Rosenberg et al v. Lashkar-E-Taiba et al
Filing
14
AFFIDAVIT/DECLARATION in Support re 12 MOTION to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction Declaration of Kevin J. Walsh filed by Inter-Services Intelligence of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, Ahmed Shuja Pasha, Nadeem Taj. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Exhibit A to the Walsh Declaration, # 2 Exhibit Exhibit B to the Walsh Declaration, # 3 Exhibit Exhibit C to the Walsh Declaration, # 4 Exhibit Exhibit D to the Walsh Declaration, # 5 Exhibit Exhibit E to the Walsh Declaration, # 6 Exhibit Exhibit F to the Walsh Declaration, # 7 Exhibit Exhibit G to the Walsh Declaration, # 8 Exhibit Exhibit H to the Walsh Declaration, # 9 Exhibit Exhibit I to the Walsh Declaration, # 10 Exhibit Exhibit J to the Walsh Declaration, # 11 Exhibit Exhibit K to the Walsh Declaration, # 12 Exhibit Exhibit L to the Walsh Declaration, # 13 Exhibit Exhibit M to the Walsh Declaration, # 14 Exhibit Exhibit N to the Walsh Declaration, # 15 Exhibit Exhibit O to the Walsh Declaration, # 16 Exhibit Exhibit P to the Walsh Declaration, # 17 Exhibit Exhibit Q to the Walsh Declaration, # 18 Exhibit Exhibit R to the Walsh Declaration, # 19 Exhibit Exhibit S to the Walsh Declaration, # 20 Exhibit Exhibit T to the Walsh Declaration, # 21 Exhibit Exhibit U to the Walsh Declaration, # 22 Exhibit Exhibit V to the Walsh Declaration, # 23 Exhibit Exhibit W to the Walsh Declaration, # 24 Exhibit Exhibit X to the Walsh Declaration, # 25 Exhibit Exhibit Y to the Walsh Declaration, # 26 Exhibit Exhibit Z to the Walsh Declaration, # 27 Exhibit Exhibit AA to the Walsh Declaration, # 28 Exhibit Exhibit AB to the Walsh Declaration, # 29 Exhibit Exhibit AC to the Walsh Declaration, # 30 Exhibit Exhibit AD to the Walsh Declaration, # 31 Exhibit Exhibit AE to the Walsh Declaration, # 32 Exhibit Exhibit AF to the Walsh Declaration, # 33 Exhibit Exhibit AG to the Walsh Declaration) (Walsh, Kevin)
EXHIBIT
O
023 568
11431 6
76
94
2 76 2
73626 33116
985265 6215
2
6 6
7 3
5238 6 2152 2 6
7
0 3
7
9852
2 65 6 32 6123
2156 355321 6 50
16
7
6
9 3
53
8
6 30516 441376
53256
2263731 63237 136573 6 17
!"%%
6#6 "6
$
6
&
'(*,)& +0& -*45/ /&8)9:(-&;& +(>;?+8*&&+@A&-8A=&
)+ -./+1 3-& ,6+ 4+& )308< &*&?;=-==?;*/)&?)/
2)
7 &
;=
0;
;&8&<;=&& 4)*=-)AC3>)D
-;+ <+>*B<(->)&-&)*=-&
/ &
:;*(&A?+& +>) 6A&-&/& F=)/&-=& 6F)AH/ I/(D:(>G*&/
-4=&/)=;&F,))1 A= -G*& @F & .)81-& G& F*& *& F6&
E &L,;=>&-)A=-=& /*4& =&/&)/>;&&
&K(@>=;C3>)& = &)= & -(DE&A*;& ,/= >G* 30F A+&-)
&
-( J
& * ; - ( /
+-/;&?M1& FN*&/+=+& *=-G(->/+M-//&/PDD )*=-O+=4M
)4&<;*>&G*& -OM/)0'F ;& /&(& ;@->= & OQ 3>)&=)/*&
= E F;
/
( C
I*F4/*&F,))&-&)>=/PDD//)*-=&/.)8& -//MDR(F&/.)8&
);8& E) 6A)AF A& & O& F4= & = & 6F <+-/& * = & 6F
->
/ ( A ; ;( ';
& /(
';<+-/SUTWTW[\]Z^WXT^_`W_^_VZbYZTcUeUW]f`\TTV `gV
-//M&TVW YZV XV Z_W TVW W aSVZXWXdV^^WV T g[h^VZ
X
_ ] TZ ] W
VU
`
/8F&*-;&j>M/>8&=)/*& );8& +*4k+8&
i)F>4**)=M,*4;& &/F&< &8M>8&>=;
_ _U
W W
S
@&
C3>)&& =6+ qL& //)A;(+ ?; -&@->r*M8*4);(+ 4)*=)*=-*oM;/& qD:(>&-&=/& M,*4//=&& FA-&-=/& (->)Q
p &
8
B<
C3>)Q *AO)/&*=+F /*4F=+(>0)&&+&)=<&/*>;& F>;/&
)*=-P-= &==>=F/)& = & /&*&/+ )/?+& &>+/&< /=->
/
+) ,/ - ) = r
;)
,*
M-FA-& =&/s[ _UXW_UmT_[)>>,/=< 8&+4/>*& M,6+ qq&
;M8*4G* = & \^^WT^ dV`_Z&>/> -& & + ;+>& I// /& JD
((
]
;; ? p
&
B>C/*/= ) &*+=AN>&&G& />);&8& +& )&& 4)*=-)AC3>)&
&+>A-& ,)+=)/& = < G/3&41 + /k;F-B<(->)&-&)*=o6 // 8 )/
; '; *
*&F)9;A>8=A> -F1-&//=Ft)A1-&+@-&>+=+&&;(M8=*>&&
>M/+&&*+?1*,)= & AA<)&Q /)& A?//==& 8-=6=&;-+/DE
=
& /)
)
)
*/ ;
&
?+**)/&&/uFpq&;*0+@/ & A*&F>&;>F=-G*&/+=+& *=-&
)= ?=A*= &)FqL?F & *GDB-& M;/M-8=* & =OM/)0'F ;1
M -( &
M/ & ); (
OM/)0k)/1 ,*)& F-& -+F /+/>& )>A+& 3-/+&-&)=+;1-&
/+=+& =>& +F F 1 /)& =)81 >);>v*/6+0)AC= >-& A
BA 58/ k/ C B,6
/ )
I+O)1 &=+4-0=) (>6/& +*4=//>0=&/?* F,/=SVXU[_dV
D((& */)/M& ,&)&/-G;3-&+F>F& (F& / -&ZwZ^ZWU
& ,0/
* ; ,? =
>+=4DR/;& &+8A& = + F*)& A
& )
,?
; /
(
& ;?= )
A?; =&-)/ -& =& 4)*=-&)*=-&-&=/&<8-*F;-+/&)&@F/&
*F,)*/44,/= (B<(->)1 3>)1 A;(+-F/= & 8=*>(>/;@A
M
G*
C )
* )M
>4**)=&*M& &+=<**F**=&/+4;&&)8+&qL&+-*48&F>+;
*--/,0<>& =;= & *-*y-)0pq1 *4-&>M;/&&
0
*; @ &(/ 6
=
F= -;&/M-F=
)*== &&8)F&-& ;)F& ;8* &<(&;<*D
*)
/ ; = M&
&
H; //*&*& +&?)/=(-*&)*=-& //G/(@&/-)>/A& +@,/=G(+& = >,;/)?+-&)& C3>)1 +& &)/>/&&=)0* ;/ -&&
>(
= G(
,?
*
;+ *=+F/)*-(?& & ,6+&<(>M,,*/&)/+M4*/1 )&)?-&&
8&F/)&F= >*DB>,/ />;&*&; =/(@& ;-zA& = ?/>*
6) + ; &
=
= /
G( ( C3>)&)&/ -;>* F)*-&;&-0<+ 8&;F&& 4)*=-&8&F;<+(&
)*=-(>=,/A8& * = >-= F& & + )>*B<(->)1 = >& &/
+
,?M ; ; ; ; 4 6 ) ;=
>)*=&< ;=Q -+F *&-& + O&)*-F/8*DR/(@&/-?+8-&+/
=6F0;& 8('/=)& ))A< & D = )& M+=& &)/6/&8>*4= /&
* O
B> ; PD - ; > 0&
(
;NM*/&* F-;>0*&)*=-& |-)M-&=6F0{;*MF/;; M&-&/8*|&
6/= >>,8= /8F& C3>)9J& (-*4>)*=& F*)1M-,*1 A>M+= }
@
)
{/
*?= &
)
0
~nmX^lwUTdVZUeVl^UVX\^WV ]WXTZVT^W_T[WZ_W[
V m]W VT^W_U]_^ZTT_W WZ UUhSV ZW_wUTV_V V ^ V
U _
Z
S
S Z
O)/}-& |-;+4-&&F>+/)*-(?6= /&F,))&-& 6F& +8()
==>& A{ & M8)*4)M;/&F= >*&/G/-E) 6A)A.)8D:(;4&&
) j/
+ ;
>
&
M+4>;&+4/>& ;&/<+=* && +&)&&
)/8FMF )/&?+)(& )/>/-&*-&< ;+>Du+(& >&,/*,;/= -)
0 6
G/
? & = *= - (
AMA1 &M4*/)A)//44-&/?;F&< )*=-;&/+/*,)/*=+>>)A
/)/& + ;-z&-&+&-)*4= &/?/;& 3>)&-= *&4= =& //=&-&
G//
(
C
( F* ?*+=>&@-)& &-;+4&+)/&;F6+=-*&+)&< =)&=+>D
+;*/1 /&>G//M8)/4/=+ F ;)* & )/>;& 8F-//=&
*/
M) ;,8 * &
&
CF*)F1 T^W_UYe`_T[\^WXVTZUSeVZW[^WVV`WZcUT`V
;*MF & UTdV^^TV_V `Tc` [XVTZUWZV ]TXT^ `VWgZ
= 0C
^
^ Z
`_ Ze
/8F+8 )&&>F;&M-&;>*=-F/;,>& /84)/&-&=-**APDD
i*6*,&>)+ 8=/= -=8* )&<+ D:(&?+AA)A*/>& OQ
*
/ &+ M =; + &
C3>)&=)/*& );81 *(OM/)0'F=-)Au+*-5**=+ //(&;@-A*&
)*=-O+=4MI*F4/& M&/+=+& *;&-&;/4& ->/& +>* -//&
G(
t8 M
-
QQ
p&
5)M1)&+@AA)<) G;3=&-)/C3>)&-,88F+;*/&-&>*=A=/
+(& >?;*/&& ,/ +& /44&)*=-;& =)& *+=>)A)>>/& &
(
+
;
? *
(
C3>)*;/- -&&=8=+-&<+ &+M)&&-Q/,&=6F0&
)*=-& @+,/=->+M8*4+ ;,>M8*F;F 4=+ >)*=D&
4
*
/
=;
*&
&
Y_\^T`aT^W_U`TZUSeV [V _VnSAM>;>-M>)0=& /&/
]] Y` V UTdV [XVTZ\TZ\TcW lV/**-&//>+& ,/=(&
cw
Z
]
; =
\nn`VlZ[Y_^]U]VZf dVW_Q0)+/ -DB>)+>FC3>)&)&(&
WT`TXZV][W _VSV UbT[6&4/,/=& && 8= )*=-(>>*=A
c
^ W
& / &
<; /;; MM**&&&/*A;&M-,*&M@+Do=/&8(AM>;>)A+<+ & F
+,&M-,*&+>>=)?+;&< ;; M+ ;/0& (+;4&/**-&-& ;,>G*&
;
/
/ & =
/
F
6&//>+&&-8/=)&)*=-+,)-&-=/?=&G)A&M-,*&/<8)0=/>+& = 3>)& *>;& &)(= +>/;; M>F& <**-0& +
; (C /
( ;
>
&
;/(8/&>*=-/?;+,>& A&;>6/6&/F-,)3v-)MAC+-+(?G*&
@+)FA)>>)M&+4) 1 /?>*F&0= & A +& (-/&)=/>*& =
,)
()
(
C3>)& =G*&/?+*<+/=//+<+ &&+)&8()&-+0& /&F;G*& +(+
)*=-BM1 F(F& -;M& >& ;,>*)/>>M&>//4D 0)>& F< =/&
&F / ( / :(
F8
* +@&8&F=-(?G*&/C3>)*/?/6&*-F 4;+8?+& +A+>*4
,?;/;+/)* >*& == &)*=-& ;F&0>4)* &8& ?;=;& A/>-&
+ ;
((
?
- > <)
wUTdV >&+>*4?;F,>&
T^W_U\]= />-&+6/ D&
?
&
&
:(>&+4) & 8A-=)/6/&;>6/G* ;=(>M\\^ZdVTZU^ZSeV
//?;+,>G;F&;& @&/-?>*F& = 8&*&] WZU` [XSmV VTZ
(
( =
W Z
V
6/&-)/&&&8>)=/A);8&-(G&&/==8=+&8&>*=-/=& ,*/*&
/-/44A*)>6=-* &*F4/;&; =6>&+M8/;+ >>)M& ,)* z&>
@
; >
)
;
=
* )=)AE;3<+ +&&;=8AM;/MF6+=-)&*)& +07 4+x/,)&
,?M1-&F;& G)A=M-* /&F>&;F ;)* &>* =F +Q8)Q + & & ; ; ) ; -* ./
<-*4M,/&-*/& 8F& ;=-&&)>4&< M-=8=-o?;=-=& -& &
8A-&; >;F Dvi)F* +)=>?>)/;& ;>+M* & ?+8* ;/{
- & 0,? *
2/
;
0 2o|
F4>)*-& *(G;F& +(+ ;>/&8&<;=&&=6F/wUTd&;A++)&0
/*F= 1 M& 8A< =/& F=+ + <+>=>)*z&T^W_U6+/&/>6&
; G(
8 6 ;/ ; *
)
M/= 4F*/;; M;?+8*/D& >G;F&F;>?;= )*=-&M-=8=-/<+>
+)* &M=M-,*&?;=-=>&2o& 8A)>&8?+& 3>)*/;>+M* &<;=&
- *&
*&
C +
;
*&/6+/&+)&0>* F=4/;; M;?+8*D
-= &;A+ />6&= )* &M-,*&?;=-=&
(
)
,8 0
&
o-M8=+/++> *>/1 +,/5**=+ F-&-&+>A-&)A+&)/8*A=/
&;-/=+;*,& 8>& * & ->/& )* AC/*/= +)* @&-= & &
> C
k* )
( /(
C3>)*/?/r*M8*4=/;?>=-rgS_VZwUT^ `TcU]_^Z^VZ
)*=-& ;F&& FA-& &?;*;&&Z^[W VT^W_V ^XdVZUeV W V
? (
*
S
\^W
_S
=*)&+)DR/M-;& +/&)&/C3>)*/?/)A),/& +/&)/,)/(4&
+6F />& &)-=;4=(=(&)*=-& ;F&-&+ A< M>(@& A&8/
) &
< ==
?
;
>M**/&>?+&<(><4=& &/?>& -();/&M+>;&-M-&)*=->(@&/)+)&)= &*& (DE = &)= =&F-1 ;/&<-;/= 3>)*&)/6/&
; = * &-( ,;
> * C
3FA;& 8AA*&8MA&=M>& -+A&<(8)A&< )*=->(@&F;(A=/+
*/&+ -/& >**/)= 3D8A/>;&;>->;& 3>)*&)/)>&)& *&
F G; ) &
=
C
(
F/&?-/D&
* >8/AA&
@
&
&
B>OM/)0'F=-/ (>zAA+-&/& =6+ qL@>=-&4*&=(& +(O+=4M
&/+=+& *;&,?)*/&8*4(+ ;/& q&**)A))-)&/5)M&=)/*&
oM p &
=
I*F4/&/B,/*)&/?/G*&;=8&&=-&0=/C3>)*/?/*&/+* &<
);81(& +M-?;F& FM-* /=>)A6& &)*=-& ;F& = *&,/;&
=
F - ;
(
? -( =
-/DRZTZm][WVZWZh]`dVXZWXe[X U^W_ZWV^mTZVT^W_UT[
/A& VXVXnV gV V X[U` lUV ]^ZV V UUTYV [U`Y[wUT^V_V
&
] S
T m ]T
]
G/G*&8F&-=)&8?+1>E-;-/&8*4,0y-&**=&)*=-& BE )AO)/
& F6* ;& = ?;=)&)-8MAA+-& &8/@>=;C3>)DPO I&-&==&
F A (> & &
&
&
)/M-*8-&&+@A&&-/;&=6F)*-)>>)M&&;=M-F=+)DR/)?/*=&
+&;= *4=?;*/)+ 4&< )*z= &>*=-/*?>Q;<*&/>& &?+M)/
- ;
) > *;
M) &
W^V \\^ZdVnmXV +-;)*/)?;M/&&-8*4=)&*&>*=-/+)(>
SU] WZUUm]W;&-@= &?+)(>=/>+-& =(>)>>)M& M/&
W
<* @
;
(=
/
C3>)*; -=>,;==A6&*F-/)A,;=--/&< 8&8?+D:(;4&*&
)*=-& ,,8*/& >&&&/A;& + ?;=& +8(=>
M
* )
*
;> &
(
)>>)M&-&/ ,;*&-&A;M,,8*)*-&+4) 1 &+&/?-&/C3>)*
>*=-/)A-G& 6F)A+ *&; -M= >?;+,>& )/(F*4= &)*=-&
/ )
;
G/
(
?;F&&@+; &//=/ >&)+=/)A/A=/MM/;&+,*=*F-/&
/?/=;/M,/= &+,*= +)* &-&-& &0F&< =/ >&;/MD
;
(
- @
(
/ @
&
o8& M>A>M+=&>*=-/)AM;/M;/)*-G*&/C3>)* F)0)/&<;+/&
+;8/&/8* )>>)M&-&F>&;?+= & == &)*=-& *+&+1 & 8>1
<
0
; ((
,*= ; M
M*MF;F& X n`^lwUT^]_Z^UXZYVTT^WUT[UT^lwUTdV
+=)&;> V ^ _VT^W_V nWX_nl_cYmg`^ V_VSm_VT^W_U
* = ]g [
Y
^Z
M8=+/++> ;/)*-Dv@-)& &M/>&8&**)&>*=-/F@F1&/*@& &
;-/=+;*,&?+= >& /&>G/* +)/;+ @F-)>>)M& />&6F /G/
; &
M*
/ E /
,8= *=*&8&/8*&>*=-/)A))==;/ +*4-/>&
>& -)-;+ M+=)>>)M&-&A?&&&,/4-&/AD&
,)
> 0
*=
&
&
C+)>=/,;=*-6/&>
/(?& & >&4**)= 3>)Q/)/&//;,/= -/y-)0pq&)&/-*&
( >
C
>
=
* +@A+F=-(?G*& 4)*=-& M4**4=)&)*=_UT[sS_UTdV =+>
,?;/& )* >*& =B<(->)D2/;-z-& = 3>TdV_V lT^W_U< 8/&
/;
(
&
(C
8
)/*=+G*/1 &)/M-8=AM;/0G*&;(4@+,/=&-;+=)/0& +8(=/
+& /= -A& (@&;>F &F>F& =6=&;/- ->;&8&+=4D:(;4& &
G/
/
(
> &
(
=*=+F+M>1 &)/& (@& *==A)>4**)=(G& +)* >6= /& ) 6A)A
) ? G/ ) *
= -/ ;
>
QQ
j&
.)8&-&-;+4A?;+>&-+4;)&M-,*&=4)*-& //*&;&/&=)/*&
6F A/M8)/&+4/>;& *-F ;; M*/+= D:(+& -= = +=4M
)
/ /
- ;& > 0>
>,,/+&-)F;*>&8&/=) -&< *<+-/&(8AM/=&A*;)&?;=-=>)&
0 =0;&F=?M1 =(& G*4;&/M>>;F&+)/)A= -F ?+8*/&>
& 6= (
A
* ;
*
]XZ^_`^`\TcT[m`^TVWTZc[e`mbl^^TWaT^W_U`TZU_hV
nVl]TVm] YV_V]^Y` XWlVZZ]UV ^_Y_`V UTdV [XV]
X [
W U
V
cw
Z
?6*F&M-GFA/=/M;>6+/&)8/;&//=/ >&+)&-&)& 4)&=6F0*&
8F 0)3; /4& &+>Q;A+ =+&<(&+,*=(/= A= = (->)*=&
M
(
- =
= ) ( B<
*>
^VT^W_U^WXU5/- *1 &)/)>& F; A=/+>,?*-;& +&/8-&
_wUTdV ZZWV )G(F& (@&F;G/M,/& & 8 = &< /< i/=
_ V
/G/
( / ; ,; +
(4Q//&*F4/6= /& G& F*-&F,))1 *(>;F&//*+4;)&=6F0&
*(F@F );8&/G/-H/ I/(& AE) 6A& M&(8A6-<=/*-F )*=D&
A
) >
G(
& > *&
&
I8*4(+ ?; -&**=&)*=-&/+=+& *=-G*&M-//=/O+=4MI*F4/
+-&/& M,*4@>=;C3>)1 M/)0'F ;& F+ ;@-& &=)/*& );8&
8
&
O
- F/
(
G*&;/4& ->/& +>*;)>>&+G*4M;/)*-;&?M&-*4<; //4&-&
=u+*-5**=+ /(&&>/>4; -&;?+= &-= *>+ 4-& ,&-+0)A
(
t8 =
; ; ) +
G)/1;/8)*-)A()=1;M8=+=+;*,&-&//>&>/DO /G*&F;,/= =&
=+=&AM= &-&/F &&;-/Q/++> )AA<-/*8>& (& F)>& /& (
&
;
(=
> & F
G*
)+-/;&/*+ )*=-&<**F&&-;+4&F>+;F6+=-*&+)&< =)&=+>D
& 4&< -;& 3>)* =/M8)/M;/& F ;)* & )/>;& 8F-//=
) > C ; ;
M) ;,8 * &
&
BM;>=/6+/1(&80p& 6F -//M& F?;*/)&?;=-=& +(& 4)&
+>& &;A+=/yF&q.)8& <+-/G*&+@A&-;?+8* < &/B<((
&
';
F
0; =
4@+,/=;;<+;M//?)>=&//*=/B<(-?;FD:(>*&/<+= N+
;/- -&&& -+=&F-& 6-<=(& 4)&/?/& *& = & >& ;&
= M
; &
& >( * ,)
*=+)*-F;<+-/(F&& 4)*=->-/=/J>)A)& ;=-&=?=G)A&
-/-= )& -//M&/A*B<(->)&*M& &Lq&-&-* +)= /& +>
; M
(
,? > ;
4/=+ 4)&G-+(?)A>@+*-0& &/=(= +>A-& +)& F)A/>
+)/& (-; />*&-&;//4=DR//?M&)& /*/= z* FA+>&
B<
&
= C .) G*&
M,,* ->(& A&&*& @,6+ qL*)4+FA+>&-&=(&)8+&qq7 -;&
; = =&/,)/*(>H;/ /& q& 88)& A/>)A)&/y-)0pJ&;A,/
p - )
=
';<+-/r*M8*4;&?M&8()&-4@+)M&-&M;-)*=1+F&<) &-&
-//M&& FA-&-= *>>M&>;&;/--/)A)M8=6F0&8/;&G1 A
;
*& F )
/;; M)A>M)&//;,/=
M-,*&-&;*F @F? -D
A
&
&
B,;4=/,;=,?+)=-;-/ ->G*&/=/<+ F)-(;&-;/)*-F
-& & >& ;=-& -8M,/=& F6& & ,)&8M&< &?+= )&
( *
)
F (; F
) ;
+*=4)*-?;+,18?+/&0)&=+)*-F+>& -DBA*;)F1(& ?+,/=<
/-/+= &+4) & ?;=A6&-*/-= )&8=8A& A=-F &/I/)= -& &
;
>
- ; = < & * 0=
;
I//>&)&/-)=;*/&&?-&?=&Jq,**-=&8?+&*)& 4)&/-/+=<-/(>6/&8(+zA=>/A8& q& F;& >?;=-=F (-+*=4)* &
;
;
F ; * * B<
;
/<+>& (/*4)A+6/)A<@+6/+>F=-;&/M-F= F+i*/=/B<(<;=DBM*@-&&8)F&-& ;)F& ;8* &<(&;<*& F/8+& & 4)&
&
)
/ ; = MG*& (
4@+,/=;*M/>-F&A+>&ZsS_m]`dV+/)M>)A/;; M-/>& *&
;/- -&& +)*40)A/>W V lTVZmZU4*@-/&-&M-,*&/AD:(>
=S
&
*M8/&/>z6/-,6+ <-84->G(&+&;&<*)/& =&Ft)A&-&)/6/&
-FA>= &*)F&8 /& &>+/=& ;)/-= +/M& + ;QA;;*)&);>&+>A-& ) &*M>/&*=4)*= M/& = & 84-0< & -*/F4MF/>-DC/*/= ,)A>8>A+-/+= &
+ ;( ;+ &
o6
/ ;
)A+M-*)*-G*&+>A-& +)& /&/@>=AR)(-=-*& 0& & F; A=/
-& ;MF= & =C/*/= z* -(&** & >*4;& 5)DR/G/M,/& &
/ *; (
.) G(
/
- &
(
sS_leX\ZWUmTVV]WV _nWWZwTZXTh^VVmZZWWZl]m]V
lTV]Z_ _dV`_WSUV]U` ^ VZYV^lV WTX XU_T^ VXnV
] T Te
SZ
e
B<(->M/0=&*M>&/A=*&<(>+*=4)*-?)&-&+)/&8+)(/<+>& &
4)&;*=& A>8>= &/)F;&*& -/+= &F-)A6;A+ =/M&<;=DR/
;
( >= / ;
;
&
)/_hVnmX^lWZsS_leX\ZWUZXUWV `\ZWZZT&*4&8M,/D
+&] Um]W V V lTV]Z_ _dV]WV ^ Z _V eX` +);=; >&
_S
]\m U y
&
n^lwZ^ZW XTdVM-&**&+>A-& ) &*+=A=)&8&8?+& + 4)Q
X_VXU[_V ^U+ /= >=C/*/= ,)+= )/& = + ?;=;& (T / @ 1
o6 // ( ; > < B<
FA+*=4)*-)A+M-*)*-*&)/&-)>)/&; = -&& F=)>)/M&-&
/& -/+= &-& ;MF= & 6>A;&&(+AM,,* =;< F+-?+-0)A
/ ; / *; >
,/ = 8 &
6>M?*M?/DE>+/=& >9J&8&/&&Ft)A}p&/>&*F-/))-=(& 4)&
)*&+-*F>&-84->,8={| =*>=)Q /)& | )/@;/M&4*>&/B<(&
& M= ;
{M
=
>)/&-& |M/=(& 4)&;>*=-&M8*4*&+=M*-& + 8 -+4=&-&
==} A{ & M?&/B<(-M-=8* 1-FA-&>?;/= >< & ,)& (>)A
) j) =
=; *
= ; ;( *
h] _UZn`cV + ;*;&-=*&>&;-&&-,64;>& 4)Q/&/M&<;=&
\ZdVT^o8& >=-;& >F = *=>8) *88DB<(-FA?)//<+>
WV ? * ( )? *
&
,8=;&/)@(M/<+//>-&/?;+>&< 4)& ,/&-&*F&*M&qJ& &
>& = &&/*F& &@+*4= &+4/>;& (-G; -)A4+>>-/pqDB>
-6
;+
(
B<
&
OM/)0'F=-+*+=AA+-&+>A-V XTd&**&^^V>/=F(= ,/+4=&
/+=+& *;& =)/&8*4C/*/W ^>@>=WU/>-*&)& ->*(>
- //
T
1 V )= G; &
T[h] _U]mXn^ZVXV]VTXY[]VT `[]VVZXY_^T^_m]ZUV V
_V \Z m]W_WUTZ_W Y^^ZVXX\mZV_^W V ]Y`W VXYUV
V
^
U
W
_S Z ^ ]
Z
G*&;&g_]V lT^W_Uh] _V
F-= T[_sS_UTdV \Z
F T
&
B-=/& ;=-&8M,/;&/.)8& -//M& FF/06&/)-8M,/=<&*=
;(+,?+)= =; &<(& 6F <+-/G*&3F&/= &-;-/ -& &N-&
*
;
=
';
F* (
; );
HB:oQ 4)&;/- -&+@-*F+-*;&F-&-B?*& Bu?+-+&-& F>
B<(-4@+,/= ;*M)&)>=-?)DE& +FE &)=/>)ABF/&
?
= * & 1O
*
/A+/&&/**-,)*4<) G;3=&*M>& =&/B<(-4@+,/=& O-;&
-;>A)AM>;Q 3-& ,/ +& A>8>G* = & 4)&;/- -DHB:o&/*+
+
;
((
&
'**)& )>A+ +&/G*&)&/-M;A-=4G*& 4)& ->/>=&8F/)
@F-B,6>);& 3OA F(>6/&;+*)* & =B<(-,**=+& ;=-&&
*
5)
F
- (
; *
QQ
K&
A=*A,/(-> & )>= -G*&;&/)>-F&@-1;& F*+?//=(&-&<(&
/)F & M)*,D:+-*;& F-= &&*4///=-+ F=/+>-&//A;&/
/
& * F 6
& G*&&
=
=
*=+)*-F F)0)AM@F-)>>)M&&/B<(-4@+,/=-)?+*8)&+@-/&
-/-= )& *+&-&**)&>*=-/== & 4)&;/- -&&&)= F+ ;*MD
; ,*=
*
;(
* M ? &
E>/A&)>= -G*&/)?;/>6& *(=/B<(-4@+,/=>8 >4/=+
-=)1+-*;& F6&&+M>&0G(M& & 4)&;/- -& >,/&+)/&
= * F
(
)
+>;>6F0<+/8*DB>M-*;>* +@&-=/4;-1(& 4)&;/- -& F6&
/?-**=& & M+=& &;A=-& ;/;& &+8A&/B<(-4@+,/= F/
* ; > 0&
* ,?
(
=
G*&
)F&&+@A& +@A>+*/&&/&*=*=&=(&8Q)*-F//D
6/=?;*/* ;/&/@M>*30A>+M>)&/>6-= )&@F
;
,?
=
; F &
&
E&*&;=1=>)>& ;=-&&-/>)A=/,/--&<80pJDB>C/*/= ) 1
-=>M-/=**&F;* +)=;8A+=-& & )*4;& F&qJ& &+>A-& ,)&
(
&& ,? =
(
y
&
o6
) ( A ; )&
OM/)0'F=-&-&/+=+& =>(@& A&F)180pJ*&;&& =A) F)/<+F
/+=+& *;1 AOM/)0k)/&)/,)/M/+yF&qJ>-= G* +G)& =& &F
- )
&
PDD; )& +/DfVZwZ^ZWUh][a V `_WgVh^(-&<&/F(>)A
O& ,6=;M>&_W VXU[_dV XUV h^V]V ZU = *4;<(&4=&-&
M < &S
hZ ` M = *
Y]^lWZ[]VZ^[nV *&&80pJ& & F64-+AM-& O&; )&;?
`U_V V]X S_VUV F*yF&qJG/G*&/*& 8*4PDD ,6=+;&
S g
R(/F /
M =
F@F1(&*/;&-&,*4;&-&AM*-*& +/& F6&//,*/&&&;;4&
//>&/>z&< A= -&< 0+ 8= & < M>G*&/A=+ -A)=+ = +8(
=
) * ) / ; -; F
)(
)>>,/=(= F)M8=;&/@/ &<(& 4)&;/- -1>G/F>;+O & F>
>/> -&)& FM;-& +(&*G>;&/B<(-4@+,/=)& F)&8& BuBF/&
= G*& < =
=
& & E *
)A?+-+D:(&@-8F)/;&/+AM*-*& O&; )&;?& FA?-&-=/
-&)=/>& ///=)& M&<(& 8= & PDD ,6=+;>G*&//A;& &
&
? = / ;- M =
F
(
M-*;>;&/4;-DB-&@-=/18&)=/>*& =&/B<(-4@+,/=-&
;A=-&-= &+8A& A//& -& + +-+(?G* = & 4)&;/- -& A
* (
&
( ;?
((
)
B<(-?;F& F-=-D
4)&/?/G*&;& A&
F /
&
B>C/*/= ) &F*/&8*4(>N*=+>&;<+-/G*&+>A-& +)&-5)&
&+>A-& ,)/?)-AA+-&*& -& />M-//M& =C/*/= z* & 0
o6
; ?
(
.) ;
a
e_TV VZ^VVTUW _UYXWVU]Ug`cWV lTU]ZVZ_VZXhZh^V
V ZVUhZgl_WW_^]VZn^ X m_^^WV sS_VeXSVZW Ta V `
]X ^
cZ
^]
W c V `
>>)-)+6>&; = -VV lT^W_l^lX Xh^VTWZV WVZsS_m]`V
8=*&& 8= ,,* W_sS_UTV]_V hT[ `mX_X SW V lTVZmZ
; M ,/ ^
]
` h^ S
<+(&-&+ r=G)A)<=+&< +)/&/8*1+>/*18=/&_VXlZUV /
;&/F 4=,&& +&& 8/;& /=+ M+=& ;?+=&>* 1 [m]XUV &
= ; / ; 8 4 > 0? 0N M T
:(
>)/;&*&-Q/,&; = -& F6&F+&&; -& -(&>G/-4==&&/
(?&<(>F 4=+ M,,* = F/M)**A*M,*4,;=>)& &/;*/)-G&
= ;
,/ G*&
)
O+=4MC+-+(?G* &/B<(-4@+,/=& /O+=4MC+-+(?G*&+@A&&
=)/*&)=/>*& == & 4)&;/- -D:(&=)/*&)=/>*& F?;*/)
((
&
F
<) G;3<++-*;*4=&& +&;,)&*=+F/)*-(?G*&/B<(-4@+,/=&
+,/ +& &)>=--& ),;/-+ F F/)&F= >*& == & 4)&;/- -D&
;= * ;
6) + ;
((
&
I*M>*-& F;&/ >M*MF;=/PDD 4)*=-+F=-(?&M8*4;+
>8>;>G*& 8&-= ,/&+=)&& & OQ (->)& )* >*1-FA-&8&
F; (
* = ( B<
/; *
F-Q/,&; = -&8*&-&M-,*&>*=-/& &)/M,,*/&&;>F
;4=+ M,,* = & M+=)A/;; M)>>)MDR/(@&; =A=M-8=
,/ ; > 0
&
=; &
sS_UTdVZlgXV_VZVTWZUTVTWSUVZ^ZT^_a_V `TUVZm
lT^W_U_^S]UT[cmX_XVUmXV VZZ[` XW UV [h^V`]ZV
]W g ] T `
';4/>& F* ;,/D
8 0&
vi)F& ;=-& F6&&8=*/&=+)*-F; = -&&8?+*4=/B<(8F * +)= F/)>>)-A*/-= )& ,,* =;>?;= & & 4)&
0,? G*&
- ; M ,/ =
-(
4@+,/=&))FF;;+ /;*=-;&&/ PDD 4)*=-O+=4MC+-+(?& & F
;/- -DC+F &&8& 4= * &< -G& OQ (->)&=)/*&)=/>*1 G*&
& /= - ); )
B<
G/ F
M-8= =&8& BuBF/&-&)=/>&-;+4-&/ =&8FF&; =;& |
;>FG* ;+O & F>)A?+-+1 M8)*4= ,& ?6*0M,,*=9J&
&( E *
/
( ; M
&{
M-*8A)>>)M& +X^^lT[Znm^lsS_UTdVZn^V XZ_V Xe[_V
;= /&>*=-/< &T__V_V^m_V lT^W_UUYXW YUV [~ V ]^^l
;W
c] T m
F-Q/,&//;,/=>*=-/& *&-Q/,&; = -&&/;F& 0=&-8/=)&
;4=+ A@F? -& >>)MD:(>F 4=+ M,,* =>= &-0G)& />+& =
)
& ;
,/ * (
; (
;+ )-&+&8)F&-&)& 4)*=-A/&;&-/))-6M,/)><&)/&; G(M&
8& *>)/A+6/)A= = (->)&;>-= M&4*&/; &&)/(@-< ,& *(
4
( B<
;
+
/=/ >>?;&=M>;&8&; F-D
+,*=&F= = 3&-;+ ,/)A&
))
(
&
&
C8/=F-*4<+(& =+&(8A-=/,*=3-<+&M&<; = -&&8&-;-&
+A-&)--& &/< 8/>;F&;& & >)/& &F 3;& ,,* =;;+ 4*4
?
;= 8
6
; )) M ,/ = ;
M@,*/<+>&&8F/&8&**)&*)*/& /&)?)/&/;/=*&; =/*&
*Q F<;=DE =-A;+ @F-*== >G(-E?/+A6<+& >M,,*/&
& &; * M * -* @
&
(
=y-)0)A?//=A=/B<(->)&-&)*=-2/*-F =6F)*-O+=4Do@+(&
)8+&-&+>-/& & 4)*=-)AC3>)& 4;)& )*z= &=)/0& /&/
(
O *;
& =
?>&*& -(1 -+F /+/>)AE )/<+(+0M+-zA;+**)&-& F)0?)>
)= ,;=>& /)& =)8&-&(@& =/& -(;*/&8&@F-)A,*=+&F-&
>
k/ C
& 8 >
M*
*
6&;=8-&&/*>;&**)Q F)0M;A-=->>*-DE& +FG/M-//& +G;
0M-* *4)>+/&< @F-,*=+&;+*)* &/>;>&-B?*& &;@-A< & &
M* *
;
& 1
;=
A0&& 6F =&//=/M@,*v,6>0EBu=) &+>A-& +)1-&*&/*+
)>*.)8& (= &-*&*Q F )>QO & ,1 /*/= z*)A(>>-;&
- G* ( + &
/ C .) &
,**=+&&@/ ;+ +4/>)A<+(+/*/;+ +4) DR/)+/&&M-//*&*&
->/>=+ *G&8& ;+>&-& =/&<-&8& ;+,>& &4/A=+ ;@-& =>
;/
?
8 +
?
&
;/
-(
<+ =4*&& =6+& & -+F /+/>(>-G&)>= -A=&&/ +F&>'o5EBu&
;,)& )-*oM;/DB>k//)& =)8&)&; =-*;/& )-G& /)& O 1
) &
C
+ * ; ;
;+F>&;F6+=-(>*=-**A;&&-/;&>/1-FA-&8?+& + 4)Q/&
8&;/MF ;)* &)& />&-)+ 4&<>8>&M8*4>?;=;& (-FA
M ) ; ) * *
< B<
+*=4)*-)A)>>)-6/)?;M&&M/>-&FM+M=&+AM*-<+ -))D
/-/+= &-&&8=*)F&?+)(=* +)*4//=** ?;8= & & A(+&
;
;0
; ; .)
QQ
&
&
73& -&< ;1&)/=)//&8>A&< 6F@+(&)=*& -(&&/&8&*Q F
*/,)0;& 8&(@& @FA;=*/;& 8& /&/?>&,;=>=>/;+ @,*
0 E +
.) ; = >
; M &
/<+><+=)A& -++&&; &+>&M;->&8&**)>(@&84A& +&)&1q&
<;=& >(-D';=)0=>,/?/>)M8=1 + @F-&)/>+/D5;/= -Jqq
* &
;
;M *
& (
PO M@F-/ F0/&; J&/)= ->)A)/M/&+&; >+*4*& 4)*=-& =&
k&**)&,?;/>< ,&qA?+,/=&-&4-*>)/-G&/@-& B<(->)1 (
*
+
G*
)4)&<8=/&M/>-&/M@F-?//M&0)& M&>p&/M-&0=//A;&qq&
&;F & +(+-+)*4= &**)&+>-/6&>,8()&q?+/= & &-&& +*4)AF*4*&/>,/A-/;>
-&<(>&**)>)/A?;/&-= & -F/1 3-&-&@-& = &) &)4+8&
=
*
( + * G;
* -(
M-*;>)&8&; )&;?&&FM>F /.)A(+-& +)Dv)(M@F-*&/;+ ,6=+;>*?)/&3& -))& A5)N(& M&**)& = & F&
*
M = - *
)
&
* -( *
;=-/ F0&?J& 4)&)=/>& /&+&-)/&&&-/;&M**/1+,&6**4
&,?;>8&qB<(-?+-+D:(0)//44A*)+ 4&< = =>&; + 8F-&
&
- ) ) @* < / A
sS_UTdV_ZegTWl^nWX`ZWX=& +*4G*&/& 4)& ->+/&& +@&
lT^W_U]YV^X_V XY` TV Y]a;G;3-& =30B<(-,**=*>=* ;/
T nU V
(
;,?
?;**-;&/F1AM=-&>*/&-&=/&/@M>;=*/;&+@-*F)*FD&
+@>;&< )=& 8)* 18= 1 A;(+ +*/&8>A&< ;*M)& ?=>&
( (/ ; N M ) >
?
M )&
&
R/(@&; =A=&/?;**4/(-/&@F&< @+*(&-&& +*4G*&/
&)/M,,*/& 6&+@A-&-)MAF />;& />4= A=G;3-& == &
=;
/ ; ) ;
((
B<(-4@+,/=;* +@&/=)>)/M&-&M;-)*=&<=& ->+/D./&&
4)&;/- -&& ;/= & -?+-0)A)M8=6F0;&>,**=*>& 0=
= ,? ( +
* *
& ;
=///<+>(>6/&&AM*-;&8&F-/;&+/*=+)*-F;=)=+&-&
(>&<;=&)&/-)+ 8= &< +/* M&-F4& /-= )& -+M;>)A
/ ; ; +) ) - ; M
/=6*( -&<-)M/*=-?;/><+ 4)& ->+/&&M*/*M/>&*/=
>)F ,/= & &M+A=* &+M>& & (-,**=*>=+ /@& +)/A+M&
> ;)
);
; B<
;/ )>>)M&&/& +@&)>)/M1@+*(1-&M;-)*=D:(>& )8/&/?8&
>*=-/*= 0* ;/=-?+-0& />4=)A)M8=6F0& //,/>+>(F&>
<( ,? +
; &
*&
,))/=/+>& &>8 &0G;3-&&8()M,?/&-*;,/=&
-4& & 3G/)>,/6& +*4*>M&&; F/@+- -D&
(*
&
&
R/(@&F;/44A*&&F)Q0AA>8>;& =&+>A-& +)&-=/M)F-/&<
&)/)>&-)/& )M/+//&*M>*-G* C/*/= z* & &(F 4>;&
(
.) ; ( /
M+8=-r*M8*4;&/i/= -;&; =/P-=AO)/&-&=/&=+)*-F;;>
;+?* && FA-&-= &8>* &< G& & * &==>)A;(+-/-= )& -+&
; ( ; ( ( /
* ; A
M-/>+&)&8&;=)=4?)=/&;-=;=*8/=&DC/*/= +)&/=*A
)&-8/= = + -+M* &+M* >A&;& -+6=& *& +>A-& z*A-*/&
(;M - M
M
;=&
.) * <
M+8=-)&& N+;M+&&*&)4+FA+>&-& &8?+&=?&/(>=3-=&/*&
;+?* &>),);& -/-*(>* 88)& A/>)AG/>?;= />(&)& /& 64;
M - - )
>
) ;
)A/>-&*&+6/ & //*M8/*>*4)C/*/=F M/&& +(pJ&)&
A+>*4=>?;F,D:(>& FA& 8-&&+>A-*& +/*5)M&qq= =
(
& - >
)I/ (
?;*/&/PO IQ8?+/& 4& 4=A*;)&@>*)*/?G/>&=F;
+@AA= & BE >?;=A*(o<*/;& +*(& A=-F-/= = &; +DE)>&
(
o@ ) * * 4 @
&&
;=-A)?;/>& *(G/)/>?;= 4& +>)F(-&& -=+-&-& )8=8F/&&+M>1 M& &+&8?+* 1;& =6* *4)5;* *4)Av@F)* &
*
G(
- >
;
;
'; =/;&;+?*-M,?*/&< 4)&-&=+)*-F/=DBF-& =&=/& O&
,,*/&-M+8= &; +>A;& (-)A*/-= )& ?+>& ;4G* ;(+ D
=
;
B<
- ; / &
( PD
)>>)M&&/5);& * >:)XZT[sS_UTdV[YTcV VXVZm_VZ
>*=-/== & N+ ,/& UV]YV_V lT^W_U ^^Xa TZS`^lW V
;( '+
n hZ
S
B<(-4@+,/=,?/ -&A*;)&)/8+>),/&=/8*4M+8=-&
4)&;/- -& F,/= A=-F <4)A&* A)&AM-&;+?* D
*
) * >
+
;
&
u+8/& &M& -&=/&(F-/&&M*@-&8&**)&;F&& 4)*=-&M8*4
;& +1 < /,)0;(+ )F 4>=)(/*4;+ @F-4)>*B<(->)1-FA-&
> G/)
M / ;
M*
*
)+>F-&>+/M&-&,*A&F/=-+)*4B<(-4@+,/=))*Dx8& &+&
& */=-84-0)AF = 1 6**M/>-& 4)&;/- -& ?M=& = )/
/* *
* /) &
M 0& G/
64-*4=&/&*)&>F&; ;+ / >+=4&&//)&+)DR/?)&&+@A&& +&
/*--& >/*=F/8=< ,&8& G&=)/0*>@+F />& &F-=?;*/),;/
; -* + >+ - ) &
;
A=*A;/@/ ;&//+>F&=+(>0)18&= &*&&G&+/&,?/9
/)F &@+*G&<(>& 8=F/&*&/+6=/& M=)< 6*< ) F>&
/
= / >) = & F ,/ / / /
&
sf UTXY`XV]YZVXlT &8M/&&/=,6+ qL&)&*=*8/& /=
b dVl^nW ZenSX ]X\1)-(A*O?/ /& q1 >A>+6=AG()&
n
m F
p (
>/&& +&)& 1q&+ +1+*/&qqqB<(-<+ +&&/=+M*/1-&
/A=,;/= -j qq< ,/>&)-A¡1q& 4)& ,/>*6>& )= >& A
; (
) =
) - ? M)
/ F0A;/&qqqB<(-&->;==+ ++F-+>+M8/?;/=DE& -&FM>
,?;/&@+ 1q& 4)>;&(+Q/,& )&<)=8=+&+NM>&-,)0?)/&
8 *
&
=+8(8&/sS_UTdV]W1(>&+4) &+&M/>-F&/-&A ->//&
(;4;=(& lT^W_UUnS&//?;+,>)/* +)*406*4),**=+A
=
=
8A+(&8?M>;&/B<(-5**=0;& +MF+1 ;//=-*-)/=&M*/
-/&/)>*/&<(& 4)& ->+&< *8= /& >&/>;&4->+ /@&
=
=
B4 8 G(
/
=)--&; <+ +Q/F0APO )APBE )+MF+&A*;>&
+**4< ,& G)AA?;/& IB&-& I&4*8= /)@>+D
+ ;
8
&
-pq1 &(&8&;-/-+;*>>+=4&G)&; /)*)*-& *(AAF=&&
E&qL& >*=A;+ 8=+)M= &=)/0) 0< ,&+AM= 1 M&*&=/=
G/
M
M
+
; G( *F ;
+AM&;?&8=)*-)A?>/&]XT\ZU^WVZ¢T^TdVT[Do8&/
/8/??0MF@= &-&8(Am]VX XV ]W V ` _US_>& + G&
*;
_ S g
& M8=+)M=>>+=4&&; +(-*/&; **4&G&-;M,/=*=F4-/&
;-/-+;* &=)/0*M,?//>@1 ,6--9) /<+/ -}-/F/M}
M
>
M
F
& *
*=+*=-&/ -&AM*-&4;)&;+*)*-&-&F+)*/F/*;A&+4) D
-/AM* } ,)A+ 8= }/*-F ;A-= } A)=-= &@F ;>?;+,>&
;A / ;+ M
;) / @* (
&
O-/* F,/=4*& &)/>/&*->*9(&8 /&< +4F6&
*M& / -* &1 (@&/->4**)=-+)/& &/-,6+ & 8& >
,? - =G/
*
-=
;A )
QQ
&
A>+0A&/-,6+&< +4=))+>/}(&,;->;&?8 &;?1/;-&
/=;/}(&8 />;& 8& <*3+&+/=A&/) 8=&< *,1 ?0& +*1
=
A +
=
; ? (
)A,;?*/6>&/zA&-&/-,6+ <;-&?+=-& =& 4)& +/D'**)&
-& +(-&)/>*/} A= &8 /& &*= /)* >G* B<(-< M>& @F) (
;N ; ; (
; & *
IvB&4->)/(F*4=&)-B<(-';-/-+;*>C F/&-& +*4G*& 4)&
)/=&+&/?-& =*& 4)& 8=+)M= &;* 1 AG;3-& =B<(;+
M M)
(
& ( * i ;p
?+;-F;*/=0)AA>+0-+;+<*3-&/G;3DE&/<+=8+/&< qq&
/>-/&& -* &-&/=;&)M=)&-= & >& )=+ & J1
=A <
*=+)*-F-& 4)& +/&;AM/& ,*=+&-&GQ-;M,/=-/AM*-/-= )& AB<(-< M>M-8=A& F)0)AF /<+/ -&=+*= &
; )
;
*
)
* ;
;/)*-&& 4)*=-&+/0*&/O8(& //;/)*-&/=;/& j =*& -&
?+= >*B<(->)1)4F& = &;=D:(>&?+= >A>+0AJD5/+M:;>
; F -(
&
;
{ &< ?8 &L&*4) &< +(-1D& ;&/;-&D& ;&)(>&-1qJ
5:| & *,1 3F +,>;& ?*/&p5:&< +*1 ¡5:&< >*()A& D&
;; J ;
,; J
( L
(
J
5:&< +M+;&(,*)>&
;& /8>+ / MFD&
?
M
&
&
N*=O Q )>& 6F<;=)&/-+>;*4MFF+/@M&&+)& //=/
B& -& Buv,6>0.)8&<+& >6/& =+-&/F)& +*/*)/>G(+& &
; E
/ (
/
8 > (
:)*)&)&/=;/&+ /M*)/&G/>& /&qMF=G/>(@&/-+)=)/&&
F -(>A>+0A;& )= =A= +Do@+ &/F; +&)/6/& M* =A*
6
A @ ; & p &
/ @ /,)A)A.)A(+G*&*-& /;&8&**)>
F -&-& -))1 =>4**)= -<=< &MF ,,8*/Do-&< + @F-&
&(
6 >; F M
*& ;M *
/ /AAG*&/5)*/&& G)& F -&+@-/+?+/&)&;-)=+&MF/F
,6A/& == & +->*H) 1 ,)AC;*M& ;=A= = ;&&F )& F
((
- /
/ (>
); M &
=G/&>,/&?+=-SZVZ`S_VSmVm_[^VZ[UXYVTTX_Vf YXU
; +/8 A;/)* &WXZY`m]ZU]U]ZZV W V^W^W TV [bVT[V
+
;
V
_S
g T
G//))F6/*&/G(F&<(&*=*=& =;=-;@,/=+,&/5)*/&+ O&
+&@* F& = & ;/;&/A>+M&G* 8&@F/ -&; = & +->;& D
) -(
=
r ( *
< (
PD
M@F-Du+ +&; MF=/+/)*/&&/A>+M&-&+@-*F)*F&&/&&
**)>&),/>-G&)F(*&F= >*= &*=*= A?;*M)& ?=>=>/*
* &
& + @ -(
)
M ); <
?*/& 3&& +( *&&)>;=(*&;ADu,*/&)& +&)(;(+68&
+M>,)/*G;=G(F==-?+&/+ ;>&) F>M-G)-/M&=/& ;=
=
/;+ = 4 & *
)
*<8/&< F)&+ ->;&/+)V F>+*/(>+M-F&/-/=-/&& +)&
-F>;& * -;& /&-= & AV F/@M&)& /= 6/&/AA=5)N(
:)6 ,* ( ; '/&
/ 0
;
)Ak),>+G*&* F+M-,*&-&/8*&//*DE&/M,*4,;=>& Bu)A
-& + *1 =>,* & ;; M)A>M+=6-<=&-= &; -& -(1O &-&
& ( )/
0 >& (
E
;+ )>& FG;3=&+)/)6M8&/G;3*&+)& //=/:)*)&(=&; &
8& >0G*& +& M/=&&)3?-= +& )/>G(+& & F ->8>AGv,6 F ;
( 6
?*)/M+*+D *& F?;*/8*=+8=A)M>& + 4)>& +@-&/8*& +
+@=&)+/>& >G*&+@A&--/+?/&M/>< & (-1,?;*4>M+=< &
:( F
; B< *
0;
M,,8*/&>G/F>;+ G-M@F-)A,*=+&/>-/D&
; -=>)& F)&8& &**)&-& F)0?+;-F&
*
& ; *
*
&
&
EA/1 4)>*&+)&+@;>0A,*)/&0=/:)*)&+&FGF&8?+*4=/B<(-/A& (-& )/>?/*8F&; -=A6& & F -)/>; 0>?;= & & 4)&
B< ( 6
-(
4@+,/=& /&+&?+M)*/;&/* +@,/=&)&8&**)&+4) &+&+-*4
;/- -D:(0)/)?/*= &<(& ;/ ->= = + @F-?;+,>)/6*4-&
&
@ = ,?
(;M *
=&/+; -=>& /&,/& =&&+8&A+-& &M-&**=& +)1(0
;= *& ,,8*/DR(-E = ()4;?;&A+&8*4,0+ /= >=;5)N(&/&
( M
* & & G*
/
/ @&
=
/?/>A4)*A& + 8&4*8=+F8?+D:(0)>&-/>;/&/4/=/>-F*3&
+>/&+=8/< & + +MF )& ?;=& /&F;8A+M+A= &+)& +;)&>>
= ;; ) 8 > &
( ? +
=/& +&-/=3-&&=-Q?))-=(& F )D
(0G//8A+)*4=>)A8&4*>&/:)* -&
;
= 6
&
PF,)/0&8&;F>=&,?G/&/B<(-4@+,/=;=)&&&&/>+-/=;>6/
= =F1 + )&& / ; +(& 4)&;/- -& & ==>*= &=;4>& >*F&
* ; 4 *;
=
> ( ** -(
?
?>=-)& 4)Q/&;*MF-&M-,*&<;=& @& + +D:(>G*&i*/M-*8A
;*;&>B<(-FA?F*)& A/;; M/<+>,;/< G)A& *& F+ 8+&;= /&
*
= )
; & F/
?;+>&0=/B<(-4@+,/=-&;=8A*=+)*-F8?+DE*& ;=-&&
+4/>6& & 4)&;/- -& AM-* /& /-= )& ?;=&& * +)=;
(
) - - ; > &=>,? =
+,/ /&)& &+&;&F-&&*&-/@+&*M&+>A-& ) &?3&= >&;-&/ ,6+(= )/-= ;/*=>/A);DO-/C/*/= ,)>;/)& = *= &
= G/ ) -(
&
o6
R/ C ;
I// /&1O & F>)A?+-+&)/?;*/& 8(0J1q&A*;)&;?&-&
M,6+ & BuBF/&-&)=/>(@&+@AA+ 4F&qqq)A=-F+;>)A
JE *
;
* =
>@+F8A/&A*;)&)-+&&8?+&/8*&<;=D5;/=)&qM8=*>)/
//)& -+A)A=-F+*/>=>?;= M+=/<+>& +& - &;-+/&+&
(
* = ;
> 0 & (
?;**4M@F-)>>)M&& 4)*=-& A+(&*(0M?6/F)/>*&< O/*F
+@A-&**)&>*=-/=B<(->)DP-/&/(4F&))F& A+(?;& ?M)&
*
;
& =
/
PH&
2/+>-)*/O)<-A& >8))AB,6>);&/G*1 ,6+&<(&=+)*-F
?//== &=<)&/5*=+&-& )>A+ A F& />;&/*/-= )&
@
O F,/
=- ;
M,,8*&+&M/>-&/+;+*)*-;&/4;-&-&&/* F,/==-;&/+
; -=)/* +)*4= *& ;A-= &-= &+8A)A*= & / -)* &<(*&
0 ( M
; (
-( ,?
; =
?;+,>& /&+& M>-&-B<(-?*+=>)A* F,/=4=/ *&& 0=)&8F>
+4) D:(0)/< 8*4;& 4)&+;*/&-& / -* & ,& )G)& = * &
&
;
* ,? - ( - ( 6 A
B<(-4@+,/=))*D
4)&;/- -& ?M=&
M 0
&
O,8=-;>0& &+&-)*4EA)& >*1 *)&-&/'/=)& *-+?6*>=&*M>&
* F /8F1 )//44-& *1 >)& -1 A= & -+F )& 8F & A>8>
)
G/
- 28 '( ) (
B> / M ;
G)>=)&/&)&8?+&4;)&=6F0G(F&-8*4=/+/*,)/*=+>>& A
0& =(0M->?;=/*-F )*=& * />+-& *&4= =& //=DB-&
(=
+ > * /
( F* - &
6^^l]VXU[_V T dV8/pq&?/(*& *;& &) (>,)/*)=??*+=&&
n`_V_wZ^ZW \TUy-&qL>/M& ')+1 = ,&)& A&&& &+;* =
[
£g
- ,0/
= ; 0;
^YZUV U^ YnW^UVnmXV X 4)*=-& /+;=*8*-&)+&;*MF *(&
_XTZn` ]_XZd m]W]V (->)D:(*& -+6= >M+0?F*)& 4=
\V
U B<
& M ;
= G/
60-&+@A-&;*@&=&-=/4;-D:;M=&-0)= //;& &+8A& &* ;F&& ;& 0/) F>&
*
(
& / / ,)
QQ
&
&
/PBv1 0=)AO8* )*&)/?>/&/+*>&>A-& )>A+&& 6F&
:(& & ?1-&)A& 6)(@&;=A= *&+=/*/= >);>=.)8D
v4 &
B+
( < + B,6
; &
O@-o+)*)*-;&F,*& -//M& '|;-+/&)=*)/*&/*=+)*-F
//& 4-z= &<>) M';<+-/{ & 8=*>?+*?=& = & /-= )&
; E
oE M
M -( - ;
O &8?+&+8D
2BC>?;= ;?&
4 &
&
+/&)&+)F&)AA*&)--&<(& 4)& =-F /8*&;M>&
:830(>4/= /?-/&>=**4;&/B<(-H)* )& M+=u+/D
0
=+
=
; O 0
&
/PBv&)&)AA<--*F>*=-/)A*& -*4>@+F-;)*/**)*/D
:(& (>/?-/& )M)& >>)M&-& < A-&//)&-@= & == >&
* )
>8
* @ -* @
&
F0*&-& 0=)/M,,*/& ;=-& AMF/;+/DE*&)A=&@+==&/
5))>))Av4?& @&; =A* +)= *)&>8M>&=>(+& ;/>)/= &
(
= ,? ,/ +
&& ;
(
?)=)&-&0 ;*&<8-/;& >* G; -AM;>=/= 4B<(-?=->&
+M* F A>,6F * F/M&< F ,/&;=+& )* & 4)&)* =D
M)
M58 ,&
+/ &
&
B>C/*/= ) 1/+=+& *=-&-& -+F /+/>(@&,?)*/18&**)&
&+>A-& ,)& M/)0'F ;1 Ak//)& =)8&)// (>zA& + @Fo6 O
- )
C
;M *
,*>;&&+M)&&/?;+>&< 8&@+F>+=4&& 4)*=-& A=-F18&
>*-*M8*F;= &+4/>;& + /)F=)/0*B<(->)DBA*;)F& +
> =(
;; & & * 0;
M@F-?;+,>?;*/)<8A=-<+ 8&-Q/,&; = -&&/?-&/B<(**)&+4) &+@A&& -)* & & +;4=+ M,,* =;(F*4= & 4)&
*
; ; ;; F
,/ =
(
?;F&6*&; j&/+&<-F>& +& *&8& F)0,*>;&& 4)*=-*&;&
/?/+ 8F< ,&q0)>;& A/>G)DR(F;+ *+& >*-*B<(->)& -=
/ A+
/
& / ,*=
>
;/Q-/18&**)&; = -& F/A+&-&&8&; )&;?&; &; DE*&
?-/AA& + @F-M,,* = F-8/F 4)=+ + ,6=+;>M,/(,/&=>
;M *
,/ G*& ; ; M =
&&
/>-*F(= &,)-A;&8&6/=/&-&A?&8&=)/0=&;A=-&-=/
>/= &)& + *& 8/&-;+ NM* >)A))= + +=4& M-*;>;& &
)= G// ;
; @
;> ; * (
4;-1 *&F;)FG*4= & + 8&/ ?;+,>=&/ -=)/?;+>D
+8A& F)>&F -&,/< & + G&+4) & A,;>+=&+4/>&
G(/ ; * ; ; ;
&
:(-&;&4*& +(&?;=-=&&?/+ /;/08=A0&&;& + +&&&;=8A
)308))-< &/;?+8* =)?)& <+&;& )DE;3< G)A=)M-* /&
;=
0; 6
; &F ; ; A);8&-=//*>/&-&,&F)/&&3&;+ 8>*-D
*F4/;& >& 8>)A) ?/>A== /08& /= >&
( >
;) i ;
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?