United States of America v. Jujamcyn Theaters LLC

Filing 6

ADDENDUM TO CONSENT DECREE NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED as follows:1. This Court has jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 42 U.S.C. §12188(b)(1)(B) and 42 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1345.2. The Consent Decree is he reby modified with respect solely to the Theater andsolely with regard to the Production for the duration of its run; in other words, solely as to theAugust Wilson Theater for the planning, production, and closing (if any) of Cabaret. ThisAddendum do es not alter the duties and responsibilities of the parties as to any other theater, nordoes it alter or amend any provision of the Consent Decree except as specifically indicatedherein.Upon the conclusion of the Production, the Theater shall revert to the specifications set forth in the Consent Decree, including with respect to the seating plan, wheelchair accessible seating and aisle transfer seating locations. (And as further set forth herein.) SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Analisa Torres on 11/15/2023) (jca)

Download PDF
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ------------------------------------X UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Plaintiff, : ADDENDUM TO CONSENT DECREE : v. : JUJAMCYN THEATERS LLC, : Defendant. 11/15/2023 21 Civ. 5853 (AT) : ------------------------------------X WHEREAS, the United States of America (the “Government”) commenced this action to enforce provisions of Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (“ADA”), 42 U.S.C. §§ 12181 et seq., and the Department of Justice regulations implementing Title III of the ADA, 28 C.F.R. Pt. 36 (the “Regulations”), and the ADA Standards for Accessible Design, consisting of 28 C.F.R. Pt. 36, App. D (the “1991 Standards”); and Appendices B and D to 36 C.F.R. Pt. 1191 (2009), and the requirements contained in subpart D of 28 C.F.R. Pt. 36 (the “2010 Standards”), against Jujamcyn Theaters LLC (“Jujamcyn”) with respect to, inter alia, the August Wilson Theatre, opened in 1925 and located at 245 West 52nd Street (the “Theater”); WHEREAS, the Theater is owned by Jujamcyn, which is a limited liability company organized under the laws of Delaware and headquartered in New York; WHEREAS, Jujamcyn and the United States entered into a Consent Decree approved and entered by the Court on July 12, 2021, pursuant to which Jujamcyn agreed to make certain accessibility improvements to the Theater; WHEREAS, by notice dated October 12, 2021, January 19, 2022, and February 17, 2022, Jujamcyn certified that it complied with the obligations of the Consent Decree with regard to the Theater; WHEREAS, Jujamcyn now proposes significant alterations to the Theater pursuant to paragraph 17 of the Consent Decree to permit a “theater in the round” production of “Cabaret” (the “Production”); WHEREAS, the Production will reduce the total number of seating locations in the Theater, and WHEREAS, the United States has reviewed the proposed alterations and has no objection thereto; NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED as follows: 1. This Court has jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 12188(b)(1)(B) and 42 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1345. 2. The Consent Decree is hereby modified with respect solely to the Theater and solely with regard to the Production for the duration of its run; in other words, solely as to the August Wilson Theater for the planning, production, and closing (if any) of “Cabaret.” This Addendum does not alter the duties and responsibilities of the parties as to any other theater, nor does it alter or amend any provision of the Consent Decree except as specifically indicated herein. 3. The Consent Decree is hereby modified with respect to the Theater for the duration of the Production as follows: A. Entrance to the Theater: Paragraph 5 of the Consent Decree is amended to the extent that Jujamcyn shall provide an accessible entrance route at the Theater as set forth in Exhibit 1. B. Restrooms: Paragraph 6 of the Consent Decree is amended to the extent that Jujamcyn shall maintain two wheelchair accessible unisex toilet rooms that meet the requirements of 2010 Standards §§ 213, 603-606, to the extent set forth in Exhibit 1, it being agreed that the existing wheelchair accessible unisex toilet room is not being altered and shall meet the requirements of 2010 Standards §§ 213, 603-606, as and to the extent set forth in Exhibit 2A of the Consent Decree. C. Egress Route: Paragraph 9 of the Consent Decree is amended to the extent that Jujamcyn shall provide in the Theater a designated access route to the extent set forth in Exhibit 1. D. Wheelchair and Companion Seating Locations: Paragraph 14 of the Consent Decree is amended to the extent that Jujamcyn shall provide eleven (11) wheelchair seating locations and the associated companion seating locations at the Theater to the extent set forth in Exhibit 1. It is agreed that each wheelchair seating location at a table shall be permitted to be sold only if both seats at such table are purchased, so long as seats at all other tables sold to the general public at the StandardAdmission price for table seats are also sold only in pairs. E. Aisle Transfer Seating: Paragraph 16 of the Consent Decree is amended to the extent that Jujamcyn shall provide and maintain aisle seats that are equipped with folding armrests or, in the case of seats at tables, at Jujamcyn’s option, no armrests (“designated aisle seats”) to the extent set forth in Exhibit 1. F. Ticket Pricing: Paragraph 18 of the Consent Decree is amended to the extent that the ticket pricing for wheelchair and companion seating locations in the Theater shall be as follows: (a) six of the wheelchair seating locations and one companion seat for each such wheelchair seating location shall be offered for sale to wheelchair users and their companions at the lowest ticket price at which tickets are offered for sale for Standard-Admission Seats for the general public at the Theater; (b) the remaining five wheelchair seating locations and one companion seat for each such wheelchair seating location shall be offered for sale to wheelchair users and their companions at the price of the tickets for Standard-Admission Seats in proximity to the wheelchair seating locations; (c) all remaining wheelchair companion seating locations may be priced at the price of tickets for standard-admission, non-accessible seats in proximity to the applicable wheelchair seating location; and (d) all aisle transfer seating locations shall be offered for sale to people with disabilities at the price at which adjacent seating locations in the same row are offered for sale for that performance, or, in the event such adjacent seating locations are not, for that performance, being offered for sale to the general public, at the price such seating locations would otherwise be offered for sale for that performance to the general public. 4. Upon the conclusion of the Production, the Theater shall revert to the specifications set forth in the Consent Decree, including with respect to the seating plan, wheelchair accessible seating and aisle transfer seating locations. Dated: November 15, 2023 New York, New York Exhibit 1 REFERENCE TO 2022BC §28.2-1009.6 Areas of rescue assistance. Every required area of rescue assistance shall be accessible from the space it serves by one or more accessible means of egress components as listed in Section 28.2-1009.2. §28.2-1009.6.2 Stairway or elevator access. Every required area of rescue assistance shall have direct access to a stairway complying with Sections 28.2-1009.3 and 28.2-1023, or an elevator complying with Section 28.2-1009.4. DANCE II §28.2-1009.6.3 Size. Each area of rescue assistance shall be sized to accommodate one wheelchair space of 30 inches by 48 inches (762 mm by 1220 mm) for each 200 occupants or portion thereof, based on the occupant load of the area of rescue assistance and areas served by the area of rescue assistance. Such wheelchair spaces shall not reduce the means of egress minimum width or required capacity. Access to any of the required wheelchair spaces in an area of rescue assistance shall not be obstructed by more than one adjoining wheelchair space. Every required area of rescue assistance shall be accessible from the space it serves by one or more accessible means of egress components as listed in Section 28.2-1009.2. FIRE GUARD ASSIGNED TO WHEELCHAIR SAFE AREA STAIR J 4HR 4HR 4HR DN 106A UP UP FG X 4HR 4HR M1 FG C 9" 3' - C C C C C C 4' 101 C S " 21 T C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C S 21 " C C RED BAR 102 AISLE TRANSFER SEAT AISLE TRANSFER COMPANION SEAT 3' RAM P (+ 1:12 24") DN WHEELCHAIR COMPANION SEATS EXTENTS OF REAR ORCHESTRA BAR. MERCH AREA AND ASSISTIVE LISTENING DEVICE LOCATION TO BE INCLUDED WITHIN THIS ZONE S 21 " 21 S " S 21 " 4HR STAIR 5 WHEELCHAIR POSITION WITH 36" X 48" CLEARANCE EL 3''-0" HOUSE-SIDE SEATING ADA 1:12 RAMP BAR AREA (SERVICE SIDES INDICATED BY ARROWS) 21 S " S 21 " 21 S " 4' X STAIR B EX X X 4' EX 4HR EX EX 4HR X DN EX ENTRY CORRIDOR 104 STAIR A DN DN UP DN EX EX EX EX PROJECT MANAGEMENT GBA 214 WEST 43RD STREET NEW YORK, NY 10036 telephone 917.300.1199 THEATRE CONSULTANTS CHARCOALBLUE 330 7TH AVE, SUITE2002 NEW YORK, NY 10001 telephone 212.645.0790 STRUCTURAL ENGINEER MCLAREN ENGINEERING 131 W 35TH STREET, 4TH FL NEW YORK, NY 10001 telephone 212.324.6300 MEP ENGINEER AMA GROUP 825 8TH AVE., FL18 NEW YORK, NY 10019 telephone 212.944.7722 CODE CONSULTANT NYCCODE 114 W 47TH STREET, C1 NEW YORK, NY 10036 telephone 212.586.2114 CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT YORKE CONSTRUCTION 140 WEST 31ST STREET, 4TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NY 10001 telephone 212.564.8467 DN EXISTING ADA RESTROOM PER EXISTING CONSENT DECREE EX KEY PLAN: UP W 53RD ST UP STAIR I EX CLIENT AMBASSADOR THEATRE GROUP 630 NINTH AVE, SUITE 800 NEW YORK, NY 10036 telephone 646.973.1592 EX BROADWAY EXTISTING WHEELCHAIR LIFT UP UP KOSTOW GREENWOOD ARCHITECTS 594 BROADWAY, SUITE 300 NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10012 telephone 212.334.0116 STAIR G UP 106C STAIR C EXUP DN DN FIRE GUARD 1" EL 2'-2 1/2" C C 4HR WHEELCHAIR PATRON PATH TO SEAT C C C 4HR WHEELCHAIR LIFT ADA 1:12 RAMP C C C 4HR 4' 4'-6" C C C EX EX UP STAIR 3 RAMP (+2 1/2") 1:12 UP EX 106D EX 5' X STAIR 1 4HR FLAT PORTION OF REAR ORCHESTRA BAR 3' 5 10 4HR X X C C EL 2 1/2" C DN X C C C STAGE UP EXISTING RAKED ORCHESTRA FLOOR TO REMAIN. SLIGHT ADJUSTMENTS TO BE MADE TO THE EXISTING ADA CONCRETE PLATFORMS TO CREATE SMOOTH AND LEVEL WALKING SURFACE 4HR C C C C S S S 21" 2 S S S 21" 21" 1" 2 S 21" 1" S S S 21" S S S S 21" S S S S1" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21 S " 21" S 21" 2 21" S S 1" S 21" S S 21" 2 S " S 20 S S 21" S " S 1 1 S " 2 S S 2 S " 2 S 21" 21" S 21" 21 " " 21" 0" S S 21" 21" 21 21" S S S " 21 20 21" S 21" S " S 1 2 S " 1 2 S S 1 2 " 2 20 S " 2 0 " S S S " " S 1" " S S 21 S S 20 S " 21 21 S 21" 21" S 21 " " " 21 2 S 1 " 1 1 " S 2 2 21" " S " 2 1 0 2 S 21" S 21" S " S 1 20 21" S S " 20 S 21" S " 2 " S " 2 S 21" S S 1 S 1" 21 20 S S S 2 2 0" S S S " " S 21" " 21 " 1 " 21" 2 21 S " 1 2 2 S 1 2 " S " 0 1 1 2 " 2 S " S 2 S 21" S 1 1 " 2 S " 21" S 20 0" S S " 2 S 21" " 2 S 21" 1 20 S " 21 S S S 21" S S 0" S S S " 2 " S 1 S 1 20 20 S " 2 1" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21 S 2 2 S " 1 " " 2 S " S S 1 " S 2 " 2 1 S S 1 20 " 2 2 S " " 2 1 21 1 1" S " S " S 1 S 21" S " 2 2 2 2 2 " C C 1" S 1" S S " 0" C C 1 S " 21 21 C C S " 2 21 21 C " S C S " 21 1 " 2 S 2 1" S C C 1 S " 21 S " 2 C 21 " C 21 1 " S 2 C S " C 21 1 " S C C C C S " 2 C C 21 C " C 21 C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C S " 1 S " 2 21 4HR S T 21" C 4HR C C 4HR C C 4HR C C Checked by Checker UP " All rights reserved. No part of this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form without the prior written authorization of Kostow Greenwood Architects, LLP. Drawn by Author C 10 X 8 10 © 2023 Kostow Greenwood Architects, LLP C C C C 3'- STAGE-SIDE SEATING C 4' 106 " 6 3'- C C C DN STAIR H S " 21 C C S AI 2 HR UP 24") P (+ M RA :12 1 STAIR 6 DN X LE S " 1 S " 2 21 2 HR X STAIR 4 S " 21 2 HR S S H 21" 2 S S S 2H 1" 2 H 1"" 21" S 1" S H1" 2211"" 21 2 1 S " 2S S 2 1" S 2H1"" 21" S 21" S 2H11"" 21 S 21" S S S S S 2 " 1 " 1 " 21" 2 21" S S S 1S" 2 1" 21 21" S 21S" " 221" 2 21 S S" 1 S S 2 S 21 S " S S S " 21" S 1"1" 21 S S 2S S S " 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21 S " 21" S S 21 T 21" 2 S 21 " 21" 1 " T 2 S 1" 2 S S T 1" 2 1" S 21" 2 S S S S S S 21 S S 21" " S S S " 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21 21" S S " 21" S S 21 S 21" 21 S 21" 21" 21" 1" " S S 2 S " S 1 1 " 2 2 " 2 1" S 21" S S 21" S " 21 S S S S 21 21" S S S S 21" " S S 21 2 1 S 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" S S " 2S S 21" S 21" 21" 21" " 1" S 21" S S S 21 1" 2 2 2 " 1 1" S S 21" " S S S " 21 S S 21" S 21 S S 21" 21" 21" 2S S S S 21" " S 2 " S 1" " S " 21 1 21 S 2 2 1 " " S 21 1" 21" S S S 21" 21" 21 " 21 21" " S S 1" S " 21 2 T 2 2 1" S T 1" S S 21" 21" S S 21 S S S 2 S 1 S 21" S S 1" 2 " S 21" 21 1 " S " S " 2 21" 2 S S " 2S 21 1" 21" 21" S " 21 S 1" 2 1" 2 " 1" S 21 1" S S 21" 2 S 21 2 T 2 1 " 1 T " 2S " S S 21" S S S " 21 S 21 1" S S S S S 21" 1 " S 2 S 21" 21" 21" 2 1 " 1 S " S " 2 2 " 21" S S 21" 21" 1" S 21 2 2 S 1 " 1 21 S 21" S " " 21" S T S " 21 21 T S 21" 1 " S 21 C C " C C S 2 " S 1 2 2 S C 1 C 21 1" " S " C C S " S " 2 2 S " 21 C 21 1" C " S C 21 21 C 2 T 1 T " S C 21 C " S " 21 2 HR EX 2HR NEW WHEELCHAIR LIFT TO MEZZANINE 37 1/4" X 51" CLEAR PLATFORM SIZE 750 LB CAPACITY S " 0 S " 2 0 2 ADA RESTROOMS ACCESS LADDER ROOM 2 HR STAIR 2 DN DN EXTERIOR COURT EX X EX STAIR K DOORS INTO ENTRY COURT ARE 90 MIN., TYP. 10 6B 4HR 111 UP X 111 ADA RR LEGEND 4HR DN 112 ENTRY CORRIDOR 4'-11" 4HR 103 8TH AVE SECOND ADA RESTROOM AUGUST WILSON THEATRE 245 W 52ND STREET NEW YORK, NY 10019 EX W 52ND ST DESCRIPTION ACCESSIBLE PATH 1 DOJ SEATING PLAN ORCHESTRA scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" NO DATE WEST 52ND STREET WEST 52ND STREET 1ST FLOOR (ORCHESTRA LEVEL) DOB NOW no TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE AND PROFESSIONAL JUDGEMENT THESE DRAWINGS ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE NEW YORK CITY BUILDING CODE AND ADA COMPLIANCE. project no NOTE: DO NOT SCALE OFF OF PLANS drawing no M00914934-I1 23-002 scale 1/8" = 1'-0" graphic scale 0 8' DOJ-001.00 sheets in set 1 OF 35 DANCE II AUGUST WILSON THEATRE 245 W 52ND STREET NEW YORK, NY 10019 KOSTOW GREENWOOD ARCHITECTS 594 BROADWAY, SUITE 300 NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10012 telephone 212.334.0116 OPEN TO BELOW X NEW WHEELCHAIR LIFT TO MEZZANINE DN STAIR 4 DN E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E MEP ENGINEER AMA GROUP 825 8TH AVE., FL18 NEW YORK, NY 10019 telephone 212.944.7722 CODE CONSULTANT NYCCODE 114 W 47TH STREET, C1 NEW YORK, NY 10036 telephone 212.586.2114 C E C C E E C B 21 " B 21 B 21 " " B 2 B 1 " 21 B 21 B " 21 " " 2 B 1" E E E E E STAIR 3 E DN CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT YORKE CONSTRUCTION 140 WEST 31ST STREET, 4TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NY 10001 telephone 212.564.8467 E E E DN STRUCTURAL ENGINEER MCLAREN ENGINEERING 131 W 35TH STREET, 4TH FL NEW YORK, NY 10001 telephone 212.324.6300 E E E DN THEATRE CONSULTANTS CHARCOALBLUE 330 7TH AVE, SUITE2002 NEW YORK, NY 10001 telephone 212.645.0790 E E E B B B B B B B B B 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21 B B " 21" B B 21" 21" 21" 21" B B 21" 21" B B 21" B B B B B 21" B " B B 21 B B 21" B 21" B 21" 21" 2 B 21" 21" B 21" B 1" 21 B 21" 21" 21" 21 " " 21 B " 2B B 21" B " 21 " 21 B 1" B B 21" " 1 B B B 2 B B 21" B B " B " 21 1 B B 2 1 21" B B " B 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 2 B B " B " 2 1 B 21" B 21 2 " 1 2 1 " B " 2 1 1 2 B " B B 1 " 1 " 2 1 " B 2 2 B " 21" B 2 21 " " B 1 1 2 " B 1 B B 21" B " B B B B " 21 B B 1" 2 B B 2 B " 2 21 1 2 B 1 21" 21" 21 " " B " 1 B " 21 2 B 1 2 1 " " 2 1 1 " " B B " B 2 2 2 2 2 " 1 1 " 21 B 2 1 " 1 B 1 " B 1 " " 1 " 21 B " 2 B 21 B " 2 21 B B 21" 2 " 1 " B 21" B " B B B " 2 21 B B B B B 21" 21 B 21 " 1 " B " 2B B 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" 21" B B B " 21 B " 2 2 2 1" B B 21" 1" 1" 2 B " 21 21 1" B 21 B 21" 21" B 1 " B B 21" B " 2 2 21 " 1" " B 21 B " 21 21 1 " B 2 B " 21 1 " B 21 B " 2 " 21 E E Checked by Checker E E E All rights reserved. No part of this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form without the prior written authorization of Kostow Greenwood Architects, LLP. Drawn by Author E E E E DN DN X 21 B " 21 B " 21 B " UP KEY PLAN: W 53RD ST 8TH AVE BROADWAY © 2023 Kostow Greenwood Architects, LLP E E OPEN TO BELOW DN X E E OPEN TO BELOW TYP. STAIR 7 PROJECT MANAGEMENT GBA 214 WEST 43RD STREET NEW YORK, NY 10036 telephone 917.300.1199 E C B B 21" " 1 2 E B " 21 E B " 1 B " 2 1 2 DN E STAGE-SIDE SEATING PLATFORM DN 8 E B " 21 E DN B " 21 B STAIR " 21 E DN E B " 21 E B " 21 B " 21 301 DN DN E X CLIENT AMBASSADOR THEATRE GROUP 630 NINTH AVE, SUITE 800 NEW YORK, NY 10036 telephone 646.973.1592 UP W 52ND ST UP DN DESCRIPTION NO DATE UP 1 DOJ SEATING PLAN SEATING PLATFORM scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" 1ST FLOOR (ORCHESTRA LEVEL) SEATING PLATFORM DOB NOW no TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE AND PROFESSIONAL JUDGEMENT THESE DRAWINGS ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE NEW YORK CITY BUILDING CODE AND ADA COMPLIANCE. project no NOTE: DO NOT SCALE OFF OF PLANS drawing no M00914934-I1 23-002 scale 1/8" = 1'-0" graphic scale 0 8' DOJ-002.00 sheets in set 2 OF 35

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?