Federal Trade Commission et al v. Quincy Bioscience Holding Company, Inc. et al

Filing 164

ORDER: My rulings on the objections made during the deposition of the FTC's 30(b)(6) designee are as follows; as further set forth herein. Defendants' request to compel plaintiff to provide another 30(b) (6) witness is denied. It does no t appear that Ms. Rosso was unprepared to testify or was intentionally evasive. Defendants may serve additional interrogatories to discover any outstanding information to which the Court previously found it was entitled. (Signed by Judge Louis L. Stanton on 3/9/2021) (nb)

L,

Case 1:17-cv-00124-LLS Document 164 Filed 03/09/21 Page 1 of 2
• USDC SD:\\;
·
DOCU'.\1El\T
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EL F.C TRO~ICALLY FILED
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION , ET AL

DO C :1:
DA I i. f_-L_E_D_
I
:

.,

- J__,,_/...,.._ j_
/ f 2-

Plaintiffs ,
- against -

17 Civ . 124

QUINCY BIOSCIENCE HOLDING CO .,
ET . AL .,

INC .,

(LLS)

ORDER

Defendants .
My rulings on the objections made during the deposition of
the FTC ' s 30(b)(6) designee are as follows 1 :
•

pp.

•

p . 29 ,

•

overruled
•

p . 38 ,

pp.

65 - 66 : overruled

p . 7 0 , 1 ine 8:
overruled

pp . 33 - 36 : sustained

•

54 - 57 : sustained

•

line 10 :

pp.

•

10 - 27 : sustained

lines 3-4 ,

•

10 :

p . 39 ,

•

p.

43 ,

p . 76 ,

•

p . 78,

line 5 :

overruled

pp . 49 - 51 : overruled

•

•

pp . 44 - 48 : overruled

•

line 13 :

overruled

line 12 :

overruled

1

p . 7 4 : overruled

•

lines 4 , 14 :

overruled
•

line 15 :

overruled

overruled
•

p . 72 ,

p . 52 : overruled

•

p . 80 ,

line 5 :

overruled

Page numbers are those appearing on 0kt . 157 - 1 .

- 1-

Case 1:17-cv-00124-LLS Document 164 Filed 03/09/21 Page 2 of 2

Defendants '

request to compel plaintiff to provide another

30(b) (6) witness is denied . It does not appear that Ms . Rosso
was unprepared to testify or was intentionally evasive .
Defendants may serve additional interrogatories to discover any
outstanding information to which the Court previously found it
was entitled .
So ordered .
Dated :

New York, New York
March 9 , 2021

~.~ i, ✓f~

Louis L. Stanton
U. S . D. J .

- 2-