Anderson et al v. Islamic Republic of Iran

Filing 125

ORDER: The Exhibits to the Court's Report & Recommendation filed at ECF No. 10755 are amended to (1) include $12.5 million in solatium damages for Plaintiff Margaret Randazzo- Maloy, the spouse of 9/11 decedent Gene Maloy; (2) correct the spelling of the surname of Personal Representative Sandra Heffernan; and (3) correct the spelling of the surname of Latent Injury Decedent Charles Williams. The Court therefore recommends awarding damages as reflected in the attached Exhibits. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn on 3/6/2025) Filed In Associated Cases: 1:03-md-01570-GBD-SN et al. (dsh)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
-----------------------------------------------------------------X
In re:

3/6/2025
03-MD-01570 (GBD)(SN)

TERRORIST ATTACKS ON
SEPTEMBER 11, 2001

ORDER

-----------------------------------------------------------------X
SARAH NETBURN, United States Magistrate Judge:
This document relates to:
Accardi v. Islamic Republic of Iran, No. 21-cv-06247 (GBD)(SN)
Alexander v. Islamic Republic of Iran, No. 21-cv-03505 (GBD)(SN)
Amin v. Islamic Republic of Iran, No. 20-cv-00412 (GBD)(SN)
Anderson v. Islamic Republic of Iran, No. 20-cv-00354 (GBD)(SN)
Betso v. Islamic Republic of Iran, No. 21-cv-01394 (GBD)(SN)
The Exhibits to the Court’s Report & Recommendation filed at ECF No. 10755 are
amended to (1) include $12.5 million in solatium damages for Plaintiff Margaret RandazzoMaloy, the spouse of 9/11 decedent Gene Maloy; (2) correct the spelling of the surname of
Personal Representative Sandra Heffernan; and (3) correct the spelling of the surname of Latent
Injury Decedent Charles Williams. The Court therefore recommends awarding damages as
reflected in the attached Exhibits.
SO ORDERED.

DATED:

March 6, 2025
New York, New York

SARAH NETBURN
United States Magistrate Judge

Exhibit A

Latent Injury Decedents - ECF No. 9766

Personal Representative
First
1

Middle

Jill
Robin

Matthew
2 Robert
Kristin

Last

9/11 Decedent
Suffix

Accardi
Mundy-Sutton
B.

Blair
Blair
Folberth

Jr.

First

Middle

Last

Suffix

Claim Information
Nationality
on 9/11

Date of
Death

9/11
Site

Case

Complaint

Pain & Suffering
Damages
Amount

Notes

William

Mundy

U.S.

10/19/13 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 1
21-cv-06247, 1 at 4

$7,000,000

Robert

Blair

U.S.

12/6/17 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 1
21-cv-06247, 1 at 1
21-cv-06247, 1 at 2

Matthew B. Blair, Robert Blair, Jr., and Kristin
$7,000,000 Folberth are Co-Executors of Robert Blair's
Estate.

3 Gloria

Finegan

Patrick

Finegan

U.S.

11/7/14 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 2

$7,000,000

4 Denise

Grossarth

Glenn

Grossarth

U.S.

12/3/16 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 2

$7,000,000

5 Caroline

Lodewyks

Matthew

Lodewyks

U.S.

1/6/18 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 3

$7,000,000

6 Pamela

Mahoney

Kevin

U.S.

2/15/18 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 3

$7,000,000

7 Michele

McLean

Hernan

McLean

U.S.

11/12/09 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 4

$7,000,000

8 Doreen

Morstatt

Joseph

A

Morstatt

U.S.

3/5/16 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 4

$7,000,000

9 Kathleen

Nerney

Kevin

P

Nerney

U.S.

12/18/15 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 4

$7,000,000

10 Marian

Pennachio

James

Lanza

U.S.

4/6/17 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 4

$7,000,000

11 Genevieve

Sharp

William

Sharp

U.S.

3/26/17 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 5

$7,000,000

12 Josh

Weismer

Diane

Pillersdorf

U.S.

5/1/12 NY

21-cv-06247

21-cv-06247, 1 at 5

$7,000,000

P.

Mahoney

Sr.

Jill Accardi and Robin Mundy-Sutton are CoExecutors of William Mundy's Estate.

Exhibit B

Latent Injury Decedents - ECF No. 9770

Personal Representative
First

Middle

1 Evelyn
2 Amy
3 Maria
4 Paula
5 Maryrose

6 Joanna
7 Karen
8 Liam
9 Cheryl
10 Sandra
11 Patricia
12 Steven
13 Melissa
14 Bonnie
15 Stephen
16 Jennifer
17 Ari
18 Bessie
19 Lisa
20 Rosalie
21 Tresa
22 Laura
23 Patricia
24 Virginia
25 Nakia
26 Denise
27 Katherine

L.

9/11 Decedent

Claim Information

Pain &
Suffering
Damages

Date of 9/11
Case
Death
Site
6/17/15 NY
21-cv-01394

21-cv-01394, 1 at 1

$7,000,000

Betso

James

Betso

Nationality on
9/11
U.S.

Bosche
CastroMorales
Cohen
DeNunzio

Christopher

Bosche

U.S.

9/12/17 NY

21-cv-01394

21-cv-01394, 1 at 1

Formerly Amy L.
$7,000,000 Christian

Gregorio
Ronald
James

Morales
Cohen
DeNunzio

U.S.
U.S.
U.S.

7/30/16 NY
11/25/14 NY
3/2/13 NY

21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394

21-cv-01394, 1 at 1
21-cv-01394, 1 at 1
21-cv-01394, 1 at 1

$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000

Last

DixonReisman
Gaines
Greaney
HafnerZawada
Heffernan
Kalbouros
Lakeman
Lawson
Malloy
McCarey
McNamara
Meisel
Mercado
Quick
Ragucci
Roth
Runco
Stines
Sullivan
Torres
Trapani
Ventriglia

Suffix

First

Middle

Last

Suffix

Complaint

Amount

Notes

Steven
Scott
Thomas

B.
N.

Reisman
Gaines
Greaney

U.S.
U.S.
U.S.

6/1/14 NY
9/27/17 NY
1/5/14 NY

21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394

21-cv-01394, 1 at 2
21-cv-01394, 1 at 2
21-cv-01394, 1 at 2

Claimant's name
was mispelled as
Johanna on the
original
$7,000,000 complaint
$7,000,000
$7,000,000

Stephen
James
Kevin
Georgetta
Roger
Brian
Eugene
John
Elisabeth
David
William
Raymond
Robert
Robert
James
Lawrence
Walter
Franco
Robert

L.

Zawada
Heffernan
Czatoryski
Lakeman
Steinert
Malloy
McCarey
McNamara
Temin
Mahmoud
Quick
Ragucci
Roth
Runco
Stines
Sullivan
Torres
Trapani
Ventriglia

U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.

11/23/12 NY
12/1/13 NY
12/5/10 NY
11/17/16 NY
6/2/17 NY
3/28/11 NY
11/13/14 NY
8/9/09 NY
2/14/11 NY
11/11/10 NY
1/18/11 NY
9/4/11 NY
3/16/08 VA
12/20/14 NY
3/17/14 NY
8/20/12 NY
12/18/12 NY
12/4/10 NY
11/2/10 NY

21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394
21-cv-01394

21-cv-01394, 1 at 2
21-cv-01394, 1 at 3
21-cv-01394, 1 at 3
21-cv-01394, 1 at 3
21-cv-01394, 1 at 3
21-cv-01394, 1 at 3
21-cv-01394, 1 at 3
21-cv-01394, 1 at 3
21-cv-01394, 1 at 4
21-cv-01394, 1 at 4
21-cv-01394, 1 at 4
21-cv-01394, 1 at 4
21-cv-01394, 1 at 4
21-cv-01394, 1 at 4
21-cv-01394, 1 at 4
21-cv-01394, 1 at 5
21-cv-01394, 1 at 5
21-cv-01394, 1 at 5
21-cv-01394, 1 at 5

$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000

C.
C.
F.

M.

J.

J.

Exhibit C

Latent Injury Decedents - ECF No. 9776

Personal Representative
First

Middle

1 Raymond
2 Robert

Last

9/11 Decedent
Suffix

Alexander
Anderson

Robert
Carl

AurelloBeauchamp
BrowneMarshall

3 Lucia
4 Gloria
5 Anna

R.

Byrnes

6 Lawrence
7 Patricia

M.

Byrnes
Byrnes

8 Donna
9 June
10 Lynn
11 Jean
12 Anne
13 John
14 Mary
15 Sara
16 Denise

Canari
Murphy Carrozza
Casey
Marie
DeBiase
Dierking
Dimor
Eikeseth
Lea
Elarat
Flanagan

First

Middle
P.

Charles
Ernest
Jr.

Claim Information

Pain &
Suffering
Damages

Alexander
Anderson

Nationality
on 9/11
U.S.
U.S.

Date of 9/11
Case
Death
Site
8/14/17 NY
21-cv-03505
8/26/14 NY
21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 1
21-cv-03505, 5 at 1

$7,000,000
$7,000,000

Aurello

U.S.

6/22/18 NY

21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 1

Listed as Lucia Beauchamp$7,000,000 Aurello in Complaint

Last

Complaint

Amount

Marshall

U.S.

12/5/16 NY

21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 1

$7,000,000

Kevin

R.

Byrnes

U.S.

2/4/04 NY

21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 2

$7,000,000

Lawrence
Joseph

M.
L.

Byrnes
Battaglia

U.S.
U.S.

6/14/15 NY
8/5/09 NY

21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 2
21-cv-03505, 5 at 2

$7,000,000
$7,000,000

Canari
Carrozza
Casey
DeBiase
Wolken
Hersh
Eikeseth
Elarat
Flanagan

U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.

12/15/15 NY
1/11/15 NY
7/3/13 NY
4/9/06 NY
3/4/17 NY
8/7/11 NY
3/15/19 NY
12/30/18 NY
2/3/12 NY

21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 2
21-cv-03505, 5 at 2
21-cv-03505, 5 at 3
21-cv-03505, 5 at 3
21-cv-03505, 5 at 4
21-cv-03505, 5 at 4
21-cv-03505, 5 at 4
21-cv-03505, 5 at 4
21-cv-03505, 5 at 4

$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000

John
Francis
Peter
Mark
Ronald
Donna
Leif
Marcos
Peter

Evan

17 Elizabeth
18 Martha
19 Gwendolyn

Garcia Roman
Gless
Hanlon

Richard
Robert
Kevin

Lopez
Gless
Hanlon

U.S.
U.S.
U.S.

6/24/18 NY
10/25/16 NY
8/25/17 NY

21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 5
21-cv-03505, 5 at 5
21-cv-03505, 5 at 5

$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000

20 Lynn
21 Barbara
22 Jody
23 Keisha

Hansell-Perkins
Hanson
Hawkes
Henderson

Gary
Harold
Robert
Auriel

Perkins
Hanson
Hawkes
Henderson

U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.

6/19/19 NY
3/26/19 NY
10/22/13 NY
12/28/16 NY

21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505

24 Elizabeth
25 Gresy
26 Leigh
27 Hillary
28 Joan
29 Winston

Horne
Johnson
Jones
Katzman
Lalicata
Lewis

Cornell
Stephen
Charles
Howard
Salvatore
Charles

Horne
Johnson
Jones
Katzman
Lalicata
Williams

U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.

10/5/14 NY
11/28/10 NY
1/29/13 NY
4/27/14 NY
1/14/17 NY
7/10/18 NY

21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 5
21-cv-03505, 5 at 5
21-cv-03505, 5 at 6
21-cv-03505, 5 at 6
21-cv-03505, 5 at 6
21-cv-03505, 5 at 7
21-cv-03505, 5 at 7
21-cv-03505, 5 at 7
21-cv-03505, 5 at 7
21-cv-03505, 5 at 7

$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000

Mansberger
Mazzillo
Mendizza

James
Robert
Rod

Mansberger
Mahon
Mendizza

U.S.
U.S.
U.S.

8/1/18 NY
4/8/16 NY
11/1/18 NY

21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 8
21-cv-03505, 5 at 8
21-cv-03505, 5 at 9

$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000

30 Carolyn
31 Lee
32 Jennifer

Anne

Ann
Lynn

B.

Notes

Latent Injury Decedents - ECF No. 9776

33 Sheif
34 Jean
35 Anna

Mesiha
Meyerowitz
Murray

Karen
Andrew
Edward

Mesiha
Libo
Murray

U.S.
U.S.
U.S.

12/12/15 NY
10/25/11 NY
2/24/16 NY

21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 9
21-cv-03505, 5 at 9
21-cv-03505, 5 at 9

$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000

36 Margaret
37 Chantal

O’Hanlon
Paultre

Michael
Jacques

O'Hanlon
Paultre

U.S.
U.S.

8/28/17 NY
6/24/08 NY

21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 9
21-cv-03505, 5 at 10

$7,000,000
$7,000,000

38 Margaret
39 Neelam
40 Brittany
41 Jane

RandazzoMaloy
Silhi
Smith
Tuohy

Gene
Louis
Daniel
Joseph

Maloy
Bryan
Smith
Tuohy

U.S.
U.S.
U.S.
U.S.

9/11/01 NY
11/7/16 NY
2/7/16 NY
11/8/17 NY

21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505
21-cv-03505

21-cv-03505, 5 at 10
21-cv-03505, 5 at 10
21-cv-03505, 5 at 10
21-cv-03505, 5 at 11

The only Decedent killed in
$2,000,000 the 9/11 Terrorist Attacks.
$7,000,000
$7,000,000
$7,000,000

Edward
G.
G.

Exhibit D

Solatium - ECF No. 9776

Claimant
First

1 Margaret

Middle

Last

Randazzo-Maloy

9/11 Decedent
Suffix

Nationality on
9/11

US

First

Gene

Middle

Edward

Last

Maloy

Claim Information

Nationality on
9/11

Date of
Death

9/11
Site

US

9/11/01 NY

Case

21-cv-03505

Complaint

21-cv-03505, 5 at 10

Solatium Damages
Relationship

Spouse

Amount

$

Notes

12,500,000 00 Spouse of 9/11 decedent

Exhibit E

Latent Injury Decedents - ECF No. 9995

Personal Representative
First

1 Lauren

2 Florence

a) Jill
3 b) Robin

Middle

Ann

Last

Fischer

Hoosein

a) Lynch
b) Rossi

Claimant
Suffix

First

Michael

Rebecca

Roberto

Middle

F.

A.

Carlo

Last

Shipsey

Buck

Rossi

Suffix

Pain & Suffering Damages

Claim Information
Nationality on
9/11 Site
9/11

US

US

US

NY

NY

NY

Case

20cv00354

20cv00412

20cv00412

Complaint

20cv00354,11 at
15

20cv00412, 13 at
11

20cv00412, 13 at
15

Amendments &
Substitutions

9992

9992

9992

Documentation

Amount

Notes

8356, 8356-3, 8356-4,
8356-15 at 2

R. & R. at ECF 8901,
adopted at ECF 9274,
recommended damages
sought here, but death of
prior Personal
Representative required
substitution and re-filing,
see R. & R. at ECF 9216,
$7,000,000 adopted at ECF 9274.

8375, 8375-3, 8375-4
at 8, 8375-13 at 6

R. & R. at ECF 8901,
adopted at ECF 9274,
recommended damages
sought here, but death of
prior Personal
Representative required
substitution and re-filing,
see R. & R. at ECF 9216,
$7,000,000 adopted at ECF 9274.

8375, 8375-3, 8375-4
at 68, 8375-14 at 12

R. & R. at ECF 8901,
adopted at ECF 9274,
recommended damages
sought here, but death of
prior Personal
Representative required
substitution and re-filing,
see R. & R. at ECF 9216,
$7,000,000 adopted at ECF 9274.