Youngers v. BHC Mesilla Valley Hospital, LLC et al

Filing 112

ORDER by District Judge Judith C. Herrera Adopting Proposed Findings and Recommended Disposition 105 , approving settlement as described herein. (Attachments: # 1 Redacted document) (baw)

Case 1:20-cv-00686-JCH-LF Document 112 Filed 12/14/22 Page 1 of 3

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO
JOLEEN YOUNGERS, as Personal
Representative of the Wrongful Death Estate of
Deven Chavez, and C.C., a minor child,
Plaintiffs,
v.

1:20-cv-00686-JCH-LF

BHC MESILLA VALLEY HOSPITAL, LLC,
SANJOY BANIK, M.D., and JOHN DOES 1-10,
Defendants.
ORDER ADOPTING MAGISTRATE JUDGE’S
PROPOSED FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDED DISPOSITION
The Magistrate Judge filed her Proposed Findings and Recommended Disposition
(“PFRD”) on November 18, 2022. Doc. 105. The proposed findings notified the parties of their
ability to file objections within fourteen (14) days and that failure to do so waived appellate
review. Id. at 8. To date, none of the parties have filed objections and the time to do so has now
passed. The Court, therefore, adopts the magistrate judge’s proposed findings and recommended
disposition.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that the Court adopts the magistrate judge’s proposed
findings and recommended disposition and approves the settlement as follows:
1) The Court approves the allocation and distribution of the settlement proceeds and the
payment of plaintiffs’ attorney’s fees as outlined in sealed ex parte exhibit 1 (Doc.
107).
2) Payment to C.C. will be used to purchase a structured annuity as set forth in
Attachment A to this order. Attachment A has been redacted to protect the privacy of

Case 1:20-cv-00686-JCH-LF Document 112 Filed 12/14/22 Page 2 of 3

the minor child and to maintain the confidentiality of the agreement. An unredacted
copy of Attachment A has been filed separately, under seal, and is incorporated into
this order in its entirety by reference. See Doc. 106.
3) The Court releases Ms. Collins from her duties as guardian ad litem. The three
parties will each pay one-third of her fees.
4) The parties must file closing documents within 30 days of this order, absent a written
motion showing good cause for an extension.
5) The details of the settlement, including the settlement amounts, shall remain
confidential. The Court will impose the annuity schedule as outlined in unredacted
Attachment A (Doc. 106) to this order. Unredacted Attachment A (Doc. 106) and the
details regarding the amount of the settlement shall not be disclosed to anyone other
than the plaintiffs, their counsel and staff, the GAL, and the entities assisting in
establishing the annuity, absent prior Court order. The structured settlement annuity
set forth in unredacted Attachment A (Doc. 106) is in C.C.’s best interest, and its
terms are material, integral and inseparable elements of the Court’s approval of the
settlement and are essential to this Court’s determination of fairness.
6) Pursuant to the Structured Settlement Protection Act, NMSA 1978 §39-1A-4(C) and
this Court’s continuing jurisdiction over this matter, the Court prohibits the transfer of
the structured settlement payment rights, as reflected in unredacted Attachment A
(Doc. 106), at any time. Any attempt by a third-party to access or assign said funds

2

Case 1:20-cv-00686-JCH-LF Document 112 Filed 12/14/22 Page 3 of 3

or payments designated for annuity investment will be considered a violation of this
order, and any petition for the transfer of the structured settlement payment rights
must be filed in this Court and cause of action.

_______________________________________
SENIOR UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

3