Ramsay-Nobles v. Keyser et al

Filing 387

ORDER: The Court having convened the final pretrial conference and heard the parties' objections to the exhibits in dispute, the following exhibits are admitted, as further set forth. (Signed by Judge Colleen McMahon on 1/27/2020) (mml)

. ,..,.......,.._.,,_.,,~

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

,...,.,.

,,

'
L

I r" ·,

JULIA RAMSAY-NOBLES,

_l ..

.

Plaintiff,
-against-

..

~.

~

- ...

'

\_ ..

\.'..I

I

A

I

·

·=

.t

Ti

L, ...

~

.ll) p

!i

---~,

1/~r -- ;,
---

16 Civ. 5778 (CM)

WILLIAM KEYSER et al.,
Defendants.

___________________x

McMahon, C.J.:
The Court having convened the final pretrial conference and heard the parties' objections to the
exhibits in dispute, the following exhibits are admitted:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

Exhibit DXCO - B
Exhibit DXKB - A
Exhibit DXKB - B
Exhibit DXKB - C
Exhibit DXKB - D
Exhibit DXKB - E
PTX-001
PTX-002
PTX-003
PTX-004
PTX-005
PTX-008: only against Officers Walter and Tucker for the limited purpose of showing
coordinated testimony, and not for the truth of the matter asserted
PTX-009
PTX-010
PTX- 011
PTX- 012
PTX- 013
PTX- 014
PTX- 015
PTX- 016
PTX-017

1

•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

PTX- 018
PTX- 019
PTX- 020
PTX- 021
PTX-022
PTX- 023
PTX- 029: with redaction
PTX- 050
PTX- 086
PTX- 087
PTX-088
PTX- 090
PTX- 091
PTX-092
PTX- 093
PTX- 094
PTX- 095
PTX- 096
PTX- 100
PTX-104
PTX- 105
PTX- 106: limited to the first page (NYSP00000909)
PTX- 127
PTX-177
PTX- 179
PTX- 196
PTX- 197: to prove notice to Superintendent Keyser
PTX-199
PTX-202
PTX-205
PTX-206
PTX- 210
PTX-211
PTX- 212
PTX- 214
PTX- 215
PTX- 216
PTX-217
PTX- 218
PTX- 220: to prove notice
PTX- 221: to prove notice
PTX- 222: to prove notice
PTX- 223: to prove notice
PTX- 224: to prove notice

2

•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

PTX- 226: to prove notice
PTX- 227: to prove notice
PTX- 231
PTX- 232
PTX-233
PTX- 235: to establish time of death
PTX-237
PTX-239
PTX-243
PTX-245
PTX-248
PTX-251
PTX-254
PTX- 255
PTX- 256 to establish officers' locations and what they did on April 13
PTX- 258: only admissible against Officer Tucker
PTX- 259: only admissible against Officer Tucker
PTX- 260: only admissible against Officer Tucker and Superintendent Keyser
PTX- 261: only admissible against Officer Tucker and Superintendent Keyser
PTX- 262: only admissible against Officer Tucker and Superintendent Keyser
PTX- 263: only admissible against Officer Tucker and Superintendent Keyser
PTX-264
PTX-265: to establish the fact of phone calls between and among the correction officers
PTX- 268 (Plaintiff to use only 40 photographs of Sullivan County Correctional Facility)
PTX- 275
PTX-276
PTX-282 (to be filed under seal)
PTX- 283: to prove notice (Plaintiff to use only one exhibit of list and records of Officer Tucker's
uses of force)
PTX- 293 (Plaintiff to use only 40 photographs of Sullivan County Correctional Facility)
PTX- 294
PTX- 297
PTX- 398 (Plaintiff to use only one floorplan of Sullivan County Correctional Facility)
PTX-399
PTX- 400 (Plaintiff to use only one death certificate)
PTX-404
PTX- 409 (Plaintiff to use only one map of Sullivan County Correctional Facility)
PTX- 413

3

Judgment on the admission of the following exhibits is reserved:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

PTX- 051: to prove notice, subject to connection that Superintendent Keyser and/or Deputy
Superintendent Burnett
PTX- 103: subjectto connection
PTX- 228: subject to connection
PTX- 252: subject to connection to Sullivan County Correctional Facility
PTX- 253: subject to connection
PTX- 269 (Plaintiff to identify which autopsy photos she plans to introduce)
PTX- 287: depending on Plaintiffs redactions
PTX- 300: subject to connection
Plaintiff proposed many duplicative exhibits. Plaintiffs counsel represented that they would use

only the single, most complete exhibit of (i) Taylor's grievance report (e.g., PTX- 276); (ii) Taylor's
misbehavior report (e.g., PTX- 275); (iii) the list and records of Officer Tucker's uses of force (e.g., PTX283); (iv) the prison floorplan/map ( e.g., PTX- 398) (which will be shown to the jury, but filed under
seal); and (v) Taylor's death certificate (e.g., PTX- 400). Plaintiffs counsel will use only 40 photographs
of the Sullivan County Correctional Facility and identify which photographs of Karl Taylor's autopsy
Plaintiff plans to introduce.
Lastly, Plaintiff sought to exclude the testimony of the C.O. Defendants' expert Dr. Bardey. The
C.O. Defendants shall submit a written proffer as to what they expect to elicit from Dr. Bardey.

SO ORDERED.

Dated: Januan-1,_J::; 2020
New~rk, New York
Chief Judge
BY ECF TO ALL PARTIES

4