Irving H. Picard v. Saul B. Katz et al

Filing 30

COUNTER STATEMENT TO 22 Rule 56.1 Statement,,,,,,,,. Document filed by Irving H. Picard. (Bohorquez, Fernando)

Download PDF
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

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?