McRee v. HCA Healthcare, Inc.

Filing 38

ORDER denying 30 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by District Judge Max O. Cogburn, Jr on 8/30/2024. (ams)

234567ÿ95
569ÿ749545ÿ
25ÿ
69563ÿ749545ÿ
ÿ3
5ÿ

43
ÿ

9646ÿ74494
3ÿ

ÿ
ÿ
9

3ÿ66ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ
!"#$$%ÿ#ÿ'ÿ()*#$+ÿ'+ÿ#ÿ,$#--ÿ'+ÿ ÿ
-.$#/$%ÿ-0"#0)ÿ!"#$-1ÿ ÿ ÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ
ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ2345675889ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ
76ÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ
ÿ
9:ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ
ÿ

ÿ6
5
6ÿ43:ÿ ÿ ÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ
ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ7;8;6<467:ÿ ÿ ÿ
===================================ÿÿÿ
ÿ
549ÿ
556ÿ>?@ABÿCAD?EAÿFGAÿH?IEFÿ?JÿKÿL?FM?JÿF?ÿNMB@MBBÿD?EÿOKMPIEAÿF?ÿQFKFAÿKÿ
HPKM@RÿDMPASÿCTÿNADAJSKJFÿUHVÿUAKPFG>KEARÿWJ>XÿYN?>XÿZ?Xÿ[\]Xÿÿÿÿÿÿ
4:ÿ _
`a
237ÿÿÿÿ
NADAJSKJFÿbcdÿbfghijkglfmÿnokpÿqrbcdstÿuvÿgÿwxyhukhzÿFEKSASÿG?PSMJ{ÿ>?@|KJTÿKJSÿ
MJSMEA>Fÿ>?E|?EKFAÿ|KEAJFÿ?Dÿ0}~ÿG?B|MFKPBÿKJSÿK||E?M@KFAPTÿ€R\\ÿBMFABÿ?Dÿ>KEAÿP?>KFASÿ
ijl‚xƒj‚xiÿijfÿ„ouif…ÿ†igifvÿgo…ÿ„ouif…ÿ‡uoƒ…‚ˆÿqrd‰‰uhugif…ÿb‚vwuighvÿgo…ÿŠgkuhuiufvstpÿUHVÿ
KBBAEFBÿFGKFÿFGAÿVDDMPMKFASÿU?B|MFKPBÿKJSÿOK>MPMFMABÿKEAÿBA|KEKFAÿPA{KPÿAJFMFMABÿDE?@ÿAK>Gÿ?FGAEÿKJSÿ
DE?@ÿUHVXÿOE?@ÿFGAMEÿEAB|A>FM‹AÿP?>KFM?JBRÿFGAÿVDDMPMKFASÿU?B|MFKPBÿKJSÿOK>MPMFMABÿ|E?‹MSAÿSMEA>Fÿ
|KFMAJFÿ>KEAXÿ
WJÿFGMBÿK>FM?JRÿŒPKMJFMDDRÿKÿD?E@AEÿEAB|MEKF?ETÿFGAEK|MBFÿKFÿLMBBM?JÿU?B|MFKPÿMJÿVBGA‹MPPARÿ
Z?EFGÿHKE?PMJKRÿGM>GÿMBÿKJÿVDDMPMKFASÿU?B|MFKPÿKJSÿOK>MPMFTRÿGKBÿBIASÿUHVÿF?ÿEA>?‹AEÿK{ABÿ
|IE|?EFASPTÿ?ASÿF?ÿGAEÿKJSÿ?FGAEÿMJSM‹MSIKPBÿA@|P?TASÿKFÿLMBBM?JÿU?B|MFKPÿKJSÿ?FGAEÿVDDMPMKFASÿ
U?B|MFKPBÿKJSÿOK>MPMFMABÿMJÿFGAÿBIEE?IJSMJ{ÿEA{M?Jÿ|IEBIKJFÿF?ÿFGAÿOKMEÿŽKC?EÿQFKJSKESBÿV>FRÿ€ÿ
ÿ

0ÿ

234353ÿ6ÿ078ÿ9
ÿ93ÿ
ÿÿÿ!ÿ"#ÿ!$ÿ%&ÿ'(ÿ)353ÿ*+)3ÿ4,-,3ÿ6ÿ./0
0/38ÿ
"%(ÿ123ÿ)45
6ÿ51547821ÿ94::42ÿ71;ÿ<=2>=
ÿ925896:92
?=12
=:ÿ:95=8
@3ÿA2ÿ
=BB45
(ÿC7182
8DDÿ1779E9ÿ
61
ÿF5-ÿ8:B54B957Gÿ54=2393ÿ123?45ÿ938
93ÿ695ÿ123ÿ
69ÿB=
1
8H9ÿ
I!JJKLÿMÿ'$Kÿ!$ÿJ$ÿÿINÿJÿMÿOPKÿÿKÿ!$ÿKÿMKK$ÿ$$ÿ!ÿPÿ
45ÿ;959ÿ82
955=B
933ÿÿÿ
Q2ÿR=29ÿ07(ÿ070S(ÿT9D92312
ÿD8793ÿ
69ÿB92382Eÿ:4
842ÿ
4ÿ38:8(ÿ99U82Eÿ38:817ÿ4Dÿ
V!JJLKÿ'MKÿJÿJ&ÿÿKÿÿ'Mÿ&!$ÿW&ÿXY
O
ZÿJÿÿ$ÿW&KÿJÿ[ÿ
C54993=593ÿ<T493ÿ)43ÿ\7@3ÿT9D92312
ÿ942
923ÿ
61
(ÿ1KÿÿMÿJÿ]ÿV!JJLKÿM!$$ÿ
54:B7182
ÿ349ÿ24
ÿ942
182ÿD19
ÿ=DD89892
ÿ
4ÿ9
1^786ÿ
69ÿ59=88
9ÿ9:B74G:92
ÿ5971
84268Bÿ
^9
;992ÿC7182
8DDÿ123ÿT9D92312
ÿF5-3ÿC7182
8DDÿ61ÿD8793ÿ1ÿ59B429(ÿ123ÿT9D92312
ÿ61ÿD8793ÿ1ÿ
59B7G3ÿ<T493ÿ)43ÿ\0(ÿ\_@3ÿ,68ÿ:1

95ÿ8ÿ58B9ÿD45ÿ38B48
8423ÿÿ
``aÿ cdefgehgÿjkÿhlm`lnÿ
o939517ÿp=79ÿ4Dÿ58H87ÿC54993=59ÿ80<^@<q@ÿB54H839ÿ
61
ÿ1ÿ:4
842ÿ:1Gÿ^9ÿ38:893ÿD45ÿ
D187=59ÿ
4ÿ
1
9ÿ1ÿ9718:ÿ=B42ÿ;6896ÿ59789Dÿ912ÿ^9ÿE512
933ÿ-ÿ:4
842ÿ
4ÿ38:8ÿB=5=12
ÿ
4ÿp=79ÿ
80<^@<q@ÿ
9
ÿ
69ÿ=DD898929Gÿ4Dÿ
69ÿ94:B7182
ÿ;8
64=
ÿ5947H82Eÿ942
9
ÿ4DÿD19
ÿ45ÿ
69ÿ:958
ÿ4Dÿ1ÿ
9718:3ÿÿp9B=^78912ÿC15
Gÿ4Dÿ)353ÿH3ÿr15
82(ÿ.s7ÿo303ÿ.S\(ÿ./0ÿ<S
6ÿ5853ÿ8..0@(ÿ995
3ÿ392893(ÿ/87ÿ
2343ÿs0sÿ<8..\@3ÿ,6=(ÿ
69ÿp=79ÿ80<^@<q@ÿ82=85Gÿ8ÿ78:8
93ÿ
4ÿ39
95:8282Eÿ8Dÿ
69ÿ1779E1
842ÿ
'!K&ÿÿKÿ!$ÿI!ÿKM!ÿJÿÿ'MÿK]!#ÿÿI$ÿKÿ!$ÿÿJÿ
B=5=12
ÿ
4ÿo939517ÿp=79ÿ4Dÿ58H87ÿC54993=59ÿs<1@<0@3ÿtÿK&[[ÿÿ$J!$!LKÿM!ÿÿ$KM KKÿ
J'&ÿ#!Kÿ!ÿÿ'MI!ÿM&KÿOÿK&JJ'!ÿÿKÿÿ#ÿÿJÿO[ÿÿ
KI'&[ÿ[uÿv977ÿ-
73ÿ545B3ÿH3ÿ,;4:^7G(ÿ//7ÿ2343ÿ/SS(ÿ/_7ÿ<077_@3ÿ,6=(ÿ1ÿ94:B7182
ÿ;877ÿ
K&[[ÿJÿÿ'!!Kÿ!&#ÿJ'KÿÿKÿÿ'MÿÿJÿÿKÿI&KOÿ!ÿKÿJ'uÿÿ
-6954D
ÿH3ÿA^17(ÿ//qÿ2343ÿqq0(ÿq_sÿ<077.@ÿ<=4
82Eÿ,;4:^7G(ÿ//7ÿ2343ÿ1
ÿ/_7@3ÿÿÿ
0ÿ
ÿ

234ÿ567ÿ89
8
ÿÿÿ9
ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ89ÿ!"
ÿ
ÿ
#$%&'5&((ÿ#$7%)*ÿ(%+5,%$ÿ+3'57'5ÿ56%5ÿ%$$3-*ÿ567ÿ+3,45ÿ53ÿ)4%-ÿ567ÿ47%*3'%.$7ÿ&'(747'+7ÿ56%5ÿ567ÿ
/

/ÿÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ/9ÿ
0
/12ÿ3)4ÿ56,35&'7ÿ8-39.$:;ÿ<<=ÿ>4?4ÿ%5ÿ<<@A4ÿ867ÿ
B3,45ÿ9,*5ÿ)4%-ÿ%$$ÿ47%*3'%.$7ÿ(%+5,%$ÿ&'(747'+7*ÿ&'ÿ(%C34ÿ3(ÿ567ÿ#$%&'5&((4ÿD4&34&5:ÿE,53ÿF4#4;ÿ
3'+4ÿC4ÿ234)ÿG3534ÿB34;ÿH<Hÿ240)ÿI0H;ÿI0Jÿ5K56ÿB&44ÿL=IKA4ÿ3'ÿ%ÿM,$7ÿIL5.A5@Aÿ%'%$:*&*;ÿ567ÿB3,45ÿ
9,*5ÿ*7#%4%57ÿ(%+5*ÿ(439ÿ$77%$ÿ+3'+$,*&3'*;ÿ%*ÿ9747ÿ+3'+$,*&3'*ÿ%47ÿ'35ÿ7'5&5$7)ÿ53ÿ%ÿ#47*,9#5&3'ÿ
3(ÿ54,564ÿ36.%$;ÿ<<@ÿ>4?4ÿ%5ÿ@HN4ÿO8
ÿ!PQ

/

ÿ

ÿÿ
ÿ


ÿÿÿ9
ÿÿ
ÿ988

/ÿÿ

ÿ9
ÿ

ÿ/ÿÿ9
12ÿ3)4ÿR3-7C74;ÿ-7$$S#$7%)7)ÿ
(%+5,%$ÿ%$$77%5&3'*ÿ%47ÿ7'5&5$7)ÿ53ÿ%ÿ#47*,9#5&3'ÿ3(ÿ54,56;ÿ%')ÿ567ÿ+3,45ÿ*63,$)ÿ)75749&'7ÿ-675674ÿ
567ÿ%$$77%5&3'*ÿ#$%,*&.$:ÿ7&C7ÿ4&*7ÿ53ÿ%'ÿ7'5&5$797'5ÿ53ÿ47$&7(4ÿ3)4ÿ%5ÿ@HJ4ÿÿÿ
TTTUÿ WTXYZXXT[\ÿ
R747;ÿ7&C7'ÿ567ÿ7]54797$:ÿ$7'&7'5ÿ#$7%)&'7ÿ*5%')%4)*ÿ3(ÿ36.%$ÿ%')ÿ8-39.$:;ÿ567ÿB3,45ÿ
-&$$ÿ)7':ÿ567ÿ935&3'ÿ53ÿ)&*9&**;ÿ#7')&'7ÿ(,45674ÿ)7C7$3#97'5ÿ3(ÿ567ÿ47+34)4ÿ867ÿ*#7+&(&+ÿ&**,7ÿ
.7(347ÿ567ÿB3,45ÿ&*ÿ-675674ÿD$%&'5&((ÿ%')ÿ567ÿ35674ÿ#43#3*7)ÿ+$%**ÿ979.74*ÿ&'ÿ56&*ÿ+%*7ÿ%47ÿ
79#$3:77*ÿ3(ÿ^7(7')%'5ÿRBE4ÿD$%&'5&((ÿ%$$777*ÿ56%5ÿ,')74ÿ567ÿ_9
ÿ`
9aÿ
ÿ


ÿ
57*5;ÿ567:ÿ%47ÿb

/aÿ
8

4ÿ?77ÿc744ÿC4ÿG%4*6%$$ÿ>'&C4ÿd)4ÿ3(ÿF3C74'34*;ÿNLKÿ240)ÿ@L;ÿ
N0ÿ5K56ÿB&44ÿL=I@A4ÿ^7(7')%'5ÿ%47,7*ÿ56%5ÿ567:ÿ%47ÿ'35;ÿ%')ÿ^7(7')%'5ÿ6%*ÿ*,.9&557)ÿ567ÿ
^7+$%4%5&3'ÿ3(ÿe)-%4)ÿB,4C&'ÿ53ÿ#43C7ÿRBEÿ&*ÿ'35ÿ567ÿ79#$3:74ÿ3(ÿD$%&'5&((ÿ%')ÿ567ÿ#43#3*7)ÿ
+$%**ÿ979.74*4ÿ?77ÿ5^3+4ÿf34ÿ0=SLA4ÿ86&*ÿ)7+$%4%5&3';ÿ63-7C74;ÿ+%''35ÿ.7ÿ+3'*&)747)ÿ-67'ÿ
%'%$:g&'7ÿ%ÿM,$7ÿIL5.A5@Aÿ935&3'ÿ53ÿ)&*9&**4ÿE94ÿB6&43#4%+5&+ÿE**h'ÿC4ÿ84&73'ÿR7%$56+%47;ÿ3'+4;ÿ
ijÿ_1i/ÿÿikÿkÿ`
1ÿllkÿ!mÿ%ÿ77'74%$ÿ4,$7;ÿ7C&)7'+7ÿ*63,$)ÿ'35ÿ.7ÿ+3'*&)747)ÿ%5ÿ567ÿ
ÿ0
124ÿ
d%*7)ÿ3'$:ÿ3'ÿ567ÿ%$$77%5&3'*ÿ*75ÿ(3456ÿ&'ÿ567ÿE97')7)ÿB39#$%&'5;ÿ567ÿB3,45ÿ+3'+$,)7*ÿ
0ÿ
ÿ

2342ÿ564782799ÿ34
ÿ
9977
826ÿ466

ÿ942
ÿ2342ÿ4
2
ÿ4
ÿ2
ÿ
2ÿ
9
8482ÿÿÿ
4
ÿ!"!##ÿ
$6
%ÿ&376
ÿ7
'
ÿ48ÿ
(

)
82ÿ$278ÿ427
ÿ$4ÿ'7
ÿ23
ÿ2ÿ
*723ÿ4727846ÿ4$
82
ÿ8ÿ2342ÿ7

ÿ564782799ÿ34
ÿ
427
97
ÿ3
ÿ6
478ÿ(
8%ÿ+3
ÿ
7
$7

46ÿ7
ÿ82ÿ
ÿ42ÿ237
ÿ
24
ÿ78ÿ23
ÿ

78
%ÿ,

ÿ
%%ÿ68ÿ'%ÿÿ
46234
ÿ-8%ÿ
.%ÿ/01/'20ÿ1310ÿ&4ÿ5133160ÿ42ÿ71ÿ89%%ÿ+
88%ÿ94%ÿ13ÿ1310:ÿ8
878ÿ4ÿ$278ÿ2ÿ
7
$7

ÿ(ÿÿ78ÿ4ÿ
7$764ÿ;4,ÿ4278:%ÿÿ
<=>ÿ @AB@CDE<ABÿ
FG#G"H"ÿIJ!J"ÿJÿH!I!ÿ!ÿHG"!GHKÿÿÿÿÿ
<Lÿ<EMÿLNOPOQAPOMÿAPROPORÿ23420ÿ
5%ÿ+3
ÿ9278ÿ2ÿ7
$7

ÿ9ÿ;476
ÿ2ÿ,242
ÿ4ÿ647$ÿ976
ÿ(ÿ
9
8482ÿÿ8%ÿ
.%ÿ/3:ÿ7
ÿROB<OR%ÿ
ÿ
Signed: August 30, 2024
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ

ÿ

0ÿ