The Authors Guild, Inc. et al v. Hathitrust et al
Filing
49
DECLARATION of Edward H. Rosenthal in Opposition re: 37 MOTION for Judgment on the Pleadings.. Document filed by Authors' Licensing and Collecting Society, Pat Cummings, Pat Cummins, Erik Grundstrom, Angelo Loukakis, Norsk Faglitteraer Forfatter0OG Oversetterforening, Roxana Robinson, Helge Ronning, Andre Roy, Jack R. Salamanca, James Shapiro, Daniele Simpson, Danielle Simpson, T.J. Stiles, Sveriges Forfattarforbund, The Australian Society Of Authors Limited, The Authors Guild, Inc., The Authors League Fund, Inc, Union Des Ecrivaines Et Des Ecrivains Quebecois, Fay Weldon, the Writers' Union of Canada. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E, # 6 Exhibit F)(Rosenthal, Edward)
EXHIBIT D
Professional Syndicates Act
© Éditeur officiel du Québec
http://www2.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/dynamicSearch/telecharge...
Updated to 1 January 2012
This document has official status.
R.S.Q., chapter S-40
PROFESSIONAL SYNDICATES ACT
DIVISION I
CONSTITUTION AND POWERS
1.
(1) 15 persons or more, Canadian citizens, engaged in the same profession, the same employment or in
similar trades, or doing correlated work having for object the establishing of a determined product, may make
and sign a memorandum setting forth their intention of forming an association or professional syndicate.
(2) Such memorandum shall indicate:
(a) The name of the association;
(b) Its object;
(c) The names, nationality and addresses of the first directors or administrators, to the number of three at least
and not more than 15, and the names, nationality and addresses of the persons to be the first president and the
first secretary;
(d) the address at which its head office will be situated.
(2.1) The name of an association or syndicate must be in conformity with section 9.1 of the Companies Act
(chapter C-38).
(3) The enterprise registrar may, upon a petition accompanied by the memorandum of the association,
authorize the constitution, as an association or professional syndicate, of the persons who have signed the
memorandum and of those who may hereafter be admitted to form part of the association or syndicate.
(4) The enterprise registrar shall refuse to authorize the constitution of an association or syndicate where the
memorandum of the association or syndicate contains a name not in conformity with any of paragraphs 1 to 6 of
section 9.1 of the Companies Act.
(5) The enterprise registrar shall authorize the constitution of an association or syndicate by drawing up a
notice to that effect, which he shall deposit in the register referred to in Chapter II of the Act respecting the legal
publicity of enterprises (chapter P-44.1).
(6) From the date of such deposit, the association or syndicate shall constitute a legal person.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 1; 1965 (1st sess.), c. 51, s. 1; 1969, c. 26, s. 115; 1975, c. 76, s. 11; 1981, c. 9, s. 24;
1982, c. 52, s. 257, s. 262; 1987, c. 59, s. 1; 1993, c. 48, s. 509; 1999, c. 40, s. 312; 2002, c. 45, s. 619;
2010, c. 7, s. 282.
2. The by-laws of the syndicate must provide for the number, which must be at least 3, of directors or
administrators to be elected, as well as for the amount of the entrance fee and the assessment payable by the
members. The entrance fee shall be $1 or more and the assessment shall not be less than $1 per month.
In the case of syndicates of farming operators or producers, the assessment shall not be less than $6 per
annum.
1 of 7
1/30/2012 5:10 PM
Professional Syndicates Act
http://www2.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/dynamicSearch/telecharge...
The by-laws may however provide that the payment of the assessment shall be suspended when the employee
is unemployed or not employed in his usual occupation.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 2; 1965 (1st sess.), c. 51, s. 2; 1966-67, c. 51, s. 1; 1969, c. 26, s. 115; 1975, c. 76, s.
11; 1981, c. 9, s. 24; 1982, c. 52, s. 262; 1987, c. 59, s. 2.
3. A member bound to pay the assessment and being three months in arrears shall ipso facto be suspended.
He may however be relieved from such suspension without retroactive effect, under the conditions fixed by the
by-laws.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 3.
4. A syndicate may at any time amend its by-laws and adopt new ones.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 4; 1969, c. 26, s. 115; 1975, c. 76, s. 11; 1981, c. 9, s. 24; 1982, c. 52, s. 262; 1987, c.
59, s. 3.
5. Every syndicate must keep one or several registers containing:
(a) The minutes of the meetings of the members and of the administration board;
(b) The names, nationality, addresses and occupations of each member indicating the date of his admission,
and if need be, that of his retirement or suspensions;
(c) The revenues and expenses, the assets and liabilities of the syndicate.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 5.
6. Professional syndicates shall have exclusively for object the study, defence and promotion of the economic,
social and moral interests of their members.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 6.
7. A minor sixteen years of age may be a member of a professional syndicate.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 7; 1976, c. 26, s. 1.
8. Only Canadian citizens may be members of the administrative council of a syndicate or form part of its
personnel.
Legal persons may be members of a syndicate of employers. They are authorized to designate one of their
directors, members or employees to represent them at the meetings of the syndicate and vote thereat in their
name; such representatives may be elected members of the administrative council of the syndicate.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 8; 1999, c. 40, s. 312.
9. Professional syndicates may appear before the courts and acquire, by gratuitous or onerous title, any
property suited to their particular objects.
They shall, subject to existing laws, enjoy all necessary powers for the attainment of their object, and may, in
particular:
(1) establish and administer special indemnity funds for the heirs or beneficiaries of deceased members, or for
the members on the decease of their spouses, special funds for assistance in case of illness or unemployment,
or other funds of the same nature, which shall be governed exclusively by the by-laws approved by the Autorité
des marchés financiers;
2 of 7
1/30/2012 5:10 PM
Professional Syndicates Act
http://www2.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/dynamicSearch/telecharge...
(2) establish and administer pension plans to which the members or their employer may contribute;
(3) devote a part of their resources to the erection of cheap dwellings and the purchase of grounds for
workmen's gardens, and physical and hygienic training;
(4) establish and administer information bureaus for offers of and applications for work;
(5) establish, administer and subsidize professional undertakings, such as professional provident institutions,
laboratories, experimental fields, scientific, agricultural and social training undertakings, lectures and publications
of interest to the profession;
(6) subsidize and assist cooperative associations for production and consumption;
(7) purchase to resell, lease, lend or distribute, amongst their members, all necessaries for the maintenance of
a family, for the exercise of their profession, raw materials, tools, instruments, machines, fertilizers, seeds,
plants, animals and alimentary substances;
(8) lend their services for the sale of products derived solely from personal labour or from syndical operations;
assist such sale by exhibitions, advertising, grouping of orders and of shipment;
(9) deposit their mark or label;
(10) enter into contracts or agreements with all other syndicates, societies, undertakings or persons,
respecting the attainment of their objects and particularly such as relate to the collective conditions of labour;
(11) exercise before any court of law, all the rights of their members with respect to acts directly or indirectly
prejudicial to the collective interest of the profession which they represent.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 9; 1965 (1st sess.), c. 51, s. 3; 1972, c. 62, s. 1; 1975, c. 76, s. 11; 1977, c. 5, s. 14;
1981, c. 9, s. 24; 1982, c. 52, s. 258; 1983, c. 54, s. 86; 1989, c. 38, s. 277; 1999, c. 40, s. 312; 2002, c. 6, s.
236; 2002, c. 45, s. 617; 2004, c. 37, s. 90.
10. When a syndicate wishes to change its name, the enterprise registrar may, on evidence, deemed by him
sufficient, that such request to change the name is not made for an unlawful purpose authorize the change of
name prayed for in the petition addressed to him by the syndicate.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 10; 1969, c. 26, s. 115; 1975, c. 76, s. 11; 1981, c. 9, s. 24; 1982, c. 52, s. 262; 2002,
c. 45, s. 619.
11. The enterprise registrar, as soon as the authorization is granted, shall draw up a notice to that effect, which
he shall deposit in the register. Subject to such deposit, but from the date of the authorization, the syndicate
shall be designated under the new name mentioned in the authorization.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 11; 1969, c. 26, s. 115; 1975, c. 76, s. 11; 1981, c. 9, s. 24; 1982, c. 52, s. 262; 1993, c.
48, s. 510; 2002, c. 45, s. 619.
12. No change of name effected under sections 10 and 11 shall alter the rights and obligations of the
syndicate; and proceedings which might have been commenced or continued by or against the syndicate under
its former name may be commenced or continued by or against it under its new name.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 12.
12.1. The remedy provided for in section 123.27.1 of the Companies Act (chapter C-38), adapted as required,
may be exercised in respect of the name of an association or a syndicate.
1993, c. 48, s. 511.
13. Every syndicate formed under this Act shall keep and divide its accounts so that each kind of service and
3 of 7
1/30/2012 5:10 PM
Professional Syndicates Act
http://www2.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/dynamicSearch/telecharge...
benefit accorded to the members may be separately administrated, and the fund or cash therefor be kept
distinct.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 13.
14. Every pension plan contemplated by subparagraph 2 of the second paragraph of section 9 is governed by
the Supplemental Pension Plans Act (chapter R-15.1) and the rules prescribed by the said Act with respect to
multi-employer pension plans apply to any plan established for members of several professional syndicates,
adapted as required.
For the purposes of this Act, the pension fund of a multi-employer pension plan is a special fund.
1965 (1st sess.), c. 51, s. 4; 1972, c. 62, s. 2; 1989, c. 38, s. 278.
15. In addition to the special funds, a fund must be established for the general expenses of the syndicate.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 14.
16. When a special fund ceases to be self-supporting, it may be voluntarily or judicially liquidated without
affecting the juridical personality of the syndicate.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 15; 1999, c. 40, s. 312.
17. As between members, special funds shall only be liable for their own debts except in a general liquidation
when all the funds, after their particular debts have been paid, shall, subject to the Supplemental Pension Plans
Act (chapter R-15.1), be turned into the general fund of the syndicate.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 16; 1989, c. 38, s. 279.
18. The funds of the special mutual benefit and pension accounts shall be unseizable, save for the payment of
the annuities and benefits to which a member of the syndicate may be entitled.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 17.
19. Three or more syndicates, constituted or not under this Act, may concert in the study and defence of their
economic, social and moral welfare, and for such purpose form a union or federation upon complying with the
provisions of section 1 of this Act in so far as they are applicable. The petition for such purpose shall be
accompanied by a resolution of each of the adhering syndicates.
The by-laws of the union or federation shall determine the rules by which the syndicates forming part thereof
shall be represented in the administrative council or at the general meetings. Syndicates forming part of a union
or federation shall not be liable for the debts of such union or federation.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 18; 1972, c. 63, s. 1; 1999, c. 40, s. 312.
20. Syndicates, constituted or not under this Act, unions and federations of syndicates may constitute
themselves into a confederation, by following the procedure prescribed in section 19; such confederation shall
enjoy, once constituted, all the rights conferred, by section 21, to unions and federations of syndicates.
The approval by the Autorité des marchés financiers of the by-laws governing an insurance or an indemnity fund
established by a confederation, shall confer juridical personality upon such fund; it shall be thereafter
administered by a committee composed of at least 10 persons appointed by the administrative council of the
confederation.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 19; 1969, c. 26, s. 115; 1972, c. 63, s. 2; 1975, c. 76, s. 11; 1981, c. 9, s. 24; 1982, c.
52, s. 259; 1999, c. 40, s. 312; 2002, c. 45, s. 618; 2004, c. 37, s. 90.
4 of 7
1/30/2012 5:10 PM
Professional Syndicates Act
http://www2.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/dynamicSearch/telecharge...
21. Unions and federations of professional syndicates shall enjoy, in their own sphere, all the rights and powers
conferred by this Act upon professional syndicates, and particularly those provided for in section 20. They may
also establish and administer a special fund or a pension plan provided for in subparagraphs 1 and 2,
respectively, of the second paragraph of section 9, for the benefit of the members of the adhering syndicates
and of their heirs or beneficiaries, if such syndicates agree thereto, whether they adhere directly to such union
or federation or are members of an affiliated union or federation.
They may, in addition, institute councils of conciliation and arbitration between the syndicates, which shall, at the
request of the interested parties, render decisions upon the disputes submitted to them. Such decisions shall be
submitted to the Superior Court for homologation, and, after the judgment confirming them, shall have the force
of a final judgment and be executory in the manner provided for the execution of judgments of the said Court.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 20; 1989, c. 38, s. 280.
22. The members of a professional syndicate may resign voluntarily, without prejudice to the syndicate's right
to claim the assessment for the three months following such resignation.
They shall not be personally liable for the debts of the syndicate.
The syndicate shall not claim from a member ceasing to adhere thereto the assessment of more than three
months.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 21.
23. If it be stipulated in any contract that workmen, or the members of a syndicate, union or federation of
syndicates shall receive a stated wage, such workmen or members, although not a party to the contract, are
entitled to the rate of wages therein stated, notwithstanding any renunciation thereto afterwards agreed upon by
them, whether express or implied.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 22.
24. (Repealed).
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 23; 1996, c. 2, s. 944.
DIVISION II
LIQUIDATION
25. In the case of a voluntary or judicial dissolution, one or three liquidators shall be appointed by the general
meeting, which shall be deemed as continuing to exist for the purposes of the liquidation.
The services of the liquidator or liquidators shall be gratuitous unless their remuneration shall have been
previously fixed by the general meeting.
The property of the syndicate shall be distributed as follows:
(a) first, provision shall be made for payment of the costs of liquidation and of the debts of the syndicate;
(b) the property derived from gifts or legacies shall be returned, in accordance with the provisions of the act
creating the gift or legacy, to the donor or to the legal representatives of the donor or of the testator. Failing
such provisions, they shall be handed over to one or more similar or correlated undertakings determined by the
by-laws, or, failing by-laws, by the ruling of the general meeting;
(c) then, provision shall be made for the maintenance and administration, in trust, of the special indemnity funds
or the pension funds established in accordance with section 9 or 14;
(d) the remaining assets must be devoted to one or more similar undertakings designated by the Minister of
5 of 7
1/30/2012 5:10 PM
Professional Syndicates Act
http://www2.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/dynamicSearch/telecharge...
Labour.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 24; 1968, c. 43, s. 17; 1969, c. 26, s. 115; 1975, c. 76, s. 11; 1981, c. 9, s. 24, s. 34;
1982, c. 53, s. 56; 1982, c. 52, s. 260; 1989, c. 38, s. 281; 1994, c. 12, s. 66; 1996, c. 29, s. 43.
26. The existence of any syndicate, union, federation or confederation terminates whenever the enterprise
registrar so orders after having ascertained
(a) that they have ceased to exercise their powers; or
(b) that the number of their members who are Canadian citizens and in good standing is reduced to less than
15 in the case of a syndicate and to less than three in the case of a union, federation or confederation; or
(c) in the case of a syndicate, when more than one-third of its members are not Canadian citizens.
The enterprise registrar shall deposit the order in the register. The order takes effect from the date of such
deposit.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 25; 1966-67, c. 51, s. 2; 1969, c. 26, s. 115; 1975, c. 76, s. 11; 1981, c. 9, s. 24; 1982,
c. 52, s. 261; 1993, c. 48, s. 512; 1999, c. 40, s. 312; 2002, c. 45, s. 619.
27. The Minister of Revenue shall be ex officio liquidator of every syndicate, union, federation or confederation
the existence of which has been terminated in accordance with section 26 or the dissolution of which was
decreed under section 118 of the Labour Code (chapter C-27).
For such purposes the Minister of Revenue shall exercise the powers vested in a liquidator by section 25 and
shall be bound by the obligations therein prescribed.
He may levy on the assets resulting from the liquidation his disbursements and fees fixed by the tariff for
curatorship cases.
R. S. 1964, c. 146, s. 26; 1971, c. 81, s. 45; 1989, c. 54, s. 199; 1999, c. 40, s. 312; 2005, c. 44, s. 53; 2006,
c. 58, s. 69.
DIVISION III
SPECIAL PROVISIONS
28. (This section ceased to have effect on 17 April 1987).
1982, c. 21, s. 1; U. K., 1982, c. 11, Sch. B, Part I, s. 33.
29. Notwithstanding any contrary legislative provision, no association, syndicate, union or federation or
confederation of such associations or syndicates governed by this Act shall be required, from 23 June 1987, to
submit its by-laws for approval, except those under which a special indemnity fund, a special assistance fund or
any other fund of the same nature is established.
1987, c. 59, s. 6.
30. The Government designates the Minister responsible for the administration of this Act except the provisions
relating to the responsibilities of the enterprise registrar, which are administered by the Minister of Revenue.
2002, c. 45, s. 620; 2006, c. 38, s. 85.
not in force
31. The Minister of Economic Development, Innovation and Export Trade is responsible for the application of
this Act.
6 of 7
1/30/2012 5:10 PM
Professional Syndicates Act
http://www2.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/dynamicSearch/telecharge...
2002, c. 45, s. 620; 2003, c. 29, s. 170; 2006, c. 8, s. 31.
FORMS
1.—
(Repealed).
R. S. 1964, c. 146, form 1; 1969, c. 26, s. 115; 1975, c. 76, s. 11; 1981, c. 9, s. 24; 1982, c. 52, s. 263; 1993,
c. 48, s. 513.
2.—
(Repealed).
R. S. 1964, c. 146, form 2; 1969, c. 26, s. 115; 1975, c. 76, s. 11; 1981, c. 9, s. 24; 1982, c. 52, s. 263; 1993,
c. 48, s. 513.
REPEAL SCHEDULE
In accordance with section 17 of the Act respecting the consolidation of the statutes (chapter R-3), chapter 146
of the Revised Statutes, 1964, in force on 31 December 1977, is repealed effective from the coming into force
of chapter S-40 of the Revised Statutes.
7 of 7
1/30/2012 5:10 PM
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?