Indratech, LLC v. Fibrix, LLC
Filing
24
PROTECTIVE ORDER. Signed by Magistrate Judge David Keesler on 4/6/2017. (nvc)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA
STATESVILLE DIVISION
CIVIL ACTION NO. 5:16-CV-179-RLV-DCK
INDRATECH, LLC,
a Michigan limited liability company,
Plaintiff,
v.
PROTECTIVE ORDER
FIBRIX, LLC,
a Delaware limited liability company,
Defendant.
WHEREAS, Plaintiff, Indratech, LLC and Defendant, Fibrix, LLC (hereinafter referred
to collectively as “the Parties” or individually as a “party”) recognize that pursuant to discovery
or otherwise during the course of this Action, each party, and potentially non-parties, will be
required to disclose confidential or proprietary information, the unrestricted disclosure of which
would tend to cause injury to the disclosing party;
WHEREAS, in order to facilitate orderly discovery, the Parties seek entry of a protective
order limiting disclosure thereof in accordance with Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(c);
THEREFORE, it is hereby stipulated among the Parties and ORDERED that:
This Order shall govern the production, use, and disclosure of confidential documents
and information produced, used, or disclosed in connection with this action and designated in
accordance with this Order. Any party or non-party disclosing information (hereinafter,
“disclosing party”) may designate information or documents produced, used, or disclosed in
connection with this action as “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” and subject to the protections and requirements of
this Order, if so designated in writing to each party, by stamping the legend
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,”
or
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—
PROSECUTION BAR” on the documents or information prior to production, or orally if
recorded as part of a deposition or court record, pursuant to the terms of this Order.
2.
Any disclosing party may designate any document, material, or information as
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,”
or
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—
PROSECUTION BAR.” In designating information and materials as “CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR,”
counsel for a disclosing party will make such designation only as to that information that he or
she in good faith believes to be “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” as defined in Paragraphs 2.a., 2.b., and
2.c. rder.
a.
“CONFIDENTIAL” means testimony, information, documents, and data
which constitute trade secrets or other confidential research, development, business, financial, or
marketing information of the disclosing party, the unrestricted disclosure of which would tend to
cause injury to the disclosing party. The “CONFIDENTIAL” category shall be invoked by a
disclosing party only relative to documents and testimony or categories of documents and
testimony that contain confidential information that legitimately falls within the definition of
protectable documents under Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c), including but not limited to confidential
research, development, business, financial, or marketing information, the unrestricted disclosure
of which would tend to cause injury to the disclosing party.
b.
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL” means testimony, information documents,
and data that meet the criteria of “CONFIDENTAL” contained in Paragraph 2.a. of this Order,
2
and that, if disclosed to a business competitor, would tend to damage the disclosing party’s
competitive position.
c.
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” means testimony,
information, documents, and data that meet the criteria of “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL”
contained in paragraph 2.b. of this Order and shall consist only of technical information and shall
not be applied to information that is exclusively financial.
3.
In the case of a document, a designation of “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” shall be
accomplished by marking the header or footer of each page of the document, to the extent
reasonable, with the legend “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR.”
4.
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Order, the Parties and any non-party
disclosing party shall confer and attempt to agree before any Court trial or hearing on the
procedures to be included in a protective order pursuant to which “CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR”
material may be used or introduced into evidence at such trial or hearing. Upon reaching
agreement, the Parties shall give notice of the terms of such agreement to each disclosing party
producing
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,”
or
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” material which may be used or introduced at such
trial or hearing. Because it would affect the public availability of material used at a trial or
hearing, any such agreement will be effective only upon Court approval. Absent agreement
among the Parties, any party upon reasonable notice to the disclosing party producing
“CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—
3
PROSECUTION BAR” material which may be used or introduced at such trial or hearing may
move the Court to issue an order governing the use of such information at a trial or hearing.
Unless the Parties agree otherwise in advance, information conveyed or discussed in testimony at
a deposition shall be subject to this Order and shall initially be designated “HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” at the time the testimony is given. During such
time
as any
information
or
documents designated “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” are disclosed in
a deposition, any party shall have the right to exclude from attendance at the deposition any
person who is not entitled to receive such information or documents pursuant to this Order.
Unless counsel for a party states otherwise on the record, the entire deposition transcript for each
deponent in this action and the information contained therein is to be treated as “HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” for a period of time not to exceed 14 days after the
party receives a copy of the deposition transcript, during which time the party may designate, in
writing, specific portions of the transcript “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,”
or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” as appropriate. If the party fails to
designate in writing any portions of the transcript as “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” within the 30
day period, the other parties shall be permitted to use the transcript and the information contained
therein with no restrictions of confidentiality subject to the provisions of paragraph 5 below.
5.
Subject to the provisions of Paragraphs 2 and 3, the failure to object to a
designation of information or documents as “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,”
or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” in accordance with this Order shall
not preclude a party at a later time from subsequently objecting to the designation of such
4
information or documents as “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR.” A receiving party shall treat all documents as
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR,” no matter how designated, for a period
of five (5) business days after said disclosure to permit a disclosing party who erroneously fails
to
designate
certain
information
or
documents
as
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” to cure the error.
Thereafter, the Parties understand and acknowledge that failure of a party to designate
information or documents as “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” relieves the receiving party of obligations of
confidentiality until such a designation is made, except as otherwise provided herein.
6.
A party that objects to the designation of any document or information as
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,”
or
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—
PROSECUTION BAR” shall provide written notice of the objection to the designating party.
The notice shall state with specificity the document objected to and the basis for the objection. If
the dispute cannot be resolved, the objecting party may move the Court requesting that the
document(s) in question be redesignated. If such motion is brought by the objecting party, the
designating party shall bear the burden of establishing the confidentiality of the document(s) in
question. No party shall be under any obligation to object to any designation of confidentiality at
the time such designation is made, or any time thereafter. No party shall, by failure to object, be
found to have acquiesced or agreed to such designation or be barred from objecting to such a
designation at any time thereafter. Each party to this litigation additionally acknowledges that
nothing in this Order shall prevent interested members of the public from challenging the
propriety
of
a
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY
5
CONFIDENTIAL,
or
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” designation of documents and/or categories
of documents by petitioning this Court.
7.
Other than by the disclosing party, any information or document designated as
“CONFIDENTIAL” shall be used solely in connection with the action and shall not be used in
any other manner by a receiving party. Any such designated information or documents shall not
be disclosed to anyone other than:
a.
the Court and court personnel;
b.
court reporters taking testimony in this action and their necessary
stenographic, videographic, and clerical personnel;
c.
counsel of record for the parties (including any attorney at the firms of
record) and counsel of record’s employees;
d.
no more than three employees of a party who require the information to
assist the attorneys involved in this action or to evaluate this action for
settlement discussions and who have executed a Declaration in the form
and scope of Exhibit A attached hereto;
e.
vendors retained by or for the parties to assist in preparing the case,
including, but not limited to, e-discovery vendors, experts, investigators,
outside counsel retained by the parties for purposes of this matter whose
attorneys have not filed any appearances in this case (“Non-Appearing
Outside Counsel”), translators, jury consultants, and mock jury members
that are not presently employees of a party, provided, however, that before
any person other than those identified in paragraphs 7(a), 7(b), and 7(c)
above is shown or receives any information or document designated as
“CONFIDENTIAL,” he or she must execute a Declaration in the form and
scope of Exhibit A attached hereto and the procedures of Paragraph 9 shall
be followed;
f.
persons testifying in depositions or court proceedings (including, without
limitation, persons preparing to testify in such depositions or court
proceedings) to the extent the “CONFIDENTIAL” document or
information was authored by, addressed to, or received by the person or
party testifying;
g.
such other persons as the parties may designate in writing by stipulation or
orally agree upon on the record at a deposition in this action, provided,
however, that before such person is shown or receives any information or
document designated as “CONFIDENTIAL,” he or she must (1) execute a
6
Declaration in the form of Exhibit A attached hereto or (2) agree orally on
the record at a deposition in this action to be bound by the terms of this
Order, and further provided that any documents designated as
“CONFIDENTIAL” shall not be left in the possession of the person subject
to this subparagraph “f”, unless the person otherwise qualifies for access
to such documents pursuant to this Order.
8.
Other than by the disclosing party, any information or document designated as
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” shall
be used solely in connection with the action and shall not be used in any other manner by a
receiving party. Any such designated information or documents shall not be disclosed to anyone
other than:
a.
the Court and court personnel;
b.
court reporters taking testimony in this action and their necessary
stenographic, videographic, and clerical personnel;
c.
counsel of record for the parties (including any attorney at the firms of
record) and counsel of record’s employees;
d.
vendors retained by or for the parties to assist in preparing the case,
including, but not limited to, e-discovery vendors, experts, translators,
Non-Appearing Outside Counsel, jury consultants, and mock jury members
that are not presently employees of a party, provided, however, that before
any person other than those identified in paragraphs 8.a., 8.b., and 8.c.
above is shown or receives any information or document designated as
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” he or she must execute a Declaration in
the form and scope of Exhibit A attached hereto and the procedures of
Paragraph 9 shall be followed;
e.
persons testifying in depositions or court proceedings (including, without
limitation, persons preparing to testify in such depositions or court
proceedings) to the extent the “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL” document or
information was authored by, addressed to, or received by the person or
party testifying;
f.
such other persons as the parties may designate in writing by stipulation or
orally agree upon on the record at a deposition in this action, provided,
however, that before such person is shown or receives any information or
document designated as “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” he or she must (1)
execute a Declaration in the form and scope of Exhibit A attached hereto
or (2) agree orally on the record at a deposition in this action to be bound
7
by the terms of this Order, and further provided that any documents
designated as “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL” shall not be left in the
possession of the person subject to this subparagraph “f”, unless the person
qualifies for access to such documents pursuant to this Order.
Notwithstanding the foregoing paragraphs a. through f., absent written consent from the
disclosing party, any individual who receives access to HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—
PROSECUTION BAR information shall not be involved in the prosecution of the patent asserted
in this action and any patent or application claiming priority to or otherwise related to the patent
asserted in this action, before any foreign or domestic agency, including the United States Patent
and Trademark Office (“PTO”). For purposes of this paragraph, “prosecution” includes directly
or indirectly drafting, amending, advising, or otherwise affecting the scope or maintenance of
patent claims. It includes, for example, original prosecution and reissue proceedings, and also
includes reexamination proceedings initiated by, for the benefit of, or on behalf of anyone other
than an opposing party in this case. In such reexamination proceedings counsel is prohibited
from (1) using the opposing party’s confidential information to draft new claims or amend
existing claims or for any other purpose during such reexamination process; and (2) directly or
indirectly revealing the opposing party’s confidential information to any reexamination counsel
or agent. This Prosecution Bar shall begin when access to HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—
PROSECUTION BAR information is first received by the affected individual and shall end two
(2) years after final termination of this action, including any appeals.
9.
The attorneys of record for each of the parties shall retain the original, executed
Declarations (in the form and scope of Exhibit A hereto) that have been executed by that party
and/or its employees and that party’s witnesses, experts, translators, and jury consultants. It shall
be sufficient for an expert, investigator, and jury consultant to execute the Declaration on behalf
of the members and employees of his or her firm; no additional Declarations are necessary from
8
such members and employees. Prior to disclosure of any documents or information designated
“CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—
PROSECUTION BAR” to any experts or Non-Appearing Outside Counsel, a copy of the
executed Declaration shall be served upon opposing counsel (and, for experts, with a copy of
such person’s curriculum vitae, a general statement of any prior or current relationship or
connection with either party, a list of all cases in which such person has been deposed or testified
as an expert, and a general statement as to the issues the expert is intended to opine upon
attached). Opposing counsel shall make any objections to the disclosure to the expert or NonAppearing Outside Counsel in writing no later than seven (7) business days from the date of
receipt. No such disclosure shall occur until the objection is resolved or the Court grants a
motion permitting the disclosure. The burden to file any such motion is on the party that seeks to
disclose
documents
or
information
designated
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” to an expert or
Non-Appearing Outside Counsel. Any such objections to the disclosure must be in good faith
and not interposed for purposes of delay or harassment.
10.
All parties shall make reasonable efforts to avoid requesting the filing of any
documents or information designated as “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” under seal by, for example, redacting or
otherwise excluding from a submission to the Court any confidential information not directly
pertinent to the submission. Where not reasonably possible, any Party wishing to file a document
or paper containing “CONFIDENTIAL,” “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” material may request that material be filed under
seal by motion, consistent with the Local Rules of the United States District Court for
9
the Western District of North Carolina.
11.
Unless otherwise permitted herein, within sixty (60) days after the final
disposition of the action, including all appeals therefrom, all documents (originals and copies)
designated
as
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,”
or
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR,” and all excerpts therefrom in the possession,
custody, or control of parties other than the disclosing party, and experts, investigators, advisors,
or consultants shall be destroyed or returned to counsel for the disclosing party. Outside Counsel
for parties other than the disclosing party may retain one copy of each document, pleading, trial
exhibit, deposition exhibit, work product, and transcript embodying documents or information
designated
as
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,”
or
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR” for archival purposes only, but shall destroy or
return all additional copies of such documents, pleadings, trial exhibits, deposition exhibits, work
product, and transcripts. Upon request, the parties and their counsel shall separately provide
written certification to the disclosing party within sixty (60) days after the final disposition of
this action that the actions required by the paragraph have been completed.
12.
The Court shall retain jurisdiction over the parties for the purpose of ensuring
compliance with this Order and granting such amendments, modifications, and additions to this
Order and such other and further relief as may be necessary, and any party may apply to the
Court at any time for an amendment, modification, or addition to this Order. This Order shall
survive the final disposition of the action, by judgment, dismissal, settlement, or otherwise.
13.
A party in receipt of documents or information designated as confidential
hereunder who is requested or required to disclose the document or information pursuant to any
law, regulation, order, or rule of any governmental authority, shall make reasonable efforts to
10
promptly notify (in writing) the parties, through their counsel, to provide them sufficient time to
limit or oppose such disclosure. To the extent possible, and without violating any applicable
laws, such notice shall be at least ten (10) business days before such disclosure is required.
14.
In the event that anyone violates or threatens to violate the terms of this Order, the
parties agree that the aggrieved party may apply immediately to obtain injunctive relief against
any such violation or threatened violation, and in the event the aggrieved party shall do so, the
respondent, subject to the provisions of this Order, shall not employ as a defense thereto any
claim that the aggrieved party possesses an adequate remedy at law.
15.
Neither this Order nor any stipulation therefore, nor any disclosure or use of
information or documents, in whatever form, pursuant to this Order, shall be deemed an
admission, waiver, or agreement by any party that any information or documents designated as
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,”
or
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL—
PROSECUTION BAR” hereunder is or is not a trade secret or confidential information for
purposes of determining the merits of any claims any party may have against one another or a
third party. Neither this Order nor any stipulation therefore shall be deemed to expand the scope
of discovery in this action beyond the limits otherwise prescribed by law, nor to enlarge the
scope of discovery to matters unrelated to this action.
16.
Inadvertent production of documents subject to work product immunity or the
attorney-client privilege or any other privilege or immunity shall not constitute a waiver of the
immunity or privilege; provided that the disclosing party takes reasonable steps to rectify the
error, including by notifying the receiving party in writing via e-mail of such inadvertent
production immediately upon learning of same. This Order shall be interpreted to provide the
maximum protection allowed by Federal Rule of Evidence 502(d). Such inadvertently produced
11
documents, and all copies thereof, shall be returned to the disclosing party upon request
immediately. Nothing in this Protective Order shall prevent the receiving party from
requesting
that the Court order the production of any such inadvertently produced
documents. Nothing in this Protective Order prevents any party from petitioning the Court
for return of later discovered, inadvertently produced documents that are subject to work
product immunity or attorney-client privilege.
17.
Nothing in the order shall be construed to affect the admissibility of any
document, material, or information at any trial or hearing; any request for confidentiality,
closure, or sealing of any hearing or trial must be made to the judge then presiding over
this action. A party intending to introduce confidential information or documentation at any
hearing or trial in this action will request a sidebar with the Court for a ruling on how the
information or documentation is to be treated.
18.
Nothing in this Order shall bar or otherwise restrict any qualified attorney
herein from rendering advice to his or her client with respect to this litigation and, in the course
thereof, relying upon his examination of information or documents designated as
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—
PROSECUTION BAR,” provided that no disclosure of the substance of any such information
shall be made except to those permitted to access such documents or information in accordance
with this Order.
19.
The parties agree to abide by and be bound by the terms of this Order
upon signature hereof as if the Order had been entered on that date.
13
IT IS SO ORDERED:
Signed: April 6, 2017
SO STIPULATED AND AGREED:
CARLSON, GASKEY & OLDS, P.C.
ADAMS AND REESE LLP
/s/Brian B. Brown
Timothy C. Bradley
(N.C. State Bar No. 4119)
Brian B. Brown (pro hac vice)
400 West Maple Road, Suite 350
Birmingham, MI 48009
Telephone: (248) 988-8360
Facsimile: (248) 988-8363
tbradley@cgolaw.com
bbrown@cgolaw.com
/s/Lyndey Ritz Zwingelberg
Lyndey Ritz Zwingelberg
Federal Bar ID 49638
1501 Main Street, Fifth Floor
Columbia, SC 29201
Telephone: (803) 254-4190
Facsimile: (803) 779-4749
lyndey.zwing@arlaw.com
Attorneys for Plaintiff/Counter-Defendant
Indratech, LLC
Ray Ferrera (pro hac vice)
Lyondell Basell Tower
1221 McKinney, Suite 4400
Houston, TX 77010
Telephone: (713) 308-0127
Facsimile: (713) 652-5152
Melissa Rizzo (pro hac vice)
Eric J. Partlow (pro hac vice)
Bank of America Plaza
101 East Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 4000
Tampa, FL 33602
Telephone: (813) 402-2871
Facsimile: (813) 402-2887
Attorneys for Defendant/Counter-Plaintiff
Fibrix, LLC
14
EXHIBIT A
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA
STATESVILLE DIVISION
CIVIL ACTION NO. 5:16-CV-179-RLV-DCK
INDRATECH, LLC,
a Michigan limited liability company,
Plaintiff,
v.
AGREEMENT TO BE BOUND BY
PROTECTIVE ORDER
FIBIRX, LLC,
a Delaware limited liability company,
Defendant.
DECLARATION OF
I,
1.
, declare as follows:
My address is
.
2.
If I am an expert, a copy of my curriculum vitae is attached.
3.
My present employer is
.
4.
My present occupation or job description is
.
5.
I have received a copy of the Stipulated Protective Order Regarding
Confidentiality entered in this action on
.
14
6.
I have carefully read and understood the provisions of the Stipulated Protective
Order Regarding Confidentiality.
7.
I will comply with all of the provisions of the Stipulated Protective Order
Regarding Confidentiality.
8.
I will hold in confidence, not to disclose to anyone not designated in the Stipulated
Protective Order Regarding Confidentiality, and will use only for the purposes of this litigation,
any
information
or
documents
designated
as
“CONFIDENTIAL,”
“HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL,” or “HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL—PROSECUTION BAR.”
9.
I hereby submit to the jurisdiction of this Court for the purposes of enforcement
against me of the terms of the Stipulated Protective Order Regarding Confidentiality and of the
terms of this Declaration.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed on
in
.
(Signature)
15
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?