IBM Corporation v. Micro Focus (US), Inc. et al

Filing 98

OPINION AND ORDER re: #56 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint filed by Micro Focus (US), Inc., #22 MOTION to Disqualify Counsel filed by Micro Focus (US), Inc. The motion to dismiss is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART. IBM's copyright infringement claim shall proceed. IBM's breach of contract claim is dismissed. By June 13, 2023, Micro Focus shall file an answer. The motion to disqualify IBM's counsel is DENIED. Given that the Court has relied upon material that remains under seal, the Court is releasing this Opinion and Order under seal, pending review by the parties. In the unlikely event the parties believe that certain material in this Opinion and Order should be redacted, counsel should jointly submit a proposed redacted version by no later than June 9, 2023. After reviewing the parties' submission, the Court will subsequently issue a publicly available version of its Opinion and Order. SO ORDERED. (Previously filed under seal on 5/31/2023) (Signed by Judge Vincent L. Briccetti on 5/30/2023) (mml) Modified on 6/9/2023 (mml).

‫‪ 11‬ﺀ ﺍ‪،‬ﺩ ﻩ‪،‬ﻩ ﺍﺀ‪٠‬ﺃ ‪. ٢‬ﺍﺀﺩ‪ ٦‬ﻩﺀ ﺩ´ ‪ (8٧‬ﻻﺃ‪1‬ﺩ>ﻭﺩ‪:) ٥:‬ﺃ( ﻩ‪،‬ﺀﻩ ‪).‬ﻻﺩﻻ ‪.‬ﺀ‪) ~ ٥‬ﺀ(ﺍﺍ()) ﺀ‪ ٩ <1‬ﻩ ﺍ‬
‫((( ﺩﺃ‬

‫ﺍﺀ<‪٧ :.‬ﺓ´(‬
‫´‪.‬ﻟﻢ))‪. ٤‬ﺀﻩ ‪٠. (٥‬ﻩ‪(:‬ﺀﻩ ﺩ‪ (١:‬ﻩ‪ (8٧ :‬ﻭ‪:٠‬ﺀ‪٠‬ﺀﺩ‪ ٠٠‬ﻡﺀ< ‪´1. ٤«‌-‬ﺃ‪٠٦٥‬‬

‫‪) ٥٨ .‬ﺀ~ )ﺀ ‪ 2‬ﺃ(ﻩ ﺩﺍ ‪) 7‬ﻻ‪ 5 5‬ﺩ ‪ ٧٥ (.‬ﺩ( ﺩ‬

‫‪(.‬ﺃﺍﺀﺃﺩ)ﻡ‬

‫(‪ ٥‬ﺩ‪ ٠‬ﺩﻫﻪ ﻭ ‪( (((. ٤٥،‬ﺍ‪ ٥،٦٥1‬ﺀ ‪ 8‬ﺩ‪،‬ﺍﺩﺃﺃﺍﺃ ‪). ٧‬ﺀﺩ‪٠‬ﺍ>‪٥‬ﺀﺀ(ﺩ»ﺩﻭﺀﺩ (~ﻩﺀ(‪<،‬ﺀﺩﺀﻩﻭﺀ‪ ،‬ﺩﺃ ‌«ﺍﺩﺍﺀﻩﺃ ‪٨‬‬
‫‪.‬ﻷﺃﺃﺩ<ﻭﺩ‪:‬ﻫﻪ‌«‪،‬ﻩﺃﺀ‪ - ٥‬ﺀﺍﺀ‬

‫ﻩ ﺀﻭﻩ ﺍﺀﻩﺀ ‪ ٩‬ﻫﺪﻩ ﻫﺎ‪٠‬ﻫﻸ<ﺀ‪ ٦‬ﺀﻩ( ﺀ(ﺀ ‪ ٦‬ﺃ ﻩﺀﺍﺩ‌«ﺀﺃﺀﺩ) ﺩ‪ ٠‬ﺀﻩ( ﻩﺀﺀﺃ ‪. ٧‬ﺍﻛﺎ ﻩ( ﺀﻏﺎﻩ»ﻩﺀﺀ ‪٩‬‬
‫ﺀﺀ> ‪ ٧‬ﺩ( ﺀ((‪ ٤‬ﻩ ﺩ‪٦‬ﺀﺀ( ﺀﺍﺍ ﻩ( ﺍﺀﺀ<ﺀﻩ )‪ ٦‬ﺩ ‪.‬ﺩﻩ ﺩﺭﻩ‪،‬ﻡ (‪ ٠٦‬ﻩ‪٠‬ﺩ‪:‬ﻁ‬
‫ﻃﻪ ﺀ ﺀﺍﺀ ‪.‬ﻫﻪ ﺀ ﺀﺍﺀ‪.‬ﺀ‪،1‬ﺀ‪ ٠٦‬ﺀﺀﺭ ‪٥٨‬ﺍﺀ ‪٨٥‬‬
‫ﺀﺩ‪ ٠‬ﺀﻩﺀ‪،‬ﺃﺩ«ﺩ ﻩﺀﺃﻭﻩﺀ )ﺍﻩﺀﺀﺀﺍ‪ 1‬ﺩ ﺩﺩﺀﻩ ﺀ ﻩ‪،‬ﺀﺃ ‪«‌ ٧‬ﺀﺀﺀﻩﻫﻸ ‪،<4٠-.‬ﺀ‪ ٩٥٥‬ﻃﻪ ﺀ ‌«ﺍ( ﺃ‌«ﻩ ‪ ٦(.‬ﺀﻋﻪﺀﻩ(( ‪٨‬‬
‫ﺩ<ﺀﻩ(‬

‫ﻩ»‌«ﺍﻩﺀﺍ‪ 1‬ﻩﺀﺩ<ﺀﻩﺃ(ﺩﺀﺃ‪( 1‬ﻭﻩ ﺀ‪٠‬ﺩ ‪٨‬ﺀ(ﻩﺩ ﺀﺀ‪(:‬ﺀﻡ ‪ ٨‬ﻩﺀﺀ(ﺩﺀﺀﺀ ﻩ ﺍ ‪ 5 ٧5‬ﺀﺍﺀ (ﻩ ﺩﺀﺩﻡ ﺃﺀ‪،‬ﺀﺀﺀﻩ‪-‬ﺀ‬

‫‪ ) .)).‬ﺍ ﻻ ‪»٥. ()٥.‬ﺩ‪ ٨ :«(1‬ﺃﺃﻩ( ﺀﻩ ﻩ ﻣﻪ ﺩﺃ (ﺀﺃ)ﺃﺩﻩﺀﺀ>ﺍ( ﺩﺩ ﺀﻩ ﻩﺩ ﺩﺩ)‪<.‬ﺩ‪ 1‬ﺩ‪.‬ﺀﻩ(‬

‫‪2٥22‬ﻭ‪24‬ﺀﺀﻁﻩ(ﺀ ‪٩‬‬
‫‪،‬ﻩﺃﺀﺀﺩ ﺩﺃﺩ‪ ٠‬ﺀﻩ‪ ٧‬ﻩ‪،‬ﺀﺃ_ ‪،،‬ﻩ ﻯﻩ ﺃﺩﺃﻩ‪4‬ﺩ (ﺩﻩ ﻥ ﺀﻩ( ﺩﻣﺎﺀﻩ‪ ٧‬ﻩ‪،‬ﺀﺃ_ ‪ 4‬ﺀﺀﺃﻩ‪٦٦‬ﺃ ~ﺀﺩ‪٨1‬ﺀﺃ ‪. . . ٨‬ﻭ‬
‫ﺍﺩ‪(٠‬ﺀﺀﺍﺍﺀ(ﻣﺄ ‪ ٦‬ﻩﺀﺩﺩﻭﺀﺀﻭ ﻩ( _ﻩﺀ(ﺀﺀﺩﺩ‪،‬ﺀ ‪4٦‬ﺀﺩ ﺍ‪٢‬ﺀ~ ﺩﺃ‪٦4‬ﺩﺍ‪٨‬ﺀﺃﻛﺎ ﻭ‪٨٢‬ﺀﻩ~ﻁﺀ~‪،1٠‬ﺀﺃ ‪ ٦‬ﺀﺃ(_‪٢(.‬ﺀ‪4‬‬
‫ﻫﺬﺩ~ﻣﺔ ‪ ٢‬ﺀﺃ(~<ﺀﻭﺩ‪ ٨‬ﺀﻩﻭ ﻻﺃ‪٠،‬ﺀﺀﺩ ~ﺀﻭﻩ‪،‬ﻩ‬
‫‪.‬ﺀﻩ~ ﺃﺃ‪ 18.‬ﺩﺃﺩﻣﺎﺀﻩﻷ ﻩ ﺩﺀﺃ_‪ ٤‬ﻩ ﺍﺍﺩﻯ‪٦‬ﺃﻻﺃ(ﺀﺀﻑﺃﻓﻲﺀ(ﺩ(ﺃﺩﺩﺀﺀﺀ‪٠‬ﺀ‬
‫‪ 10).‬ﻟﻢ‪884‬‬

‫ﺀﺍﺃ(ﺩﺀﺀﻭﻩ ﺀ‪(( ٦‬ﻩ ﻭﺀﺀﺀﺃﺀ‪ 2،‬ﻻﺩ ﺀ(( ﺩﺀ(‪٦‬ﻣﺎ‪ 1‬ﻩ‪٧‬ﺀ ‪ ٥،٨‬ﺀ ﺀ(‪. 1‬ﺀ‪٥‬ﺃ(‪ 12(~)(6) _ ٥‬ﺀﺍﻣﺎ ‪ ٩‬ﺩ ﻻﻩﺃ‪4‬ﺃ‪،‬ﺀ~ ﺀ‪1‬‬
‫‪.‬ﻩﺍ(ﻩ~ﺀﺀ ‪ 4،٦‬ﺀﺃ ‪ ٨‬ﺩﻩ ﺀﺀﺀﺀﺀ‪،‬ﻭﺋﺎ‪ 5‬ﺀ‪(٨‬ﻻ~ ‪ 4‬ﺀﺍﻩ ﺍﺩﺀﺃ ‪ ٨‬ﺩ ﺃ´‪ ٢‬ﺀﻩ ﻩ‪،‬ﺀﺀﻩ~ﺀﻯ‪ ٥،،‬ﺀﻡ‪-‬ﻩ_ ﺀ(((ﺃ ‪،‬ﺀﻩﺀﻣﺎ (‪٦‬ﺃﺩﺍ(‪،‬ﺀﺀﻩﺀ‬
‫ﺩ‪1‬ﻩ(ﺃﺀﺀﺀ ﺀﺩﺩ~‪٥‬ﺩﺀﻁ)((ﺃﺃ ﻩﺀﻩ ﺩﺀﻫﺄﺩﻣﺎ‪1‬ﺀ‪ ٦‬ﻩﺀ‪1‬ﺩﻯﺀ‪ 1‬ﺩﻻ(ﺃ(ﻩ‪،‬ﺩ‪ 1‬ﻡ ﻩﺭ(ﺩ«ﺃ‪ 5. 662. 679(2٥٥9). ٧‬ﻻ‪556‬‬
‫‪٥‬ﺀ)(ﺃﺍﺀ‪ ٥‬ﺍﻫﻪ ﺀ‪٦‬ﺩﺃﺃﺭﺩ(‪،،‬ﺀ‪،٨‬ﺀ(ﻩ(ﺩ‬

‫‪~.‬‬
‫‪1‬‬

‫ﻫﺪﻻﺍﺀﺀﻩﺀ ﺀ‪،‬ﺀ_ ﻻ‪~ ٢‬ﺀﻻﻩ ﻩ ﻩﻣﺎﺩ ﻭﻩ ﻩﺃ(ﺀﺩ‪ ٤‬ﻩ ﺀﺩﻣﺎﻩﺀ ﺩ (‪٥‬ﺩ(ﺍﺀﺀ_ﺀ‪1‬ﺀ ﺀ‪ ٤(٨‬ﻩ‬

‫‪( 678٠‬ﻩ‪. 1~.‬ﺩﺩﺃ_ﺩﺃ~ ﻩ(‪٥،٠‬ﺃ(‪ _ ٥‬ﻩ ~ﺩﻩ ﺍﺩ)(ﺃﻥ ﻩ( (‪،٠‬ﺀﺃﺀ‪(٦،‬ﻣﺎﺩ (ﻩ ﺀ ﺩ‪() ٠‬ﺀ«ﻩ‪ ٦4‬ﻩ ‪٨‬ﻻﺀ(‪ ٤‬ﻩ ﻩ ﻩ ﺃ(ﻡ_ﻣﺎﺩﺩﻩ ﺀ‪ (١‬ﻩ(‬
‫‪.‬ﺫ‬
‫‪ 11٠‬ﺀ‪ -‬ﺀ‪،‬ﺩ ﺀ‪،‬ﺀ‪ ١٢‬ﺀﺀ‪(~)٢‬ﺃﺃ<~‪٥٦‬ﺀﺀ‪. 2٥١٥). 5‬ﺩﺃﺀﻓﻲ‪161(2‬ﺭ‪594٧.3~ 15٥‬ﻭ‪ ٦‬ﻩﺩﺩﺀ(ﻩ‪٧. ٩‬ﻩ‪،‬ﺀ‪ 4‬ﺩﻷ‬
‫~ﺀ~ﺩﺀﺍﺀ‬
‫ﻻﺀ‪(٢‬ﺀﺀﺍﺍ(ﺀ‪ ~ ٢‬ﺀ‪ ٨‬ﺃ~ﺀ(ﺀ‪ 4‬ﺍ‪،‬ﺀ‪(٨‬ﻓﻲ ﺀﺩ ﻻﺃﺀﻩ‪،‬ﺀ‪ ٧‬ﺀﺃﺀ‪_ (٨‬ﻻﺩﺩﺩ ‪ ٥‬ﺍ‪ ٠‬ﻩ‪٢‬ﺩ ‪٥ ٨‬ﺀ ﺩ ‪.‬ﺩﺀﻩﺃ(ﺩﻯﺀﺍﺍﺩ‪ 1‬ﻩ ﻟﻪﺀﻩ(‬
‫‪ ٦٥٤‬ﺀ(ﺩ ‪ ٩‬ﺃﺃ‪.‬ﺍﺀﺃﺍﺀﺀ ﻩ ﺍ (ﺀﺀ_ﺀ‪( 1‬ﺃ(ﻩﺀ ﺍ‪،‬ﻩ ﻩ( ﺀﺩﺃﻩ ﺀﺍﺃﻯﻻ)~ﺃﺩﻣﺎﺩ‪ 1‬ﻡ‬
‫‪( 679.‬ﻩ ‪ 5.‬ﻻ ‪ 6‬ﺩ‌«ﺍﺩ~ ‪( ، . 1‬‬
‫‪ 11‬ﻩ ﺀ(( ‪،.‬ﺩﻩ ﺃ(ﻩ_ )‪ 12(~)(6‬ﺍﻻ ‪ ٩‬ﺩ ﺀﺍﺃ_ﻣﺎﺩ ‪٨٥‬‬
‫~ﺩﺩ‪ 4‬ﺀﻩ(ﺩ ﻩ (ﺀﺀ_ﺩﻻ‪،‬ﺀ«ﺍ‪،‬ﺀﺃﺩ‪ 1‬ﻡﺀﺀﻩﺀ ﺀ(( ﻩﺃ ﺩﺀﻩﺃ(ﺩﻯﺀ‬
‫ﺭ‪ 5. 544‬ﻻ‪ . 55٥‬ﺍ‪_ ٢‬ﻩ ﻥ‪ ٥ . ٧. ٦‬ﺀ ‪11٩(1.‬ﺀﻁﻥ‪( 678‬ﺩ ‪ 5.‬ﻻ‪. 556‬ﺍﻩ~ ‪. 1‬ﺀ (‪ ٧‬ﻩﺩﺀ)ﺩ ‪٩‬ﺃ´‪.‬ﻻ(ﺃﺍﺃﻁﺃﺩ‪ ٠‬ﻩ‪ 1‬ﻡﺃﺃ‪ ٤‬ﻩ‬
‫ﺩﻻﻩ ﺃﺍﺩ (ﻩ‪ ٦( (٢‬ﺀ(ﺩﻩﺀ ﺍﻩﻻ(ﺀﺩ( ﺩ~ﺩ‪ ٩‬ﺍﻩ‪ ٤٤‬ﺃ(ﻩ ﺃﺩﺍﻩ ﺀ‪٠‬ﺍ(‪«٠‬ﺀ‪٠‬ﺍ_ﺃﺃ ﺀ‪~ 1‬ﺃﺩﻧﺎﺩﺍﻡ ﻡ ﺍﺍﻩ ﺃﺀﻩ‪ ٤‬ﺩﺃ _‪،‬ﺩﺍﺀ ‪557(2٥٥7). ٩‬‬
‫ﺀﺀﻣﺎ~ﺀﻩ ﺀﺩﺃ_ ﺀ‪ ٨‬ﺍ ﺩﻩ( ﺀﺍﻁ ﻩ ﺃﺃ ﺩﺃ (ﺍ‪،‬ﻩ‪ 4‬ﻩﺀ‪٧‬ﺀ~ ﺀ‪( (٢‬ﻩ‪(٢‬ﺀﺀﺀﺀﺀﺀ‪ ٤‬ﺀﺃ ﺀ‪ ٢1‬ﻩ ﻩ ﻩﺩﺩﺀﺀﺀﺀﺃ( ﻥ ﻩﺀﻁ ‪، ٨ (٥‬ﺀ ﺀ‪٠‬ﺍ(‬
‫ﺩ ﻩ( ﻋﻨﻼﻩ (ﻩ ﺩ ﺩﺃ ~ﺀﻩ‪4‬ﺀﺩ(ﺩ ﻻﺃ‪1‬ﺃﻁﺃﺩﻫﺎﻩ ﺍﻩ ﺀﺀﺍﺍﺃﺃ ‪( 678.‬ﻩ ‪ 5.‬ﻻ‪<556‬ﺍﺩ‪(( ٧. 1 ٢‬ﻩﺩﺀ‪٨‬ﺩ ‪ ٩‬ﺃﺃ‪.‬ﻩﺀﻯﺀﺍ‪ 1‬ﺩ‬
‫ﻩﺀ(ﺀﻩ ﺩﺩ‪(٦‬ﺩﺀﺩ‪4‬ﺀﺀ(ﺀ‪ ٥‬ﺩ ﻩ‪،‬ﻻ ﻷﺃﺍﺃ‪ ٢‬ﺃﺩﺩﻩ ﻩ ﺀﺀﺀ(ﺩ ﻩ ﺀﻩ(( ﺀﺩﻩ_ ﺩﻩ‪ ٤‬ﺩ‪ ٨‬ﺩﻩ ‪(،،‬ﻣﺎﻁ ﺃ‪.‬ﺍﺀﺀ_ﺀﺫﺩﻡﺀﺀ ﻻﺃ‪1‬ﺃﻁ ﻩﻁ ﻩﺀﻡ‬

‫ﺃ‪.‬ﺫ‪ ٥٦‬ﺃ(ﺩ‪١.‬ﺩﺃﻯﺀ ‪ ٩‬ﺀ((‪٥٢ )٠‬ﺀﺀﺀ‪٥٦‬ﺀ ﺩﺃﺀﺃ<‪٧‬‬

‫‪ 11‬ﻩ ﻩ( ﺩﺍ‪(٦:‬‬
‫~ﻁ‪ - 5‬ﺀ‪1٨‬ﺀﻯﺀ‬

‫‪.‬ﺩﺀﺀﺍﺀﺩﺩﺃ) ﺀ‪ 1‬ﻩﺀ ﺀ‪1‬ﺍ ‪٨‬‬

‫‪. 1٠٠‬‬
‫‪: ٠.‬ﺀ ﺃ)ﺍ ﺀ( ﺍ ‪).‬ﺃ‪ 1‬ﺃ)‪ 1(.‬ﺃﺀ ‪.‬ﺀ‪- ٠<.) 1‬ﻩ ﻷ ‪-‬ﻩ>‌«ﺀ ﺍ<‪ ٠‬ﺩ‪. »‌.‬‬

‫‪ 5. (٠1‬ﻷ(‬
‫)‪. 2٥22).‬ﺩ ‪.‬ﺀ ‪٥٨1‬ﺀ‬

‫‪،). ~.‬ﺀﺍﺩﻩ ﻩ ﻩ‪٦‬ﺩ‪٦‬ﺀ‪٠‬ﺩ( )‪. 1٥. 2٥) 2‬ﺀﺩ ‪<«.٧‬ﺀ ﺃ)( )‬

‫‪).‬ﺃ´ﺩ‪٠‬ﺍ‪ ٠« ٩٠‬ﻩ ﻷ ‪((()٠ ´٧٠٦‬ﺀ<‪ ٠٥‬ﻩ ﺀ‪ ٠٠1‬ﻩ‌«ﺩﺀ‪ ٤‬ﻩ‪(( ٠‬ﻩ<‪<«8«‌ ٠‬ﻩ ﻷ ‪ ((٠٨٠-‬ﻩ ‌«<‪٠‬ﺀ‪٠٠‬‬

‫‪:‬ﺩ‪ ٥٥‬ﺃ‪. ٥٧‬ﻭ)~(‪ .7‬ﺃ ﺀﺍﻣﺎ ‪٩‬‬

‫ﺀ()((ﺁ´ ﺩﺀ~ﺃ ‪ ٩١‬ﺍﻡ (( ‪( 5.‬ﺀﺃ_( ‪ ٥‬ﺀ ﺀ(ﻟﻤﻪﻟﻤﺎ) ( ‪ ٥‬ﺩ)ﺀ ‪ ٦‬ﺃﺩﻻ‬

‫( ‪( ٥‬ﺀ‪5‬ﻟﻤﺎ )ﺀ(‪٩‬‬

‫ﺀﺃﺍﺩﺃ)ﻟﻢ‪ 5٥‬ﻩ‬

‫ﺩﻻﺀﻩ_ ‪( ٥‬ﺀ ﺃ_‬

‫ﺀﺀ(ﺩﻷ~ﻩ‬

‫ﺀﺩﺩﻻﺀﺩﺃ ‪ ) .) ٩‬ﺀ‪.‬ﻟﻤﺎﻻ ‪٥‬ﺀ ))‬

‫(ﺀﺃ(ﻻ ‪( ( ٩‬ﺀﺃ‪ ٥ (1).‬ﺀ ﺀ~~‪(( ٩‬ﺀ‪ ٥ ()5‬ﺀ ﺩ ﺩﺃ (ﺃ‬

‫()ﺀﻫﻪ ﺍ ‪~ ٥‬‬

‫‪(.‬ﺀﺃ‪ ٥ ().‬ﺀ ((ﺀ ‪ ٧‬ﻻﺀ)( ‪ ٥‬ﺀ‬

‫ﺍﻩ‪:‬ﺀ‪٦‬ﺀ‪ ٤<٥‬ﺀ‪٥‬ﺀ´´ ﺀﺩ‪ (١‬ﻷﺃﺍﺃ‌«ﺩﺩﻩ( ‪ ١٥-‬ﺩ ﺩﺃ ﺀ‪،‬ﺀ‪.(١‬ﺀ<‪(٥‬ﺀ‪ ٠‬ﺀﺃ‪. ٧‬ﺀ‪٦«‌٠‬ﺀ‪٥٤‬ﺩ ‪: ٠‬ﻻ‪ 5‬ﺀﺩﺃ‪ ٠‬ﻡ ﺀﺀﺩﺀ ﺩ‪،‬ﺀﻩ ﺀ‪٠٥‬ﺀ‪٧ :‬‬

‫(ﻩﺩ<ﺀﺩ‪ ٠‬ﻩ‪ ٠‬ﺍﻩ ﺀ‪(:‬ﺩ‪:‬ﺍ‪،‬ﻩﺩ´ﺃ( )ﺃ (‪ 1٩) ٥. ٠‬ﺃﺃ)‬

‫~ )‪.. ) ٥1‬ﺀ‪:‬ﺀ‪٠«‌:‬ﺃﺍﻩ<ﺍ´‪«‌ 1.٠. 5‬ﺀ‪: ٠‬ﺃﺍﻩ ﻷ ‪.‬ﻩ(‪(:«‌ ٠<٨٠‬‬

‫~ ‪(.‬ﺀﺃ ‪ ٥ )1(.‬ﺀ‬

‫(ﺀﺍﻻﺀ(ﻩﺀ ﺩﺃ)( ( ‪ ٥ • ( ٥‬ﺃﺀ(ﺀ( ‪ ~ ٥‬ﺀ(ﺍ ‪. ( ٩‬ﺀ ‪ 7‬ﺃ(ﺃ( ‪ 7 ٧‬ﺃ‬

‫‪ ٠٠.‬ﻩ<‪٠٠٠٦‬ﺀ‌«(‪1‬ﺍﺩﺃ< ﺩ‪ ٠٠‬ﻩﻷ ‌«ﺀ‪ )). ) ٥)). ٧ :‬ﺀ‪ )٠٦‬ﻡ‪8‬‬