Advanced Internet Technologies, Inc. v. Dell, Inc.

Filing 222

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 192 Motion to Seal. Counsel, see Order for complete details. Signed by USMJ David W. Daniel on 5/21/2010. (Heath, D.)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA
WESTERN DIVISION

No. 5:07-CV-426-H
ADVANCED INTERNET TECHNOLOGIES, INC.) Plaintiff,
Y.

) ) ) ) ) )

ORDER

DELL INC. and DELL FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC., Defendants

) )
) ) )

This matter is before the Court on PlaintifT A d v a n c e d Internet Technologies, Inc,,' s motion to seal documents filed ln connection with its motion to de-designate certain confidential documents. [DE-192..] The Court having d c t e n n i n e d that certain d o c w n e n t s are o r are n o t confidential [DE-220, 221], AlT's motion to seal is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART" The Clerk is DIRECTED to UNSEAL the 1i.)lJowing documents: I Docket Entry 174 - M a i n Document and Attachments # 1 Exhibit Tab I - DELL0000229,

# 2 Exhibit Tab 2 DELL0000426) # 3 Exhibit Tab 3 DELL0000464, # 4 Exhibit Tab 4
DELL0000541, # 5 Exhibit Tab 5 DELL0000552, # 6 Exhibit Tab 6 DELL000083 8) # 7 Exhibit Tab 7 DELL0000863, # 8 Exhibit Tab 8 DELL0000880, # 9 Exhibit Tab 9 DELL0000955, # 11 Exhibit Tab 11 DELL0000992, # 12 Exhibit Tab 12 DELL0001268, # 13 Exhibit Tab 13 DELLOOOI309, # 14 Exhibit Tab 14 DELL0001321, # 15 Exhibit Tab 15 DELL0001369, # 16 Exhibit Tab 16 DELLOOOI634, # 17 Exhibit Tab 17 DELL0075150, and # 18 Exhibit Tab 18 DELL0085 194.

In an attempt to maintain the integrity of the docket and to prevent re-filing of documents, where an attachment contains both confidential and non-confidential documents, it shall be sealed for purposes of this order..
I

Docket Entry 175 - Main Document and Attachments # 5 Exhibit Tab 20 DELL0085376,
# 6 Exhibit Tab 21 DELL0085382, # 7 Exhibit Tab 22 DELL0085587, and # 8 Exhibit Tab 23 DELL0086302

Docket E n t r y 176 (this appears to be a duplicate ofDocket Entry 175) - M a i n D o c u m e n t and
Attachments # 5 Exhibit Tab 20 DELL00853 76, # 6 Exhibit Tab 21 DELL0085382, # 7 Exhibil Tab 22 DELL0085587, and # 8 Exhibit Tab 23 OELL0086302.

Docket Entry 177 - M a i n Document. Docket Entry 178 - Main Document. Docket Entry t 79 - M a i n Document and Attachments # 2 Exhibit Tab 25 Part 9
OELL0087078, # 4 Exhibit Tab 25 Part 11 DELL0087078, and # 5 Exhibit Tab 25 Part 12 DELL0087078.

Docket Entry 180 - Main Document and # 1 Exhibit Tab 26 Part 1 DELL0087109, /I- 2
Exhibit Tab 26 Part 2 DELL0087109, # 3 Exhibit Tab 26 Part 3 DELL0087109, and # 4 Exhibit Tab 26 Part 40ELL00871 09.

Docket Entry 181- M a i n Document Docket Entry 182 - M a i n Document. Docket Entry 183 - Main Document. Docket Entry 184 - M a i n Document and Attachments # 1 Exhibit Tab 29 Part 1
DELL0087250, # 2 Exhibit Tab 29 Part 2 DELL0087250, # 3 Exhibit Tab 29 Part 3 DELL0087250, # 4 Exhibit Tab 29 Part 4 DELL0087250, and H5 Exhibit Tab 29 Part 5 DELL0087250.

Docket Entry 185 - M a i n Document and Attachments # 1 Exhibit Tab 29 Part 6
DELL0087250, # 2 Exhibit Tab 29 Part 7 DELL0087250, # 3 Exhibit Tab 29 Part 8 DELL0087250,

2

# 4 Exhibit Tab 29 Part 9 DELL0087250, # 5 Exhibit Tab 29 Part 10 DELL0087250, # 6 Exhibit Tab
30 DELL0087447, # 7 Exhibit Tab 31 - DELL0087452, # 8 Exhibit Tab 32 - DELL0087465, and

# 9 Exhibit Tab 33 - DELL0087485,
Docket Entry 186 - M a i n Document and Attachment # 1 Exhibit Tab 34 Part 1a of 5
DELL0087569"

Docket Entry 187 - M a i n Docwnent and Attachments # 2 Exhibit Tab 34 Part Sb of 5
DELL0087569, # 4 Exhibit Tab 3S - DELL0087996, and # 5 Exhibit Tab 36 - DELL0091 037"

Docket Entry 188 - Main Document and Attachments # 6 Exhibit Tab 40 - DELL0130244
and # 7 Exhibit Tab 41 - DELL0130550,

Docket Entry 189 - M a i n Document and Attaclunents # 4 Exhibit Tab 43 - DELLO 134854,

# 5 Exhibit Tab 44 - D E L L 0 1 3 5 3 2 6 , # 6 Exhibit Tab 45 - D E L L 0 1 3 5 4 5 1 , # 7 Exhibit Tab 46
DELL0137764, # 8 Exhibit Tab 47 - D E L L 0 1 4 1 9 9 4 , # 9 Exhibit Tab 48 - D E L L 0 1 4 2 1 7 7 , # 10 Exhibit Tab 49 - D E L L 0 1 4 2 1 8 0 , # 11 Exhibit Tab 50 - D E L L 0 1 4 2 1 8 5 , if 12 Exhibit Tab 51 DELL0142207, # 13 Exhibit Tab 52 - DELL0142229, # 14 Exhibit Tab 53 - D E L L 0 1 4 3 6 9 9 , # 15 Exhibit Tab 54 - D E L L O i 4 3 7 0 5 , # 16 Exhibit Tab 55 - DELL014371 I, # 17 Exhibit Tab 56 DELL0145637, # 18 Exhibit Tab 57 - DELL0146704, # 19 Exhibit Tab 58 - D E L L 0 1 4 8 0 8 6 , # 20 Exhibit Tab 59 - DELL0148655, if 21 Exhibit Tab 60 - D E L L 0 1 5 6 2 8 7 , # 25 Exhibit Tab 64 - Amy Taylor Ex. 38, # 26 Exhibit Tab 65 - Amy Taylor Ex, 42, and # 27 Exhibit Tab 66 - Amy Taylor Ex. 45"

Docket Entry 190 - M a i n Document and Attachments # I Exhibit Tab 67 - Kenneth Joines
Ex. 51, # 2 Exhibit Tab 68 - J a m e s Hutlen Ex. 57, # 3 Exhibit Tab 69 - James Hutten Ex. 59, # 5 Exhibit Tab 71 - William Luhrs Condensed Transcript, # 6 Exhibit Tab 72 - William Luhrs Ex. ],

# 9 Exhibit Tab 75 - W i l l i a m Luhrs Ex. 5, # 10 Exhibit Tab 76 - William Luhrs Ex. 6, if 12 Exhibit

3

Tab 78 ~ William Luhrs Ex. 8, # 13 Exhibit Tab 79 - William Luhrs Ex. 9, # 15 Exhibit Tab 81 William Luhrs Ex. ] 1, and # 16 Exhibit Tab 82 - William Luhrs Ex. 12. Docket Entry 191 - Main Document and Attachments # I Exhibit Tab 83 - William Luhrs Ex. 13, # 4 Exhibit Tab 86 - William Luhrs Ex. 16, # 5 Exhibit Tab 87 - Harold Slone Condensed Transcript, # 6 Exhibit Tab 88 - P a r t 1 of 3 - Harold Stone Ex.! 0, and:/l. 8 Exhibit Tab 88 - Part 3 of 3 - Harold Stone Ex.l 0" The following documents shall remain SEALED: Docket Entry 174 - Attachment #1 0 Exhibit Tab 10 DELL0000979 Docket Entry 175 - Attachments #- 1 E x h i b i t Tab 19 Part 1 of 3 DELL0085220, # 2 Exhibit TAB J9 Part 2a of 3 DELL0085220, # 3 Exhibit TAB 19 Part 2b of 3 DELL0085220, and ff 4 Exhibit TAB 19 Part 3 of3 DELL0085220.. Docket Entry 176 (this appears to be a duplicate of Docket Entry 175) - A t t a c h m e n t s # 1 Exhibit Tab 19 Part 1 of 3 DELL0085220, # 2 Exhibit TAB 19 Part 2a of 3 DELL0085220, # 3 Exhibit TAB 19 Part 2b of 3 DELL0085220, and:/l. 4 Exhibit TAD 19 Part 3 of 3 DELL0085220. Docket Entry 177 - Attachments I/. 1 E x h i b i t Tab 24 Part 1aof5 DELL0086583, #2 Exhibit Tab 24 Part 1b of 5 DELL0086583, # 3 Exhibit Tab 24 Part Ie of 5 DELL0086583, # 4 Exhibit Tab 24 Part Id of 5 DELL0086583, # 5 Exhibit Tab 24 Part 2 of5 DELL0086583, # 6 Exhibit Tab 24 Part 3 of 5 DELL0086583, # 7 Exhibit Tab 24 Part 4 of 5 DELL0086583, # 8 Exhibit Tab 24 Part 5 of 5 DELL0086583 . Docket E n t r y 1 7 8 - Attachments # 1 E x h i b i t Tab 25 P a r t 1 D E L L 0 0 8 7 0 7 8 , # 2 Exhibit Tab 25 Pare 2 DELL0087078, # 3 Exhibit Tab 25 Part 3 DELL0087078, # 4 Exhibit Tab 25 Part 4 DELL0087078, # 5 Exhibit Tab 25 Part 5 DELL0087078, # 6 Exhibit Tab 25 Part 6 DELL0087078,

4

#- 7 Exhibit Tab 25 Part 7 DELL0087078.
Docket Entry 179 - A t t a c h m e n t s # 1 Exhibit Tab 25 Part 8 DELL0087078, and # 3 Exhibit Tab 25 Part 10 DELL0087078, Docket Entry 180 - A t t a c h m e n t s # 5 Exhibit Tab 26 Part 5 DELL00871 09, # 6 Exhibit Tab 26 Part 6 DELL0087109, # 7 Exhibit Tab 26 Part 7 DELL0087109, # 8 Exhibit Tab 26 Part 8 DELL0087 109, # 9 Exhibit Tab 26 Part 9 DELL0087109, # 10 Exhibit Tab 26 Part 10 DELL0087 109, and # 11 Exhibit Tab 27 DELLOOS7137. Docket E n t r y 1 8 1 - A t t a c h m e n t s # 1 E x h i b i t T a b 28 Part 1 o r 12 DELL0087179,"# 2 E x h i b i t Tab 28 Part 2 of 12 DELL0087179, # 3 Exhibit Tab 28 Part 3 of 12 DELL0087179, # 4 Exhibit Tab 28 Part 4 of 12 DELL0087179, and # 5 Exhibit Tab 28 Part 5 of 12 DELL0087179. Docket Entry 182 - A t t a c h m e n t s # 1 E x h i b i t Tab 28 Part 6 of 12 DELL0087179, # 2 Exhibit Tab 28 Part 7 of 12 DELL0087179, # 3 Exhibit Tab 28 Part 8 of 12 DELL0087J 79, # 4 Exhibit Tab 28 Part 9 or 12 DELL0087179, and I/. 5 Exhibit Tab 28 Part 10 of 12 DELL0087179. Doeket Entry 183 - A t t a c h m e n t s # 1 Exhibit Tab 28 Part 11 of 12 DELL0087179 and # 2 Exhibit Tab 28 Part ]2 of 12 DELL0087179. Docket E n t r y 1 8 6 - A t t a c h m e n t s tt2 Exhibit Tab 34 Part 1b of5 DELL0087569, # 3 Exhibit Tab 34 Part Ic of 5 DELL0087569, # 4 Exhibit Tab 34 Part 2 DELL0087569, # 5 Exhibit Tab 34 Part 3 of 5, and # 6 Exhibit Tab 34 Part 4 of 5 DELL0087569. Docket Entry 187 - A t t a c h m e n t s I/- 1 Exhibit Tab 34 Part 5a of 5 DELL0087569 and # 3 Exhibit Tab 34 Part 5c of 5 DELL0087569 Docket Entry 188 - A t t a c h m e n t s # 1 Exhibit Tab 37 Part 1 of 3 DELL0091294, I/- 2 Exhibit Tab 37 Part 2 of 3 DELL0091294, # 3 Exhibit Tab 37 Part 3 of 3 DELL0091294, # 4 Exhibit Tab

5

38 - DELL0091354, and # 5 Exhibit Tab 39 - DELLOI0565L

Docket Entry 189 ~ Attachments # 1 Exhibit Tab 42 Part 100 DELL0132394, # 2 Exhibit
Tab 42 Part 2 of3 DELL0132394, # 3 Exhibit Tab 42 Part 3 of3 DELL0132394, # 22 Exhibit Tab 61 - DELL0163416, # 23 Exhibit Tab 62 -DELL0163446, and # 24 Exhibit Tab 63 - DELL0163559,

Docket Entry 190 - Attachments if. 4 Exhibit Tab 70 - Mesa Carlson Ex, 62, # 7 Exhibit Tab
73 - William Luhrs Ex. 3, # 8 Exhibit Tab 74 - William Luhrs Ex. 4, # 11 Exhibit Tab 77 - William Luhrs Ex. 7, and H14 Exhibit Tab 80 - William Luhrs Ex" 10.

Docket Entry 191 - Attachments # 2 Exhibit Tab 84 - William Luhrs Ex. 14, # 3 Exhibit Tab
85 - William Luhrs Ex 15, and # 7 Exhibit Tab 88 - Part 2 of3 - Harold Stone Ex,IO,

This ~~ay of May, 2010.,

D AV l D W45AN1EL

United States Magistrate Judge

-l~Cd

6