Sylvester et al v. Interbay Funding LLC et al

Filing 64

OPINION AND ORDER: re: 46 MOTION for Summary Judgment filed by Bayview Loan Servicing LLC, Interbay Funding Inc., Interbay Funding LLC, 27 MOTION TO INCLUDE MICHAEL GOLDSTEIN AS A PARTY TO TH. filed by Celeste Wenegieme. For the foregoing reasons, Plaintiffs' motion to join Michael Goldstein is DENIED, and Defendants' motion for summary judgment is GRANTED. Judgment shall be entered in favor of Defendants on all claims. The Clerk of Court is directed to close the motions at Docket Numbers 27 and 46 and to close this case. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge J. Paul Oetken on 9/29/2017) Copies Mailed By Chambers. (ama)

U I E S A E DS RC C U T
NT D T T S I TI T O R
S U H R DS RC O N
O T E N I TI T F EWY R
OK
A L Y ES L E T R ea,
L E N Y V S E, t l
.
Pi i s
l nf ,
a tf

1- V 13 (P )
5C -76J O

-v

OI I NA DO D R
PN O N R E

I T R A F N I GL Cea,
N E B Y U D N L, l
t .
D edns
e na .
f
t
J P U O T E,Dt cJde
. A L E K N irt ug
si
:

Pi i sAen S vs rade s Wng m (oeie, Pi i s ,
l nf l ye y e e nC e e ee e e c lc v y“l nf ”
a tf l
l t
lt
i
l t l
a tf )
i i t
it t
i
Ie
)
i
poed g r s, r gh ain g n I eby ud gL C( n ra”adav w
rce n po e b n t s c o aa s n ra Fn n, L “ t by nBy e
i
La S vig L C( By e ”(oeie, D edn ”frn r s rig uo a
on e i n L “ av w c lc v y“ e na s oi u e as o f
rc ,
i ) l t l
f
t)
ji i n t
mr ae o c sr B o teCu a t o m in Pi i s m in o o a adin
o ggfr l u. e r h or r w o os l nf ’ o ot j n n d t a
t
eo e fe
t e
t : a tf
t
i
io l
d edn adD edn’m in os m ayug e. Frhraos h f l w
e na, n e na s o o fr u m jd mn oteesnta o o,
f
t
f
t
t
r
t
tl
Pi i s m ins e e , n D edn’m ins rn d
l nf ’ o oi dn d ad e na s o oi g t .
a tf
t
i
f
t
t
ae
I
.

Bc go n
akr u d
F mi i w h h d p es rs mdad h fc otecs a d aei te
a iat i t si u i p u e ntea s fh aer ei d n h
lry t i s t
e
,
t
e tl

Cu’ p oo n nt h m in oi m stg. e S vs rv By e La Sr c g
or s r r p i ate o o- -s i s e Se y e e . av w on evi
t i io
t td s a
l t
i
in
.
v
,
,
,
.
l n t
L C N 1 C . 7621 W 3624a* (.... ue 421) Te o oiga s
L , o 5 i 13 06 L 563 t 1 SDNYJn 2 06 hf l w fc
a ud p e u e o e w e o d
r n su d n s t ri n e
e i t ls h s t.
O Jnay 820 Aen S vs rok ua mr aeon n h a on o
n au 1 05 l ye y e eto o
r ,
, l
l t
t o gglai te mu f
t
t
$7 00r m n ra.( k N 4- D.N 6 ¶ (P. 6 S m”)Teonws
46 0 fo I eby D. o 81 k o 2 1“l 5 1 t t) hla a
,
t
t . ; t .
s .
..
scrd yh poe yoa dt 1 Ws 14ht e N wYr N wYr ( k N 4-;
eu bte rp tlc e a25 e 3tS e, e ok e ok D. o 82
e
r
t
t
rt
,
.
t .
D.N 3t ( C m .. S vs r usqe lt n e ete edt te rp t t
k o a3“ o p”) y e esbeun yr s r d h de o h poe yo
t .
l)
l t
t a fr
r
C e e Wng m o Jn 1 20 ( o p E A P. 6 S m ¶.
e s ee e e n ue 5 05 C m . x ; l 5 1 t t 5
lt
i
,
.
l .
s .
. )

1

O Jnay 821 By e c m ecd frc sr ain n h Sp m Cu o
n au 1 01 av w o mne a o l u c oi te ur e or f
r ,
,
i
eo e t
e
t
N wYr aa s Pi i s ( k N 4-) TeN wYr Sp m Cu g n d u m y
e ok g n l nf . D. o 71 h e ok ur e or r t s m a
i t a tf 1
t . .
e
t ae
r
jd mnt By e o Nv me 2 21 ( k N 1- ) TePi i sa rmvd o
ug e o av w n oe b 1 02 D . o 53 h l nf l e oet
t
i
r ,
. t . .
a tf t
d m s h ainae ntate hd e mr ae a mn t By e taifld o
i i te c o l g gh hy a sn o gg py e s o av w h taet
s s
t ,li
t
t t
t
i
t i
c d, utet e ordn d h m in olc oe dne n u i e ns o Jn 2
r i b h st cu e ete o o frak f v ec ad n mie n ue 4
et t
a
t i
t
i
t l s
,
21 ( k N 4- ) Te orr e ete o c sr ain o r e e n u 921
03 D. o 73 h cu e r d h fr l u c ot ae r o J y, 03
. t . .
t fr
eo e t
fe
l
( k N 4-)ad of md hr e e rpradi c d a o Jn 821 ( k N
D. o 74 n cnr etee r ’ eo n d e e s e n ue, 05 D. o
t .
,
i
f es
t
rt l
t .
4-)
75
.
Pi i si d h ain n M c 921 (e D .N 1 adi d h rA edd
l nf fet s c o o a h, 05 se k o ) n fete mne
a tf l i t
r
t .,
l
i
C m a t( eC m a t ) nAr 921 ( e o p) Atei ePi i si d h
o pi t “o pi ” o pl, 05s C m . t ht m l nf fet s
ln h
ln
i
e
l.
a tf l i
ain By e ws n h poe orv w gS vs r oaonmdia o D edn
c o av w ai te rcs fe ei y e efr la o f t n e na s
t ,
i
s
i n l t
i ci . f
t
ci ta By e o e d y e etemdia o o Ar 2 21 b ta S vs r
l m h av wf r S vs rh o f t n n pl 9 05 u h y e e
a
t
i
fe l t
i ci
i ,
, t t l t
“ i do ootee m ote. mdia o are e ad n ed n s d h ..
fl t hnrht s fh.. o f t n g mn nis aist ta .
ae
r
i ci
e t
t
ie t
Wng m b. . de a ga n r fhla ” D.N 4 ¶ 1‒5 “reaA. ;e
ee e e e. add s u a o oteon ( k o 8 ¶ 31 ( Tub f ” se
i
rt
.
t .
f)
a o k N 4- ) D edn l e s d h rn rsi temr aeo n nt cld
l D. o 88 e na sa r o te i e t n h o ggt a e i ae
s t . . f
t t
l i te
t
ty l
G d e GopH d g Ic( e G d e Gop , sm mrl e b aCro t
o si ru o i , n t “ o si ru” a e o azd y opr e
lt n
ln
. h lt n
)
ii
a
A in e o Mr ae a d M c 1 21 ( reaA. 1 D.N 4- )
s g mn f o gg d e a h 5 06 Tub f ¶ 7 k o 89
s
t
t
t
r ,
.
f
; t . .
Pi i s v s n fh s ri df e. Te n eh o Sp me 321 cus
l nf ’ ei otet ysi e n hy o ta n e e b , 05 one
a tf r o
o
fr t
t t
t r
,
l
frD edn rqe e a e es n fi eo n w teC m a trp sn nt teCu
o e na s eus d n x n o ot mt as e h o pi ,er e igo h or
f
t
t
t i
r
ln
e t
t
tate ais hv are ote a m e o amdia o are e ” utate w e
h h p t “ae g d n h p a e r f o f t n g mn b h hy e
t
re
e
r ts
i ci
e t t t
r

1

As m p na e mk ghla I eby s getemr aeoBy e.
t o e o tf r a nteon n ra a ind h o ggt av w
i t
i
,t
s
t
i
Pi i srutate s g mnt By e wsivi ( ee. P. 6 S m ¶ 23
l nf ageh h a in e o av w a na d S ,. , l 5 1 t t ¶ ‒
a tf
t
s
t
i
l. e g s .
.
,
2 ) T sip es o m e a h wv, easteCu hsl ayi m sdl o
6 h d u i n a rl o ee bcueh or a a ed d i e a f
. i st
t t i,
r
t
r
s s
l
Pi i sci set g o h vi t ote o c sr ain Se y e e, 06 W
l nf ’l mr a nt te a d y fhfr l u c o e S vs r 21 L
a tf a
li
li
eo e t .
l t
3624a*‒
563 t 45
,
.
2

wr n o a h dp. deo p e i tli u w h d n a e ga n r n h
ok g u “o u.. ut a o na ies e i ad g n w u a o ote
i
t
l
t tl t s t i
rt
mdia o a[ y e e hseus d o o ( k N 1 a1 selo k N 5 a1 .
o f t n s S vs r arqe et d ” D. o 1t ;e a D. o 3t 0 )
i ci
l t]
t
.
t .
s t .
Pi i st eh w hu n iy gh m“av w . s d h poe yw l[ e]t re
l nf stta i o of nte, By e . . o te rp t het i a ony
a tf a t t t t i
i
l
r
i hr t
ifr e [ y e e te w er nt rs vteiesu ”(l 5 1S m ¶ 5
no md S vs r hy e ty go eo e htli e P. 6 t t 2 )
l t]
r i
l
t s. s .
. .
Item s oa ot sD edn mvd oi m s h C m a t ( e D.N
n h i t fl fh, e na s oet d i te o pi . Se k o
d
l i f
t
s s
ln
t .
1 )A c mee bteRoe- e mn o r e h Cu d m sdlci s hln n
3 s o pld yh okr F d a dci , e or i i e a l m caeg g
.
l
l
tn t
t s s
l a
l i
te o c sr ainte. e S vs r 21 W 3624a*‒ TeCu d , o er
hfr l u c oi l Se y e e, 06 L 563 t 45 h or i h w e,
e o e t sf
l t
,
.
t d
v
a o t o fPi i sci s o o o w d() ci aeig ot n f h “ul w w o l nf ’l mt g fr a : 1al ml gnv li o te da
l
a tf a
r
a l
i ao
l
t c n” rh i oi teDd-rn WlS e R o m n Cnu e Po c o A
r k g po bin n h odF k a t e e r ad os m r ein c
ai
it
a
l rt f
r tt
t
( Dd- ak,se da *‒ ad2at e a trci “of uu n y r eu nte
“ odrn” e i t 24 n() st- wo l m frr d e l psc igh
F
)
.
,
a l
ta
a lt o t
frc sr ain nifc n e o oadt s ” d t 6
o l u c o ad niig m in ir s i a*
eo e t
lt
t l s e, . .
a
Ala t smci byn d p e Te rp t ws vn a y o . A etest
tes h uhs eodi u: h poe y a ee ul s d f rh t e
ti
st
r
tl l 2 t
cu e e d jd mn ofrc sr ad a o Ags 221 ( e k N 4-) te
or n r a ug e f o l u n s e n uu , 06s D . o 76 h
t te
t
eo e
l
t
e t .
,
r e eeo e tea o Sp me 721 ( k N 4-)
e r rpr d hs e n e e b , 06 D . o 77
fe
t
l
t r
t .
.
N w eo teCu a t om in Fs Pi i smvt j n M he G d e ,
o b fr h or r w o os it l nf oeo o i a o si
e
t e
t . r, a tf
i c l lt n
o n oteG d e Gop n h ain ( k N 2 ) Scn D edn mv fr
we fh o si ru i te c o D. o 7 eod e na s oe o
r
lt n
,
t . t . .
, f
t
s m ayug e o a ci s se e b Pi i s ( k N 4 )
u m jd mn nl l m a r d y l nf. D. o 6
r
t
l a
st
a tf
t . .

2

Dedn cn n taBy e nv s d h poe yb tate a ws h
e na s o ed h av w ee o te rp t u h h s e ate
f
t t
t i
r l
r, t t
l
G d e Gop d n ( e D.N 4 ¶ 2‒8 Pi i sepnta“ av w a n
o si ru’ o g Se k o 9 ¶ 62 ) l nf rsod h By e hd o
lt n
s i.
t .
. a tf
t
i
r ht sl h[ ]r ae ad[] e bcueBy e nv poe y cu ete o fo
i t o e te mo gg[n] no ” eas av w ee rp l aq rd h n er m
g
l
t
t
i
r
r
i
t
I eby (l 5 1S m ¶ 6 Aa, h d p es o m e abcue h Cu hs
n ra P. 6 t t 2 ) g n i i u i n a rl easte or a
t . s .
. .
i ts s t
t ti
t
l t
,
d m sdlci s hln nte o c sri e.Se y e e, 06 W 3624a*‒
i i e a l m caeg ghfr l u t l e S vs r 21 L 563 t 4
s s
l a
l i
e o e sf
5
.
3

I
I
.

Mt n o on M he G d en
oo t J
i
i i a o si
c l lt
Pi i s aemvdt ic d M M he G d e a a a y fh c il wu.
l nf hv oe “ n ue r i a o si s p t ot si la s t
a tf
o l
. c l lt n
r
i v
i”

( k N 2 a1 Pi i s b e apa t r y nFd a R e fC i Poeu 1 te
D. o 7t. l nf ’ r f pe s oe o ee l u o i l rcdr 9—h
t .
) a tf i
r
l
r l
v
e
r e omna r j ne ( e k N 3 a1 H wv, o oigh dt eh “ ]
u frad oy o d. S D. o 3t. o ee fl w tei a ta [
l
t
i r e t .
)
r l n
ct t a
dc mnfe po e st bl e ly os ud ”r ko v Pru, 5 US8 9 (07
ou e i d r s i‘ ei rl cnre ’E csn. ads 51 .. 9 4 20)
tl
o
ba
t , i
,
(u igsl v G m e 49US9 16 17) teCu cnrePi i s m in s
qo n E ee. a b , 2 .. 7 0 (96, h or os us a tf
t
tl
l
,
)
t t l nf ’ o o a a
t
rqe t j n M he G d e ad rh G d e Gop u unt e h Fd a R e f
eus o o i a o si n ote o si ru pr a oi e ee l u o
t i c l lt n /
lt n
s t tr
r l
C i Poeu 1 ( q rd o d )o R e 0 p m s eo d )
i l rcdr 9r u ej ne r u 2 (e i i j ne.
v
e
ei
i r
l
r sv i r
J ne oao e p sn ne R e 9seu e we “ tap sn asne h
o d f n h e o ud u 1irq rd h ei h e o’ bec te
i r
tr r
r l
i
r n t r s
,
cu cnoacr c m e ri a og xt g ais o we ta p sn asnemy
or an cod o pt ee mn e s n p t , r h eh e o’ bec a
t
t
l e lf
ii
re ”
r t r s
“ ma oi pdte e o’ a l yo r e [ni e s[ ligo h sb cote
i p r r meeh p sn bi t po c a] n r tr a nt te u e fh
i
r s it
tt
t e et
jt
ain o“ev a e s n p t sb ct a us nar k fnuig ob,m t l o
c o] r lae n xt g a y u e o sb a i i oicr n du e ui e r
t ”
ii
r
jt
t tl s
r
l
l p,
o e w enostn o ia os” Fd R C .P1( ;e a o onehDv C v U v
t ri icn s t b gin. e . i . 9 ) el Cn Tc e o . n.
h s
ie l t
.
v
as s
. .
i
o Cn Eu PoeisIc 12F d 7 61 2 C. 96
f on dc rpre n , 0 . 67 8 (d i 19)
.
.
t, .
3
,
r
.
Pi i sa t meteeu e e so R e 9 Te n ci s e a igeo te
l nf fl o e hrq r mn f u 1 . h o y l m r m n b r h
a tf i
t
i
t
l
l a
in fe
Cu r a t I eby s n By e ’ cnu b o ad u nte o c sr poed g
or et o n ra ’ ad av w odc e r n dr ghfr l u rce n
t le t
i s
t fe
i
eo e
i,
n tte a d y fhfrc sri e. e S vs r 21 W 3624a*‒ Ad
o oh vi t ote o l u t l Se y e e, 06 L 563 t 45 n
t
li
e o e sf
l t
,
.
l t,
bcueDd- aks u - ak g rvin os o p m i uc vri,e S vs r
eas odF n ’da t c n po s de n e i n nieee se y e e
r
lr i
io
t rtj t
lf
21 W 3624a* te e taPi i s a hpfrimn ay a ae aa s
06 L 563 t 3 h bs h l nf cn oe o s oe r d mgs g n
, ,
t t a tf
t
it
D edn. A sc G d e ’ p snes o“ee ayo cod o ptri ” o
e na s s uh o si s r eci n ncs rt acr c m e ee t
f
t
, lt n e
t
s
l e lf
Pi i s FdR C .P1(,eas G d e d sn o nadi n slat nta
l nf , e . i . 9 ) cue o si o o w (n d o e)n h gh
a tf
v
ab
lt n e t
d t l yi
t
Pi i s o d o i yeoe
l nf cu ps b rcv .
a tf l
sl
r
J ne o d edn ud R e 0s e mtdf ayiht ri i a e e aa s
o d f e na s ne u 2i p iei“n r t oee s s r d g n
i r
f
t
r l
rt
g
l f st
it
te j n ysv a yoi tel ra v w hepct oas g u ote a ernain
h m o t, ee l, rn h aenie i rse o rri o f h s mt sc o
il
rl
t t
t
t
in t
a t ,
4

ocr neos is frnain o ocr ne” n “n qein fa ofcc m ot
cu ec r e e ot sc os r cu ecs ad ay us o ol w r a o mn o
r , r
a t
r
t
t
a d edn wlr en h ain Fd R C .P2( () I apy gR e 0cus
l e na s i asi te c o ” e . i . 0a 2 n p i u 2 or
l f
t l i
t .
.
v
) .
ln l , t
ms“ ot teo c r a os p e wetel m ad e r ie we ete se i
u l ko hlg a et nh b t en h ci s n d e m ‘ h h h e na
t o
i l li i
a
t n
tr
s tl
fc ote a osl m a slg a y onc d h cn d a o ojdi eoo y n
a s fh v iu ci sr o o cl cne eta os e t n fu cl cn m ad
t
r
a
e
il
t
t i ri s
ia
.
f re dt eh a tesus eeo ei oea s t”K i v Bn o A.Cr , 9
a ns i a ta l hi e brs vd n nl wu. ae. akf m op 27
i s ct t l
s
l
i’ l
FRD5257 SDNY21) qo n U td t e v Auvl , 1 F d 22 (dC.
... 5 5 (.... 03(u ig ne S ts. qae a 65 . 1 2 2 i
,
t
i
a
l
2 ,
r
17)
99.
)
Pi i s m inloas ne R e 0 G d e — hs gop cu ete
l nf ’ o o a fl ud u 2 o si woe ru aq rd h
a tf
t
s i
r l . lt n
i
mr aea msa u yaa ete o pi wsi di n acsd f ai pign n
o gg l o f l e f rh C m a t afe — o cue o p tia ni ay
t
t l rt
ln
l s t
rc t
wynD edn’l gd u t c n otr os odc Tu t te x e ta Pi i s
ai e na s aee da r k g roiu cnu. hs o h e tn h l nf
f
t l
l ai
t
t
,
t t a tf
myhv std o el m ori aa s G d e, n sc cii lg a yiicfo
a aet e s m ci free g n o si ay uhl ms o cl dt tr m
a
a
lf i t l t n
a
i l sn
tel gin aa s D edn. A aeu, cn d a os fu cl cn m ad
h aea os g n e na s s rs t“os e t n ojdi eoo y n
l t
it f
t
l
i ri
ia
f re ” o ocus i fvr fo igG d e.Sed
a ns d n one nao oj n
i s
t
l
i n o si ei
lt n
.
Pi i s m in o o M he G d e ite fr dn d
l nf ’ o ot j n i a o si s h eo e e
a tf
t
i c l lt n
r e i.
I . Mt n o S
I
I
o o fr ummr J d et
i
ay u gmn
A
.

Lg Sa dr
ea t n ad
l

“ h cu sa g ns m ayug e itemvnso s h te i n gn n
Te or hl r t u m jd mn fh oa h wta h es o eu e
t l a
r
t
t
t r
i
d p e s o n m e afcad h mvni e iet jd mna a mt ol w Fd
i u at ay a rl a n te oa s nt d o ug e s ae fa. e
st
ti t
t tl
t
tr
” .
R C .P 5( ; e a olde.Ko 54F d 0 18 2 C. 09(S m ayug e
. i . 6 )sel S g v o , 6 . 15 0 (d i 20)“ u m jd mn
v
a
s e
i
3
,
r
r
t
i w rn dwe a e cnr nte v eci teih msfvrb t te o mv g
s a a e hn f r os u gh e dne n hl t o ao l o h nn o n
r t
,t
ti
i
g
t
ae
i
p t ad r w glraoa en rnei i fvr h es o eu esu at ay
a y n d i a esnb if ecs nt ao te i n gn ni e s o n
r
a n l
l e
s
, r
i s
m e afc”.“ fci m e a wei m ha e te u o e fh s t ne gv n g
a rla. ) Aa s a rl hnt i t f c h o c m ote u ud oe i
ti t
t
ti
g ft
t
i
r
rn
l w Gra -iMg o.Cu r w eH m LasIc, 2 F Apx 711 2 C.
a. oh m D ag v on yi o e on n 41 . p’ 9 0 (d i
”
i
t d
, .
,
r
21) qo n M Cr y.Dn &Bas e Cr 42F d 8 22 2 C. 07 ( t n
01(u ig c a h v u
t
t
rd re op 8 . 14 0 (d i 20) i e a
t t
.,
3
,
r
) nr l
5

qot nm k o ie) Ad aip ei‘ n n’ .ite v eci sctaa
u a o a s mtd n d u “ g u e. .fh e dnes uh h
ti
r
t .
st sei
i
t
raoa euy o d e r a edt ote o mv g a y A dro v L e yLby
esnb jr cu r un v i frh nn o n p t. n e n. i r ob
l
l t
rc
i
r ”
s
bt
,
Ic 47US2228 18)
n, 7 .. 4 4 (96
.
,
.
“ h mv g a y e s hi tl udn f e os a n ‘h asne f gn n
Te o n p t ba teni bre o d mnrigte bec o a eu e
i
r
r
ia
tt
i
i u o m e afc’ FD...Ge A. n C , 0 F d 8 22 2 C. 00
s e f a rl a. .. Cv ra mIs o 67 . 28 9 (d i 21)
s
t i t” I
t
. .
3
,
r
(uig e txCr v C rt 47US3733 18) Oct s udnsm,te
qo n C o
t
l e op . a e , 7 .. 1 2 (96. neh brei e “
.
tt
,
)
i
t h
ops g a ymsc m fr adw h pci e dne e os a nte xtne f
po n p t u o e o w
i
r
t
r i se f v ec d mnrigh e s c oa
t
ic i
tt
ie
gn n d p e fm e afc”I (t g ne o , 7 USa29 “ p t a eigh
eu ei u o a rla. d ci Adr n 47 ..t 4) A a y s r nta
i st
ti t . in
s
.
r st
t
aa cno b oi gn n yip e msspo te sein e h b “t go
fc an e rs eu e d u d u upr h a r o”i e y ci t
t
t
il st
t
t
st
tr
in
p t u r as fm e a i teeod o b “h w gh tem e a ce d n
ai l p t o a rl n hrcr” r y soi ta h a rl i d o o
rc a r
ti s
n t
ti s t
t
e a ihh asne r rsne f gn n d p eotaa av s p t cno poue
s bste bec o p ec oa eu ei u, rh n de e a y an rdc
tl
e
i st
t
r r
t
a m s l e dneo uprtea. Fd R C .P5( ()
d i i e v ect spo hfc” e . i . 6 )1
sb i
t
t
.
v
c .
“le dne u mtd n h m ins o e os ud n h mne msfvrb t
A v ec sb ie ote o oit b cnrei te an o ao l o
l i
t
t
t
r t
ae
te o mv g a y O n.Vlo Cr w l O - usnP ieDp, 7 F d 1 47
h nn o n p t ” k v i.f on a- n Hdo oc e’ 57 . 45 2
i
r. i
l
l
l
t
3
,
(dC. 09(u ig ov h. Ws o L rr A ’ , 6 F d 4 11 2 C. 04
2 i 20) qo n Hra v e pr i ay s n 32 . 17 5 (d i 20)
r
t
t
t t b
s
3
,
r
)
( t n qot nm k mtd H wv, [ o e aa u m yug e m in h nn
i e a u a o a o ie) o ee “] d e s m a jd mn o o te on r l ti
r
t .
r t ft
r
t t ,
mv g a y ms d mrta s m y h wh te i s m m ahs adu at te
o n p t ‘ u o o hni p so ta h es o e e py c ob s o h
i
r
t
e
l
t r
t
il
t
m e afc,ad my or y n oc sr aea os r nus na d pc a o ’
a rla s n ‘ a n e o cn uoyl gin o usb a i e seut n ”
t i t’
tl
l
l t
t tt
li .
Ge A. n C , 0 F dt 9 (tin o ie)fs qo nM ss t E cIds C
ra mIs o 67 . a22 ca os mtd(r u iga uh a l . nu o
t
. .
3
it
t
it t
t i e
. .
v Zn hRd Cr , 7 US5456 18) hn u igc t v Amns 13F d 0
. e t a o op 45 .. 7 8 (96 te qo nSo o. l ea, 4 . 15
i
i
.
,
,
t
t
3
,
14 2 C. 98)
1 (d i 19)
r
.

6

B
.

D cs o
i uin
s s
1
.

Fdr D a- rci gC im
eea u Takn l
l l
a

Pi i s fsci aeeta D edn v l e Dd-rn’ po bin n u
l nf ’itl ml gs h e na si a d odF k rh i o o da
a tf r a l
t f
t ot
a s it
l
t c n “ cod go h[ os m F aclPo c o Bra(C P’, u t c ni
r k g Acr nt te Cnu e i n a r ein u u‘ F B]da r k gs
ai .
i
r n i
tt
e
)
l ai
we a ev e mvs o w dw h o c sr poed g w l s m tnos wr n
h e s i r oefr a i fr l u rce ns hei uaeu y ok g
r
rc
r t eo e
i
i
l
l
i
w hh bro et ao frc sr ” Wng m v By e La Sr c g N 1C .
i te o w o v d o l u . ee e e. av w on evi n o 4 v
t
r r
i eo e
i
i
i, . i
93 21 W 2582a* (.... My, 05 C P rg a os rvna ev e
17 05 L 112 t 2 SDNY a 721) F Beut n p e s i r—
,
,
.
li
e t rc
w h c t nw d w ot m ad u e t c t n xe in —fo () mk n] hfs
i i e a i o s fi e n sb c o e a ecp os r m 1“ a[ gteit
t n ri n
jt
ri
t
i
r
n ie ri n rq rd y p ia ea fr n jdi o nnjdi frc sr poe ,
oc ofigeu e b apcb l w oayu cl r o-u cl o l u rcs”
t
l
i
l l
ia
ia e o e
s
o() mv n] ofrc srjd mn o od os eo cnu [ ga o c sr s e
r 2 “ o[ gfr o l u ug e r re f a, r odci ] fr l u a,
i
eo e
t
r l
tn
e o e l”
a erc v g a o ptls mia o apcinfo te o o e 1 CFR
f r ee i “ c m e o i gin p ia o”r m h br w. 2 ...
t
in
le s t t
l t
r r
§ 04 1f‒g
12 4( ()
. ) .
T e u -rc n rg a o cv s ny e oalasSe Ry Hs Ray L C.
h da t k geut n oe o p sn on e oa o e t L v
l ai
li
r l r l
.
l t l,
73N t Ae Ray L C 12F Sp 3 3835 SDNY21) Te rh i o o da
9 i h v e t L , 9 . up d 4 5 (.... 06 h po bin n u
n
. l,
.
,
.
it
l
t c ni p v e efreb ud 1 CFR§ 04 1 ) h ht e ta“ ] o o e
r k gs r al no a e ne 2 ... 12 4(, i sts h [ br w
ai
ity
c l
r
. aw c a
t a r r
my no eh po s n ot s ein u unt sc o 6) fR S A teRa E a
a efr te rvi s fh sc o pr a o ein ( o E P ”— h e st
c
io
i t
s t
t
f
l te
St mn Poeu sA o 17 1 USC§ 61esq R S A os oap t
el e rcdr c f 94 2 ... 20 t e
te t
e t
,
. E P de n p yo
t l
“bu ns proeon ” 2CFR§ 04 ( ‒b wc a d ie a “x n o[ o
[]s e upslas 1 . . 12 5a () hh r e nd s e es ns f
i s
,
.
. ) , i e f
t i ]
c d p m iy o a u ns c m e i, r g c tr proea d ie b 1 C R
r i r al fr bs e, o m clo ar u u l ups s e nd y 2 F
et i r
i s
ra
il a
,
f
. (;
s
a
i
t
12 3 )1 o Rg a o Z I § 04 ()2 selo 2USC§ 66 ) “ h ca e
06 ( () f eut n . d 12 5b ) e a 1 ... 20( ( T s hp r
.a
li
” .
de n ap t c d t nainiv v g x n os frd .. r m i fr u ns
os o p yo r i r sc os no i e es n oc i . p al o bs e,
t l
et a t
ln t i
et
i ry
i s
c m e i, r g c tr proe..” L e 12 5 eut nZ d ie “bu ns
o m clo ar u u l upss.. .i § 04, g a o
ra
il a
) k
. R li
e ns[]s e,
f
i s

7

c m e i, g c tr , r ra zin c d” s[ nx n o oc d p m i fr
o m clar u u l o ogn a oa r i a “ ]e es n fr i r al o a
ra i l a
i t l et
a t i
et i ry
bs e, o m cl r g c tr proe”1 CFR§ 06( .
u ns c m e i o ar u u l ups. 2 ... 12 3)
i s
ra
il a
. a3
“ h p t a eig v lin fR S A. ba te udn f h w gh teon
Te a y s r n ai a o o E P .. e s h bre osoi ta hla
r st
ot
r
n t
i qeinws bie fr e oa a opsd o u ns proe b n ni w h te
n us o a o a d o p sn, s poe t bs e upss r g g i i h
t
tn
r l
i s
, ii t tn
pr e otet u [”Ry Hs Ray 12F Sp 3 a36 I d e m igwe ea
uv w fh st e . oa o e t , 9 . up dt 5 n e r i n h h
i
at ]
l t l
.
.
t n
tr
la ws o a u ns o p sn proe“ e mhs so d e n h proefh
on afr bs e r e oa ups t e pa s hu b ote upsote
i s
r l
, h
i
l
t nain n n te a gr a o ote rp t s sd o eu teon I (u ig
r sc o ad o h c eo zin fh poei uet scr hla ” d qo n
a t
t
t it
re
e
. . t
G id v F ac F.Ic,N 0 C . 39 20 W 4534a* (..C.O.,
a no. i no i, n
l
n
n . o 7 i 091 08 L 424 t 4 ND a c 3
.
v
,
,
l t
20)
08)
.
A e dne o tt te oc s n h te o c sd rp t i am t u t u d g
l v ec p n o h cn u ota hfr l e p oe ys ui n b l n
l i
is
li
t
eo
r
l- i i i ,
w c Pi i s og frh proe f ee t gno e Fs te rp t ai ui a
h h l nf buh ote ups o gn a nic m it h poe yts es
i a tf
t
ri
. r,
r
s
b l n tacu ac m oa m t ltnn. Te f cl o gg ad ed ou e s
u d g h o d co md e ui eea s h oi amr ae n de dc mn
ii
t l
t lp
t
fi t
t
id a tate u d gs “ E L N O L – F I Y” C m .E A D.N 4n c eh h b l ni aDW LI G N Y 6 AML . ( o p x ; k o 8
it t
ii
l .
t .
2 Pi i sip eD edn’ o e in h te rp t i “ b l n w hi u t” D.
. l nf d u e na scn n ota h poe ys a u d g i s ns( k
) a tf s t f
t
tt
t
r
ii
t x i
t
N 4 ¶ )s m wacnu n yepn ntaii a 1 2a iyw h u t” P. 6
o 9 6 o e h ofs g rsod gh ts “- f m i 6 ns (l 5 1
.
,
t
il
i
t
l t
i
s .
S m ¶ 6 Pi i se o amr ae s g mn dc mntads iete rp t a “t t ) l nf r y n o gg a in e ou e h ec bs h poe y s 12
. . a tf l
t
s
t
t t r
r
F
AM WT A T HG R O V C N L N. ( k N 5 E A D.N 5 a2) n
I H T C A / R A A T A D D. o 3 x ; k o 3t . I
” t .
.
t .
ay vn te ais g eh,t m i u , h poe y o dco md e w f mis
n ee,h p t ar ta a i m mte rp t cu a m oa t oa ie
t
re e t
n
r
l c
t
l.
Scn , hla apcin n c etate rp twsn i edd o e p m y
eod teon p ia oid a s h h poe ya o n net b a r a
l t
it
t
r
tt
i r
oscnaye dne ntai ws xe e t gn a “ot e ahl w ( ub A.
r eod rs ec ad h t a epc d o ee t psi cs f . T ea f
r i
t
t
r e iv
o ” r
f

3

I o erse s Rg a o Zs hi p mn n rg a o frh Tu i
nt repc, eut n ite m e e igeut n ote r h n
h
t
li
l t
li
t
Ln n A (I A 1 USC10 esq n R S A H wv, 2CFR§ 04 d e s
ed g c TL ) 5 ... 61 t e , o E P. o ee 1 ... 12 5i c
i
t
,
. t
r
. rt
ta frh proe o d i n bs e proeon ud R S A“p rosmye o
h, ote upss f e n g u ns upslas ne E P,[] sn a r y n
t
fi
i s
r
e
l
Rg a o Zn e r i n we ete x m in p is
eut n i d e m ig h h h ee p o ape ”
li
t n
tr
t
l.
8

¶;D.N 4- ) De o h po qat otecne i ae fhlaapcin ts
8 k o 83 ut te or uiy fhsand mg oteonp ia o ii
t . .
l
l t ,
i ps b t v iyD edn’l m h te p ia oststatePoe yws n
mo i eo ef e na sci ta h apcint e“ t h rp t a a
sl
r
f
t a
t
l t
a
h
r
Ivs mn Poe yo e sd oivs mn proe ”( k N 4 ¶. Tas d
ne e rp t t b ue frne e upss D. o 9 7 h a,
t t
r
t t
.
t .
) ti
Pi i s o y epne oD edn’l ms h By e i n te o e otemr ae
l nf ’ n rsost e na s ci ita av ws o h h d fh o gg
a tf l
f
t a
t
i
t
lr
t
s “ei otemr ae an b aa zd (l 5 1S m ¶. T sl m s oo d as fh o gg cno e n ye ” P. 6 t t 7 h ci i nn
tl
t
t
l .
s .
. ) i a
rsos e
epn v
i.
T r ,S vs rind nAia t fC m e i Poe yUe w csts h te
h d y e es e a f dv o o m cl rp t s h h a ta h
i
l t g
f i
ra
r
, i te t
“rp t uewl e a a “ vs mn poe y (reaA. 9 D.N 4- )Te
poe y s i b” s ni e e rp t ” Tub f ¶; k o 84 h
r
l
n t t
r.
f
t . .
dc mnae tate rp t wu “o[e o n oe td ad h i ws prhsd s
ou e v s h h poe y o d n b we p a ” nta t a “u ae a
t r t
r
l t ]
r re
t
c
aivs mnt b h d re et ah d a y ( k N 4- )Aa ,Pi i s o y
nne e o e e orn d o t r p t ” D. o 84 g n l nf ’ n
t t
l
t
i r.
t . . i a tf l
r o ite o- sos e sein h “ei otemr ae an b aa zd (l
e r s h nn epn v a r ota d as fh o gg cno e n ye ” P.
tt
r
i st
t tl
t
t
l . s
5 1S m ¶ 89)
6 t t ¶ ‒.
.
.
F a y S vs r rv e I eby i a A in e o Lae adRn ac s g
i l, y e e po dd n ra w h n s g mn f ess n e stl i .
nl l t
i
t
t
s
t
t
on
(r b A. 1 D.N 4- ) T s ou e s ma y ec bs h poe y s
T ea f ¶ 0 k o 85 h dc mn i i r ds iete rp t a a
u
f
; t . . i
t ll
r
r
“ E L N O L – F I Y ad s gs [ le s n ad u rlae” n “ ]
DW LI G N Y 6 AML ” n a in “ ] xt g n f u ess ad[ l
s
al ii
te
al
rn, d t n rn,eeus no e sus n pot.. dpssacut adt r
e sadi a e srvne ic m i e ad rfs., eot cons n oe
t
io l t
,
,s
i
i,
h
bn i as gr mte rp t t I eby ( k N 4- a12 Pi i s g n epn
eet ri fo ”h poe y o n ra D. o 85t ‒ )l nf aa rsod
fs i n
r
t
. t .
. a tf i
o yh “ei ote mr ae an b aa zd (l 5 1S m ¶ 0
n ta d as fh o gg cno e n ye ” P. 6 t t 1 )
l t tl
t
t
l . s .
. .
D edn hv m te i tl udn o e os a te bec o a eu eip e
e na s ae e h rni bret d mnr e h asne f gn nd u
f
t
t i ia
tt
i st
oete u ns proe fhla Te udn hn htt Pi i s o c mfr adw h
v h bs e ups oteon h bre te s f o l nf t “o e o w
r
i s
.
is
a tf
r i
t
se f e dne e os a nte xtne f gn n d p e fm e afc”Ge A.
pci v ec d mnrigh e s c oa eu ei u o a rla. ra m
ic i
tt
ie
i st
ti t
t
Is C , 0 F d 22 qo n Adro , 7 USa29 Pi i so e o y n
n o 67 . a 9 (u ig ne n 47 ..t 4) l nf f r n oe
. .
3t
t
s
. a tf f l
rsos cig “ ei e Frn c on Ad o rpr ( e CL Rpr )frh
epne i n a C tid o s La u tr eo ” h “ FA eo ” ote
,t
rf
ei
i s
tt
t

9

poot nh teonws a ovn oala ” ot o d o b a o m cl on ( k
rpsi ta hla a “ cne in on sicu n e c m e i la
io t
t l ,
l t
r a . D.
t
N 5 a6
o 3t.
.
)
A u ig b n dc igta te F ARpr hslgi a e dnay a e te
s m (u o e d )h hC L eo a e t m ev e i v u 4 h
s n t t in
t
t
i t i tr l ,
Cu i p sae b D edn’ w rsoss Fs a cne in ” onmylo e
or s e udd y e na st o epne it “ovn oa la a a b a
t r
f
t
. r,
t l
s
“o m cl on ste F ARprs cne in ”aede n h goipoete
c m e i la ” o h C L eo’ “ovn oa lb os o i t d rv h
ra ,
t
t l
l
tn
s
c m e i n u ote mr ae Scn teC L Rprid a s h S vs r
o m cl a r fh o gg eod h F A eo n c eta y e e s
ra t e
t .
,
t it
t l t’
mr ae o wslcd n ars“ost n] f po o fsl nf e r e n
o gg n e a p e i o tu cn sig oa o f iti ,i da ad
t
t
a
t
t
i[
l
r e x t
a u a ea c m e i rae a las ( k N 5 E Lt 3 Tu te F ARpr
d s b r e o m cle st on ” D . o 3 x a2 ) hs hC L eo
jtl t
ra l te
.
t .
.
.
,
t
de n r s a eu e ip e fm e afc
os o a e gn n d u o a rl a.
ti
i st
ti t
TeCu n e a huh h Pi i s o or y n h p c o e dne— h te
h or o s—togte l nf d n e ot si e f v ec ta h
t t
l
a tf
tl
i e
i
t
rcr cnis dc rintigh “ e s Wng m hs en a ntemr ae n
eod o a a e a t st ta C e e ee e e a b py gh o gg ad
tn
l ao an t l t
i
e i
t
rs ign h poe y s c 20 ( k N 5 a3 H wv,[ on o a et g n
e d i te rp t”i e 05 D. o 3t. o ee “]as bi d o a a
in
r
n
. t .
)
r l
tn
i
pot ntoe oivs mni nno n ocp [] e apoeisrlas o bs e
rf adhsfrne e n o- we cu edrnl rp t a onfr u ns
i
t t
r
i
t
re e
i s
proe ”M a.Bok e RhbFn n N 1 C . 3521 W 1410a*
upss u v rov w ea ud g, o 0 i 11 01 L 789 t 2
. i
i
i
.
v
,
,
(.... My, 01 Wng m ws eea a yo h mr ae (reaA. 1
NDNY a 521) ee e e a nv p t t te o gg Tub f ¶ 1
.
i
r r
t .
f ;
D.N 4- D.N 4- ) Ad h hs oa i r a os p oS vs r Wng m
k o 81 k o 86 n se a n f m yet nh t y e e ee e e
t . ; t . .
l li i
l t;
i
ds ie S vs r ny s e“u ns p te”( k N 5 a2
ec bs y e e o a h bs e a n. D. o 3t.
r
l t l
r i s r r
t .
)
EeiteCu cn d ete rp t t b o n -cu e ta wu n cag
vnfh or os e dh poe yo e we ocp d h o d o hne
t ir
r
r
i, t l t
i cn u o O n -cu e rnl rp t s r bs e edao wete u d gs
t oc s n we ocp d e apoei a u ns nevr hn h b l ni
s li .
r
i
t
re e i s
s
ii
l g eog ote o m cl a r ote n rr eslabsd n n me ofc r
a e nuh rh c m e i n u fh e epsi c rae o a u b fa o.
r
ra t e
t i
e
r
ts

4

TeCu n eta m ytecusa n w h h Fd a T d
h or o s h a o r or,l g i te ee l r e
t t
t n h
t o
t
r a
C m i in rg d hs s- l d ei e frn c u t w h kpc m Se e. asn
o m s ,ea tee o ae c tid o s ads i se i s . e,., no
so
r
cl rf
ei i t
ti
gH
, .
v
,
,
.
,
v Wl FroBn NA N 1 C . 9821 W 2486a* (WD Ws My 6
. es ag ak .. o 0 i 14 01 L 143 t 3 .. ah a 2
l
21) Nn h e, n m in os m ayug e, h Cu i bud oi wh
01 oe e s o a o o fr u m jd mn te or s on t v te
.
tls
t
r
t
t
e
e dnenhl h msfvrb t te o mv g a y
v ecitei t o ao l o h nn o n p t
i
g
t
ae
i
r.
1
0

Se r d a v Mse Fd La & a A ’ , 0F Sp 3 13109 (.... 04
e F e mn. ap h e on Sv s n 3 . up d 8 9–1 EDNY21)
i
t
.
. s
.
,
.
G e S vs r ud p e st mn ao te upsfrhla ( e D .Ns4-t
i n y e e s n su dt e e s bu h proe oteon se k o 82 o
v
l t’ i t a
t
t
t
.
4-) h Cu cn uetaS vs r mr aews bs e -upsla eei
85 te or oc ds h y e e s o gg a a u ns proeon vnf
,
t l
t l t’
t
i s
Wng ml ei te rp t w lte edws n e n m “n e r i n we ete
ee e ei d n h poe y heh de ai h a e I d e m ig h h h
i
v
r
i
r
.
t n
tr
la ai ui sb ct teeu e e s fR S A hr ea qeins h proe o
onts es u e o hrq r mn o E P, ee vn us o ite upsfr
s
jt
i
t
t l t t
w ctemr aeonwsmd ” o“ e upsfrw cte rp ti b n ue o
h hh o ggla a ae n t proe o h h h poe ys e g sd n
i
t
, t h
i
r
i
te a otel gdR S Ai a os Bre v GenTe Sr c g L C N 1 C .
h d e fh aee E P v lin ” a t . re re evi , L , o 4 i
t
l
ot . rt
in
.
v
2721 W 6023a* (..O oDc221)
9 04 L 890 t 3 SD h e , 04
,
,
i
.
.
Asc n raoa e a f d cu cn ue h Pi i shv m te bret
s uh oesnb fci e o d oc dta l nf ae e h r udn o
,
l tn r l
l
t a tf
t i
so “ ateon n us o ws bie fr e oa a opsd o u ns proe ”
h wt t hlai qein a o a d o p sn, s poet bs e upss
h
t
tn
r l
i s
.
Ry Hs Ray 12F Sp 3 a36Bcue u ns -ups mr ae a ee p
oa o e t , 9 . up dt 5 eas bs e proe o ggsr x m
l t l
.
.
i s
t
e
t
fo R S A D edn a e iet s m ayug e at te nr yfPi i s da
r m E P, e na sr nt d o u m jd mn s o h e i t o l nf ’ u f
t e tl
r
t
te
a tf
l
t c nci .
r k g am
ai l
2
.

Sa - a Tr C im
tt L w o l
e
t a

Atem in t d m stg teCu cnre teC m a tie l i fvr f
t h o o -oi i s e h or os ud h o pi l rl nao o
t
-s s a ,
t t
l n b ay
ter s Pa tf “ r stetogsag mn te sge. S vs r 21 W
hpo e l nf t a eh s ne ru e s hy ugs” y e e, 06 L
iis o i
r
t
t
t l t
3624a* (u ig r smnv Fd Bra o P sn 40F d 7 47 2 C. 06
563 t 2 qo n T e a . e ueuf r os 7 . 41 6 (d i 20)
,
t
it
.
i ,
3
,
r
)
( t n qot nm k o ie) Ap igh s nad h Cu epieta“ e
i e a u a o a s mtd p y t st d , e or x a d h t
n r l ti
r
t .
ln i a rt
t ln
t h
A eddC m a t a b ud s o ar s g al m h “ e na s naei f u
mne o pi cn e net d s ai ” ci ta D edn eggd nr d
ln
ro
in
a
t f
t
a
l t
, .
adn n oaifc o oe o oadt s. S vs r 21 W 3624a*
ni e in niin f m in ir s” y e e, 06 L 563 t 4
t t l lt
t l se
B n wh b i h h . W l sla d g yh “o y fie l cnr n po
u o te a si e hetl b i bte p ic ol rl os u g r
t
r gr i i in
l
b ay t i
s o, it
3
,
t t
i r t t r a tf
s sb i in ”r smn 40F dt 7 teCu ms n w os e n we e Pi i s
e u m s s T e a , 7 . a45 h or u o cn d o h h l nf
hv p u b std ci free b is a we e tehvr sd gn n d p e f
ael s l t e al m ori , u n ed h h hyaea e a eu ei u o
ai y a
a
lf t t
tr
i
i st
m e afc “ ] h m in os m ayug e aeu e spo e b aia t te
a rla. [Wt a o o fr u m jd mn dqal upr d yf dvs h
ti t
i
t
r
t
ty
t
f i,
1
1

p t ops gh m in an r y nl gini te o pi , u mscu ete
a y po nte o o cno e o aea os n h c m a tb u on rh
r
i
t
tl
l t
ln t t t
mvn sf dvsw h pcifc soigh e s ne f eu esusw rn n a
oa ’ aia t i se f a s h w te xt c o gn ni e a a ig
t f i t
ic t
n
ie
i s
r t
i t,
3 ,
r
.
t l
t
t a”M Kna. W g 36F d 3 46 2 C. 04 TeCu cn ueta
rl c en v r h 8 . 42 3 (d i 20) h or oc ds h
i.
Pa tf hvfld o met s“ o po n ts fr u m yug e. m oes R.
li i s aeaet e h mr rb ge ” os m a jd mn E p ye e
nf
i
ti
e i
t
r
t l
’ t
Sso Gv oteV g I ad v B n r, 9 F d 9 36 2 C. 05
y f o t f h i i s ns. l f d 74 . 27 0 (d i 21)
.
’
rnl
ao
3
,
r
.
T poeat aal m oe h f u oi e in ifc o oe o oadt s
o rv t rl ci fri e r d rn n oa niin f m in ir s
i
a
tr a
t t l lt
t l s e,
Pi i swu net so ta D edn d n hv aear ht te o c sr Se
l nf o d ed o h wh e na si o ae lg i t o hfr l u. e
a tf
l
t f
t d t
lg
eo e
M A.Faig L C.Vr hCn.Ic 17F Sp 3 1511 NDNY21)
i t r m , L v a s os n
d l
n
i
t ., 1 . up d 4 5 (.... 05
,
.
,
(x a igh tel mn o N wYr c m o- wruic da h w gh “ e
epi nta he e s f e ok o mn a f d n ue soi ta t
ln
t
e t
l
a
l
n t h
d edn md am e af srp snt n ad h “ e e na i edd o e ad h
e na ae a rla e er e a o” nta t d edn n net d rute
f
t
ti l
e ti
t h f
tt
f
pi i te b” Tr y. S Lca an Ic 74F d 4 17 2 C. 04(o ig
l nf h ey ; u e vI G ak wna n, 7 . 10 5 (d i 21) h d
a tf r ) l
, .
3
,
r
ln
taa e mn oteo oi e in ifc o oe o oadt sita“ fna
h nl e f htr fn n oa niin f m in ir ss h d edn
t
e t
t t t l lt
t l se
t e
t
egge] ne r m ad u aeu cnu,w c st ncns h bud o dcny s o
na[di ‘x e e n o rgos odc h h or sedte ons f eec at
t
t
t i
a
brgre a a o os ni o rb i ai l e sct’(u igr h e v Ha t
eeadd st c u ad n l a en c izd o e ” qo n Fe o r. er
ri
te l
vi
iy
t
if
s
Cr , 8 NE d 4 35NY 18))
op 40 .. 39 5 ( . 95)
.
2
,
.
.
I spo ote m in os m ayug e, e na sp nt N wYr st
n upr fh r o o fr u m jd mn D edn o t o e okt e
t
i t
r
t f
t i
a
cu poed gtacnr te a d yfh frc sr poed g g n S vs r ( e
or rce ns h of m h vii ote o l u rce n aa s y e e S
t
i
t i
l t
eo e
i
it l t. e
f
t ia
tt
D.N s4 4-t 4- )T s as e D edn ’ ni bret d mnr eh asne
k o. 7 71 o 77 h siis e na s i tl udn o e os a te bec
t
,
. i tf
oa eu eip e v D edn’iht prute o c sr ad h nnruu n
f gn n d u oe e na sr t o u ehfr l u nte o- ad e
i st r f
t g
s
eo e
f
lt
n u ote cnu i tet e orain
a r fh r odc n h st cu c o
te
i
t
a
t t .
I rsos Pi i smk o y we n aea os fee l e m faac.( e
n epne l nf ae n s ep g l gin ogn azd a esne S ,
, a tf
l
i
l t
ri
l
e
e. D.N 5 a1 (lg g h “ D edn]r a uc o c m a worf uu n y
. , k o 3t 3ae n ta [ e na s a bnh fr i l h a r d e l
g t .
l i
t f
t e
i ns
e a lt
r p g f h m o n [ adl m go w mr ae w c a n te ad. sl g
i i o o e we s n ci i t o n o ggs h h r o h e n.. ei
pn f
r]
a n
t
i e t r
ln

1
2

fk mr ae s g mn n e” D.N 6 a 1 (lg gh “ av wi a d h
ae o gg a in e o s ;k o 1t 0ae nta By e v l ete
t
s
t t ) t .
l i
t
i
ot
pi i[ ]ih [n] s uh asd m in p n adiacl o t teli i s.
l nf s r t ad asc cue e o oa a s n f n als o h p nf ”)
a tf ’ g s
t l i
n i
s
a tf )
Eel e ly os ud n h mne msfvrb t Pi i s hs st mn a ont
vni rl cnre i te an o ao l o l nf, eet e e s mu o
ba
t
r t
ae
a tf t
a
t
t
n h gmrta “oc sr aea os ad usb a i e seut n Se ra A.
oi
t n o hn cn uoyl gin” n “nus na d pc a o ” e Ge m
e
l
l t
t tt
li .
t
Is C , 0 F dt 9 (u igc t, 4 F d 14 Sc st mn a isf c nt
n o 67 . a22 qo nSo o 13 . a 1) uht e e sr nui e o
. .
3
t
t
3t
.
a
t e
fi t
c r Pi i s bret “t ] o aiu r as fm e a i teeodo“h w tate
a y l nf ’ udn o c[ t p t l p t o a rl n hrcr r so [ h h
r a tf
ie
rc a r
ti s
”
] t
m e a ce [yD edn] o oe a ih h asne. a eu e ip e Fd R C .
a rl i d b e na sd n s bste bec.. gn n d u. e . i
ti s t
f
t
t tl
i s t” .
v
P 5( ()
. 6 )1.
c
D edn a te fre iet s m ayug e at Pi i sst- wo
e na sr h eo nt d o u m jd mn s o l nf ’t e a tr
f
t e r e tl
r
t
a tf a l
t
ci .
l m
a
3
.

P itf Rqe frA di n D cvr
l nf ’ e us o di o a i oey
a is
t
t l s

F a y Pi i sak h Cu t dn s m ayug e ad rn h m n x n o
i l, l nf ste or o ey u m jd mn n g t e a e es n
nl a tf
t
r
t
at
t i
ot mt c m e fc d cv y ( k N 5 a2 R e 6dsts h “] a o mvn
fi eo o pt a i oe . D. o 1t. u 5()t eta [f nn oa
le t s r 5
t .
) l
a
ti
t
so s yf dv o dc rin h, ose f desn icno p snfc e e i t
h w b aia t r e a t ta fr pci raos t an r e a s s na o
f i
l ao t
ie
,
t e t t s tl
jsfi opsin h cu my()e r os e ntem in r ey ; 2a o t mt
uiy s pot , e or a 1d ecn d igh o o o dni ()l wi eo
t t
io t
t :
f
ir
t
t
l
o a aia t o dc rin ot tk d cv yo()su ayteaport od.
bi f dvs r e a t s roaei oe ; r 3i e n o r prp a re ”
tn f i
l ao
s r
s
h
ie r
Fd R C .P5()
e . i . 6d
.
v
.

5

Te aisip ewe e Pitf ees vdD edn w hicv y
h p t d u h h l nf v e e e na s i d oe
re s t
t r a is r r
f
t t s r
d mns Pi i sl m h D edn hv “ fsd o o pyw h eus d n rq rd
e ad l nf ci ta e na s aer uet c m
. a tf a
t f
t
e
l i rqe e ad eu e
t
t
i
pouin f ou e a o i e oa r d mnsad eot n ”( k N 5 a1
rdc o o dc mnt n n r g oy e ad n dpsi s D . o 1t.
t
ti , t r t
,
io .
t .
)
D edn rsod h “l nf ntes vd icv y e ad nr eus d eot n
e na sepnta Pi i s e h e e d oe d mns orqe e dpsi s
f
t
t a tf i r r
s r
t
io
iteielsmn sicte ceu n od ws n rd ( k N 5 a6 Iapa
n hf p
v u o hs eh shd ig re a e e . D. o 2t. t pe s
t n
l
r
te” t .
)
r
ta Pi i smy ae e d cv y e adt teCu ( e k N 5 E Q b fld
h l nf a hv sn i oe d mns o h or s D. o 3 x ) u ae
t a tf
t s r
te t .
.
t i
ttkfr e ainwete ou e wse ret sne I ay vn oeh gs
oae u h c o hn h dc mn ar und o ed. n n ee, nt ni
tr t
t
t
r
t
i
c a Te e o fra d cv y ne o Fbu y 821 ( k N 2 ) Tei e o
l r h p id ofc i oe edd n era 2 07 D. o 6 ht mfr
e:
r
t s r
r ,
. t . .
rs v gicv yip e hs og a e ad h qein o i we es m ay
eo i d oe d u s aln ps d n te us o n ws h h u m
ln s r st
s,
t
tr
r
jd mni aport bsd n h aaa eeod
ug e s prp a ae ote vlb rcr
t
ie
i l
.
1
3

Pi i s aeaet fehrq sef dv t spo te rqe.IteScn
l nf hvfld oi teeui aia t o upr h r eus n h eod
a tf
i
l
it f i
t i
t
C c ta a y po n am in os m ayug e ote a s fndqa d cv y
i u, p t ops g o o fr u m jd mn n h bs oiaeu ei oe
ri
r
i
t
r
t
i
t s r
“ u fe nf dv ds i n ()wafc a suhad o te a t b o a e ()
ms i a aia t ec b g 1 h a s r og n h whyr o e bi d 2
tl
f i
ri :
t t e
t
e
tn;
h whsfc a raoa y xe e t r s a eu esu o m e afc ()wae os
o teea sr esnb epc d oa e gn ni e f a rl a; 3 h f r
t e
l
t
i
i s
ti t
t ft
tef a hsmdt o a te ; n ()wyh ainsfosw e nucs u”
h ain a aeo bi h mad 4 htef a ’e r e usce f.
f t
tn
f t ft r
sl
Ga n v Aa s 35F d 3 24 2 C. 04 “ r e neo R e 6d ad o h
u ad . d m , 8 . 26 4 (d i 20) A e r ct [ u 5() nt te
l i
3
,
r
.
fe
l
]
ne fr d t n d cv yn m mrnu ol wn pot n o m in os m ay
ed o adi a i oe i a e o d m fa i opsi t a o o fr u m
io l s r
a
io
t
r
jd mni n a aeu e ust e oa R e 6d aia tad h flrt fe n
ug e s o n dqa sbi tfr [ u 5() f dv, nte a u oi a
t t
t
tu
l
]f i
i e l
aia t .ii e sf c n gons oe cal m h te po u t fricv yws
f dv ..st l ui e rudt r e ci ta h opr n y o d oe a
f i
s f fi t
jt a
t
ti
s r
iaeu e Pd n o Pr e v Buhr , 4F d 1213 (dC. 94(tin
ndqa. ad g n a nr . ocad 3 . 13 17 2 i 19)ca os
t”
it
t s
3
,
r
it
o ie)
mtd
t .
H wv , n os e t no Pi i s po et u teCu wl os ute
o ee i cn d a o f l nf ’ r s sts h or i cnreh r
r
i ri
a tf
a ,
tl
t
i
rsos e r f g s R e 6daia t Ee s te sb i insnui e.Te
epn v b e n a a u 5()f dv. vn o h r u m s iisf c n h
i ii
l
f i
, i
so
fi t
Pi i sa t ds iew h n se fiywafc te set d cv ad o te
l nf fl o ec b i ay pcit h a s hy ek oi oe n h why
a tf i
r
t
ic
t t
s r
wu d s Se ea.Rl 61F Ap 2 2 (dC. 05(e c n ar s p t’
o d o o e Vg v e , 1 . p’ 2 6 2 i 21) r eig po e a y
l
.
l
x ,
r
jt
r s
“sein h s m ayug e ws r m u deo no pt d cv y bcue ei
a r ota u m jd mn a p a r ut ic m e i oe ” eas h d
st
t
r
t
e te
le s r
d
n ie iyay pci d cv a eno min e oet o a b h d cv yeus
o dnf“n se f i oe b ifr a o h hpd o bi yi i oe rqe s
t t
ic s r l
t
tn
s s r
t
ta wu hvr sd m e ai u ofc )I r Dn Cr , 7 F d 2 184 (d
h o d aea e a a rls e f a ” n e aa op 54 . 19 4–9 2
t l
i
ti s
t;
.
3
,
C. 09( A orpi y a d c t n oe caeusfricv yfh e dne og
i 20)“ cu l n hsi ri t r e rqe o d oe ite v ec suh
r
t al
s eo
jt
t
s r
i
t
wu b c m a v oiteeusi bsd n o ‘pc a o at wap e il cu
o d e u ut e rfhrqe s ae o y nseut n s o h o na y o d
l
li
t
l
li
t t tl
l
it
t s
3
)
t
r
b d cv e’.. (u ig ad g nPr e , 4F dt 18.“t o o , p t my
ei oe d..” qo n Pd n o a nr 3 . a13) A b t ma a y a
s r
t
n ueR e 6da amas fid g u we ei hs cs ”D Po v CyfN w
o s u 5() s en of i o h h t a a ae e a a. i o e
t
l
nn t tr
.
l
t
Yr, 8 F Apx 07 (dC. 04
ok 56 . p’ 7 1 2 i 21)
,
r
.

1
4

Acr n y Pi i srqe fr n x n o ot mt cnu fcd cv ys
cod g , l nf ’ eus oa e es n fi eo odc a i oe i
il
a tf
t
t i
t t s r
dn d
ee
i.
I.
V

Cn u o
oc s n
li
Frhfrg n raos Pi i s m int j n M he G d e i D NE, n
ote o o gesn l nf ’ o o o o i a o si s E I Dad
ei
, a tf t
i c l lt n

D edn ’ o o fr u m yug e i G A T D Jd mnsa b e e d nao o
e na s m in os m a jd mn s R N E . ug e hl e n r i fvr f
f
t t
r
t
t l
te
D edn o a ci s
e na s nl l m
f
t
l a .
TeC r o Cu i d e et c stem in a Dce N me 2 ad 6 nt
h l k f or si c d ol eh o ost ok u b s 7 n 4 ad o
e
t rt
o
t
t
r
c st s ae
l eh cs.
o i
S O DRD
O R E E.
D e Sp m e 2 21
a d e e br 9 07
t: t
,
N wYr N wYr
e ok e ok
,
__________________
__________________
JP U O T E
. AL EKN
UtdStsDt cJde
ne t e irt ug
i
a
si

C P MI E T P O EP RI SB C AM E S
O Y AL D O R S A TE Y H B R

1
5