United States of America v. Callard et al
Filing
22
SHORT ORDER re 19 Motion for Default Judgment; re 20 Motion for Default Judgment. It is hereby Ordered that the plaintiff's motion is denied in its entirety without prejudice to re-file the motion in accordance with Local Civil Rule 7.1(a) and Individual Rule II.C. The Clerk of Court is directed to terminate Docket Nos. 19 and 20; and it is further Ordered that prior to re-filing the motion for default judgment and within sixty days of the date of this Order, the plaintiff must either (1) determine the real name of defendant Edward "Doe" and upon learning his actual name, file a request for a certificate of default or (2) Provide the Court with legal authority establishing that the Clerk of the Court may still note the default of defendant Edward "Doe", although his name is fictitious. So Ordered.. Ordered by Judge Arthur D. Spatt on 1/7/2013. (Padilla, Kristin)
f;: ;
'i " :--,
:···· {'"!.[:;;:·''('3
US -. - · '•
*
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
-----------------------------------------------------------
)(
CIFF:Ct:
:·ouRT E.D N y
JAN 0 7 2013
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Plaintiff,
-against-
*
LONG ISLAND OFFICE
SHORT ORDER
11-CV-4819 (ADS) (ETB)
PIERRE CALLARD, Deceased, MAGDA
SHIRLEY CALLARD, LATOY A NEWKIRK,
EDWARD "DOE," PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF
NEW YORK, JOHN DOE #1-10 and )(YZ
CORPORATION, said names being fictitious, but
intending to designate tenants, occupants or other
persons, if any, having or claiming any estate or
interest in possession upon the premises or any
portion thereof known as 12 South 25th Street,
Wyandach, New York 11798,
Defendants.
------------------------------------------------------------)(
APPEARANCES:
Mullen and Iannarone, P.C.
Attorneys for the United States Department ofHousing and Urban Development
300 Main Street, Suite 3
Smithtown, NY 11787
By: Dolores M. lannarone, Esq., Of Counsel
NO APPEARANCE:
Pierre Callard, deceased
Magda Shirley Callard
People of the State ofNew York
"John Doe" #1-10
)(YZ Corporation
Latoya Newkirk
Edward "Doe"
SPATT, District Judge.
On October 3, 20 II, the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development,
an agency of the United States of America ("the Plaintiff' or "the United States") commenced
this action by filing the Complaint against defendants Pierre Callard, deceased; Magda Shirley
Callard; United States Internal Revenue Service; People of the State ofNew York, "John Doe"
#1-10 and XYZ Corporation, said names being fictitious, but intending to designate tenants,
occupants or other persons, if any, having or claiming any estate or interest in possession upon
the premises or any portion thereof known as 12 South 25th Street, Wyandach, New York. The
Plaintiff brings this action to foreclose a mortgage upon real property situated in the County of
Suffolk, State of New York. On December 24, 20 II, the Court granted the Plaintiffs motion to
amend the pleadings so as to replace John Doe# I and #2 with Latoya Newkirk and Edward
"Doe," respectfully, and to remove the United States Internal Revenue Service as a party
defendant, as it was confirmed that there were no outstanding federal tax liens on the premises in
question.
Presently before the Court is Plaintiffs motion, dated May 24, 2012, (I) to dismiss
defendants "John Doe# 1-10" and "XYZ Corporation"; (2) for a default judgment against the
remaining allegedly defaulting defendants; (3) for the appointment of a Master to sell the
mortgaged premises in one parcel; (4) for the ascertainment and computation of the amount due
to the Plaintiff for principal and interest, or otherwise, upon the promissory note and mortgage
mentioned in the Complaint; (5) for judgment for the relief demanded in the Complaint; and (6)
for such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper.
However, in bringing this motion, the Plaintiff has failed to comply with Local Civil Rule
7.1 and therefore, the Court denies the motion without prejudice. The Plaintiff may re-file this
motion, provided the Plaintiff complies with Local Civil Rule 7.1 and includes the following
motion papers with its motion:
(I) A notice of motion, or an order to show cause signed by the
Court, which shall specify the applicable rules or statutes
2
pursuant to which the motion is brought, and shall specify
relief sought by the motion;
(2) A memorandum oflaw, setting forth the cases and other
authorities relied upon in support o(the motion, and divided,
under appropriate headings, into as manv parts as there are
issues to be determined; and
(3) Supporting affidavits and exhibits thereto containing any
factual information and portions of the record necessary for the
decision of the motion.
Local Civil Rule 7.l(a) (emphasis added). In addition, as this Court's April24, 2012 Order
made clear (see Dkt. No. 18), to the extent the Plaintiff wishes to dismiss one of more parties in
this action, the Plaintiff must submit the motion with a proposed amended caption in
conformance with this Court's Individual Rule II. C.
Also, while the Plaintiff has obtained a certificate of default as to defendants Magda
Shirley Callard, Latoya Newkirk and People of the State of New York on April3, 2012 (Dkt.
No. IS), the Plaintiff has not obtained a certificate of default as to defendant Edward "Doe,"
because his last name is fictitious (see Docket, April3, 2012 NOTICE). As such, before re-filing
the motion for a default judgment and within sixty days of the date of this Order, the Court
directs the Plaintiff to either (I) determine the real name of Edward "Doe" and, upon learning his
actual name, to file a request for a certificate of default or (2) in the event the Plaintiff is unable
to determine the real name of Edward "Doe," provide the Court with legal authority establishing
that the Clerk of Court may still note the default of defendant Edward "Doe," although his name
is fictitious.
Accordingly, for the foregoing reasons, it is hereby
ORDERED that the Plaintiffs motion is denied in its entirety without prejudice tore-file
the motion in accordance with Local Civil Rule 7.I(a) and Individual Rule II.C. The Clerk of
Court is directed to terminate Docket Nos. I 9 and 20; and it is further
3
ORDERED that prior tore-filing the motion for default judgment and within sixty days
of the date of this Order, the Plaintiff must either (I) determine the real name of defendant
Edward "Doe" and, upon learning his actual name, file a request for a certificate of default or (2)
provide the Court with legal authority establishing that the Clerk of Court may still note the
default of defendant Edward "Doe," although his name is fictitious.
SO ORDERED.
Dated: Central Islip, New York
January 7, 2013
Is/ Arthur D. Spat!
ARTHUR D. SPATT
United States District Judge
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?