the Spill Act Litigation was
approximately six million pages. OxyChem asserts that there were layers of protection to prevent
against the disclosure of privileged documents. For instance, on August 11, 2009, the court in the
Spill Act Litigation issued an Agreed Order Regarding Documents Withheld From Production
which detailed an option to claw back inadvertently disclosed documentation pursuant to N.J. Ct.
R. 4:10-2(e)(2). The parties to that litigation were informed that, in the event of inadvertent
disclosure, the parties shall notify all other parties in writing. The parties in receipt of this
documentation were to return, sequester, or destroy the documents promptly on notice. Between
February 2011 and August 2011, Maxus clawed back documents on three occasions, but that did
not include the VE Memo.
Following a production by Maxus in February 2011, OxyChem wrote to Maxus identifying
privileged documents that had been inadvertently disclosed by Maxus, and Maxus confirmed that
it would send a formal clawback letter to all parties. Inexplicably, Maxus did not send a clawback
letter until February 2017, six years later. No action was taken by OxyChem in the interim. Further,
the clawback demand was directed to fourteen counsel of record, rather than counsel for the
hundreds of parties in the Spill Act Litigation. The attorney for the Joint Defense Group (“JDG”),
which was a group of third-party defendants that included many of the current SPG Defendants in
this lawsuit, acknowledged receipt of the clawback request, forwarded same to the member parties,
informed OxyChem that the JDG no longer existed, and asserted that the privilege was likely
waived.

6

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 7 of 167 PageID: 65579

In June 2016, Maxus filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, where it produced documents to
OxyChem. In 2017, in the Bankruptcy Court, Judge Sontchi provided instruction to OxyChem that
it would need to return to New Jersey State Court to claw back the Spill Act production. OxyChem
never returned to the New Jersey State Court to do so.
LEGAL STANDARD
Rule 37 provides that a party may move for an order compelling disclosure or discovery.
FED. R. CIV. P. 37(a)(1). Where the court orders production pursuant to a motion to compel, and
a party fails to obey an order to provide or permit discovery, the court may issue further just orders,
including sanctions. FED. R. CIV. P. 37(b)(2)(A).
Rule 26(b)(1) provides that parties may obtain discovery regarding any non-privileged
matter that is relevant to any party’s claim or defense and proportional needs of the case. See also
W. Elec. Co. v. Stern, 544 F.2d 1196, 1199 (3d Cir. 1976). Rule 26(b)(5) permits a party to
withhold information otherwise discoverable by claiming that the information is privileged or
subject to protection as trial-preparation material. To assert a privilege or protection, the party
must: (i) expressly make the claim; and (ii) describe the nature of the documents, communications,
or tangible things not produced or disclosed—and do so in a manner that, without revealing
information itself privileged or protected, will enable other parties to assess the claim. FED. R. CIV.
P. 26(b)(5)(A). The party asserting a claim of privilege or protection must give notice to the
receiving party that is “as specific as possible in identifying the information and stating the basis
for the claim.” FED. R. CIV. P. 26, Advisory Committee Note to Subdivision (b)(5). The notice
“should be sufficiently detailed so as to enable the receiving party and the court to understand the
basis for the claim and to determine whether waiver has occurred.” Id. Accordingly, the party
asserting a privilege or protection bears the burden of establishing its applicability on a document-

7

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 8 of 167 PageID: 65580

by-document basis. United States v. Rockwell Int’l, 897 F.2d 1255, 1265 (3d Cir. 1990) (stating
“privilege must be asserted” on “document-by–document” basis); In re Human Tissue Prod. Liab.
Litig., 255 F.R.D. 151, 163 (D.N.J. 2008) (same).
Rule 502(b) of the Federal Rules of Evidence governs the disclosure of privileged
information. When made in a federal proceeding or to a federal office or agency, the disclosure
does not operate as a waiver if: (1) the disclosure is inadvertent; (2) the holder of the privilege or
protection took reasonable steps to prevent disclosure; and (3) the holder promptly took reasonable
steps to rectify the error, including (if applicable). FED. R. EVID. 502. The parties cite to differing
standards for the disclosure of privileged communications: Gloucester Twp. Hous. Auth. V.
Franklin Square Assocs., 38 F. Supp. 3d 492, 496-97 (D.N.J. 2014) and In re Teleglobe
Communications Corp., 493 F.3d 345, 379 (3d Cir. 2007).
In re Teleglobe is the standard that applies to joint-client privilege and the community-ofinterest doctrine (“COI”), whereas Gloucester is the standard for inadvertent disclosure. The
burden of proof for the privilege, its waiver and COI is:
The parties dispute whose burden it is to establish that the COI doctrine
applies. This analysis is not difficult. It is well-established that the party seeking
protection because of the work-product doctrine has the burden of proof. . .
Thereafter, the party asserting that the protection was waived has the burden of
proof. . . Plaintiff satisfied this burden by showing that defendants exchanged workproduct protected documents. Thereafter, the party denying waiver has the burden
to show that the COI doctrine applies.
McLane Foodservice, Inc. v. Ready Pac Produce, Inc., No. 10-6076 (RMB/JS),
2012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 76343, at *10 (D.N.J. June 1, 2012).

8

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 9 of 167 PageID: 65581

ANALYSIS
I.

The VE Memo
There is no dispute that the VE Memo is privileged under the work product doctrine.3

Indeed, the Order on Remand only instructs the Special Master “to make further factual findings
on the record regarding whether the documents at issue were clawed back in the Spill Act litigation
and, if they were not, whether any privilege is deemed waived as to the documents.” See Order on
Remand at 10.
a. The VE Memo is Privileged Under the Joint-Client Privilege.
The joint-client privilege may apply when “two or more people consult a single attorney,”
and as co-clients, “convey their desire for representation, and the lawyer consents.” In re
Teleglobe, 493 F.3d at 362-63 (citations omitted). Whether parties have “jointly consulted a lawyer
or merely entered concurrent but separate representations is determined by the understanding of
the parties and the lawyer in light of the circumstances” and must be “distinguished from situations
in which a lawyer represents a single client but another person with allied interests cooperates with
the client and the client’s lawyer.” Graco, Inc. v. Pmc Global, 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 14718, at
*59-60 (D.N.J. Feb. 14, 2011) (citing In re Teleglobe, 493 F.3d at 362; Restatement (Third) of the
Law Governing Lawyers § 75 comment C).
While the joint-client privilege is not necessarily to be applied in every circumstance where
two or more parties are seemingly aligned, if two or more persons are jointly represented by the
same lawyer in a matter, a communication of either co-client that relates to matters of common
interest is privileged as against third persons. See In re Teleglobe, 493 F.3d at 362; see also Graco,

3

See Special Master Decision on SPG Motion to Compel, dated March 18, 2021 (ECF No. 1185)
at 18 (“The documents reflect clear attorney work product, including drafts of documents that were
prepared by counsel, or at the direction of counsel.”)
9

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 10 of 167 PageID: 65582

Inc. v. Pmc Glob., Civil Action No. 08-1304 (FLW), 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 14718, at *61-62
(D.N.J. Feb. 14, 2011). The privilege also requires termination. “In particular, a joint
representation terminates when it becomes clear to all parties that the clients’ legal interests have
diverged too much to justify using common attorneys.” Id.
“The great caveat of the joint-client privilege is that it only protects communications from
compelled disclosure to parties outside the joint representation.” Id. at 366. “When former coclients sue one another, the default rule is that all communications made in the course of the joint
representation are discoverable.” Id. Cross claims do not always create “the requisite adversity to
eviscerate the joint defense privilege.” Resolution Tr. Corp. v. Fid. & Deposit Co., Civ. No. 921003(WHW), 1995 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 21903, at *5-6 (D.N.J. Apr. 27, 1995). Moreover, even if a
cross claim was deemed sufficient, it does not render material subject to the joint-client privilege
universally discoverable, but only discoverable as between the joint clients. Id.
Here, there is no question that there was a joint-representation. The issue for resolution is
whether points of adversity in the relationship between the parties waived the joint-client privilege
as it relates to third-parties. It is clear that OxyChem and Maxus were aligned with their interests
of defense of claims against third-parties prior to and during the Spill Act Litigation. The VE
Memo was created on September 24, 1996, prior to and in anticipation of the Spill Act Litigation,
and contained advice that clearly related to their aligned interests. As the Order on Remand
explains:
[T]o the extent that documents [were] created with respect to
litigation on the cross-claim address an issue on which the parties
have a joint interest—i.e. defending Spill Act litigation and
minimizing liability—those communications may still be protected.
However, communications where the parties are clearly adverse and
share no common legal interest will not be privileged under either
exception. Further review of the documents is necessary to make
that distinction.
10

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 11 of 167 PageID: 65583

[Order on Remand at 7, n.4.]
Accordingly, the VE Memo is privileged under the joint-client privilege.4 To be certain,
the record reveals that the joint-client representation was not expressly terminated by OxyChem
until 2007.
b. The Inadvertent Disclosure by Maxus Did Not Waive OxyChem’s Privilege
SPG Defendants assert that there was a waiver of the privilege in light of the disclosure of
privileged documents in: (1) the Spill Act Litigation in the New Jersey Courts and the failure to
clawback the documents; and (2) the Maxus bankruptcy proceeding. Neither argument has merit
and the SPG Defendants have not carried the burden of showing that OxyChem’s privilege related
to the VE Memo was waived.
The attorney-client privilege protects communications between attorney and client and can
be waived by disclosure. Teleglobe Communs. Corp., 493 F.3d at 359-361. Inadvertent disclosure,
however, does not constitute waiver, if: (1) the disclosure is inadvertent; (2) the holder of the
privilege or protection took reasonable steps to prevent disclosure; and (3) the holder promptly
took reasonable steps to rectify the error, including (if applicable). FED. R. EVID. 502(b); see also
Gloucester Twp. Hous. Auth. v. Franklin Square Assocs., 38 F. Supp. 3d at 496. Here, Maxus
clearly disclosed the VE Memo during the Spill Act Litigation. There were protections in place to
avoid such inadvertent disclosures and notice was ultimately given to the relevant parties, albeit

4

The community-of-interest doctrine only applies when clients are represented by separate
counsel. McLane Foodservice, Inc. v. Ready Pac Produce, Inc., No. 10-6076, 2012 WL 1981559,
at *3-4 (D.N.J. June 1, 2012). The VE Memo is a legal memoranda created by a single counsel
for OxyChem’s and Maxus’s joint defense of the claims in the Spill Act Litigation. Thus, the
community-of-interest privilege is inapplicable to the VE Memo.
11

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 12 of 167 PageID: 65584

not in a timely manner. However, as OxyChem correctly notes, Maxus cannot waive OxyChem’s
joint-client privilege.
It is well-settled that “one co-defendant could not waive the privilege that attached to the
shared information without the consent of all others.” In re Teleglobe Communs. Corp., 493 F.3d
at 379. Indeed, “[w]aiving the joint-client privilege requires the consent of all joint clients.”
Graco, Inc. v. Pmc Glob., Civil Action No. 08-1304 (FLW), 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 14718, at *6162 (D.N.J. Feb. 14, 2011). That Maxus and OxyChem‘s joint-client representation terminated
after the VE Memo was created is of no moment, even when they had direct claims against each
other.

This adversity merely destroys the joint-privilege among and between Maxus and

OxyChem. Resolution, 1995 U.S. Dist. LEXIS at *5-6.
Maxus’s inadvertent disclosure cannot waive OxyChem’s privilege. In fact, OxyChem
explicitly informed Maxus that the documents were disclosed and requested that Maxus claw back
the documents. Despite Maxus’s failure to claw back the documents for years, OxyChem never
consented to the disclosure or the waiver of the privilege.
Finally, the record does not reveal any disclosure in the Maxus bankruptcy of the VE Memo
that would alter this ruling. Indeed, the bankruptcy orders and plans, including the April 17, 2017,
Site Transition Order (“Site Transition Order”) and the July 18, 2017, Consent Order (“July
Order”) confirm that the transition of Maxus documents to OxyChem was done without waiver of
any privilege owned by Maxus or OxyChem.
Accordingly, the Special Master finds that the VE Memo is a document that is privileged
under the joint-client privilege and OxyChem’s privilege has never been waived. Thus, the VE
Memo remains privileged and does not need to be disclosed.

12

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 13 of 167 PageID: 65585

II.

H-1, H-3 and H-4 (“Documents”) for In Camera Review
a.

In Camera Review For A Threshold Finding of Privilege

As described above, the Order on Remand provides: “to the extent documents were
prepared by independent counsel and the community-of-interest or joint-client privilege does not
apply, the Court remand[ed] to the Special Master to reconsider those documents and make
specific findings” See Order on Remand at 7.
The Documents total 31,357 in number. Rather than conduct a full review of the
Documents for privilege, the parties agreed to an in camera review of ten percent (10%) of the
Documents by the Special Master. The Special Master undertook this review to make a threshold
determination if the Documents contained privileged information. The Special Master performed
this review and has created Schedule A, which is appended to this Decision. On Schedule A,
specific documents are labeled to be produced, withheld, or redacted and produced.
Documents that are not privileged on their face should be produced. If the documents are
to be withheld, the Special Master determined that a privilege applied and the document was
properly on the privilege logs. In some instances, redactions are also required if the documents
contain only some privileged information. OxyChem will need to redact the document accordingly
and reproduce the portions of the documents that are not privileged.
When assessing the in camera documents, the Special Master considered: (1) the jointclient privilege and community-of-interest privilege, (2) the work product doctrine, and (3) the
attorney-client privilege.

13

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 14 of 167 PageID: 65586

b.

Withheld Documents
i.

Joint Client Privilege/Community-of-Interest

As discussed above, a joint-client privilege may be waived where there are points of
adversity in the relationship between the parties warranting production. Here, as set forth in
Section 1(b) of this Decision, the Special Master found that there have been points of adversity
between the parties, but the points of adversity have been related to indemnification. The parties
remained aligned in their defense of claims against third parties. According to the SPG Defendants,
the adversity related to cross claims and opposing positions on indemnification between 1995 and
2007. Following the termination of the joint-client privilege, the parties remained adverse through
the Spill Act Litigation. But at the time of Maxus’s Bankruptcy in 2016, the parties were again
aligned in their interests.
The Special Master has reviewed documents for the period of the joint-client privilege with
respect to aligned interests. The Special Master found documents that were privileged under the
joint-client privilege and community-of-interest doctrine because OxyChem and Maxus, through
their various attorneys (Vinson & Elkins, Andrews & Kurth, and Drinker Biddle), shared
communications for a joint interest. The documents in Schedule A designated with these privileges
reflect documents that address an issue in which OxyChem and Maxus were aligned, and either
had the same counsel, or their counsel shared the information, and thus is not subject to disclosure.
ii.

Work Product Privilege

The Special Master also undertook a review to determine whether Maxus waived the
attorney-client privilege or the work product doctrine.
“When the corporation is solvent, the agent that controls the corporate attorney-client
privilege is the corporation’s management. . . [T]his power passes to the trustee because the

14

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 15 of 167 PageID: 65587

trustee’s functions are more closely analogous to those of management outside of bankruptcy than
are the functions of the debtor’s directors.” Commodity Futures Trading Comm'n v. Weintraub,
471 U.S. 343, 356 (1985). “[T]he Liquidating Trust controls the privilege.” In re Hechinger Inv.
Co. of Delaware, 285 B.R. 601, 613 (D. Del. 2002). As set forth separately in Maxus’s bankruptcy,
“[t]he Trust thus obtained whatever documents were then in Maxus’s possession, including the
otherwise privileged documents whose production was ordered in the New Jersey lawsuit.” Maxus
Liquidating Tr. v. YPF S.A. (In re Maxus Energy Corp.), Nos. 16-11501 (CTG), 18-50489 (CTG),
2022 Bankr. LEXIS 3300, at *12 (Bankr. D. Del. Nov. 22, 2022).
Maxus shared the H-1, H-3 and H-4 Documents with OxyChem during Maxus’s
bankruptcy proceeding pursuant to the Site Transition Order and July Order. OxyChem argues that
this negates any finding of waiver relating to the joint-client or community-of-interest privilege.
SPG Defendants argue that the record of adversity between OxyChem and Maxus destroys the
privilege regardless of when the documents were shared.
OxyChem and Maxus were sufficiently adverse from at least April 2007, when OxyChem
terminated the joint representation and hired new counsel shortly thereafter, through the filing of
the Maxus bankruptcy petition on June 17, 2016. During that period, OxyChem and Maxus had
direct claims against each other and OxyChem refused to enter into joint representations.
However, at the time of the transfer of the documents in the bankruptcy filing, OxyChem and
Maxus were no longer adverse. Attorney work product and attorney-client communications of
Maxus and OxyChem were exchanged with the protection of the Site Transition Order, the July
Order and the Maxus Bankruptcy Plan preserving such privileges and affirmatively finding no
waivers. For example, the Maxus Bankruptcy Plan vested Maxus and Tierra’s privilege in the

15

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 16 of 167 PageID: 65588

Maxus Liquidating Trust and provides for non-waiver of privileges. Specifically, the Maxus
Bankruptcy Plan states:
In connection with the Liquidating Trust Assets, any attorneyclient privilege, work product privilege, joint interest privilege
or other privilege or immunity attaching to any documents or
communications (in any form, including, without limitation,
written, electronic or oral) shall be transferred to and shall vest in
the Liquidating Trust. The Liquidating Trust’s receipt of such
privileges associated with the Liquidating Trust Assets shall not
operate as a waiver of those privileges possessed or retained by the
Debtors, nor shall it operate to eliminate the rights of any codefendant to any applicable joint privilege.
[Maxus Bk. Plan, Art. VI.C (emphasis added)]
Specifically, the production of those materials, after the bankruptcy filing, to OxyChem,
was not a production to an adverse party and did not waive any attorney-work product protection.
See Westinghouse Elec. Corp. v. Republic of Phil., 951 F.2d 1414, 1428 (3d Cir. 1991); United
States v. Mass. Inst. of Tech., 129 F.3d 681, 687 (1st Cir. 1997); Planalto v. Ohio Cas. Ins. Co.,
256 F.R.D. 16, 18 (D. Me. 2009) (stating transfer between parties who are no longer adverse—but
once were—does not waive protection).
If Maxus obtained the documents independently, the attorney-client and work product
privileges remain with those documents. Maxus transferred the Documents to OxyChem pursuant
to the Bankruptcy Order, which had non-waiver provisions. While the Order on Remand required
consideration of the Documents’ context to determine the applicability of the joint-client privilege
and the community-of-interest doctrine, the Special Master’s review must also consider whether
the documents retained Maxus’s attorney-client privilege and the work product doctrine after they
were provided to OxyChem. The Special Master finds that the work product privilege remained
with the documents shared by Maxus in the Bankruptcy Proceeding and has considered this in its
review.
16

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 17 of 167 PageID: 65589

Under Rule 26(b)(3), the work product doctrine protects “documents and tangible things
that are prepared in anticipation of litigation or for trial by or for another party or its
representative.” FED. R. CIV. P. 26(b)(3)(A). Work product is defined as materials in anticipation
of litigation, including mental impressions, legal theories, opinions, conclusions, litigation
strategy, and other similar materials. See FED. R. CIV. P. 26(b)(3)(B). Documents that are routinely
prepared in the ordinary course of business are outside the scope of work product protection. See
In re Gabapentin Litig., 214 F.R.D. 179, 184 (D.N.J. 2003).
The lynchpin for the application of the work product doctrine is the phrase “in anticipation
of litigation.” Maertin v. Armstrong World Indus., 172 F.R.D. 143, 148 (D.N.J. 1997). To meet
this standard, the party must show more than a “remote prospect” or “likely chance of litigation.”
In re Gabapentin Litig., 214 F.R.D. at 183. It must be shown that “the document can fairly be said
to have been prepared or obtained because of the prospect of litigation” given the nature of the
document and factual situation of the particular case. Maertin, 172 F.R.D. at 148; see also In re
Gabapentin Litig., 214 F.R.D. at 184 (stating whether document is protected by work product
doctrine depends on reason or purpose for documents creation”).
Here, some of the in camera documents were created by in-house counsel, outside counsel
and consultants that were clearly work product created in anticipation of litigation. For others, the
Special Master could not determine whether the document was produced in the ordinary course of
business or created in anticipation of litigation. Schedule A contains the Special Master’s findings
based on the face of the documents and direct that those covered by the work product privilege be
withheld from disclosure as there was no waiver of such privilege.

17

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 18 of 167 PageID: 65590

iii.

Attorney-Client Privilege

The attorney-client privilege is the oldest of the common-law privileges. Like all
privileges, it is an exception to the common-law maxim that the public has a right to every man's
evidence. Teleglobe Communs. Corp., 493 F.3d at 359-60 (internal citations omitted). “As the
Supreme Court has noted more recently, the purpose of the attorney-client privilege is to encourage
full and frank communication between attorneys and their clients and thereby promote broader
public interests in the observance of law and administration of justice.” Id. (quoting Upjohn Co. v.
United States, 449 U.S. 383, 389, 101 S. Ct. 677, 66 L. Ed. 2d 584 (1981)).
As discussed above, any existing privilege remained with the documents through the
transfer of Maxus’s documents in bankruptcy. The Special Master conducted an in camera review
of the sample documents for attorney-client privilege. Some of the documents consisted of
communications with in-house or outside counsel seeking legal advice, while others consisted of
internal communications without attorneys. Schedule A contains the Special Master’s
determination as to the applicability of the attorney-client privilege to the documents reviewed and
directs that those containing attorney-client privileged communications be withheld.
III.

CONCLUSION
Accordingly, the Motion for production of documents is hereby GRANTED IN PART

and DENIED IN PART. After review of the in camera documents, the Special Master has listed
in Schedule A whether the documents require production or may be withheld. This Decision
applies only to the documents reviewed in camera. The Special Master will conduct a conference
with the parties to discuss how to proceed for the remainder of the documents from H-1, H-3, and
H-4. The Special Master will not conduct this conference with the parties until the resolution of
the SPG Defendants’ Motion for Leave to File an Unopposed Motion for a Stay.

18

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 19 of 167 PageID: 65591

Dated: February 28, 2023

/s/ Thomas P. Scrivo
THOMAS P. SCRIVO
Special Master

19

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 20 of 167 PageID: 65592
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv000044
MaxPriv000050
MaxPriv000057
MaxPriv000097
MaxPriv000109
MaxPriv000129
MaxPriv000135
MaxPriv000301
MaxPriv000312
MaxPriv000532
MaxPriv000639
MaxPriv000672
MaxPriv000673
MaxPriv000677
MaxPriv000876
MaxPriv000878
MaxPriv000881
MaxPriv000882
MaxPriv000883
MaxPriv000887
MaxPriv000888
MaxPriv000939
MaxPriv000993
MaxPriv001005
MaxPriv001007
MaxPriv001009
MaxPriv001017

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv001146

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 1 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 21 of 167 PageID: 65593
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv001150
MaxPriv001152
MaxPriv001161
MaxPriv001261
MaxPriv001816
MaxPriv001829
MaxPriv001830
MaxPriv002288
MaxPriv002338
MaxPriv002378
MaxPriv002911
MaxPriv002961
MaxPriv003036
MaxPriv003037
MaxPriv003038
MaxPriv003039
MaxPriv003040
MaxPriv003041
MaxPriv003049
MaxPriv003050
MaxPriv003052
MaxPriv003053
MaxPriv003055
MaxPriv003056
MaxPriv003068
MaxPriv003102
MaxPriv003103
MaxPriv003104
MaxPriv004180

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 2 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 22 of 167 PageID: 65594
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv004272
MaxPriv004297
MaxPriv004356
MaxPriv004503
MaxPriv004654
MaxPriv004661
MaxPriv004674
MaxPriv004695
MaxPriv004797
MaxPriv005453
MaxPriv006085
MaxPriv006086
MaxPriv006089
MaxPriv006092
MaxPriv006140
MaxPriv006142
MaxPriv006158
MaxPriv006176
MaxPriv006186
MaxPriv006187
MaxPriv006188
MaxPriv006189
MaxPriv006191
MaxPriv006192
MaxPriv006244
MaxPriv006245
MaxPriv006271
MaxPriv006272
MaxPriv006285

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including outside counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Page 3 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 23 of 167 PageID: 65595
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv006300
MaxPriv006303
MaxPriv006305
MaxPriv006313
MaxPriv006316
MaxPriv006317
MaxPriv006326
MaxPriv006327
MaxPriv006328
MaxPriv006333
MaxPriv006334
MaxPriv006335
MaxPriv006336
MaxPriv006337
MaxPriv006361
MaxPriv006388
MaxPriv006395
MaxPriv006418
MaxPriv006422
MaxPriv006424
MaxPriv006443
MaxPriv006446
MaxPriv006509
MaxPriv006511
MaxPriv006647
MaxPriv006649
MaxPriv006651
MaxPriv006653
MaxPriv006656

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Work Product Privilege

Page 4 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 24 of 167 PageID: 65596
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv006662
MaxPriv006666
MaxPriv006667
MaxPriv006671
MaxPriv006672
MaxPriv006675
MaxPriv006676
MaxPriv006700
MaxPriv006722
MaxPriv006723
MaxPriv006724
MaxPriv006725
MaxPriv006726
MaxPriv006729
MaxPriv006730
MaxPriv006731
MaxPriv006734
MaxPriv006735
MaxPriv006741
MaxPriv006743
MaxPriv006744
MaxPriv006746
MaxPriv006747
MaxPriv006748
MaxPriv006756
MaxPriv006757
MaxPriv006805
MaxPriv006903
MaxPriv006908

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Page 5 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 25 of 167 PageID: 65597
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv006950
MaxPriv006955
MaxPriv006967
MaxPriv006971
MaxPriv006981
MaxPriv007000
MaxPriv007012
MaxPriv007053
MaxPriv007094
MaxPriv007112
MaxPriv007146
MaxPriv007239
MaxPriv007252
MaxPriv007261
MaxPriv007264
MaxPriv007267
MaxPriv007268
MaxPriv007269
MaxPriv007270
MaxPriv007273
MaxPriv007275
MaxPriv007280
MaxPriv007286
MaxPriv007289
MaxPriv007290
MaxPriv007297
MaxPriv007298
MaxPriv007299
MaxPriv007300

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Page 6 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 26 of 167 PageID: 65598
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv007301
MaxPriv007303
MaxPriv007304
MaxPriv007308
MaxPriv007314
MaxPriv007315
MaxPriv007317
MaxPriv007318
MaxPriv007319
MaxPriv007321
MaxPriv007322
MaxPriv007323
MaxPriv007324
MaxPriv007325
MaxPriv007326
MaxPriv007327
MaxPriv007335
MaxPriv007337
MaxPriv007370
MaxPriv007372
MaxPriv007392
MaxPriv007393
MaxPriv007506
MaxPriv007536
MaxPriv007694

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv007902
MaxPriv007941
MaxPriv007944
MaxPriv008075

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 7 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 27 of 167 PageID: 65599
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv008076
MaxPriv008078
MaxPriv008079
MaxPriv008484
MaxPriv008608
MaxPriv008733
MaxPriv008801
MaxPriv009005
MaxPriv009010
MaxPriv009013
MaxPriv009067
MaxPriv009069
MaxPriv009170
MaxPriv009223
MaxPriv009484
MaxPriv009485

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Redactions Needed then
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv009607

Withhold

MaxPriv009608
MaxPriv009630
MaxPriv009631
MaxPriv009632
MaxPriv009633
MaxPriv010112
MaxPriv010113
MaxPriv010114
MaxPriv011899

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 8 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 28 of 167 PageID: 65600
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv011925

Withhold

MaxPriv011968

Withhold

MaxPriv012250

Withhold

MaxPriv012262

Withhold

MaxPriv012266
MaxPriv012287

Withhold
Redactions Needed then
Produce

MaxPriv012365

Withhold

MaxPriv012390

Withhold

MaxPriv012393

Withhold

MaxPriv012401

Withhold

MaxPriv012409

Withhold

MaxPriv012418

Withhold

MaxPriv012431

Withhold

MaxPriv012434

Withhold

MaxPriv012436

Withhold

MaxPriv012440
MaxPriv012447

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including outside counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 9 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 29 of 167 PageID: 65601
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv012451
MaxPriv012452

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv012460

Withhold

MaxPriv012466
MaxPriv012496

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv012615

Withhold

MaxPriv012623

Withhold

MaxPriv012627

Withhold

MaxPriv013302
MaxPriv013303

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv013339

Withhold

MaxPriv013340

Withhold

MaxPriv013369

Withhold

MaxPriv013373
MaxPriv013634
MaxPriv013635
MaxPriv013652
MaxPriv013656
MaxPriv013668
MaxPriv013741

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice

Page 10 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 30 of 167 PageID: 65602
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv013757
MaxPriv013759
MaxPriv013778
MaxPriv013795
MaxPriv013797
MaxPriv013798
MaxPriv013799
MaxPriv013800
MaxPriv013804
MaxPriv013830
MaxPriv013907
MaxPriv013912
MaxPriv013969
MaxPriv013989
MaxPriv014008
MaxPriv014010
MaxPriv014012
MaxPriv014024
MaxPriv014036
MaxPriv014119

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv014455

Withhold

MaxPriv014456

Withhold

MaxPriv014459
MaxPriv014573
MaxPriv014658

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv014667

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 11 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 31 of 167 PageID: 65603
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv014670
MaxPriv014849

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv014894

Withhold

MaxPriv014897
MaxPriv014910

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv014914
MaxPriv014924

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv014930

Withhold

MaxPriv014933

Withhold

MaxPriv014948

Withhold

MaxPriv014949
MaxPriv014984
MaxPriv015011
MaxPriv015012

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv015023
MaxPriv015032

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv015053

Withhold

MaxPriv015076
MaxPriv015153
MaxPriv015266
MaxPriv015373

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 12 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 32 of 167 PageID: 65604
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv015455

Privilege Designation
Redactions Needed then
Produce

MaxPriv015465
MaxPriv015471
MaxPriv015474

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv015483
MaxPriv015670
MaxPriv015671
MaxPriv015673
MaxPriv015674

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv015682

Withhold

MaxPriv015690

Withhold

MaxPriv015692

Withhold

MaxPriv015693

Withhold

MaxPriv015695
MaxPriv015734

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv015735

Withhold

MaxPriv015736

Withhold

MaxPriv015739

Withhold

MaxPriv015740

Withhold

MaxPriv015744

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 13 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 33 of 167 PageID: 65605
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv015851
MaxPriv015921
MaxPriv016006

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv016378

Withhold

MaxPriv016379
MaxPriv016380
MaxPriv016381

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv016382

Withhold

MaxPriv016383

Withhold

MaxPriv016386

Withhold

MaxPriv016389

Withhold

MaxPriv016390

Withhold

MaxPriv016396

Withhold

MaxPriv016400

Withhold

MaxPriv016404

Withhold

MaxPriv016407

Withhold

MaxPriv016430

Withhold

MaxPriv016435

Withhold

MaxPriv016436

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 14 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 34 of 167 PageID: 65606
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv016440

Withhold

MaxPriv016444

Withhold

MaxPriv016453

Withhold

MaxPriv016458

Withhold

MaxPriv016461

Withhold

MaxPriv016462

Withhold

MaxPriv016464
MaxPriv016466
MaxPriv016468
MaxPriv016469

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv016474

Withhold

MaxPriv016476

Withhold

MaxPriv016491

Withhold

MaxPriv016492
MaxPriv016494

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv016495

Withhold

MaxPriv016496

Withhold

MaxPriv016504

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 15 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 35 of 167 PageID: 65607
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv016516

Withhold

MaxPriv016517
MaxPriv016519

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv016520

Withhold

MaxPriv016523

Withhold

MaxPriv016528

Withhold

MaxPriv016529

Withhold

MaxPriv016530

Withhold

MaxPriv016560

Withhold

MaxPriv016562

Withhold

MaxPriv016564
MaxPriv016566

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv016567

Withhold

MaxPriv016571

Withhold

MaxPriv016614
MaxPriv016622
MaxPriv016717

Withhold
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv016718
MaxPriv016773

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege

Page 16 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 36 of 167 PageID: 65608
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv016995

Withhold

MaxPriv017175

Withhold

MaxPriv017219

Withhold

MaxPriv017220

Withhold

MaxPriv017221

Withhold

MaxPriv017223

Withhold

MaxPriv017233

Withhold

MaxPriv017428

Withhold

MaxPriv017538

Withhold

MaxPriv017748
MaxPriv018317

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv018322

Withhold

MaxPriv018327

Withhold

MaxPriv018331

Withhold

MaxPriv018466

Withhold

MaxPriv018506

Withhold

MaxPriv018630

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 17 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 37 of 167 PageID: 65609
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv018809

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv018835

Withhold
Redactions Needed then
Produce

MaxPriv018957

Withhold

MaxPriv018962

Withhold

MaxPriv018999

Withhold

MaxPriv019000

Withhold

MaxPriv019197

Withhold

MaxPriv019201

Withhold

MaxPriv019216

Withhold

MaxPriv019663

Withhold

MaxPriv019682

Withhold

MaxPriv019720

Withhold

MaxPriv019724

Withhold

MaxPriv019726

Withhold

MaxPriv019766
MaxPriv019876

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv019905

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including outside counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Page 18 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 38 of 167 PageID: 65610
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv019912
MaxPriv019917
MaxPriv020010
MaxPriv020023
MaxPriv020027

MaxPriv020173

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Redactions Needed then
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Withhold

MaxPriv020174

Withhold

MaxPriv020175

Withhold

MaxPriv020197

Withhold

MaxPriv020205

Withhold

MaxPriv020207

Withhold

MaxPriv020484

Withhold

MaxPriv020522

Withhold

MaxPriv020523

Withhold

MaxPriv020541

Withhold

MaxPriv020802

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including outside counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 19 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 39 of 167 PageID: 65611
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv020827

Withhold

MaxPriv020828

Withhold

MaxPriv020841

Withhold

MaxPriv020895

Withhold

MaxPriv020923

Withhold

MaxPriv020931

Withhold

MaxPriv020965
MaxPriv020999
MaxPriv021098

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv021229

Withhold

MaxPriv021342

Withhold

MaxPriv021391

Withhold

MaxPriv021403

Withhold

MaxPriv021439

Withhold

MaxPriv021440

Withhold

MaxPriv021482

Withhold

MaxPriv021483

Withhold

MaxPriv021523

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 20 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 40 of 167 PageID: 65612
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv021849

Privilege Designation
Produce

MaxPriv021871
MaxPriv021911
MaxPriv021937

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv021981

Withhold

MaxPriv022155

Withold

MaxPriv022218

Withhold

MaxPriv022219

Withhold

MaxPriv022220

Withhold

MaxPriv022229

Withhold

MaxPriv022283

Withhold

MaxPriv022284

Withhold

MaxPriv022288

Withhold

MaxPriv022297

Withhold

MaxPriv022298

Withhold

MaxPriv022304
MaxPriv022311
MaxPriv022312

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv022316

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including outside counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including outside counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including outside counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 21 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 41 of 167 PageID: 65613
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv022343
MaxPriv022349

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv022351
MaxPriv022362
MaxPriv022380
MaxPriv022391
MaxPriv022429
MaxPriv022464
MaxPriv022467

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv022474

Withhold

MaxPriv022512

Withhold

MaxPriv022561
MaxPriv022567
MaxPriv022569
MaxPriv022574

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv022601

Withhold

MaxPriv022605

Withhold

MaxPriv022606
MaxPriv022638

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv022651

Withhold

MaxPriv022666
MaxPriv022683
MaxPriv022685

Withhold
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including outside counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 22 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 42 of 167 PageID: 65614
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv022697
MaxPriv022698
MaxPriv022700
MaxPriv022701
MaxPriv022720
MaxPriv022725

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv022740

Withhold

MaxPriv022759
MaxPriv022762
MaxPriv022764
MaxPriv022766

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv022770

Withhold

MaxPriv022772

Withhold

MaxPriv022773
MaxPriv022774

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv022776
MaxPriv022779
MaxPriv022790
MaxPriv022806

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv022843

Withhold

MaxPriv022844

Withhold

MaxPriv022846

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Joint-Client/Community-of-Interest Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 23 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 43 of 167 PageID: 65615
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv022848

Withhold

MaxPriv022880
MaxPriv022889
MaxPriv022890

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv023051

Withhold

MaxPriv023096

Withhold

MaxPriv023101

Withhold

MaxPriv023122

Withhold

MaxPriv023123

Withhold

MaxPriv023161

Withhold

MaxPriv023174
MaxPriv023183
MaxPriv023191
MaxPriv023194
MaxPriv023195

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv023225
MaxPriv023226

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv023279
MaxPriv023295
MaxPriv023297

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv023299

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 24 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 44 of 167 PageID: 65616
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv023449

Privilege Designation
Produce

MaxPriv023450

Withhold

MaxPriv023550

Withhold

MaxPriv023552
MaxPriv023553

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv023556

Withhold

MaxPriv023557

Withhold

MaxPriv023560

Withhold

MaxPriv023561

Withhold

MaxPriv023564

Withhold

MaxPriv023566

Withhold

MaxPriv023587

Withhold

MaxPriv023596

Withhold

MaxPriv023615
MaxPriv023628
MaxPriv023646

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv023657

Withhold

MaxPriv023675

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 25 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 45 of 167 PageID: 65617
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv023676

Withhold

MaxPriv023763

Withhold

MaxPriv023764

Withhold

MaxPriv023765

Withhold

MaxPriv023771

Withhold

MaxPriv023777

Withhold

MaxPriv023978

Withhold

MaxPriv024120

Withhold

MaxPriv024201
MaxPriv024252

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv024320

Withhold

MaxPriv024351

Withhold

MaxPriv024381

Withhold

MaxPriv024497

Withhold

MaxPriv024500

Withhold

MaxPriv024763
MaxPriv024794

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv024800

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 26 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 46 of 167 PageID: 65618
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv024835

Withhold

MaxPriv024879
MaxPriv025346

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv025917

Withhold

MaxPriv026273

Withhold

MaxPriv026303

Withhold

MaxPriv026307

Withhold

MaxPriv026308

Withhold

MaxPriv026313

Withhold

MaxPriv026425

Withhold

MaxPriv026431

Withhold

MaxPriv026576

Withhold

MaxPriv026577

Withhold

MaxPriv026582

Withhold

MaxPriv026584

Withhold

MaxPriv026621

Withhold

MaxPriv026622

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 27 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 47 of 167 PageID: 65619
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv026702

Withhold

MaxPriv026837

Withhold

MaxPriv027180

Withhold

MaxPriv027200

Withhold

MaxPriv027217

Withhold

MaxPriv027226

Withhold

MaxPriv027324

Withhold

MaxPriv027326

Withhold

MaxPriv027331

Withhold

MaxPriv027344

Withhold

MaxPriv027357

Withhold

MaxPriv027372

Withhold

MaxPriv027411

Withhold

MaxPriv027528

Withhold

MaxPriv027552

Withhold

MaxPriv027556

Withhold

MaxPriv027574

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 28 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 48 of 167 PageID: 65620
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv027594

Withhold

MaxPriv027701

Withhold

MaxPriv027853

Withhold

MaxPriv028066

Withhold

MaxPriv028242

Withhold

MaxPriv028245

Withhold

MaxPriv028249

Withhold

MaxPriv028294

Withhold

MaxPriv028326

Withhold

MaxPriv028328

Withhold

MaxPriv028720

Withhold

MaxPriv028743

Withhold

MaxPriv028748

Withhold

MaxPriv028818

Withhold

MaxPriv028838

Withhold

MaxPriv028846

Withhold

MaxPriv028856

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 29 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 49 of 167 PageID: 65621
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv028874

Withhold

MaxPriv029082

Withhold

MaxPriv029095

Withhold

MaxPriv029140

Withhold

MaxPriv029177
MaxPriv029221

Withhold
Redactions Needed then
Produce

MaxPriv029226
MaxPriv029289

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv029299

Withhold

MaxPriv029300

Withhold

MaxPriv029314

Withhold

MaxPriv029408

Withhold

MaxPriv029409
MaxPriv029459
MaxPriv029484

Withhold
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv029603

Withhold

MaxPriv029626

Withhold

MaxPriv029729

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 30 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 50 of 167 PageID: 65622
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv029751

Withhold

MaxPriv029788

Withhold

MaxPriv029850
MaxPriv029901
MaxPriv029918

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv029921
MaxPriv029936

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv029938
MaxPriv029941

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv030097

Withhold

MaxPriv030103

Withhold

MaxPriv030124

Withhold

MaxPriv030126

Withhold

MaxPriv030129

Withhold

MaxPriv030292

Withhold

MaxPriv030296

Withhold

MaxPriv030312

Withhold

MaxPriv030324

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 31 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 51 of 167 PageID: 65623
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv030340

Withhold

MaxPriv030431

Withhold

MaxPriv030442
MaxPriv030444
MaxPriv030448

Withhold
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv030459

Withhold

MaxPriv030467
MaxPriv030506
MaxPriv030543

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv030625

Withhold

MaxPriv030632

Withhold

MaxPriv030743

Withhold

MaxPriv030744

Withhold

MaxPriv030937

Withhold

MaxPriv030994

Withhold

MaxPriv031020

Withhold

MaxPriv031225

Withhold

MaxPriv031226

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Joint-Client/Community-of-Interest Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 32 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 52 of 167 PageID: 65624
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv031342
MaxPriv031363

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv031402

Withhold

MaxPriv031508

Withhold

MaxPriv031628

Withhold

MaxPriv031631

Withhold

MaxPriv031683

Withhold

MaxPriv031779

Withhold

MaxPriv031932

Withhold

MaxPriv031975

Withhold

MaxPriv032172

Withhold

MaxPriv032188

Withhold

MaxPriv032189

Withhold

MaxPriv032194

Withhold

MaxPriv032196
MaxPriv032246

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv032279

Withhold

MaxPriv032293

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Joint-Client/Community-of-Interest Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 33 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 53 of 167 PageID: 65625
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv032361

Withhold

MaxPriv032625

Withhold

MaxPriv032659

Withhold

MaxPriv032700

Withhold

MaxPriv032785
MaxPriv032826
MaxPriv032831
MaxPriv032834
MaxPriv032868

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv032882

Withhold

MaxPriv032897

Withhold

MaxPriv032938

Withhold

MaxPriv033020

Withhold

MaxPriv033084

Withhold

MaxPriv033260

Withhold

MaxPriv033261

Withhold

MaxPriv033268

Withhold

MaxPriv033422

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 34 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 54 of 167 PageID: 65626
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv033458

Withhold

MaxPriv033499

Withhold

MaxPriv033539

Withhold

MaxPriv033582

Withhold

MaxPriv033592

Withhold

MaxPriv033631
MaxPriv033702

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv033723
MaxPriv033729

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv033779

Withhold

MaxPriv033797
MaxPriv033815

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv033816
MaxPriv034039
MaxPriv034042
MaxPriv034044

Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv034172

Withhold

MaxPriv034211

Withhold

MaxPriv034213

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 35 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 55 of 167 PageID: 65627
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv034239
MaxPriv034249
MaxPriv034254
MaxPriv034259
MaxPriv034269
MaxPriv034274
MaxPriv034291
MaxPriv034305
MaxPriv034308
MaxPriv034309
MaxPriv034311
MaxPriv034312
MaxPriv034330

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv034439

Withhold

MaxPriv034445
MaxPriv034467
MaxPriv034495

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv034559

Withhold

MaxPriv034574

Withhold

MaxPriv034583
MaxPriv034586
MaxPriv034589

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv034590
MaxPriv034592

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 36 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 56 of 167 PageID: 65628
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv034609

Privilege Designation
Produce

MaxPriv034614
MaxPriv034631
MaxPriv034636

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv034638
MaxPriv034652
MaxPriv034655
MaxPriv034669
MaxPriv034670
MaxPriv034677
MaxPriv034680
MaxPriv034681

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv034695
MaxPriv034696
MaxPriv034698
MaxPriv034704

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv034710
MaxPriv034715
MaxPriv034733

Withhold
Redactions Needed then
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv034764

Withhold

MaxPriv034765

Withhold

MaxPriv034767

Withhold

MaxPriv034770

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 37 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 57 of 167 PageID: 65629
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv034771
MaxPriv034772
MaxPriv034935

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv035007
MaxPriv035108
MaxPriv035111
MaxPriv035125

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv035138

Withhold

MaxPriv035141
MaxPriv035155
MaxPriv035156
MaxPriv035158
MaxPriv035163

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv035168
MaxPriv035170
MaxPriv035192
MaxPriv035272

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv035287
MaxPriv035293

Withhold
Redactions Needed then
Produce

MaxPriv035315
MaxPriv035372
MaxPriv035394
MaxPriv035402

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 38 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 58 of 167 PageID: 65630
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv035404

Privilege Designation
Produce

MaxPriv035414
MaxPriv035420
MaxPriv035436
MaxPriv035497
MaxPriv035501
MaxPriv035585
MaxPriv035604
MaxPriv035605

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv035609
MaxPriv035611
MaxPriv035785
MaxPriv035788
MaxPriv035801

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv035862
MaxPriv035863

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv035902

Withhold

MaxPriv035904

Withhold

MaxPriv035906

Withhold

MaxPriv035907

Withhold

MaxPriv035912

Withhold

MaxPriv035913

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 39 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 59 of 167 PageID: 65631
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv035979

Withhold

MaxPriv035985
MaxPriv035987
MaxPriv035994
MaxPriv036008
MaxPriv036009
MaxPriv036054
MaxPriv036133
MaxPriv036225
MaxPriv036266
MaxPriv036267
MaxPriv036271
MaxPriv036328
MaxPriv036363
MaxPriv036590
MaxPriv036591
MaxPriv036593
MaxPriv036599
MaxPriv036608
MaxPriv036610
MaxPriv036620
MaxPriv036623
MaxPriv036666
MaxPriv036714
MaxPriv036805
MaxPriv036828

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv036877

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 40 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 60 of 167 PageID: 65632
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv037011
MaxPriv037014

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv037025

Withhold

MaxPriv037061
MaxPriv037142
MaxPriv037143
MaxPriv037146
MaxPriv037216
MaxPriv037277
MaxPriv037406
MaxPriv037407

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv037476
MaxPriv037496

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv037512
MaxPriv037579
MaxPriv037635
MaxPriv037673
MaxPriv037745
MaxPriv037752
MaxPriv037770
MaxPriv037793

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv037801

Withhold

MaxPriv037906
MaxPriv037971
MaxPriv038017

Withhold
Produce
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Page 41 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 61 of 167 PageID: 65633
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv038156
MaxPriv038306
MaxPriv038389

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv038408
MaxPriv038410

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv038462
MaxPriv038470

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv038476
MaxPriv038504

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv038507
MaxPriv038509
MaxPriv038533

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv038535

Withhold

MaxPriv038565

Withhold

MaxPriv038577

Withhold

MaxPriv038689
MaxPriv038760
MaxPriv039230
MaxPriv039274
MaxPriv039792
MaxPriv039935
MaxPriv039941
MaxPriv039942

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Page 42 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 62 of 167 PageID: 65634
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv040126
MaxPriv040150
MaxPriv040258

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv040309

Withhold

MaxPriv040398
MaxPriv040609
MaxPriv040677
MaxPriv040696
MaxPriv040764
MaxPriv040765

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv040766
MaxPriv040770
MaxPriv040807
MaxPriv040809
MaxPriv040811
MaxPriv040812
MaxPriv040824
MaxPriv040831
MaxPriv040834
MaxPriv040838
MaxPriv040842
MaxPriv040955
MaxPriv041056
MaxPriv041166
MaxPriv041287
MaxPriv041315
MaxPriv041442

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 43 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 63 of 167 PageID: 65635
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv041473

Privilege Designation
Produce

MaxPriv041529
MaxPriv041837
MaxPriv041947
MaxPriv041948
MaxPriv041958
MaxPriv041989
MaxPriv042003

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv042061
MaxPriv042098

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv042160
MaxPriv042174
MaxPriv042181
MaxPriv042347
MaxPriv042458
MaxPriv042521

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv042719
MaxPriv042769
MaxPriv042776

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv042779

Withhold

MaxPriv042781
MaxPriv042782

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv042819

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Page 44 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 64 of 167 PageID: 65636
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv042820
MaxPriv042823

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv042930

Withhold

MaxPriv042933

Withhold

MaxPriv042967

Withhold

MaxPriv043026
MaxPriv043037
MaxPriv043038
MaxPriv043041
MaxPriv043050
MaxPriv043160

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Redactions Needed then
Produce

MaxPriv043189
MaxPriv043202
MaxPriv043206
MaxPriv043223
MaxPriv043224
MaxPriv043225

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv043231

Withhold

MaxPriv043309

Withhold

MaxPriv043311

Withhold

MaxPriv043314

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 45 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 65 of 167 PageID: 65637
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv043332

Withhold

MaxPriv043354

Withhold

MaxPriv043364

Withhold

MaxPriv043366

Withhold

MaxPriv043367

Withhold

MaxPriv043368
MaxPriv043376

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv043380

Withhold

MaxPriv043386

Withhold

MaxPriv043389

Withhold

MaxPriv043390
MaxPriv043397

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv043398
MaxPriv043435
MaxPriv043436

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv043456

Withhold

MaxPriv043546

Withhold

MaxPriv043559

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 46 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 66 of 167 PageID: 65638
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv043587

Withhold

MaxPriv043594
MaxPriv043648
MaxPriv043773
MaxPriv043774
MaxPriv043813
MaxPriv043835

Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv043890

Withhold

MaxPriv043892
MaxPriv043943
MaxPriv043944
MaxPriv043984

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv043985

Withhold

MaxPriv043989
MaxPriv043999
MaxPriv044000
MaxPriv044002

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv044027

Withhold

MaxPriv044029
MaxPriv044030

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv044037

Withhold

MaxPriv044040

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 47 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 67 of 167 PageID: 65639
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv044041

Withhold

MaxPriv044061

Withhold

MaxPriv044068
MaxPriv044070
MaxPriv044089

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv044097

Withhold

MaxPriv044100
MaxPriv044135
MaxPriv044148

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv044154
MaxPriv044159

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv044200

Withhold

MaxPriv044218
MaxPriv044246
MaxPriv044257
MaxPriv044258
MaxPriv044259
MaxPriv044260
MaxPriv044261
MaxPriv044262
MaxPriv044279
MaxPriv044306

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv044337

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 48 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 68 of 167 PageID: 65640
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv044343

Withhold

MaxPriv044357

Withhold

MaxPriv044363

Withhold

MaxPriv044367

Withhold

MaxPriv044380

Withhold

MaxPriv044393

Withhold

MaxPriv044518

Withhold

MaxPriv044527
MaxPriv044532
MaxPriv044556
MaxPriv044557

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv044585

Withhold

MaxPriv044587
MaxPriv044588

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv044589

Withhold

MaxPriv044590

Withhold

MaxPriv044601

Withhold

MaxPriv044602

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 49 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 69 of 167 PageID: 65641
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv044616
MaxPriv044625
MaxPriv044628

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv044677

Withhold

MaxPriv044681

Withhold

MaxPriv044685

Withhold

MaxPriv044686

Withhold

MaxPriv044691

Withhold

MaxPriv044704
MaxPriv044741
MaxPriv044745

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv044761
MaxPriv044770
MaxPriv044800

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv044805
MaxPriv044807
MaxPriv044815
MaxPriv044832
MaxPriv044838
MaxPriv044846
MaxPriv044859
MaxPriv044877

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 50 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 70 of 167 PageID: 65642
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv044878
MaxPriv044898
MaxPriv044922
MaxPriv044926

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv044946
MaxPriv044982
MaxPriv044983
MaxPriv044986
MaxPriv044987
MaxPriv044997

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv044998
MaxPriv045001
MaxPriv045009

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv045010

Withhold

MaxPriv045015

Withhold

MaxPriv045017

Withhold

MaxPriv045067

Withhold

MaxPriv045083

Withhold

MaxPriv045085

Withhold

MaxPriv045104

Withhold

MaxPriv045106

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 51 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 71 of 167 PageID: 65643
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv045107
MaxPriv045120
MaxPriv045240
MaxPriv045268
MaxPriv045274
MaxPriv045279
MaxPriv045281
MaxPriv045283
MaxPriv045287
MaxPriv045289
MaxPriv045293

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv045298

Withhold

MaxPriv045300

Withhold

MaxPriv045419
MaxPriv045450
MaxPriv045451
MaxPriv045481
MaxPriv045490

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv045526
MaxPriv045530
MaxPriv045532
MaxPriv045535
MaxPriv045536
MaxPriv045537
MaxPriv045538
MaxPriv045539

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 52 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 72 of 167 PageID: 65644
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv045541
MaxPriv045542
MaxPriv045544
MaxPriv045546
MaxPriv045547
MaxPriv045550
MaxPriv045557
MaxPriv045558
MaxPriv045562
MaxPriv045570
MaxPriv045663
MaxPriv045698
MaxPriv045772

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv046177
MaxPriv046647
MaxPriv046670

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv046759
MaxPriv046762
MaxPriv046763
MaxPriv046850
MaxPriv046964
MaxPriv046999
MaxPriv047416

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv047981
MaxPriv048071
MaxPriv048085
MaxPriv048270

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 53 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 73 of 167 PageID: 65645
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv048326

Withhold

MaxPriv048335

Withhold

MaxPriv048393

Withhold

MaxPriv048416
MaxPriv048646

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv048764
MaxPriv048933

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv048957
MaxPriv048973
MaxPriv049129
MaxPriv049312
MaxPriv049345
MaxPriv049382
MaxPriv049385
MaxPriv049401
MaxPriv049413
MaxPriv049427
MaxPriv049551
MaxPriv050149

Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv050213
MaxPriv050508
MaxPriv050642
MaxPriv050747

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Page 54 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 74 of 167 PageID: 65646
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv050953
MaxPriv050967
MaxPriv051234
MaxPriv051341
MaxPriv051357

Privilege Designation
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv051391

Withhold

MaxPriv051544
MaxPriv051610
MaxPriv051612
MaxPriv051613
MaxPriv051614
MaxPriv051618
MaxPriv051630
MaxPriv051631
MaxPriv051762
MaxPriv051763
MaxPriv051768

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv051865
MaxPriv052001
MaxPriv052038
MaxPriv052040

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv052081
MaxPriv052119

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv052137

Withhold

MaxPriv052167

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 55 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 75 of 167 PageID: 65647
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv052173

Withhold

MaxPriv052177

Withhold

MaxPriv052201

Withhold

MaxPriv052202

Withhold

MaxPriv052252
MaxPriv052296

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv052306
MaxPriv052518

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv052640
MaxPriv053193

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv053203

Withhold

MaxPriv053205
MaxPriv053279
MaxPriv053285
MaxPriv053288

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv053359

Withhold

MaxPriv053368
MaxPriv053377
MaxPriv053378
MaxPriv053379
MaxPriv053456

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 56 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 76 of 167 PageID: 65648
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv053459
MaxPriv053622
MaxPriv053623
MaxPriv053641
MaxPriv053643
MaxPriv053684
MaxPriv053685
MaxPriv053697
MaxPriv053710
MaxPriv053749
MaxPriv053780

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv053810

Withhold

MaxPriv053812
MaxPriv053952
MaxPriv053988
MaxPriv054080
MaxPriv054085

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv054211

Withhold

MaxPriv054225

Withhold

MaxPriv054243

Withhold

MaxPriv054248
MaxPriv054249

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv054251

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 57 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 77 of 167 PageID: 65649
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv054583

Privilege Designation
Produce

MaxPriv054588
MaxPriv054814
MaxPriv054820

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv054831
MaxPriv054837
MaxPriv054870
MaxPriv054871

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv054872

Withhold

MaxPriv054876
MaxPriv054892

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv054915
MaxPriv054916
MaxPriv054943
MaxPriv054944
MaxPriv054967
MaxPriv054969
MaxPriv054992
MaxPriv054995

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv055013
MaxPriv055026
MaxPriv055027

Withhold
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv055088

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 58 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 78 of 167 PageID: 65650
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv055089

Withhold

MaxPriv055143

Withhold

MaxPriv055144
MaxPriv055177

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv055178
MaxPriv055179
MaxPriv055336
MaxPriv055361
MaxPriv055478
MaxPriv055625
MaxPriv055799

Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv055857

Withhold

MaxPriv055862

Withhold

MaxPriv055887
MaxPriv055901
MaxPriv055927

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv056047
MaxPriv056065

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv056067

Withhold

MaxPriv056068

Withhold

MaxPriv056072

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 59 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 79 of 167 PageID: 65651
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv056195
MaxPriv056198
MaxPriv056202
MaxPriv056210
MaxPriv056212
MaxPriv056215
MaxPriv056259
MaxPriv056654
MaxPriv056807
MaxPriv056817
MaxPriv056831
MaxPriv056832
MaxPriv056833
MaxPriv056842
MaxPriv056865
MaxPriv056866
MaxPriv056867
MaxPriv056868
MaxPriv056869
MaxPriv056870
MaxPriv056874
MaxPriv056897
MaxPriv056900
MaxPriv056947

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Redactions Needed then
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv056989
MaxPriv057054
MaxPriv057299
MaxPriv057313

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 60 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 80 of 167 PageID: 65652
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv057473
MaxPriv057484
MaxPriv057696
MaxPriv057697
MaxPriv057698
MaxPriv057772

Privilege Designation
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv057777
MaxPriv057832
MaxPriv057834
MaxPriv057908
MaxPriv057911
MaxPriv058027

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv058158

Withhold

MaxPriv058169

Withhold

MaxPriv058170

Withhold

MaxPriv058281

Withhold

MaxPriv058282
MaxPriv058285
MaxPriv058286
MaxPriv058334

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv058405

Withhold

MaxPriv058671
MaxPriv058672

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 61 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 81 of 167 PageID: 65653
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv058700

Privilege Designation
Withhold

MaxPriv058719

Withhold

MaxPriv058720

Withhold

MaxPriv058721

Withhold

MaxPriv058828
MaxPriv058850

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv058889

Withhold

MaxPriv058909

Withhold

MaxPriv058910
MaxPriv059009
MaxPriv059010
MaxPriv059053

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv059173

Withhold

MaxPriv059174

Withhold

MaxPriv059175
MaxPriv059728
MaxPriv060411
MaxPriv060440
MaxPriv061233
MaxPriv061236
MaxPriv061329
MaxPriv061356

Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 62 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 82 of 167 PageID: 65654
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv061369
MaxPriv061492
MaxPriv061637
MaxPriv061822
MaxPriv062038
MaxPriv062130
MaxPriv062330
MaxPriv062361
MaxPriv062377
MaxPriv062398
MaxPriv062399
MaxPriv062420
MaxPriv062434
MaxPriv062567
MaxPriv062612
MaxPriv062662
MaxPriv062681
MaxPriv062711
MaxPriv062731
MaxPriv062999
MaxPriv063021

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv063058

Withhold

MaxPriv063067
MaxPriv063146
MaxPriv063173

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv063353
MaxPriv063411

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 63 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 83 of 167 PageID: 65655
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv063478
MaxPriv063479

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv063502
MaxPriv064045

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv064066

Withhold

MaxPriv064105
MaxPriv064291
MaxPriv064429

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv064501
MaxPriv064511
MaxPriv064529
MaxPriv064637
MaxPriv068370

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv068980
MaxPriv068983
MaxPriv068986
MaxPriv069263
MaxPriv069275
MaxPriv069753
MaxPriv069754
MaxPriv069768

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv069806
MaxPriv069956
MaxPriv069965
MaxPriv070321

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 64 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 84 of 167 PageID: 65656
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv070569

Withhold

MaxPriv070584
MaxPriv071313

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv071319

Withhold

MaxPriv071814

Withhold

MaxPriv072070

Withhold

MaxPriv072101
MaxPriv072210

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv072258
MaxPriv072503
MaxPriv073130
MaxPriv073131

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv073370
MaxPriv073525
MaxPriv073534
MaxPriv073535
MaxPriv076270

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv076405

Withhold

MaxPriv076406

Withhold

MaxPriv076407

Withhold

MaxPriv076408

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 65 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 85 of 167 PageID: 65657
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv076409

Withhold

MaxPriv076410

Withhold

MaxPriv076412

Withhold

MaxPriv076413

Withhold

MaxPriv076414

Withhold

MaxPriv076420

Withhold

MaxPriv076435
MaxPriv076436
MaxPriv076437
MaxPriv076440
MaxPriv076449
MaxPriv076450

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076451
MaxPriv076452
MaxPriv076453
MaxPriv076493
MaxPriv076494
MaxPriv076556

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076580

Withhold

MaxPriv076582

Withhold

MaxPriv076591

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 66 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 86 of 167 PageID: 65658
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv076593

Withhold

MaxPriv076595

Withhold

MaxPriv076597

Withhold

MaxPriv076601

Withhold

MaxPriv076603

Withhold

MaxPriv076605

Withhold

MaxPriv076607

Withhold

MaxPriv076609

Withhold

MaxPriv076611

Withhold

MaxPriv076613

Withhold

MaxPriv076617

Withhold

MaxPriv076619

Withhold

MaxPriv076623

Withhold

MaxPriv076625

Withhold

MaxPriv076627

Withhold

MaxPriv076629

Withhold

MaxPriv076631

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 67 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 87 of 167 PageID: 65659
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv076633

Withhold

MaxPriv076635

Withhold

MaxPriv076637

Withhold

MaxPriv076641

Withhold

MaxPriv076643

Withhold

MaxPriv076645

Withhold

MaxPriv076651

Withhold

MaxPriv076655

Withhold

MaxPriv076657

Withhold

MaxPriv076659

Withhold

MaxPriv076661

Withhold

MaxPriv076663

Withhold

MaxPriv076665
MaxPriv076678

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076679
MaxPriv076680

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076681
MaxPriv076682

Withhold
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Page 68 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 88 of 167 PageID: 65660
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv076683
MaxPriv076684

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076685
MaxPriv076686

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076687
MaxPriv076688

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076689
MaxPriv076690

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076691
MaxPriv076692

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076693
MaxPriv076694

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076695
MaxPriv076696

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076697
MaxPriv076698

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076699
MaxPriv076700

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076701

Withhold

MaxPriv076703

Withhold

MaxPriv076705

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 69 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 89 of 167 PageID: 65661
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv076707

Withhold

MaxPriv076709

Withhold

MaxPriv076711

Withhold

MaxPriv076713

Withhold

MaxPriv076722

Withhold

MaxPriv076729
MaxPriv076731
MaxPriv076732

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076734

Withhold

MaxPriv076736

Withhold

MaxPriv076738

Withhold

MaxPriv076740

Withhold

MaxPriv076742

Withhold

MaxPriv076744

Withhold

MaxPriv076746

Withhold

MaxPriv076749

Withhold

MaxPriv076751

Withhold

MaxPriv076753

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 70 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 90 of 167 PageID: 65662
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv076755

Withhold

MaxPriv076757

Withhold

MaxPriv076759

Withhold

MaxPriv076761

Withhold

MaxPriv076763

Withhold

MaxPriv076765

Withhold

MaxPriv076767

Withhold

MaxPriv076769

Withhold

MaxPriv076771

Withhold

MaxPriv076773
MaxPriv076775

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076777

Withhold

MaxPriv076779

Withhold

MaxPriv076781

Withhold

MaxPriv076799

Withhold

MaxPriv076801

Withhold

MaxPriv076803

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 71 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 91 of 167 PageID: 65663
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv076805

Withhold

MaxPriv076807

Withhold

MaxPriv076809

Withhold

MaxPriv076811

Withhold

MaxPriv076813

Withhold

MaxPriv076815

Withhold

MaxPriv076817

Withhold

MaxPriv076819

Withhold

MaxPriv076827
MaxPriv076829

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076831
MaxPriv076832

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076833
MaxPriv076834

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076835
MaxPriv076836

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076837
MaxPriv076838

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076839

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 72 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 92 of 167 PageID: 65664
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv076840

Privilege Designation
Withhold

MaxPriv076841

Withhold

MaxPriv076842
MaxPriv076843
MaxPriv076844
MaxPriv076845

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076846
MaxPriv076847

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076848
MaxPriv076849

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076850
MaxPriv076851

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076852
MaxPriv076853

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv076854
MaxPriv077068
MaxPriv081751
MaxPriv085862
MaxPriv086022
MaxPriv086030

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv086289

Withhold

MaxPriv086303

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 73 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 93 of 167 PageID: 65665
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv086315
MaxPriv086321
MaxPriv086324
MaxPriv086327
MaxPriv086328
MaxPriv086330
MaxPriv086407
MaxPriv086576
MaxPriv086706
MaxPriv086756

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv086954
MaxPriv086959
MaxPriv086970
MaxPriv087268
MaxPriv087278
MaxPriv087280
MaxPriv087358
MaxPriv087365
MaxPriv087422
MaxPriv087424
MaxPriv087504
MaxPriv087525
MaxPriv087541
MaxPriv087569
MaxPriv087592
MaxPriv087672
MaxPriv087674

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 74 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 94 of 167 PageID: 65666
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv087684

Withhold

MaxPriv087770
MaxPriv087844
MaxPriv087859
MaxPriv087953
MaxPriv087990
MaxPriv088003

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv088021

Withhold

MaxPriv088025

Withhold

MaxPriv088076
MaxPriv088121
MaxPriv088129
MaxPriv088139
MaxPriv088141

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv088143
MaxPriv088146
MaxPriv088156
MaxPriv088167
MaxPriv088168
MaxPriv088179

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv088187

Withhold

MaxPriv088188

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – communication
including outside counsel as recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 75 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 95 of 167 PageID: 65667
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv088189
MaxPriv088199
MaxPriv088200
MaxPriv088202
MaxPriv088210
MaxPriv088215
MaxPriv088270
MaxPriv088279
MaxPriv088280

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv088281
MaxPriv088283
MaxPriv088286
MaxPriv088302
MaxPriv088320

Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv088330
MaxPriv088332
MaxPriv088336
MaxPriv088477
MaxPriv088699
MaxPriv088732

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv089472

Withhold

MaxPriv089500
MaxPriv089526
MaxPriv089685

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv089689
MaxPriv089702

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 76 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 96 of 167 PageID: 65668
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv089780

Withhold

MaxPriv089795

Withhold

MaxPriv089813

Withhold

MaxPriv089897
MaxPriv089900
MaxPriv089922
MaxPriv089979
MaxPriv089986
MaxPriv089993

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv090021

Withhold

MaxPriv090023
MaxPriv090058
MaxPriv090145
MaxPriv090218
MaxPriv090259

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv090280
MaxPriv090317
MaxPriv090460
MaxPriv090470
MaxPriv090472
MaxPriv090483
MaxPriv090496
MaxPriv090512
MaxPriv090522

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 77 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 97 of 167 PageID: 65669
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv090572
MaxPriv090573

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv090591

Withhold

MaxPriv090627
MaxPriv090628

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv090630
MaxPriv090631

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv090633

Withhold

MaxPriv090635

Withhold

MaxPriv090636
MaxPriv090697

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv090703
MaxPriv090714

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv090721

Withhold

MaxPriv090724

Withhold

MaxPriv090789
MaxPriv090792
MaxPriv090793
MaxPriv090795
MaxPriv090798
MaxPriv090807

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 78 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 98 of 167 PageID: 65670
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv090809
MaxPriv090819
MaxPriv090941
MaxPriv090955
MaxPriv090981
MaxPriv090989
MaxPriv090990
MaxPriv091000

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv091021

Withhold

MaxPriv091082

Withhold

MaxPriv091340

Withhold

MaxPriv091398

Withhold

MaxPriv091399

Withhold

MaxPriv091411
MaxPriv091431
MaxPriv091441
MaxPriv091476

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv091533

Withhold

MaxPriv091569
MaxPriv091598
MaxPriv091605
MaxPriv091612

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 79 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 99 of 167 PageID: 65671
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv091614
MaxPriv091692
MaxPriv091700

Privilege Designation
Produce
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv091704

Withhold

MaxPriv091795

Withhold

MaxPriv092273
MaxPriv092305

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv092390

Withhold

MaxPriv092396

Withhold

MaxPriv092549

Withhold

MaxPriv092572

Withhold

MaxPriv092575

Withhold

MaxPriv092579

Withhold

MaxPriv092618

Withhold

MaxPriv092646

Withhold

MaxPriv092697

Withhold

MaxPriv092794

Withhold

MaxPriv092795

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Page 80 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 100 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65672
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv092799

Withhold

MaxPriv092817

Withhold

MaxPriv092819
MaxPriv092882

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv092885
MaxPriv092899
MaxPriv092914
MaxPriv092923
MaxPriv092929
MaxPriv093397
MaxPriv093448

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv093569

Withhold

MaxPriv093575

Withhold

MaxPriv093725

Withhold

MaxPriv093729
MaxPriv093752

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv093755

Withhold

MaxPriv093759
MaxPriv093802

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv093804
MaxPriv093810

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 81 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 101 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65673
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv093811
MaxPriv093812
MaxPriv093820

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv093851

Withhold

MaxPriv094007

Withhold

MaxPriv094025

Withhold

MaxPriv094035
MaxPriv094083
MaxPriv094087
MaxPriv094088

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv094117
MaxPriv094145
MaxPriv094398

Withhold
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv094527
MaxPriv094528

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv094536

Withhold

MaxPriv094575

Withhold

MaxPriv094849

Withhold

MaxPriv095025
MaxPriv095039

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 82 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 102 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65674
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv095056

Withhold

MaxPriv095057
MaxPriv095074

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv095124

Withhold

MaxPriv095195

Withhold

MaxPriv095198

Withhold

MaxPriv095201
MaxPriv095300

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv095319

Withhold

MaxPriv095401

Withhold

MaxPriv095403

Withhold

MaxPriv095423
MaxPriv095439

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv095440

MaxPriv095452

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including
in-house counsel as recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including
in-house counsel as recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Withhold

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Withhold

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including
outside counsel as recipient to obtain legal advice

Page 83 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 103 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65675
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv095455
MaxPriv095459

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv095461
MaxPriv095756

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv096022
MaxPriv096213
MaxPriv096242
MaxPriv096244
MaxPriv096245
MaxPriv096247
MaxPriv096248
MaxPriv096249
MaxPriv096257
MaxPriv096258

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv096469

Withhold

MaxPriv096583

Withhold

MaxPriv096699
MaxPriv096756

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv096786

Withhold

MaxPriv096800
MaxPriv096804

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv096822
MaxPriv096835

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 84 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 104 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65676
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv096843
MaxPriv097001
MaxPriv097015
MaxPriv097024
MaxPriv097062
MaxPriv097063
MaxPriv097064
MaxPriv097075
MaxPriv097094
MaxPriv097167
MaxPriv097242

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv097251

Withhold

MaxPriv097262

Withhold

MaxPriv097264
MaxPriv097297
MaxPriv097298

Withhold
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv097317
MaxPriv097319
MaxPriv097859
MaxPriv097865
MaxPriv097880
MaxPriv097881
MaxPriv097892

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 85 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 105 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65677
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv098214
MaxPriv098321

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv098459
MaxPriv099075

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv099861
MaxPriv100093

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv101192
MaxPriv101282

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv101288

Withhold

MaxPriv101311
MaxPriv101367
MaxPriv101575
MaxPriv101973

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv102144
MaxPriv102543

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv103649
MaxPriv103654
MaxPriv103655

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv103656
MaxPriv103688
MaxPriv103742
MaxPriv103788

Withold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 86 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 106 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65678
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv103800
MaxPriv104488
MaxPriv104551
MaxPriv105484
MaxPriv105731
MaxPriv105733
MaxPriv105735
MaxPriv105737
MaxPriv105862
MaxPriv105865
MaxPriv105867
MaxPriv105870

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv105875

Withhold

MaxPriv105876
MaxPriv105877

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv105880
MaxPriv105890

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv105891
MaxPriv105916
MaxPriv105921
MaxPriv105925
MaxPriv105934
MaxPriv105984
MaxPriv106142
MaxPriv106196
MaxPriv106236

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Page 87 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 107 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65679
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv106268
MaxPriv106271
MaxPriv106312
MaxPriv106313

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv106439

Withhold

MaxPriv106442
MaxPriv106497

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv106601

Withhold

MaxPriv106626
MaxPriv106627
MaxPriv106637

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv106677

Withhold

MaxPriv106681

Withhold

MaxPriv106691

Withhold

MaxPriv106713

Withhold

MaxPriv106727
MaxPriv106758
MaxPriv106762
MaxPriv106771
MaxPriv106772

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv106874

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 88 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 108 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65680
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv106941

Withhold

MaxPriv107064
MaxPriv107118
MaxPriv108246
MaxPriv108452
MaxPriv108888
MaxPriv108894
MaxPriv108906
MaxPriv108907
MaxPriv108908
MaxPriv108909
MaxPriv108910
MaxPriv108911

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv108926

Withhold

MaxPriv108935

Withhold

MaxPriv109135

Withhold

MaxPriv109146

Withhold

MaxPriv109148
MaxPriv109165
MaxPriv109206
MaxPriv109211
MaxPriv109233

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv109276

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 89 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 109 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65681
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv109292
MaxPriv109293
MaxPriv109303

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv109304

Withhold

MaxPriv109321
MaxPriv109332

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv109333
MaxPriv109338

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv109358

Withhold

MaxPriv109359

Withhold

MaxPriv109409

Withhold

MaxPriv109410
MaxPriv109460

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv109472
MaxPriv110287
MaxPriv110293
MaxPriv110506

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv110512

Withhold

MaxPriv110513
MaxPriv110517
MaxPriv110569
MaxPriv110603

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 90 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 110 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65682
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv111002
MaxPriv111041
MaxPriv111099
MaxPriv111108
MaxPriv111382
MaxPriv111384
MaxPriv111441

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv111448
MaxPriv111506

Withhold
Withhold

MaxPriv111536
MaxPriv111573

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv111580
MaxPriv111596

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv111660

Withhold

MaxPriv111724
MaxPriv111725

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv111774
MaxPriv111775
MaxPriv111776

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv111789

Withhold

MaxPriv111809

Withhold

MaxPriv111859

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 91 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 111 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65683
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv111874

Withhold

MaxPriv111893

Withhold

MaxPriv111934

Withhold

MaxPriv111964

Withhold

MaxPriv111969

Withhold

MaxPriv111970

Withhold

MaxPriv111976

Withhold

MaxPriv111980

Withhold

MaxPriv111986

Withhold

MaxPriv112018
MaxPriv112111
MaxPriv112124
MaxPriv112125
MaxPriv112138
MaxPriv112140
MaxPriv112141
MaxPriv112146
MaxPriv112148
MaxPriv112151
MaxPriv112152
MaxPriv112157
MaxPriv112161

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 92 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 112 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65684
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv112162
MaxPriv112165
MaxPriv112166
MaxPriv112167
MaxPriv112197
MaxPriv112201
MaxPriv112202
MaxPriv112233

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv112236

Withhold

MaxPriv112311

Withhold

MaxPriv112518

Withhold

MaxPriv112523

Withhold

MaxPriv112675
MaxPriv112693
MaxPriv112950
MaxPriv112955
MaxPriv112961
MaxPriv113056

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv113241
MaxPriv113265

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv113283

Withhold

MaxPriv113628

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 93 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 113 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65685
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv113636

Withhold

MaxPriv113641
MaxPriv113783
MaxPriv115159
MaxPriv115301

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv115589
MaxPriv115881
MaxPriv115888
MaxPriv116023
MaxPriv116028
MaxPriv116034
MaxPriv116036
MaxPriv116037
MaxPriv116039
MaxPriv116129
MaxPriv116146
MaxPriv116149
MaxPriv116170
MaxPriv116180
MaxPriv116193
MaxPriv116308
MaxPriv116334
MaxPriv116343
MaxPriv116344
MaxPriv116345
MaxPriv116353
MaxPriv116362

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 94 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 114 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65686
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv116364
MaxPriv116367
MaxPriv116368
MaxPriv116369
MaxPriv116485
MaxPriv116493
MaxPriv116538
MaxPriv116726
MaxPriv116728
MaxPriv116730
MaxPriv116734
MaxPriv116989
MaxPriv116999
MaxPriv117070
MaxPriv117072
MaxPriv117170
MaxPriv117331
MaxPriv117434
MaxPriv117869
MaxPriv117976
MaxPriv117979
MaxPriv117987

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv118045
MaxPriv118249
MaxPriv118254

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv118278

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 95 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 115 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65687
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv118293
MaxPriv118300
MaxPriv118342
MaxPriv118457
MaxPriv118518
MaxPriv118864
MaxPriv118920
MaxPriv119241
MaxPriv119242
MaxPriv119267
MaxPriv119289
MaxPriv119291
MaxPriv119298
MaxPriv119389
MaxPriv119454
MaxPriv119479
MaxPriv119504
MaxPriv119529
MaxPriv119603
MaxPriv119628
MaxPriv119653
MaxPriv119678
MaxPriv119703
MaxPriv119728
MaxPriv119753
MaxPriv119778
MaxPriv119801
MaxPriv119805
MaxPriv119812

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 96 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 116 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65688
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv119848
MaxPriv119849
MaxPriv119850
MaxPriv119851
MaxPriv119862
MaxPriv119863
MaxPriv119865
MaxPriv119867
MaxPriv119868
MaxPriv119869
MaxPriv119870
MaxPriv119871
MaxPriv120100
MaxPriv120105
MaxPriv120113
MaxPriv120114
MaxPriv120228

MaxPriv120243
MaxPriv120361
MaxPriv120368
MaxPriv120779
MaxPriv120955
MaxPriv120965
MaxPriv121090
MaxPriv121091

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Redactions Needed then
Produce
Redactions Needed then
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 97 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 117 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65689
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv121096

Privilege Designation
Redactions Needed then
Produce

MaxPriv121133

Withhold

MaxPriv121147

Withhold

MaxPriv121206

Withhold

MaxPriv121561

Withhold

MaxPriv122046
MaxPriv123100

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv123200

Withhold

MaxPriv124169
MaxPriv124178
MaxPriv124204
MaxPriv124220
MaxPriv124222
MaxPriv124227
MaxPriv124236
MaxPriv124275
MaxPriv124286
MaxPriv124296

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv124378

Withhold

MaxPriv124379

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including
in-house counsel as recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 98 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 118 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65690
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv124720

Privilege Designation
Produce

MaxPriv124729

Withhold

MaxPriv124896

Withhold

MaxPriv126048

Withhold

MaxPriv127776
MaxPriv127814
MaxPriv127880
MaxPriv127881
MaxPriv127882
MaxPriv127884
MaxPriv127893
MaxPriv127963
MaxPriv128716

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv129427
MaxPriv129435
MaxPriv129884
MaxPriv129891
MaxPriv129894

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv129926
MaxPriv129972
MaxPriv134741
MaxPriv134837
MaxPriv134839
MaxPriv134840
MaxPriv135866

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 99 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 119 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65691
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv135867
MaxPriv135868
MaxPriv135869
MaxPriv135870
MaxPriv135871
MaxPriv135872
MaxPriv135873
MaxPriv135875
MaxPriv135876
MaxPriv135879
MaxPriv135880
MaxPriv135884
MaxPriv135885
MaxPriv135887
MaxPriv135888
MaxPriv135890
MaxPriv135892
MaxPriv135893
MaxPriv135895
MaxPriv135896
MaxPriv135897
MaxPriv135898
MaxPriv135899
MaxPriv135901
MaxPriv135902
MaxPriv135903
MaxPriv135904
MaxPriv135905
MaxPriv135907

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Page 100 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 120 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65692
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv135908
MaxPriv135909
MaxPriv135910
MaxPriv135911
MaxPriv135912
MaxPriv135914
MaxPriv135915
MaxPriv135916
MaxPriv135917
MaxPriv135918
MaxPriv135919
MaxPriv135920
MaxPriv135921
MaxPriv135922
MaxPriv135923
MaxPriv135924
MaxPriv135925
MaxPriv135926
MaxPriv135927
MaxPriv135928
MaxPriv135929

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv136134
MaxPriv136447
MaxPriv136452
MaxPriv136454
MaxPriv136578
MaxPriv136587
MaxPriv136591
MaxPriv136597

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 101 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 121 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65693
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv136599
MaxPriv136600
MaxPriv136604
MaxPriv137002

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv137011
MaxPriv138584
MaxPriv138607
MaxPriv138614
MaxPriv138617
MaxPriv138626
MaxPriv138627
MaxPriv138647
MaxPriv138649

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv140225
MaxPriv140228

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv140231

Withhold

MaxPriv140465
MaxPriv144426
MaxPriv144433
MaxPriv144436
MaxPriv144500
MaxPriv144501
MaxPriv144516
MaxPriv144534
MaxPriv144739
MaxPriv144764

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 102 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 122 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65694
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv144789
MaxPriv144838
MaxPriv144863
MaxPriv144888
MaxPriv144963
MaxPriv145142
MaxPriv145332
MaxPriv145333
MaxPriv145334

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv145391

Withhold

MaxPriv145395
MaxPriv145417

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv145432

Withhold

MaxPriv145438

Withhold

MaxPriv145442

Withhold

MaxPriv145536
MaxPriv145543
MaxPriv145585
MaxPriv145622

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv145674
MaxPriv145683
MaxPriv145704

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv145849

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 103 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 123 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65695
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv145859
MaxPriv145903

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv145951
MaxPriv146414

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv146885

Withhold

MaxPriv146903
MaxPriv146967
MaxPriv146985
MaxPriv147816
MaxPriv148521

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv148576
MaxPriv148652
MaxPriv148670

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv148675

Withhold

MaxPriv148762
MaxPriv148768

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv148891

MaxPriv148895

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including outside counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – communication
including outside counsel as recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Withhold

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice

Withhold

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice

Page 104 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 124 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65696
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv148913

Privilege Designation
Produce

MaxPriv148927
MaxPriv149062
MaxPriv149063
MaxPriv149077

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv149119
MaxPriv149134
MaxPriv149150

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv149174

Withhold

MaxPriv149209
MaxPriv149350
MaxPriv149446

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv149466
MaxPriv149788

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv149869

Withhold

MaxPriv149911
MaxPriv149934
MaxPriv149975

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv150033

Withhold

MaxPriv150035
MaxPriv150044
MaxPriv150047
MaxPriv150050

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 105 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 125 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65697
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv150068
MaxPriv150076

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv150081
MaxPriv150083

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv150110

Withhold

MaxPriv150113

Withhold

MaxPriv150115

Withhold

MaxPriv150117

Withhold

MaxPriv150121
MaxPriv150162
MaxPriv150211

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv150221

Withhold

MaxPriv150235
MaxPriv150269

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv150310
MaxPriv150312
MaxPriv150313
MaxPriv150479
MaxPriv150480
MaxPriv150481
MaxPriv150502
MaxPriv150513
MaxPriv150551

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 106 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 126 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65698
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
MaxPriv150552
MaxPriv150553
MaxPriv150554

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv150558
MaxPriv150574
MaxPriv150594
MaxPriv150595
MaxPriv150603
MaxPriv150617
MaxPriv150633
MaxPriv150636
MaxPriv150646
MaxPriv150700
MaxPriv150760
MaxPriv150803
MaxPriv150810
MaxPriv150814

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv150895
MaxPriv150896
MaxPriv150897
MaxPriv150898
MaxPriv150899
MaxPriv150995

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv151013

Withhold

MaxPriv151032

Withhold

MaxPriv151038

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 107 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 127 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65699
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv151054
MaxPriv151062
MaxPriv151109

Withhold
Produce
Withhold

MaxPriv151259

Withhold

MaxPriv151260
MaxPriv151525

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv151526

Withhold

MaxPriv151536

Withhold

MaxPriv151537

Withhold

MaxPriv151539

Withhold

MaxPriv151558
MaxPriv151622

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv151718

Withhold

MaxPriv151853
MaxPriv151854
MaxPriv151919

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv151936
MaxPriv151938
MaxPriv151992

Withhold
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including
in-house counsel as recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 108 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 128 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65700
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv152029
MaxPriv152031

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv152034

Withhold

MaxPriv152042

Withhold

MaxPriv152045

Withhold

MaxPriv152073
MaxPriv152104
MaxPriv152125

Withhold
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv152184
MaxPriv152261

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv152330

Withhold

MaxPriv152338
MaxPriv152421

Withhold
Produce

MaxPriv152429

Withhold

MaxPriv152482

Withhold

MaxPriv152513
MaxPriv152551
MaxPriv152600
MaxPriv152742
MaxPriv152751

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv152802

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 109 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 129 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65701
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

MaxPriv153106
MaxPriv153211
MaxPriv153219
MaxPriv153879

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv153890

Withhold

MaxPriv154046

Withhold

MaxPriv154103
MaxPriv154121
MaxPriv154137
MaxPriv154196

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

MaxPriv154307

Withhold

MaxPriv154315

Withhold

MaxPriv154320
OCC-CER-IM000024431
OCC-CER-IM000071905
OCC-CER-IM000144559
OCC-CER-IM000144581
OCC-CER-IM000324204
OCC-CER-IM000341007
OCC-CER-IM000342569

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Redactions Needed then
Produce

OCC-CER-IM000343014

Withhold

OCC-CER-IM000343802

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 110 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 130 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65702
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-IM000377477
OCC-CER-IM000382323
OCC-CER-IM000383308
OCC-CER-IM000383434
OCC-CER-IM000425278
OCC-CER-IM000447795
OCC-CER-IM000493508

Privilege Designation
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-IM000493755

Withhold

OCC-CER-IM000493790
OCC-CER-IM000512805
OCC-CER-IM000534409
OCC-CER-IM000534772

Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-IM00053825
OCC-CER-IM000554120
OCC-CER-IM000557656
OCC-CER-IM000558113
OCC-CER-IM000558146
OCC-CER-IM000558421
OCC-CER-IM000558480

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-IM000593954
OCC-CER-IM000593965

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-IM000644021
OCC-CER-IM000645747
OCC-CER-IM000645794
OCC-CER-IM000646346
OCC-CER-IM000647828

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 111 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 131 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65703
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-IM000648702
OCC-CER-IM000650469
OCC-CER-IM000651426
OCC-CER-IM000652436
OCC-CER-IM000671859
OCC-CER-IM000676158
OCC-CER-PRIV002004
OCC-CER-PRIV002011

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV002012
OCC-CER-PRIV002013

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV002017
OCC-CER-PRIV002019
OCC-CER-PRIV002074
OCC-CER-PRIV002103
OCC-CER-PRIV002112
OCC-CER-PRIV002113
OCC-CER-PRIV002114
OCC-CER-PRIV002115
OCC-CER-PRIV002116
OCC-CER-PRIV002117
OCC-CER-PRIV002137

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV002145
OCC-CER-PRIV002146
OCC-CER-PRIV002149
OCC-CER-PRIV002150

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Joint-Client/Community-of-Interest Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 112 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 132 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65704
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV002155
OCC-CER-PRIV002158
OCC-CER-PRIV002164
OCC-CER-PRIV002166
OCC-CER-PRIV002212
OCC-CER-PRIV002215
OCC-CER-PRIV002217
OCC-CER-PRIV002218
OCC-CER-PRIV002221
OCC-CER-PRIV002222
OCC-CER-PRIV002223
OCC-CER-PRIV002224
OCC-CER-PRIV002253
OCC-CER-PRIV002261
OCC-CER-PRIV002263
OCC-CER-PRIV002284

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV002294
OCC-CER-PRIV002298

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV002303

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV002304

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV002305
OCC-CER-PRIV002318
OCC-CER-PRIV002330
OCC-CER-PRIV002334

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV002348

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 113 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 133 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65705
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV002349
OCC-CER-PRIV002353

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV002363
OCC-CER-PRIV002365
OCC-CER-PRIV002371
OCC-CER-PRIV002374
OCC-CER-PRIV002391

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV002403
OCC-CER-PRIV002404
OCC-CER-PRIV002441
OCC-CER-PRIV002456
OCC-CER-PRIV002457
OCC-CER-PRIV002458
OCC-CER-PRIV002459
OCC-CER-PRIV002460
OCC-CER-PRIV002461
OCC-CER-PRIV002553
OCC-CER-PRIV002745
OCC-CER-PRIV002746
OCC-CER-PRIV002747
OCC-CER-PRIV002748
OCC-CER-PRIV002750

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV002760
OCC-CER-PRIV002763
OCC-CER-PRIV002765
OCC-CER-PRIV002766

Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 114 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 134 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65706
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV002767
OCC-CER-PRIV002768
OCC-CER-PRIV002769
OCC-CER-PRIV002770
OCC-CER-PRIV002826
OCC-CER-PRIV002871
OCC-CER-PRIV002911
OCC-CER-PRIV002914
OCC-CER-PRIV002947
OCC-CER-PRIV002989
OCC-CER-PRIV003011
OCC-CER-PRIV003019
OCC-CER-PRIV003032
OCC-CER-PRIV003065
OCC-CER-PRIV003118
OCC-CER-PRIV003137
OCC-CER-PRIV003208
OCC-CER-PRIV003230
OCC-CER-PRIV003236
OCC-CER-PRIV003238
OCC-CER-PRIV003272
OCC-CER-PRIV003311
OCC-CER-PRIV003326
OCC-CER-PRIV003333
OCC-CER-PRIV003334
OCC-CER-PRIV003335
OCC-CER-PRIV003337
OCC-CER-PRIV003338
OCC-CER-PRIV003341

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege

Page 115 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 135 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65707
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV003349
OCC-CER-PRIV003352
OCC-CER-PRIV003354

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV003358
OCC-CER-PRIV003363
OCC-CER-PRIV003364
OCC-CER-PRIV003367
OCC-CER-PRIV003373
OCC-CER-PRIV003374
OCC-CER-PRIV003387
OCC-CER-PRIV003403
OCC-CER-PRIV003404
OCC-CER-PRIV003468
OCC-CER-PRIV003497
OCC-CER-PRIV003571
OCC-CER-PRIV003578
OCC-CER-PRIV003579
OCC-CER-PRIV003580
OCC-CER-PRIV003581
OCC-CER-PRIV003582
OCC-CER-PRIV003583
OCC-CER-PRIV003584
OCC-CER-PRIV003586
OCC-CER-PRIV003587
OCC-CER-PRIV003588
OCC-CER-PRIV003589
OCC-CER-PRIV003593
OCC-CER-PRIV003730
OCC-CER-PRIV003731

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 116 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 136 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65708
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV003735
OCC-CER-PRIV003740

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV003742
OCC-CER-PRIV003747
OCC-CER-PRIV003767
OCC-CER-PRIV003773

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV003783

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV003796

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV003797
OCC-CER-PRIV003798

Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV003803
OCC-CER-PRIV003805
OCC-CER-PRIV003806
OCC-CER-PRIV003807
OCC-CER-PRIV003891
OCC-CER-PRIV003894
OCC-CER-PRIV003897
OCC-CER-PRIV003919
OCC-CER-PRIV003930
OCC-CER-PRIV003947
OCC-CER-PRIV003952
OCC-CER-PRIV003953
OCC-CER-PRIV003957

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including
in-house counsel as recipient to obtain legal advice; Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege

Page 117 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 137 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65709
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV003960
OCC-CER-PRIV003961
OCC-CER-PRIV003962
OCC-CER-PRIV003982
OCC-CER-PRIV003985
OCC-CER-PRIV004001
OCC-CER-PRIV004015

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004065

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV004215

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV004216
OCC-CER-PRIV004217
OCC-CER-PRIV004218

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004228
OCC-CER-PRIV004229
OCC-CER-PRIV004255
OCC-CER-PRIV004258
OCC-CER-PRIV004259
OCC-CER-PRIV004261
OCC-CER-PRIV004275
OCC-CER-PRIV004294
OCC-CER-PRIV004314
OCC-CER-PRIV004353
OCC-CER-PRIV004381
OCC-CER-PRIV004557
OCC-CER-PRIV004558
OCC-CER-PRIV004570

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 118 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 138 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65710
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV004577
OCC-CER-PRIV004583
OCC-CER-PRIV004591
OCC-CER-PRIV004613
OCC-CER-PRIV004617

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004649
OCC-CER-PRIV004650

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004651
OCC-CER-PRIV004652
OCC-CER-PRIV004653

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004654

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV004655
OCC-CER-PRIV004656
OCC-CER-PRIV004658
OCC-CER-PRIV004660

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004662
OCC-CER-PRIV004663
OCC-CER-PRIV004665

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004666
OCC-CER-PRIV004672
OCC-CER-PRIV004674
OCC-CER-PRIV004675
OCC-CER-PRIV004676
OCC-CER-PRIV004682
OCC-CER-PRIV004689

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 119 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 139 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65711
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV004700
OCC-CER-PRIV004701

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004704
OCC-CER-PRIV004707

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004731

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV004740
OCC-CER-PRIV004747
OCC-CER-PRIV004749
OCC-CER-PRIV004799
OCC-CER-PRIV004815
OCC-CER-PRIV004816
OCC-CER-PRIV004826
OCC-CER-PRIV004827

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004840
OCC-CER-PRIV004859

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV004867
OCC-CER-PRIV004925
OCC-CER-PRIV004928
OCC-CER-PRIV004962
OCC-CER-PRIV004967
OCC-CER-PRIV004968
OCC-CER-PRIV004969
OCC-CER-PRIV005053
OCC-CER-PRIV005097
OCC-CER-PRIV005098
OCC-CER-PRIV005105

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Page 120 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 140 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65712
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV005109
OCC-CER-PRIV005128

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV005134
OCC-CER-PRIV005143
OCC-CER-PRIV005149
OCC-CER-PRIV005153
OCC-CER-PRIV005162
OCC-CER-PRIV005163
OCC-CER-PRIV005164
OCC-CER-PRIV005165
OCC-CER-PRIV005166
OCC-CER-PRIV005167
OCC-CER-PRIV005168
OCC-CER-PRIV005169
OCC-CER-PRIV005170
OCC-CER-PRIV005171
OCC-CER-PRIV005172
OCC-CER-PRIV005173
OCC-CER-PRIV005174
OCC-CER-PRIV005175
OCC-CER-PRIV005176
OCC-CER-PRIV005177
OCC-CER-PRIV005178
OCC-CER-PRIV005179
OCC-CER-PRIV005180
OCC-CER-PRIV005181
OCC-CER-PRIV005182
OCC-CER-PRIV005184

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 121 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 141 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65713
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV005185
OCC-CER-PRIV005186
OCC-CER-PRIV005188
OCC-CER-PRIV005191
OCC-CER-PRIV005192
OCC-CER-PRIV005193
OCC-CER-PRIV005194
OCC-CER-PRIV005195
OCC-CER-PRIV005196
OCC-CER-PRIV005197
OCC-CER-PRIV005198
OCC-CER-PRIV005199
OCC-CER-PRIV005200
OCC-CER-PRIV005201
OCC-CER-PRIV005202
OCC-CER-PRIV005203
OCC-CER-PRIV005204
OCC-CER-PRIV005205
OCC-CER-PRIV005206
OCC-CER-PRIV005207
OCC-CER-PRIV005208
OCC-CER-PRIV005209
OCC-CER-PRIV005210
OCC-CER-PRIV005211
OCC-CER-PRIV005212
OCC-CER-PRIV005213
OCC-CER-PRIV005214
OCC-CER-PRIV005215
OCC-CER-PRIV005216

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 122 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 142 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65714
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV005217
OCC-CER-PRIV005218
OCC-CER-PRIV005219
OCC-CER-PRIV005220
OCC-CER-PRIV005221
OCC-CER-PRIV005222
OCC-CER-PRIV005223
OCC-CER-PRIV005224
OCC-CER-PRIV005225
OCC-CER-PRIV005226
OCC-CER-PRIV005227
OCC-CER-PRIV005228
OCC-CER-PRIV005229
OCC-CER-PRIV005230
OCC-CER-PRIV005231
OCC-CER-PRIV005232
OCC-CER-PRIV005233
OCC-CER-PRIV005234
OCC-CER-PRIV005297
OCC-CER-PRIV005300
OCC-CER-PRIV005310
OCC-CER-PRIV005316
OCC-CER-PRIV005335
OCC-CER-PRIV005341
OCC-CER-PRIV005349
OCC-CER-PRIV005396

OCC-CER-PRIV005402

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including
in-house counsel as recipient to obtain legal advice

Page 123 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 143 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65715
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV005403

Privilege Designation
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV005412
OCC-CER-PRIV005416
OCC-CER-PRIV005417

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV005418
OCC-CER-PRIV005470
OCC-CER-PRIV005524

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV005531
OCC-CER-PRIV005532

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV005535
OCC-CER-PRIV005543
OCC-CER-PRIV005551
OCC-CER-PRIV005553
OCC-CER-PRIV005570
OCC-CER-PRIV005706
OCC-CER-PRIV005719
OCC-CER-PRIV005741
OCC-CER-PRIV005742

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV005746
OCC-CER-PRIV005753

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV005755
OCC-CER-PRIV005756
OCC-CER-PRIV005777
OCC-CER-PRIV005796
OCC-CER-PRIV005799

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 124 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 144 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65716
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV005823
OCC-CER-PRIV005893
OCC-CER-PRIV005895

Privilege Designation
Produce
Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV005901
OCC-CER-PRIV005982

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV005990
OCC-CER-PRIV005994
OCC-CER-PRIV005995
OCC-CER-PRIV006000
OCC-CER-PRIV006001
OCC-CER-PRIV006019
OCC-CER-PRIV006021
OCC-CER-PRIV006095

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV006104

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006120
OCC-CER-PRIV006133
OCC-CER-PRIV006135

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV006158

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006159
OCC-CER-PRIV006201
OCC-CER-PRIV006275
OCC-CER-PRIV006299

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV006322

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 125 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 145 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65717
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV006323

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006324

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006332
OCC-CER-PRIV006377
OCC-CER-PRIV006398
OCC-CER-PRIV006405
OCC-CER-PRIV006407
OCC-CER-PRIV006417
OCC-CER-PRIV006418
OCC-CER-PRIV006436
OCC-CER-PRIV006437
OCC-CER-PRIV006441

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV006442

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006443

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006444

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006455
OCC-CER-PRIV006465

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV006467

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006470
OCC-CER-PRIV006476

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV006477
OCC-CER-PRIV006484

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 126 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 146 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65718
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV006493

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006494

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006495

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV006496
OCC-CER-PRIV006498

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV006499
OCC-CER-PRIV006500
OCC-CER-PRIV006504
OCC-CER-PRIV006506
OCC-CER-PRIV006515

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV006649
OCC-CER-PRIV006668
OCC-CER-PRIV006670
OCC-CER-PRIV006671
OCC-CER-PRIV006678
OCC-CER-PRIV006690
OCC-CER-PRIV006707
OCC-CER-PRIV006708
OCC-CER-PRIV006770
OCC-CER-PRIV006772
OCC-CER-PRIV006777
OCC-CER-PRIV006782
OCC-CER-PRIV006783
OCC-CER-PRIV006788
OCC-CER-PRIV006791

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 127 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 147 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65719
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV006795
OCC-CER-PRIV006848
OCC-CER-PRIV006861
OCC-CER-PRIV007033
OCC-CER-PRIV007034
OCC-CER-PRIV007037
OCC-CER-PRIV007038

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV007042

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV007080

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV007098

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV007102
OCC-CER-PRIV007120
OCC-CER-PRIV007121
OCC-CER-PRIV007124

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV007130

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV007138
OCC-CER-PRIV007146
OCC-CER-PRIV007152
OCC-CER-PRIV007191
OCC-CER-PRIV007192
OCC-CER-PRIV007193
OCC-CER-PRIV007218
OCC-CER-PRIV007219
OCC-CER-PRIV007340
OCC-CER-PRIV007362

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 128 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 148 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65720
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV007374

Privilege Designation
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV007377
OCC-CER-PRIV007379
OCC-CER-PRIV007390
OCC-CER-PRIV007391
OCC-CER-PRIV007416
OCC-CER-PRIV007417
OCC-CER-PRIV007418
OCC-CER-PRIV007419
OCC-CER-PRIV007420
OCC-CER-PRIV007440
OCC-CER-PRIV007451

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV007454
OCC-CER-PRIV007461
OCC-CER-PRIV007462
OCC-CER-PRIV007499
OCC-CER-PRIV007503
OCC-CER-PRIV007507
OCC-CER-PRIV007515
OCC-CER-PRIV007516
OCC-CER-PRIV007519
OCC-CER-PRIV007529
OCC-CER-PRIV007600
OCC-CER-PRIV007601
OCC-CER-PRIV007614
OCC-CER-PRIV007640
OCC-CER-PRIV007641
OCC-CER-PRIV007643

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 129 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 149 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65721
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV007645
OCC-CER-PRIV007646
OCC-CER-PRIV007868
OCC-CER-PRIV007910
OCC-CER-PRIV007952
OCC-CER-PRIV007968

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV007979

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV007997
OCC-CER-PRIV007998
OCC-CER-PRIV008031

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV008032

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008033
OCC-CER-PRIV008037
OCC-CER-PRIV008042
OCC-CER-PRIV008087
OCC-CER-PRIV008088
OCC-CER-PRIV008094
OCC-CER-PRIV008095
OCC-CER-PRIV008096
OCC-CER-PRIV008097
OCC-CER-PRIV008101
OCC-CER-PRIV008102
OCC-CER-PRIV008103
OCC-CER-PRIV008104
OCC-CER-PRIV008107
OCC-CER-PRIV008148

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 130 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 150 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65722
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV008154

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008163

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008169
OCC-CER-PRIV008174
OCC-CER-PRIV008176
OCC-CER-PRIV008179
OCC-CER-PRIV008186

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV008191

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008205

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008206

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008207

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008214

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008216

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008218
OCC-CER-PRIV008219
OCC-CER-PRIV008225
OCC-CER-PRIV008230
OCC-CER-PRIV008246

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV008253
OCC-CER-PRIV008302
OCC-CER-PRIV008306

Withhold
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 131 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 151 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65723
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV008307
OCC-CER-PRIV008311
OCC-CER-PRIV008316

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV008341

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008343

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008345
OCC-CER-PRIV008490
OCC-CER-PRIV008500

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV008501
OCC-CER-PRIV008502

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV008506
OCC-CER-PRIV008508
OCC-CER-PRIV008532
OCC-CER-PRIV008559

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV008593

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008603
OCC-CER-PRIV008604

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including outside counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

OCC-CER-PRIV008610

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008615

Withhold

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Withhold

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including
in-house counsel as recipient to obtain legal advice

OCC-CER-PRIV008616

Page 132 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 152 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65724
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV008628

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008635

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008638
OCC-CER-PRIV008647
OCC-CER-PRIV008651

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV008692

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008695
OCC-CER-PRIV008713
OCC-CER-PRIV008750
OCC-CER-PRIV008751
OCC-CER-PRIV008757
OCC-CER-PRIV008768
OCC-CER-PRIV008859
OCC-CER-PRIV008860
OCC-CER-PRIV008861
OCC-CER-PRIV008864

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV008886

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV008891
OCC-CER-PRIV008894
OCC-CER-PRIV008937
OCC-CER-PRIV008946
OCC-CER-PRIV008947
OCC-CER-PRIV008963
OCC-CER-PRIV008968

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 133 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 153 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65725
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV009106

Privilege Designation
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV009111

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV009113

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV009115
OCC-CER-PRIV009149

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV009154

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV009155

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV009163

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV009167
OCC-CER-PRIV009168

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV009190
OCC-CER-PRIV009221
OCC-CER-PRIV009223
OCC-CER-PRIV009238
OCC-CER-PRIV009245

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV009254
OCC-CER-PRIV009261
OCC-CER-PRIV009355
OCC-CER-PRIV009463
OCC-CER-PRIV009486
OCC-CER-PRIV009852
OCC-CER-PRIV009954
OCC-CER-PRIV009955

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Page 134 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 154 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65726
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV009970
OCC-CER-PRIV009974
OCC-CER-PRIV009979
OCC-CER-PRIV009989
OCC-CER-PRIV009992
OCC-CER-PRIV009993
OCC-CER-PRIV010003
OCC-CER-PRIV010004
OCC-CER-PRIV010005
OCC-CER-PRIV010009
OCC-CER-PRIV010016
OCC-CER-PRIV010022
OCC-CER-PRIV010026
OCC-CER-PRIV010030
OCC-CER-PRIV010042
OCC-CER-PRIV010044
OCC-CER-PRIV010045
OCC-CER-PRIV010048
OCC-CER-PRIV010049
OCC-CER-PRIV010074
OCC-CER-PRIV010079
OCC-CER-PRIV010080
OCC-CER-PRIV010084
OCC-CER-PRIV010087
OCC-CER-PRIV010094
OCC-CER-PRIV010098
OCC-CER-PRIV010104
OCC-CER-PRIV010105
OCC-CER-PRIV010106

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Page 135 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 155 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65727
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV010125
OCC-CER-PRIV010126
OCC-CER-PRIV010127

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV010128
OCC-CER-PRIV010133
OCC-CER-PRIV010153

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV010154
OCC-CER-PRIV010159
OCC-CER-PRIV010167
OCC-CER-PRIV010201
OCC-CER-PRIV010203
OCC-CER-PRIV010205
OCC-CER-PRIV010206
OCC-CER-PRIV010222
OCC-CER-PRIV010225
OCC-CER-PRIV010227
OCC-CER-PRIV010228
OCC-CER-PRIV010233
OCC-CER-PRIV010236
OCC-CER-PRIV010247
OCC-CER-PRIV010261
OCC-CER-PRIV010297
OCC-CER-PRIV010302
OCC-CER-PRIV010313
OCC-CER-PRIV010320
OCC-CER-PRIV010326
OCC-CER-PRIV010328
OCC-CER-PRIV010330

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 136 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 156 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65728
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV010332
OCC-CER-PRIV010341
OCC-CER-PRIV010345
OCC-CER-PRIV010346
OCC-CER-PRIV010354
OCC-CER-PRIV010364
OCC-CER-PRIV010366
OCC-CER-PRIV010372
OCC-CER-PRIV010374
OCC-CER-PRIV010377
OCC-CER-PRIV010382
OCC-CER-PRIV010393
OCC-CER-PRIV010401
OCC-CER-PRIV010403
OCC-CER-PRIV010413
OCC-CER-PRIV010418
OCC-CER-PRIV010419
OCC-CER-PRIV010420
OCC-CER-PRIV010421
OCC-CER-PRIV010422
OCC-CER-PRIV010425
OCC-CER-PRIV010429
OCC-CER-PRIV010431
OCC-CER-PRIV010440
OCC-CER-PRIV010446
OCC-CER-PRIV010450
OCC-CER-PRIV010469

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Page 137 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 157 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65729
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV010472
OCC-CER-PRIV010479
OCC-CER-PRIV010503

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV010521

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010524

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010525
OCC-CER-PRIV010532
OCC-CER-PRIV010534

Withhold
Produce
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010576

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010577
OCC-CER-PRIV010600
OCC-CER-PRIV010601

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV010605
OCC-CER-PRIV010611

Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010612

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010613

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010618
OCC-CER-PRIV010627
OCC-CER-PRIV010629
OCC-CER-PRIV010630
OCC-CER-PRIV010635

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege

Page 138 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 158 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65730
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV010645

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010647
OCC-CER-PRIV010670
OCC-CER-PRIV010676
OCC-CER-PRIV010677

Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010742

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010779
OCC-CER-PRIV010787
OCC-CER-PRIV010788

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV010806

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV010808
OCC-CER-PRIV010812

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV010829
OCC-CER-PRIV010833
OCC-CER-PRIV010835
OCC-CER-PRIV010856
OCC-CER-PRIV010857
OCC-CER-PRIV010858
OCC-CER-PRIV010871
OCC-CER-PRIV010883
OCC-CER-PRIV010888

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV010909
OCC-CER-PRIV010926

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 139 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 159 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65731
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV010944
OCC-CER-PRIV010945
OCC-CER-PRIV010946
OCC-CER-PRIV011031
OCC-CER-PRIV011053
OCC-CER-PRIV011055
OCC-CER-PRIV011061
OCC-CER-PRIV011063
OCC-CER-PRIV011066
OCC-CER-PRIV011081
OCC-CER-PRIV011105
OCC-CER-PRIV011106
OCC-CER-PRIV011109

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV011122
OCC-CER-PRIV011138
OCC-CER-PRIV011151
OCC-CER-PRIV011155
OCC-CER-PRIV011162
OCC-CER-PRIV011172
OCC-CER-PRIV011201
OCC-CER-PRIV011223
OCC-CER-PRIV011231
OCC-CER-PRIV011232
OCC-CER-PRIV011248

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV011254
OCC-CER-PRIV011279

Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 140 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 160 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65732
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV011282
OCC-CER-PRIV011283
OCC-CER-PRIV011284
OCC-CER-PRIV011286
OCC-CER-PRIV011294
OCC-CER-PRIV011310
OCC-CER-PRIV011334
OCC-CER-PRIV011335
OCC-CER-PRIV011336
OCC-CER-PRIV011338
OCC-CER-PRIV011343

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011351
OCC-CER-PRIV011355
OCC-CER-PRIV011356
OCC-CER-PRIV011357
OCC-CER-PRIV011359

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV011360

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011364
OCC-CER-PRIV011428
OCC-CER-PRIV011458

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011459

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011468

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011469

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 141 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 161 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65733
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV011472
OCC-CER-PRIV011477
OCC-CER-PRIV011485
OCC-CER-PRIV011486
OCC-CER-PRIV011487

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011570
OCC-CER-PRIV011582
OCC-CER-PRIV011604

Withhold
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV011605

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011620
OCC-CER-PRIV011677
OCC-CER-PRIV011705
OCC-CER-PRIV011706
OCC-CER-PRIV011710

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011719
OCC-CER-PRIV011742
OCC-CER-PRIV011743
OCC-CER-PRIV011756
OCC-CER-PRIV011775
OCC-CER-PRIV011776
OCC-CER-PRIV011781

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011833
OCC-CER-PRIV011835
OCC-CER-PRIV011839
OCC-CER-PRIV011840
OCC-CER-PRIV011842

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Page 142 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 162 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65734
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV011848
OCC-CER-PRIV011850
OCC-CER-PRIV011863
OCC-CER-PRIV011864
OCC-CER-PRIV011866
OCC-CER-PRIV011868
OCC-CER-PRIV011870
OCC-CER-PRIV011916

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV011971
OCC-CER-PRIV011972

Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011981

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV011982
OCC-CER-PRIV011988
OCC-CER-PRIV011994
OCC-CER-PRIV011996
OCC-CER-PRIV012000
OCC-CER-PRIV012002
OCC-CER-PRIV012013
OCC-CER-PRIV012016
OCC-CER-PRIV012019
OCC-CER-PRIV012023
OCC-CER-PRIV012029
OCC-CER-PRIV012031
OCC-CER-PRIV012035
OCC-CER-PRIV012041

Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege

Work Product Privilege

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice; Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication
with outside counsel seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 143 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 163 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65735
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV012045
OCC-CER-PRIV012049
OCC-CER-PRIV012052
OCC-CER-PRIV012057
OCC-CER-PRIV012059
OCC-CER-PRIV012061
OCC-CER-PRIV012062
OCC-CER-PRIV012065
OCC-CER-PRIV012066
OCC-CER-PRIV012067
OCC-CER-PRIV012068
OCC-CER-PRIV012069
OCC-CER-PRIV012070
OCC-CER-PRIV012071
OCC-CER-PRIV012072
OCC-CER-PRIV012073
OCC-CER-PRIV012074
OCC-CER-PRIV012075
OCC-CER-PRIV012077
OCC-CER-PRIV012078
OCC-CER-PRIV012079
OCC-CER-PRIV012080
OCC-CER-PRIV012081
OCC-CER-PRIV012082
OCC-CER-PRIV012083
OCC-CER-PRIV012084
OCC-CER-PRIV012085
OCC-CER-PRIV012087
OCC-CER-PRIV012096

Privilege Designation
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Withhold
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege
Work Product Privilege

Page 144 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 164 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65736
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV012097

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012099
OCC-CER-PRIV012100
OCC-CER-PRIV012106
OCC-CER-PRIV012108

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012112

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012113
OCC-CER-PRIV012124

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012125

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012130

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012132

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012142

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012156
OCC-CER-PRIV012291
OCC-CER-PRIV012292
OCC-CER-PRIV012293
OCC-CER-PRIV012294
OCC-CER-PRIV012296
OCC-CER-PRIV012298
OCC-CER-PRIV012306
OCC-CER-PRIV012323
OCC-CER-PRIV012329
OCC-CER-PRIV012338

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 145 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 165 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65737
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number
OCC-CER-PRIV012340
OCC-CER-PRIV012342

Privilege Designation
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012352
OCC-CER-PRIV012354

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012365

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012389
OCC-CER-PRIV012407

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012408

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012409
OCC-CER-PRIV012474
OCC-CER-PRIV012481
OCC-CER-PRIV012486

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012488
OCC-CER-PRIV012497
OCC-CER-PRIV012498
OCC-CER-PRIV012502
OCC-CER-PRIV012504
OCC-CER-PRIV012505
OCC-CER-PRIV012508
OCC-CER-PRIV012513
OCC-CER-PRIV012516
OCC-CER-PRIV012522
OCC-CER-PRIV012527
OCC-CER-PRIV012531
OCC-CER-PRIV012535

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce
Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Work Product Privilege

Page 146 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 166 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65738
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV012541
OCC-CER-PRIV012675
OCC-CER-PRIV012696
OCC-CER-PRIV012789

Withhold
Produce
Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012833
OCC-CER-PRIV012835
OCC-CER-PRIV012851
OCC-CER-PRIV012854

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012857
OCC-CER-PRIV012858
OCC-CER-PRIV012859
OCC-CER-PRIV012861
OCC-CER-PRIV012867

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012868

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012870
OCC-CER-PRIV012871
OCC-CER-PRIV012872
OCC-CER-PRIV012883

Withhold
Produce
Produce
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012885

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012886

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012896

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012898

Withhold

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with outside counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – communication including in-house counsel as
recipient to obtain legal advice

Page 147 of 148

Case 2:18-cv-11273-MCA-LDW Document 2286 Filed 03/01/23 Page 167 of 167 PageID:
Occidental v. 21 Century Fox
65739
Civil Action No. 18-11273
Spcial Master Decision
Schedule A

Control Number

Privilege Designation

OCC-CER-PRIV012907
OCC-CER-PRIV012911

Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012917
OCC-CER-PRIV012921

Withhold
Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012923

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012924

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012933
OCC-CER-PRIV012936

Withhold
Produce

OCC-CER-PRIV012937

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012940

Withhold

OCC-CER-PRIV012941
OCC-CER-PRIV012953
OCC-CER-PRIV012970

Withhold
Produce
Produce

Special Master Privilege Determination
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Work Product Privilege
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice
Attorney-client privileged communication – direct communication with in-house counsel
seeking legal advice

Page 148 of 148