Chan et al v. United States Department of Transportation et al

Filing 87

ORDER: The May 17, 2024 oral argument in the above-captioned cases shall proceed according to the following schedule: From 9:00 A.M. to 1:00 P.M., the Court will hear oral argument from the Plaintiffs and Defendants (except for Stephanie Winkelha ke) in Chan, 23-cv-10365, regarding the motions at 23-cv-10365, Dkt. Nos. 54, 64 and 67. There will be a 15-minute break at approximately 10:30 A.M. From 2:00 P.M. to 4:00 P.M., the Court will hear oral argument from the Plaintiffs and Defendants (except for the New York State Department of Transportation) in New Yorkers, 24-cv-367, and Mulgrew, 24-cv-1644, regarding the motions at 24-cv-367, Dkt. Nos. 57 and 62, and 24-cv-1644, Dkt. Nos. 47 and 52. From 4:10 P.M. to 5:10 P.M., the Court wi ll hear oral argument from the Plaintiffs in Chan, 23-cv-10365, New Yorkers, 24-cv-367, and Mulgrew, 24-cv-1644, and Defendants Stephanie Winkelhake and the New York State Department of Transportation regarding the motions at 23-cv-10365, Dkt. No. 61, 24-cv-367, Dkt. No. 59, and 24-cv-1644, Dkt. Nos. 49 and 63. Within each of these periods, time shall be evenly divided between the relevant Plaintiffs, on the one hand, and the relevant Defendants, on the other. The Court will not hear oral argument from amici. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Lewis J. Liman on 5/10/2024) ( Oral Argument set for 5/17/2024 at 09:00 AM before Judge Lewis J. Liman.) (ks)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
---------------------------------------------------------------------- X
:
MICHAEL MULGREW, as President of the UNITED
:
FEDERATION OF TEACHERS, Local 2, American
:
Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO, VITO J. FOSSELLA, :
individually and in his capacity as Staten Island Borough :
President, PAUL CAMINITI, TROY McGHIE,
:
MARTHA MAZIER, CARLY BIANCHINI, HANNAH :
CHOI, FRANK GARCIA, LINDSEY LAMPF,
:
:
Plaintiffs,
:
-v:
:
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF
:
TRANSPORTATION, FEDERAL HIGHWAY
:
ADMINISTRATION, SHAILEN BHATT, in his official :
capacity as Administrator of the Federal Highway
:
Administration, RICHARD J. MARQUIS, in his official :
capacity as Division Administrator of the New York
:
Division of the Federal Highway Administration, the
:
METROPOLITAN TRANSIT AUTHORITY, the
:
TRIBOROUGH BRIDGE AND TUNNEL
:
AUTHORITY, the NEW YORK STATE
:
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, the NEW
:
YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION :
:
Defendants.
:
---------------------------------------------------------------------- :
:
NEW YORKERS AGAINST CONGESTION
:
PRICING TAX, DANNY BUZZETTA, DR. GREGOR :
WINKEL, LEE BERMAN, MEREDITH LeVANDE,
:
RITA SUE SIEGEL, TOMMY LOEB, KATHRYN
:
FREED, TREVER HOLLAND, RICKY YANG, PAUL :
ENG, BARUCH WEISS, ROBERT FRIEDRICH,
:
KEVIN FORRESTAL, WARREN SCHREIBER,
:
CHRISTOPHER RYAN, BEN MASON, DENNIS
:
ROSARIO, RABBI Y.S. GINZBERG, JACOB
:
ENGLANDER, AARON GONZALEZ, HOWARD
:
CHIN, ELAINE LA PENNA, THOMAS ANTHONY
:
SCARPACI, COUNCILMEMBER JOSEPH C.
:
BORELLI, COUNCILMEMBER KRISTY
:
MARMORATO, COUNCILMEMBER VICKIE
:
PALADINO, COUNCILMEMBER JOANN ARIOLA, :

5/10/2024

24-cv-1644 (LJL)
24-cv-367 (LJL)
23-cv-10365 (LJL)
ORDER

COUNCILMEMBER SUSAN ZHUANG,
COUNCILMEMBER KALMAN YEGER,
COUNCILMEMBER INNA VERNIKOV,
COUNCILMEMBER DAVID CARR,
COUNCILMEMBER ROBERT F. HOLDEN, and
ASSEMBLYMEMBER DAVID WEPRIN, individually
and on behalf of all others similarly situated,

:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
Plaintiffs,
:
-v:
:
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF
:
TRANSPORTATION, FEDERAL HIGHWAY
:
ADMINISTRATION, SHAILEN BHATT, in his official :
capacity as Administrator of the Federal Highway
:
Administration, RICHARD J. MARQUIS, in his official :
capacity as Division Administrator of the New York
:
Division of the Federal Highway Administration,
:
METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY, :
TRIBOROUGH BRIDGE AND TUNNEL
:
AUTHORITY, NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT
:
OF TRANSPORTATION, NEW YORK CITY
:
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION and
:
TRAFFIC MOBILITY REVIEW BOARD,
:
:
Defendants.
:
---------------------------------------------------------------------- X
:
ELIZABETH CHAN, TAMARA HOFFMAN, and DOES :
1 through 200,
:
:
Plaintiffs,
:
:
-v:
:
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF
:
TRANSPORTATION, FEDERAL HIGHWAY
:
ADMINISTRATION, SHAILEN BHATT, in his official :
capacity as Administrator of the Federal Highway
:
Administration, RICHARD J. MARQUIS, in his official :
capacity as Division Administrator of the New York
:
Division of the Federal Highway Administration, LISA :
GARCIA, in her official capacity, STEPHEN
:
GOODMAN, in his official capacity, ALLISON L.C. DE :
CERRENO Ph.D., in her official capacity, NICHOLAS :
A. CHOUBAH, P.E., in his official capacity, WILLIAM :

2

J. CARRY, in his official capacity, and DOES 1 through :
10.
:
:
Defendants.
:
---------------------------------------------------------------------- X
LEWIS J. LIMAN, United States District Judge:
The May 17, 2024 oral argument in the above-captioned cases shall proceed according to
the following schedule:
•

From 9:00 A.M. to 1:00 P.M., the Court will hear oral argument from the Plaintiffs and
Defendants (except for Stephanie Winkelhake) in Chan, 23-cv-10365, regarding the
motions at 23-cv-10365, Dkt. Nos. 54, 64 and 67. There will be a 15-minute break at
approximately 10:30 A.M.

•

From 2:00 P.M. to 4:00 P.M., the Court will hear oral argument from the Plaintiffs and
Defendants (except for the New York State Department of Transportation) in New
Yorkers, 24-cv-367, and Mulgrew, 24-cv-1644, regarding the motions at 24-cv-367, Dkt.
Nos. 57 and 62, and 24-cv-1644, Dkt. Nos. 47 and 52.

•

From 4:10 P.M. to 5:10 P.M., the Court will hear oral argument from the Plaintiffs in
Chan, 23-cv-10365, New Yorkers, 24-cv-367, and Mulgrew, 24-cv-1644, and Defendants
Stephanie Winkelhake and the New York State Department of Transportation regarding
the motions at 23-cv-10365, Dkt. No. 61, 24-cv-367, Dkt. No. 59, and 24-cv-1644, Dkt.
Nos. 49 and 63.

Within each of these periods, time shall be evenly divided between the relevant Plaintiffs,
on the one hand, and the relevant Defendants, on the other. The Court will not hear oral
argument from amici.
SO ORDERED.
Dated: May 10, 2024
New York, New York

__________________________________
LEWIS J. LIMAN
United States District Judge

3