MCFADYEN et al v. DUKE UNIVERSITY et al

Filing 321

ORDER of USCA that the court consolidates the above-captioned appeal numbers 11-1436, 11-1438, 11-1453, 11-1458, 11-1460, and 11-1465 under lead case number 11-1436(L). USCA Case Number: 11-1436 (1:08-cv-119-JAB-JEP) (1:07-cv-953-JAB-JEP) (Law, Trina)

Appeal: 11-1436

Doc: 90

Filed: 12/17/2012

Pg: 1 of 6

FILED: December 17, 2012
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT
___________________
No. 11-1436 (L)
(1:07-cv-00739-JAB-WWD)
___________________
DAVID F. EVANS; COLLIN FINNERTY; READE SELIGMANN
Plaintiffs - Appellees
v.
STEVEN W. CHALMERS; BEVERLY COUNCIL; RONALD HODGE; JEFF
LAMB; MICHAEL RIPBERGER; LEE RUSS; PATRICK BAKER
Defendants - Appellants
and
CITY OF DURHAM, NORTH CAROLINA; MARK GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN
HIMAN; DAVID ADDISON; MICHAEL NIFONG; LINWOOD WILSON;
STEPHEN MIHAICH; DNA SECURITY, INCORPORATED; RICHARD
CLARK; BRIAN MEEHAN
Defendants
___________________
No. 11-1438
(1:07-cv-00739-JAB-WWD)
___________________
DAVID F. EVANS; COLLIN FINNERTY; READE SELIGMANN
Plaintiffs - Appellees

Appeal: 11-1436

Doc: 90

Filed: 12/17/2012

Pg: 2 of 6

v.
CITY OF DURHAM, NORTH CAROLINA; MARK GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN
HIMAN; DAVID ADDISON
Defendants - Appellants
and
MICHAEL NIFONG; LINWOOD WILSON; STEVEN W. CHALMERS;
BEVERLY COUNCIL; RONALD HODGE; JEFF LAMB; STEPHEN MIHAICH;
MICHAEL RIPBERGER; LEE RUSS; DNA SECURITY, INCORPORATED;
RICHARD CLARK; BRIAN MEEHAN; PATRICK BAKER
Defendants
___________________
No. 11-1453
(1:08-cv-00119-JAB-WWD)
___________________
EDWARD CARRINGTON; CASEY J. CARROLL; MICHAEL P. CATALINO;
GALE CATALINO; THOMAS V. CLUTE; KEVIN COLEMAN; JOSHUA R.
COVELESKI; EDWARD J. CROTTY; EDWARD S. DOUGLAS; KYLE DOWD;
PATRICIA DOWD; DANIEL FLANNERY; RICHARD GIBBS FOGARTY;
ZACHARY GREER; IRENE GREER; ERIK S. HENKELMAN; STEVEN W.
HENKELMAN; JOHN E. JENNISON; BEN KOESTERER; MARK
KOESTERER; JOYCE KOESTERER; FRED KROM; PETER J. LAMADE;
ADAM LANGLEY; CHRISTOPHER LOFTUS; DANIEL LOFTUS; BARBARA
LOFTUS; ANTHONY MCDEVITT; GLENN NICK; NICHOLAS O'HARA;
LYNNDA O'HARA; DANIEL OPPEDISANO; SAM PAYTON; JOHN
BRADLEY ROSS; KENNETH SAUER, III; STEVE SCHOEFFEL; ROBERT
SCHROEDER; DEVON SHERWOOD; DANIEL THEODORIDIS; BRET
THOMPSON; CHRISTOPHER TKAC; TRACY TKAC; JOHN WALSH, JR.;
MICHAEL WARD; ROBERT WELLINGTON, IV; WILLIAM WOLCOTT;
MICHAEL YOUNG
Plaintiffs - Appellees

Appeal: 11-1436

Doc: 90

Filed: 12/17/2012

Pg: 3 of 6

v.
PATRICK BAKER; STEVEN CHALMERS; RONALD HODGE; LEE RUSS;
BEVERLY COUNCIL; JEFF LAMB; MICHAEL RIPBERGER
Defendants - Appellants
and
DUKE UNIVERSITY; DUKE UNIVERSITY HEALTH SYSTEMS,
INCORPORATED; RICHARD BRODHEAD; PETER LANGE; LARRY
MONETA; JOHN BURNESS; TALLMAN TRASK; SUZANNE WASIOLEK;
MATTHEW DRUMMOND; AARON GRAVES; ROBERT DEAN; TARA
LEVICY; THERESA ARICO; J. WESLEY COVINGTON; KATE HENDRICKS;
VICTOR DZAU; CITY OF DURHAM; LINWOOD WILSON; MARK
GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN HIMAN; STEPHEN MIHAICH; DAVID ADDISON;
MARSHA COVINGTON COVINGTON, Executrix of the Estate of John Wesley
Covington
Defendants
___________________
No. 11-1458
(1:07-cv-00953-JAB-WWD)
___________________
RYAN MCFADYEN; MATTHEW WILSON; BRECK ARCHER
Plaintiffs - Appellees
v.
PATRICK BAKER; STEVEN CHALMERS; RONALD HODGE; LEE RUSS;
BEVERLY COUNCIL; JEFF LAMB; MICHAEL RIPBERGER
Defendants - Appellants
and

Appeal: 11-1436

Doc: 90

Filed: 12/17/2012

Pg: 4 of 6

DUKE UNIVERSITY; DUKE UNIVERSITY POLICE DEPARTMENT; AARON
GRAVES; ROBERT DEAN; LEILA HUMPHRIES; PHYLLIS COOPER;
WILLIAM F. GARBER, III; JAMES SCHWAB; JOSEPH FLEMING; JEFFREY
O. BEST; GARY N. SMITH; GREG STOTSENBERG; ROBERT K. STEEL;
RICHARD H. BRODHEAD, Ph. D.; PETER LANGE, Ph. D.; TALLMAN
TRASK, III, Ph. D.; JOHN BURNESS; LARRY MONETA, Ed. D.; DUKE
UNIVERSITY HEALTH SYSTEMS, INCORPORATED; PRIVATE
DIAGNOSTIC CLINIC, PLLC; JULIE MANLY, MD; THERESA ARICO, R. N.;
TARA LEVICY, R. N.; THE CITY OF DURHAM, NORTH CAROLINA;
MICHAEL NIFONG; STEPHEN MIHAICH; EDWARD SARVIS; LAIRD
EVANS; JAMES T. SOUKUP; KAMMIE MICHAEL; DAVID ADDISON;
MARK D. GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN W. HIMAN; LINWOOD WILSON;
RICHARD D. CLAYTON; DNA SECURITY, INCORPORATED; RICHARD
CLARK; BRIAN MEEHAN, Ph. D.; VICTOR J. DZAU, MD; ALLISON
HALTON; KEMEL DAWKINS; SUZANNE WASIOLEK; STEPHEN BRYAN;
MATTHEW DRUMMOND; DUKE POLICE DEFENDANTS
Defendants
___________________
No. 11-1460
(1:07-cv-00953-JAB-WWD)
___________________
RYAN MCFADYEN; MATTHEW WILSON; BRECK ARCHER
Plaintiffs - Appellees
v.
THE CITY OF DURHAM, NORTH CAROLINA; DAVID ADDISON; MARK
GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN HIMAN
Defendants - Appellants
and
DUKE UNIVERSITY; DUKE UNIVERSITY POLICE DEPARTMENT; AARON
GRAVES; ROBERT DEAN; LEILA HUMPHRIES; PHYLLIS COOPER;

Appeal: 11-1436

Doc: 90

Filed: 12/17/2012

Pg: 5 of 6

WILLIAM F. GARBER, II; JAMES SCHWAB; JOSEPH FLEMING; JEFFREY
O. BEST; GARY N. SMITH; GREG STOTSENBERG; ROBERT K. STEEL;
RICHARD H. BRODHEAD, Ph. D.; PETER LANGE, Ph. D.; TALLMAN
TRASK, III, Ph. D.; JOHN BURNESS; LARRY MONETA, Ed. D.; DUKE
UNIVERSITY HEALTH SYSTEMS, INCORPORATED; PRIVATE
DIAGNOSTIC CLINIC, PLLC; JULIE MANLY, MD; THERESA ARICO, R. N.;
TARA LEVICY, R. N.; MICHAEL NIFONG; STEPHEN MIHAICH; EDWARD
SARVIS; LAIRD EVANS; JAMES T. SOUKUP; KAMMIE MICHAEL;
LINWOOD WILSON; RICHARD D. CLAYTON; DNA SECURITY,
INCORPORATED; RICHARD CLARK; BRIAN MEEHAN, Ph. D.; VICTOR J.
DZAU, MD; ALLISON HALTON; KEMEL DAWKINS; SUZANNE
WASIOLEK; STEPHEN BRYAN; MATTHEW DRUMMOND; DUKE POLICE
DEFENDANTS; PATRICK BAKER; STEVEN W. CHALMERS; RONALD
HODGE; LEE RUSS; BEVERLY COUNCIL; JEFF LAMB; MICHAEL
RIPBERGER
Defendants
___________________
No. 11-1465
(1:08-cv-00119-JAB-WWD)
___________________
EDWARD CARRINGTON; CASEY J. CARROLL; MICHAEL P. CATALINO;
GALE CATALINO; THOMAS V. CLUTE; KEVIN COLEMAN; JOSHUA R.
COVELESKI; EDWARD J. CROTTY; EDWARD S. DOUGLAS; KYLE DOWD;
PATRICIA DOWD; DANIEL FLANNERY; RICHARD GIBBS FOGARTY;
ZACHARY GREER; IRENE GREER; ERIK S. HENKELMAN; STEVEN W.
HENKELMAN; JOHN E. JENNISON; BEN KOESTERER; MARK
KOESTERER; JOYCE KOESTERER; FRED KROM; PETER J. LAMADE;
ADAM LANGLEY; CHRISTOPHER LOFTUS; DANIEL LOFTUS; BARBARA
LOFTUS; ANTHONY MCDEVITT; GLENN NICK; NICHOLAS O'HARA;
LYNNDA O'HARA; DANIEL OPPEDISANO; SAM PAYTON; JOHN
BRADLEY ROSS; KENNETH SAUER, III; STEVE SCHOEFFEL; ROBERT
SCHROEDER; DEVON SHERWOOD; DANIEL THEODORIDIS; BRET
THOMPSON; CHRISTOPHER TKAC; TRACY TKAC; JOHN WALSH, JR.;
MICHAEL WARD; ROBERT WELLINGTON, IV; WILLIAM WOLCOTT;
MICHAEL YOUNG

Appeal: 11-1436

Doc: 90

Filed: 12/17/2012

Pg: 6 of 6

Plaintiffs - Appellees
v.

CITY OF DURHAM; MARK GOTTLIEB; BENJAMIN HIMAN; DAVID
ADDISON
Defendants - Appellants

and
PATRICK BAKER; STEVEN CHALMERS; RONALD HODGE; LEE RUSS;
BEVERLY COUNCIL; JEFF LAMB; MICHAEL RIPBERGER; DUKE
UNIVERSITY; DUKE UNIVERSITY HEALTH SYSTEMS, INCORPORATED;
RICHARD BRODHEAD; PETER LANGE; LARRY MONETA; JOHN
BURNESS; TALLMAN TRASK; SUZANNE WASIOLEK; MATTHEW
DRUMMOND; AARON GRAVES; ROBERT DEAN; TARA LEVICY;
THERESA ARICO; J. WESLEY COVINGTON; KATE HENDRICKS; VICTOR
J. DZAU; LINWOOD WILSON; STEPHEN MIHAICH; MARSHA SAUNDERS
COVINGTON, Executrix of the Estate of John Wesley Covington
Defendants
___________________
ORDER
___________________
The court consolidates the above-captioned appeal numbers 11-1436,
11-1438, 11-1453, 11-1458, 11-1460, and 11-1465 under lead case number
11-1436(L).
For the Court--By Direction
/s/ Patricia S. Connor, Clerk