Gianni Versace, S.r.l. v. R & B Online Trading, Corp. et al
Filing
30
FINAL JUDGMENT AND INJUNCTION ON CONSENT AGAINST DEFENDANT R & B ONLINE TRADING, CORP Accordingly, the Court does hereby ORDER, ADJUDGE, AND DECREE as follows: This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this action. Venue is pro per in the Southern District of New York. Defendant is subject to the jurisdiction of this Court pursuant to and in accordance with the laws of the State of New York, the United States Constitution, and Rule 4 of the Federal Rules of Civil Proc edure. Pursuant to and in accordance with 15 U.S.C. § 1117(c), but limited by certain requirements in a January 16, 2023 settlement agreement between the parties ("Settlement Agreement"), the Court hereby Orders Defendant to pay Plai ntiff One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($100,000.00). All claims asserted against Roman Bondarenko and "John Doe" defendants are dismissed with prejudice. (And as further set forth herein)R & B Online Trading, Corp., Roman Bondarenko and John Does 1-5 terminated. (Signed by Judge Philip M. Halpern on 1/17/2023) (jca)
<![CDATA[
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 1 ofPage
11 1 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
Michael Lee (ML6353)
Lee Law PLLC
57 West 38th Street, 11th Floor
New York, NY 10018
Telephone: (212) 621-8239
Attorney for Plaintiff
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
CASE NO. 7:22-cv-06081
GIANNI VERSACE, S.R.L.,
Plaintiff,
[PROPOSED] FINAL JUDGMENT AND
INJUNCTION ON CONSENT
AGAINST DEFENDANT
v.
R & B ONLINE TRADING, CORP.
R & B ONLINE TRADING, CORP.; ROMAN
BONDARENKO; and “JOHN DOES” 1-5,
Defendants.
THIS MATTER comes before the Court on consent from Gianni Versace S.r.l. (“Plaintiff”
or “Versace”) and R & B Online Trading, Corp. (“Defendant”) hereby alleges as follows:
The Court, having considered all pleadings and other documents filed in this action, hereby
directs the entry of this Final Judgment and Injunction against Defendant. Accordingly, the Court
does hereby ORDER, ADJUDGE, AND DECREE as follows:
1.
This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this action.
2.
Venue is proper in the Southern District of New York.
3.
Defendant is subject to the jurisdiction of this Court pursuant to and in accordance
with the laws of the State of New York, the United States Constitution, and Rule 4 of the Federal
Rules of Civil Procedure.
4.
Plaintiff is the owner of, including, but not limited to, the following federal trademarks
which are registered in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office:
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 2 ofPage
11 2 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
Image
Country
Device
Type
Status
U.S.A.
Wording
"V" SEWING
Device
Acceptance
ex-officio
without
refusal
*
Appln. Date Appln. Number
Reg. Date
Reg. Number
04/08/2006
11768-D/2006
31/08/2006
903043
U.S.A.
CAP, BOTTLE,
CIRCULAR FRET,
MEDUSA'S HEAD
Tridimensional
Registered
17/01/2006
793170
27/04/2010
3782820
U.S.A.
CAP, OVAL BOTTLE,
CIRCULAR FRET,
MEDUSA'S HEAD
Tridimensional
Registered
04/10/2010
85/144352
28/06/2011
3984609
U.S.A.
CIRCULAR FRET
PATTERN
Device
Total
acceptance
INT
27/04/2005
11117-D/2005
26/05/2005
863493
U.S.A.
FRET PATTERN
Device
Final partial
refusal
INT
04/08/2006
11767-D/2006
10/10/2006
U.S.A.
LINEAR FRET
PATTERN
Device
Total
acceptance
INT
27/04/2005
11116-D/2005
U.S.A.
MEDUSA HEAD
(VERSION 8)
Device
Registered
09/01/2018
U.S.A.
MEDUSA HEAD
(VERSION 8)
Device
Registered
U.S.A.
MEDUSA HEAD
(VERSION 8)
Device
Pending
application
INT
Subsequent Notification Renewal
designation date
Deadline
N.A.
31/08/2026
Int. Classes
Owner
N25
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
27/04/2030
L03
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
28/06/2031
L03
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
N.A.
26/05/2025
N03N09N14N16 GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
N18N24N26
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
922170
07/06/2007
10/10/2026
P03P09P18P20 GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
P24P25P26
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
26/05/2005
866162
N.A.
26/05/2025
L03L09L14L16L GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
18L24 25
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
87748570
14/08/2018
5540330
14/08/2028
26
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
07/06/2019
88/464503
17/12/2019
5937934
17/12/2029
09
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
07/03/2022
97/298,406
09 35 41 42
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
Int. Classes
Owner
L03
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
Trademark Portfolio in the USA in the name of Gianni Versace srl
October 27, 2022
Image
Reg. Date
Reg. Number
Registered
31/05/1996
112541
22/07/1997
2081230
Subsequent Notification Renewal
designation date
Deadline
22/07/2027
Device
Registered
17/05/1993
391423
24/01/1995
1875093
24/01/2025
09 14 16 21
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
MEDUSA HEAD IN
CIRCULAR GREEK
(VERSION 4)
Device
Registered
03/05/1996
98204
15/07/1997
2078918
15/07/2027
L26
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
U.S.A.
MEDUSA'S HEAD
DEVICE (VERSION 8)
Device
Registered
28/07/2003
536034
02/08/2005
2980455
02/08/2025
L03
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
08L09L11L14L1 LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
8 19L20L21L24 ITALIA
25 27
U.S.A.
MEDUSA'S HEAD
DEVICE (VERSION 8)
Device
Final partial
refusal
INT
21/09/2012
12035-D/2012
21/09/2012
1139072
13/12/2012
21/09/2032
P33
U.S.A.
PATTERN THE GREEK Device
Final partial
refusal
INT
06/08/2015
11706-D/2015
18/08/2015
1291548
10/03/2016
18/08/2025
P03P09P14P18 GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
P21P25
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
U.S.A.
STYLIZED "V"
Device
Acceptance
ex-officio
without
refusal
INT
04/08/2006
11770-D/2006
31/08/2006
902034
N.A.
31/08/2026
N25
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
U.S.A.
STYLIZED "V"
Device
Acceptance
ex-officio
without
refusal
INT
04/08/2006
11769-D/2006
31/08/2006
931491
N.A.
31/08/2026
N25
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
U.S.A.
THREE DIMENSIONAL
BOTTLE WITH LION'S
HEAD
Tridimensional
Registered
21/03/1994
503797
10/12/1996
2022368
10/12/2026
L03
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
Wording
Device
Type
Status
U.S.A.
MEDUSA HEAD IN
CIRCULAR GREEK
(VERSION 4)
Device
U.S.A.
MEDUSA HEAD IN
CIRCULAR GREEK
(VERSION 4)
U.S.A.
*
October 27, 2022
1
Appln. Date Appln. Number
Country
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
2
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 3 ofPage
11 3 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
Trademark Portfolio in the USA in the name of Gianni Versace srl
Image
Country
Wording
Type
Status
Appln. Date Appln. Number
Reg. Date
Reg. Number
U.S.A.
DYLAN BLUE
Word
Final partial
refusal
INT
23/12/2015
12362-D/2015
23/12/2015
1309180
Subsequent Notification Renewal
designation date
Deadline
15/09/2016 23/12/2025
U.S.A.
DYLAN PURPLE
Word
Registered
INT
05/04/2022
342022000049979 05/04/2022
1668646
30/06/2022
05/04/2032
03
U.S.A.
DYLAN TURQUOISE
Word
23/01/2020
10666-D/2020
23/01/2020
1523591
02/04/2020
23/01/2030
P03
PALAZZO EMPIRE
Word
Total
provisional
refusal
Final partial
refusal
INT
U.S.A.
INT
09/02/2016
10751-D/2016
09/02/2016
1299889
23/06/2016
09/02/2026
P18
U.S.A.
V
BAROQUE VERSION
Word and
device
Pending
application
08/09/2021
97/017764
U.S.A.
V
BAROQUE VERSION
Word and
device
Total
provisional
refusal
14/02/2019
10734-D/2019
14/02/2019
1481566
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
Registered
28/02/1996
64870
14/09/1999
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
Registered
05/10/1994
582355
16/12/1997
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
Registered
28/05/1996
110711
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
Registered
06/12/1999
864716
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
Registered
09/05/2011
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
Registered
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
Pending
application
published
Pending
application
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
Pending
application
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
Partial
invalidation
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
U.S.A.
VERSACE
Word
U.S.A.
VERSACE BLUE JEANS
Word
Device
Word
*
Int. Classes
Owner
P03
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
Word
Word
Word
INT
09
08/08/2019
14/02/2029
L03L09L14L18L GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
25
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
2278257
14/09/2029
42
2121984
16/12/2027
L03L18 25
22/09/1998
2190233
22/09/2028
03/04/2001
2440541
03/04/2031
85/315871
10/01/2012
4082997
10/01/2032
07/06/2019
88/464490
30/06/2020
6088586
30/06/2030
23/06/2021
90/791,413
07/03/2022
97/298,387
26/04/2022
97/382561
INT
11/08/2009
11557-D/2009
03/09/2009
1018595
Partial
invalidation
INT
25/10/2010
12264-D/2010
09/11/2010
1073076
Total
provisional
refusal
Registered
INT
25/10/2010
12264-D/2010
09/11/2010
1073076
14/11/1994
598827
15/04/1997
2053186
Word
Word
Word
Word
Word
Word
Word
Word
Word
Word
Word
Word
Word
08/02/2021
26/11/2009
03/09/2029
28/04/2011
09/11/2030
25/03/2021
09/11/2030
15/04/2027
Trademark Portfolio in the USA in the name of Gianni Versace srl
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
09
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
N08N19N20N21 GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
N24
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
N20
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
P09
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
L35
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
09 35 41 42
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
35
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
L09
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
N11N14N27N35 GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
L16L42
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
L03
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
October 27, 2022
Image
Reg. Date
Reg. Number
INT
30/11/2015
12213-D/2015
30/11/2015
1293440
Subsequent Notification Renewal
designation date
Deadline
24/03/2016 30/11/2025
Total
provisional
refusal
INT
24/09/2021
274606
27/09/2021
1633596
16/12/2021
Logo
Final partial
refusal
INT
20/03/2018
10904-D/2018
20/03/2018
1431132
VERSACE EROS
FLAME
Logo
Final partial
refusal
INT
18/01/2019
10637-D/2019
18/01/2019
1474151
U.S.A.
VERSACE JEANS
COUTURE
Word
Registered
08/07/1998
519687
06/02/2001
U.S.A.
VERSACE JEANS
COUTURE
Word
Registered
25/10/2001
330062
23/12/2003
U.S.A.
VERSACE RED JEANS
Word
Registered
14/11/1994
598858
U.S.A.
VERSACE THE
DREAMER
Word
Registered
20/09/1996
169332
U.S.A.
VERSUS
Word
Registered
17/11/2004
U.S.A.
VERSUS VERSACE
Registered
26/06/2014
Wording
Device
Type
Status
U.S.A.
VERSACE
COLLECTION
FRAME
Word and
device
Final partial
refusal
U.S.A.
VERSACE DREAM
HORIZONTAL LINES
Word and
device
U.S.A.
VERSACE EROS
U.S.A.
Word
Word
*
Int. Classes
Owner
P18P25
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
27/09/2031
L18L25
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
01/11/2018
20/03/2028
P03
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
27/06/2019
18/01/2029
P03
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALY
2426052
06/02/2031
L18L25
2798577
23/12/2023
18 25
15/04/1997
2053187
15/04/2027
L03
13/10/1998
2194621
13/10/2028
L03
518310
22/05/2007
3243564
22/05/2027
14
86/321572
01/12/2015
4864033
01/12/2025
L14
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
GIANNI VERSACE S.R.L., PIAZZA
LUIGI EINAUDI 4, 20124 MILANO,
ITALIA
Word
Word
Word
HEAD OF LION, CIRCLE Word and
(VERSION 2)
device
Z0015976
F0066150
3
Appln. Date Appln. Number
Country
Z0015976
(Hereinafter collectively referred to as the “Plaintiff’s Registered Trademarks”).
5.
Plaintiff is also the owner of, including, but not limited to, the following federal
copyrights which are registered in the U.S. Copyright Office:
October 27, 2022
4
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 4 ofPage
11 4 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 5 ofPage
11 5 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 6 ofPage
11 6 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 7 ofPage
11 7 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 8 ofPage
11 8 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 9 ofPage
11 9 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
(Hereinafter collectively referred to as the “Plaintiff’s Registered Copyrights”.) (The
Plaintiff’s Registered Trademarks and the Plaintiff’s Registered Copyrights may hereinafter be
collectively referred to as the “Versace IP".)
6.
Plaintiff is responsible for assembling, finishing, marketing, and selling in interstate
commerce high-quality Versace merchandise.
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 10 of
11 10 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
Page
7.
Plaintiff is the exclusive distributor and warrantor in the United States of Versace
merchandise, all of which bear one or more of Plaintiff’s Registered Trademarks and/or Plaintiff’s
Registered Copyrights.
8.
Plaintiff has used the Versace IP in the United States and in interstate commerce for
many years.
9.
The Versace IP is entitled to protection under the federal trademark and/or copyright
laws and under the laws of the State of New York.
10.
On July 18, 2022, Plaintiff filed its Complaint against Defendant.
11.
Accordingly, the Court hereby permanently enjoins and restrains Defendant from:
a) using any counterfeit or infringement of the Versace IP to identify any goods not
authorized by Plaintiff;
b) infringing the Versace IP by importing, manufacturing, distributing, selling, offering
for sale, advertising, promoting, displaying any products bearing any simulation,
reproduction, or copy of the Versace IP;
c) using any simulation, reproduction, or copy of the Versace IP in connection with the
importation, promotion, advertisement, display, sale, offering for sale, manufacture,
production, circulation, or distribution of any unauthorized products in such fashion
as to relate or connect, or tend to relate or connect, such products in any way to
Plaintiff, or to any goods sold, manufactured, sponsored or approved by, or connected
with Plaintiff;
d) making any statement or representation whatsoever, or using any false designation of
origin or false description, or performing any act, which can or is likely to lead the
trade or public, or individual members thereof, to believe that any services provided,
products manufactured, distributed, sold or offered for sale, or rented by Defendant
are in any way associated or connected with Plaintiff;
e) engaging in any other conduct constituting an infringement of the Versace IP, of
Plaintiff’s rights in, or to use or to exploit, said trademark, or constituting any
weakening of Plaintiff’s names, reputations, and goodwill.
12.
Pursuant to and in accordance with 15 U.S.C. § 1117(c), but limited by certain
requirements in a January 16, 2023 settlement agreement between the parties (“Settlement
Case 7:22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
30 inFiled
01/17/23
Page 11 of
11 11 of 11
Case 7-22-cv-06081-PMH
Document
29 Filed
NYSD
on 01/17/2023
Page
Agreement”), the Court hereby Orders Defendant to pay Plaintiff One Hundred Thousand Dollars
($100,000.00).
13.
This Final Judgment and Injunction is deemed served on Defendant as of entry therein.
14.
The terms of this Final Judgment and Injunction shall govern and bind the activities
of the Defendant, its agents, servants, employees, and attorneys, and all persons in active concert or
participation therewith. This Final Judgment and Injunction shall carry over to any successor
companies to Defendant, except as limited by the Settlement Agreement.
15.
All claims asserted against Roman Bondarenko and “John Doe” defendants are
dismissed with prejudice.
16.
This Court reserves and retains jurisdiction of the subject matter of this cause and of
the parties hereto for the purpose of enforcing the terms of this Final Judgment and Injunction on
Consent.
Dated: _________,
January 17 2023
____________________________
Philip M. Halpern
United States District Court Judge
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
