Viacom International, Inc. et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 311

RESPONSE in Support re: 177 MOTION for Summary Judgment Regarding Applicability of the DMCA and on Plaintiffs' Inducement Claims. Defendants' Local Rule 56.1 Statement. Document filed by Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC, Google, Inc.. (Schapiro, Andrew)

K>68DB >CIlA >C8(& :I 6A(& E\QY^dYVVc& f( NDJIJ7:& >C8(& :I 6A(& 9UVU^TQ^dc( I=: ;DDI76AA 6HHD8>6I>DC EG:B>:G A:6<J: A>B>I:9& :I 6A(& _^ RUXQ\V _V dXU]cU\fUc Q^T Q\\ _dXUbc cY]Y\Qb\i cYdeQdUT& E\QY^dYVVc& f( NDJIJ7:& >C8(& :I 6A(& 9UVU^TQ^dc(

% % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % %

:8; 8QcU 8YfY\ C_( *1'8K',+*- $AAH%

:8; 8QcU 8YfY\ C_( *1'8K'-/2, $AAH%

EebceQ^d d_ 8YfY\ Ge\U /0(+$Q% _V dXU A_SQ\ Ge\Uc _V 8YfY\ Eb_SUTebU V_b dXU H_edXUb^ 9YcdbYSd _V CUg N_b[& 9UVU^TQ^dc N_eIeRU& >^S(& N_eIeRU& AA8& Q^T <__W\U >^S( XUbURi ceR]Yd dXU V_\\_gY^W HdQdU]U^d _V BQdUbYQ\ ;QSdc 6c I_ LXYSX IXUbU >c C_ <U^eY^U >cceU I_ 7U IbYUT(

+(

E\QY^dYVVc Y^ dXU QSdY_^

&

8YfY\ C_( *1'8K',+*- $AAH%& QbU KYQS_] >^dUb^QdY_^Q\& >^S( $mKYQS_]n%& 8_]UTi EQbd^Ubc& 8_e^dbi BecYS IU\UfYcY_^& >^S(& EQbQ]_e^d EYSdebUc 8_b`_bQdY_^& Q^T 7\QS[ :^dUbdQY^]U^d IU\UfYcY_^& >^S( KYQS_] 6]( 8_]`\( pp +/'+3( ,( IXU `edQdYfU S\Qcc `\QY^dYVVc Y^ dXU QSdY_^ & 8YfY\ C_( *1'8K'-/2, $AAH%& QbU 7_eb^U 8_( $m7_eb^Un% Q^T Ydc QVVY\YQdU BebR_ BecYS EeR\YcXY^W& >^S( $mBebR_n%5 8XUbbi AQ^U BecYS EeR\YcXY^W 8_]`Q^i& >^S( $m8XUbbi AQ^Un%5 8Q\ >K :^dUbdQY^]U^d& AA8 $m8Q\ >Kn%5 IXU G_TWUbc " =Q]]UbcdUY^ DbWQ^YjQdY_^ $mG"=n%5 HdQWU IXbUU BecYS $JH%& >^S( $mHdQWU IXbUUn%5 :TgQbT 7( BQb[c BecYS 8_]`Q^i& ;bUTTi 7YU^cd_S[ BecYS 8_]`Q^i T)R)Q 7YU^cd_S[ EeR\YcXY^W 8_]`Q^i Q^T 6\\Ui BecYS 8_b`_bQdY_^ $S_\\USdYfU\i& m8Qb\Y^n%5 M'GQi 9_W BecYS& >^S( $mM'GQi 9_Wn%5 Q^T IXU BecYS ;_bSU BUTYQ <b_e` AA8& IXU BecYS ;_bSU AA8 Q^T HY^' 9b_]U GUS_bTc& AdT( $S_\\USdYfU\i& mBecYS ;_bSUn%( HUS_^T 6]( 8\Qcc 6SdY_^ 8_]`\( pp +0& +2',*& ,.'-*& --(

1

-(

9UVU^TQ^dc QbU N_eIeRU& >^S(& N_eIeRU& AA8& Q^T <__W\U >^S(

$S_\\USdYfU\i& mN_eIeRUn%(

.(

N_eIeRU _`UbQdUc Q gURcYdU \_SQdUT _^ dXU >^dUb^Ud Qd

Xdd`4))ggg(i_edeRU(S_]( 9US\( _V BYSXQU\ H_\_]_^ Y^ He``_bd _V 9UVc(l B_d( V_b He]]Qbi ?eTW]U^d $mH_\_]_^ 9US\(n% p ,( /( N_eIeRU gQc V_e^TUT Y^ ;URbeQbi ,**/ Ri 8XQT =eb\Ui& HdUfU 8XU^&

Q^T ?QgUT @QbY]( 9US\( _V 8XQT =eb\Ui Y^ He``_bd _V 9UVc(l B_d( V_b He]]Qbi ?eTW]U^d $m=eb\Ui 9US\(n% p ,( 0( IXU V_e^TUbc SbUQdUT N_eIeRU d_ `b_fYTU Q `\QdV_b] V_b ecUbc d_

S_^fU^YU^d\i cXQbU `Ubc_^Q\ fYTU_c Q^T d_ ReY\T Q S_]]e^Ydi Qb_e^T ecUbc `_cdY^W Q^T fYUgY^W ceSX fYTU_c( ( " :hc( .& +/5 9US\( _V 6^TbUg =( HSXQ`Yb_ Y^ He``_bd

_V 9UVc(l B_d( V_b He]]Qbi ?eTW]U^d $mHSXQ`Yb_ 9US\(n% :h( +/2( 1( IXU V_e^TUbc ^Q]UT dXU ^Ug S_]`Q^i mN_eIeRUn d_ U]`XQcYjU dXUYb

W_Q\ dXQd dXU cYdU RUS_]U Q XeR _V cX_bd& `Ubc_^Q\ fYTU_c U]`XQcYjY^W mi_e(n =eb\Ui 9US\( p 15 HSXQ`Yb_ :h( +0,( 2( IXU V_e^TUbc SX_cU dXU c\_WQ^ m7b_QTSQcd N_ebcU\Vn c_ dXQd ecUbc

g_e\T me^TUbcdQ^T gXQd dXU cYdU Yc ce``_cUT d_ RU gXU^ dXUi fYcYd(n =eb\Ui 9US\( p 1( 3( N_eIeRUlc ]UccQWU d_ dXU `eR\YS Q^T d_ Ydc ecUbc S_^cYcdU^d\i XQc RUU^

dXQd ecUbc cX_e\T `_cd _^\i fYTU_c dXQd dXUi XQT SbUQdUT dXU]cU\fUc _b _dXUbgYcU XQT dXU bYWXd d_ `_cd( ( p 35 9US\( _V OQXQfQX AUfY^U $mAUfY^U 9US\(n% pp /& 1(

2

+*(

D^ 6`bY\ ,-& ,**/& N_eIeRU \Qe^SXUT dXU mRUdQn fUbcY_^ _V dXU gURcYdU&

TUcSbYRY^W YdcU\V d_ dXU `eR\YS Qc mdXU VYbcd _^\Y^U S_]]e^Ydi cYdU dXQd Q\\_gc ]U]RUbc d_ `_cd Q^T cXQbU `Ubc_^Q\ fYTU_c(n =eb\Ui 9US\( pp .'/( ++( >^ 6`bY\ ,**/& N_eIeRUlc V_e^TUbc `eR\YSYjUT dXUYb ^Ug gURcYdU d_ dXU

R\_W mKYTU_ AY^[n Qc V_\\_gc4 m6 cYdU SQ\\UT kN_eIeRUl XQc Zecd \Qe^SXUT( >d Q\\_gc ]U]RUbc d_ `_cd Q^T cXQbU `Ubc_^Q\ fYTU_c dXUilfU ]QTU( IXU cYdU QY]c d_ RUS_]U Q S_]]e^Ydi _V TYWYdQ\ fYTU_ QedX_bc Q^T dXUYb fYTU_c(n HSXQ`Yb_ :h( +0-( +,( >^ 6`bY\ ,**/& N_eIeRU bQ^ dXU V_\\_gY^W QTfUbdYcU]U^d _^ dXU gURcYdU

m8bQYWc\Ycdn4 mN_eIeRU(S_] Yc Q gUR'RQcUT S_]]e^Ydi RQcUT Qb_e^T SbUQdYfU Q^T Ve^ fYTU_c( LU QbU cUU[Y^W V_\[c gX_ `_ccUcc Q TQcX _V dUSX^YSQ\ [^_g'X_g Q^T Q dbeS[\_QT _V V\QbU(n +-( ( :h( +0/(

>^ UQb\i BQi ,**/& N_eIeRU d_\T dXU _^\Y^U dUSX^YSQ\ `eR\YSQdY_^

4 mLU Zecd \Qe^SXUT Q ^Ug gURcYdU& ggg(N_eIeRU(S_]& RQcUT _^ dXU YTUQ _V fYTU_ R\_WWY^W gXUbU ]U]RUbc g_e\T dQ[U S\Y`c bQ^WY^W Vb_] dXU ]e^TQ^U d_ dXU VQcSY^QdY^W( Deb X_`U Yc dXQd Q S_]]e^Ydi g_e\T RU ReY\d Qb_e^T kSXQ^^U\cl ceSX Qc kH`_bdcl& k@YTcl& kKQSQdY_^cl& k8Qbcl& UdS(n +.( ( :h( +0.(

D^ 9USU]RUb +.& ,**/& N_eIeRU _VVYSYQ\\i \Qe^SXUT Ydc gURcYdU(

=eb\Ui 9US\( p ,-(

+/(

IXU N_eIeRU gURcYdU Q\\_gc ecUbc Vb_] Qb_e^T dXU g_b\T d_ e`\_QT

fYTU_c VbUU _V SXQbWU d_ S_]`edUb cUbfUbc _g^UT _b \UQcUT Ri N_eIeRU( H_\_]_^ 9US\( p ,(

3

+0( ecUbc(

IXU `b_SUcc _V e`\_QTY^W Q fYTU_ d_ N_eIeRU Yc Y^YdYQdUT Ri N_eIeRUlc

( p ,( +1( 6 ecUb e`\_QTc Q fYTU_ Ri fYcYdY^W dXU N_eIeRU gURcYdU& SbUQdY^W Q^

QSS_e^d& cU\USdY^W Q fYTU_ VY\U Vb_] dXU ecUblc S_]`edUb _b _dXUb cd_bQWU TUfYSU& Q^T dXU^ S\YS[Y^W Q Redd_^ d_ Y^cdbeSd dXU N_eIeRU cicdU] d_ e`\_QT dXQd fYTU_( +2( c Yd U( ( p -(

N_eIeRU T_Uc ^_d S_^db_\ gXYSX fYTU_c Q ecUb SX__cUc d_ e`\_QT d_ dXU

( p p -& 3 +3( J`\_QTUT fYTU_ VY\Uc QbU Qed_]QdYSQ\\i `b_SUccUT Ri N_eIeRUlc

S_]`edUb cicdU]c Q^T S_^fUbdUT Y^d_ VY\U V_b]Qdc dXQd QbU ce``_bdUT Ri Q fQbYUdi _V fYUgY^W TUfYSUc( ,*( ( pp 0'1(

IXU cUbYUc _V UfU^dc dXQd Yc dbYWWUbUT Ri Q ecUblc TUSYcY_^ d_ e`\_QT Q

fYTU_ d_ N_eIeRU Q^T U^Tc gYdX dXU ecUblc fYTU_ RUY^W ]QTU `\QiQR\U _^ N_eIeRU Yc Ve\\i Qed_]QdUT Q^T T_Uc ^_d Y^f_\fU dXU Y^dUbfU^dY_^ _b QSdYfU Y^f_\fU]U^d _V N_eIeRU `Ubc_^^U\( ,+( ( p ,(

6^i_^U gYdX >^dUb^Ud QSSUcc Q^T cdQ^TQbT >^dUb^Ud Rb_gcY^W c_VdgQbU ( p 3(

SQ^ fYUg V_b VbUU dXU fYTU_c dXQd ecUbc XQfU cd_bUT _^ N_eIeRU( ,,(

6 ecUb Y^YdYQdUc `\QiRQS[ _V Q N_eIeRU fYTU_ Ri cU\USdY^W dXU fYTU_ (

dXQd dXU ecUb gYcXUc d_ fYUg _^ dXU N_eIeRU cUbfYSU( ,-(

>^ bUc`_^cU d_ Q `\QiRQS[ bUaeUcd& dXU N_eIeRU cicdU] Qed_]QdYSQ\\i

cdbUQ]c Q S_`i _V dXU bUaeUcdUT fYTU_ Vb_] _^U _V Ydc fYTU_ cUbfUbc d_ dXU ecUblc S_]`edUb _b _dXUb fYUgY^W TUfYSU( (

4

,.(

>^ Q\]_cd Q\\ SQcUc& N_eIeRU `b_XYRYdc ecUbc Vb_] T_g^\_QTY^W fYTU_c ( p +*(

Vb_] dXU cYdU& Q^T T_Uc ^_d _VVUb dXQd Ve^SdY_^Q\Ydi d_ ecUbc( ,/(

JcUbc ]Qi cUQbSX dXU N_eIeRU gURcYdU V_b fYTU_c Ri U^dUbY^W Q aeUbi

_V dUb]c dXU ecUb TUU]c bU\UfQ^d Y^d_ cUQbSX VYU\Tc `b_fYTUT _^ fQbY_ec `QWUc dXb_eWX_ed dXU cYdU( ,0( ( p ++(

>^ bUc`_^cU d_ dXU aeUbi& dXU cUbfYSU Qed_]QdYSQ\\i bUdeb^c Q bUce\dc

`QWU dXQd cX_gc dXU ecUb Q `QWU _b `QWUc S_^dQY^Y^W cY^W\U& bUTeSUT'cYjU Y]QWUc _V dXU fYTU_ S\Y`c dXQd dXU cUQbSX Q\W_bYdX] YTU^dYVYUc Qc RUY^W bUc`_^cYfU d_ dXU ecUblc aeUbi& QSS_]`Q^YUT Ri Q `_bdY_^ _V dXU dUhd dXU ecUb gX_ e`\_QTUT dXU fYTU_ `b_fYTUT d_ TUcSbYRU dXU fYTU_( (

,1(

LXU^ N_eIeRU _VVYSYQ\\i \Qe^SXUT Y^ 9USU]RUb ,**/& Yd gQc bUSUYfY^W

Q``b_hY]QdU\i 0&*** ^Ug fYTU_ e`\_QTc UQSX TQi& Q^T Ydc ecUbc gUbU gQdSXY^W ^UQb\i ,(/ ]Y\\Y_^ fYTU_c UQSX TQi( =eb\Ui 9US\( p ,- " :h( ,2( ,2( ,/&***( ,3( ( >^ ?e\i ,**0& ecUbc e`\_QTUT d_ N_eIeRU ]_bU dXQ^ ,(+ ]Y\\Y_^ fYTU_c ( 7i ;URbeQbi ,**0& dXU ^e]RUb _V TQY\i fYTU_ e`\_QTc d_ N_eIeRU gQc

d_ dXU cYdU& Q^T gQdSXUT ]_bU dXQ^ - RY\\Y_^ fYTU_c( -*(

7i 9USU]RUb ,**1& ecUbc gUbU e`\_QTY^W d_ N_eIeRU ]_bU dXQ^

-**&*** fYTU_c UQSX TQi Q^T cYdU dbQVVYS XQT bUQSXUT 2** ]Y\\Y_^ TQY\i fYTU_ fYUgc( ( p ,-(

5

-+(

7i ?e\i ,**2& e`\_QTc d_ N_eIeRU XQT bUQSXUT ]_bU dXQ^ .**&***

fYTU_c `Ub TQi( -,( 9US\( p ,0( --( AUcc dXQ^ +! _V dXU ]_bU dXQ^ /** ]Y\\Y_^ fYTU_c `_cdUT d_ N_eIeRU B_bU dXQ^ /** ]Y\\Y_^ fYTU_c XQfU RUU^ `_cdUT d_ N_eIeRU( AUfY^U

XQfU RUU^ dXU ceRZUSd _V Q 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSU _b Q^ UaeYfQ\U^d dQ[UT_g^ bUaeUcd cU^d d_ N_eIeRU Ri Q S_`ibYWXd _g^Ub( -.( (

N_eIeRU X_cdc Xe^TbUTc _V ]Y\\Y_^c _V fYTU_c dXQd ^_ _^U XQc UfUb (

Q\\UWUT d_ Y^VbY^WU Q^i S_`ibYWXd( -/(

6d `bUcU^d& ]_bU dXQ^ ,. X_ebc _V ^Ug fYTU_ Yc e`\_QTUT d_ N_eIeRU

UfUbi ]Y^edU& _b Q\]_cd V_eb iUQbc g_bdX _V ^Ug fYTU_ UfUbi TQi( =eb\Ui 9US\( p ,0( -0( N_eIeRU T_Uc ^_d ]Q^eQ\\i `bUcSbUU^ _b bUfYUg UQSX _V dXU fYTU_c

e`\_QTUT d_ dXU cUbfYSU Ri Ydc ecUbc( AUfY^U 9US\( p ,05 =eb\Ui 9US\( p +25 9US\( _V BYSQX HSXQVVUb Y^ He``_bd _V 9UVc(l B_d( V_b He]]Qbi ?eTW]U^d $mHSXQVVUb 9US\(n% p ++( -1( N_eIeRU Yc Q `\QdV_b] V_b Qc`YbY^W QbdYcdc Q^T VY\]]Q[Ubc( 9US\( _V

=e^dUb LQ\[ Y^ He``_bd _V 9UVc(l B_d( V_b He]]Qbi ?eTW]U^d $mLQ\[ 9US\(n% p +0( -2( -3( N_eIeRU Yc Q c_ebSU _V `_\YdYSQ\ Y^V_b]QdY_^( ( p p 0& 2& 3(

<_fUb^]U^dc Q^T _dXUb _VVYSYQ\ R_TYUc XQfU UcdQR\YcXUT SXQ^^U\c _^&

Q^T `_cdUT fYTU_c d_& N_eIeRU& Y^S\eTY^W dXU KQdYSQ^& dXU @bU]\Y^& dXU FeUU^ _V :^W\Q^T& dXU J^YdUT CQdY_^c& Q^T dXU W_fUb^]U^dc _V >bQa& >cbQU\& H_edX @_bUQ& Q^T :cd_^YQ( LQ\[ 9US\( p 2(

6

.*(

8_\\UWUc Q^T e^YfUbcYdYUc XQfU `_cdUT fYTU_c d_ N_eIeRU& Y^S\eTY^W ( p +,(

dU^c _V dX_ecQ^Tc _V fYTU_'\USdebUc _^ QSQTU]YS ceRZUSdc( .+( dXUYb SQecUc( .,(

C_^`b_VYd _bWQ^YjQdY_^c XQfU `_cdUT fYTU_c d_ N_eIeRU d_ `eR\YSYjU ( pp +*'++( AQg U^V_bSU]U^d _VVYSYQ\c XQfU `_cdUT fYTU_c d_ N_eIeRU cUU[Y^W dXU ( p +3(

`eR\YSlc XU\` Y^ YTU^dYViY^W SbY]Y^Q\ cec`USdc( .-(

B_fYU Q^T dU\UfYcY_^ cdeTY_c $Y^S\eTY^W 87H& C78)J^YfUbcQ\& 778&

Q^T AY_^c <QdU%& c`_bdc \UQWeUc $Y^S\eTY^W dXU C76 Q^T C=A%& bUS_bT \QRU\c $Y^S\eTY^W J^YfUbcQ\ BecYS <b_e`& H_^i& LQb^Ub BecYS <b_e`& Q^T :B>%& Q^T ]ecYS `eR\YcXUbc XQfU U^dUbUT Y^d_ S_^dU^d `Qbd^UbcXY` QbbQ^WU]U^dc gYdX N_eIeRU( 9US\( _V 8XbYcd_`XUb BQhSi Y^ He``_bd _V 9UVc(l B_d( V_b He]]Qbi ?eTW]U^d $mBQhSi 9US\(n% p 3( ..( KYQS_] UhUSedYfUc Q^T U]`\_iUUc XQfU e`\_QTUT Q^T gQdSXUT fYTU_c

_^ N_eIeRU( HSXQ`Yb_ :h( +,1 $+,34,+'+-*4+.%& :h( +,2 $1341'2*4-& 2+4+1',.& 2-4+,' +0& 2.4+.'+2%& :h( +,3 $,+/4,/',+242& ,,.4,',,/4+-%& :h( +-* $+34+*'+.& //4,+',.%& :h( ,/ $,/-4+*'+3%& :h( ++, $+04+3',/%( ./( :]`\_iUUc _V dXU `edQdYfU S\Qcc `\QY^dYVVc XQfU e`\_QTUT Q^T gQdSXUT

fYTU_c _^ N_eIeRU( HSXQ`Yb_ :h( ,* $+**4+,'+*-43%& :h( 12 $,-/4+',-241%& :h(+-+( .0( .1( KYQS_] S_^cYTUbUT ReiY^W N_eIeRU( HSXQ`Yb_ :h( - $1141'+/%(

HU^Y_b UhUSedYfUc Qd KYQS_] fYUgUT dXU `b_c`USd _V QSaeYbY^W N_eIeRU (

Qc Q mdbQ^cV_b]QdYfU QSaeYcYdY_^(n

7

.2(

7UWY^^Y^W gYdX Ydc \Qe^SX Q^T S_^dY^eY^W d_TQi& N_eIeRU bUaeYbUc Ydc

ecUbc d_ QWbUU d_ IUb]c _V HUbfYSU RUV_bU RUY^W `Ub]YddUT d_ e`\_QT Q fYTU_ d_ dXU cYdU( =eb\Ui 9US\( p 25 AUfY^U 9US\( p 0( .3( N_eIeRUlc IUb]c _V HUbfYSU XQfU Q\gQic `b_XYRYdUT ecUbc Vb_]

ceR]YddY^W S_`ibYWXdUT ]QdUbYQ\ dXQd dXUi QbU ^_d QedX_bYjUT d_ e`\_QT( =eb\Ui 9US\( p 25 AUfY^U 9US\( p 0( /*( KYbdeQ\\i UfUbi `QWU _V dXU N_eIeRU gURcYdU S_^dQY^c Q TYbUSd \Y^[ d_ (

N_eIeRUlc IUb]c _V HUbfYSU( /+(

HY^SU DSd_RUb ,**0& N_eIeRU XQc TYc`\QiUT m8_]]e^Ydi <eYTU\Y^Ucn

_^ Ydc cYdU Y^cdbeSdY^W ecUbc d_ mbUc`USd S_`ibYWXdn Q^T _^\i d_ me`\_QT fYTU_c dXQd i_e ]QTU _b dXQd i_e QbU QedX_bYjUT d_ ecU(n /,( ( p 1(

HY^SU Qd \UQcd BQbSX ,**0& UQSX dY]U Q ecUb cUU[c d_ e`\_QT Q fYTU_&

N_eIeRU Y^V_b]c Ydc ecUbc& fYQ ]e\dY`\U ]UccQWUc TYc`\QiUT Y^ dXU e`\_QT `b_SUcc& dXQd dXUi QbU `b_XYRYdUT Vb_] e`\_QTY^W S_`ibYWXdUT S_^dU^d e^\Ucc dXUi XQfU dXU bYWXd _b QedX_bYjQdY_^ d_ T_ c_( /-( ( p 2(

HY^SU Qd \UQcd BQbSX ,**0& N_eIeRU XQc `b_fYTUT Q m8_`ibYWXdc IY`cn

`QWU dXQd WYfUc ecUbc WeYTQ^SU _^ S_`ibYWXd YcceUc Q^T TUcSbYRUc dXU S_^cUaeU^SUc d_ ecUbc _V S_`ibYWXd Y^VbY^WU]U^d _^ dXU cYdU( /.( ( pp 3& +/(

IXU 8_`ibYWXdc IY`c `QWU \Y^[c d_ _dXUb `QWUc S_^dQY^Y^W QTTYdY_^Q\ ( p 3(

Y^V_b]QdY_^ QR_ed S_`ibYWXd(

8

//(

HY^SU Qd \UQcd BQbSX ,**0& N_eIeRU XQc bUaeYbUT dXQd ecUbc ceR]Yd Q ( p ++(

fQ\YT Q^T g_b[Y^W U]QY\ QTTbUcc d_ N_eIeRU RUV_bU e`\_QTY^W Q^i fYTU_c( /0(

HY^SU Qd \UQcd BQbSX ,**0& N_eIeRU XQc fUbYVYUT dXU QSSebQSi _V Ydc

ecUbcl U]QY\ QTTbUccUc d_ U^cebU dXUbU Yc Q ]USXQ^Yc] V_b gQb^Y^W ecUbc _V Y]`b_`Ub ecU _V dXU N_eIeRU cUbfYSU( /1( (

HY^SU BQbSX ,**0& N_eIeRU XQc \Y]YdUT dXU TebQdY_^ _V fYTU_c

e`\_QTUT Ri ]_cd ecUbc d_ +* ]Y^edUc d_ `bUfU^d ecUbc Vb_] e`\_QTY^W Q fYTU_ S_^cYcdY^W _V Q^ U^dYbU dU\UfYcY_^ cX_g _b VUQdebU'\U^WdX VY\]( /2( ( p +,(

N_eIeRU XQc ^UfUb Y^cdbeSdUT ecUbc d_ U^WQWU Y^ S_`ibYWXd

Y^VbY^WU]U^d( =eb\Ui 9US\( p ,*( /3( N_eIeRU XQc ^UfUb U^S_ebQWUT ecUbc d_ U^WQWU Y^ S_`ibYWXd

Y^VbY^WU]U^d(

0*(

HY^SU HU`dU]RUb ,**/& N_eIeRU XQc TYc`\QiUT Y^V_b]QdY_^ _^ Ydc

gURcYdU Y^cdbeSdY^W S_`ibYWXd X_\TUbc X_g d_ `b_fYTU ^_dYSU d_ N_eIeRUlc TUcYW^QdUT QWU^d _V Q\\UWUT\i e^QedX_bYjUT ]QdUbYQ\c e`\_QTUT Ri ecUbc( =eb\Ui 9US\( p ,+5 AUfY^U 9US\( pp +/'+0( 0+( N_eIeRU V_b]Q\\i bUWYcdUbUT Ydc 9B86 QWU^d gYdX dXU 8_`ibYWXd

DVVYSU Y^ DSd_RUb ,**/( =eb\Ui 9US\( p ,+( 0,( N_eIeRUlc 9B86 QWU^dlc S_^dQSd Y^V_b]QdY_^ Yc QSSUccYR\U dXb_eWX

N_eIeRUlc m8_`ibYWXd >^VbY^WU]U^d C_dYVYSQdY_^n `QWU( AUfY^U 9US\( p +/(

9

0-(

HY^SU Qd \UQcd BQbSX ,**0& Q \Y^[ d_ dXU 8_`ibYWXd >^VbY^WU]U^d

C_dYVYSQdY_^ `QWU XQc RUU^ Y^S\eTUT Qd dXU R_dd_] _V fYbdeQ\\i UfUbi `QWU _V dXU N_eIeRU gURcYdU( (

0.(

N_eIeRU bU]_fUc _b TYcQR\Uc QSSUcc d_ Q\\UWUT\i Y^VbY^WY^W fYTU_c ( p +35 HSXQVVUb 9US\( p

gXU^UfUb Yd bUSUYfUc Q 9B86'S_]`\YQ^d dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSU( +*( 0/(

N_eIeRU bU]_fUc Q\]_cd Q\\ fYTU_c YTU^dYVYUT Y^ 9B86 ^_dYSUc gYdXY^

,. X_ebc _V bUSUY`d( AUfY^U 9US\( p +3( 00( ;_b Q``b_hY]QdU\i 2/! _V dXU 9B86 ^_dYSUc Yd XQc bUSUYfUT& N_eIeRU (

bU]_fUc dXU YTU^dYVYUT fYTU_c gYdXY^ Q VUg ]Y^edUc( 01(

N_eIeRU U]`\_ic Q TUTYSQdUT dUQ] dXb_eWX_ed dXU g_b\T d_ `b_SUcc

]Q^eQ\\i'ceR]YddUT 9B86 ^_dYSUc Q^T d_ QccYcd S_`ibYWXd X_\TUbc Q^T ecUbc gYdX YcceUc QbYcY^W Vb_] dXU ^_dYSU `b_SUcc( 02( (

D^ ;URbeQbi ,& ,**1& KYQS_] $dXb_eWX Ydc QWU^d& 7QiIHE% cU^d 9B86

^_dYSUc bUaeUcdY^W dXQd N_eIeRU bU]_fU ]_bU dXQ^ +**&*** fYTU_c Vb_] dXU cUbfYSU( AUfY^U 9US\( p ,*5 HSXQVVUb 9US\( p +.( 03( N_eIeRU bU]_fUT fYbdeQ\\i Q\\ _V dXU fYTU_c YTU^dYVYUT Y^ KYQS_]lc

;URbeQbi ,& ,**1 ]Qcc dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSUc RUV_bU dXU ^Uhd RecY^Ucc TQi( AUfY^U 9US\( p ,*5 HSXQVVUb 9US\( p +.( 1*( N_eIeRUlc bUc`_^cYfU^Ucc d_ 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ bUaeUcdc XQc TbQg^

`bQYcU Vb_] S_^dU^d _g^Ubc( AUfY^U 9US\( p ,,5 HSXQ`Yb_ :h( +,*(

10

1+(

HY^SU Qd \UQcd BQbSX ,**0& gXU^ N_eIeRU XQc bU]_fUT Q fYTU_

`ebceQ^d d_ Q 9B86 ^_dYSU& N_eIeRU XQc S_^dQSdUT dXU ecUb gX_ e`\_QTUT dXU fYTU_ d_ Q``bYcU dXQd ecUb _V dXU Q\\UWQdY_^ Y^ dXU ^_dYSU( AUfY^U 9US\( p ,-( 1,( HY^SU Qd \UQcd BQbSX ,**0& gXU^ N_eIeRU XQc bU]_fUT Q fYTU_

`ebceQ^d d_ Q 9B86 ^_dYSU& N_eIeRU XQc S_^dQSdUT dXU ecUb gX_ e`\_QTUT dXU fYTU_ d_ bU]Y^T dXQd ecUb _V N_eIeRUlc `_\YSi `b_XYRYdY^W dXU e`\_QTY^W _V e^QedX_bYjUT S_`ibYWXdUT ]QdUbYQ\( 1-( (

HY^SU Qd \UQcd BQbSX ,**0& gXU^ N_eIeRU XQc bU]_fUT Q fYTU_

`ebceQ^d d_ Q 9B86 ^_dYSU& N_eIeRU XQc S_^dQSdUT dXU ecUb gX_ e`\_QTUT dXU fYTU_ d_ gQb^ dXQd ecUb dXQd bU`UQdUT QSdc _V S_`ibYWXd Y^VbY^WU]U^d gY\\ bUce\d Y^ dXU dUb]Y^QdY_^ _V dXU ecUblc N_eIeRU QSS_e^d( 1.( (

HY^SU Qd \UQcd BQbSX ,**0& gXU^ N_eIeRU bU]_fUc Q fYTU_ `ebceQ^d d_

Q 9B86 ^_dYSU& Yd cU^Tc dXYc ]UccQWU d_ dXU ecUb gX_ `_cdUT dXU fYTU_4 GU`UQd Y^SYTU^dc _V S_`ibYWXd Y^VbY^WU]U^d gY\\ bUce\d Y^ dXU TU\UdY_^ _V i_eb QSS_e^d Q^T Q\\ fYTU_c e`\_QTUT d_ dXQd QSS_e^d( >^ _bTUb d_ Qf_YT VedebU cdbY[Uc QWQY^cd i_eb QSS_e^d& `\UQcU TU\UdU Q^i fYTU_c d_ gXYSX i_e T_ ^_d _g^ dXU bYWXdc& Q^T bUVbQY^ Vb_] e`\_QTY^W QTTYdY_^Q\ fYTU_c dXQd Y^VbY^WU _^ dXU S_`ibYWXdc _V _dXUbc( ;_b ]_bU Y^V_b]QdY_^ QR_ed N_eIeRU#c S_`ibYWXd `_\YSi& `\UQcU bUQT dXU 8_`ibYWXd IY`c WeYTU( AUfY^U 9US\( p ,- " :h( +,( 1/( HY^SU Qd \UQcd BQbSX ,**0& QVdUb Q^ Q\\UWUT\i Y^VbY^WY^W fYTU_ Yc

bU]_fUT Vb_] dXU cYdU& N_eIeRU XQc `_cdUT Q ^_dYSU Qd dXU fYTU_lc `bY_b \_SQdY_^ _^ dXU cYdU cdQdY^W dXQd dXU fYTU_ Yc ^_ \_^WUb QfQY\QR\U TeU d_ Q S_`ibYWXd S\QY]( ,.( (p

11

10(

HY^SU Qd \UQcd DSd_RUb ,**/& N_eIeRU XQc XQT Q `_\YSi V_b

dUb]Y^QdY^W dXU QSS_e^dc _V bU`UQd Y^VbY^WUbc& gXYSX Yd XQc `_cdUT _^ Ydc gURcYdU( =eb\Ui 9US\( p ,+5 AUfY^U 9US\( p ,1( 11( J^TUb N_eIeRUlc bU`UQd'Y^VbY^WUb `_\YSi& Q mcdbY[Un Yc YcceUT d_ Q ecUb

gXU^ N_eIeRU bUSUYfUc Q dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSU V_b ]QdUbYQ\ dXQd dXU ecUb XQc e`\_QTUT( AUfY^U 9US\( p ,1( 12( LXU^ Q^ QSS_e^d bUSUYfUc dXbUU cdbY[Uc& Y^ fYbdeQ\\i Q\\ SQcUc N_eIeRU (

dUb]Y^QdUc dXQd QSS_e^d( 13(

LXU^ N_eIeRU dUb]Y^QdUc Q ecUblc QSS_e^d& dXU QSS_e^d SQ^ ^_ \_^WUb

Ri ecUT V_b Q^i `eb`_cU _^ dXU cYdU( AUfY^U 9US\( p -*( 2*( LXU^ N_eIeRU dUb]Y^QdUc Q ecUblc QSS_e^d& N_eIeRU dUb]Y^QdUc Q\\ (

_dXUb QSS_e^dc Qcc_SYQdUT gYdX dXQd ecUblc U]QY\ QTTbUcc( 2+(

LXU^ N_eIeRU dUb]Y^QdUc Q ecUblc QSS_e^d& N_eIeRU bU]_fUc Q\\ _V

dXU fYTU_c e`\_QTUT d_ dXU cYdU Vb_] dXU dUb]Y^QdUT QSS_e^d& Y^S\eTY^W fYTU_c dXQd gUbU ^_d ceRZUSd d_ Q^i 9B86 ^_dYSU( 2,( (

LXU^ N_eIeRU dUb]Y^QdUc Q ecUblc QSS_e^d& N_eIeRU cUU[c d_ `bUfU^d

dXU ecUb Vb_] ceRcUaeU^d\i SbUQdY^W Q^_dXUb QSS_e^d Ri bUS_bTY^W Q^T R\_S[Y^W dXU U]QY\ QTTbUcc Qcc_SYQdUT gYdX dXU dUb]Y^QdUT QSS_e^d( 2-( (

N_eIeRUlc IUb]c _V HUbfYSU cUd V_bdX N_eIeRUlc bU`UQd'Y^VbY^WUb

`_\YSi( AUfY^U 9US\( :hc( +& ,(

12

2.(

N_eIeRU S_]]e^YSQdUc Ydc bU`UQd'Y^VbY^WUb `_\YSi d_ Ydc ecUbc fYQ Ydc

gURcYdU& Y^S\eTY^W _^ dXU m8_`ibYWXd IY`cn `QWU Q^T dXU m=U\`n cUSdY_^ _V dXU cYdU( ( p ,1( 2/( JcUbc Q\c_ QbU ^_dYVYUT _V N_eIeRUlc bU`UQd'Y^VbY^WUb `_\YSi gXU^ dXUi

bUSUYfU Q^ U]QY\ ^_dYViY^W dXU] dXQd Q fYTU_ dXUi e`\_QTUT d_ N_eIeRU XQc RUU^ bU]_fUT TeU d_ Q\\UWUT S_`ibYWXd Y^VbY^WU]U^d( 20( p ,- " :h( +,(

6``\iY^W Ydc bU`UQd'Y^VbY^WUb `_\YSi& N_eIeRU XQc dUb]Y^QdUT ]_bU

dXQ^ .**&*** $_V dXU ]_bU dXQ^ ,/*&***&***% ecUb QSS_e^dc RQcUT Qd \UQcd Y^ `Qbd V_b S_`ibYWXd cdbY[Uc( 21( p -+(

N_eIeRU XQc bUSUYfUT `bQYcU Vb_] S_^dU^d _g^Ubc V_b Ydc UVV_bdc d_ pp -,'--(

bUcdbYSd Q^T QTTbUcc S_`ibYWXd Y^VbY^WU]U^d Ri Ydc ecUbc(

22(

>^ BQbSX ,**0& N_eIeRU RUWQ^ ecY^W B9'/ XQcX dUSX^_\_Wi d_ SbUQdU

Q TYWYdQ\ mVY^WUb`bY^dn _V UfUbi fYTU_ dXQd N_eIeRU bU]_fUc Y^ bUc`_^cU d_ Q 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSU( 23( p ,/5 9US\( _V 9QfYT @Y^W $m@Y^W 9US\(n% p.(

IXU B9'/ dUSX^_\_Wi Qed_]QdYSQ\\i `bUfU^dc Q^i ecUb Vb_] e`\_QTY^W

Q fYTU_ VY\U YTU^dYSQ\ d_ _^U dXQd XQT `bUfY_ec\i RUU^ bU]_fUT Y^ bUc`_^cU d_ Q 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSU( AUfY^U 9US\( p,/( 3*( $m8KEn%( 3+( >^ BQbSX ,**0& N_eIeRU \Qe^SXUT Ydc 8_^dU^d KUbYVYSQdY_^ Eb_WbQ] p +2( 8KE Yc _`U^ d_ Q^i S_`ibYWXd _g^Ub( (

13

3,(

8KE U^QR\Uc S_`ibYWXd _g^Ubc d_ \_SQdU Q^T V\QW dXUYb fYTU_c _^ ( p +2(

N_eIeRU Q^T cU^T 9B86 ^_dYSUc U\USdb_^YSQ\\i( 3-( 3.(

B_bU dXQ^ -&*** S_^dU^d _g^Ubc XQfU bUWYcdUbUT d_ ecU 8KE( >^ ;URbeQbi ,**1& N_eIeRU \Qe^SXUT Y^ RUdQ V_b] Ydc 8\QY] N_eb

8_^dU^d $m8N8n% cicdU]( @Y^W 9US\( pp 1'2( 3/( 8N8 ecUT QeTY_'VY^WUb`bY^dY^W dUSX^_\_Wi d_ U^QR\U `QbdYSY`QdY^W

bYWXdc X_\TUbc d_ VY^T fYTU_c S_^dQY^Y^W dXUYb S_^dU^d dXQd ecUbc XQT e`\_QTUT d_ N_eIeRU( 30( ( p 1( D^SU 8N8 V_e^T Q fYTU_& Q bYWXdc X_\TUb S_e\T Q``\i _^U _V dXbUU & Y^cdbeSd N_eIeRU d_

N_eIeRU `_\YSYUc Y^ bUc`_^cU d_ Q ]QdSX4 $+% mR\_S[n $ bU]_fU dXU fYTU_ Vb_] N_eIeRU%5 $,% mdbQS[n $

& \UQfU Yd e` _^ N_eIeRU Q^T & \UQfU Yd e` _^ N_eIeRU Q^T

bUSUYfU bU`_bdc QR_ed dXU fYTU_%5 _b $-% m]_^UdYjUn $ cXQbU Y^ QTfUbdYcY^W bUfU^eU%( 31( p 1(

>^ ?Q^eQbi ,**1& N_eIeRU RUWQ^ Ve\\'cSQ\U TUfU\_`]U^d _V Q fYTU_'

RQcUT YTU^dYVYSQdY_^ dUSX^_\_Wi SQ\\UT mKYTU_ >9(n @Y^W 9US\( p+1( 32( 33( N_eIeRU _VVYSYQ\\i \Qe^SXUT KYTU_ >9 Y^ DSd_RUb ,**1( p +2(

7UdgUU^ ?Q^eQbi Q^T DSd_RUb ,**1& N_eIeRU XQT RUdgUU^ +/ Q^T ,* p

U^WY^UUbc Q^T _dXUb dUSX^YSQ\ `Ubc_^^U\ g_b[Y^W Ve\\ _b `Qbd dY]U _^ KYTU_ >9( +1( +**( KYTU_ >9 gQc dXU VYbcd fYTU_'RQcUT S_^dU^d YTU^dYVYSQdY_^ dUSX^_\_Wi d_

RU TU`\_iUT _^ Q^i gURcYdU TUTYSQdUT d_ ecUb'ceR]YddUT S_^dU^d( :h( +03 $,214+0',224.%(

p +35 HSXQ`Yb_

14

+*+(

>^ 6`bY\ ,**2& N_eIeRU ce``\U]U^dUT KYTU_ >9 Ri \Qe^SXY^W Q^ QeTY_' p ,*(

RQcUT S_^dU^d YTU^dYVYSQdY_^ dUSX^_\_Wi SQ\\UT 6eTY_ >9( +*,(

N_eIeRU ]Q[Uc KYTU_ >9 Q^T 6eTY_ >9 $S_\\USdYfU\i& m8_^dU^d >9n%

QfQY\QR\U d_ S_^dU^d _g^Ubc d_ Q\\_g dXU] d_ YTU^dYVi dXUYb S_^dU^d _^ dXU N_eIeRU gURcYdU( +*-( ( 8_^dU^d >9 g_b[c Ri YTU^dYViY^W fYTU_c _^ N_eIeRU dXQd ]QdSX p ,-(

bUVUbU^SU VY\Uc ce``\YUT Ri `QbdYSY`QdY^W bYWXdc X_\TUbc( +*.(

6c _V 9USU]RUb ,**3& bYWXd X_\TUbc XQT ce``\YUT N_eIeRU gYdX

Q``b_hY]QdU\i - ]Y\\Y_^ bUVUbU^SU VY\Uc V_b 8_^dU^d >9( +*/( >V 8_^dU^d >9 YTU^dYVYUc Q fYTU_ Qc ]QdSXY^W _^U _V dX_cU bUVUbU^SU

VY\Uc& dXU bYWXdc X_\TUb SQ^ R\_S[)bU]_fU dXU fYTU_& Q\\_g dXU fYTU_ d_ Q``UQb Q^T cXQbU Q^i bUfU^eU WU^UbQdUT Vb_] QTfUbdYcY^W cX_g^ Q\_^WcYTU Yd& _b Q\\_g dXU fYTU_ d_ Q``UQb gYdX ^_ ]_^UdYjQdY_^( +*0( p ,.(

HY^SU Ydc \Qe^SX Y^ DSd_RUb ,**1& UfUbi fYTU_ dXQd Q ecUb XQc p ,0(

QddU]`dUT d_ `_cd d_ N_eIeRU XQc RUU^ cSbUU^UT ecY^W 8_^dU^d >9( +*1( p ,1( +*2( >9( p ,2( +*3( _V SXQbWU( ++*(

8_^dU^d >9 cSQ^c dXU RQS[ SQdQ\_WeU _V fYTU_c `_cdUT _^ N_eIeRU(

N_eIeRU SebbU^d\i XQc Q dUQ] _V .* dUSX^YSQ\ cdQVV g_b[Y^W _^ 8_^dU^d

N_eIeRU XQc Q\gQic ]QTU 8_^dU^d >9 QfQY\QR\U d_ bYWXdc X_\TUbc VbUU p ,,( B_bU dXQ^ +&*** S_^dU^d _g^Ubc g_b\TgYTU ecU 8_^dU^d >9( p ,+(

15

+++(

KYQS_] `QbdYSY`QdUT Y^ dXU `bU'\Qe^SX dUcdY^W _V KYTU_ >9 Y^ ]YT',**1(

pp +2& ,35 HSXQ`Yb_ :h( +1+( ++,( KYQS_] cYW^UT e` d_ ecU KYTU_ >9 Y^ ;URbeQbi ,**2( @Y^W 9US\( p ,3(

++-(

E\QY^dYVVc S_\\USdYfU\i XQfU YTU^dYVYUT Q``b_hY]QdU\i 13&*** fYTU_ S\Y`c

dXQd dXUi Q\\UWU d_ RU Y^VbY^WY^W _^ dXU N_eIeRU cUbfYSU $mS\Y`c Y^ ceYdn%( 9US\( _V BYSXQU\ GeRY^ Y^ He``_bd _V 9UVc(l B_d( V_b He]]Qbi ?eTW]U^d $mGeRY^ 9US\(n% pp 1& +0( IXQd d_dQ\ bU`bUcU^dc \Ucc dXQ^ (*,! _V dXU ]_bU dXQ^ /** ]Y\\Y_^ fYTU_c UfUb e`\_QTUT d_ N_eIeRU( AUfY^U 9US\( p ,0( ++.( IXU ]QZ_bYdi _V KYQS_]lc S\Y`c Y^ ceYd QbU e^TUb V_eb ]Y^edUc \_^W(

GeRY^ 9US\( p +/( ++/( ++0( 8UbdQY^ _V KYQS_]lc S\Y`c Y^ ceYd QbU VUgUb dXQ^ +* cUS_^Tc \_^W( IXU EbU]YUb AUQWeU Yc ceY^W N_eIeRU _fUb T_jU^c _V S\Y`c dXQd QbU p +0( (

e^TUb VYfU cUS_^Tc \_^W& Y^S\eTY^W _^U dXQd Yc _^U cUS_^T Y^ \U^WdX( ++1(

B_cd _V dXU S\Y`c Y^ ceYd gUbU dXU ceRZUSd _V 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSUc(

HSXQ`Yb_ :hc( +2 $+.+4+*'+35 +.242'+2%& +1 $+2043'+2141%( ++2( H_]U _V dXU `edQdYfU S\Qcc `\QY^dYVVcl S\Y`c Y^ ceYd gUbU ^UfUb dXU

ceRZUSd _V Q^i dQ[UT_g^ bUaeUcd `bY_b d_ RUY^W YTU^dYVYUT Qc Q\\UWUT Y^VbY^WU]U^dc Y^ dXYc SQcU( HSXQ`Yb_ :hc( ,* $3.4+3'3/40%& ,+ $,04+/',+%& ,, $GUc`_^cU -/%( ++3( KYQS_]lc S\Y`c Y^ ceYd gUbU YTU^dYVYUT Vb_] Q `__\ _V fYTU_c bU]_fUT

`ebceQ^d d_ 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSUc cU^d Ri KYQS_]( HSXQ`Yb_ :h( +2 $+.242'+2%(

16

+,*(

6\\ _V dXU S\Y`c Y^ ceYd XQfU RUU^ bU]_fUT Vb_] dXU N_eIeRU gURcYdU(

AUfY^U 9US\( p ,+(

+,+(

LYdXY^ ]_^dXc _V N_eIeRUlc \Qe^SX& ]QZ_b ]UTYQ S_]`Q^YUc& Y^S\eTY^W

KYQS_]& ecUT N_eIeRU d_ `b_]_dU dXUYb S_^dU^d Ri e`\_QTY^W S\Y`c _V dXUYb ]_fYUc Q^T dU\UfYcY_^ cX_gc d_ dXU cUbfYSU( 9US\( _V 6bdXeb 8XQ^ $m8XQ^ 9US\(n% pp.& /& 35 9US\( _V 9Q^YU\ Dcdb_g $mDcdb_g 9US\(n% pp,& .& /& 05 HSXQVVUb 9US\( p /5 9US\( _V GeRY^ 9US\( p , " :hc( +'.+( +,,( KYQS_] XQc Q\\_gUT KYQS_] S_^dU^d e`\_QTUT Ri _dXUb ecUbc d_ bU]QY^

_^ N_eIeRU( HSXQ`Yb_ :hc( . $+3.42'++%& /+ $K>6 ++121*30%( +,-( KYQS_] XQc e`\_QTUT d_ N_eIeRU dX_ecQ^Tc _V fYTU_c d_ ]Qb[Ud Q^T

`b_]_dU Xe^TbUTc _V Ydc ]_fYUc Q^T)_b dU\UfYcY_^ cX_gc& Y^S\eTY^W ]Q^i dXQd QbU g_b[c Y^ ceYd( GeRY^ 9US\( pp ,& +.& +2 " :hc( -'-+( +,.( KYQS_] XQc ecUT ]Qb[UdY^W QWU^dc d_ e`\_QT Ydc S_^dU^d d_ N_eIeRU(

HSXQ`Yb_ :hc( -/'..& ./ $,240'1%5 8XQ^( 9US\( pp -'/5 Dcdb_g 9US\( p/( +,/( KYQS_] XQc dQ[U^ cdU`c d_ S_^SUQ\ dXQd Yd gQc dXU c_ebSU _V SUbdQY^

fYTU_c dXQd Yd e`\_QTUT d_ N_eIeRU V_b ]Qb[UdY^W `eb`_cUc( 8XQ^ 9US\( pp.& /& 35 Dcdb_g 9US\( pp,& .& /& 05 HSXQ`Yb_ :hc( --& -.& .0& .1 $+/24,*',,%& .2& .3& /*5 GeRY^ 9US\( p /$Q%'$V% " :hc( .& +.& +/& +3& ,,& ,0( +,0( DdXUb ]UTYQ S_]`Q^YUc XQfU dQ[U^ cdU`c d_ S_^SUQ\ dXQd dXUi gUbU dXU

c_ebSU _V SUbdQY^ fYTU_c dXQd dXUi e`\_QTUT d_ N_eIeRU V_b ]Qb[UdY^W `eb`_cUc(

17

Dcdb_g 9US\( p 05

8XQ^ 9US\( pp -& .& 3& +*5 GeRY^ 9US\( p , " :hc( ,& -,'.+5

HSXQ`Yb_ :h( ,2 $<DD**+'*/+0+,/1'/2%( +,1( N_eIeRU gQc QgQbU _V `b_]_dY_^Q\ QSdYfYdYUc _SSebbY^W _^ Ydc cUbfYSU(

HSXQVVUb 9US\( pp 1'25 7_dXQ 9US\( pp ++'+,5 BQhSi 9US\( pp -'15 HSXQ`Yb_ :h( /-5 GeRY^ 9US\( p +& :hc( ,& -,'.+(

+,2(

KYQS_] XQc [^_gY^W\i \UVd e` _^ N_eIeRU dX_ecQ^Tc _V S\Y`c

S_^dQY^Y^W Ydc S_^dU^d( HSXQ`Yb_ :hc( /1& 0,& 1/& 10( +,3( N_eIeRU WQfU Y^cdbeSdY_^c d_ Ydc QWU^d& 7QiIHE& QR_ed gXYSX S\Y`c d_ :hc( ++

dQ[U T_g^ Vb_] N_eIeRU Q^T gXYSX S\Y`c d_ \UQfU e` _^ N_eIeRU(

$++/40'++24+%& /. $76NIHE **+*3-.+,%& // $76NIHE **-1,.1*.%& /0 $,+.4,/',+/40%& /1 $76NIHE **++,/0*/'*2%& /3& 0*& 0-'0.& 0/ $76NIHE **-1+2,*+%( +-*( KYQS_] TYT ^_d cXQbU gYdX N_eIeRU dXU dQ[UT_g^ Y^cdbeSdY_^c Yd :h( ++ $++24+*'+3%(

`b_fYTUT d_ 7QiIHE( +-+(

IXb_eWX Qd \UQcd DSd_RUb ,**0& KYQS_] XQT Q^ Y^dUb^Q\ `_\YSi _V

TUS\Y^Y^W d_ YcceU dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSUc V_b ecUb'ceR]YddUT S\Y`c _^ N_eIeRU S_^dQY^Y^W BIK CUdg_b[c $mBIKCn% S_^dU^d dXQd gUbU \Ucc dXQ^ VYfU ]Y^edUc \_^W( /3& 0*( +-,( >^ DSd_RUb ,**0& KYQS_] d_\T 7QiIHE d_ \UQfU e` _^ N_eIeRU Q^i :hc(

S\Y`c S_^dQY^Y^W BIKC S_^dU^d dXQd gUbU cX_bdUb dXQ^ ,(/ ]Y^edUc Y^ \U^WdX& bUWQbT\Ucc _V gX_ XQT `_cdUT dXU]( :h( /.(

18

+--(

AQdUb Y^ DSd_RUb ,**0& KYQS_] d_\T 7QiIHE dXQd Q\\ fYTU_c S_^dQY^Y^W

BIKC S_^dU^d cX_e\T RU \UVd e` _^ N_eIeRU e^\Ucc dXU fYTU_c gUbU mVe\\ U`Yc_TUc(n :hc( // $76NIHE **-1,.1*.%& /0 $,+.4,/',+/40%( +-.( KYQS_] Y^cdbeSdUT 7QiIHE d_ \UQfU e` _^ N_eIeRU mVe\\ U`Yc_TUcn _V :hc( ++ $++/40'++24+%&

SUbdQY^ _V Ydc `b_WbQ]c $c_]U _V gXYSX QbU g_b[c Y^ ceYd%( :h( /1 $76NIHE **++,/0*/'*2%( +-/(

KYQS_] XQc cdQdUT `eR\YS\i dXQd Yd gQc SX__cY^W d_ Q\\_g c_]U YV Ydc :h( 11(

S_^dU^d d_ bU]QY^ _^ N_eIeRU(

+-0(

IXU `edQdYfU S\Qcc `\QY^dYVVc XQfU \YSU^cUT dXUYb S_^dU^d d_ Q``UQb _^

N_eIeRU& Y^S\eTY^W G_TWUbc " =Q]]UbcdUY^ $mG"=n%& gXYSX XQc YcceUT ^e]Ub_ec \YSU^cUc dXQd Q\\_g \YSU^cUUc d_ `_cd G"= ]ecYSQ\ S_]`_cYdY_^c _^ dXU >^dUb^Ud $Y^S\eTY^W _^ N_eIeRU%( $,34,,'-*4,,& -+40'-,4 +,%( +-1( 8Q\ >K XQc \YSU^cUT Ydc ]ecYSQ\ S_]`_cYdY_^c& Y^S\eTY^W SUbdQY^ g_b[c :hc( ,, $GUc`_^cUc ,0',3%& 12 $+-,4,.'+-/4+-%& 13

dXQd dXU S\Y`c Y^ ceYd QbU Q\\UWUT d_ XQfU Y^VbY^WUT $mg_b[c Y^ ceYdn%& V_b WU^UbQ\ TYccU]Y^QdY_^ _^ dXU >^dUb^Ud( +-2( :h( 2+(

8Q\ >K XQc QedX_bYjUT SUbdQY^ _V Ydc g_b[c Y^ ceYd d_ Q``UQb _^ :h( 2,(

N_eIeRU V_b `b_]_dY_^Q\ `eb`_cUc( +-3(

HdQWU IXbUU XQc YcceUT \YSU^cUc Q\\_gY^W Ydc ]ecYSQ\ S_]`_cYdY_^c& :h( 2- $GUc`_^cU +1& +3%(

Y^S\eTY^W g_b[c Y^ ceYd& d_ Q``UQb _^ N_eIeRU(

19

+.*(

8XUbbi AQ^U XQc QedX_bYjUT Ydc ]ecYSQ\ S_]`_cYdY_^c& Y^S\eTY^W g_b[c :hc( 20 $GUc`_^cU +1%& 21(

Y^ ceYd& d_ RU `_cdUT d_ N_eIeRU( +.+(

Ieb& 7_eb^U& 8Qb\Y^& Q^T M'G6N 9D< XQfU \YSU^cUT dXYbT `QbdYUc d_ :hc( 225 23 $GUc`_^cUc

`ed dXUYb S_^dU^d& Y^S\eTY^W g_b[c Y^ ceYd& _^ N_eIeRU(

+0'+2%& 3* $GUc`_^cUc +1& +3%& 3+ $GUc`_^cUc +1& +3%& 3, $+,.41'+,/4/%& 3-( +.,( ;;I Q^T BecYS ;_bSU XQfU `_cdUT dXUYb S_^dU^d _^ N_eIeRU _b :hc( 3. $+224/'+314,.%& 3/'31& 32 $GUc`_^cUc -*& .*&

QedX_bYjUT _dXUbc d_ T_ c_( .+& ..%& 33( +.-(

8UbdQY^ _V dXU c_SSUb S\eRc dXQd QbU ]U]RUbc _V Q^T XQfU _g^UbcXY`

Y^dUbUcdc Y^ dXU EbU]YUb AUQWeU XQfU SbUQdUT _VVYSYQ\ N_eIeRU mSXQ^^U\cn d_ gXYSX dXUi XQfU e`\_QTUT fYTU_c& Y^S\eTY^W V__dQWU _V ]QdSXUc( +**& +*+( +..( 8UbdQY^ _V dXU `edQdYfU S\Qcc `\QY^dYVVcl S_^dU^d& Y^S\eTY^W SUbdQY^ _V :hc( 2- $GUc`_^cU 02%& 32 :hc( +1 $,1043',3141&

dXUYb g_b[c Y^ ceYd& QbU S_'_g^UT Ri _dXUb `QbdYUc( $GUc`_^cU ,/%& +*- $GUc`_^cU --%& +*. $.24+0'.34+,%(

+./(

KYQS_] XQc cU^d 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSUc V_b fYTU_c dXQd KYQS_] YdcU\V

e`\_QTUT _b _dXUbgYcU QedX_bYjUT d_ Q``UQb _^ N_eIeRU( GeRY^ 9US\( p - " :hc( .,' 02 $bUdbQSdUT dQ[UT_g^c%5 HSXQVVUb 9US\( pp +/'+25 HSXQ`Yb_ :hc( +.3'+/*( +.0( KYQS_] XQc cU^d 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSUc d_ N_eIeRU dXQd bUce\dUT Y^

dXU dUb]Y^QdY_^ _V KYQS_]lc _g^ N_eIeRU QSS_e^dc( HSXQVVUb 9US\( pp +/'+0 " :h( .5 GeRY^ 9US\( p - " :hc( .,& /0'01(

20

+.1(

KYQS_] XQc bUaeUcdUT dXU dQ[UT_g^ _V S\Y`c dXQd _dXUb S_^dU^d _g^Ubc

XQT QedX_bYjUT d_ RU _^ N_eIeRU( HSXQVVUb 9US\( p +1 " :hc( /'1( +.2( KYQS_] U^WQWUT Y^ Q m]e\dY'cdU` `b_SUTebU TUcYW^UT d_ QSSebQdU\i

YTU^dYVin dXU S\Y`c Y^ ceYd( HSXQ`Yb_ 9US\( :h( +12( +.3( p 3( +/*( >^ DSd_RUb ,**3& QVdUb S_]`\UdY^W Q maeQ\Ydi SXUS[n _V dXU S\Y`c Y^ ceYd& 9_jU^c _V KYQS_]lc S\Y`c Y^ ceYd gUbU e`\_QTUT Ri KYQS_]( GeRY^ 9US\(

KYQS_] c_eWXd d_ gYdXTbQg ,.+ S\Y`c Y^ ceYd& ]_bU dXQ^ +** _V gXYSX KYQS_] XQT e`\_QTUT d_ N_eIeRU( GeRY^ 9US\( p 3 " :hc( ++3'+,*( +/+( D^ ;URbeQbi ,0& ,*+* KYQS_] bUaeUcdUT TYc]YccQ\ gYdX `bUZeTYSU _V

dXU ,.+ S\Y`c dXQd Yd XQT _bYWY^Q\\i c_eWXd d_ gYdXTbQg& `\ec Q^ QTTYdY_^Q\ +3- S\Y`c& cYh _V gXYSX gUbU e`\_QTUT Ri KYQS_]lc ]Qb[UdY^W QWU^d& LYbUTHUd( GeRY^ 9US\( pp +,'+- " :hc( +,,'+,-( +/,( ;_\\_gY^W KYQS_]lc bUaeUcd V_b TYc]YccQ\ gYdX `bUZeTYSU _V .-. S\Y`c _^

;URbeQbi ,0& ,*+*& dXUbU bU]QY^ S\Y`c Y^ ceYd dXQd KYQS_] XQT QedX_bYjUT d_ Q``UQb _^ N_eIeRU( GeRY^ 9US\( p +. " :h( +,2( +/-( IXU `edQdYfU S\Qcc `\QY^dYVVc XQfU cU^d 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSUc d_

N_eIeRU dXQd dXUi UfU^deQ\\i bUdbQSdUT RUSQecU _V S\QY]c Ri _dXUb bYWXdc X_\TUbc( HSXQ`Yb_ :hc( +*- $GUc`_^cU ,-%& +/.& +// $0243'1,4+.%& +/0 $HI**+*/*,-',0%& +*, $+/+4,+'+/.4+1%(

21

+/.(

8Q\ >K gYdXTbUg Q 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSU Yd XQT cU^d d_ N_eIeRU :hc( +/.& +*- $GUc`_^cU

QVdUb Q^_dXUb bYWXdc X_\TUb VY\UT Q S_e^dUb'^_dYSU( ,-%&+// $0243'1,4 +.%( +//(

HdQWU IXbUU gYdXTbUg Q 9B86 dQ[UT_g^ ^_dYSU QVdUb _^U _V Ydc

\YSU^cUUc Y^V_b]UT HdQWU IXbUU dXQd Yd gQc QedX_bYjUT d_ `_cd dXU S\Y` _^ N_eIeRU( :hc( +*, $+/+4 ,+'+/.4+1%& +/0( +/0( 8UbdQY^ _V dXU `edQdYfU S\Qcc `\QY^dYVVc bU\i _^ Q W\_RQ\ ^Udg_b[ _V ceR' :hc( 13 $+**41'+/%& 3, $+/*4+-',,& +*, $0+4,/'

`eR\YcXUbc d_ \YSU^cU dXUYb S_^dU^d(

0-4,,%& +/, $,*4+/',,%& ++1 $+/-4+/'+/.4+*%( +/1( E\QY^dYVV M'G6N 9D< S_e\T ^_d Y]]UTYQdU\i TUdUb]Y^U gXUdXUb Q S\Y`

`_cdUT d_ N_eIeRU dXQd S_^dQY^UT Ydc S_^dU^d gQc _b gQc ^_d QedX_bYjUT d_ RU dXUbU( :h( 3, $+/24++'+0*41% +/2( E\QY^dYVV G"= S_e\T ^_d Y]]UTYQdU\i TUdUb]Y^U gXUdXUb Q S\Y` `_cdUT

d_ N_eIeRU dXQd S_^dQY^UT Ydc S_^dU^d gQc _b gQc ^_d QedX_bYjUT d_ RU dXUbU( :h( 13 $+-4,-'+24,*5 ++.4-'+.%( +/3( E\QY^dYVV HdQWU IXbUU XQc bUdQY^UT `b_VUccY_^Q\ ]ecYS_\_WYcdc d_

TUdUb]Y^U gXUdXUb SUbdQY^ N_eIeRU S\Y`c S_^dQY^ S_^dU^d dXQd gQc S_`YUT Vb_] _^U _V Ydc ]ecYSQ\ S_]`_cYdY_^c( :hc( 2/ $,+34*',,*4++%& +*, $+1+4 ,-'+1,4,+%& +/1(

+0*( +0+(

N_eIeRU Yc Q VbUU cUbfYSU( =eb\Ui 9US\( p ,( N_eIeRU T_Uc ^_d SXQbWU Q ceRcSbY`dY_^ VUU Q^T T_Uc ^_d SXQbWU ecUbc

d_ e`\_QT _b d_ fYUg fYTU_ S\Y`c(

22

+0,( +0-(

N_eIeRU WU^UbQdUc bUfU^eU Vb_] QTfUbdYcY^W( GUYTUb 9US\( p /( N_eIeRUlc QTfUbdYcY^W _VVUbY^Wc QbU S_^cYcdU^d gYdX `bUfQY\Y^W Y^Tecdbi

cdQ^TQbTc( GUYTUb 9US\( p +,( +0.( 7UdgUU^ ,**0 Q^T ,**3& N_eIeRU U^dUbUT Y^d_ dX_ecQ^Tc _V TYbUSd

`Qbd^UbcXY` QWbUU]U^dc dXQd `b_fYTU V_b N_eIeRU d_ be^ QTfUbdYcY^W QWQY^cd fYTU_c S\QY]UT Ri dX_cU _g^Ubc Q^T d_ cXQbU dXU bUfU^eU Vb_] dXQd QTfUbdYcY^W( BQhSi 9US\( p 3'+*( +0/( N_eIeRUlc bUfU^eU'cXQbY^W TUQ\c WU^UbQdUT Q``b_hY]QdU\i `UbSU^d

_V N_eIeRUlc _fUbQ\\ bUfU^eU RUdgUU^ ,**1 Q^T ,**3( GUYTUb 9US\( p /( +00( B_cd _V N_eIeRUlc _dXUb bUfU^eU S_]Uc Vb_] QTfUbdYcU]U^dc dXQd be^

_^ dXU N_eIeRU X_]U`QWU Q^T _^ dXU `QWUc dXQd \Ycd dXU bUce\dc _V ecUbcl cUQbSX aeUbYUc( +01( p /( N_eIeRU T_Uc ^_d cUU[ d_ UQb^ bUfU^eU Vb_] ecUbcl `_dU^dYQ\\i p ++(

Y^VbY^WY^W QSdYfYdYUc( +02(

C_^U _V N_eIeRUlc QTfUbdYcY^W _VVUbY^Wc Y^ Q^i gQi VQf_bc fYTU_c dXQd p

]Qi ^_d XQfU RUU^ QedX_bYjUT d_ Q``UQb _^ N_eIeRU _fUb QedX_bYjUT fYTU_c( ++( +03( N_eIeRU( +1*( +1+( N_eIeRU( B_cd _V dXU ^QdY_^lc d_` +** QTfUbdYcUbc `ebSXQcU QTfUbdYcY^W _^ p .( AQbWU ]UTYQ S_]`Q^YUc be^ QTfUbdYcU]U^dc _^ N_eIeRU( p,(

KYQS_] XQc c`U^d ]_bU dXQ^ _^U ]Y\\Y_^ T_\\Qbc QTfUbdYcY^W _^ p .(

23