Rodriguez v. Commissioner of Social Security

Filing 16

OPINION AND ORDER: re: 10 MOTION for Judgment on the Pleadings filed by Commissioner of Social Security. For the foregoing reasons, the Commissioners motion for judgment on the pleadings is DENIED. Pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 405(g), the case is remanded to the Commissioner for further proceedings consistent with this Opinion and Order. The Clerk of Court is directed to close the motion at Docket Number 10 and to close this case. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge J. Paul Oetken on 9/29/2017) Copies Mailed By Chambers. (ama)

U I E S A E DS RC C U T
NT D T T S I TI T O R
S U H R DS RC O N
O T E N I TI T F EWY R
OK
N R SM N E O
E Y A CB ,

Pi i,
l nf
a tf

1- V 60 (P )
6C -40J O

-v

OI I NA DO D R
PN O N R E

C
OMMSI N RO S C A
I S O E F OI L
S C RT ,
E UI Y
D edn
e na.
f
t

J P U O T E,Dt cJde
. A L E K N irt ug
si
:
Pi i N y Mneopoed g r s, hlne h dnl f o ascr y
l nf e s acb rce n po e caegs e e aoscl eut
a tf r
,
i
l
r i
i
i
d a l y eet. h C m i in o SclScr ymvs ojd mn otela ns
i bi bn i Te o m s e f o a eut oe frug e n h p d g
s it
fs
so r
i
i
t
ei .
Frhraos h f l w h m insdn d
oteesnta o o, e o oi e e.
tl t
t
i
I
.

Bc go n
akr u d
Mneows on nNv me 2 16 ( k N 9“T ” a8. H lsjbws
acb a br o oe b 9 91 D. o ( r )t 0) e a o a
r ,
. t .
.
r t

a a aemng , r nt nersnt ead e n o se asfr ha h nu ne
s cs aae o e a orp e a v n r e in pclt o a et isr c
r i ti
e ti ,
tt
ii
l
a
c may (.a 6 8)Sewsa o i 21 a eecs v asne s m igr m a
o pn. T t 4 0 h al d f n 02f rxe ie becst m fo p n
r
, .
i f
t
s
e n
i
r a d o e d a l y (.a6 6–97 ) A u b o dc r hv ea ie Mneo
et t h i bi. T t 4 86 7
le
r s it r
,
, . n me f o o ae x m d acb
r
ts
n
s c 21 A oghs md apo s oa, h es ra cness h Mneo u e
i e 02 mntoe e c rf s n s e i bod osnuta acb sf r
n
.
i l ei l t r
t
fs
,
,
,
,
.
fo f r ma i adtea mn.( e r a 5 275 248 238 365)
r mi o y g n o ri e s S T t 1 4–7 7–2 8–8 4–6
b
la
h l t e .
Mneo ape fr o ascr y eeti 21 b h apcinwsdn d
acb p id oscl eut bn i n 03 u e p ia o a e e
l
i
i
fs
, t r l t
i.
)
r fr
t
i
r
fe
nt t
(ra8. Seh e t rqe e ad ee e a e ig eo a A m irieL w ug
T t 9 hte a e eus d n rc vd ha n b r n d i s a v a Jde
.
( L ” (ra6–9 Ate e igMneo tsf d bucn na p n n e kes
“ J ) T t 17 ) t h ha n acb ei e ao o iu a i h ne
A . .
.
r ,
ti
t t l i
r
,
bc adis (ra6 –6 Selo pk o ep in n f r us f ef r mag,
ak n h . T t 5 6 ) h a soe f xe ec gl e p o h i o y i
,
p
.
.
s
r i arb
la
w cl t eicpca d o dy aai e (ra6 –2 Seloei etah f r
h he h naat e fr ast t m T t 9 7 ) h a tsf d h e l e
i f r
it
. .
.
s ti
t r a-

1

us rvn h fo c m gowr o aeu r a sadm ni nln- r e p y e .
p p e e r m o i t ok n rg a bs n a t n g oge m m o mn
e t r
n
l
i
i ai
t
l
t
(ra7 )
T t7
. .
I 21 AJ M he F e mn u d h Mneows oe g l fria l y
n 05 L i a r d a r e ta acb a n l i e o d bi
,
c l i
l
t
tib
s it
bn i .l huh h AJ oc dd h Mneo hd ee i p r e s h c a d“ r
eet Atogte L cn ueta acb a sv e ma mn ta r t m e
fs
l
t
r
i t t ee o
ta m i al ma oso h a l yowr h a o oc dd h Mneo hd h
hn i m i it n n e bi t ok el cn ueta acb ate
n l ti ”
r it
,
s
l
t
cpc yo e o m l h w k .w h s/ ad p o ”h iv vs s m eru n
aatt p fr “ g o .. t ais n o in ta no e “ p, o ie
i
r
it r
i
tt
t
t l
i l
t ,
rpi vtptss n rq r s o y ca oacn c w h uev o, o ok sad h
eet e yeak ad eu e ] n ocs n o a i sp i r c wre, nte
ti
i[ l
i l tt t
rs s
r
pbc (ra5–2 Ad easteAJ ontascjb e si s nia n me
u i ” T t 15 ) n bcueh Lfud h uh os xt ni i cn u b s
l.
.
.
t
i
gf t
r
ite a oaeoo yh cn ueta Mneoa n e g l fria l y eet . T
nh nin cn m e oc dd h acbws o l i e o d bi bn i (r
t l
,
l
t
tib
s it
fs
.
a5‒6
t 55 )
.
Aky oc s n yh AJws h “ acb’ st mn cnen g hi es y
e cn u o bte L ata [Mneo ]t e e s oc i ten nt
li
t
s a
t
rn
t i,
p stne nl migf c o[e s m o s r n e i l c d l ”(ra5 )I
ei ec adi i n e e s f h ] y p m a o nr yr i e T t 2 n
rs
t
ft
r
t
e t t e e b.
. .
rah gh cn u o t AJ pcia yee o t emd a o n n
ec nt s oc s n h L se f l rid n h ee c p i s
i i
li , e
i cl l
r
il i o.
D Ce D .h l Ce hd en e n Mneo bu oc amn atei e f
r hn r Cai hn a be se g acb ao ne o h t ht m o
.
:
re
i
t
t
te e ig eo teAJ (ra7–1 D Ce ’ wt nmd ao n n oc dd h
h ha n b r h L T t 07) r hn s rt e c p i cn ueta
r
fe
. .
. .
ie
il i o
l
t
Mneo’s m o swu f qe l adinia li e e w h ea l yowr ad
acb s y p m o dr un y n s i cn yn r r i h bi t ok n
t
l e t
g f t t f e t r it
,
h d goe a u b orsiin o Mneo a l yoi s n mv ad ocn a
ei nsd n me fert s n acb’ bi t s,t d oe n cne r e
a
r
tco
s it
t a,
,
tt
itewrp c (ra375 ) D Ce n e ta i h o n n Mneows nb t
nh ok ae T t 5–8 r hn o d h, ni p i , acb a ua eo
l . .
. .
t
t
s io
l
py cl c r o te e ad oa u wr we adwu rq rrs b as n f qe
hs a y a y u h d mns f f l ok ek n o d eu ee r k adr un
il r t
l
,
l
i t e
e t
dy o deol eus (ra376 )TeAJgv D Ce’ o n nlt w g ”
as f ut f r-p T t 5–0 h L ae r hns p i “te e h
f
a
. .
.
.
i o il i t
bcuei cn u os a n spo ei teeod ad eas “ r Ce hs rv e
eas h oc s n “r o upr d n h rcr ” n bcue D hn a po dd
s li
e t
t
,
.
i
nt a mnrcrs o uprh f d g ”(ra5 )
or t e eodt spo i i i s T t 4
e
t
t s n n.
. .

2

D Tdf D H w dTdfi a sco gtwo x m e Mneo n 04 (r
r eo: r o a eo s pyh o s h ea i d acb i 21
.
f .
r
f
li
n
. T
.
a24) r Tdf cn ueta Mneowsn r a n wlw hte adwu hv a
t 8. D eo oc dd h acb a o et g e i o r n o d ae
.
f l
t
t li
l t hs
l
h di e eigw ht si tewrp c (ra27 D Tdf n etateeus f
a t m da n i s e n h ok ae T t 8 ) r eo o d h hrs t o
r
l
t rs
l . .
. .
f t
t
l
h ea ia o w e“ostn w h sc ai df uista i cne w h e py c
i x m t n e cn s t i pyht c ii le”h, n oc t i h hs a
s
ni
r
ie t
ir fct
t
r t r il
i us wu “ t f e w h acb s a l yo uc oi tewrp c o a a y a s
s e o di e e [ i [Mneo] bi t fnin n h ok ae n dl bs.
s , l nr r ] t
’ it
t
l
i
i”
(d TeAJ aeD Tdfs p in p tlw g ” eas h “pe s o aeee
I ) h L gv r eo’o n “ai e h bcue e apa t hv rid
.
.
f i o ra i t
r
l
s e o [Mneossb c v c m a trg d g e py c a lis (ra5 )
ol n acb’ u eie o pi sea i h hs a bie” T t 3
ly
] jt
ln
r n r i l it .
. .
D Ti D Ib Ti x m e Mneoi 21 ad se etase a a m d
r e : r qa e ea i d acb n 04 n a s d h h hd “l
. l
. ll
n
,
ss
t
i
rsiin o po ne s n n adw k g b ws oi “ u dt s ”(ra219 )
ert fr r ogdt d g n a i ” u a n na t ir s T t 9–2
tco
l
ai
ln t
t c e s e. .
.
TeAJ aeD Ti s p ins nia w g , bcue h ea ia o ws hruh
h L gv r e ’ o n “ g f n e h” eas “ s x m t n a toog
. l
i o i ic t i t
i
ni
adee e o ym dert n w c wu n p vn[Mneofo p fr ig g
n rva d n i rsii s h h o d o r e
l l l tco , i
l t e t acb]r m e o m l h
r
nit
wr o a u a e bs. (ra5 )
ok n ssi d a s
tn
i” T t 4
. .
Mneo qe e rv w fh AJ dcin w cteSclScr yApa
acb reus d e e ote L s e s , h h h o a eut pe s
t
i
’ io i
i
i
l
Cuc dn d (ra1 T s u f l wd A ete oen e mvd ojd mn ote
onl e e T t. h s t o o e f rh gv mn oe frug e n h
i i. . ) i i l
. t
r
t
t
p a ns Mneoi n fe n pot n r fad h Cu te fr de etem in
l d g acb d o i a opsi b e nte or h eo e md h o o
ei ,
d tl
i o i,
t r e
t
uopsd ( k N 1 )
npoe D. o 3 1
. t . .
I
I
.

Sa dr o Rv w
t n ad f e e
i
“ dt ccu my ea dteC m i in ’ d e m a otaal mni n
Airt or a s s eh o m s e s e r i t n h ci a s o
si
t
ti
so r
t ni
t a t t

d a e o yfh fc af d g a n spo e b ‘us nae dne oite e s n
i b d n itea u i i s r o upr d ysb a i v ec rfh dci
sl l
tl nn e t
t
t tl i
’
io
i bsd neae o”Sa v Ca r 21F d 2 11 2 C. 00 “ b a i
s ae olg r r h w. h e, 2 . 16 3 (d i 20) S s na
l r.
t
3
,
r
. u t tl
e dnesmrta a m e c tl I mas uhe vne dne s raoa em d
v eci ‘o hn e s nl. t ensc r ea v ec a aesnb i
i
e
r i ia
l t i
l n

1

Mne fe aee w h h Cu ( k N 1)ad pe ei p snt n
acboi d lt i te or D. o 4 n apa d n e o aa
l
tr t
t t . ,
r
r
o lru e h d n u 1 21 T Cu tks o i o confr upss f e d g
r ag mn e o J y 9 07 h or ae b h n acu o proe o dc i
a
t l
l ,
. e
t
t t
t
in
t s m in
h oo
i t .
3

m hacpa aeu e o upra oc s n ” Shav A e 14F d 9 51 2 C.
i t ce s dqa t spo cn u o ’ ca . pl 3 . 46 0 (d i
g
t
t
t
li .
l
f,
3
,
r
19) qo n R hrsn.Pr e, 0 US3941 17) A or my osbi ti
98(u igi ado v ea s 42 .. 8 0 (91. cu a n ust et
t
c
l
,
)
t
t tu s
jd mnfrh C m i in ’ “vnft m hjsf b hvrahd df e rs t
ug e ote o m s eseeii i t ui a y aeece ai e n eu
t
so r
g ti l
fr t l
uo a e oo e e. DJss.A re 72FSp 2 6363 SDNY 01(u ig
pn d nv rv w eeu v s u 6 . up d 7 8 (.... 1) qo n
i ”
t ,
.
,
2
t
Jns. uia 99F d 75 (dC. 91.
oe vS l n 4 . 5 9 2 i 19)
lv ,
2 ,
r
)
Cusms a ofod r s pi i s se as itd ”Ro l vIR. 2 F d,
or u l a r po el nf “pcl oc ue u o ... , 8 . 6
t
t s f
a tf
i li .
to
S
3
8 2 C. 94 We al nf poed po ete orso dra h spoig ae
(d i 19) hn pi i rces r s, h cu hu “ d i upr n pp s
r
.
a tf
t l e s
t
r
l e l, n.. n rr te t r stetogsag mn tate sge. Bro v
i rl ad. i ep t h m oa eh s ne ru e s h hy ugs” ugs.
b ay
t e
i
r
t
t t
t
Hp n , 4F d 8 70 2 C. 94(t g k br v B t S.C 98F d 2 30
ok s 1 . 77 9 (d i 19)ci Mi eg. ai . o 8 . 37 3
i
3
,
r
in i n
lc S .,
2 ,
(dC. 93.“ vn h e m in ojd mn otela nss npoe teCu
2 i 19) Ee we a o o frug e n h p d gi uopsd h or
r
)
r
t
t
ei
,
t
msslrv wh e i rcr ad nu tatemv g a ys nt d o ug e a a
u tle e te nr eod n esr h h o n p ti e iet jd mn s
ti i
te
e t
i
r
tl
t
mt ol w ”Gaa v C m ’ o ScSc,N 1 C . 4 21 W 1343a*
ae fa. rh m. o m f o e
tr
r
. . o 6 i 12 07 L 229 t 1
.
v ,
,
(.... M . 121)
EDNY a 3 07
r ,
.
I . D cs o
I
I i uin
s s
A Mneos po e l nfad a n f e aopsin r f h Cu fcss
s acbi a r s pi i n hs o i dn pot b e te or oue
a tf
tl
i o i,
t
3t .
otetogsag mni h fvr rsn d yhrcr Se ugs 1 F d 70Te
nh s ne ru e n e ao p e e bteeod e Bro, 4 . a 9 h
r
t
t
r
e t
.
Cu ie i et oi us n h poed g b o: 1teAJ o n ni n ad s
or dnf s w s ei te rce ns e w()h L s p i d o dr s
t ti
s
i
l
’ io d t e
Mneo’ ci tah f r-p p vn d efo m ni n ao ad 2teAJ
acb sl m h e l eus r e e h r m a t n g jb n ()h Ls
a
t ra
e t r
i ai
,
’
o n n mrp l d cu ete p in f acb’ t a npy c n
p i i poe yi on d h o n o Mneo r t ghsi .
io
r s t
io
s ei
ia
Fs teAJs p in oue a msec s e o Mneo’ py c cn t nt
it h L’ o n fcssl o x u v y nacb s hs a odi a
r,
io
t lil
i l io
tei e f e v iu dc rit b flt ad sMneo’cn aci : h h
ht m o h a os o o vi, u as o dr sacb s e r l mta e
r r
t ss t i
e
tl a
t r
dbit gl eus rvn h fo h d g o n jb Dr gh ha n b o te L
e la n f r-p p e e r m o i d w ao u nte e ig e r h AJ
iti a
e t r
ln
. i
r
fe
,
Mneo ee e yt setatel e-p w e e b gs os c t cn s n
acb rpa d s e d h hf r us e h i e b a eo ost t
tl rs
t
a
r r g t tl
ie
e p y e.( ee. T a 7 ( h ’ wyhye m g fo m jb . I a b
m o mn S ,. , rt 7“ a s htel e or m yo .. cne
l
t e g .
Tt
t
.
4

fnin a op o dy ad h nm f r -p c m ] ... Y teAJ s p in
uc oa cu e f as nte ] yl e us o e ..”) e h L ’ o n
t l
l
[
a
[
) t
io
mn osl e us ny nen a ig hnt ec bs (nd m ss D Ce’ o n n
e inf r -p o oci ps n wei ds ie ad s i e)r hn p i .
t
a
l
s
r
i s
.
s io
(ra5 )
T t4
. .
Is a o d cs n Mneo a l yom ni cn nos m omn ,h AJ
n ed fi u ig acb’ bi t a t n o iuu e p ye te Ls
t
s s
s it
ia
t
l
t
’
o n n oue p m i o h w Mneo pe e ase f md aea ia o s (e
p i fcss r al n o acb apa dt pci e c x m t n. Se
io
i ry
r
ic i l
ni
e. T a5 ( e in gh, u n a 03 o o vi Mneo h wdgo gn ast
. , r t 3 mn o nta dr g 21 dc rit acb so e “ d ee lt e
g .
t i
t i
t s,
o
r a
o ha h w h ow g g n ro , owans n fiu n fv, od x c eo rne
f et i n e h a ols n eke, oa ge oee go ee i t e c
l, t
it i
s
s
t ,
r
rs l a ,
ads b t d uu ai t s) Ide teAJ aeh ms w g t D Ti o n n
ni a eo o sa c vi ”) ned h L gvte o e h o r e’ p i ,
l
l t ie .
,
t it
. ls i o
w c fcssl o ec s e o h w Mneo rsn dt n viad o a si ul
h h oue a ms x u v y n o acb p e e aoeit n cni vta y
i
t lil
e t
s
tn r l
n fr ad o bc w d ok gid g ( e ra 209 )TeAJ s p in n
o o w -r ak a - o n f i s S T t 9–2 h L ’ o n ,
r
r l i n n. e .
.
ioi
d cs n D Ti f d g l eie oue fr x m eo h w Mneo nee n h p
i u ig r e’ i i s i w fcss o ea p, n o acb “edd o e
s s
. ls n n , k s
,
l
l
cag g ote x mgt g n fte x ma ead a a eoier m h ca w hu
hn n frh ea, ei o o h ea tb, n ws b t r f o te h r i o
i
tn / f
l
l
s
i t t
df u y” n cn ne b ds i nteodin f es n h s i b ad o t (ra
ii l , ad o ius y ec b gh c i o o h p e i , ms nj n. T t
fct
t
ri
nt
r i, pl ,
is .
5–4 TeAJ apa t hv cn ue w huep nin h Mneo’aeu e
35 ) h L pe s o ae oc dd i o x aa o ta acb s dqa
.
r
l , t t l t , t
t
py c sae u n oe o o vicn a c h ci tah p id f r-pp vn
hs a hp dr g n dc rit o rdt e l m h e e o cl eusr e
il
i
t s
t is r a
t r r i a
e t
h fo cn s n ywr n
e r m ost t ok g
r
i el
i.
Scn teAJ mrp l d cu ete p in fD Ce Mneo t a n
eod h L poe yi on d h o n o r hn acb’ r t g
,
i
r s t
io
.
,
s ei
hn a nscl eut e r i t n L r on btet a n
i
i
i t ni , s e
rt
py c n2 We mk go ascr yd e m a os AJ a bud yh “eig
hsi .
ia

2

Teeods oe i l c a o we e D Cei Mneo p m y a
hrcri n nr yl r n h h r hns acb’ r a c e
t te e
tr .
si r r
py c n n h fr asne H wv, h r ea rg a o de n rq rtera n
hsi i te o m es o ee tee vn eut n os o eu eht t g
ia
l
.
r
l t li
t i
ei
py c n o e p m y a py c n Is a “ eig ore i d ie a“a]
hsi t b a r a c e hsi . n ed t a n su ” s e nds [n
ia
i r r
ia
t , rt
c
f
acp b md asu ewo rv e..md at a mn o ea a o adwo a o hs
ce a e e c or h po ds. e c r t e r v uin n h hs r a
tl
il c
i
il e
t
lt
,
hda og nt a mnr a os pw h te ae ] 2 CFR§ 0 12( () T s
a n no gr t e et nh i [ pin. 0 ... 44 57a 2 h
,
i e
t li i t h t t”
.
) . i
rq r mni gn a y as e we te ae sete o o “i arqec cn s n
eu e e s ee l siid hn h pin es h dc r w h f uny ost t
i
t
rl tf
t t
t
t
e
ie
w h ce e md ap ccfrhtp ot a mnad r v uin eu e frte
i acp d e c r t e ote ye fr t e n oea a o rq rd o[ ]
t
t
i l ai
e
t /
lt
i
h
md acn t n ] I Mneoei etase a D Ce ao oc amn (ra
e c odi [ ” d acbtsf d h h s w r hn bu ne o h T t
i l io . .
ti
t
.
t
t .
7–1 w c sf cs o mk h m t a n py c n
07) h h uiet aei ar t g hsi .
, i
f
ei
ia
5

py c n u. Ks e v C v ,N 1 C . 2121 W 6701a * (....O.
hsi r e e lr. oi
ia l” s
l n o 4 i 80 05 L 431 t 4 SDNY c
.
v
,
,
t
2 21) Te u mna s h “]e p in f ci a ’t a n py c n s o h
7 05. hr e ad eta [ h o n oal mnsr t g hsi at te
,
l
t
tt
io
a t ei
ia
n u ad eet ote ma mni g e ‘o r l gw g ’ o og stiwl
a r n sv iy f hi p r e si n cn oi e h sln ai‘ e te
r
i t v
t ln i t
sl
spo e b md a yce a el iaadao tr d goitcn usadso
upr d y e c l acp b c n l nlbr oyi nsceh qe nin
t
il
tl ic
a
a t
i
t
s t
icn s n w h ho esb a i e dnente csrcr ’ Bre v A re 57
nost t i tet r us na v eci [ ] aeeod ” ugs . s u , 3
ie t
h
t tl i
h
.
F d 1 18 2 C. 08 (t a oi o g a (u ig 0CFR§ 0 12()2;e
. 17 2 (d i 20) ae t n n r i l qo n 2 ... 44 57d ) se
3
,
r
l ri
i n) t
.
()
a o re - one v Brhr 35F d 9160 (dC. 03(o igh a AJ r d
l Gen Yugr. ana, 3 . 9 0–7 2 i 20) h d ta n L e e
s
t
3 ,
r
ln t
r
i n g ig t a n py c n d go s fi o y g cn oigw g ) Teesn o
n o i nar t g hsi ’ i ns ofr ma i o r l
t v
ei
ias a i
b
l a t l n e h. h rao fr
it
t s u itat a n py c n o eau qe eseieo h md ae dneta
h r es h r t g hsi s f r “n u prpc vt te e c v ec h
i l
t ei
ia f
i
t
il i
” t
cnoo e w e e bie fo teeod 2 CFR§ 0 12( ()
an t ri b o a dr m hrcr 0 ... 44 57 )2
t h s
tn
.
.
c .
H e h AJ u m i d cu e D Ce’ o n n— e n md a o n n
e, e Ls m al i on d r hn p i t o y e c p i
rt
ry s t .
s io h l
il i o
d cs ntesu of r us—n h bs ta D Ce’ cn u os a n spo ei
i u ighi e fl e p ote a s h r hn oc s n “ e o upr d n
s s
s
ai t .
s li
r t
t
teeod bcue D Ce hs rv e nt a mnrcrs o uprh f d g ”(r
hrcr” eas “ r hn a po dd or t e eodt spo i i i s T
,
.
i
e
t
t s n n.
.
a5 )H wv ,“] od t oeieh o n n fht a n py c n[ eScn
t 4 o ee [ n re o v r te p i oter t g hsi ,t eod
.
r i
r
rd
io
ei
ia h
C c t a h d h teAJ msepcl cn d,n rl : 1terqe l ln h
i u hs e ta h L u x it os e i e a a()hf un y eg,
ri ] l t
t li y i r t i
e t, t
n u, n e e ot a mn ()h a on o md ae dne upr nte p in()
a r ad x n fr t e ; 2te mu f e c v ec spoigh o n ; 3
te
tt e
t
t
il i
t
io
te ostny fh o n nw h hr m n gmd ae dnead 4 we ete
h cn s c ote p i i tee a i e c v ec n () h h h
ie
io t
in
il i
;
tr
py c ns se as ”Sin.A re 78F d 0 48 2 C. 03 TeAJ o n n
hsi i a pclt e a v s u, 0 . 49 1 (d i 21) h L s p i
ia
ii. l
t
3
,
r
.
’ io
de n d s “a u t po d‘odesn fr oc digh o n n f ci a ’
os o o o Flr o rv e go raos o n r i nte p i oal mn s
t
. i e
i
’
t et
io
a t
t a n py c ns gon fre ad Ao s.Brhr, 03 W 2936 a*
r t g hsi i a rud or mn ” rn v ana 20 L 2517 t 5
ei
ia
.
i
t
,
l
f,
3
,
r
) nr l
(....Dc1 20) qo n Se v A e 17F d 2 13 2 C. 99 ( t n
SDNY e 5 03(u ig nl. pl 7 . 18 3 (d i 19) i e a
. ,
t
qot nm k o ie)
u a o a s mtd
ti
r
t .

6

Mroe ee i D Ce s p ineu e mr croo t n“n L cnor e
o v, vn f r hn o n rq rd o o bri , a AJ an e c
e r
.
’ io
i
e r ao
t jt
ara n py c n d go sw hufsae p nt fl n c a gpi te
t t g hsi ’ i ns i o itt m igoi ayl r as n h
ei
ia s a i t tr t t
l
e
l
3 ,
r
. f
t
a m irieeod” oa.C lhn 18F d 27 (dC. 99 “ teAJs o
d i s a vrcr. Rs v a aa , 6 . 7 9 2 i 19) I h Li n
nt t
a eo u yrd ara n py c n o n n eastemd arcrsr m h py c n
b t f l c i t t g hsi ’ p i bcueh e c eodfo te hsi
l
l e t ei
ia s i o
il
ia
a ic m e o d n cni d ae spo frh o n n ep se teAJs b g e
r no pt r o o o a ei d upr ote p i s xr sd h Li o ia d
e
le
t t n tl
t
io
e ,
l t
t rqe sc m s g no minr m hpy c n Cre eEg hrv A re 67F
oeus uh i i ifr a o fo t hsi . o a - n ea . s u , 8 .
t
sn
t
e ia” r l
l t t
Sp 2 3648 SDNY21) H eaa ,t pe s h teAJ i n d s
up d 9 2 (.... 00 e, g n iapa ta h L d o o o
.
,
. r
i
r t
d t
.
Tel s e fh po e itate w o n n o w cteAJd r y hs
hf pi ot s rb ms h ht o p i s n h h h L i e — oe
i d
i
l
t
io
i
d lt
b D.Ti n Tdf rs tdr m n t m cnua v vi, e o md n h s m dy
y r e ad eo
s l
f—eue fo oe i e os tieit p fr e ote a e a
l
lt
ss r
,
i cneinw h Mneo scl eut apcin H wv,“ cnuig hsin
n onc o i acb’ o ascr y p ia o o ee a os t py c ’
t
t
s i
i
l t .
r
ln
i as
o n n orprso d eiel me w g .. eas ‘os tie x m a o e
p i s reo hu b g ni i d e h . bcue cnua v ea sr f n
io
t l
v
t
it
lt
et
b e a gn a y e o mdw hu bn i orv w fl mn smd ahtr ada
r f r ee l p fr e i o eet r e e oci a ’ e c i oy n t
i, e rl r
t t f
i
a t
il s
,
bs o yie g ms otel mn o aig dy ”Cu vS l a , 1 F d, 3 2
e, n g al pe fh ci a n s l a ’ rz. ui n 92 . 81 (d
t l v i
a t
ne .
lv
2
C. 90 (tin mtd(u ig o e v B wn 70F Sp 10 11 (....
i 19) ca o o ie) qo n Tr s. o e , 0 . up 36 32 SDNY
r
it
t
t
r
.
,
18) seloKs e 21 W 6701a* (Cu ’ a mnins aiu r r ea
98) e a
;
s e lr 05 L 431 t 4 “rz s d o t i p t l l e vn
s ,
,
[
]
io
rc a y l t
we al mn . hs o e as h a bt ta o e .(t n qot nm k ad
hn ci a .. a s m dyta r ee hnt r ”i e a u a o a s n
a t
t e tr
h s n r l ti
r
b ce o ie) B ecs v ye igo h wacb p sn d n s g dy h
r k s mtd) y xe ie r y
a t t .
s l l n n o Mneo r e e o ai l a te
e t
ne ,
AJ o n nmy ae m s d hfrsfr ht e
L s p i a hv i e te o toter s
’ io
s
e
e.
Tkn oe e teAJr d yaig o os e Mneo ci s f e la n
aetg h , h Le e b fl t cn d acb’ l m o dbit g
tr
r
in
ir
s a
iti
f r us ni poe yicu ig et a n py c ns p in TeCu de n h d
l e p ad mrp l d on n h r t g hsi ’ o n . h or os o o
ar s t
r ei
ia
io
t
t l
ta Mneosia e otases nt d o o ascr y eet TeCu h d o y
h acbi d b d rh hi e iet scl eut bn i. h or o s n
t
sl
t
tl
i
i
fs
t l l
tate ae hu b r mnet teC m i in fr u h poed gtaf l cn d
h h cs so d ee add o h o m s e ofr e rce ns h u y os e
t
l
so r
tr
i
tl
ir

7

tef co Mneo f r us n a in hpoe w g t te a osmd ao n n o
h e e f acb’ l e pad s g terp e h o h v iu e c p i s f
ft
s as
r it
r
il i o
h dc r
e o o.
r ts
I.
V

Cn u o
oc s n
li
Frhfrg n raos teC m i in ’ m in ojd mn ote la nss
ote o o gesn h o m s es o o frug e n h p d gi
ei
,
so r t
t
ei

D NE . Prunt 4 USC§ 0() hcs ir mnet teC m i in fr u h
E I D u a o 2 ... 45g teae se addo h o m s e ofr e
s t
,
so r
tr
poed g cn s n w h h O n n n Od. TeC r oCu i d e et c ste
rce ns ost t i t s p i ad re
i
ie t i i o
r h l k for s i c d ol eh
e
t rt
o
m intDce N me 1 ad oc st s ae
o o a ok u b 0 nt l eh cs
t
t
r
o i
.
S O DRD
O R E E.
D e Sp me 2 21
a d e e b 9 07
t: t r ,
N wYr N wYr
e ok e ok
,
__________________
__________________
JP U O T E
. AL EKN
UtdStsDt cJde
ne t e irt ug
i
a
si

C P MI E T P O EP R YB C AM E S
O Y AL D O R S A T Y H B R

8