Connecticut Fund for the Environment, Inc. d/b/a Save the Sound v. Westchester County, New York
Filing
298
SUPPLEMENT TO AMENDED STIPULATED ORDER WITH RESPECT TO DEFENDANT CITY OF RYE: NOW, THEREFORE, without the trial of any issue of fact or law, without the admission by Defendant of any of the facts or violations alleged in the Complaint, upon consent o f the Parties, and upon consideration of the mutual promises contained herein, IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED BETWEEN THE PARTIES AND ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED BY THE COURT AS FOLLOWS: As further set forth by this Order. D. Stipulated Additional EBP. i. Project Three: Rye shall pay a total of one hundred and forty thousand dollars ($140,000) on projects to reduce, mitigate, and remediate stormwater pollution to the Long Island watershed. On or before October 31, 2024, Rye shall complete Projec t Three, attached hereto as Appendix F. An accounting will be provided to Plaintiffs on or before November 15, 2024. Plaintiffs will have until December 10, 2024, to object to any costs included in the final accounting. If the final accounting result s in costs less than $140,0000, the difference will be added to the EBP Maintenance Fund set forth in sub-Paragraph D.ii, infra. ii. EBP Maintenance Fund: In addition to Project Three, Rye agrees to earmark an additional thirty thousand dolla rs ($30,000) as part of its 2025 annual budget for maintenance of the three EBP Projects conducted pursuant to settlement of this action, namely: Project One (Stipulated Order Paragraph 12, retrofitting downtown parking lot with green infra structure); Project Two (Amended Order Paragraph 12, installing bioretention swale at Recreation Center); and Project Three (Supplemental Order Paragraph D.i, supra). Rye shall provide an annual report as to the status of the EBP Projects and main tenance activities to Plaintiffs throughout the Term of Decree. iii. Remaining Stipulated Additional EBP: To the extent Rye accrued Stipulated Additional EBPs in excess of $260,000, such sum is waived. The remaining ninety-thousand dollars ( 036;90,000) is suspended, as follows: a. Forty-five thousand dollars ($45,000) shall immediately be due and payable to the Rye Nature Center if Rye fails to meet the deadline set forth in Paragraph B, supra. b. Forty-five thousand dollars ($ ;45,000) shall immediately be due and payable to the Rye Nature Center if Rye fails to meet the deadline set forth in Paragraph C, supra. c. Any payment made pursuant to this sub-paragraph shall be for use on projects relating to the reduction, mitig ation, and/or remediation of the effects of stormwater pollution or environmental restoration of, or other benefit to, the Long Island Sound watershed. iv. Paragraph 35 of the Amended Order applies to any late Deliverable under this Supplemental Orde r. E. Fees and Costs. Rye shall pay a sum of fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) as full and complete satisfaction of Plaintiffs claims for attorneys fees and costs incurred to date, including investigative and expert costs, against Rye. The Cler k shall terminate ECF No. 297. SO ORDERED. Motions terminated: 297 CONSENT MOTION to Approve Consent Judgment as to City of Rye. filed by Save The Sound, Atlantic Clam Farms of Connecticut, Inc.. (Signed by Judge Cathy Seibel on 10/24/2024) (tg)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
--------------------------------------------------------------SAVE THE SOUND and ATLANTIC CLAM
FARMS of CONNECTICUT, INC.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
WESTCHESTER COUNTY, NEW YORK;
TOWN/VILLAGE OF HARRISON; VILLAGE OF
LARCHMONT; TOWN OF MAMARONECK;
CITY OF NEW ROCHELLE; VILLAGE OF
PELHAM MANOR; CITY OF RYE; VILLAGE OF
RYE BROOK; and VILLAGE OF SCARSDALE;
Defendants.
---------------------------------------------------------------
X
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
: Case No. 7:15-cv-06323-CS
:
:
:
:
:
:
X
SUPPLEMENT TO AMENDED STIPULATED ORDER
WITH RESPECT TO DEFENDANT CITY OF RYE
Plaintiffs Save the Sound and Atlantic Clam Farms of Connecticut, Inc., and defendant
City of Rye (“Rye”) (collectively, the “Parties”) hereby enter into this Supplement to the
Amended Stipulated Order (“Supplemental Order”) in further settlement of this action.
WHEREAS, Plaintiffs commenced this action asserting, inter alia, claims that Rye was
in violation of provisions of the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. § 1365 et seq.), was in violation of
provisions of the County Environmental Facilities Sewer Act (Charter and Administrative Code
of Westchester County, Article 824) (“County Sewer Act”)), and was contributing to a public
nuisance;
WHEREAS, on February 24, 2021, the Court entered a Stipulated Order as to Rye, ECF
192 (“Stipulated Order”), setting forth (inter alia) requirements for repairs and remediation to
the Rye sewer system; for the study and adoption of financial measures necessary to cover such
projects; for the implementation of ongoing operational and management measures; and for an
environmental benefit project, all to be completed on an agreed-upon schedule (“Stipulated
Schedule”);
WHEREAS, subsequent to Stipulated Order I, Rye failed to complete all the work by the
deadlines set forth in the Stipulated Schedule and, on August 15, 2023, the Court entered an
Amended Stipulated Order as to Rye, ECF 268 (the “Amended Order”);
1
WHEREAS, for a variety of reasons, some of which were outside of Rye’s control, Rye
did not complete every deliverable in accordance with the Amended Order; and
WHEREAS, certain deliverables remain outstanding, requiring further adjustment to the
Stipulated Schedule; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Amended Order ¶ 35, Rye has accrued stipulated additional
environmental benefit payments (“EBPs”) in excess of $260,000;
NOW, THEREFORE, without the trial of any issue of fact or law, without the admission
by Defendant of any of the facts or violations alleged in the Complaint, upon consent of the
Parties, and upon consideration of the mutual promises contained herein,
IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED BETWEEN THE PARTIES AND ORDERED, ADJUDGED
AND DECREED BY THE COURT AS FOLLOWS:
A. Review by Agencies and Entry of Supplemental Order. Pursuant to 33 U.S.C.
§ 1365(c)(3), this Supplemental Order cannot be entered by the Court until forty-five (45)
days after the receipt of a copy of the proposed Supplemental Order by the United States
Department of Justice and Environmental Protection Agency. The Parties shall follow the
procedures set forth in the Amended Order, Paragraphs 16–17, to secure entry of this
Supplemental Order by the Court. This Supplemental Order shall take effect on the date it
is entered by the Court (the “Effective Date”).
B. Amended Order, Appendix A – Remedial Measures, Paragraph 1 is hereby amended
as follows:
1.
Rye shall complete the following work by December 31, 2024:
a. Complete at least a total of 250 open cut replacements/point
repairs/pipe linings;
b. Complete a minimum of 200 manhole repairs.
C. Amended Order, Appendix B – Sewer System Management and Operational
Measures, Paragraph 2 deadlines are hereby amended as follows:
Rye shall submit a revised CMOM program document that is consistent with industry
standards and Appendix B, sub-Paragraphs 2.a–2.i, for final approval within thirty (30)
days of the Effective Date of this Supplemental Order.
2
D. Stipulated Additional EBP.
i.
Project Three: Rye shall pay a total of one hundred and forty thousand dollars
($140,000) on projects to reduce, mitigate, and remediate stormwater pollution to
the Long Island watershed. On or before October 31, 2024, Rye shall complete
Project Three, attached hereto as Appendix F. An accounting will be provided to
Plaintiffs on or before November 15, 2024. Plaintiffs will have until December 10,
2024, to object to any costs included in the final accounting. If the final accounting
results in costs less than $140,0000, the difference will be added to the EBP
Maintenance Fund set forth in sub-Paragraph D.ii, infra.
ii.
EBP Maintenance Fund: In addition to Project Three, Rye agrees to earmark an
additional thirty thousand dollars ($30,000) as part of its 2025 annual budget for
maintenance of the three EBP Projects conducted pursuant to settlement of this
action, namely: Project One (Stipulated Order ¶ 12, retrofitting downtown parking
lot with green infrastructure); Project Two (Amended Order ¶ 12, installing
bioretention swale at Recreation Center); and Project Three (Supplemental Order
¶ D.i, supra). Rye shall provide an annual report as to the status of the EBP Projects
and maintenance activities to Plaintiffs throughout the Term of Decree.
iii.
Remaining Stipulated Additional EBP: To the extent Rye accrued Stipulated
Additional EBPs in excess of $260,000, such sum is waived. The remaining ninetythousand dollars ($90,000) is suspended, as follows:
a. Forty-five thousand dollars ($45,000) shall immediately be due and
payable to the Rye Nature Center if Rye fails to meet the deadline set forth
in Paragraph B, supra.
b. Forty-five thousand dollars ($45,000) shall immediately be due and
payable to the Rye Nature Center if Rye fails to meet the deadline set forth
in Paragraph C, supra.
c. Any payment made pursuant to this sub-paragraph shall be for use on
projects relating to the reduction, mitigation, and/or remediation of the
effects of stormwater pollution or environmental restoration of, or other
benefit to, the Long Island Sound watershed.
iv.
Paragraph 35 of the Amended Order applies to any late Deliverable under this
Supplemental Order.
E. Fees and Costs. Rye shall pay a sum of fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) as full and
complete satisfaction of Plaintiffs’ claims for attorneys’ fees and costs incurred to date,
including investigative and expert costs, against Rye. The City of Rye will arrange for
3
10/24/24
_________________________________
Honorable Cathy Seibel
United States District Judge
The Clerk shall terminate ECF No. 297.
5
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?