Dayton Anesthesia & Pain Services, LLC et al v. Trinity Hope Associates, LLC et al

Filing 15

JUDGMENT in favor of Defendants Trinity Hope Associates, LLC and Tabatha Mullis against Plaintiffs (nvc)

Download PDF
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA STATESVILLE DIVISION 5:16-cv-158 DAYTON ANESTHESIA & PAIN SERVICES, LLC, LAWRENCE ANESTHESIA SERVICES, LLC, PALMETTO ANESTHESIA SPECIALISTS, LLC, PARRISH ANESTHESIA SPECIALISTS, LLC, PHS TH ANESTHESIA, PC, PORTLAND ANESTHESIA SPECIALISTS, LLC, RACINE ANESTHESIA SERVICES, LLC, REDMOND ANESTHESIA & PAIN TREATMENT, PC, SAGINAW ANESTHESIA SERVICES, PLLC, SOUTH FLORIDA ANESTHESIA & PAIN TREATMENT, PA, TOPEKA ANESTHESIA & PAIN TREATMENT, PA, TREASURE COAST ANESTHESIA GROUP, PA, WARRENSBURG ANESTHESIA & PAIN TREATMENT, LLC, WOLVERINE ANESTHESIA CONSULTANTS, LLC, and WOOD ANESTHESIA & PAIN TREATMENT, LLC ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) JUDGMENT Plaintiffs, v. TRINITY HOPE ASSOCIATES, LLC, and TABATHA MULLIS, INDIVIDUALLY Defendants. 1. On April 28, 2017, Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, offered to allow the Plaintiffs Dayton Anesthesia & Pain Services, LLC, Lawrence Anesthesia Services, LLC, Palmetto Anesthesia Specialists, LLC, Parrish Anesthesia Specialists, LLC, R&S 1823531_1 PHS TH Anesthesia, PC, Portland Anesthesia Specialists, LLC, Racine Anesthesia Services, LLC, Redmond Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, PC, Saginaw Anesthesia Services, PLLC, South Florida Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, PA, Topeka Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, PA, Treasure Coast Anesthesia Group, PA, Warrensburg Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, LLC, Wolverine Anesthesia Consultants, LLC, and Wood Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, LLC, to take judgment against them, jointly and severally, in the following amounts, said amounts including any and all damages, attorney's fees taxable as costs, expert witnesses, interest, and any and all remaining costs accrued as of May 10, 2017. Plaintiff Dayton Anesthesia & Pain Services, LLC $56,832.52 Plaintiff Lawrence Anesthesia Services, LLC $86,639.35 Plaintiff Palmetto Anesthesia Specialists, LLC $73,004.90 Plaintiff Parrish Anesthesia Specialists, LLC $58,786.13 Plaintiff PHS TH Anesthesia, PC $64,917.34 Plaintiff Portland Anesthesia Specialists, LLC $82,914.41 Plaintiff Racine Anesthesia Services, LLC $96,759.55 Plaintiff Redmond Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, PC $95,673.88 Plaintiff Saginaw Anesthesia Services, PLLC $154,559.82 Plaintiff South Florida Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, PA $146,763.57 Plaintiff Topeka Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, PA Plaintiff Treasure Coast Anesthesia Group, PA $59,548.28 $112,832.64 Plaintiff Warrensburg Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, LLC $48,971.91 Plaintiff Wolverine Anesthesia Consultants, LLC $62,777.92 Plaintiff Wood Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, LLC $73,404.95 TOTAL $1,274,387.17 2. On May 10, 2017, Plaintiffs accepted the offer of judgment. R&S 1823531_1 IT IS, THEREFORE, ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED as follows: (1) The Plaintiff Dayton Anesthesia & Pain Services, LLC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $56,832.52, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (2) The Plaintiff Lawrence Anesthesia Services, LLC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $86,639.35, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (3) The Plaintiff Palmetto Anesthesia Specialists, LLC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $73,004.90, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (4) The Plaintiff Parrish Anesthesia Specialists, LLC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $58,786.13, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (5) The Plaintiff PHS TH Anesthesia, PC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $64,917.34, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (6) The Plaintiff Portland Anesthesia Specialists, LLC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $82,914.41, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (7) The Plaintiff Racine Anesthesia Services, LLC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $96,759.55, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (8) The Plaintiff Redmond Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, PC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $95,673.88, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (9) The Plaintiff Saginaw Anesthesia Services, PLLC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, R&S 1823531_1 individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $154,559.82, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (10) The Plaintiff South Florida Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, PA, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $146,763.57, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (11) The Plaintiff Topeka Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, PA, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $59,548.28, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (12) The Plaintiff Treasure Coast Anesthesia Group, PA, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $112,832.64, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (13) The Plaintiff Warrensburg Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, LLC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $48,971.91, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (14) The Plaintiff Wolverine Anesthesia Consultants, LLC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $62,777.92, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (15) The Plaintiff Wood Anesthesia & Pain Treatment, LLC, shall have and recover of the Defendants Trinity Hope, LLC, and Tabatha Mullis, individually, jointly and severally, the sum of $73,404.95, a sum which includes prejudgment interest, and nothing more. (16) The Clerk of Court is instructed to enter Judgment this day in accordance with this decision, with interest thereafter running at. (17) Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. ยง 1961, the Plaintiffs are further awarded post-judgment interest at the lawful federal judgment rate as of the date of the entry of judgment. IT IS SO ORDERED. R&S 1823531_1 Signed: May 11, 2017

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?