Schoolcraft v. The City Of New York et al

Filing 598

DECLARATION of Alan H. Scheiner in Opposition re: 566 FINAL MOTION for Attorney Fees for Levine & Gilbert and Peter J. Gleason, Esq.., 559 MOTION for Attorney Fees , Costs and Disbursements.. Document filed by The City Of New York. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit, # 7 Exhibit, # 8 Exhibit, # 9 Exhibit, # 10 Exhibit, # 11 Exhibit, # 12 Exhibit, # 13 Exhibit, # 14 Exhibit, # 15 Exhibit, # 16 Exhibit, # 17 Exhibit, # 18 Exhibit, # 19 Exhibit, # 20 Exhibit, # 21 Exhibit, # 22 Exhibit, # 23 Exhibit, # 24 Exhibit, # 25 Exhibit, # 26 Exhibit, # 27 Exhibit, # 28 Exhibit, # 29 Exhibit)(Scheiner, Alan)

Download PDF
DEPOSITIONS II{ SCHOOLCRAFT LITIGATION A L Witnesses / Expert B Date(s) 10:10 AM - Lauterborn, Theodore LL/7/2Ot3 2 Caughey, Timothy c Start - End Time 7:O7 PM 11:17 AM - Attorney(s) in Attendance Also Present John Lenoir; Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; MatthewJ. Koster, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; F E Examination By Magdalena Bauza Nathaniel B. Smith, Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. Esq. ; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq.; Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; Walter t2/e/20L3 7:42PM 3 D Matthew J. Koster, MatthewJ. Koster, Esq.; Brian Esq.; Osterman, Esq. Ryan G. Shaffer, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Matthew Koster, Esq.; Schoolcraft, Larry Gregory John 4 Boston, Curtis 5 Huffman, Rasheena 6 Hanlon, Elise (Lt.) 7 ; Matthew Koster, Esq.; GregoryJohn Radomisli, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq t2/ttl2ot3 6:50PM Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Matthew J. L0:46 AM Koster, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. Ll6/2Ot4 1:21PM Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker 2:31 PM - 6:05 Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Matthew J Koster, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. r/6/2OL4 PM Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Matthew J. Koster, Esq.; Brian 10:l-9 AM Osterman, Esq. tlL3/2OL4 5:47 PM L0:22 AM - Ryan G. Shaffer, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq. Magdalena Radomisli, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian Bauza E. Lee, Esq. Magdalena Bauza NathanielSmith, Nathaniel Esq B. Smith, Matthew Magdalena Esq. ; Bauza Koster, Esq. Magdalena NathanielSmith, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. Bauza J. Nathaniel B. Smith, Lamstein-Reiss, Catherine (M D) I 10:22 AM - tl30/2oL4 7:47 PM Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr., Esq.; William R. Divine, Esq.; Paul Callan, Esq. ;Matthew J. Koster, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. Esq. ; F Walter Kretz, Jr. , Magdalena Esq.; Brian Osterman, Bauza Esq. DEPOSITIONS A t Witnesses / Expert B Date(s) c Start - End II\ SCHOOLCRAFT LITIGATION D E Also Present Attorney{s} in Attendance ltme F Examination By Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; Aldana-Bernier, Lilian (Dr.) 10:30 AM 2/1.1_l2Ot4 6:31 PM 9 Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; Howard Suckle, Esq.; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Gregory Radomisli, Esq.; Brian E Magdalena Lee, Esq.; Peter F. Callan, Esq. Bauza Howard Suckle, Esq.; Esq.; Gregory Radomislí, Esq Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; lsakov, lsak 10 10:214M 3:47PM 2lt2/2OL4 NathanielSmith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; Howard Suckle, Esq.; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Gregory Radomisli, Esq.; Robert Magdalena Howard Suckle, Esq.; Gregory Radomisli, Devine, Esq.; Peter F. Callan, Esq. Bauza Esq.; Nathaniel TL 10:344M 4/to/2074 5:49 PM 72 L0:214M 4/tu2OL4 4:28 PM Gough, William Sawyer, Frederick (Sgt.) 10:09 AM - 4/2s/201.4 2:32PM 13 Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Suzanna publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Matthew Koster, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Nathaniel Trainor, Timothy (Lt. B. Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian Koster, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. E. Lee, Esq.; Matthew J Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq Nathaniel J Matthew . Koster, Esq. L4 s/1.2/201.4 2:11-PM ; Matthew J. Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq.; Matthew , Koster, Esq Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, James, Shantel(PO) 10:11AM - Esq. B. Smith, Koster, Esq. Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq.; Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Suzanna publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Matthew Koster, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. B. Smith, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; ; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Matthew J. J Koster, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. DEPOSITIONS IN SCHOOLCRAFT LITIGATION A 1 Witnesses / Exper"t B Date(s) c Start - End Time D E Also Present Attor.ney(s) i n Atte.nda nce F Examination By NathanielSmith, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Marquez, Jessica (EMT) 10:24 AM - s/L4/2OL4 4:59 PM 15 Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Paul F. Callan, Esq.; Gregory Magdalena Mettham Esq.; Brian J. Radomisli, Esq. Callan, Esq. Bauza Lee, Esq.; Paul E. F. NathanielSmith, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Sangeniti, Salvatore (EMT) s/ts/2014 16 10:28 AM 2:23PM Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Stefanie Miller, Esq.; A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian Gregory J. Radomisli, Esq. Miller, Esq.; Nathaniel B. Smith, s/2s/2ot4 3:51PM Weiss, Steven (Sgt) t7 Maffia, Anthony J. VP Psy 18 Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; Ryan G. Shaffer, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq. Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Stefanie Miller, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. 10:284M s/30/2oL4 01:04 PM E. Lee, Esq.; Stefanie Nathaniel Smith, Esq, ; Ryan Shaffer, Esq. ; Walter A. Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Gregory Radomisli, Esq.; MichaelT. lvone, Esq.; Paul Callan, Esq. 1.0:19 AM - ; Magdalena Esq. ; Brian Osterman, Bauza Esq. NathanielSmith, Esq, NathanielSmith, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Ferrara, Joseph A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Laura 10:L4 AM 19 6/s/20t4 4:53 PM Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Magdalena Bouzar, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Laura M Lamkay, Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Arshia Hourizadeh, Esq. Vincenzo M. Lamkay, Esq.; Brian Petulla, E. Lee, Esq.; Arshia Videographer Hourizadeh, Esq. DEPOSITIONS II{ SCHOOLCRAFT LITIGATION B Witnesses L / Expert Date(s) c Start - End Time E Attorney{s) in Attendance F Also Present Examination By NathanielSmith, Esq.; Broschart, Christopher L0:28 AM 4:35 PM 6/78/2Or4 20 11:23 AM - 7/3/2OL4 L2:35 PM Dhar, Vinod (M.D.) 22 Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Paul Gregory J. Radomisli, Esq. J. Radomisli, Esq. F. Callan, Esq.; Gregory Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Lwin, Khin Mar (MD) 21 NathanielSmith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; WalterA. Kretz,Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Paul F. Callan, Esq.; 10:06: AM 7 /7 /2074 3:12 PM Esq.; WalterA. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian NathanielSmith, E. Lee, Esq.; Paul F. Callan, Esq.; Esq.;Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Gregory J. Radomisli, Esq. Magdalena Bauzi Paul Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Mariana Olenko , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Paul F. Callan, Esq.; Gregory John Roy Lubit, M.D.; Nathaniel B. Smith, Magdalena Esq. ; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Radomisli, Esq. Bauza Paul F. Callan, Esq.; F. Callan, Esq. Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Whalen, Bernard 01:46 PM - 7/ts/2oL4 2:37PM 23 Whittman, David Nathaniel 10:17 AM 7 /Lsl2O1.4 11:384M 24 Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian Miller, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. E. Lee, Esq.; Stefanie Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Stefanie Miller, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. Nathaniel B, Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq.; Ryan G. Shaffer, Esq.; 26 27 Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Ryan G. Shaffer, Esq.; 2:30 PM - 3:58 Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Stefanie Miller, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. 7 /r7 /2Or4 PM 25 Finnegan, Kevin Milone, William (Sgt.) Bauza B. 2:35 PM - 3:37 Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Stefanie Miller, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. 7/16/2014 PM Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir , Esq; Ryan G. Shaffer, Esq.; 10:15 AM Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq. ; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Stefanie Miller, Esq.; Brian 12:22PM Osterman, Esq. 7 /L7 /20t4 Valenti, Dominik (Lt) Magdalena John Lenoir, Esq John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Publícker Magdalena Mettham, Esq.; Walter Bauza Kretz, Jr. , John Lenoir, Esq Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq NathanielSmith, Esq, DEPOSITIONS IN SCHOOLCRAFT LITIGATION A 1 Witnesses / Expert B Date{s) c Start - End Time E Attorney(s) in Attendance F Also Present D Examination By Nathaniel B. Smith, Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Stefanie Miller, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Bauza ; Adrian Schoolcraft Esq. Magdalena Cooper, Alan 12:11 PM - 7/24/2014 3:51PM 28 Carrasco, Edward 11:47 AM - elte/2oL4 12:28 PM 29 Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Ryan G. Shaffer, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Stefanie Miller, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. Nathaniel Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq. B. Katherine Byrn John Lenoir, Esq Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Halpren-Ruder, Daniel PhD 10:05 AM - s/30/20L4 L:L9 PM 30 Paul F. Callan, Esq.; Nathanielsmith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; WalterA. Kretz,Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; PaulF. Callan, Esq.; GregoryJ. Gregory J. Radomisli, Kristen Keehan Radomisli, Esq. Esq. Suzanna Publicker Mettham, ; Walter Eterno, John A. 10:20 AM LO/17/2OL4 6:46 PM 31 Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Qiana Smith, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian Kretz, Jr., Esq.; .; Brian Osterman, Esq.; Brian E. l-ee, Esq.; MatthewJ. Koster, Esq. Koster, Esq. E. Lee, Esq.; Nathaniel Matthew J B. Smith, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. Silverman, Eli B (PhD) Esq.; Brian Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker t0:14 AM-7:29 Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian 32 to/24/2Or4 PM Koster, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. E. Lee, Esq.; Matthew J. f. lee, fsq; Matthew J. Koster, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. DEPOSITIONS IN SCHOOLCR.AFT LITIGATION A L Witnesses / Expert B Date(s) c Start - End Time D Attorney(s) in Attendance 4,28 Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; Joh n Lenoir, Esq.; Duncan, Kurt 33 Purpi, Michael (Sgt) 34 Patel, lndira (MD) 11:1-L AM - LO/31./2014 11:18 AM Also Present Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; paul F. Callan, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. 10:27 AM 6.23 Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; 04/28/2OL4 5:33 PM 10:2L WalterA. Kretz,Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; PaulF. Callan, Esq.; Brian 06/23/2014 AM - 12:03PM Osterman, Esq. 7.L6 Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John r, Esq.; Ryan G. Shaffer, sq.; WalterA. Kretz,Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Stefanie Miller, Esq.; Brian 10:25 AM Osterman, Esq. 12:10PM 9.L9 Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Ryan G. Shaffer, Esq.; 07/1.6/2014 10:06 AM Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Robert Devine, Esq. ; Stefanie Miller, Esq.; oe/te/2014 11,:10PM Brian Osterman, Esq. 12:26PM 07/25/201,4 10:08 AM35 E F Examination By 4.28 NathanielSmíth, Esq. 6.23 NathanielSmith, Esq.; Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; Brian Osterman 7.16 NathanielSmith, Esq 9.19 Katherine 9.19 NathanielSmith, Byrnes Esq 7.25 Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Mark McAndrew, Esq.; Mariana Olenko, Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; MatthewJ. Koster, Esq.; Gregory John Radomisli, Esq. 10.31 Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq.; Rachelseligman, Esq.; Mark 7.25 Adrian McAndrew, Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; MatthewJ. Koster, Esq.; Gregory Schoolcraft,Roy John Radomislí, Esq. ; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq. Lubit, M.D.; 7.25 NathanielSmith, Esq. 10.31 Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq.; Matthew J. Koster, Esq.; Gregory John Radomisli, Esq. 9.23 Gregory 9.23 NathanielSmith, Esq,; John Lenoir, Esq. ; Ryan Shaffer, Esq. ; Walter A. Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Gregory Radomisli, Esq.; W. Robert Devine, Lubit, Roy (PhD) 36 Radomisli, Esq.; W. Robert Devine, Esq.; Esq.; Paul Callan, Esq. Paul Callan, Esq. 11.10 NathanielSmith, Esq, ; John Lenoir, Esq.; Ryan Shaffer, Esq.; 9:24 AM - 4:39 WalterA. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Gregory Radomisli, Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; PM 2:25 PM - Paul Callan, Esq. os/23/2OL4 5:04 PM 11.13 Nathaniel Smith, Esq, ; John Lenoir, Esq.; Ryan Shaffer, Esq. ; Lt/ro/2014 9:154M Walter A. Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Gregory Radomisli, Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; 71./13/201.4 L2:26 PM Ramsen Youash, Esq. , Esq. 9.23 Kristen 11.10 Ryan Shaffer, Keehan Keehan Esq. ; ; Paul Callan, Esq. 11.13 Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Gregory 11.13 Kristen Radomisli, Esq. 11.10 Kristen Keehan DEPOSITIOI{S IN SCHOOLCRAFT LITIGATION A t Witnesses / Expert B Date(s) c Start - End Time 10:17 AM -7 PM LO/08l2OL3 10:28 AM - 7 to/18/2ot3 37 F Also Present Attor.ney(s) in Attendance 10J8 Marino, Michael E Examination By D Nãthaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Mer¡dith B. Borg, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. 10.18 Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq. ; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter Kretz, Jr. , Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Meridith B. Borg, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq. 10.08 Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq. Magdalena Bauza; John 10.18 Nathaniel B. Smith, Esq.; Brian E. Lenoir PM 10.08 Lee, Esq. 10.11 Suzanna 10.11John L. Norinsberg, Esq.; Gerald Cohen, Esq. and John Meeham, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker, Esq. and Qiana Smith Esq.; Gregory John Radomisli, Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Meredith B. Borg, Esq. ; Walter A. Kretz, Jr. Esq. Schoolcraft, Adrian 9.26 Nathanielsmith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Mettham, Esq. 10:204M -6:53 and Ryan G. Shaffer, Esq.; Gregory John Radomisli, Esq.; Brian E. Lee, PM L0:10 AM - Esq.; Bruce Brady, Esq. ; Walter A. Kretz, Jr. Esq. 9.27 Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Mettham, Esq.; LO/Lu2oL2 7:08PM Gregory John Radomisli, Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.;Meredith Borg, Esq. ; os/26/20L3 10:12 AM oe/2712OL3 6:30 PM lwrt"r. A. Kretz, jr. Esq. Publicker, Esq. 10.11 Robert 9.26 Suzanna Horgan, Publicker, Esq. Videographer 9.26 Peter Benimoff, ;Walter A. Kretz, Jr. Magdalena Radomisli, Esq.; Brian Bauza E. Lee, Esq.; Bruce Esq. 9.27 Gregory John 9.27 Magdalena Brady, Esq. ; Walter A. Mauriello, Steven 39 12.20 Nathaniel Smith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Esq.; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Brian Osterman, Esq.; Matthew. Koster, Esq. 7.OL Nathanielsmith, Esq.; John Lenoir, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker 10:16 AM L2/20/2Ot3 7:30 PM 10:24 Mettham, Esq.; Walter A. Kretz, Jr., Esq.; Brian E. Lee, Esq.; Brian 07lotlzot{ AM -7:03 PM Osterman, Esq.; Paul F. Callan, Esq. Bauza Kretz, Jr. Esq. t2.20 38 12.20 NathanielSmith, Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Magdalena Esq.; Brian Osterman, Bauza; 7.01 Esq. Adrian Schoolcraft, 7.01 NathanielSmith, Magdalena Esq.; Suzanna Publicker Mettham, Bauza Esq.

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?