Brate v. Belcan Corporation

Filing 8

TRIAL PROCEDURAL ORDER: Signed by Judge Herman J. Weber on 4/19/2013. (eb)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
WESTERN DIVISION
LILLIE BRATE,
Plaintiff
v.

CIVIL ACTION: C-1-13-5

BELCAN CORPORATION,
Defendant
TRIAL PROCEDURAL ORDER
The Court ORDERS that the parties shall comply with the following:
A.

EXPERT WITNESSES
The parties shall certify as part of the proposed Joint Final Pretrial Order that they have complied with

Fed. R. Civ. P. 26 pertaining to expert testimony. Additionally, the parties shall submit with the Joint Final Pretrial
Order a curriculum vitae and a binding summary of the written reports of the expert witnesses who will testify at
trial.
B.

WITNESS LIST
Upon filing of the Joint Pretrial Order, the parties shall file with the Court and submit a copy via email

([e-mail]) a list of witnesses who will testify or who will be available to testify.
When more than a combined total of 10 witnesses are listed to testify at trial, a detailed and binding summary of
the testimony of each witness shall be submitted.
Leave to call additional witnesses may be granted by the Court in unusual situations.

C.

PREPARATION OF EXHIBITS

(1)

Each of the parties shall assemble all documents, photographs or other materials expected to be

used at trial. Such documents or copies thereof properly identified shall be provided to all other parties on or
before FIVE BUSINESS DAYS PRIOR TO THE FILING OF THE PROPOSED JOINT FINAL PRETRIAL
ORDER.
(2)

Exhibits shall be presented to the Court as follows:
(a)

All documents, photographs and other materials expected to be used at Trial shall be

SUBMITTED TO THE COURT 5 BUSINESS DAYS PRIOR TO THE FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE in
looseleaf notebooks as follows:
One set of looseleaf notebooks shall contain original exhibits with a
NUMBERED ORIGINAL EXHIBIT STICKER ON THE LOWER RIGHT HAND
CORNER OF THE DOCUMENT. This set of notebooks is submitted to the
Court for use by witnesses during trial, shall become part of the record and will
accompany the jury to the jury room where appropriate.
Two additional sets of notebooks shall be assembled using copies of original
exhibits after original exhibits have been marked with the appropriate exhibit
labels. These notebooks shall be submitted to the Court for its use during trial.
In each notebook, the exhibit number shall also appear on a tab extending
beyond the notebook on the right hand side thereof.
A neutral list of the party=s exhibits shall be prepared by the parties which shall
be supplied to the jury during its deliberations. FOUR COPIES of the exhibit
list shall be provided to the Court and copies of the exhibits and the exhibit list
provided to each party.

(b)

THE PARTIES SHALL INCLUDE IN EACH VOLUME OF EXHIBITS, THE NEUTRAL

LIST OF THE EXHIBITS AND SHALL PROVIDE THE COURT WITH FOUR (4) EXTRA COPIES OF THE
EXHIBIT LIST AND WITNESS LIST.
(c)

Joint exhibits will bear Roman numerals; plaintiff exhibits - Arabic numbers; and

defendant exhibits - letters. Third-party exhibits may be marked with an identifying letter prefix.
(d)

If defendant exhibits will exceed 26, defense counsel must promptly advise opposing

counsel. In such event, both sides will identify exhibits by number as follows: Plaintiff: 1-499; 1000-1499;
2000-2499, etc.; Defendant: 500-999, 1500-1999, 2500-2999, etc.
(e)

Deposited exhibits shall be retrieved by counsel within 10 days of final disposition of the

case. Those not retrieved will be disposed of in accordance with Local Rule 79.2(b).
D.

JURY INSTRUCTIONS

Proposed jury instructions and Special Verdict Forms shall be submitted to opposing party 10 BUSINESS DAYS
prior to trial. The parties shall ELECTRONICALLY submit to the Court 5 BUSINESS DAYS BEFORE trial,
copies of their opponent's instructions and forms which are: underlined in BLUE as to those matters which are
correct statements of law; underlined in YELLOW as to those matters which are correct statements of law but
irrelevant; and, underlined in RED as to those matters which misstate the law.

THE PARTIES SHALL EMAIL ([e-mail]) TO THE COURT THEIR
PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS (word or wordperfect format). Instructions upon issues that could not
reasonably be foreseen in advance may be submitted at least 24 HOURS prior to final argument. Each
requested instruction must be presented on a separate page. Instructions must contain a citation of authority
upon which counsel relies. Instructions which do not contain such citations may be rejected.
E.

DEPOSITIONS, INTERROGATORIES AND ADMISSIONS
Depositions filed electronically with the Court shall be submitted to the Court in hard-copy FIVE

BUSINESS DAYS prior to the Final Pretrial Conference.
If any party intends to present evidence by depositions, admissions or interrogatories, the party shall
specify to the opposing party and the Court in the proposed Joint Final Pretrial Order those portions that will be
presented as evidence. The opposing party shall note objections to any portion of the depositions, admissions
or interrogatories in the proposed Joint Final Pretrial Order. No admission or interrogatory answer shall be
considered for admission in evidence unless they are attached to the proposed Joint Final Pretrial Order.
Where a necessity for the use of a deposition, admission or interrogatory develops unavoidably after the
proposed Joint Final Pretrial Order is submitted, leave to use such deposition, admission or interrogatory shall be
granted.

The parties shall advise the Court as soon as the necessity to read a deposition, admission or

interrogatory becomes apparent.

Videotape presentation of a deposition or interrogatory must include a method for cutting off either sound
or the entire picture from the jury in situations where the Court must rule on objections to testimony. Additionally,
a written transcript of the deposition or copy of the interrogatory must be filed with the Court.
F.

HYPOTHETICAL QUESTIONS
In a jury trial, no opinion witness may be asked a complex hypothetical question on direct examination

unless the following procedure is observed. The question must be written in advance and submitted to the Court
and the opposing party no later than the beginning of the session at which it will be asked. Assumptions must be
separately numbered and identified as to source, i.e., testimony of a witness, deposition, admission, etc.
G.

DEMONSTRATIVE EVIDENCE
If any sketches, models, diagrams or demonstrative evidence of any kind will be used during the trial

or in argument, they must be exhibited to opposing counsel at least 10 BUSINESS DAYS prior to trial.
Objections to such exhibits must be submitted to the Court for decision FIVE BUSINESS DAYS prior to trial.
H.

PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
In a trial to the Court, at the time of the filing of the Joint Final Pretrial Order, each party shall

ELECTRONICALLY FILE WITH THE COURT Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law which the parties believe
are necessary to be made to support a favorable judgment.

Ten days thereafter each party shall

ELECTRONICALLY FILE AND PROVIDE A COURTESY COPY TO CHAMBERS its opponent's Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law underlined in the following manner:
1.

Underline in BLUE those Findings of Fact which are true;

2.

Underline in YELLOW those Findings of Fact which are true but irrelevant or
unimportant;

3.
4.
I.

Underline in RED those Findings of Fact which are not true; and
Underline in RED any misstatement of law contained in the Conclusions of Law.

JOINT FINAL PRETRIAL ORDER

A Joint Final Pretrial Order in the attached form must be JOINTLY prepared and submitted
by counsel to the Court in every case which is not settled.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
s/Herman J. Weber
Herman J. Weber, Senior Judge
United States District Court

Rev: 2/15/07

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
WESTERN DIVISION

____________________,
Plaintiff
v.

CIVIL ACTION:

____________________,
Defendant

JOINT FINAL PRETRIAL ORDER
This matter is before the Court pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 16.
I. APPEARANCES:
For Plaintiff(s):

For Defendant(s):

II. NATURE OF ACTION AND JURISDICTION:
A. This is an action for ______________________________.
B. The jurisdiction of the Court is invoked under Title _______, United States Code
_________.
C. The jurisdiction of the Court is ________ disputed.
III

TRIAL INFORMATION:
A. The estimated length of trial is ______ days.
B. Trial to Court/Jury will begin on ____________.

IV. STATEMENT OF THE CASE:
Submit a concise statement of the case for the information of the Court and for use in the
impanelment of the jury. Include names, dates, places and elements of the claims, counterclaims,
third-party claims and affirmative defenses if any. Each party may submit a separate statement.
V. TRIAL DETERMINATIONS:
A. FACTS
1. Stipulated Facts:
Suggested Language:

9

The parties stipulate as to the following facts.
(List)
2. Disputed Facts:
Suggested Language:
The parties dispute the following facts.
a. Plaintiff(s):
b. Defendant(s):
B. APPLICABLE PROPOSITIONS OF LAW:
1. Agreed Applicable Propositions of Law:
Suggested Language:
The following applicable propositions of law are agreed to by the parties. (List)

Rev. 5/04

10

2. Disputed Applicable Propositions of Law:
Suggested Language:
The following applicable propositions of law are disputed by the parties.
a. Plaintiff(s):
b. Defendant(s):
C: Witnesses:
Suggested Language:
The parties have listed on the appropriate appendices those persons who will be called
or who will be available to testify. (Proceed to comply with Section B of the Order Instructing
Certain Pretrial and Trial Procedures).
The parties reserve the right to call without prior notice to opposing counsel rebuttal
witnesses whose testimony could not reasonably be anticipated.
D: Expert Witnesses:
Suggested Language:

11

The parties propose to call the following number of expert witnesses, all of whom have
been disclosed to the opposing side:
Plaintiff(s)

______________________________

Defendant(s) ______________________________
The curriculum vitae of the expert witnesses and a binding summary of their written reports
are attached as Appendix _____.
The parties certify we have complied with Fed. R. Civ. P. 26 pertaining to expert testimony.
Rev 5/04

12

E. Exhibits:
The parties will offer as exhibits those items listed on appendices hereof prepared in
accordance with Section C of the Order Instructing Certain Pretrial and Trial Procedures as follows:
(1) Joint Exhibits: Appendix ______
(Roman Numerals)
(2) Plaintiff Exhibits: Appendix _____
(Arabic Numerals)
(3) Defendant Exhibits: Appendix _____
(Letters and/or numbers)
(4) Third-Party Exhibits: Appendix _____
(Letters Prefixed by the Initial of the Party)
F. Depositions, Interrogatories and Admissions:
Suggested Language:
Evidence from the following witnesses will be presented by_____________.
Proceed to comply with Section E of the Order Instructing Certain
Procedures.

Pretrial and Trial

13

(or)
No evidence will be presented by deposition, videotape, interrogatories or admissions.
G. Discovery:
Suggested Language:
Discovery has been completed.
The following provisions have been made for discovery.
Rev. 5/04

14

H. Pending Motions:
Suggested Language:
The following Motions are pending at this time.
(or)
There are no pending Motions at this time.
IV. SETTLEMENT EFFORTS:
Suggested Language:
The parties have made a good faith effort to negotiate a settlement.
(or)
________________________________________
(Explain)

V. TRIAL TO THE COURT:
The parties will submit Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law in accordance with Section H
of the Order Instructing Certain Pretrial and Trial Procedures.

15

IT IS SO ORDERED.

_____________________________
Herman J. Weber, Senior Judge
United States District Court
_________________________________
Counsel for Plaintiff(s)

_________________________________
Counsel for Defendant(s)
(Rev.5/04)

16

AO 187 (Rev. 7/87) Exhibit and Witness List
======================================================================================================================

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
WESTERN DIVISION

EXHIBIT LIST

Plaintiff

CASE NO. ______________________

v.

Defendant
Presiding Judge
Herman J. Weber

Plaintiff Attorney

Trial Dates

Pltf.
No.

Defendant Attorney

Court Reporter

Deft.
No.

Date
Used

Date
Offered

Courtroom Clerk
Darlene Maury

Obj.

Adm.

Description of Exhibit

17

18

AO 187 (Rev. 7/87) Exhibit and Witness List
==============================================================================================================
========

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
WESTERN DIVISION

Plaintiff
v.

WITNESS LIST
CASE NO. ______________________

Defendant
Presiding Judge

Plaintiff Attorney

Defendant Attorney

Court Reporter

Courtroom Clerk

Herman J. Weber
Trial Dates

Darlene Maury

Pltf.

Def.

Date
Offered

Description of Witness

19