The Authors Guild et al v. Google Inc.

Filing 954

DECLARATION of Belinda Bulger in Support re: 945 MOTION to Approve Amended Settlement Agreement / Notice of Motion for Final Approval of Amended Settlement Agreement.. Document filed by Association of American Publishers, Inc., The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., Pearson Education, Inc., Simon & Schuster, Inc., John Wiley & Sons, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibits 1-5 to Bulger Declaration, # 2 Exhibit 6 to Bulger Declaration)(Keller, Bruce)

Download PDF
The Author's Guild et al v. Google Inc. Doc. 954 UNI ED S ATESDI TRI T COURT T T S C S UTHERN DI TRI T OF NEW YORK O S C T h Au h r Gu l , n .Asso iaio o e t o s i d I c, ctnf Amerc nP u lsh r , n .eta. i a b i e s I c , l, P l in if , a t f v . Go g e In . o l c, d N N o 0 CV 8 3 - C .5 1 6D DECLARATI N OF O BELI DA BULGER N I, eln aBu g r h r byd c a e a f lo s: B i d l e , e e e l r s ol w QN I a V ic P r sid n , r jec s a dL eg lR esea c , fKin elaM ed a L L C (KM , n m e e e t P o t n a r h o s l i, ) a a v risin a dl g ln tf c to f r inW a h n t n D. .h tspec aiz s int e d sig d e t g n e a o i i ai n i m s i g o , C t a ile h e n a dimpl men aio o c a s a to a dba k u t yn tf c to pr g a s t r a h n e t t n f l s c i n n n r p c o i i ai n o r m o e c u id n if edpu aiv c a s member . n e t i tt e ls s RN T h d c a aio o Kah rn Kin ela f l dint e a o e-a to edc se, u ln s my e e lrt n f t e i e s l , i e h b v c p i n a o ti e f r c ed n ias a dt e N o ic P r g a d sig eda dimpl men edbyKM int is ims r e t l n h t e o rm e n n e t h c se.T h in t n d c a aio d t il c mpla c w t t e n tc r q ir men s setf rh a e s a t e l r t n e a s o i n e i h h oi e e u e t ot byt is Co r init N o ember1 , 0 9O r erGr n in P r lmin r Appr v lo h ut s v 9 2 0 d a t g e i ay o a f Amen edS etl men (O r er )a da d to a n tc ef o t KM ex c t da t e d te t d n d i i n l o i e f rs e ue t h d r c io o Cl ss Co n el iet n f a us . SN I h v beenempl y dbyKM f rmo e t a t oy a s, n h v per o al ma a ed ae oe o r h n w e r a d a e s n ly n g sev r lo t e f r l r estn tc pr g a s d rn t a tme,n l d n Inr e a f h i m s a g o i e o r m u i g h t i i c u i g e Ph r ac uic lIn u t yAv r g W h l sal Prc L itg to ( r c 2S tl me t , o a m e t a d s r e a e oe e i e i a i n T a k ete n) N . CA:1 CV - 2 5 , DL N o 1 5 ( . a s., n Inr Ine n to alAir 0 - 1 2 7 M . 4 6 D M s )a d e t r a i n Q Dockets.Justia.com T an po t to S r h r eAnit u tL itg to , o M :6 c - 1 9 ( . . a.. a a r s ra i n u c a g t r s i a i n N . 0 -v 0 7 3 N D C l) I m membero t e S t t Ba o Caif r ia(n c iv )a dt e Distic o Co u biaBa . f h ae r f l o n i a t e n h r t f lm r TN I w s t e prma ypr jec ma a erf rt e a o e-a to edc se a KM a dw s in a h i r o t n g o h b v c p i n a t n a c a g o aln n pad med a r l t da pec s o t e N o ic P r g a ,n l d n h r e f l o - i - i -e ae s t f h t e o r m i cu i g c o d n to w t o t id a t o , u lsh r a dc py ig tg o ps. o r i ai n i h u s e u h r p b i e , n o r h r u UN T h s d c a aio is ba edu o myper o a k o l d e a du o in o maio pr v d d i e lrt n s pn s n l n we g n p n f r t n o i e bymyc lea u s, l ss Co n el a dmyf r pa en c mpa y R u tCo su tn , n . ol g e C a u s ,n i m s r t o n , s n li g I c (R u t ) s . S ppl me t lNo ic Pr pa a io a d Tr nsl to u e n a t e e r t n n a ai n VN T h S u pl men a N o ic su ma iz s k yc a g s f o t e S etl men Ag eemen t e pe tl t e m r e e h n e r m h te tr to t e Amen edS etl men Ag eemen .W h nCl ss Co n elf n lz dt e c n en o t e h d te tr t e a u s i ai e h o t t f h S u pl men a N o ic , M f r at dt e d c men a d o N o ember2 , 0 9 pe t l t e K o m te h o u t n , n v 3 2 0 , pr v d ditt Go g e f ru l a in t t e S etl men W ebsit .T h f n lS u pl men a o i e o o l o p o d g o h te t e e i a p e tl N o ic inEn lshis at c eda Ex ibit1 t e gi ta h s h . WN KM t enc o d n t dta sl to o t e S u pl men a N o ic f o En lshin o3 h o r i ae r n ai n f h pe t l t e r m gi t 6 a d to a N o ic L a g a es t e l n u g s inw ic t e S etl men W ebsit is dii nl t e nug h agae h h h te t e a al bl pl s S w h l.T h S u pl men a N o ic w s a al bl int e sa e 3 via e u aii e p e tl t e a v i a e h m 7 l n u g s inw ic t e o ig n lN o ic w s a al bl . a g a e h h h r i a t e a v i a e XN T r n P erec ta sl t dt e S u pl men a N o ic in ot e f lo in 3 l n u g s: a s f t r n ae h pe t l t e t h ol w g 2 a g a e Ar bic Bu g ra , h n se ( implf ed , h n se ( r d to a) Cr aia , z c , a , l a i n C i e S i i ) C i e T a i i n l, o t n C e h Da ish Du c , in ish F en h Gr ek H ebr w H in i, u g ra , n o esia , t la , n , t h F n , r c , e , e , d H n a i n I d n n I ai n J pa ese, o ea , it u n a , aa , o ish P o t g ese ( o tn n a) P o t g ese a n K r n L h a i n M l y P l , ru u C n i e t l, ru u ( r zla ) R o a ia , u sia , er ia , l v k S l v n a , pa ish T h i, u k sh B a i i n , m n n R s n S b n S o a , o e i n S n , a T r i , R a dV iet a ese. n nm YN AS T A- S A ta sl t dt e S u pl men a N o ic in ot r e a d to a l n u g s U r n ae h pe tl t e t he d i i n l a g a e Ger a , o w g a , n S w d shbec u e t a f r h dr -r n l t dt e o ig n l m n N r e i n a d e i a s h t i m a e ta s ae h r i a N o ic in ot ese l n u g s.Itasota sl t dt e S u pl men a N o ic in oS w h l t e t h a g a e l r n ae h pe tl t e t aii bec u e itta sl t dt e o ig n lN o ic in oS w h l. a s r n ae h r i a t e t aii QPN Det il din o maio a o tt e q aif c to s, x eren e, n c ien s o T r n P erec a e f r t n b u h u l i ai n e p i c a d l t f a s f t a dAS T A- S A a e in l d dinEx ibit5 o t e d c a aio o Kah rn Kin ela n U r cu e h 5 f h e l r t n f t e i e s l. QQN O n e KM r c iv dt e ta sl to s f o T r n P erec a dAS T A- S A, M sen t e c e e e h r n ai n r m a s f t n U K th En lsh l n u g v r io o t e S u pl men a N o ic a dt e ta sl to s t Ato n y g i -a g a e e s n f h pe t l t e n h r n ai n o t r e T r n l to S er ic s ( T S )f rf rh rr v ewa pa to apr - l n edta sl to a s ai n v e A o u t e e i s r f e p a n r n ai n r v ewpr c ss.AT S spec aiz s inl g lta sl to s a du es at r ey ta sl t r o ,n e i oe i l e e a r n ai n n s to n -r n ao s r i so e c ses P hD l g lta sl t r o ex eren edl g lta sl t r .M o e in o maio ma . e a r n ao s r p i c e a r n ao s r fr t n a o tAT S a dit sa pl c ien lsta e at c eda Ex ibit2 KM in tu t dAT S t b u n s m e l t i r ta h s h . s r ce o h v it ta sl t r c r f lyr v ewea hta sl to a dpr v d ed t a df ed a k a e s r n ao s a e u l e i c r n ai n n o i e i s n e b c . QRN KM asosen t e f lo in ta sl to s o t e S u pl men a N o ic t at a o l t h o l w g r n ai n f h pe tl t e o e m f ln u st a Go g e f rt eirr v ewa dc mmen :Ch n se ( implf ed , h n se i g i s t o l o h e i n o t i e S i i ) C i e ( r d to a) Du c , r n h Ger a , n o esia , a a ese, o t g ese ( o tn n a) T a i i n l, t h F e c , m n I d n n J p n P ru u C n i e t l, P o t g ese ( r zla ) R u sia , n S pa ish KM sen ed t f o t e Go g e ln u st ru u B a i i n , s n a d n. t is rm h ol i gi s t AT S , n AT S ln u st t enin o po aedt o e ed t in ot e ta sl to s o t e o ad s i g i s h c r r t h s i s t h r n ai n f h S u pl men a N o ic , h l c mpl tn it o er l r v ewo t e ta sl to s.AT S t en pe t l t e w i e o e i g s v al e i f h r n ai n h sen KM t e c mu aiv ed t t t e ta sl to s. t h u l t e i s o h r n ai n QSN KM t ensen aled t su g st dbyGo g e a dbyAT S t t e t of r s t a h d h t l i s g e e o l n o h w im ht a pr pa edt e in ta ta sl to s o t e S u pl men a N o ic , r n P erec a dAS T Ae r h i i l r n ai n f h pe t l t e T a s f t n S U S A,oen u e t a alln u st w r ina r emen a o ted t t t e ta sl to s. t s r h t l i g i s e e g e t b u i s o h r n ai n QTN T r n l to c rif c to s f o T r n P erec , S T A- S A, n AT S a e at c eda a s ai n e t i ai n r m a s f t A U ad r ta h s Ex ibit3 h . QUN Cl ss Co n ela v sedme t a, o a d to a a su a c a t t e q ait o c ran a us di h t f r d i i n l s r n e s o h u l y f e t i ta sl to s o t e S u pl men a N o ic ,h ysen t e Du c , r n h Ger a , n r n ai n f h pe t l t e t e th t h F e c , m n a d S w d shta sl to s t at r ey w oa e n tv spea er o t o e l n u g s f rt eir e i r n ai n o to n s h r ai e k s f h s a g a e o h f rh rr v ewa dt eyh dt e J pa ese ta sl to r v ew dbya ex eren ed ut e e i n h a h a n r n ai n e i e n p i c ta sl t r an tv spea ero J pa ese, h h dsu st n ia f mila it w t t e r n ao , ai e k f a n w o a b at la i ry ih h S etl men a dit t r s.T h se r v ew r pr v d df rh red t t t e f v ta sl to s, te t n s e m e e i e s o i e u t e i s o h i e r n ai n w ic KM t enin o po aedin ot e ta sl to s a pa to t e pr c ss o pr pa in hh h c r r t t h r n ai n s r f h o e f e r g f n lv r io s o t e ta sl to s o t e S u pl men a N o ic . i a e s n f h r n ai n f h pe t l t e QVN O nDec mber1 , 0 9 KM pr v d dGo g e w t t e f n lta sl to s o t e e 0 2 0 , o i e o l i h h i a r n ai n f h S u pl men a N o ic inalr l v n l n u g s f ru l a in t t e S etl men W ebsit . pe t l t e l e e a t a g a e o p o d g o h te t e QWN Cl ss Co n ela v sedme t a, nDec mber2 , 0 9 t eyr c iv da emalc lin a us di h t o e 1 2 0 ,h e e e n i al g at n io t ta sl to ero s int e F en h l n u g v r io o t e S u pl men a N o ic te t n o r n ai n r r h r c -a g a e e s n f h pe tl t e t a h dbeensen o tint e bo yo emal inH T M L f r a.Cl ss Co n el ht a t u h d f is o m t a us immed ael br u h t e mat rt t e at n io o R u ta dKM .R u tc n ir edt me i t y o g th te o h te t n f s n s o f m o t a t e F en h l n u g v r io o t e S u pl men a N o ic t a h dbeensen v aemal h t h r c -a g a e e s n f h pe tl t e h t a ti i o Dec mber1 , 0 9w s n tt e f n l a pr v dv r io o t e F en hta sl to o n e 4 2 0 a o h i a, p o e e s n f h r c r n ai n f t e S u pl men a N o ic , h c , s o Dec mber1 , 0 9 h dbeenma e a al bl o h pe t l t e w i h a f e 4 2 0 , a d via e n t e S etl men W ebsit . u timmed ael c n a t dT r n P erec f rar v ew R u t h te t e R s i t y o t ce a s f t o e i . s d t r in dt a t e ed t t f v o t e ta sl to s o t e S u pl men a N o ic ( u c , e e m e h t h i s o i e f h r n ai n f h pe t l t e D t h F en h Ger a , a a ese, n S w d sh t a h dbeenpr v d dbyt e at r ey (n by r c , m n J p n a d e i ) h t a o i e h to n s a d T t e J pa ese l n u g ta sl t r en a edbyCl ss Co n elh dn talbeenin l d din han a g a e r n ao ) g g a u s a o l cu e t e v r io s sen t r u hemal T r n P erec , n erR u ts d r c io , ev ew dal h es n t ho g i . a s f t u d s i e t n r i e l ta sl to s o t e emalv r io s o t e S u pl men a N o ic .T r n P erec d t r in d r n ai n f h i es n f h pe t l t e a s f t e e m e t a, u l r el t aso t a e maf n to , a yo t e emalv r io s o t e ta sl to s h t d e a g y o f w r lu c i n m n f h i e s n f h r n ai n o t e S u pl men a N o ic v red(ov r in d g ees)f o t e f n l a pr v d fh pe t l t e a i t a y g e r r m h i a, p o e ta sl to s o t e S u pl men a N o ic t a a pea edo t e S etl men W ebsit . r n ai n f h pe tl t e h t p r n h te t e QXN T oen u e t a alr c pien s o emal t a h dc n an dta sl to s o t e f n lv r io s s r h t l e i tf i s h t a o t i e r n ai n f h i a e s n o t e S u pl men a N o ic w r ma e a a e o t e f n l a pr v dta sl to s t a w r fh pe t l t e e e d w r f h i a, p o e r n ai n h t e e a al bl o t e S etl men W ebsit , u ta v sedme t a R u tsen t e f lo in emal via e n h te t e R s d i h t s t h ol w g i, int e a pr prae l n u g ,oea ho t o e r c pien s: h S u pl men a N o ic f r h p o i t a g a e t c f h s e i t T e p e tl t e o t e Go g e Bo kS etl men t a w sen y uo Dec mber1 c n an dso e ta sl to h ol o te tht e t o n e 4 o t i e m r n ai n ero s.P l a e f n t e c rec ta sl to a: ln t t e l n u g -pec f cP DF o t e r r e s i d h o r t r n ai n t [i k o h a g a e s i i fh f n lS u pl men a N o ic o t e S etl men W ebsit ] F remal inl n u g s w t t e i a p e tl t e n h te t e . o is agae ih h h g estn mbero r c pien s, u ta d o KM asoh dt e ta sl to s o t e t x o su h ih u f ei t R s n /r l a h r n ai n f h e t f c emalr v ew dbyin epen en n tv spea er o t e l n u g s,n l d n at r ey . i e i e d d t ai e k s f h a g a e i c u i g to n s R u ta v sedme t a R u tsen t ese emal , it t e t x a sor v ew da ded t d o s d i h t s th i s w h h e t s e i e n i e , n Dec mber2 , 0 9 e 8 2 0 . S ppl me t lNo ic Dist ibuto u e n a t e r in QYN P ert e O r er eg n in o Dec 1 , 0 9 Cl ss Co n elsh l c u e t e S u pl men a h d:B ingn . 4 2 0 , a u s al a s h pe tl N o ic t be emal do sen bypo t lmalt alper o s w opr v d dc n a t teo i e r t s a i o l s n h o i e o t c in o maio o t e o f c a setl men w bsit o o aCl im F r , h o t do to t e f r t n n h f i i l te t e e rn a o m w o p e u f h o ig n lS etl men Ag eemen , rw of l da o jec io , mic s po ito , ro h r r i a te tr t o h i e n b t n a u s i n o t e st t men w t t e Co r. ae t ih h u t U RPN T h d c a aio o T if a eyAleno R u tc n ir s d stibu io o t e S u pl men a e e lrt n f f n l f s o f m i r t n f h pe tl N o ic t per o s w opr v d dc n a tin o maio o t e o f c a setl men w bsit o t e o s n h o i e o t c f r t n n h f i i l te te er o aCl im F r ,h se w oo t do to t e o ig n lS etl men Ag eemen , n o h r n a om t o h p e u f h r i a te tr t a d t e r c pien s, s d r c edbyCl ss Co n el ei ta iet a us . RQN KM pr pa ed a dI per o al r v ew da an tac pyo t is Co r d c et alsto e r ,n s n ly e i e g i s o f h u ts o k , i f t o e in iv d as a den ites t a f l da o jec io , mic s st t men , ro h rst t men h s d i u l n t i h t i e n b t n a u ae t o t e ae t w t t e Co r int is c se.I pr v d dt a lstt R u t w ic ex c t dt e emala d ih h ut h a o i e h t i o s , h h e ue h i n po t lmaln tc .W h na in iv d a o en it o t is lstw s r pr sen edbyc u sel s a i o i e e n d i ul r ty n h i a e e t on , n tc w s sen t t e at r eyo r c r .R ec pien s o t is lstf rw o w h da oi e a t o h to n f e o d i t n h i o h m e a n emala d ess r c iv dbo hemala dpo t lmaln tc .Ifita pea edt a En lshw s i d r e e e t i n s a i o i e p r h t g i a n tt e prma yl n u g o ar c pien , u tsen t e S u pl men a N o ic inbo h o h i r a g a e f e i t R s th pe tl t e t En lsha dt e r c pien pr su edn tv l n u g . gi n h e i ts e m ai e a g a e RRN P ert e in tu to s o Cl ss Co n el o N o ember2 , 0 9 byemal I c n a t dt r e h s r ci n f a us ,n v 3 2 0 , i , o t ce h e u br lag o ps w oh da sist dw t N o ic P r g a pa tc paio byt eirmember m el r u h a s e i h t e o r m ri i t n h o g n z to s d rn t e N o ic P ero :T h In er aio a F d r to o R epr d c io r a i ai n u i g h t e i d e t n t n l e e ai n f out n R ig t O r a isaio s (F R O ) t e F d r to o Eu o ea P u lsh r ( EP ) a dt e hs g n t n I F ,h e e ai n f r p n b i e s F , n h In er aio a P u lsh r Asso iaio (P A) I at c edt t o e emal t e f n l t n t n l bi e s c tnI . ta h o h s i s h i a S u pl men a N o ic inEn lsh ex l in dt a t e ta sl t dv r io s w u dbe o t e pe t l t e g i , p a e h t h r n ae e s n o l nh S etl men W ebsit byDec mber1 , n a k dt e t r e g o ps t a kt eirmember te t e e 4 a d s e h h e r u o s h o g n z to s t d stibu e t e S u pl men a N o ic t t eirin iv d a member . r a i ai n o i r t h pe tl t e o h d i u l s RSN P ert e in tu to s o Cl ss Co n el KM c mpil dalsto t e a t o , u lsh r a d h s r ci n f a us , o e i f h u h r p b i e , n c py ig tg o ps t a h dpa tc paedint e Dir c N o ic pr g a d rn t e N o ic o r h r u h t a ri i t h e t t e o rm ui g h te P ero .( h lstin l d dmember o IF R O , EP , n IP A, s w l a o h r i d T e i c u e sf R F ad a el s t e V u a f laedo g n z to s. KM sen t e lstt R u t w ic emal dt e g o ps o t e lst n f i i t r a i ai n ) t h i o s, h h i e h ru n h i o Dec mber1 2 0 .T h emal w r sen f o t e emala d ess o aKM st f erw o n e , 0 9 e i s ee t rm h i dr f af h pr v o sl h dw r edw t t ese o g n z to s inc n ec io w t t e Dir c N o ic e i u y a ok i h h r a i ai n o n t n i h h et t e pr g a .T h emal in l d daln t t e f n lS u pl men a N o ic inEn lsh o rm e i s c u e i k o h i a p e t l t e gi , ex l in dt a t e ta sl t dv r io s o t e S u pl men a N o ic w u dbe a al bl o p a e h t h r n ae e s n f h pe tl t e o l via e n t e S etl men W ebsit byDec mber1 , n a k dt e g o ps t d stibu e t e h te t e e 4 a d s e h r u o i r t h S u pl men a N o ic t t eirin iv d a member . pe tl t e o h d i u l s Addito a No ic Ac ivte a d M o it rng i n l t e t ii s n n oi RTN P ert e in tu to s o Cl ss Co n el o Dec mber1 , 0 9 KM d stibu edapr ss h s r ci n f a us ,n e 4 2 0 , ir t e r l a e r g r in d stibu io o t e S u pl men a N o ic .T h pr ss r l a e is at c ed e e s e ad g i r t n f h pe t l t e e e e e s ta h a Ex ibit4 T h pr ss r l a e w s d stibu edo P R N ew w r U S 1a dP r mier s h . e e ee s a i r t n s i es n e Gl ba w r s.Det il a o tt e med ao tetc v r g o t o e w r s a e a al bl int e o l ie a s b u h i ul o e a e f h s i e r v i a e h d c a aio o Kah rn Kin ela F rd stibu io o t e P r mierGl ba w r , R e lrt n f t e i e s l. o i r t n n h e o l i e P N ew w r ta sl t dt e pr ss r l a e in ot e f lo in l n u g s:Ar bic Ca a ia s i e r n ae h e e e s t h o l w g a g a e a , n d n F en h Ch n se ( r d to a) Ch n se ( implf ed , z c , u c , n lsh( sia , r c , i e T a i i n l, i e S i i ) C e h D t h E g i A ) En lsh( u o e) Est n a , r n h( u o e) Ger a , r ek H ebr w H in i, g i E r p , o i n F e c E r p , m n G e , e , d In o esia , t la , a a ese, o ea , av a , it u n a , aa , o ish P o t g ese d n n I ai n J p n K r n L t i n L h a i n M l y P l , ru u ( r zla ) P o t g ese ( o tn n a) R u sia , l v k S pa ish( u o e) S pa ish( ain B a i i n , ru u C n i e t l, s n S o a , n E r p , n L t Amerc ) T h i, n U r u i a, a a d d . RUN KM r tin dCAR M A I tr aio a t ta kin er aio a a dd mestcmed ast res ea e ne n t n l o r c t n t n l n o i i oi a o t h Amen edS etlmen d rn t e S u plmen a N o ic P ero .Detil a o t b u te d te t ui g h pe tl t e i d a s b u CAR M A I tr aio a, t ea n dmed ata k n pr c ss, n met o o o ya e a alb e n e n t n l i s r e i rc i g o e a d h d lg r v i a l inEx ib t 4 a d4 o t e d c a aio o Kah rn Kin ela CAR M A I tr aio a h i s 7 n 8 f h e lr t n f t e i e s l. n e n t n ls W r po td tiln med ac v r g o t e Amen edS etlmen b t eenN o emb r1 , 0 9 e r e a i g i o ea e fh d te t e w v e 3 2 0 a dJ n a y2 , 0 0 is atc eda Ex ib t5 n a u r 8 2 1 , ta h s h i . RVN KM ta k db o s fo S eptmb r5 2 0 , h o g J n a y2 , 0 0 a dd c men ed r c e lg r m e e , 0 9 t r u h a u r 8 2 1 , n o u t b o po tn s a o t h Amen edS etlmen .Du in t a tme pero , tla t13 8b o lg s i g b u te d te t r g h t i i d a e s ,7 l g po tn s a pea eda o t h Amen edS etlmen .A r po to t ese b o po tn s is s i g p r b u te d te t e r n h lg s i g atc eda Ex ib t6 ta h s h i . I d c a e u d rpen lyo peru yt a t e f r g in is tu a dc rec .Ex c t dt is 1 t d y e lr n e at f j r h t h o e o g r e n o r t e u e h 0h a o F br a y 2 1 inBet esd , a ya d f e u r, 0 0 h a M r l n . X

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?