Graham v. Prince et al

Filing 242

ORDER granting 236 Letter Motion to Seal. The requests as set forth above are granted. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Sidney H. Stein on 10/5/2023) (jca)

II GreenbergTraurig

MEMO ENDORSED

Ian C. Ball on
[e-mail]
L.A. Direct Dial : 310.586.6575
Pa lo Alt o Direct Di al : 650 .289.7 88 1

October 4, 2023

Hon. Sidney H. Stein
U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York
Daniel Patrick Moynihan United States Courthouse
500 Pearl Street
New York, New York 10007

Re:

Graham v. Prince, et al., No. 1:15-cv-10160-SHS (S.D.N.Y.)Redaction and Sealing of Documents

Albany
Amsterdam
Atlanta
Austin
Berlin~
Boston
Charlotte
Chicago
Dallas
Delaware
Denver
Fort Lauderdale

Dear Judge Stein:

Houston

We represent Defendants Richard Prince in the above-referenced case and write
on behalf of ourselves and Defendants Laurence Gagosian and Gagosian Gallery, Inc. (the
"Gagosian Defendants," and collectively with Mr. Prince, the "Defendants"). We submit
this letter pursuant to Section 5(8) of Your Honor' s Individual Practices.
Certain portions of the Memorandum of Law in Support of Defendants' Motion
for Security for Costs Pursuant to Local Rule 54.2, and the exhibits attached to the
accompanying Declaration, have been designated by Plaintiff Donald Graham and the
Gagosian Defendants as "Confidential" and/or "Highly Confidential -Attorneys' Eyes
Only" (the "Protected Material") under the Stipulated Protective Order entered in this
case on January 29, 2018. The Protected Material includes information that Plaintiff and
the Gagosian Defendants have previously identified as confidential commercial/business
information, non-public financial information, and/or confidential customer information.
Accordingly, we respectfully request an Order permitting Defendants to fil e under seal_
documents containin ur ortedl Protec
rial and briefing papers to the extent
ey reflect any such Protected Material. Where possible and to the extent necessary,
Defendants also request permission to file w,ac@laiold~f' ,:'di'~dacted versions of such
documents, testimony, and papers via ECF.
Ac
Thank you for your consideration of this important argument and issue.
cc: Counsel of Record (via ECF)

The requests as set forth above are granted.

Respectfully submitted,

(/

Las Vegas
London•
Long Island
Los Angeles
Mexico City+
Miami
Milan >>
Minneapolis
New J ersey
New York
Northern Virginia
Orange County
Orlando
Philadelphia
Phoenix
Portland
Riyadh «
Sacramento
Salt Lake City
San Diego

San Francisco
Seouloo
Shanghai
Silicon Valley
Singapore·
Tallahassee
Tampa
Tel Aviv~
Tokyo•
WarsawWashington, D.C.

Dated: New York, New York
October 5, 2023

Ian. C. Ballon

West Palm Beach
Westchester County
Opsali!S as "'Oflffllllrg T1u9 Germi111¥ lLP.
"Asepara1eui:~erec1e!i"1eri111y.
•a.eenbe,gT,...,'3, SC , 'Gt•,.,_9 f,...'l
00

Sama~~. Qerb!rg Triuig LLPForegn
LegalQ:muhan10ffal, 'AD'111cholGree~

11
Traurg. PA ,Fbrdl USA.. GTTokt'ol·bn~
.imuWlowldOe«tie1glra,,1-g

G t i ~ n Jmulho. ~Gteertefg
Traurg P<brr.!lowsk>Zmoc:ti Wpokmla ,o.k. •

Qeenbf!fglru11S11,gap;,reLLP'ldlldl•
l,c,en,ed a, tloJe9'1 i11'<1'ptacliDI! 111 Sngapor,, •
Greenbetglrug,PA niai:plynJt>~fl
pnt w nlln!1nSaudilva:lll

Stein, U.S.D.J.