Vallair Solutions SARL v. 321 Precision Conversions LLC

Filing 250

MEMO ENDORSED ORDER granting 204 Letter Motion to Seal. ENDORSEMENT: The motion is granted temporarily, and nunc pro tunc to April 30, 2024, so that the parties may file certain redacted documents (NOT sealed but redacted) pendente lite. Hard copie s with no redactions shall be delivered to chambers immediately. When a decision is reached on the underlying motion the parties will have 10 days to explain why anything in that decision should remain "confidential." (Signed by Judge Colleen McMahon on 9/24/2024) (mml) Modified on 9/24/2024 (mml).

Case 1: 21-cv-07507-CM -RWL

Document 204 . _ il~_d_:94/29/24____

~ ge 1 of 4

'"'\' ..

v '-' . • ~

.l

I•:-iOC' 11villNT
UNITED STA TES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF EW YORK

VALLAIR SOLUTIONS, SARL,
Plaintiff and
Defendant,

NO. 1:2 l-cv-07507-CM-RWL
JUDGE COLLEEN MCMAHON

Counterclaim

V.

DEFENDANT 321 PRECISION
CONVERSIONS, LLC AND PLAINTIFF
VALLAIR SOLUTION SARL'S JOINT
MOTION TO SEAL OR REDACT

321 PREC ISION CONV ERSIO S, LLC,
Defendant
Plaintiff.

and Co unterclaim

Defen dant 321 Precis ion Conversions, LLC ("Precision"), with the consent and
agreement of PlaintiffVa llair Solution SARL (''Val lair"), respectfull y moves this Court for leave
to file certain documents under seal or in redacted form , to protect Confidential Information as
contemplated in the paiiies' Confidentiality Agreement and Stipulated Protective Order (Doc.
37), including documents previously designated by a party as "Confidential" or "Confidential
Attorneys' Eyes Only." A memorandum of law is jointly submitted by both parties in suppo1i of
this motion.
Dated : April 29, 2024

a/;

JI/

I/_j.,.tf';'J1J )-.

c-r
.
I~
J11 /1.

YGJ--

Isl Chelsea Mikula

~;,_ ,:,_, ru,T,·-.Y-J
f

Chelsea Mikula (admitted pro hac vice)
Smita Gautam (admitted pro hac vice)

rAA?.,11

Lindsey E. Sacher (admitted pro hac vice)
Tucker Ellis LLP
950 Main Avenue
Suite 1100
Cleveland, OH 44113
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile:
216.592.5009
Email:
chel sea.mikula@tuckerellis .com
[e-mail]

V /

'l

_ ,1
✓11.c
11

I

'/-&.

~

y

rrtft7'

~
c__

Respectfully submitted,

a
H

fiY7Vl

H

2 ....

~I

:}--0

)71A,J

V

.

/

/'D
f"-

.J-</
If"
:e

I(,/.:,

11

~

{/l)o /

1/ cb/ ~v-._-::..=-..:.:_-

~

µ

)A';>~

~~cn;() ,rd.£.-<'~

/4'./e, ffe,v( o//h vYJr '--

)'.U-4'.'...smita.gautam@tuckerelli s.com

~~ ~ ,._

ti&.s ,,,_

½

AM~ ¥ ~ ~~ ~~- wi)_J L ;c ~

~

tfr---

'f& ~

,

~ ~ ;l,v/!YJ /L
'+ ·3/;. JI/A; ~ ~~~
fl
I
..,_..,,.,.1(_ • ·

/

I I
·VJ\.,(~-;J}. s
J:/1.AYVlf ~
/J
/~
,1

.

Case 1:21-cv-07507-CM-RWL

Document 204

Filed 04/29/24

Page 2 of 4

Paul B. George (admitted pro hac vice)
Lane Powell PC
601 SW Second Avenue, Suite 2100
Portland , Oregon OR 97204
Telephone:
503.778 .2 l 00
Facsimile:
503.778.2200
Email:
[e-mail]
Kelly Jones Howell (KJH-7804)
Harris Beach PLLC
I 00 Wall Street
New York, NY I 0005
Telephone:
212.687.0 I 00
Facsimile:
212.687.0659
Email:
[e-mail]
Attorneys for Defendant
Conversions LLC

321

Precision

Consented and agreed to on this 29 th day of
April, 2024, by:

By : Isl Evan Kwarta with express
permzsszon

Evan Kwarta
SDNY Bar No.: EK0712
NY Bar No.: 440 I 543
HINSHAW & CULBERTSON,
LLP
800 Third Avenue, I 3th Floor
New York, Y I 0022
Phone: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
Email: [e-mail]
and
THE AXELROD FIRM , PC
By: Isl Debora A. 0 'Ne ill with
express permission
Debora A. O ' Neill (admitted pro
hac vice)

2

Case 1:21-cv-0750 7- CM- RWL

Document 204

Filed 04/29/24

Page 3 of 4

230 S. Broad Street, 17th Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19102
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: 215 .238 . 1779
Email: doneill@theaxelrodfirm .com
Co unsel for Plaintiff Val/air
So lutions SA RL

3

Case 1:21-cv-07507-C M- RWL

Document 204

Filed 04/29/24

Page 4 of 4

PROOF OF SERVICE

A copy of the fore goi ng was served on April 29, 2024 by sending it by electronic mean s to
the email addresses provi ded by the parties as follows:
Evan Kwarta
Hin shaw & Culbertson LLP
800 Third Avenue, 13th Floor
New York, NY I 0022
ekwarta@h inshawlaw .com
Sheryl L. Axelrod
Debora A. O'Neill
THE AXELROD FIRM , PC
I 00 East Penn Square, Suite 400
Philadelphia, PA 19107
saxelrod@theaxel rodfirm.com
donei ll@theaxelrodfirm .com
Attorneys.for Plaintiff Va/lair Solutions SARL

Dated: April 29, 2024

Respectfully submitted,
Isl Chelsea Mikula
Chelsea Mikula (admitted pro hac vice)
One ofthe Attorneys.for Defendant 321 Precision
Conversions LL C

4