J.T. Colby & Company, Inc. et al v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 105

MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 104 MOTION for Summary Judgment. REDACTED. Document filed by Apple Inc.. (Cendali, Dale)

Dale M. Cendali
Claudia Ray
Bonnie L. Jarrett
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
601 Lexington Avenue
New York, New York 10022

Perry J. Viscounty
LATHAM & WATKINS LLP
140 Scott Drive
Menlo Park, CA 94025
Jennifer L. Barry
LATHAM & WATKINS LLP
600 West Broadway, Suite 1800
San Diego, CA 92101-3375

Attorneys for Defendant
APPLE INC.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
J.T. COLBY & COMPANY, INC. d/b/a BRICK
TOWER PRESS, J. BOYLSTON & COMPANY,
PUBLISHERS LLC and IPICTUREBOOKS LLC,
Plaintiffs,

Case No. 11-CIV-4060 (DLC)
ECF Case

- against APPLE INC.,

REDACTED
Defendant.

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF
DEFENDANT’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Polaroid

Abercrombie & Fitch Co. v. Hunting World, Inc.
Advance Magazine Publishers, Inc. v. Norris
Becoming, Inc. v. Avon Prods., Inc.
Bernard v. Commerce Drug Co.
Big Star Entm’t, Inc. v. Next Big Star, Inc
Black & Decker Corp. v. Dunsford
Brandwynne v. Combe Int’l, Ltd.
Bristol-Myers Squibb Co. v. McNeil-P.P.C., Inc.,
Brockmeyer v. Hearst Corp.
Bunt v. Altec Indus., Inc.,
Celotex Corp. v. Catrett
Charles Atlas, Ltd. v. DC Comics, Inc.,
De Beers LV Trademark Ltd. v. DeBeers Diamond Syndicate, Inc.
Defiance Button Mach. Co. v. C & C Metal Prods. Corp.

Dial-A-Mattress Operating Corp. v. Mattress Madness, Inc.
E. Gluck Corp. v. Rothenhaus
eMachines, Inc. v. Ready Access Memory, Inc.,
Erchonia Corp. v. Bissoon
Ergotron, Inc. v. Hergo Ergonomic Support Sys., Inc.
Estee Lauder Inc. v. The Gap, Inc.,
Exquisite Form Indus., Inc. v. Exquisite Fabrics of London
Fin. Matters, Inc. v. PepsiCo, Inc.,
First Nat’l Bank of Omaha, Inc. v. Mastercard Int’l Inc.
Freedom Card, Inc. v. JPMorgan Chase & Co.
Gameologist Grp., LLC v. Scientific Games Int'l, Inc.
Girl Scouts of the United States of Am. v. Bantam Doubleday Dell Publ’g Grp., Inc.,
Gruner + Jahr v. Meredith Corp.
Gucci Am., Inc. v. Guess?, Inc.,
Hawaii-Pac. Apparel Grp., Inc. v. Cleveland Browns Football Co.

Herbko Int’l, Inc. v. Gemmy Indus. Corp.
Hy-Cross Hatchery, Inc. v. Osborne
Ideal World Mktg., Inc. v. Duracell, Inc.,
aff'd sub nom.
Ideal World Mktg. Inc. v. Duracell, Inc.
In re Bose Corp.
Information Superhighway, Inc. v. Talk Am., Inc.,
Ippolito v. Lennon,
Jewish Sephardic Yellow Pages, Ltd. v. DAG Media, Inc.
Juicy Couture, Inc. v. L’Oreal USA, Inc.,
Kass v. W. Bend Co.,
aff'd
Kendall-Jackson Winery, Ltd v. E. & J. Gallo Winery
Kinbook, LLC v. Microsoft Corp.
Lang v. Ret. Living Publ’g Co.,
Lappe v. Am. Honda Motor Co.,
aff'd sub nom. Lappe v. Honda Motor Co. Ltd. of
Japan,
Lopez v. Gap, Inc.

Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Dooney & Bourke, Inc.,
Main Street Outfitters, Inc. v. Federated Dept. Stores, Inc.
Matsushita Elec. Indus. Co. v. Zenith Radio Corp.
McCarthy v. Dun & Bradstreet Corp.
McGregor-Doniger Inc. v. Drizzle Inc.
Mejia & Assocs., Inc. v. Int'l Bus. Machs. Corp.
Merriam-Webster, Inc. v. Random House, Inc.,
Morgans Group LLC v. John Doe Co.
Nora Beverages, Inc. v. Perrier Grp. of Am.
O’Keefe v. Ogilvy & Mather Worldwide, Inc.
Oxford Indus., Inc. v. JBJ Fabrics, Inc.,
Paco Sport, Ltd. v. Paco Rabanne Parfums
aff'd sub nom. Paco Sport, Ltd. v. Paco Rabanne
Perfumes
Polaroid Corp. v. Polarad Elecs. Corp.
Quality Serv. Grp. v. LJMJR Corp.

Randa Corp. v. Mulberry Thai Silk, Inc.,
Rich & Rich P'ship v. Poetman Records USA, Inc.,
Ringling Bros.-Barnum & Bailey Combined Shows, Inc. v. B.E. Windows Corp.
Rockland Exposition, Inc. v. Alliance of Auto. Serv. Providers of N.J.
as amended
SLY Magazine, LLC v. Weider Publ’ns L.L.C.,
SLY Magazine, LLC v. Weider Publ’ns., L.L.C.,
Sporn v. MCA Records,
Sports Traveler, Inc. v. Advance Magazine Publishers, Inc.,
Star Indus., Inc. v. Bacardi & Co.,
Sunrise Home Juices, Inc. v. Coca-Cola Co.
Syntex Labs., Inc. v. Norwich Pharmacal Co.,
THOIP v. Walt Disney Co.
Union Carbide Corp. v. Ever-Ready Inc.,
Universal City Studios, Inc. v. Nintendo Co.,
W.W.W. Pharm. Co., Inc. v. Gillette Co.

First

See

and

inter alia,

de minimus

Second

inter alia

total

Finally

Polaroid

admittedly

Daubert

See
Celotex Corp. v. Catrett
McCarthy v. Dun & Bradstreet Corp.

See Matsushita Elec. Indus. Co. v. Zenith
Radio Corp.
See id.
See Celotex

See Gruner + Jahr v. Meredith Corp.
See Hawaii-Pac. Apparel Grp.,
Inc. v. Cleveland Browns Football Co.

First
Nat’l Bank of Omaha, Inc. v. Mastercard Int’l Inc.

See Bristol-Myers Squibb Co. v. McNeil-P.P.C.,
Inc.,

Abercrombie & Fitch Co. v. Hunting World, Inc.
see also

See Information Superhighway,
Inc. v. Talk Am., Inc.,
See Randa Corp. v. Mulberry Thai Silk, Inc.,

Big Star Entm’t, Inc. v. Next Big Star, Inc
See id.
See infra
See Big Star,
¶
See Fin. Matters, Inc. v. PepsiCo, Inc.,
Sporn v. MCA
Records,
Ippolito v. Lennon,

See

see also

See Ideal World
Mktg., Inc. v. Duracell, Inc.,

aff'd sub nom. Ideal World Mktg. Inc. v. Duracell, Inc.

infra
Id.,
Id.,

Black & Decker Corp. v. Dunsford

Bristol-Myers Squibb,

See id.
See, e.g., Erchonia Corp. v. Bissoon

Bernard v. Commerce Drug Co.

Lopez v.

Gap, Inc.
Jewish Sephardic Yellow Pages,
Ltd. v. DAG Media, Inc.

Brandwynne v.

Combe Int’l, Ltd.

see Sports Traveler, Inc. v.

Advance Magazine Publishers, Inc.,
World

Ideal
Black & Decker

See Sports Traveler,

Lopez

Herbko Int’l, Inc. v. Gemmy Indus. Corp.

i.e.,

de minimus

See Kass v. W. Bend Co.,
aff'd

Bunt v. Altec Indus., Inc.,
Lappe v. Am. Honda Motor Co.,

aff'd sub nom. Lappe v. Honda Motor Co. Ltd. of Japan,
Poetman Records USA, Inc.,

Rich & Rich P'ship v.

See

two

Id.,
Id
Id.,
arguendo

unsold

i.e.,
destroyed

See
Brandwynne
Sports Traveler,

Ideal World

Sunrise Home Juices, Inc. v. Coca-Cola
Co.

All American Boys
Id.,
Id.,
Id.,
passim. See Erchonia Corp.

See

See
Ergotron, Inc. v. Hergo Ergonomic Support Sys., Inc.

Exquisite Form Indus., Inc. v. Exquisite Fabrics of London

Rockland Exposition, Inc. v.
Alliance of Auto. Serv. Providers of N.J.
as amended

total
de minimus

See Jewish
Sephardic Yellow Pages

Brandwynne,
Exquisite Form,

See Lopez,

Jewish Sephardic Yellow Pages,
any

See Sports Traveler
Ergotron

less

after

See Ergotron,
no
Publishers Weekly

Sports Traveler

See Morgans Group LLC v. John Doe Co.

New York Post

Vogue

Jewish Sephardic Yellow Pages,
Sports
Traveler

Lopez,

Rockland
Exposition,

See

see also

Rockland Exposition,

See Hawaii-Pac. Apparel

Morgans Group,

See
See Hawaii-Pac.,

prima facie
See
See

Abercrombie & Fitch,

i.e.,
i.e.,

See

See

Defiance Button Mach. Co. v. C & C Metal Prods. Corp.

See id.

Syntex Labs., Inc. v. Norwich Pharmacal Co.,

Dial-A-Mattress Operating
Corp. v. Mattress Madness, Inc.

see eMachines, Inc. v. Ready Access Memory,
Inc.,
see Syntex Labs.,
see Dial-A-Mattress,

Defiance Button Machine
Co. v. C & C Metal Prods. Corp.,

First

See eMachines,

Main Street Outfitters, Inc. v. Federated
Dept. Stores, Inc.

Second

See Syntex Labs.,

see also Hy-Cross Hatchery, Inc. v. Osborne
inter alia
Third

See Dial-A-Mattress,
Fourth

See Defiance Button,

See Becoming, Inc. v. Avon Prods., Inc.

not

single

instance

See
In re Bose
Corp.

see also Quality Serv. Grp. v. LJMJR Corp.

See De Beers LV Trademark Ltd. v. DeBeers Diamond Syndicate, Inc.

Id.

see
First
Second
See
Finally,

See Bose
See De Beers

See De Beers
Dial-A-Mattress,

See E. Gluck Corp. v. Rothenhaus

See Bose

First Nat’l Bank,

O’Keefe v. Ogilvy & Mather Worldwide, Inc.
Star Indus., Inc. v. Bacardi & Co.,

See, e.g., SLY Magazine, LLC v. Weider Publ’ns L.L.C.,
Nora Beverages,
Inc. v. Perrier Grp. of Am.

Lang v. Ret. Living Publ’g

Co.,

Universal City Studios, Inc. v. Nintendo Co.,
THOIP v. Walt Disney Co.

Advance Magazine Publishers, Inc. v. Norris
O’Keefe

Brockmeyer v. Hearst Corp.
Mejia & Assocs., Inc. v. Int'l Bus. Machs. Corp.

First Nat’l Bank,

de minimus

Polaroid

Polaroid Corp.
v. Polarad Elecs. Corp.,

See First Nat’l Bank,

Polaroid

Advance Magazine

Polaroid

Lang

McGregor-Doniger Inc. v. Drizzle Inc.,

Brockmeyer

First,
See id.

First Nat’l Bank,

see also Advance Magazine

Second,

see, e.g., O’Keefe

First Nat’l Bank,
de minimus

defendant See, e.g., Freedom Card, Inc. v.
JPMorgan Chase & Co.
Kinbook, LLC v. Microsoft Corp.

See Lang,
SLY
Magazine, LLC v. Weider Publ’ns., L.L.C.,

See Oxford Indus., Inc. v. JBJ Fabrics, Inc.,

Brockmeyer

Polaroid
Lang

Mejia,

O’Keefe
see also Brockmeyer

Louis
Vuitton Malletier v. Dooney & Bourke, Inc.,

See SLY
Magazine,

Brockmeyer

First Nat’l Bank,

—i.e.

See Mejia,

Gameologist Grp., LLC v. Scientific Games Int'l, Inc.
W.W.W. Pharm. Co., Inc. v. Gillette Co.,

See Estee Lauder Inc. v. The Gap, Inc.,

SLY
Magazine,
Brockmeyer

Lang

see also Mejia,

Gameologist Grp.,

Second,
See Nora Beverages,
lack

i.e.

See

Eveready

See Union Carbide Corp. v. Ever-Ready Inc.,

See Paco Sport, Ltd. v. Paco Rabanne Parfums

aff'd

sub nom. Paco Sport, Ltd. v. Paco Rabanne Perfumes
Brockmeyer

Lang

Id

First Nat’l Bank,

See Juicy Couture, Inc. v. L’Oreal USA, Inc.,

Gameologist Grp.,

See O’Keefe

See Ringling Bros.-Barnum & Bailey Combined
Shows, Inc. v. B.E. Windows Corp.

see also SLY Magazine,

Juicy
Couture,
See Ringling Bros.
see also Gucci Am., Inc. v. Guess?, Inc.,

Ringling Bros.

See Kendall-Jackson Winery, Ltd v. E. & J.
Gallo Winery

See SLY Magazine,

See, e.g., Charles Atlas, Ltd. v. DC Comics, Inc.,
Merriam-Webster, Inc. v. Random
House, Inc.,
Girl Scouts of the United States of Am. v. Bantam Doubleday Dell
Publ’g Grp., Inc.,

This Immortal
This Immortal
You Caught Me Kissing
You Caught Me Kissing
Code Black
This Immortal
See

s/ Dale M. Cendali