AngioDynamics, Inc. v. C.R. Bard, Inc. et al

Filing 457

ORDER: as to evidentiary rulings regarding witnesses Burnside. Signed by Chief Judge Brenda K. Sannes on 9/23/2022. (nmk)

Download PDF
AngioDynamics v. Bard, N.D.N.Y. 17-598 Bard's September 17, 2022 Submission to Court Name of Deponent Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Bard's Corrected and Revised Objections and Counter-Designations to AngioDynamics' 9/13/2022 Affirmative Designations AngioDynamics' Bard's Objections to Affirmative Bard's Counter-Designations Date of Testimony Affirmative Designations Designations March 31, 2022 5:24 -6:2 March 31, 2022 31:4 -31:12 March 31, 2022 31:13 -31:24 March 31, 2022 36:17 -36:22 March 31, 2022 38:9 -39:6 44:8-14 March 31, 2022 43:17 -44:5 March 31, 2022 44:15 -44:18 45:14-46:11, 47:7-48:16, 49:5-18 March 31, 2022 45:2 -45:13 67:20-68:21, 69:10-14 March 31, 2022 66:18 -67:19 March 31, 2022 75:13 -76:6 vague ("next process"); foundation March 31, 2022 81:12 -81:23 March 31, 2022 81:24 -82:17 vague, compound question March 31, 2022 82:18 -83:11 speculative, 403 (prejudice) March 31, 2022 83:14 -83:16 asked and answered, attorney colloquy, 403 84:13 -84:19 (prejudice) 84:2-4, 84:7-12 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 86:6 -86:21 March 31, 2022 90:23 -91:15 March 31, 2022 104:3 -104:15 March 31, 2022 106:2 -106:12 Relevance, 403 (more prejudicial than 114:3 -114:5 probative) March 31, 2022 Relevance, 403 (more prejudicial than 114:9 -114:18 probative) March 31, 2022 Relevance, 403 (more prejudicial than 114:21 -114:23 probative) March 31, 2022 115:19-116:2, 116:5-116:7 March 31, 2022 116:18 -116:20 March 31, 2022 116:23 -117:13 March 31, 2022 121:19 -121:24 March 31, 2022 122:16 -122:24 March 31, 2022 123:13 -123:14 March 31, 2022 123:17 -124:5 Court’s Ruling Overruled Overruled Overruled Overruled Sustained Sustained Sustained AngioDynamics v. Bard, N.D.N.Y. 17-598 Bard's September 17, 2022 Submission to Court Name of Deponent Date of Testimony Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 Burnside, Ed March 31, 2022 AngioDynamics' Bard's Objections to Affirmative Affirmative Designations Designations 125:6 -125:13 125:20 -125:22 125:23 -126:5 126:8-126:17 403 (prejudice) 128:19 -129:5 130:7 -130:9 130:25 -131:9 138:2 -138:11 misstates testimony, attorney colloquy, 403 138:22 -138:25 (prejudice), assumes facts 139:4 -139:9 Burnside, Ed March 31, 2022 Burnside, Ed March 31, 2022 Burnside, Ed March 31, 2022 Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 139:12 -139:18 139:21 -140:8 141:19 -141:25 Bard's Counter-Designations Court’s Ruling Overruled Sustained Sustained as to 139:4, and overruled as to the rest misstates testimony, attorney colloquy, 403 (prejudice), assumes facts misstates testimony, attorney colloquy, 403 (prejudice), assumes facts misstates testimony, attorney colloquy, 403 (prejudice), assumes facts misstates testimony, attorney colloquy, 403 (prejudice), assumes facts Overruled Overruled Overruled 142:5 -142:15 143:6 -144:2 144:25 -145:13 145:16 -146:7 146:8 -146:11 146:12 -146:25 147:4 -147:8 148:24 -148:25 149:2 -149:3 149:7 -149:9 149:22 -149:25 150:2 -150:2 argumentative 165:10-166:24, 167:17-25, 170:14-17, Overruled 170:20-23 leading, attorney colloquy Overruled 147:9-20 AngioDynamics v. Bard, N.D.N.Y. 17-598 Bard's September 17, 2022 Submission to Court Name of Deponent Date of Testimony Burnside, Ed March 31, 2022 Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed Burnside, Ed March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 March 31, 2022 AngioDynamics' Bard's Objections to Affirmative Affirmative Designations Designations 150:5 -150:8 misstates testimony, misstates document, 153:25 -154:7 assumes facts, incomplete (question with no designated answer), 403 (prejudice) 154:10 -154:11 foundation, vague 157:2 -157:7 197:2 -197:9 Relevance 197:24 -197:25 Relevance 198:2 -198:4 Relevance 198:5 -198:5 Relevance 198:13 -198:22 Relevance 198:23 -198:25 Relevance 199:4 -199:8 Relevance incomplete designation (likely should begin at 203:14 -203:25 203:15) 204:2 -204:10 232:8 -232:10 foundation 236:23 -237:13 September 23, 2022 Bard's Counter-Designations Court’s Ruling Overruled (answer in row below) 220:11-25 Overruled Overruled Overruled Overruled Overruled Overruled Overruled Overruled Sustained subject to cure 232:11-233:8 Overruled

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?