Spin Master LTD. et al. v. Amy & Benton Toys and Gifts, CO. LTD. et al.

Filing 81

FINAL JUDGMENT: It is hereby ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED as follows: I. REMAINING DEFENDANTS' OUSTANDING OBLIGATIONS 1. Remaining Defendant Fashion Your Men has satisfied the Individual Damages Award of $50,000.00 in full; 2. The other forty-five (45) Remaining Defendants have not fully satisfied the Individual Damages Award of $50,000.00 and their outstanding obligations are as follows herein. The Clerk's office is directed to terminate any motions and close this case. (Signed by Judge Vernon S. Broderick on 2/3/2021) (nb) Transmission to Finance Unit (Cashiers) for processing.

Case 1:17-cv-05845-VSB Document 80 Filed 02/02/21 Page 1 of 6

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
SPIN MASTER LTD. and SPIN MASTER, INC.,
Plaintiffs
v.
AMY & BENTON TOYS AND GIFTS CO., LTD;
GUANGZHOU COMBUY TOYS CO., LTD A/K/A
COMBUY TOYS & GIFTS CO., LTD.; GUIGANG KM
OVERSEA TRADING CO., LTD.; HEILONGJIANG
YOUTH TRADE CO., LTD.; JINHUA YINUO TOYS
CO., LTD.; NINGBO HOLLY INTELLIGENT
TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD.; NINGBO NBLOSSOM
CRAFT & GIFT CO., LTD.; SHANGHAI
GREATWALL INDUSTRIAL CO., LTD.; SHANTOU
CAPABLE TOYS CO., LTD.; SHANTOU CHENGHAI
JSTOYS FACTORY D/B/A JS TOYS; SHANTOU
CHENGJI TOYS & GIFTS CO., LTD. A/K/A
CHENGHAI CHENGJI TOYS CO., LTD.; SHANTOU
CITY CHENGHAI DISTRICT OCEAN TRADING
FIRM; SHANTOU DENKO ELECTRONICS TOYS
CO., LTD. A/K/A/ SHANTOU DENKO ELECTRONICS
NETWORK CO., LTD.; SHANTOU EASEMATE TOYS
CO., LTD.; SHANTOU FUNNYKIDS TOYS CO., LTD.;
SHANTOU GLOBALWIN TOYS CO., LTD;
SHANTOUGH
JINSHUOYOUPIN
NETWORK
TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD.; SHANTOU KING ONE
TOYS FACTORY A/K/A SHANTOU KING ONE TOYS
INDUSTRIAL CO., LTD.; SHANTOU NEWSTAR
TOYS TRADING FIRM; SHANTOU PRETTY COAST
PLASTIC TOYS CO., LIMITED; SHANTOU
ZHILETIAN TOYS TRADING CO., LTD. D/B/A
ZHILETIAN TOYS; SHENZHEN MINI TUDOU
TRADE CO., LTD.; SHENZHEN OWNSHINE TOYS
LIMITED; SUZHOU DREAMCOLOR TEXTILE CO.,
LTD.; YIWU BRIOSTA APPARELS FACTORY; YIWU
CITY KELE PACKING CO., LTD.; YIWU ECOARTIFACT CO., LTD.; YIWU HEI DU TRADE CO.,
LTD. D/B/A CHINA WHOLESALE SUPERMARKET;
YIWU JIUDI TOYS CO., LIMITED; YIWU MAG
TRADING CO., LTD.; YIWU WENTOU IMPORT &
EXPORT CO., LTD.; ANIME MOVIE TOY STORE

CIVIL ACTION No.
17-cv-5845 (VSB)
[PROPOSED]
FINAL JUDGMENT

Case 1:17-cv-05845-VSB Document 80 Filed 02/02/21 Page 2 of 6

D/B/A INFANT STORE; ANLINBABY CHINA
STORE; BABY-UP STORE; BTEFKR STORE;
CHILDREN’S DREAM WORLD; DOUQU TOY LTD.
STORE; FASHION YOUR MEN; FORESTSUNSHINE
STORE;
HAE&LOVE
SHOOPING
STORE;
HIGHQUALITYHOMEDECORE STORE D/B/A TOYS
HOUSE;
HLTREE
BOUTIQUE
MATERNAL
SUPPLIES & TOY STORE; JKLMOONSALER
STORE; JUSTBUY STORE; KENNAN’S TOY WORLD
STORE; LOLLIPOP S STORE; MA*BB SKIES STORE;
HUNAN LEADSHOPPING E-COMMERCE CO.,
STORE F/K/A MUMMY’S SURPRISE TO BABY
STORE; SMALL FIRE STORE; TOUCH TOY CO.,
LTD.; TOYSKU STORE; TRENDY TOY STORE;
YAMALA TOY STORE; ZOU TRADING CO., LTD.;
BAIBUJU9; BEAUTYLIFE66; JYD INTERNATIONAL
CO., LTD. D/B/A BOHAO88; C360; COMELY2015;
FW781; SHENZHEN FUZECHENG TECHNOLOGY
CO., LTD D/B/A HONGKONG GAMERS TRADING
CO LTD D/B/A GAMERS; HARVEYE; HUAYEYU;
JEANTREE BABY CLOTHINGS; LBDBABY D/B/A
TONGTONG YANG; LIULIANSHENG; SCOT;
SHINAN; BESTAR INTERNATIONAL INDUSTRIAL
LIMITED
D/B/A
SHIXN2008;
SMILEWO;
SPORTSOUTDOOR; VANILLA17; XIAMEN YU
TAIGU TRADE CO., LTD. D/B/A YOUYOU93; and
ZZJ905532742,
Defendants

Case 1:17-cv-05845-VSB Document 80 Filed 02/02/21 Page 3 of 6

WHEREAS, on February 6, 2019, the Court granted Plaintiffs’ motion for summary
judgment with respect to Plaintiffs’ Lanham Act claims, federal copyright infringement claim and
claims under N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law §§ 349-350 (“Summary Judgement Order”);
WHEREAS, in the Summary Judgment Order, the Court awarded statutory damages in the
amount of $50,000.00 (“Individual Damages Award”) for each of the forty-six (46) Remaining
Defendants1 plus post-judgment interest;
WHEREAS, in the Summary Judgment Order, the Court converted the Preliminary
Injunction into a permanent injunction, including an extension of the Asset Restraint;
WHEREAS, on April 8, 2019, the Court entered an Order granting Plaintiffs’ request for a
Post-Judgment Asset Transfer (“Transfer Order”);
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Summary Judgment Order and Transfer Order, Plaintiffs were
able to collect the following amounts from Remaining Defendants’ Frozen Accounts with PayPal,
Inc. in partial satisfaction of the Individual Damages Award:
REMAINING DEFENDANT
Shanghai Greatwall Industrial Co., Ltd.
Shantou Easemate Toys Co., Ltd.
Shantou Pretty Coast Plastic Toys Co., Limited
Yiwu Eco-Artifact Co., Ltd.

AMOUNT
COLLECTED
$165.50
$101.31
$167.04
$1,608.50

1
Defendants Guigang KM Oversea Trading Co., Ltd.; Jinhua Yinuo Toys Co., Ltd.; Ningbo Holly Intelligent
Technology Co., Ltd.; Ningbo Nblossom Craft & Gift Co., Ltd.; Shanghai Greatwall Industrial Co., Ltd.; Shantou
Denko Electronics Toys Co., Ltd. a/k/a Shantou Denko Electronics Network Co., Ltd.; Shantou Easemate Toys Co.,
Ltd.; Shantou Funnykids Toys Co., Ltd.; Shantou Pretty Coast Plastic Toys Co., Limited; Shenzhen Ownshine Toys
Limited; Yiwu Eco-Artifact Co., Ltd.; Yiwu Hei Du Trade Co., Ltd. d/b/a China Wholesale supermarket; Yiwu Jiudi
Toys Co., Limited; Anlinbaby China Store; BTEFKR Store; Children's Dream World; DouQu Toy Ltd. Store; Fashion
Your Men; ForestSunshine Store; Hltree Boutique Maternal Supplies & Toy Store; JKLMOONSALER Store;
Kennan's Toy World Store; MA*BB Skies Store; Hunan Leadshopping E-Commerce Co., Store f/k/a Mummy's
Surprise to Baby Store; ToysKu Store; Trendy Toy Store; ZOU TRADING CO., LTD.; baibuju9; Beautylife66; JYD
International Co., Ltd. d/b/a Bohao88; C360; Comely2015; Fw781; Shenzhen Fuzecheng Technology Co., Ltd. d/b/a
Hongkong Gamers Trading Co Ltd d/b/a Gamers; Harveye; Huayeyu; Jeantree Baby Clothings; Lbdbaby a/k/a
TongTong Yang; Liuliansheng; Scot; Shinana; Bestar International Industrial Limited d/b/a Shinxn2008; Smilewo;
Sportsoutdoor; Vanilla17; Xiamen Yu Taigu Trade Co., Ltd. d/b/a Youyou93 and Zzj905532742 are collectively,
hereinafter referred to as Remaining Defendants.

1

Case 1:17-cv-05845-VSB Document 80 Filed 02/02/21 Page 4 of 6

Children's Dream World
JKLMOONSALER Store
ZOU TRADING CO., LTD.
JYD International co., Ltd. d/b/a Bohao88
C360
Jeantree Baby Clothings

$61.50
$58.00
$22.27
$14.52
$0.43
$483.84

WHEREAS, on December 3, 2020, Plaintiff filed a Proposed Satisfaction of Judgment for
Remaining Defendant Fashion Your Men, which was entered on December 4, 2020;
It is hereby ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED as follows:

I.

REMAINING DEFENDANTS’ OUSTANDING OBLIGATIONS

1. Remaining Defendant Fashion Your Men has satisfied the Individual Damages Award of
$50,000.00 in full;
2. The other forty-five (45) Remaining Defendants have not fully satisfied the Individual
Damages Award of $50,000.00 and their outstanding obligations are as follows:
REMAINING DEFENDANT
Guigang KM Oversea Trading Co., Ltd.

OUTSTANDING
OBLIGATION
$50,000.00

Jinhua Yinuo Toys Co., Ltd.(bunchem)

$50,000.00

Ningbo Holly Intelligent Technology Co., Ltd.

$50,000.00

Ningbo Nblossom Craft & Gift Co., Ltd.

$50,000.00

Shanghai Greatwall Industrial Co., Ltd.

$49,834.50

Shantou Denko Electronics Toys Co., Ltd.
$50,000.00
a/k/a Shantou Denko Electronics Network Co.,
Ltd.
Shantou Easemate Toys Co., Ltd.
Shantou Funnykids Toys Co., Ltd.

$49,898.69
$50,000.00
2

Case 1:17-cv-05845-VSB Document 80 Filed 02/02/21 Page 5 of 6

Shantou Pretty Coast Plastic Toys Co.,
Limited

$49,832.96

Shenzhen Ownshine Toys Limited
Yiwu Eco-Artifact Co., Ltd.
Yiwu Hei Du Trade Co., Ltd. d/b/a China
Wholesale supermarket

$50,000.00
$48,391.50
$50,000.00

Yiwu Jiudi Toys Co., Limited
Anlinbaby China Store
BTEFKR Store
Children's Dream World
DouQu Toy Ltd. Store
ForestSunshine Store
Hltree Boutique Maternal Supplies &Toy
Store

$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$49,938.50
$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$50,000.00

JKLMOONSALER Store
Kennan 's Toy World Store
MA*BB Skies Store
Hunan Leadshopping E-Commerce Co., Store
f/k/a Mummy's Surprise to Baby Store

$49,942.00
$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$50,000.00

ToysKu Store
Trendy Toy Store
ZOU TRADING CO., LTD.
baibuju9
Beautylife66
JYD International co., Ltd. d/b/a Bohao88

$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$49,977.73
$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$49,985.48

Comely2015
Fw781
Zhenzhen Fuzecheng Technology Co. Ltd.
d/b/a HongKong Gamers Trading Co Ltd.
d/b/a Gamers

$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$50,000.00

Harveye
Huayeyu
Jeantree Baby Clothings
Lbdbaby d/b/a TongTong Yang
Liuliansheng
Scot
Shinan

$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$49,516.16
$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$50,000.00
3

Case 1:17-cv-05845-VSB Document 80 Filed 02/02/21 Page 6 of 6

Bestar International Industrial Limited d/b/a
Shixn2008

$50,000.00

Smilewo
Sportsoutdoor
Vanilla17
Xiamen Yu Taigu Trade Co., Ltd. d/b/a
Youyou93

$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$50,000.00
$50,000.00

Zzj905532742

$50,000.00
The Clerk's office is directed to terminate any motions and close this case

SO ORDERED.
February
3rd
SIGNED this _____ day of ____________, 2021, at _______ __.m
________________________________
HON. VERNON S. BRODERICK
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

4