Pastor et al v. Alice Cleaners Inc. et al

Filing 52

OPINION AND ORDER: For the foregoing reasons, the Court awards Pastor $57.633.40 in damages and attorneys' fees and costs against Alice Cleaners and Choi pursuant to NYLL, as follows: 1. $14,554.22 in unpaid overtime compensation; 2. $14,554.22 in liquidated damages; 3. $10,000 in statutory penalties for wage statement and wage notice violations; 4. Pre-judgment interest of $4,367.46, calculated using a principal of $14,554.22 at an interest rate of nine percent per year from July 23, 2014 to the date of entry of judgment; and 5. $13,757.50 in attorneys' fees and $400 in costs. The Clerk is directed to enter judgment for the plaintiff consistent with this Opinion. (Signed by Magistrate Judge James L. Cott on 11/21/2017) (kgo)

UN T DS A E DS R C C R
I E T T S I T I T OU T
S TH RN D S R C O N
OU E
I T I T F EWY R
O K
---------------------X
----------------------------------------J S LU SP S O,
OE I AT R
:
:
Pan i,
litf
f
:
:
-v
:
:
A I EC E E S IN.e a ,
L C L AN R , C t l
, .
:
:
Df n at
ee d ns
.
:
---------------------X
-----------------------------------------

U D SDNY
SC D Y
USDC S N
DC ET
O UM N
DOCUMENT
E E T O I A L FILED
L C R NC L Y I E
ELECTRONICALLY FL D
D C: ________
O # _________
DOC #: _________________
D T FL D__2_07_
A E I E: _/1_1 __
DATE FILED: ______________
1__2 _
1_/ __

O IN
P ION AND ORD
ER
1 - V 7 6 ( L)
6C -2 4 J C

J
AM SL CO T U ie S ae M gsr t J d e
E .
T, nt d t t s ait ae u g.
O S pem e 1,2 1, h C ut o d ce ab n h rai ti w g -n n et br 8 0 7t e o r c n ut d e c t l n h a e a d
i
s
h u cs a d o n df n at A c Ce nr I c di gb sns a A c Dy
o r ae n f u d ee d ns l e l a es n, on u es s l e r
i
, .
i
i
Ce nn,a dC a C olal t pan f Js Li Pso,bt eev d e so
l ai g n h n hii be o litf oe u atr u rsr e dc i n
i
s
i
a t d a e. Fr h r ao s efrhbl wt eC ut wrsPso $ 76 34
s o am gs o t e es n st ot eo , h o ra ad atr 5. 3. 0
i d a e u dr N wYr L brL w“ Y L” c p s d f 1, 5. 2i
n am gs n e e o k a o a (N L ) omr e o$ 45 42 n
,
i
u pi o et e om e sto;$ 45 42 i lqi ae d a e $ 00 0 n
n ad vr
im c p na n 1, 5. 2 ni udt d am gs 1, 0 i
i
;
sauoyp nl e fr w g saem n a d w g nt evoa o s pe u gm n
tttr e ais o a e tt et n a e o c ilt n r- d et
t
i
i ;
j
itrso $, 6. 6 $ 37 75 i a o n y fe a d$0 i css
neetf 43 74; 1, 5. 0 n t r es es n 4 0 n ot
t
’ ;
.
I
.

Bc go n
a kr u d
Pso bo gt h ato t rc vru pi mn um w gs o et e
atr r u h ti c n o eo e n ad iim
s i
a e vr
,
im

w gslqi ae d a e itrs a da o n y fe a d ot u dr h Fi
a e i udt d am gs neet n t r es es n css n e t e a
,
,
,
t
’
r
L brSa drsAt“ L A,2 USC § 2 1e sq a d Y L, §1 0a d6 0
a o t n ad c( F S ” 9 ... § 0 t e. n N L § 9 n 5
)
,
e sq foml eCe nr a dC o C pan dt dS pem e 1,2 1, Dt
t e. r A c l a es n hi omlit ae et br 6 0 6 k
,
i
.
,
.

1

o wn
l
e c r l n et br 8 0 7 t e o rf u d ht
i
N 1 ¶1.1 Flo i gab n ht ao S pem e 1,2 1 , h C ut o n t a
o, 1
.
A c Ce nr a dC o wr lal t Pso a dd et d h pr e t m k ps
l e l a es n hi eei be o atr n i ce t e at s o a e ot
i
r
i
t a s bm so sih e pc t d a e T a Ta srp( T ” a 1 2 2 O
r l u i i n w rs et o am gs r l r nc t“ r) t 0. n
i
s
t
. i
i
.
S pem e 2,2 1,Pso f e aps - il m oa d ,l Ps - il a d n
et br 5 0 7 atri d ott a emr n umP otT a, n o
l
r
.
r
Ot br6 2 1,df n at f e a el m oa d , Dt N 5, ai gn
co e , 0 7 ee d nsi d r py emr n um k o 1t kn o
l
. .
psi na t Pso scl ua o s e adn d a e o a o ny fe a d ot.
o to s o atr a lt n r gri g am gs r t r es es n css
i
’
c i
t
’
T e o o i gi dns f atr gri gi biyae e et dhr fr h
h fl wn fni g ofc e adn lait r r p ae ee o t e
l
l
p r oe fpoii gncsay ot xi t eass eto d a e:
ups o r vdn eesr c net n h sesm n f am gs3
1
.

Pso wr e a A c Ce nr fom N v br7 2 1 t Ar 7
atr o k d t l e l a es r
i
o em e , 0 1 o p l ,
i
2 1. T a 1 3 0.
07 r t 0–4
.

2
.

Pso g nrly wr e fom73 a . o43 p . M n a t r u h
atr e ea
l ok d r
: 0 .mt : 0 .m o d y ho g
F i a a d80 a . o43 p . aud y fra oa o5. h us
r d y n : 0 .mt : 0 .mSt r a , o ttl f 35 o r
pr we. T a 1 5
e e k r t 0.
.

3
.

Fr h wr,Pso wspi a wel slr i cs. Fom
o ti o k atr a ad
s
e ky aay n a h r
N v br2 1 t r u h M y2 1, atr wel slr ws$ 5,
o em e 0 1 ho g a 0 2Pso s e ky aay a 5 0
’

1A h d e n at
ti df d n
r
e
,

M h e S k a y hsnta p ae i t e ae
i al a hl , a o p er d n h cs
c
s
.

2A h u h hr i n rcr o e hr a yh vn odr d h ta srp a dt s
l o g t ee s o eod f i e pr ai g r ee t e r nc t n ii
t
t
t
i

nt n h dc e Pso de m k t oia o s o h ta srp i h p pr
o o t e o kt atr os a e w c t n t t e r nc t n i a es
,
ti
i
s
.
Ps - il M oa d ,dt dS p 2,2 1, Dt N 5 ( P Ps T a ) a 1 6
ott a emr n um ae et 5 0 7 k o 0“l ot r l, t , .
r
.
. .
.
-i ”
I a y v n t eC ut r ee t e r nc pfrt o n ei wa d ie t i a
n n e et h o r odr d h ta sr t o is w r ve n c s ot s
,
i
t
ncsay ho g otti Oii na d Odr
eesr t r u h u h pno n r e.
s

3T eC u wlnt eo ni fni g ofc a d o cu o s f a i a y ea
h o r i o rc utt i dns f at n c n s n ol w n n dti
t l
s
li
l

hr Fra u e rc a o, e T a 1 1 1.
ee o fl r e tt nse r t 0 – 0
.
l
i i
.
2

fomJ n 2 1 t r u h M y2 1,t ws$ 8,a d r J n 2 1
r
u e 0 2 ho g a 0 3i a 5 0 n fom u e 0 3
ut t e n o h t n r i ws$ 0.T a 1 6
nl h e d f i e ue t a 6 0 r t 0.
i
s
,
.
4
.

E eyy a d rn t e wne m nh o J n ay F b ur,a d
vr er u g h itr ot s f a ur, er ay n
, i
Mr h Pso wr e fv d y a we rt e t a sx a dh wel
ac, atr o k di e as e k ahr h n i , n i e ky
s
slr d rn t oe m nh ws 1 0 es h nh pe ai gwel
aay u g hs ot s a $ 0 ls t a i r vi n e ky
i
s
l
slr d rn t en nitr m nh .T 1 6 0.
aay u g h o- ne ot s r 0 – 7
i
w
.

5
.

Pso to pi hld y o t eF ut o Jl,L br D y Vtr n
atr o k ad o as n h o rh f uy a o a, eea s
i
D y T a kgvn,C r tms a d N wY a s D y T a 1 7
a, h n sii g h s a n e er a . r t 0.
i
,
’
.

6
.

A e Pso f e h c pani ti l w u o A g s 1,2 1,h
f r atri d i omlit n h a si n u ut 6 0 6 i
t
l
s
s
t
s
sh dl c a g d u h hth w ud e v wr er e bt e n23
ce ue h n e s c t a e ol l a e o k a ir e we : 0
l ,
p .a d30 p .Dt N 4.
.m n : 0 .m k o 9
. .

7
.

A c Ce nr a dC o ddntpoi ePso w ha y w g nt e
l e l a es n hi i o r vd atr i n a e o cs
i
t
i ,
p y t b o w te rcr s ht oml w h N L fom N v br
a sus r r t n eod t a c p i
,
i
y t YL r
o em e
o 2 1 ut 2 1. T a 1 8
f 0 1 nl 0 5 r t 0.
i
.

8
.

Pso wsnt e ua y e u e t ke ta k fh t e n r ws i
atr a o r glr r qi d o e p rc o i im o a h
l
r
s
,
s
t e rc e b A c Ce nr o C o i auio a d o s t n
im ta k d yl e l a es r hi n n rm n c n set
i
f
i
m n e T e df n at ddntpoi ea y vd ne ht hyh d
a nr h ee d ns i o r vd n ei e c t a t e a
.
c n u e w h a y n i cui g w h o ne o w h h N wYr o
o sl d i
t
t n o e n dn i c u sl r i t e e o k r
, l
t
t
f drl D pr et o L br o rle o a ya v e f o ne
e ea e atm ns f a o r e d n n di o c u sl
,
i
c
r gri g hi w g pat e.T a 1 9 1.
e adn t e a e rc cs r t 0 – 0
r
i
.

3

I
I
.

D ae
am g s
Pso se s$ 55 88 i d a e frupi o et e $ 55 88 i
atr e k 5, 1. 3 n am gs o n ad vr , 5, 1. 3 n
im

lqi ae d a e $ 00 0 oafr w g nt ea d w g saem n voa o s
i udt d am gs 1, 0 ttl o a e o c n a e tt et ilt n
,
i
i ,
a dpej d et neet P PsT a a 6
n r -u gm nitrs l ot r l t .
. .
-i
Wie pan f m ynt eo e u drbt t eF S a d N L fr h
h “litf a o rc vr n e oh h L A n
l
is
Y L ote
s e nuyc ut a o pan f t rc vru dr h saue htpoi e fr
am ij r, o rs l w litf o eo e n e t e ttt t a r vds o
l
is
t egets rle”N v Bt-amFo SrsI c, N 1- V 7 7 ( L ) J F
h r aet e f i . a Y
i.
o d ev n
. . o 3 -2 4 A C( C)
. C
,
2 1 W 3 9 8,a * (. .NY J n 2,2 1) sea oeg Ml o a o v L
0 6 L 6 6 1 t 1 S D .. a. 7 0 6 e l ,.. ad n d . a
;
s
,
N e aR p, n
uv am aI c N 1- V 8 9 ( L) J C 2 1 W 1 6 3 1 a * (. .NY
., o 0 -1 5 L S( L ) 0 2 L 6 9 4, t 5 S D ..
. C
,
Mr 2,2 1), d p db , Odr dt dA g 9 2 1, Dt N 2. Bc ue Y L
a 6 0 5 a ot y r e ae u. , 0 2 k o 0 ea s N L
.
e
,
. .
a o s o getr r q a rc vr t a t eF S a a rl v n t e d rn
l w fr r ae o e ul eo ey h n h L A t l ee atims u g
l
l
i
Pso s e uea A c Ce nr, h C ut wla py Y L fra d a e
atr t n r t l e l a es t e o r i pl N L o l am gs
’
i
l
l
cl ua o s
a lt n 4
c i .

4A h u h h c pan a e e v lt n ot e mn um w g po s n ot e
l o g t e omlit l g d i a o s f h iim
t
l
o i
a e rv i s f h
io

F S a d N L,a t a Pso o ee n ei e c t a h m d ls t a t e
L A n Y L t r l atr f r d o vd ne ht e a e es h n h
i,
f
mn um w g r qie,a dh ps t a s bm so se sd a e ol fr
iim
a e e u d n i ot- il u i i n e k am gs ny o
r
s
r
s
o et e w d P Ps- ila 6 Pso s e ua h u y ae ho g oth
vr
im o e. l otT a t . atr r glr o r rt t r u h u i
.
r
’
l
s
eml ym n wsa w y hg e t a t ea p c be mn umh u y w g rt
po et a l as i hr h n h pl al iim
i
o r a e ae
l
.
C p r a p ni a a h d o h Oii na d Odr( atr r glrh u y ae
om ae p e dx t c e t ti pno n r e Pso s e ua o r rt)
t
s
’
l
w h N wYr Sae D pr et fL br L brSa s c H tr ot e H u y
i
t e o k tt e atm n o a o a o tt t s i oy f h o r
,
ii, s
l
Mn um W g h p/ a o n. o/tt iim _ a e h ( o ry w gs
iim
a e t s/ br yg v as n um w g stm h u
, t :l .
s /m
.
l ae
d rn a p c bepro s a gn fom$. 5 n2 1 t $. 0ut Dc br3,
u g pl al e d r ni g r
i
i
i
72 i 0 1 o 97 nl eem e 1
i
2 1)ls v ie N v 2,2 1) 1 NYCRR 1 221 st n mn umh u y
0 6(at i t d o. 0 0 7 2 ..... 4 - (e i g iim
s
;
.
t
or
l
w g o $ 10 i N wYr C ya e Dc br3,2 1 fr po es w h l v n
a e f 1. 0 n e o k i f r eem e 1 0 6 o eml yr i eee
t t
t
o mr eml ye a d$ 05 fr po es w h e e eml ye . Acri gy
r oe po es n 1. 0 o eml yr i f wr po es codnl,
t
)
Pso hs wi e h rgt o a d na y v ni nt n te t , n u pi
atr a av d i i h t n i n e et s o etl d o a y n ad
s
,
i
mn um w gs
iim
ae
.
4

A
.

O et e P y
v rim a

U dr N L apan f“m s b pi o ea d n hlt e h r glr
n e Y L, litf ut e ad n n o e a ims i e ua
i
- f
s
h u y ae o e eyh u wr e o e fryh uspr we. Pnv v F D
o r rt fr vr o r o k d vr ot o r e e k i oi . D
l
”
Etrr e I c, N 1- V 2 0 ( B ) 2 1 W 4 2 8 2 a * (. .NY Jl 8
n p ss n
e i , . o 3 -8 0 G D 0 5 L 1 6 7, t 5 S D .. uy ,
. C
,
2 1) sea o1 NYCRR §1 2 22( A eml yr hl p ya eml ye o
0 5;e l 2 ..... 4 –. “ n po e s a a n po e fr
s
l
o et ea a w g rt o o ea d n-a t e t e po e ’r glr ae] .
vr
im t a e ae f n n o ehl ims h eml yes e ua rt[”
f
.)
“ n po e i nt x pfomp yn o et e w gs eeybc uet
A eml yr s o e emt r
ai g vr
im a e mrl ea s i
p y t e po e a wel slr. Am y v S pro T e & GaieCr. N
as h eml ye e ky aay
”
a a . ue r i
i
l
rn
t op, o
.
1 - V 4 2 ( G ) 2 1 W 1 0 2,a * (. .NY J n 1,2 1)“ h fc t a
0C -5 5 P G 0 2 L 3 4 5 t 9 S D .. a. 7 0 2( T e at ht
,
Pan f r glry wr e mr t a 5 h uspr we de nt niaet a t e
litf e ua
is
l o k d oe h n 0 o r e e k os oi d t ht h
c
eml ye wel slr ws ne d d o n u e h o et epemum e u e
po es e ky aay a it n e t i c d t e vr
’
l
im r i r qi d
r
b t eF S a d N L ..Wie[] eml yr m yb e emt r t e
y h L A n [ Y L]) h “an po e a e x pfom h
”
l
o et e e u em nit ee sa aayarem n bt e n po e a d
vr
im r qi etf hr i slr ge et e we eml yr n
r
eml ye ht ui etyas rs ht h eml ye wl eev al at h
po e t a sf c n
f i l s ue t a t e po e i rci e t es t e
l
mn um w g pr we, ai e wel slr “ i ‘ o b dem d o n u ea
iim
a e e e k fx d e ky aay wl nt e e e t i c d n
”
l
l
o et e om o et n h as ne fa e pesarem n’ W n v H n a
vr
im c p n ni t e be c o n xrs ge et” o g . u d
.
GasCr. N 0- V 4 0 ( L ) 2 1 W 2 4 6 8 a * (. .NY J n 2,
ls op , o 9 -4 2 R E 0 0 L 5 1 9, t 2 S D .. u e 3
. C
,
2 1) q o n G e v C y f N wYr, 4 F S p.2 3 8 3 7(. .NY1 9).
0 0( ut g i s . i o e ok 1 . u p d 0, 1 S D .. 9 9)
i
l
t
“ narem nfrai e wel slr fr mr t a 4 h us f wr pr we
A ge et o fx d e ky aay o oe h n 0 o r o o k e e k
ol c p e w h . [Y L]f hr i a e p c u drt ni gbt e n h
ny oml s i . .N L it ee s n xl i n esa dn e we t e
i
t
it
eml yra d poe a t r glra d vr e ae ” Am y,2 1 W
po e n eml ye s o e ua n o et rts
im
.
aa 0 2 L
1 0 2 ,t* ( tn G e 4 F S p.2 a 3 6 1 )
3 4 5 a 9 ci gi s 1 . u p d t 1 – 7.
i
l,

5

Pso ceil ts f d ht p o t b gni gh j b h h dd c s e t e
atr r dby eti t a r r o ei nn i o, e a i us d h
ie
, i
s
s
trm o h eml ym n w h h pro w oh e h ,a d ht h t oh dn
e sf i
s po eti t e es n h i d im n t a t e w a o
t
r
d c s o a ot w ehr h wel slr i cu e a o et e om o etfr h
i us n b u ht e t e e ky aay n d d n vr
s i
l
im c p n n o t e
h usPso w ud wr i ecs o 4 pr we. T a 1.Ti ts o y ws
o r atr ol o k n xes f 0 e e k r t 3 h et n a
.
s im
u d pt d a ddf n at ddntpo e hta y xl i u drt ni go
ni ue, n ee d ns i o r v t a n e p c n esa dn r
s
it
e pesarem n eit dbt e n atra dA c Ce nr r gri g e ua
xrs ge et x e e we Pso n l e l a es e adn r glr
s
i
a d vr eh u yrts Acri gyt eC uti d t a d a e aed e o
n o et
im o r ae. codnl, h o rfn s ht am gs r u fr
l
u pi o et e Seeg, a a 2 1 W 1 0 2,a * ( wri gd a e fr
n ad vr . e . .Am y, 0 2 L 3 4 5 t 9 a adn am gs o
im
,
u pi o et e o po e w hi e slr) W n 2 1 W 2 4 6 8 a * 4
n ad vr
im t eml ye i fx d aay o g, 0 0 L 5 1 9, t 3
t
;
(am)
s e
.
1
.

R g l r H ul R t
e ua o ry ae

“ h f s se i dtrmnn d a e i t dtrmn w a t e r glr
T ei t t p n ee ii g am gs s o ee i e ht h [e ua
r
]
h u y ae wsfr h we i q eto.T e r glrh u y ae sarv da b
o r rt a o t e e k n us n h [e ua o r rt i r e t y
l
i
] l
i
dvdn t egos w g s a pan f rci e fom Df n at fra we b t e
iii g h rs a e [] litf eev d r
i
ee d ns o
ek y h
h us wr e b P an f ] Am y , 0 2 W 1 0 2,a * ( ni gpan f pi
o r o k d y litf .
i[ ” a a 2 1 L 3 4 5 t 9f dn litf ad
i
i
$ 2 fr5 h u wr we h dh u y ae fa poimtl $ 35) sea o 2
7 0 o 3 o r o k e k a o r rt o pr x aey 1. 8;e l 1
l
s
NYCRR §1 2–. 6“W e a eml ye spi o apee wr bs , aay o
..... 4 21 ( h n n po e i ad n ic o k a sslr, r
i
a ybs ohr h nh u y aet e e ua h u y w g rt s a b dtrmn d
n a s t e t a o r rt h r glr o r a e ae hl e ee i e
i
l
,
l
l
b dvdn t e oa h us w r e d rn t e we it t e po e’ttl
y iii g h ttl o r o k d u g h e k no h eml ye oa
i
s
eri g ” sea oeg Prla . M & O r n Wrs 1 - V 3 7 ( R ) R )
a nns) e l ,.. ea v
.;
s
,
t
Io ok 2C -1 9 A R( LM
,
,

6

2 1 W 9 8 3,a * (. .NY Mr 1,2 1)fni gpan f pi $ 8 fr5
0 4 L 8 8 5 t 8 E D .. a 1 0 4( dn litf ad 3 0 o 6
.
i
i
h us f wr h d e ua h u y ae f$. 9prh u .
o r o o k a r glr o r rt o 67 e o r 5
l
)
T eC ut o n t a Pso wsg nrlypi $ 5, h n$ 8, h n$ 0
h o rf u d ht atr a e ea
l ad 5 0t e 5 0t e 6 0
fra5. h u wr we; ht n h wne m nh Pso wspi $ 5, h n
o
35 o r o k e kt ai t e itr ot s atr a ad 4 0t e
,
$ 8, h n$ 0 fra4 h u wr we;a d ht a e h f e h c pan
4 0t e 5 0 o
5 o r o k e k n t a,f r ei d i omlit
t
l
s
,
Ps o wspi $ 0 fra4. h u wr we, xet o i t e wne m nh
at r a ad 6 0 o
15 o r o k e k ec pfr n h itr ot s
,
w e h wspi $ 0 fr es h n4 h usa we o wr . T ee wel
h n e a ad 5 0 o ls t a 0 o r
e k f o k 6 hs e ky
slre rsli r glrh u y ae bt e n$ 00 a d$ 44 ,ai d ae i
aa s e u n e ua o r rts e we 1. 0 n 1. 6 s ni t d n
i
t
l
c
t e p e dxa a h dt ti Oii na d Odr
h a p ni t c e o h pno n r e.
t
s
2
.

O et e D a e
v rim am g s

U dr N wYr l wfr vr h u wr e i a we o e 4,a eml ye
n e e o k a , o e ey o r o k d n e k vr 0 n po e
s ol b pi a w g rt o o ea d n-a t e t e po e s e ua h u y
h ud e ad a e ae f n n o ehl ims h eml ye r glr o r
f
’
l
rt Se1 NYCRR §1 2 22 “h m a ue fd a e i t edfr ne
ae e 2 ..... 4 –.. T e es r o am gs s h i ee c
.
f
bt e n w a [ pan f s ol h v be pi u dr h [ Y L] n t eam ut
e we ht a litf h ud a e e n ad n e t e N L a d h
i]
on
t a [ pan f wsat a ypi. Am y ,2 1 W 1 0 2,a *.
ht a litf a cul ad” a a 0 2 L 3 4 5 t 9
i
]
l

5B c n a ,N wYr r glt n c clt t e e ua h u y ae f o p a t
y ot s e o k e ua o s a uae h r glr o r rt ohsi l y
r t
i
l
l
ti

i d sr eml ye b dv dn ttl wel eri g “ y h lse o 4 h us r
n uty po es y i ii g oa e ky a nns b t e esr f 0 o r o
t eat a n br fh us wr e b t a eml yed rn t e wr we. 1
h cul um e o o r o k d y ht po e u g h o k e k 2
i
”
NYCRR §1 6- 5
..... 4 3 .
.

6G e t eC u ’ fni g rsae i sc o It a P so wr e o e a ls
i n h o r si dn, ett d n et n, ht atr o k d n d y es
v
t
i

d rn wne m nh t eC uths a uae t eh usPso wr e i a
u g itr ot s h o r a cl lt d h o r atr o k d n
i
,
c
wne we b d d c n 85h us r t e oa n br fh us wr e i a
itr e k y e ut g . o r fom h ttl um e o o r o k d n
i
n nwne we .I lgt f h C ut fni g htPso lf wr er e a e
o - tr e k ni h ot e o r si dn t a atr e o k a ir f r
i
’
t
l
t
h c pan wsie o A gs 1,2 1 , h C ut s a ua n t eh us
i omlit a f d n u ut 6 0 6 t e o ri cl lt g h o r
s
l
c i
Pso wr e a e t ei n u n a ot im o 23 p .
atr o k d f r h fi g s g n u- e f : 0 .m
t
l
i
t
7

Pso s e ua rt dtrmnsh o et e aet e aeh s ol h v
atr r glr ae ee i e i vr
’
s
im rt (h rt e h ud a e
be pi fr vr h u h wr e pr we i ecs o 4) a d hrfr h
e n ad o e ey o r e o k d e e k n xes f 0 n t eeoe i
,
s
o et e pemum rt (h dfr nebt e n w a h s ol h v be pi
vr
im “r i ” ae t e i ee c e we ht e h ud a e e n ad
f
a d w a h wsat a ypi) A i d ae i t ea p ni ,Pso s e ua
n ht e a cul ad s ni t d n h p e dx atr r glr
l
.
c
’
h u y ae rsli o et epemumh u y ae bt e n$. 0a d$. 3
o r rts e u n vr
l
t
im r i
o r rts e we 50 n 72.
l
T cl uaed a e fragv npro,t eo et er i h u yrt i
o a lt am gs o i e e d h vr
c
i
im pemum o r ae s
l
ml p e b t en br fh us wr e i ecs o 4 pr we ; htpo ut s
uil d y h um e o o r o k d n xes f 0 e e k t a r d ci
t i
ml p edb t ea poimt n br f we s nagv npro ; n fnly
uil
t i
y h pr x ae um e o e k i
ie e d a d i a ,
i
l
w eea porae a um s utat dfom h ttl oco nfr o et e ht
hr pr p t
i , s i s brce r t e oa t ac ut o vr
im t a
wsntac u dd rn we s n wi hPso to pi hld y .Seeg,ea a
a o cr e u g e k i h
i
c atr o k ad o as e .. Prl ,
i
,
t
2 1 W 9 8 3,a * ( T e o n d e opan fi u pi o et epemum
0 4 L 8 8 5 t 9“ h am ut u t litf n n ad vr
i
im r i s
fr h t epro i cl uae b dtrmnn hl o h [e ua h u y ae
o ti im e d s a lt d y ee ii g a f i r glr o r rt]
s
i
c
f
s
l
,
wi h wsa o e mn um w g Ti n br . i t e ml p e b . . h
h
c a b v iim
a e h um e. . s h n uil d y . t e
.
s
t i
am ut f wel o et e wr e b p an f. .a d h n ml p e b . . h
o n o e ky vr
im o k d y litf . n t e uil d y . t e
i
t i
n br f we s n h pr clrim pro. .
um e o e k i ti at ua t e e d)
s
i
i ”
A st ot i t ea p ni,c n s w h h frml, atr sd e
s efrh n h p e dx o s t i ti o uaPso i u
i
t
s
$ 45 42 i d a e fru pi o et e
1, 5. 2 n am gs o n ad vr
im .
Pso se sa am ut wli ecs o w a t eC uta ad hr
atr e k n o n e n xes f ht h o r wrs ee
l
.
Pso sa poc t cl ua n d a e wi h e u s na i niatyhg e
atr pr a h o a lt g am gs h rsl i sgi c n i hr
’
c i
, c
t
f
l
r glr ae a d h sa m c hg e o et e ae a da o e u e t eC ut o
e ua rt ( n t u
u h i hr vr
im rt) n l r qi s h o r t
s
r
tet vr h u t a Pso wr e i ecs o 4 pr we a et ey
r a e ey o r ht atr o k d n xes f 0 e e k s n rl
i
u c p nae, su a ai g
nom e st di n vi n.
l

8

Pso w udh v t eC uta pyape umto u dr h F S a d
atr ol a e h o r pl
rs p n n e t e L A n
i
N L t a a e ky aay ny o es 4 h us P Ps- ila 6 ci g ee v
Y L ht wel slr ol c vr 0 o r l otT a t (i n Prz .
. .
r
t
Pa n Pa a4 0C a esI c, N 1- V 9 5 ( A ) 2 1 W 1 8 0 0
lt um l z 0 l nr n
i
e
, . o 2 -3 3 P C, 0 5 L 8 1 8
. C
(. .NY Ar 2,2 1)G a p v NY PoSg s n, N 1 C -1 3 L S
S D .. p 4 0 5 ul a . .. r i n I c o 1- V 3 3 ( G)
.
; l
. .
( ) 2 1 W 2 0 3 3 S D .. M y2,2 1)a ot db ,2 1 W 4 0 9 8
FM 0 4 L 2 0 9 (. .NY a 7 0 4 d p
,
,
e y 04 L 154
(. .NY A g 1,2 1)Am y ,2 1 W 1 0 2,a *)
S D .. u. 8 0 4
; aa 0 2 L 3 4 5 t 9
.
H w vr iw udb o d o a py u hape umto gv n h fcs n h
o e e t ol e d t pl s c
,
rs p n i e t e at i ti
i
s
cs a Pso ts fe t a h d c se t e o s o r a d aay na v ne f
ae s atr eti d ht e i us d h j b h us n slr i d a c o
,
i
s
’
satn wr ,a d atrws om e st da o e mn um w g a a t e (s
tr g o k n Pso a c p nae b v iim
i
ae t l ims a
l
d c se afont f u .Pso ts fe t a bfr h sat da A c
i us d t ot oe o r atr eti d ht eoe e tre t l e
s
)
i
,
i
Ce nr h ws tl t a t e o pi a aay f 5 0pr we a dt a h w ud
l a es e a od ht h j b ad slr o $ 5 e e k n ht e ol
,
b e pce t wr fom73 a . o43 o 50 p . M n a t r u hF d y
e x et d o o k r
: 0 .mt : 0 r : 0 .m o d y ho g r a,
,
i
a d r 80 a . o43 o 50 p . nSt r as T a 1 – 3 T u acri g
n fom : 0 .mt : 0 r : 0 .m o aud y r t 1 1. h s codn
. .
,
t Pso s w ts o y h ac pe a o t a r qie bt e n5. t 5.
o atr o n et n, e cet d j b ht e u d e we 35 o 65
’
im
r
h us f wr pr we fra wel slr o $ 5.I Prz o e f h css
o r o ok e e k o
e ky aay f 5 0 n ee , n ot e ae
Pso c e t e o rf u d ht h df n at h dnt vrom t epe umto
atr i s h c ut o n t a t e ee d ns a o o ec e h rs p n
t,
i
t a a aay o ee a4-o r wr we bc ue ulk i ti cs t e eod
ht slr c vr d 0 u o k e k ea s n e n h ae h rcr
h
, i
s
,
ws c peeyd vi o a y vd ne fa arem n o u drt ni gbt e n
a “omltl e od f n ei e c o n ge et r n esa dn e we
Pan f a d Df n at r gri g w a t e wel slr ws ne d d o o e ”
litf n ee d ns e adn ht h e ky aay a it n e t c vr
is
.
Prz 2 1 W 1 8 0 0 a *.
ee , 0 5 L 8 1 8, t 2
A di nly a to g Pso c e Am y i s p ot fh ag ett e
di o a , l u h atr i s a a n u pr o i r um n h
t
l
h
t
s
,
Am y c utat a y ple pe sl t ea poc eml y db ti C ut Se
a a o r cul a p s rc ey h pr a h po e y h o r. e
l
i
i
s

9

M oa d
emr n um Oii na d Odr 1 C -5 5( G ) dt dJ n 1,2 1, Dt N
pno n r e 0- V 4 2 P G ae a. 7 0 2 k o
,
,
. .
3,A p ni a 1 dvdn wel slr b h us wr e t dtrmn a p c be
9 p e dx t (iii g e ky aay y o r o k d o ee i e pl al
i
h u y aea d vr epemum a d h n ml pyn pemumb o et e
o r rt n o et
l
im r i , n t e uili g r i
t
y vr
im
h us o a uaed a e fru pi o et e
o r t cl lt am gs o n ad vr )
c
im .
A d c se,A c Ce nr a dC o ddntet b s t e x t ne fa
s i us d l e l a es n hi i o sal h h ei e c o n
s
i
i
s
e p c u drt ni ga t h wPso sfx d wel slr w udpoi e
xl i n esa dn s o o atr i e e ky aay ol r vd
it
’
o et e om e sto e ul o n a d n-a t e Pso sr glrh u y ae
vr
im c p na n q at o e n o ehl ims atr e ua o r rt,
i
f
’
l
a d h sPso i etl d o h o et epemumh wsntpi. Seeg,
n t u atr s n te t t e vr
i
im r i
e a o ad e ..
,
Am y ,2 1 W 1 0 2,a *;ea a 2 1 W 9 8 3, a* ; o g,2 1 W
a a 0 2 L 3 4 5 t 9Prl , 0 4 L 8 8 5 t 9 W n
t
00 L
2 4 6 8 a * – ( a ua n d a e fru pi o et eb dvdn eml ye
5 1 9, t 3 4 cl lt g am gs o n ad vr
c i
im y iii g po e s
’
fx d aayb n br fh us wr e a da adn ol u pi o et e
i e slr y um e o o r o k d n wri g ny n ad vr
im
pemum; a ca .6 -8 DnrCr. N 1 C -6 9 P C 2 1 W 1 6 2 9
r i )Gl i v 3 6 i e op o 3- V 3 8 ( K ) 0 5 L 4 9 7,
i
, .
,
a * (. .NY Mr 3,2 1) a adn ol o et epemum o 2. h us
t 5 E D .. a 0 0 5( wri g ny vr
.
im r i fr 15 o r
wr e i ecs o 4 pr we t pan f w oe mn um w g d a e “le d
o k d n xes f 0 e e k o litf hs iim
i
a e am gs a a y
r
ac ute] o apr o ot e oa o et e om e st o d e .T eC ut s
co n dfr ot n f h ttl vr
[
i
im c p nai n u” h o ri
)
a ae htal at n ohr o r i ti D t c(l e i t e ot x o a
wr t a t es o e t e c ut n h i r t abi n h c net f n
s si
t
i q eth s pr a h d h cl ua o dfr n y seeg G a p ,2 1 W
n us a a poc e ti a lt n i eet , e .. ul a 0 4 L
)
s c i
f
l
, , l
2 0 3 3 a * - (a ua n h u y ae a dd a e a e pe umn wel
2 0 9, t 3 5cl lt g o r rts n am gs f r rs i g e ky
c i
l
t
slr c vr d ny4 h usdsiepan fs o cs o t a h etr d no
aay o ee ol 0 o r e p litf c nes n ht e nee it
t
i’
i
arem n w h po e t a w gs w ud o e 6-o r wr we) bt snt
ge et i eml yr ht a e ol c vr 0 u o k e k, ui o
t
h
a ae fa ybni gSc n C ci o S pem C utpee et ht u s
wr o n i dn eo d i u r ur e o r rc d n t a r n
r t
c nrr t t ea poc t k nhr
otay o h pr a h a e ee
.

1
0

B
.

L q i ae D a e
i u d t d am g s

N L at o zsi udt dd a e e ul o o eh nr dpret f h
Y L uhr e lqi ae am gs q at “ n u de ec n ot e
i
ttlam ut f h w gs o n t b d e “ nes h eml yrpo e ago fih
oa
o n ot e a e f u d o e u ” uls t e po e r vs o d a
,
t
bs t ble e htt u dr a et f w gs ws n omla c w h h l w
a s o e v t ais n ep ym n o a e a i c p ne i t e a .
i
i
i
t
”
NY L b L w §1 81-.
.. a. a § 9( a 7
)
A t a t eC ut o n t a A c Ce nr a dC o h dntpo e ago
t r l h o rf u d ht l e l a es n hi a o r v d o d
i,
i
fihbs t ble e ht h w g pat e wr i c p ac w h h l w a d
a
t a s o e v t a t e a e rc cs ee n oml ne i t e a , n
i
i
i
i
t
t u t a lqi ae d ae wr i odr T a 1 9 1 . Acri gy Pso i
h s hti udt d amgs ee n r e r t 0 – 0 codnl, atr s
. .
etl d o i udt dd a e o 1 0% f h ttl 1, 5. 2d e o u pi
n te t lqi ae am gs f 0 ote oa $ 45 42 u fr n ad
i
o et e
vr .
im
C
.

W g N tc a d W g S aem n Voa o s
ae o e n
i
a e t t e t ilt n
i

N L r qie eml yr t poi e po es a t eim oh i g w h a
Y L e u s po es o r vd eml ye t h t e fi n, i
r
,
r
t
w g nt e otii g bs ifrmto s c a rt o p y p o t F b ur 2,
a e o c c nann a c no a n u h s ae f a; r r o er ay 7
i
i
i
i
2 1,eml yr wr r qie t poi e po es w h hs nt e a n a y
05
po es ee e u d o r vd eml ye i t ee o cs n ul .
r
t
i
l
NY L b L w §1 51 a 8 Eml yr aea o e u e t poi e po es w h
.. a. a
9() )
(.
po es r l r qi d o r vd eml ye i
s
r
t

7P so se si udt d am gsu dr N L a d osnt e k umlt e
atr e k lqi ae d a e n e Y L n de o se c ua v
i

lqi ae d a e u dr h F S.JitPera Odr dt d u.2 ,2 1
i udt d am gs n e t e L A on rt l r e, ae A g 3 0 7
i
( k N 4 )a 5 P Pst a a 6 T eSc n C ci rc n ya des da pt
Dt o 7,t ; l ot r l t . h eo d i u eet drse sl
. .
.
-i
r t
l
i
am n d t c c ut b hli g htapan f c udnt eo e c ua v
o g i r t o rs y odn t a litf ol o rc vr umlt e
si
i
i
lq ae d a e u dr N L a d h F S bc ue t d y . t ei udt d
i ut d am gs n e Y L n t e L A ea s “o a . . h lqi ae
d a e poi o sae d n cl na mtra rs et sr e h s e u c o s
am gs r v i n r i et ai l ae l e pcs ev t e am f nt n
s
i
l
i
,
i ,
a d ers t e am ij re ” C o d uy . H z E pesFo Cr. 6 6F
n r des h s e nu s h w h r v am a xrs o d op, 6 .
i.
A p 5,6 ( dC .2 1)( ummr odr
p x 9 1 2 i 06 s
’
r
ay r e .
)

8I 2 1 t e a ws
n 0 4 h l w a am n e a d h a n a r qiem n ws em v d Se
,
e d d n t e n ul e u
r et a r o e. e

2 1 NY Ss L w C.5 7 A8 0 –) c i n y)
0 4 .. es a s h 3 (. 1 6 C(M Kn e s
.
’.
1
1

aw g saem n w h a hp ym n o w gs NY L b L w§1 53 Sne
a e tt et i ec a et f a e .. a. a
t
.
9() i c
.
F b ur 2,2 1,a eml ye h wsntpoi e aw g nt e w hn e
er ay 7 0 5 n
po e w o a o r vd d a e o c i i t n
i
t
b sns d y ot eis d y f po etc n eo e d a e o $ 0 o ec
u es as f h f t a o eml ym n a rc vr am gs f 5 fr a h
i
r
wr d y ht avoa o oc r o c n n e t oc r nt o xe d$,0 ,a da
ok a t a
ilt n c us r ot us o c u, o t ece 5 0 n n
i
i
0
eml ye a rc vr$5 fr a h wr d y htaw g saem n voa o oc r
po e c n eo e 20 o ec o k a t a
a e tt et ilt n c us
i
o c n n e t oc r nt o xe d$ ,0. NY L b L w § 1 8 1)( -)
r ot us o c u o t ece 5 0 .. a. a § 9 (-, 1 d
i
,
0
b
.
A c Ce nr a dC o ddntpoi ePso w haw g saem n t a
l e l a es n hi i o r vd atr i
i
t
a e tt et ht
c p e w h Y L fr mr t a 2 wr d y u dr h c ret tttr
oml d i N L o oe h n 0 o k as n e t e ur n sauoy
i
t
d a e s h e ow ha w g nt e ht omle w h N L fr mr t a 1 0
am gs c em, ri
t
ae o c t a c p d i
i
i
t Y L o oe h n 0
wr d y u dr h c ret c em .T a 1 89 A s c,Pso i etl d o
o k as n e t e ur n s h e r t 0. s u h atr s n te t
.
i
$ , 0 i d a e fr a h f h t ovoa o sfra oa o $ 00 0
5 0 0n am gs o ec ot e w ilt n o ttl f 1, 0.
i ,
D
.

P e j d e t ne et
r -u gm n I t r s

“ Co rs yia ya adpeu gm n itrso d a e fr Y L
[ ] ut t p l wr r d et neet n am gs o N L
cl
j
voa o s Pn d v F sln I c, N 1- V 3 7 ( B ) 2 1 W 3 3 8 2 a
ilt n ” i e a . r o o n . o 5 -7 4 G D 0 7 L 8 5 8, t
i .
i i,
. C
,

9A t a d e d n o ee d pt d o um nay vd ne htP so h d e n
t r l e n at f r d i ue dc etr ei e c t a atr a be
i, f
s f
s

poi e w ha w g nt e n2 1,ao g w hap r ot d w g nt e r 2 1,
r vd d i
t
ae o c i 0 5 l n i
i
t
upre a e o c fom 0 6
i
a df n at E hb D6 T a 6,1 8 T eC ut o n t a Pso wsnt
s ee d ns xii - r t 0 0 . h o rf u d ht atr a o
’
t . .
poi e w ha y w g nt e r N v br2 1 ut 2 1,a dnt d ht h
r vd d i n a e o c fom o em e 0 1 nl 0 5 n oe t a t e
t
i
i
d pt d vd ne wsimmtra bc ue hr wsn d pt r gri g h
i ue ei e c a “
s
ae l ea s t ee a o i ue e adn t e
i”
s
voa o fom21 t 2 1. I.a 1 8 T eC uta di nlyi d hr t a t e
ilt n r
i
01 o 0 5 d t 0. h o r di o a fn s ee ht h
t
l
dc etr ei e c de ntpo e omla c w h h l wbc ue e e i
o um nay vd ne os o r v c p ne i t e a ea s v nf
i
t
,
df n at ts o y wr ceie, h nt e d nt oml w h h
ee d ns et n ee r d dt e o cs o o c py i t e
’ im
t
i
t
r qiem ns f N L . S e f a yt ep r ot d2 1 a d2 1 nt e d nt
eu
r et o Y L pci l , h upre 0 5 n 0 6 o cs o o
ic l
i
c nanac rt rts fp y a d h yitPso s e ua h u y aea $ a d
oti c uae ae o a, n t e l
s atr r glr o r rt s 9 n
’
l
h o et e aea $ 35,bth w gs wr hg e Sea p ni ( atrs
i vr
s
im rt s 1. 0 u i a e ee i hr e p e dx Pso’
s
.
h u y ae ; NY L b L w§1 51 a( a ent e m s c nan ae fp y
o r rts .. a. a
l
)
9() ) w g o c ut oti rt o a)
(
i
.
1
2

* 3 S D ..A g 2,2 1) q o n M La v Gr g M t Cr., N 0- V
1 (. .NY u. 9 0 7 ( ut g c e n . aae gm op
i
.
o 9 . C
9 2 ( L ) 2 1 W 1 5 7 9 a * 0 S D ..Ar 1,2 1) Pej d et
3 5 D C 0 2 L 3 8 3, t 1 (. .NY p 9 0 2. r -u gm n
,
.
)
itrsi a porae v n w e apan fi a oa ad di udt dd a e
neet s pr p t e e h n litf s l
i
i
s wr e lqi ae am gs
u dr N L .Se eg i. ci g el v Nt e M t GpI c ,1 1F3 2 3
n e Y L e ,.. d( tn R ly . a ws ks r. n
,
i
i
t
.
. 8 . d 5,
2 5 2 C.1 9); o h i v P a G l o H lsK c e, n , N 1- V 1 2 4
6 ( d i 9 9)Xciml . i rl f e’ i h nI c o 4 -0 3
r
t
t i
l
t
. . C
( G ) J C 2 1 W 4 0 9 7 a * 8 S D ..S p 8 2 1)a ot db ,2 1
J K( L ) 0 6 L 7 4 1, t 1 (. .NY et , 0 6 d p
,
.
,
e y 06
W 6 7 2 8 S D .. N v 2,2 1) Pej d et neeta p e ol t t e
L 8 9 5 (. .NY o. 1 0 6. r -u gm nitrs pl s ny o h
)
i
at a c p naoyd a e a dnt oi udt dd a e o t d a e
cul om e str am gs n o t lqi ae am gs r o am gs
,
,
rc vr dd e ovoa o s f w g saem n o w g nt epoi o s Sl s o .
eo ee u t ilt n o a e tt et r a e o c r v i n au i v
i
i
s .
t
1 6Cl ba D iCr. N 1- V 6 5 (
0 oumi e op, o 5 -8 7 GW ) 2 1 W 3 3 6 5 a * 4
l
. C
G 0 7 L 7 6 9, t 1
,
(. .NY A g 3,2 1) p -u gm nitrs“ o a a al frvoa o s f h
S D .. u. 0 0 7(r j d et neet nt vi be o ilt n ot e
e
l
i
w g saem n o w g nt epoi o s a d a p e ol t t eam ut f
a e tt et r a e o c r v i n” n “ pl s ny o h
i
s
i
o no
u dr a et f w gs nt h lqi ae d a e” Xciml 2 1 W
n ep ym n o a e o t ei udt d am gs; o h i , 0 6 L
,
)
t
4 0 9 7 a * 8itrs a p e ol t c p naoyd a e .
7 4 1, t 1 (neet pl s ny o om e str am gs
i
)
N wYr l wpoi e t aitrs s a b a t e ae fnn pretpr
e o k a r vds ht neet hl e t h rt o i e ec n e
l
y a NY CPLR §5 0.“W eed ae ae n ur d a vro sims
er .. .... 0 4
.
hr am gs r i c re ‘t a u t e
i
,
itrs s a b c pt du o ec iem r t edt i ws n ur d ru o a
neet hl e om ue p n a ht fom h aet a i c re o p n l
l
l
ot ed a e foma i ge es n be ne eit dt’ Xciml 2 1 W
f h am gs r
snl r ao al itrm dae ae” o h i , 0 6 L
.
t
4 0 9 7 a * 8 q o n NY CPLR §5 0) “iml peu gm nitrsi
7 4 1, t 1 ( ut g .. .... 0 1 S pe r d et neet s
i
.
j
cl uae foma i glr md on dt a db ml pyn t ep n plb t e
a lt d r
c
sn ua i pit ae n y uili g h r c a y h
,
t
ii
itrs rt b t eim pro –foma i glr md on dt –u ut a d
neet ae y h t e e d r
i
sn ua i pit ae p nl n
,
i
i cui g h dt j d et s nee. I. a ea o s i e) q o n
n dn t e ae u gm ni etr d d(l rt n om t d( ut g
l
”
t i
t
i

1
3

Ml o a o,2 1 W 1 6 3 1 a * 1 “ an f s ol rci epeu gm n
ad n d
0 2 L 6 9 4, t 1) P itf h ud eev r d et
. l is
j
itrscl uae fom h md on ot e eml ym n t t edt o ety f
neet a lt d r t e i pit f hi
c
r po et o h ae f nr o
j d eta a itrsrt o nn pretpry a ”Pn d ,2 1 W 3 3 8 2
u gm n t n neet ae f i e ec n e er i e a 0 7 L 8 5 8,
.
a * 3 sea oeg Xciml 2 1 W 4 0 9 7 a* 8
t 1; e l ,.. o h i , 0 6 L 7 4 1, t 1 .
s
,
t
Pso b g n wri g o df n at o N v br7 2 1,a dh
atr e a o kn fr ee d ns n o em e , 0 1 n i
s
eml ym n e d d nAr 7 2 1. T ea poimt md on dt bt e n hs
po et n e o p l , 0 7 h pr x ae i pit ae e we t oe
i
t opit fr h p r oe f a ua n pe u gm nitrsi Jl 2,2 1 .
w ons o t e ups ocl lt g r- d et neet s uy 3 0 4
c i
j
C ne u n y Pso i etl d o$, 6. 6 wi h sr -u gm nitrs o t e
o s q et , atr s n te t 43 74 , h ipej d et neet n h
l
i
c
p n pl f$ 45 42 cl uae a a itrs rt o nn pretpry a fom
r c a o 1, 5. 2 a lt d t n neet ae f i e ec n e er r
ii
c
Jl 2,2 1 t t edt o ety f u gm n
uy 3 0 4 o h ae f nr oj d et
.
II At r e s F e a d C ss
I. t o n y e s n ot
’
Pso r q et a a ad fa o n y fe i t eam ut f$ 22 75 a d
atr e uss n wr o t r es es n h
t
’
o n o 2, 9. 0 n
css n h am ut f$, 2. 0 P Ps - il a 8 E.Ba 13 Pso i
ot i t e o n o 21 50. l otT a,t , x
.
r
t -. atr s
r peet db t ei o M h e Fi a e &Ascae PC a d n u pr o h
ers ne y h f
rm f i al al c
c
l
so ts .. n i s p ot f i
i ,
,
s
r q et Pso hspoi e a“l n s et fom h f a a e hb t h ps
e us atr a r vd d bl g he” r t ei
,
ii
rm s n xii o i ot
t
s
t a m oa d .I.N L poi e frfe h tn t a etls pe ai g
r l emr n um d Y L r vds o e- i i g ht n te a r vi n
i
sf
i
l
pan ft rc vrh r ao al a on y fe a d ot NY L b L w§
litf o eo e i es n be t r es es n css .. a. a §
i
s
t
’
.
1 81 6 3 1 sea oeg Xciml 2 1 W 4 0 9 7 a* 9
9() 6 () e l ,.. o h i , 0 6 L 7 4 1, t 1.
,
;
s
,
t
A
.

At r e s F e
to n y e s
’

“n r e t dtrmn t ea porae e a adc ut t p a y tr b
I odr o ee i e h pr p t fe wr, o rs yi l sat y
i
cl
dtrmnn t e ocle l dsa am ut o‘h po ut fa e s n beh u y
ee ii g h s -a d o etr o n rt e r d c o r ao al o r
l
,
l
rt a d h r ao al n br fh us e u e b t e ae”Y qi a .
ae n t e es n be um e o o r r qi d y h cs’ u u em v
r
.
l

1
4

M n a a s Hr Cr , N 1- V 4 1
a ht n’ eo op o 3 -6 (WH)( L ) 2 1 W 4 0 1 6 a * 3
t
. . C
P J C 0 4 L 2 7 0, t 1
,
(. .NY A g 2,2 1)q o n Mla . M r NrhRR 6 8F3 1 4 1 6 2
S D .. u. 0 0 4(ut g i e v e o-o
i
l
t
t .., 5 . d 5, 6 ( d
C .2 1) , d p db ,2 1 W 5 3 4 8 S D ..S p 3,2 1) A ag nrl
i 0 1 a ot y 0 4 L 0 9 2 (. .NY et 0 0 4 s e ea
r
)
e
.
.
mte “ ]t t eSc n C ci a d h S pem C uth v hl t a t e
a r [boh h eo d i u n t e ur e o r a e ed ht h
t,
r t
l dsa. . r ae ape umtvl r ao al fe G r n v Ml or ,8 1F
o etr . cets rs p ey es n be e ” u u g . ahta 5 .
i
.
S p.2 5 3 5 6 S D ..2 1) q o n Mla 6 8F3 a 1 6( utto
u p d 8, 9 (. .NY 0 2( ut g i e, 5 . d t 6) q oa n
i
l
i
mr sa d a ea o om t d.
a k n l rt n i e)
t i
t
Apan f m s “ o um n t ea p cto [o fe a d ot] w h
litf ut dc et h pl a nfr es n css i
i
i i
t
c nem oa e u t e eod. . pc y n]fr a ha o n yt edt t e
ot pr no sim rcr s . s e f[ g o ec t r e, h ae h
i i ,
t
,
h us x e d d a d h nt r ot e wr d n ” NY Sa As’ frR a d d
o r e p n e, n t e aue f h o k o e .. tt s nn o e r e
.
e
t
Cide, n ,.C ry 7 1F2 1 3,1 4 ( dC .1 8)se loSo v C y f
h r nI c v ae, 1 . d 1 6 1 8 2 i 9 3 e a
l
.
r
;
s ct . i o
t
t
N wYr 6 6F3 1 0 1 2 2 C .2 1) “T eb r e i o t e e a p c n t
e ok, 2 . d 3, 3 ( d i 0 0 [] ud n s n h fe pl at o
r
.
h
i
po ue a satr ei e c . . ht h r q et d ae ae ni e w h hs
r d c st fcoy vd ne . t a t e e use rts r i ln i t oe
i
t
pe ai g n h c
r vi n i t e omm n y o s ia srie b l w es f es n by
l
ui fr im r ev s y a yr o r ao al
t
l
c
c pr be kl e pre c a d e ua o. A g ac v P a G l 7 n, N
om aal si, x e ne n r ptt n n amra . i rl I c
l
i ,
i ”
t i
. o
.
1 - V 7 7 ( G ) J C 2 1 W 3 7 7 1 a * 1 S D ..A g 2 2 1)a ot d
1C -7 7 J K( L ) 0 2 L 5 8 8, t 1 ( . .NY u. , 0 2 d p
,
,
e
b , Odr dt d Dc 1,2 1, Dt N 3.A o r m ya o ey nt o n
y r e ae e 4 0 4 k o 9 c ut a l rl o is w
,
.
. .
s
k o l d e f oa c pr be ae Se eg Y qi a 2 1 W 4 0 1 6 a
n we g olcl om aal rts e ,.. u u em, 0 4 L 2 7 0, t
.
,
l
* 3 A o n v Pr At o t o NY & NJ,6 5F S p.2 5 75 1 S D ..
1; dr o . o uhr y f ..
t
i
. . 8 . u p d 0, 1 (. .NY
2 1) C u sl o t epe ai gpry m s m k ago fih fot o x u e
0 0 o nefr h r vi n at ut a e o d a e r t ec d
.
l
t f
l
ecs v r d n at o u ncsayh us r t e e r q et Q aa n v
xes e e u d n r n eesr o r fom h fe e us urt o .
i,
,
.
i
Tf n &C . 1 6F3 4 2 4 6n6 2 C.2 0) Uimtl,a o r sd c to
i ay
f
o, 6 . d 2, 2 . ( d i 0 8 l aey c ut i r i n
r
. t
’ se

1
5

t sta e a ad sbo d H n e v Ekt a 4 1 US 4 4 4 7 1 8)
o e fe wr i r a. e s y . cehr
l
t, 6 .. 2, 3 ( 9 9
;
Mt s kv E eCy WtrAt.,7 7F3 3,6 ( dC.2 1)“W a oda
au c . r t
i
i
. a
e uh
5 . d 1 4 2 i 0 4( e f r
r
f
d t c c ut o sdr bed ce o i dtrmnn w a c nt ue r ao al
i r t o r c n eal i rt n n ee ii g ht o s tts es n be
si
i
s i
i
a o n y fe i agv n ae mnfl f h c ut s pro u drt ni g f h
t r e s es n i e cs i du ot e o r s u e r n esa dn ot e
t
’
,
’
i
li a o . .”( utto mr s i e)
i gt n . . q oa n a k om t d
t i
)
i
t .
1
.

R a o al H ul R t
e s n be o ry ae

“T e es n beh u y ae s h rt ap yn c et w udb wln t
‘ h r ao al o r rt i t e ae ai gl n ol e ii g o
l
i
l
p y b a n i mn t a ar ao al p yn c et w hs o p n t e
a, er g n i d ht ‘es n be ai g l n i e t s e d h
’
i
,
i
s
mn umncsay oi gt t e ae fetvl. Y qi a 2 1 W 4 0 1 6
iim
eesr t li ae h cs e c ey” u u em, 0 4 L 2 7 0,
t
f i ’
l
a * 3 q o n Ab r HlC ne n dCie s N g br o dAsn . t.fAb n,
t 1 ( ut g r o i o cr e i z n e h o ho s vC yo l a y
i
l
t
i
’
5 2F3 1 2 1 0 2 C .2 0) “ oass t e es n be aet eC ut
2 . d 8, 9 ( d i 0 8. T ses h r ao al rt h o r
r
)
,
c n dr t epe ai g mr e rtsfr im a srie b l w es f es n by
o s es h r vi n a kt ae‘o s i r ev s y a yr o r ao al
i
l
l
c
c pr be kl e pre c ad e ua o. Se Ml o a o 2 1 W 1 6 3 1
om aal si, x e ne n r ptt n” e ad n d , 0 2 L 6 9 4,
l
i
i ’
a * 2 q o n G r ne v G ao ,1 0F3 8 8 8 2 2 C .1 9) C ut i
t 1 ( ut g i l gr . l s n 6 . d 5, 8 ( d i 9 8. o rs n
i
ei
e
r
)
ti D t c h v dtrmn d n eet ae t a a e i t e a g o $ 5 t $ 5
h i r t a e ee i e i rc n css ht fe n h r n e f 2 0 o 4 0
s si
i a porae o e pre c digtr i w g -n -o r ae SeCr sv N w
s pr p t fr x e ne l iaos n a ea dh u css e o e . e
i
i
t
.
t
Cetr , N 1- V 5 8 ( A ) 2 1 W 3 5 3 3 a * (. .NY J n 2,2 1)
raos o 5 -6 0 P E 0 6 L 4 5 8, t 7 S D .. u. 0 0 6
. C
,
;
Kr e v Go a S ut rs 1- V 6 9 CM ( F 2 1 W 8 0 9,a * 0
e ns . l bl t cue , 5 -5 ( ) D) 0 6 L 8 1 9 t 1
r
C
,
(. .NY F b 9 2 1)a ot db , M oE drem n dt d Mr 1 2 1, Dt
S D .. e. , 0 6 d p
,
e y em n os et ae a , 0 6 k
,
.
.
N 2; Y qi a 2 1 W 4 0 1 6 a * 4 cletn css
o 7 u u em , 0 4 L 2 7 0, t 1 (o c g ae .
.
l
l i
)
Pso se s o eo e fe fr wr pro e b t rea o ny:i h e
at r e k t rc vr es o o k e rm d y he t r esM al
f
t
c
Fi ae Cln Ml o a d a d Mr o S no.P Ps - il a 78 Fi ae s
alc o
l , i uhl n , n a sl ats l otT a t -. alc i
l
i
.
r ,
l

1
6

t e m n gn m br f h f a dhsbe i pat e i c 1 8.I. t7 I
h a ai g em e ot ei
rm n a e n n rc c sne 9 3 da . n
i
a d i n o evn a i-o s c u sl o Itr a o a B sns Mci e
di o t sri g s n ue o nefr ne nt nl u es a hns
t
h
i
i
Cr oa o bt e n1 8 a d2 0,h hs a gt po etd c i a o a
oprt n e we 9 3 n 0 0 e a t u h eml ym n i r nt n t
i
s im i
Fr h
od am Ui es ya dSt n Hl Ui es y a s ho a d p a s n
nvr t n eo a nvr t l w c ol n s e k o
i
l
i
s
eml ym nl w mtes I.Pso se s e b rem nfrFi ae fe a h
po et a
a r d atr e k rim us et o alc s es t i
t .
l ’
s
bln rt o $ 5 a h u I.Ml o a d, w ore t e aebfr t eC ut
ii g ae f 4 0 n o r d uhl n
l
.
l
h t d h cs eoe h o r
i
,
hsbe pat i g a sneF b ur o 2 1 a dhsbe w h h f ,a a
a e n rc cn l w i c er ay f 0 3 n a e n i t ei
i
t
rm s n
ascae sne M y f2 1.I. t8 Pso se s e b rem nfr
so t , i c a o 0 7 da . atr e k rim us et o
i
Ml o a d fe a t e ae f$ 5 prh u I.Mr o S no ga ut d r
uhl n s es t h rt o 3 0 e o r d a sl ats r d ae fom
l ’
.
i
l w c ol n2 1 a dhsbe w h h f sne Ot br f2 1.I. t 7.
a s hoi 03 n a e n i t e i i c co e o 0 6 da t
rm
8
Pso se s e b rem nfrS no fe (o a oa o 0 4 o r o wr)a t e
atr e k rim us et o ats esfr ttl f . h us f o k t h
’
rt o $ 5 a h u I.E.Ba 1
ae f 2 0 n o r d x
. ,
t.
Ti C ut eetya po e a ae f$ 2 prh u frFi ae Xciml
h o r rc n
s
l pr v d rt o 4 5 e o r o alc o h i ,
l .
t
2 1 W 4 0 9 7 a * 0 Ti rt i c n set w h eet ae ue b ohr
0 6 L 7 4 1, t 2. h ae s o s t n i rc n rts s d y t e
s
i
t
c ut i ti D sr t pr clry n h c net ftagto wr cssi e h
o rs n h it c at ua i t e ot x osri h r ad ae lk ti
s
i,
i
l
f
s
o e wi h a s url wti Fi ae w g-n -o rpat e Seeg, o i o
n h fl q aey i hn alc s a e dh u rc c . e .. Prl
, c l
l ’
a
i
,
tl
v N wK-u h J p ns Rs, n . N 1- V 2 2 ( F 2 1 W 3 9 6 2 a
. e oS si a a ee e .I c, o 6 -4 9 JM) 0 7 L 9 5 0, t
t
. C
,
* (. .NY S p 8 2 1) a poi g$ 0 frFi ae nfi y tagto wr
1 S D .. et , 0 7 ( pr vn 4 0 o alc i “a l sri h r ad
.
l
r
f
w g -n -o r ae ;ei a . Nks I c N 1 C -3 8 A P 2 1 W
a e a dh u cs” Svl v e aa n, o 6- V 2 6 ( J) 0 7 L
)
l
. .
,
1 8 5 2 a * (. .NY Mr 3,2 1) r d cn $ 5 t $ 2 frFi ae ntn
1 5 7, t 5 S D .. a 0 0 7(e u g 4 0 o 4 5 o alc o g
.
i
l , i
t a cs wsnt oml x Hr a dz .J P C n
ht ae a o c pe) e n n e v R A I c N 1- V 4 7 ( A ) 2 1
;
., o 4 -1 6 P E 0 7
. C
,
W 6 3 5 a * (. .NY J n 6 2 1) r d cn $ 5 t $ 0 frFi aea d
L 6 2, t 3 S D .. a. , 0 7(e u g 4 0 o 4 0 o alc n
i
l

1
7

ntn t a cs l w c
o g ht ae a “omm nya po e h u y ae o $ 0-4 0 o prnr i
i
ol pr vs o r rts f 3 0 0 fr at es n
l
$
F S css.Acri gyt eC ut wlue$ 2 a t e es n beh u y ae t
L A ae” codnl, h o r i s 4 5 s h r ao al o r rt o
)
l
l
a py o M Fi ae wr.0
pl t r alc s o k1
. l ’
A t Ml o a dt eC uti d t a t epo oe $ 5 prh u rt i
s o uhl n, h o rfn s ht h r ps d 3 0 e o r ae s
l
hg e t a t e ae a s p ot A nt da o e c ut fn rts n h $ 5 t
i hr h n h cs l w u prs s oe b v o rsi d ae i t e 2 0 o
.
,
$ 5 r n e es n be o e pre c d i gtr w kn o w g-n -o r ae
4 0 a g r ao al fr x e ne li aos o i g n a ea dh u css
i
t
r
.
Ml o a d sa ascae w ohsbe pat i g o ls t a fv y as a d hs
uhl n i n so t h a e n rc cn fr es h ni e er n a
l
i
i
,
be a t ei fr nysx ot s Acri gyt eC ut wlue$ 5 prh u
en t hf
rm o ol i m nh
. codnl, h o r i s 2 0 e o r
l
a t e es n be ae oa py o Ml oln s wr. Seeg,e n n e 2 1
s h r ao al rt t pl t uhla d o k e .. Hr a dz, 0 7
’
,
W 6 3 5 a * (0 7dc i n o o i gb n h ra a da poi g$ 5 h u y
L 6 2, t 4 2 1 e so fl wn e c t l n pr vn 2 0 o r
i
l
i
l
rt fr 0 1a d2 1 l w c olga uts w h w a d he y as f x ei ne
ae o 2 1 n 0 0 a s ho r d ae i t o n t re er o e p re c,
t
rs etvl, n w g-n -o r ae ) T eC uti d t e 2 0prh u rt bl d
e pc eyi a e dh u css. h o rfn s h $ 5 e o r ae i e
i
a
l
b S no r ao al a s ehsa im a n br fy as f xe e c a d h
y ats es n be s h a s i r um e o er o epr ne n t e
,
l
i
rt i c n set w h t e rc n a ad.Seeg Prlo 2 1 W 3 9 6 2 a
ae s o s t n i ohr eet wrs e .. o i , 0 7 L 9 5 0, t
i
t
,
tl
* ( pr vn $ 0 prh u frS no ; u o .E P da a Rs,Cr. N 1
1 a poi g 2 0 e o r o ats Qi v l e r gl e . op o 6) t
t
, .
C -6 4 BM ) 2 1 W 2 0 9 9 a * (. .NY M y2,2 1) s e
V 6 3 ( C 0 7 L 3 3 7, t 2 E D .. a 6 0 7(am)
,
.

1 Dsie u g E g
0 ep
t J d e n e a e sd etv i Hr a dz t a “n uue ae t e
lm yr i c e n e n n e ht i ft r css h
’ r i
,
,

[ alc]f rmaet ei wn c ut t a rc n css n wi ha o n y’es
Fi ae[i lr r ve i g o rs ol eet ae i h
l
]
l
c t r esfe
t
h v be a ad dbs d n h wr ot e ee ata o n y i cui g ae i
a e e n wr e ae o t e o k f h rl v n t r es n dn css n
t
, l
wi ha h u ybln rt bl w ht e use i t e aea h n hsbe
h
c n o r ii g ae eo t a r q et d n h cs t a d a e n
l l
ue, Hr a dz, 0 7 W 6 3 5 a *,Pso s o ne hs a e t d s hr
s d e n n e 2 1 L 6 2, t 4 atr c u sl a fi d o o o ee
”
’
l
.
1
8

2
.

R a o al H u s E p n e
e s n be o r x e d d

“ fe dtrmnn t ea poraeh u ybln rt t ecut a uae
A r ee ii g h pr p t o r ii g ae h o r cl lts
t
i
l l
,
c
t eh us es n by x e d d Ml o a o,2 1 W 1 6 3 1 a * 3itr a
h o r r ao al e p n e. ad n d
”
0 2 L 6 9 4, t 1 (ne nl
q oa o mr s i e) I dtrmnn t e es n ben br fh us e u e
utt n a k om t d n ee ii g h r ao al um e o o r r qi d
i
t .
r
b a aet e riai qiy s w ehr a t eim t e wr wspro e,a
y cs h c t l n u i “ ht e,t h t e h o k a e rm d
,
ic
r
f
r ao al a o n y w udh v e g g d n im a t e x e d ue ”Gat .
es n be t r e ol a e n a e i s i rim e p ni rs r n v
t
l
t .
Mr nz,9 3F2 9,9 ( dC.1 9) C ut m s m k “ c nceto sad
a ie
t
7 . d 6 9 2 i 9 2 o rs ut a e a o s n u n
r
.
i i
dtie i qiy no h vld y f h r peetto s hta eti n br f
ea d n u it t e a i ot e ers na n t a cran um e o
l
r
it
i
h us wr ueu ya d es n by x e d d L n a v C y fAb n ,4 F3
o r ee sfl n r ao al e p n e. u d y . i o l a y 2 . d
l
”
t
1 1 1 4 2 C .1 9) “f h C uti d t a s e f h ca e h usae
3, 3 ( d i 9 4 It e o rfn s ht om ot e lim d o r r
r
.
‘ xeser d n at r t e w eu ncsay i m y e ue h n br f
ecsv e u d n o ohr i n eesr, t a r d c t e um e o
i,
s
’
r ao al h usacri gy B b &B b ,L C v Po C o eBat
es n be o r codnl. uml
”
e
uml L ,. r’ hi e uy
e
s
c
Cr I c, N 1- V 6 1 ( E ) J C 2 1 W 6 8 1,a * (. .NY F b 1,
ae n
, . o 4 -9 1 V C( L ) 0 6 L 5 3 0 t 9 S D .. e. 7
. C
,
2 1) q o n H n e 4 1 U Sa 4 4, d p db , 0 6 W 1 1 2 5 S D ..
0 6( ut g e s y 6 ..t 3 )a ot y 2 1 L 7 7 1 (. .NY
i
l,
e
Ar 2,2 1)
p 7 06
.
.
Pso se s o eo e fefra oa o 6. 5h us 1. 5f wi h wr
atr e k t rc vr es o ttl f 03 o r 21 o h
,
c ee
bl db Fi ae 4. b Ml o a d a d04b S no P Ps- il E.Ba 1
i e y alc 78 y uhl n, n . y ats l otT a x
l
l ,
l
. .
r ,
t 2 T eC ut s mnfl ht h cs wsi gt d o ra a di d t eh usfr
. h o ri i dut a t e ae a li ae t t l n fn s h o r o
t
i
,
t e ms pr r ao al H w vrt eC ut m ks eti r d c o sa flo s
h ot at es n be o e e h o r a e cran e ut n s o w
,
.
,
i
l .
T e77 h usFi ae p n rs aci g da i gfnl zn,a di n t e
h . 5 o r alc s et eer hn, rf n,i ai g n fi g h
l
t
i
l
c pan aeecs v Seeg,ei a 2 1 W 1 8 5 2 a * ( Th C ut
omlit r xes e e .. Svl , 0 7 L 1 5 7, t 8“ ] e o r
i. ,
l
[
fn s ht i h h us p n o a otn F S/ Y L c pani ecs v
i d t a egt o r s et n r u e L A L omlit s xes e
i
N
i,

1
9

pr clry o [ alc si , a a f t a r u nl h nls u h ae ”;
at ua fr Fi ae f ] l wi
i
l
l ’ rm
rm ht ot ey a de s c css)
i
.
Prlo 2 1 W 3 9 6 2 a * ( Th am ut fim M Fi ae p n da i g
o i , 0 7 L 9 5 0, t 1“ ] e o n ot e r alc s et rf n,
tl
[
. l
t
r v i g a di a zn t e omlit ttl f1. h us a ecs v a d
ei n, n fnl i g h c pan—a oa o 16 o r—ws xes e n
s
i
i
u r ao al Ti cs wsa a l sr i h o wr w g-n -o r ae T ai
nes n be h ae a fi y ta gt r ad a e dh u cs
. s
r
f
a
. ht s
t ebe da dbt r f M Fi ae f [ . .T eC uti d t ai s ol h v
h r a n u e o r alc si . . h o rfn s htt h ud a e
t
. l ’ rm]
t k n M Fi ae he h us a ms t pro t oe a k ” F rh oe a
a e r alc t re o r t ot o e rm hs ts s) ute r
. l
,
,
f
..
rm ,
r d c o i h us s wrat dbc ue [i n adc et spanya a k ht
e ut n n o r i ar ne ea s “]i g o um ni lil ts t a
i
fl
c udh v be pro e b a uirascae rprl gl bln a a o e
ol a e e n e rm d y j no so t o aae a ii g t l wr
f
i
, l
h u y ae”A a zr .1 4 S N hlsAe Rs Cr. N 1- V 7 5
o r rt
l
. lm n a v 3 2 t i oa v e . op, o 4 -8 0
. c
. t
. C
( E ) D) 2 1 W 8 5 4 4 a * 9 S D .. N v 7 2 1)a ot db ,2 1 W
V C( F 0 6 L 6 0 6, t 1 (. .NY o. , 0 6 d p
,
,
e y 07 L
1 9 6 2 S D .. Mr 3,2 1) Gv nFi ae e pre c w h hs mtes
1 4 8 (. .NY a 0 0 7. i e alc s x e n e i t ee a r
.
l ’
i
t
t ,
a d h sri h o wr nt r oti snl- an f cs t eC uti d t ai
n t e tagt r ad aue f h i ge litf ae h o rfn s htt
f
s
p
i
,
s ol h v t k nFi ae he a dahl h us a ms t pro t oe a k
h ud a e a e alc t re n
l
a o r t ot o e rm hs ts s
f
,
,
f
.
T eC uta ad t rea dahl rt e t a t reh us a o e f h et e a
h o r wrs he n
a, ahr h n he o r s n o t e nr s t
f
,
i
is efr09h usb as h dsrp o “Me n w hlet eie c pan ”
s u (o . o r er t e ec t n et g i c n rv d omlit
)
ii
i
t i / s
,
a d h spe um byt eim e p n e e c pse s e wr t a wsnt
n t u rs al h t e x e d d nom ass om o k ht a o
rlt d o h c pan P Ps- il E.Ba 1
eae t t e omlit l ot ra x t .
. .
T ,
A di nlyt eC uti d t a cran nre ae ov g ea t mr
di o a , h o rfn s ht eti et s r s a u s o e t
t
l
i
i
r d c o. S e f a y bt e nS pem e 1 a dS pem e 1,2 1, n h we
e ut n pci l , e we et br 2 n et br 7 0 7i t e e k
i
ic l
bf r t a Ml o a dbl da oa o 1. h us ni e e aae nre t a a
eo e r l uhl n i e ttl f 36 o r i fv s prt et s ht l
i,
l
l
i
l
b a t edsrp o “ ra Pe” r T a Pe aa o. P Ps - il E.Ba 2
er h ec t n T l r p o “ r l r prt n l otT a x
ii
i
i
i ” .
r ,
t.
T ee nre d nt xli w a ts s wr c pee o t e nt r ot e wr
hs et s o o e pan ht a k ee omlt d r h “aue f h o k
i

2
0

d n ” Cry 7 1F2 a 1 4. T eC ut a ifr r t e eoda d r t e
o e ae , 1 . d t 1 8 h o r c n ne fom h rcr n fom h
.
bln s et eti ts s htddntc nt ue hs 1. h us a t a pit
ii g he cran a k t a i o o s tt t oe 36 o r t ht on
l
i
:
,
pet afi g h da e d be s bm t d Dt Ns 3-8 Ml o a dbl da
r - ili ns a l a y e n u i e, k o 3 ; uhl n i e
r l
r
t
. 3
l
l
s prt 12h us n et br8 o “ ra Pe aa o - e ae Da o d et
e aae . o r o S pem e fr T l r prt nP pr rf f i c
i
i r
t
r ,
r ve Pan f D P S T ON f a d alc bl d28h us nS pem e 1 fr
ei w litf E O I I o ” n Fi ae i e . o r o et br 3 o
i
;
l
l
“Me n w hlet ra pe. P Ps - il E.Ba 2 W h u adsrp o o
et g i c n t l r p l otT a x
i
t i -i
” .
r ,
t . i ot ec t n f
t
ii
w a ts sc nt ue Ml o a d pe aa o fr ra bt e nS pem e 1
h t a k o s tt d uhl n s r prt n o t l e we et br 2
i
l ’
i
i
a d1 , h C ut a nt e d y vl ae w ehr h t e x e d d a
n 7 t e o r c n o r ai e aut ht et eim e p n e w s
l
ecs v a dt u t eC uti d i a porae o e ue h h usb a othl
xes e n h s h o r fn st pr p t t r d c t e o r y b u a,
i,
i
f
t s v nh us Se eg Gr a .B d HreP z, n , N 1- V 8 5 (WH)
o e e o r. e .. ac v a os i aI c
, , i
z
. o 4 -8 8
. C
P
,
2 1 W 1 2 5,a * (. .NY J n 1,2 1) r d cn fe i pr d e ov g e
0 7 L 9 9 5 t 6 S D .. a. 8 0 7(e u g es n at u t a u
i
et e ; eesa W e i gI c v W Cr. N 1- V 9 4 L S 2 1 W
nr s Svr l he n, n . PN op, o 0 -5 ( T) 0 6 L
i)
t
l
.
. C
,
1 1 5 1 a * (. .NY Ar 2,2 1) s e Be n n . N wYr L wS h, N
6 1 0, t 4 S D .. p 1 0 6(am) r n a v e ok a c . o
.
;
.
1 - V 3 8 D C(H P 2 1 W 4 7 7 6 a * (. .NY A g 1,2 1)(am)
0C -3 ( L ) B) 0 2 L 1 7 3, t 8 S D .. u. 5 0 2 s e
,
(o etn css a ot db ,2 1 W 4 9 8 6 S D ..S p 2 2 1) Ti i
cl c g ae , d p
l i
)
e y 0 2 L 1 5 2 (. .NY et 0 0 2. h s
.,
s
e pca y wrat dgv n ht h wsa rai wi h ny he w nse
s e l ar ne i e t a ti a t l n h ol t re i ess
il
s
i
c
t
( atr C o a d m n grts fe.
Pso hi n a a a e eti d
,
,
) i
Fr h fr gi g es n t eC uti d t aii a porae oa ad es
o t e oe on r ao s h o rfn s htt s pr p t t wr fe
,
i
fr. h us f wr pro e b Fi aea a h u y ae f$ 2 , o4. h us
o 79 o r o o k e rm d y alc t n o r rt o 4 5 fr 12 o r
f
l
l
o wr pro e b Ml o a da a h u y ae f 2 0 a d o04h us f
f o k e rm d y uhl n t n o r rt o $ 5 , n fr. o r o
f
l
l
wr pro e b S no a a h u y ae f $ 5 . T eeoet eC uta ad
o k e rm d y ats t n o r rt o 2 0 hrfr h o r wrs
f
l
,
Pso a o n y fe o $ 37 75 .
atr t r es es f 1, 5. 0
t
’

2
1

B
.

C ss
ot

Fnly P so se s o eo e $, 2 i css P Ps - il E.Ba 3 A
i a , a tr e k t rc vr 21 5 n ot l otT a x
l
. .
r ,
t. n
eml ye w ope a s na w g-n -o rato i etl d o eo e css N Y
po e h r vi i
l
a ea dh u c n s n te t rc vr ot
i
i
. ..
L b L w§6 31 Cssaedfn da “hs r ao al oto-o kt x e ss
a. a
6() ot r e e s t oe es n be u- pc e e p ne
.
i
f
i c re b a o n y a d ri a l c ag d o hi c et ”Lba cS r br v
n ur d y t r es n odnr y hre t t e l ns el n - e neg .
t
i
ri .
t
F t hr 1 3F3 7 8 7 3 2 C .1 9) “ s w ha o n y fe [] e us n
l c e , 4 . d 4, 6 ( d i 9 8 A i t r es es ar q et g
e
r
.
t t
’ ,
i
pry m s s bt n ae h r q et o css G o .T
at ut usat t t e e usfr ot ” u v omm sS siI c N 1 i
.
y
’ uh n , o 4
, . .
C -9 4 P E 2 1 W 4 2 1,a * (. .NY F b 5 2 1) sea oeg
V 3 6 ( A ) 0 6 L 5 3 9 t 3 S D .. e. , 0 6 e l ,..
,
;
s
,
E c d v Pes a Oea n Cr. N 1- V 3 4 ( D) S L 2 1 W 3 8 4 0
ue a . re h prt g op, o 4 -1 3 A S( I) 0 7 L 0 4 9,
i
. C
,
a * (. .NY J n 3,2 1)“n h as ne fa e ut s bt n a o,apry
t 4 E D .. u e 0 0 7( t e be c o d q ae usat t n
I
ii
at
i nt nte t rc vr ot . . Panf hs a e t poi ea y
s o etl d o eo e css . . litf a fi d o r vd n
i
i
l
s bt n a o, u ha i vie o rcit dc etn t e ot h n w e k t
usat t ns c s n o s r eeps o um n g h css e o se s o
ii
c
,
i
rc vr)a ot db ,2 1 W 38 4 8 E D ..Jl 1,2 1)
eo e ” d p
.,
e y 0 7 L 04 0 (. .NY uy 8 0 7
.
Pso se s e b rem n fr h C u’ $0 fi g e t re e aae
atr e k rim us et o t e or s 4 0 i n fe he s prt
t
l
,
$ 5poessrie fe a d$, 0 i t aitrrtr es P Ps- il E.B
7 rcs -ev r es n 15 0 n r l nepee fe l ot ra x
c
,
i
. .
T ,
a 3 T eC ut a ej d ilnt e f h $ 0 fi g e.Svl ,2 1 W
t . h o r t ks ui a o c ot e 4 0 i n fe ei a 0 7 L
c
i
l
l
1 8 5 2 a * (ai g ui a nt e fi n f e Wie srie esaei t er,
1 5 7, t 8t kn j d il o c ofi g e) h
c
i
l
. l ev fe r n hoy
c
,
c p nal hr “h poes evr es wl ntb a ad d a “ prfomt
om e s be ee t e rcs- r e fe [ i] o e wr e” s a at r is
,
s
l
o n[ii g he , t i n t ee est eFi aeF
w ‘ bln s et’ emz g hs fe h alc i hs a e t s bm a y
l
]i
i
,
l
rm a fi d o u i n
l
t
u dryn dc etto s p otn t a t e es wr i c re. A a zr 2 1
n e i g o um na n u pr g ht h fe ee n ur d lm n a , 0 6
l
i
i
”
W 8 5 4 4 a * 1 sea oeg Svl ,2 1 W 1 8 5 2 a * (eu n t
L 6 0 6, t 2; e l ,.. ei a 0 7 L 1 5 7, t 8 rf s g o
s
, l
i
a ad ot as n s p otn dc etto a d o etn css S ia yi
wr css bet u pr g o um na n n cl c g ae . im r , n
i
i
l i
)
ll

2
2

t eas ne f u pr n dc etto, h Cut wlnta ad ot fr h
h be c o s p ot g o um na nt e o r i o wr css o t e
i
i
l
itrrtr fe
nepees es
’ .
I . o cui n
VC nl so
Fr h fr gi g es n t eC uta ad Pso $ 76 34 i d a e
o t e oe on r ao s h o r wrs atr 5. 3. 0 n am gs
,
a da o n y fe a d ot a antA c Ce nr a dC o p r u n t N L a
n t r es es n css gi s l e l a es n hi us at o Y L, s
t
’
i
flo s
o w
l :
1
.

$45 42 i u pi o et e om e sto;
1, 5. 2 n n ad vr
im c p na n
i

2
.

$45 42 i lqi ae d a e
1, 5. 2 ni udt d am gs
;

3
.

$ 00 0 n tttr p nl e fr w g saem n a d w g nt e
1, 0 i sauoy e ais o a e tt et n a e o c
t
i
voa o s
ilt n
i ;

4
.

P -u gm nitrs o$, 6. 6 cl uae u n ap n pl f
r j d et neet f 43 74 , a lt ds g r c a o
e
c
i
ii
$ 45 42 a a itrs rt o nn pretpry a fomJl 2,
1, 5. 2 t n neet ae f i e ec n e er r
uy 3
2 1 t t edt o ety f u gm n;a d
0 4 o h ae f nr oj d et n

5
.

$ 37 75 i a o n y fe a d$0 i css
1, 5. 0 n t r es es n 4 0 n ot
t
’
.

T eCe k sd et d o nej d et o t epan f c n set w h h
h lr i i ce t etr u gm nfr h litf o s t n i ti
r
i
i
t
s
Oii n
pno.
SO ORD ED
ER .
Dt d N v br2 2 1
ae: o em e 1, 0 7
N wYr, N wYr
e ok e ok

2
3

Ps r.Ac C ae , n
a o v l e l nr Ic
t
i
e s .
N 1 - V 24J C
o 6 C - 6 (L )
.
7
Apn x
ped
i

2
4