Ogle v. Yates et al

Filing 26

ORDER: The Court ADOPTS Magistrate Judge Stewart's Findings and Recommendation 4 . DISMISSES with prejudice Plaintiff's claims against Defendants Oregon Medical Board, Warren G. Foote, Carolyn Alexander, David Schuman, Robert W ollheim, Lynn R. Nakamoto, and the State of Oregon; DISMISSES without prejudice Plaintiff's claims against Defendants Ralph A. Yates, Lisa A. Cornelius, Kathleen Haley, Douglas B. Kirkpatrick, Donald E. Girard, George N. Koval, Roger M. McKimmy, Lewis D. Neace, Keith A. White, W. Kent Williamson, Sheridan A. Thiringer, Joseph J. Thaler, Eric Brown, Mei-Mei Wang, and Terry Lewis; and GRANTS Plaintiff leave to filed an Amended Complaint only as to Defendants Ralph A. Yates, Lisa A. Cornelius , Kathleen Haley, Douglas B. Kirkpatrick,Donald E. Girard, George N. Koval, Roger M. McKimmy, Lewis D. Neace, Keith A. White, W. Kent Williamson, Sheridan A. Thiringer, Joseph J. Thaler, Eric Brown, Mei-Mei Wang, and Terry Lewis to cure the deficie ncies set out in the Findings and Recommendation no later than July 19, 2012. Plaintiff is advised that failure to file an Amended Complaint that cures thedeficiencies noted in the Findings and Recommendation shall result in the dismissal of this proceeding with prejudice. Signed on 06/28/2012 by Judge Anna J. Brown. See attached Order for full text. (bb)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF OREGON

DAVID J. OGLE,1

3:12-CV-00571-BR
Plaintiff,

ORDER

v.
RALPH A. YATES, D.O.; LISA A.
CORNELIUS, D.P.M.; KATHLEEN
HALEY, Esq.; DOUGLAS B.
KIRKPATRICK, M.D.; DONALD E.
GIRARD, M.D.; GEORGE N.
KOVAL, M.D.; ROGER M. McKIMMY,
M.D.; LEWIS D. NEACE, D.O.;
KEITH A. WHITE, M.D.; W. KENT
WILLIAMSON, M.D.; SHERIDAN A.
THIRINGER, D.O.; JOSEPH J.
THALER, M.D.; ERIC BROWN;
MEI-MEI WANG; TERRY LEWIS;
OREGON MEDICAL BOARD; WARREN
G. FOOTE, Esq.; CAROLYN
ALEXANDER; DAVID SCHUMAN;
ROBERT WOLLHEIM; LYNN R.
NAKAMOTO; STATE OF OREGON;
50 JOHN DOES; 50 JANE DOES,
Defendants.
1

Although Plaintiff referred to himself as M.D. in his
Complaint, the use of the title "doctor" is governed by Oregon
Revised Statute § 676.110 and the record reflects Plaintiff no
longer qualifies to use the title doctor. Accordingly, the Court
declines to use the title in this Order.
1 - ORDER

BROWN, Judge.
Magistrate Judge Janice M. Stewart issued Findings and
Recommendation (#4) on April 6, 2012, in which she recommends the
Court sua sponte (1) dismiss with prejudice Plaintiff's claims
against Defendants Oregon Medical Board, Warren G. Foote, Carolyn
Alexander, David Schuman, Robert Wollheim, Lynn R. Nakamoto, and
the State of Oregon; (2) dismiss without prejudice Plaintiff's
claims against Defendants Ralph A. Yates, Lisa A. Cornelius,
Kathleen Haley, Douglas B. Kirkpatrick, Donald E. Girard, George
N. Koval, Roger M. McKimmy, Lewis D. Neace, Keith A. White,
W. Kent Williamson, Sheridan A. Thiringer, Joseph J. Thaler, Eric
Brown, Mei-Mei Wang, and Terry Lewis; and (3) grant Plaintiff
leave to filed an Amended Complaint to cure the deficiencies
noted in the Findings and Recommendation.

Plaintiff filed timely

Objections and Supplemental Objections to the Findings and
Recommendation.

The matter is now before this Court pursuant to

28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1) and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 72(b).
When any party objects to any portion of the Magistrate
Judge's Findings and Recommendation, the district court must make
a de novo determination of that portion of the Magistrate Judge's
report.

28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1).

See also Dawson v. Marshall, 561

F.3d 930, 932 (9th Cir. 2009); United States v. Reyna-Tapia, 328
F.3d 1114, 1121 (9th Cir. 2003)(en banc).
This Court has carefully considered Plaintiff's Objections
2 - ORDER

and Supplemental Objections and concludes they do not provide a
basis to modify the Findings and Recommendation.

The Court also

has reviewed the pertinent portions of the record de novo and
does not find any error in the Magistrate Judge's Findings and
Recommendation.

CONCLUSION
The Court ADOPTS Magistrate Judge Stewart's Findings and
Recommendation (#4) and, therefore,
1.

DISMISSES with prejudice Plaintiff's claims against
Defendants Oregon Medical Board, Warren G. Foote,
Carolyn Alexander, David Schuman, Robert Wollheim, Lynn
R. Nakamoto, and the State of Oregon;

2.

DISMISSES without prejudice Plaintiff's claims against
Defendants Ralph A. Yates, Lisa A. Cornelius, Kathleen
Haley, Douglas B. Kirkpatrick, Donald E. Girard, George
N. Koval, Roger M. McKimmy, Lewis D. Neace, Keith A.
White, W. Kent Williamson, Sheridan A. Thiringer,
Joseph J. Thaler, Eric Brown, Mei-Mei Wang, and Terry
Lewis; and

3.

GRANTS Plaintiff leave to filed an Amended Complaint
only as to Defendants Ralph A. Yates, Lisa A.
Cornelius, Kathleen Haley, Douglas B. Kirkpatrick,
Donald E. Girard, George N. Koval, Roger M. McKimmy,

3 - ORDER

Lewis D. Neace, Keith A. White, W. Kent Williamson,
Sheridan A. Thiringer, Joseph J. Thaler, Eric Brown,
Mei-Mei Wang, and Terry Lewis to cure the deficiencies
set out in the Findings and Recommendation no later
than July 19, 2012.

Plaintiff is advised that failure

to file an Amended Complaint that cures the
deficiencies noted in the Findings and Recommendation
shall result in the dismissal of this proceeding with
prejudice.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
DATED this 28th day of June, 2012.
/s/ Anna J. Brown
ANNA J. BROWN
United States District Judge

4 - ORDER