Whitlow et al v. Crescent Consulting LLC

Filing 57

ORDER re 47 Denied as Moot THIRD MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply as to 30 MOTION to Certify Class , 45 FIRST MOTION to Compel Production of Documents and Brief in Support filed by Crescent Consulting LLC, granted in part and denied in part 42 SECOND MOTION for Extension of Time and Brief in Support filed by Crescent Consulting LLC granted in part and denied in part, as more fully set out. Signed by Honorable David L. Russell on 6/8/17. (jw)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF OKLAHOMA
TOMMY WHITLOW, On Behalf of
Himself and All Others Similarly
Situated,
Plaintiff,
v.
CRESCENT CONSULTING, L.L.C.,
Defendant.

§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§

CASE NO. CIV-16-1330-R

ORDER
On May 12, 2017, there came on before the Court for hearing Defendant Crescent
Consulting, L.L.C.’s (“Crescent Consulting”) Motion to Compel Production of Documents [ECF
No. 45] (the “Motion to Compel”), Second Motion for Extension of Time [ECF No. 42] (the
“Second Motion for Time”) and Third Motion for Extension of Time and Expedited Consideration
[ECF No. 47] (the “Third Motion for Time”) (collectively, the “Motions”). Plaintiffs appeared
through their counsel Jessica Bresler of the Josephson Dunlap Law Firm. Crescent Consulting
appeared through its counsel Jared D. Giddens and J. Dillon Curran of the law firm Conner &
Winters, LLP. Having read Crescent Consulting’s briefs and considered the arguments of counsel,
the Court hereby finds:
1.

The Motion to Compel should be GRANTED in part and DENIED in part;

2.

The Second Motion for Time should be GRANTED in part and DENIED in part;

3.

The Third Motion for Time is DENIED as moot.

and

IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED AS FOLLOWS:
Tax Returns, W-2 Forms and Forms 1099
A.

Plaintiffs shall produce all (1) tax returns for Tommy Whitlow, Brent Segrest and

Leo Adams Jr. and their respective businesses for the tax years during which a Plaintiff (or any of
his businesses) invoiced Crescent Consulting during the applicable three-year statute of limitations
and (2) W-2s and 1099s received by Plaintiffs or their respective businesses for the same years.
B.

On May 17, 2017, Plaintiffs’ counsel shall deliver to each Plaintiff and each

Plaintiff’s business an IRS Form 8821 Tax Information Authorization (in the form approved by
Crescent Consulting’s counsel)(each, a “TIA).
C.

Each Plaintiff shall sign and return the TIA(s) to Plaintiffs’ counsel on or before

May 19, 2017. To the degree any Plaintiff is unable to electronically sign his TIA before May 19,
2017, he will do so as soon as possible.
D.

Not later than May 19, 2017, Plaintiffs’ counsel shall (1) submit to the applicable

Plaintiff’s tax preparer a written request for delivery to Plaintiffs’ counsel of the subject returns,
and all W-2s and 1099s for the subject years and (2) provide a copy of the request to Crescent
Consulting’s counsel.
i.

For Tommy Whitlow, Plaintiff’s counsel shall make requests to Todd L. Alvey,
Rick Miller, and any other person presently or previously responsible for preparing
the subject returns for Mr. Whitlow (or his businesses).

ii.

For Leo Adams Jr., Plaintiff’s counsel shall make requests to L. Duane Allen, Roger
Saenz, and any other person presently or previously responsible for preparing the
subject returns for Mr. Adams (or his businesses).

2

iii.

For Brent Segrest, Plaintiff’s counsel shall make requests to any person presently
or previously responsible for preparing the subject returns for Mr. Segrest (or his
businesses).

E.

All tax returns, tax return transcripts, W-2 forms and Forms 1099s which are the

subject of this Order which Plaintiffs possess or Plaintiffs’ counsel receives from the IRS or a
Plaintiff’s tax preparer(s) shall be provided to Crescent Consulting’s counsel immediately;
provided, however, Plaintiffs’ counsel may redact confidential identifying numbers and children’s
names.
F.

Plaintiffs’ counsel, on the same day as receiving a TIA, shall request a transcript of

each subject tax return and order a copy of each such tax return from the IRS, with all schedules
and related W-2s and 1099s.
G.

On June 6, 2017, Plaintiffs’ counsel shall deliver to each Plaintiff and each

Plaintiffs’ business IRS Forms 4506 and 4506T (in form approved by Crescent Consulting’s
counsel) (each a “Request”). Each Plaintiff shall sign and return each Request to Plaintiffs’
counsel on or before June 9, 2017 (or as soon as possible thereafter).
H.

Plaintiffs’ counsel, on the same day as receiving a Request, shall submit each

Plaintiff’s Requests to the IRS.
I.

Plaintiffs’ counsel will timely provide Crescent Consulting’s counsel responsive

information obtained from the IRS website.
J.

Crescent Consulting shall bear all of the IRS’s charges, if any, for providing

requested tax returns.

3

Text Messages
K.

Plaintiffs shall produce all text messages in Plaintiffs’ possession, custody or

control to or from oil and gas operators for which Crescent Consulting submitted invoices for the
services Plaintiffs performed during the following time periods:
i.

Tommy Whitlow:

November 21, 2013 – December 9, 2014;

ii.

Brent Segrest:

February 20, 2014 – January 9, 2015; and

iii.

Leo Adams Jr.:

February 22, 2014 – April 13, 2015.

If Plaintiffs do not have the aforementioned text messages in their actual possession, on or before
May 23, 2017 Plaintiffs, through counsel, shall make written demand on the applicable mobile
provider for all text messages sent or received by Plaintiffs or Plaintiffs’ businesses during the
applicable above described time period and provide a copy of the request to Crescent Consulting’s
counsel. The text messages shall be delivered to Plaintiffs’ counsel. Plaintiffs will then produce
only those text messages between a Plaintiff and a Crescent Operator’s representative for the above
described time periods. Plaintiff’s counsel reserves the right to seek protection from the Court
and/or the attorneys’ fees and costs associated with reviewing, sorting, and producing voluminous
records of text messages between Plaintiffs and Crescent’s oil and gas operators.
L.

Crescent Consulting shall also bear all of the charges by the mobile carriers, if any,

of retrieving and delivering the ordered text messages. If a mobile carrier indicates the total charge
for retrieving and delivering the ordered text messages exceeds $1,000, Plaintiffs’ counsel shall
obtain Crescent Consulting’s counsel’s approval before making final arrangements for retrieval
and delivery.

Depositions

4

M.

Plaintiffs will be made available for their deposition no later than June 12, 2017.

Crescent Consulting will conduct the depositions, as follows:
i.

The deposition of Tommy Whitlow, if any, shall occur at the Oklahoma City offices

of Noble McIntyre.
ii.

The deposition of Brent Segrest, if any, shall occur in Houston, Texas at the office

of a court reporter selected by Crescent Consulting. Plaintiff’s counsel offered their Houston
offices for this deposition free of charge. To the degree Crescent refuses to take this deposition at
Plaintiff’s office, Crescent shall bear all of the costs of taking this deposition at a court reporter’s
office.
iii.

The deposition of Leo Adams Jr., if any, shall occur in Houston, Texas at the office

of a court reporter selected by Crescent Consulting. Plaintiff’s counsel offered their Houston
offices for this deposition free of charge. To the degree Crescent refuses to take this deposition at
Plaintiff’s office, Crescent shall bear all of the costs of taking this deposition at a court reporter’s
office.
Extension of Time
N.

Crescent Consulting’s deadline to file its response to Plaintiffs’ Motion for

Conditional Certification [ECF No. 30] is extended by 45 days from May 15, 2017 or June 29,
2017.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED this 8th day of June, 2017.

5

APPROVED AS TO FORM:

/s/ J. Dillon Curran
Jared D. Giddens, OBA No. 3355
J. Dillon Curran, OBA No. 19442
Of the Firm:
CONNER & WINTERS, LLP
1700 One Leadership Square
211 N. Robinson
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73102
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
AND
/s/ Michael Josephson
Michael Josephson
State Bar No. 24014780
Federal ID No. 27157
Andrew W. Dunlap
State Bar No. 24078444
Lindsay R. Itkin
State Bar No. 24068647
Jessica M. Bresler
State Bar No. 24090008
JOSEPHSON DUNLAP LAW FIRM
11 Greenway Plaza, Suite 3050
Houston, Texas 77005
Tel:
[phone]
Fax:
[phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFFS
6