In Re: Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether ("MTBE") Products Liability Litigation
Filing
3644
CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER NO. 109: WHEREAS, on September 19, 2012 plaintiffs identified the 377 sites listed on Exhibit A hereto as the sites where plaintiffs had no evidence of MTBE contamination as of that time; and therefore, IT IS ORDERED that all sites listed on Exhibit A are DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE. (Signed by Judge Shira A. Scheindlin on 3/20/2013) Filed In Associated Cases: 1:00-cv-01898-SAS-DCF, 1:07-cv-10470-SAS(ft)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
IN RE METHYL TERTIARY BUTYL ETHER
("MTBE) PRODUCTS LIABILITY
LITIGATION
Master File No. 1:00-1898
MDL 1358 (SAS)
M21-88
This document relates to:
Commonwealth ofPuerto Rico, et al. v. Shell Oil
Co., et al., Case No. 07 Civ. 10470
SHIRA A. SCHEINDLIN, U.S.D.J.
I~Dl CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER NO. I oq
WHEREAS, on September 19, 2012 plaintiffs identified the 377 sites listed on Exhibit A
hereto as the sites where plaintiffs had no evidence of MTBE contamination as of that time; and
therefore,
IT IS ORDERED that all sites listed on Exhibit A are DISMISSED WITHOUT
PREJUDICE.
~.
so 0
Dated: New York, New York
December
,~
Ma.,rc.h A
/
.
/ ):RE?,: / ) . /
I
!
' /, j(/
)
/' '
' .
;'
i!
,/
; /
,~//~\_:«./"~<
Sh r A. Sche(nillin
U.S.DJ.
\
'2..013
I
-1
,/1/
Exhibit A
Com"""""..lth 0/ Pwrt. Rico, .1 at ••
Sh.n 011 , •. , r10 Rlct>. rt 01. v.
Sh.q 011 C .. 01, 07 CI\I.I0470
..,
I'IAlNllfH' WlTIiORAW;'l WITHOUT PAEJUOICE Of SITES PREVIOU~Y IOEf>fIlflEO AS RElEASE SfTES
66-1550
Felix BetanC6s
ExTexaco· Carolina SIS #337
86-1552
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
Texaco Carrizales SIS # 563
86-1564
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
Texaco Miramar SIS #217
FERNANDEZ JUNCOS & ESTADO ST,
MIRAMAR
8S·1565
ENRIQUE ROLON RIVERA
MOROVISS/S
RD. 155 KM. 4B.8
86·1566
Angel Rivera
Angel R!vera SIS (AnteaTexaco Parque SIS #330)
ROOSEVELT AVE. #950
PUERTO NUEVO
66·1595
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
Texaco· Julio Cancel Acosta SIS ## 571
RD PR 2 KM 90.1
PUENTE WARD
86·1597
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
Pablo R. Colon SIS
ROAD 152 KM 2.2
86-1600
Caribbean Petroleum Corporation
Gulf 464
343 MENDEZ VIGO ST.
86·1602
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
Texaco· Enrique Cortez Rivera # 570
ROAD 651 KM 3.2
BO. HATOARRIBA
8S·1603
HECTOR M. FEAL
GaraJe EI Leflero
ROAD 134 KM 29.5
AIBONITO WARD
86·1605
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
Texaco- Erraln Gonzalez SJS #579
RD. 129 KM. 13.6
86·1617
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
HECTOR A. NOLLA SIS # 500
269 LUIS LLORENS TORRES AVE.
66·1622
FERDINAND VELEZ FIGUEROA
SERVICENTRO VELEZ
RD. 129, KM. 10.5
BUENOS AIRES WARD
• 86-1624
GUSTAVO LOURIDO
Lourldo SIS
Carr. 140
Calle Ramon Torres #99
Gasolinera Miraflores
CARR. 638 KM 5.4
BO. MIRAFLORES
i
66·1647 Sucn. Serrano Rloa y/o Juan A Santiago
P.R. 3 KM. 9.B
P.R. 2 KM. 85.2
CARRIZALES WARD
86·1655
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
BIRD CONSTRUCTION CORP.
RD. 887 KM. 0.4
86·1674
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
LORD ELECTRIC OF P.R.
VILLA PRAOES IND. PARK
86·1702
ISRAEL BENITEZ
VILLA FONTANA SIS (EX Texaco #370}
99 ST. BlQ. 99 NUM. 7
VILLA FONTANA
80·1765
Alberto Contreras
Rock SIS
RD. 1. KM. 20.3
Bo. Tortugo
86-1770
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
RAFAEL RIVERA SIS #304
Carr. 156 KM. 52.1
86.17761
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
RIO CA~AS SIS #391
RD. 1,KM. 27.2
RIO CAli/AS WARD
86·1767
JOSE BATIZ MELENDEZ
TEXACO FERROCARRIL SJS 601
FERROCARRll ST. CORNER HOSTOS
13 of 18
0/ hCltg Rlco# .t oJ. v.
SA,n Oil Co.,'1 01.,0701.10470
PlAINTIffS' WITHDRAWAL WlrHOUTP~!'lUOICE Of SITES PAEVlOU5l.Y ID£NTlHrO AS AEl£AsE sms
CommorIWflalth
86-1793
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
POST # 224 SUR SIS 11800
POST #224 SUR
86-1798 •
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
lAJAS ARRIBA SIS 11661
ROAD 117 INT. 118
SANTA ROSA WARD
86-1821
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
ARROYO SIS #603
RD. 3, KM. 126.6
86-1B30
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
CARLOS JIMENEZ ROMAN SIS #684
RD. #119. KM. 25.8
86-1836
Sucesion Leonides Perez
GARAJE PEREZ
RD.119 KM. 23.2
60. Aibonito
86-1841
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
HECTOR RIOS SIS # 835
RD. 10 KM. 0.2
SALIDA UTUADO
86-1848
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
NORYLUZ VELEZ SIS II 654
RD. BOQUERON. KM. 13.9
86-1 B49
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
ALBERTO SIERRA SIS 1/ 689
MAYAGUEZ MALL
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
DAVID SOTO SIS 631
CUESTA NUEVA. KM. 142.4
86-1858
Pedro Acosla Croussel
Quemado # 1
Carr 106 km 4.7 Bo Quemado
66-1870
Luis Martinez
LUIS MARTINEZ (Relaclon Tote12162) SI #873
RD.l, KM. 87.3
80. Coco Viejo
B6-1871
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
edwin Almodovar SIS 1/ 865
Calle Berdon 1/20 Carr. 116 KM 17.1
La Costa
86-1874
Aqulles Quinones Ortiz
Las Collnas SIS
RAMAL 116, KM 1.0 ENSENADA
86-1875
Carlos Rivera Nazario
GasoUnas Triunfo SIS
JOSE I. QUINTON ST. #29
86-1676
Samuel Vera Solo
Sammy's Service Station
RD. 435 INT PR 433
CALABAZAS WARD
86-1678
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
ILIA IRIZARRY SIS #620
65 DE INFANTERIA ST. #21
86-1911
ESTACION EXPERIMENTAL
AGRICOLA
SUBESTACION DE GURABO
RD. #189 KM 7.8 APT. 306
86-1912
ESTACION EXPERIMENTAL
AGRICOLA
SUBESTACION DE JUANA DiAl
RD. 510 KM 3.3
FORTUNA WARD
86-1914
ESTACION EXPERIMENTAL
AGRICOLA
ESTACION PRINCIPAL
RO.#l KM 1 HM 0
VENEZUELA WARD,rio piedras
PUERTO RICO AIR NATIONAL GUARD
MUNIZANG SASE
LUIS MOUNOZ MARIN lAP
86-1850
i
86-1917 PUERTO RICO AIR NATIONAL GUARD
86-1935
U,S. Naval Station
U,S. NAVAL STATION·ROOSEVELT ROA
86-1946
P.R. MEDICAL SERV, ADM.
MOTOR POOL
14 of 18
i
I
ROOSEVELT ROADS
MEDICAL CENTER
CommOfliWuJtIt 0{ Atttto R~ d til. v.
S;"ij 0/1 CO., .Iol 07C". 10470
I'1.AINTlFFS· WITHOR~WAl WllliOIJT PREJUDlCEOF SIlO I'REVIOVSlY IOEl'mflEDAS RElEASE SITES
86.2004
ASFALTO DEL OESTE INC.
ASFALTO DEL oeSTE INC.
PR 309 KM 0.2 Parcelas San Romualdo!
66·2015
BERMUDEZ & LONGO, INC.
BERMUDEZ & LONGO. INC.
P.O. BOX 1213
66-2021
Celestino Rosado Alejandro
San Patrlclo SIS (Ex GULF #363)
CARR#lS7 KM 10.6
Calle San Patrlclo 21
88-0005
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
SABANA SECA SIS #306
STATe ROAD 867KM 0.1
SABANA SECA WARD
88·0DOS
HOSPITAL SAN PABLO, INC
HOSPITAL SAN PABLO
SANTA CRUZ 1/ 70
Urb. Santa Cruz
88·0D77
AVIS RENT A CAR DE PUERTO RICO
AVIS RENT A CAR DE PUERTO RICO
LUIS MU~OZ MARIN INT.AIRPORT
ISLA VeRDE
88-0103
Jose Perez
JOSE U.PEREZ 11828
RD.132INT.RD. JAIMe L. DREW
LINEA PEr'lUELAS
88·0106
MUNICIPIO DE PATILLAS
GARAGE MUNICIPAL
MUtilOZ RiveRA ST.
68·0107
MUNICIPIO DE SAN JUAN
OBRAS PUBLICAS MUNICIPAL
KENNEDY AVE•• KM. 1.7
88·0108
MUNICIPIO DEARECIBO
Centro Transportation y Oblas Publlcas
ROAO # 10 Marglnallrente Autopista
Tanamaward
89-0165
MUNICIPIO DE COMERIO
GARAGE MUNICIPAL DE COMERIO
BOPINAS RD.775 KM.1.B
69-0168
Municipio de AdJunlas
GARAGE MUNICIPAL
CARRETERA# 10
Bo.Ganas
69-0174
AMERICAN PETROLEUM
CORPORATION
American petroleum Post SIS
Carr. #2 KM 186.5. Calle Post esq
Cuatro Hermanos
89·0204
Cecilia Lancara
EXPRESS AUTO SIS
RD 185KM 3.2
CAMPO RlCO WARD
Santa Paula 011
SANTA PAULA OIL
PALMA ST. #1304
Caribbean Petroleum Corporation
Gulf #469
RD.189 KM 2.0 HM 3.0
SRA.SARA RIO MORALES
SRA.SARA RIO MORALES
RD 109 KM 8.3
90-0077
VICTOR M TORRES. JULIO TORRES
Cerro Gordo SIS
RD.916 KM 1.0
CERRO GORDO
90·0104
NICOLAS A. PEREZ FELICIANO
NICOLAS A. PEREZ FELICIANO
UNION ST. #104
KM 5.9 RD 101
. 91-0009
SOL PUERTO LIMITED
COOPERATIVA DE CAROLINA TRANSPOR
RD.2BKM 2.5
SAN ANTON WARD
91·0040
TEXACO PUERTO RICO INC
JI MMY FERRER # 303
90-0031
90-0033
1
I
I
90. 0046
1
!
91-0063
V
a lNVESTMENT. INC.
VB Investment, Irlc.
150118
Carr. South Eest Main, Ext. Mlnillas
2da Seccl6n Lomas Verdes
RD 1 KM 57.7
Montellano Ward
I
C:QrNtIon~oJdJ
of Pvett.o Rico, tl 0/. If,
SMII 011 Co., or d, 07 av. 10470
PlAINTiffS' WlTHDilAWAl WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF SITES PREVIOUSlY IDEHTIFI!O AS REl!ASE SITU
91-0065
Total Petroleum Puerto Rico Corp.
GPR7
PONCE DE LEON AVE.
OCASIO ST.
9\-0084
Total Petroleum PuMo Rico Corp.
GPR#3009
eo. SAM ANTON
91-0089
Total Petroleum Puerto R!co Corp.
GPRI/5398
UNION ST. #41
91-0095
Hauger Martin Hau
Martin Shell Service Center
RD 2, KM 110.1
Arenales Balos Ward
91-0129
JUAN HERNANDEZ FAL.CON
Sueesion Juan Hernandez (Antes Gasolinera Comeriol
RD 156 KM 34.5
91-0159
SOL PUERTO LIMITED
SHELL. SIS #804924
RD ISLA VERDE KM 2.4
91-0164
PUERTO RICO TELEPHONE CO
GUERRERO REMOTa
RD 2 KM 113 Barrio Guerrero
91-0173
SOL PUERTO L.IMITED
SHELL SIS 004030
RD 852KM 1.2
91-0190
Sal PUERTO LIMITED
SHELL SIS #805033
RD 153 KM 8.9 Coamo By Pass
Coamo By pass
91-0200
Ismael Herrera
HERRERA SIS (antes Texaco 527)
RD. 111 KM 34.7
PUEBLO
91-0232
Sal PUERTO liMITED
SHELL SIS 11003964
RD 883 KM 4.5 Santa ROsa
SANTA ROSA
91-0263
SOL. PUERTO LIMITED
SHEL.l SIS 11003972
RD 129 & 134. KM 15.2
SAYANEY WARD
91·0277 :
SOL. PUERTO LIMITED
SHELL SIS 11804096
MAYOR CANTERACORNER
ACUEDUCTO
91-0344
ESSO STANDARD O!l CO PR
SEARS ROEBUCK DE P.R.
RD #176 KM 0.8, CUPEY
91-0382
Total Petroleum Puerto Rico Corp.
Total Petroleum 112307
INT. RD 921 & RAMAL Bo telas
91-0384
Fllmando Solo
Raceway SIS
Ave. HoSt06 # 967
91-0397
Total Petroleum Puerto Rico Corp.
Total Petro!eum #1246
RD 150 KM 18.1
~~,
.y
.,~
.
Esqulna Moree
91-0399
OSCAR BARQUIN
GPR#2297
• 92·0001
ESSO STANDARD OIL. CO PR
ESSO SIS 43441
RD. 144 KM. 4.4
92-0063
Autoridad de Acueductos y
Aicantarlilados
PONCEWWTP
RD. 2 KM. 258.2
92-0079
Autoridad de Energia Electrica
CENTRAL HIDROELECTRICA YAUCO II
ALMACIGOALTO
92-0105
American AgenCies Co. Inc.
American Agencies Co. Inc.
Carr. 887 Km. 0.9 Bo Martin Gonzalez
Bo. Martin Gonzalez
16 of 18
CommQlUffmlrh of l'1J~tW /flat.. d 91, -"
S!lcH 011 CO.,.f ".,01 ellt. 10470
PLAINT1H$' wnHOiVIWAl WlnlOUT PREJUOIa OF snes PREVIOUSLY IO!NTlFIEO AS RHEASE slTn
92-0128
PUERTO RICO NATIONAL GUARD
GUARDIA NACIONAL DE P.R SALINAS·MATES
RD 1 km 88,5 Int Carr 154
Campamento Santiago
93-0002
SAN JUAN OIL COMPANY
Servicentro de Pllrlemll #5
HOSTOSAVE. #1128
93-0009
SUCESION RUIZ GRAU
PANADERIA RESTAURANTE LlSBOA
PONCE DE LEON AVE. #1850
CORNER JORDAN ST.
93-0052
PUERTO RICO NATIONAL GUARD
JUANA DiAl TRAINING SITE
EDIF. 222 FUERTE ALLEN
AUTORIDAD DE EDIFICIOS
PUBLlcoe
ESCUELA BENITO CEREZO
RD. 45B. KM 2
BORINQUEN WARD
93-0067
SOL PUERTO LIMITED
SHELL SIS #004017
RD.3KM28.2
94-0018
JOSE LUIS GONZALEZ
LEE SIS
ST RD #111. KM 30.3
JUNCAL WARD
94-0043
BIENVENIOO MATOS CHAPARRO
Servicenlro Matos
RD. 411 KM 1,3
JAGUEYWard
94-0116
MILTON RAUL TaRO SANTIAGO
COMERCIALTORO
PR 312 KM. 1.1
BO.BALLAJA
94-0132
GARAGE MOLINO INC
Sunrise Gas Stallon
RD. 111 KM.3.6
94-0142
Ernesto SanUago
Family Service Station #1 (Antes garaje el f>unto)
RD. 782 KM 9.3
NARANJO WARD
194-0162
SAN JUAN GAS COMPANY
SAN JUAN GAS COMPANY
EXPRESO MARGINAL SUR AVE.
MIRAMAR
, 94-0163
Jose f>erez de Leon
Chao SIS I
RD. 165 KM 5.7 INT. RD. 824
QUEBRADA CRUZ WARD
, 94-0171
COMPNlIA DE FOMENTO
INDUSTRIAL
COMPANIA DE FOMENTO INDUSTRIAL
RD. 1 KM. 34.2
BA1ROAWARD
94-0178
COMPAf'lIA DE FOMENTO
INDUSTRIAL
COMPAf:lIA DE FOMENTO INDUSTRIAL
RD. 165 KM 10.6
CONTORNO WARD
95-0044
ADM.SERV.DESARROLLO
AGROPECUARIO
ASDA GUANICA
RD. 116 KM 21.3
CIENAGAS WARD
96-0009
ADM.SERV.DESARROLLO
AGROPECUARIO
ASDA LAS PIEDRAS
CARR. 189 KM.20A
BARRIO ARENAS
96·0011
ADM.SERV.DESARROLLO
AGROPECUARIO
ASDA NARANJITO
CARR. 152 KM. 12.6
BARRIO CEDRO ARRIBA
96-0032
ANTONIO DE JESUS
Gel SIS Borlnquan Service Station
Road 2 Km. 6507
80. Factor 1
Teresa Rivera Maldonado
G
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?