AngioDynamics, Inc. v. C.R. Bard, Inc. et al

Filing 443

ORDER: with rulings on objections to deposition designations for witness Greiner. Signed by Chief Judge Brenda K. Sannes on 9/21/2022. (Attachments: # 1 Additional rulings for Witness Greiner) (nmk)

Case 1:17-cv-00598-BKS-CFH Document 443 Filed 09/21/22 Page 1 of 5

Case No. 1:17-cv-598 (BKS)(CFH)
Date:_________ Presiding Judge: Honorable Brenda K. Sannes

United States District Court
For the Northern District of New York

AngioDynamics' Responses to Bard's Affirmative Deposition Designations (ECF #417)
Name of Deponent
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

Date of Testimony
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

Affirmative Page
From
8
14
17
24
39
75

100
103
108
108
108
118
118
138
138

Affirmative Line
From
21
16
16
12
2
11

9
7
1
7
20
13
20
3
11

Affirmative
Page To

Affirmative
Line To
9
15
18
24
39
75

100
106
108
108
109
118
120
138
138

AngioDynamics' Objections to Affirmative
Designations

1
1
7
19
15
16

21
21
4
17
7
18
12
7
15

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

139
141
142

1
1
10

139
141
142

18
15
13

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

144
151

3
12

145
153

12
7

Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

153

18

155

2

AngioDynamics'
Counter-Designations

Court’s Ruling

24:20-25:11
75:17-76:5
Obj. to D-082 see ECF # 411; D-082 includes
email and attachment but witness was only
shown attachment
Obj. to D-082 as above
Obj. to D-082 as above
Obj. to D-082 as above
Obj. to D-082 as above
Obj. to D-082 as above

Overruled
107:1-107:21

Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled

139:19-140:5; 140:6140:21
141:16 -142:9
142:14 -143:7

145:19 -147:14
Obj. to D-207 see ECF #411; hearsay, witness
not on the majority of the document; 403 any
probative value is outweighed by the substantial
prejudice and the risk of wasting time and jury
confusion re undisputed TLS facts

Overruled (relevant
portion - Mr. Greiner's
email - is party opponent
statement)

Case 1:17-cv-00598-BKS-CFH Document 443 Filed 09/21/22 Page 2 of 5

Case No. 1:17-cv-598 (BKS)(CFH)
Date:_________ Presiding Judge: Honorable Brenda K. Sannes

Name of Deponent

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

Greiner, Charles

Greiner, Charles

Greiner, Charles

Greiner, Charles

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

Greiner, Charles

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

Date of Testimony

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

April 26, 2022

April 26, 2022

April 26, 2022

April 26, 2022

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

April 26, 2022

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

United States District Court
For the Northern District of New York

Affirmative Page
From

155
157

162

165

168

169

175
176

178

182
186
187
188
190

Affirmative Line
From

7
14

17

13

4

2

3
1

21

17
11
1
3
3

Affirmative
Page To

157
159

163

167

168

169

175
178

180

182
186
187
188
190

Affirmative
Line To

AngioDynamics' Objections to Affirmative
Designations

AngioDynamics'
Counter-Designations

Obj. to D-207 see ECF #411; hearsay, witness
not on the majority of the document; 403 any
probative value is outweighed by the substantial
prejudice and the risk of wasting time and jury
confusion re undisputed TLS facts

8
3 Obj. to D-050 see ECF #411; 403

9

14

18

14

16
9

9

20
15
9
7
8

Court’s Ruling

Overruled

Overruled

Obj. to D-555 see ECF #411; 403, witness not 165:2-165:8; 165:9mentioned on and document and says unfamiliar 165:12

Sustained

Obj. to D-555 see ECF #411; 403, witness not
167:15 -168:3
mentioned on and document and says unfamiliar

Sustained

Obj. to D-555 see ECF #411; 403, witness not
168:19-169:1
mentioned on and document and says unfamiliar

Sustained

Obj. to D-555 see ECF #411; 403, witness not
169:15-170:2
mentioned on and document and says unfamiliar

Sustained

Obj. to D-555 see ECF #411; 403, witness not
mentioned on and document and says unfamiliar

Sustained

Obj. to D-555 see ECF #411; 403, witness not
mentioned on and document and says unfamiliar

Sustained

Obj. to D-555 see ECF #411; 403, witness not
mentioned on and document and says unfamiliar

Overruled

Obj. to D-120 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-120 see ECF #41; 403
Obj. to D-120 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-120 see ECF #411; 403

Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled

Case 1:17-cv-00598-BKS-CFH Document 443 Filed 09/21/22 Page 3 of 5

Case No. 1:17-cv-598 (BKS)(CFH)
Date:_________ Presiding Judge: Honorable Brenda K. Sannes

Name of Deponent

Date of Testimony

United States District Court
For the Northern District of New York

Affirmative Page
From

Affirmative Line
From

Affirmative
Page To

Affirmative
Line To

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

190
191
193
194
196
197
217
219
219
221
224
234

19
7
9
14
2
2
17
1
19
17
16
20

190
191
193
194
196
197
218
219
220
223
225
235

21
18
17
19
10
10
20
3
3
11
5
9

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

235
237
239
240
240

18
19
15
5
9

236
238
239
240
240

6
2
21
7
16

Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

258

8

258

19

AngioDynamics' Objections to Affirmative
Designations
Obj. to D-120 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-120 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-120 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-120 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-120 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-120 see ECF #411; 403

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

260

261
266
266

10

17
6
14

191:19-193:1

196:11-197:1

Court’s Ruling
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled

221:4-221:16
223:12-15

236:16-237:4; 237:12237:18

240:1-240:4
DX 285 not on exhibit list; hearsay; Obj. to
attachment D-563 "BioFlo Evidence Matrix" see
ECF #411, 403, objective evidence of PICC
performance, no foundation for witness; 403
DX 285 not on exhibit list; hearsay; 403

Greiner, Charles

AngioDynamics'
Counter-Designations

Overruled

260:16-260:18

260

15

263
266
266

DX 285 not on exhibit list; hearsay; attorney
"represents" content of attachment not presented 264:1-266:5
21 to witness; 403
12 DX 285 not on exhibit list; hearsay; 403
266:20-267:8
18 DX 285 not on exhibit list; hearsay; 403

Sustained (does not
appear to refer to an
exhibit on anyone's list)
Sustained
Sustained
Sustained

Case 1:17-cv-00598-BKS-CFH Document 443 Filed 09/21/22 Page 4 of 5

Case No. 1:17-cv-598 (BKS)(CFH)
Date:_________ Presiding Judge: Honorable Brenda K. Sannes

Name of Deponent

Date of Testimony

United States District Court
For the Northern District of New York

Affirmative Page
From

Affirmative Line
From

Affirmative
Page To

Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

267

9

268

Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

269

16

270

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

272
274
275
276
278

8
8
12
17
11

272
275
276
277
279

Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

280

4

282

Affirmative
Line To

AngioDynamics' Objections to Affirmative
Designations

DX 285 not on exhibit; obj. to D-563 as above;
hearsay; 268:18-17 403, asked and answered;
3 argumentative
DX 285 not on exhibit; obj. to D-563 as above;
271:4-271:6; 271:9hearsay; 269:3-4; 403, asked and answered;
271:18
15 argumentative
DX 285 not on exhibit; obj. to D-563 as above;
18 hearsay; 403
3
14
14
3
16

April 26, 2022

283

5

286

Court’s Ruling

Sustained

Sustained
Sustained

277:19-278:5
Obj. to D-063 see ECF #411; Hearsay; 403
Obj. to D-063 see ECF #411; Hearsay; 503

Greiner, Charles

AngioDynamics'
Counter-Designations

2

Obj. to D-063 see ECF #411; Hearsay; 403;
Obj. to D-085 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-085 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-085 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-085 see ECF #411; 403

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

287
289
290
291

16
3
2
8

287
289
290
291

20
21
4
14

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

292
299

11
5

297
299

19
9 Obj. to D-085 see ECF #411; 403

286:3-286:5; 286:7286:20; 287:1-287:6;
287:10-287:15

288:21 -289:2

Obj. to D-085 see ECF #411; 403

Obj. to D-085 see ECF #411; 403

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

300
305

9
6

303
305

13
10 Obj. to D-085 see ECF #411; 403

Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

305

13

305

18 Obj. to D-085 see ECF #411; 403

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

306
307
308
309

18
19
13
2

307
308
308
309

1
6
18
21

Obj. to D-554 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-554 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-554 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-554 see ECF #411; 403

299:10 -300:8

303:14 -305:2

305:19 -306:16
307:11 -307:15

Sustained as to 280:17281:16 (hearsay)
Sustained as to 285:6285:11 and sustained as to
285:18 to 286:21
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Sustained as to 294:14297:4
Overruled
Sustained as to 302:2303:13
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Sustained (hearsay)
Overruled

Case 1:17-cv-00598-BKS-CFH Document 443 Filed 09/21/22 Page 5 of 5

Case No. 1:17-cv-598 (BKS)(CFH)
Date:_________ Presiding Judge: Honorable Brenda K. Sannes

Name of Deponent

Date of Testimony

United States District Court
For the Northern District of New York

Affirmative Page
From

Affirmative Line
From

Affirmative
Page To

Affirmative
Line To

AngioDynamics' Objections to Affirmative
Designations

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

310
313
316

3
5
11

310
316
316

17 Obj. to D-554 see ECF #411; 403
2 Obj. to D-554 see ECF #411; 403
15 Obj. to D-146 see ECF #411; 403

Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

317

11

318

2 Obj. to D-146 see ECF #411; 403

Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

319

19

321

10 Obj. to D-146 see ECF #411; 403

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

323
326

10
10

324
326

20
18

AngioDynamics'
Counter-Designations

318:3 -318:9
321:11 -322:12
324:21-325:15

Obj. to D-554 see ECF #411; 403
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

329

3

329

19

Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

330

12

331

4

Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022

333

4

334

3

Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles
Greiner, Charles

April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022
April 26, 2022

343
348
348
366
366
367
388

1
8
14
3
10
12
20

343
348
349
366
367
368
389

14
11
13
7
5
16
9

Obj. to D-554 see ECF #411; 403; hearsay
Obj. to D-554 see ECF #411; 403
Obj. to D-554 see ECF #411; 403

Dated: September 21, 2022

331:21-332:13
334:7-334:10; 334:12334:13
347:16-347:18; 347:21348:1

Court’s Ruling
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled

Overruled (but it is not
clear what exhibit this is
referring to.)
Overruled (party opponent
statement)
Overruled
Overruled