Bott v. Edelson et al

Filing 58

OPINION AND ORDER:I GRANT in part and DENY in part Dr. Bott's Motion for Reconsideration 53 . But, for the reasons stated in this Opinion and Order, I DENY Dr. Bott's request to amend my judgment and allow him to proceed on his legal malpractice claim based on the allegations in paragraphs 33, 37, and 38 of his Complaint. Signed on 06/01/2017 by Judge Michael W. Mosman. (rs)

I T EU I E S A E DS RC C U T
N H NT D T T S I TI T O R
F RT EDS RC O O E O
O H I TI T F R G N
P R L N D VS O
O T A D I II N
R D RC B T ,
O EI H O T
Pi i,
l nf
a tf
v
.

N 3 6 v066 O
o : - -03-M
. 1c
OI I NA DO D R
PNO N R E

J F R Y M E E S Ntl
E F E . D L O e a,
.
D edn.
e na s
f
t
M SM NJ
O A,.,
A e o lru e o Fbu y 4 21 IG A T DD edn’ M infr
f r r ag mn n era 2 07 R N E e na s o os o
t a
t
r ,
,
f
t
t
S m ay ug e [21] nh gonsh Pi i B t ci sw e rc dd yh
u m Jd mn 1 4 ot e rudta l nf o’ l m e p l e bte
r
t ,
t a tf ts a
r eu
st e fi it n Acr n yIDSMS E tel m w hp jd e 5] D B ti d
t u ol ma os cod g, I I S D h ci s i r u c[1 r o fe
at
ti .
il
a
t e i
. . t l
a M in o Rcn d a o [3 t wihD edn M Guhyepne [5i
o o fr eos e t n 5] o hc e na c age rsodd 5] n
t
i ri
,
f
t
opsinadD B te id 5]
pot , n r o rpe [7
io
. t l
.
I h m in D B trus so deos e mjd mn d m s g i ci s o
ni o o r o ageI hu rcn d yug e i i i h l mfr
s t , . t
l
ir
t s sn s a
t oesn Fs h agetaIno el ape O gna i d e m igwete
w raos it erush icr c y p id r ol wn e r i n hnh
. r,
t
rt
l
e
t n
ci s c ud Scn h agetaI hudl wi t poed nl m aa s
l m ac e eod erus h sol a o h mo rce o ci s g n
a
r .
,
t
l
a
it
D edn bsd nneedna sh ocr dw h te w-e st e fi it n I
e na s ae oidpne c ta cu e i i ht oya t u ol ma os
f
t
t t t
r tn
r at
ti .
D N D B t M in o Rcn d a o [ 3 oteitru e, uIG A TD
E Y r o’ o o fr eos e t n 5] nhfsag mn b
. ts t
i ri
r
t t R N r
.
B t M in o Rcn d a o [3 ote eodru e.I ay vn ID N D
o’ o o fr eos e t n 5] nh scn ag mn n n ee, E Y r
ts t
i ri
t
t
.

1 OI I NA DO D R
- PNO N R E

B t rqe t e e il a ed iter o te aeo rce o a s fibi tah
o’ eus o s na y mn h hoy f h cst poed n c ol it h e
ts
t
s tl
s
t
aly t
age ocr dw h tet u ol ma os
rus cu e i i h st e fi it n
r tn
at
ti .
DS U S O
I C SI N
Fd a R e fC i Poeu 5( a o s “ si cu [ ]eos ei g no
ee l u o i l rcdr 9 )l wa dt c or t rcn d t r t f
r l
v
e e l
irt t o
i rs a
s m ayug e . Sho Dt N 1 M to a C..A ad Ic 5F d 2516
u m jd mn” co i. o J u n mh t v CnS n , . 15 22
r
t
l s . , l
y
, .
3
,
( hC. 93 Teirt orhsic t nn e r i n we et g nam in o
9 i 19) h dt ccu a d r i i d e m ig h h o r t o o fr
t r
.
si
t
s eo
t n
tr
a
t
rcn d a o I “ eos e t ns prp a it dt ccu ()s rsn dw h
eos e t n d Rcn d a oi aport fh irt or 1i p e e i
i ri . .
i ri
i e e si
t
e t t
n w d cv e e dne() o mtdla e o ote ni dcinws mn el
el i oe d v ec 2c m ie c r r r r hi tl e s
y s r i
,
t
e r
ia i o a a fs y
i t
u u, r 3ite i ai evn g hnen o r l ga. I a16
n s o()fh es nn re n cagi cn oi l w d t 23
jt
r
t
i
t ln
” .
.
D B t fsag mni spo o h m ins ae o h a einh I
r o’ itru e n upr fi o oi bsd ni s r ota
. ts r
t
t s t
s st
t
icr c y p idO gna i d e m igwe h ci acud Io of dh t s
no el ape r o l w n e r i n hn i l m c e d n i ta h
rt
l
e
t n
s a
r .
tn ti
ag mn me tetnad orcn d a o adh eo, dntem in soh
ru e e s h s d fr eos e t n nte fr I eyh o o att s
t t
a r
i ri ,
r e
t
i
ag mn
ru e .
t
Itel ra v D B t ssmt ptl a edh Jd mnt a o h mo
nh aenie r o ak e o ail mnte ug e ol wi t
t t , . t
ra y
t l
poed nilg m p cc ci bsd n h e c o ng gneh h age a
rce o h ea a r t el m ae o tr a s f e iecta erusr
s l l ai a
e t
l
t
e
ie i ei p arps 43 a 3 fo h C m a t Tee c aee y a w h te
dnf dn a g h 3 7 n 8r mi o pi . hs a sl gd fl i i h
ti
r a
, , d
s
ln
t l l l tn
t oyast e fi it n T b c a t s hoy fibi ws or sdnD B t
w-e t u ol ma os o el r h ter ol it a n a ei r o’
r at
ti .
e, i
aly
ti
. ts
m mrnu i opsino u m yug e o dr g r ag mn ad arew h
e o d mn pot t s m a jd mn r u n o lru e, n I g i
a
io
r
t
i
a
t
e t
D edn taicu hv be r sd B bcue ar e h m od d m s g i
e na sh t o d ae ena e u easI g ta y re i i i h
f
t t
l
i . t
e t
r s sn s
ci sw h r u c wu b mn el u u iaenie c o ng gnea w h te
l m i p jd e o d e a fs y n s fl ra v a s f e iecfl i i h
a
t e i
l
i t jt t t
t
l
l tn
st e fi it n I rnrcn d a o otii u o y
t u ol ma os g teos e t n nhss e n.
at
ti , a
i ri
s l
A ai tlmt , n eh t sm i n orcn d a oi aeu o m hv g
s nni ae I o ta h o o freos e t ns rs t f y a n
ia t r t t i t
i ri
l
i
g n d u m yug e i fvr fD edn.Ite m in D edn ide mvd
r t s m a jd mn nao o e na s nh r o os e na sned oe
ae
r
t
f
t
i t , f
t

2 OI I NA DO D R
- PNO N R E

fr u m yug e o a o D B t a ea os fwogo g ae ote ag mn
os m a jd mn nl f r o’ l gin o rnd n bsd nh rru e
r
t
l
. ts l t
i
i
t
tahfldo rv a oteeu e e s ot e ci fr e iec Tu i
h eaet poel fhrq r mn t st al m o ng gne hs n
t i
l
i
t
a
a
l
.
,
cn d igD B t m in e , msd e mn we eteeod upr aid gh
os e n r o’ o o h eI u e r ie h h hrcr spos f i ta
ir
. ts t
r
t t
tr
t nn t
te i a eu e ip e fm e afc sc ta D edn a n e ie t jd mna a
h es gn n d u o a rla, uh h e na sr o nt d o ug e s
r
i st
ti t
t f
t e t tl
t
mt ol w Fd R C.P5( ; C o xCr v C rt 47US3733 18) A
ae fa. e . i . 6 ) e t op . a e , 7 .. 1 2 (96 s
tr
.
v
a le
.
tt
,
.
epie fr e b o,D Bths o m h bre o d m s a n truh v eci
x a d u h e w r o a n e i udn f e o t t g hog e dnen
ln
tr l
. t
t t s
nri ,
i
teeod h te i ai u ofcrg d gh aeeidpne a s f e iec
hrcr ta h es ns e fa ea i tel gdneedn c o ng gne
, t r
s
t rn
l
t t
l
,
fo w c auy o d oc d D ed t a l b frea m p cc
r m h h jr cu cn ue e nasr i l olg a r t e
i
l
l
f n eae
l l ai .
T poeea m p cc al nf ms so: 1a u rnfo te e na t
o rvlg a r t e pi i u h w() d y usr mh d edn o
l l ai , a tf t
t
f
t
tel nf () b ah f h d y()euig a mo h pi i mau b i d mgs
h pi i; 2a r c ota u ; 3rst h t te l nf esr l n a ae
a tf
e
t t
ln r
a tf
ae
;
ad 4cua o S vn v B pa , 5 P d 5 50 O 19) D B ts ek go
n () asin t es. i h m 81 . 56 6 ( r 93 r o ise nt
t . e
s
2
,
.
. . t
i
pru h m p cc ci otre c ietidn a g ps 33 ad 8 fh
u ei a r t el m nh a sdn f i p ar h 3 7 n 3 ote
s s l ai a
e t
ie
r a
, ,
C m a t w c h ci sni m ina idpne a s f e iec
o pi , h h el mi h o o r needn c o ng gne
ln i
a
s t
e
t t
l
.
P arp 3 oteC m a tt e
a g h 3 fh o pi sts
r a
ln a :
Bcue e na s c dav e ad ucs u y norgdh L Col n
eas d edn a e d sd n sce f l ecu ete L t a g
f
t t, i
sl
a
i
teL C i e saa spi i,h d edn ea eteL Coae
h L’ n r t g n l nf te e na s nb dh L ttk
s te
i t a tf
f
t
l
ain aa steL C o n n rs Sc ainic ddb w e o
c os g n h L’ w i e t uh c osn ue u e n
t
it
s
t e.
t
l , t r t
l me t te ee n oa i pr n u nsr a os p eweteL C n
i i d o h sv ig f n mo a bs e et nh b enh L ad
t
r
t t i s li i t
D B tK dr gh cu e fh Ud r igAin Sc a s ost e a
r o G u nte or ote nel n c o uh c cni td
. t
i
s
y
t .
t
tu
b ah fh d edn’ u tteL C T s nuncueteL Cooe
r c ote e na s d yoh L. h, tr asdh L tls
e
f
t t
ii
,
rvne
eeu
.
P arp 3 oteC m a tt e
a g h 7 fh o pi sts
r a
ln a :
Ds ttea tate w eiqaf d sh L C a ony te e na s
epehfc h hy e d uie ate L’ t res h d edn
i
t t
r s li
st
,
f
t
i poe y e te s vs uateL C a ony b sbeun yi n ad
mrp l h dh me e o sh L’ t res y usqe l fig n
r l
l
t
st
t l
pr n a apapro e y n ea oteL C. Te pe wsi d n
uig n pe upr d o bh f fh L .. h apa afe o
s
l
tl
l
l
l
oao Nv me 2 21 eetogte ws oiajd mntte
r bu oe b 0 03 vnhuhh e a n f lug e oh
t
r ,
,
r
n
t
Ud l n Ain Te pe ws u m r y i m sd y h apl e or
ne y g c o h apa as m ai d i e b te pea cu
ri
t .
l
l s s
lt
t
o oao Nv me 2 21 Te co pru g n pe, n bl g n
n r bu oe b 5 03 h a f u i a apa adii ad
t
r ,
.
t
sn
l
ln
rc v gr mh L C mny olg s v ei cneinh ei,
ee i fo te L oe frea e i sn onc ote w h
in
l rc
t
r t
cni td b ah fh d edn’ u tteL C
ost e a r c ote e na s d yoh L.
tu
e
f
t t

3 OI I NA DO D R
- PNO N R E

P arp 3 oteC m a tt e
a g h 8 fh o pi sts
r a
ln a :
Ds ttea tate w eiqaf e ateL C a ony te e na s
epehfc h hy e d ui id sh L’ t res h d edn
i
t t
r s l
st
,
f
t
cn neti poe y o te s vs uateL C a ony b
o iudo mrp l h dh me e o sh L’ t res y
t
r l
l
t
st
sbeun yi n ad u u g pi o frwt fmna u pro e y n
usqe l fig n pr i a et n o r o ad ms upr d o
t l
sn
ti
i
tl
bh f fh L C. Te et n o awtwsi d n r bu Nv me 1
ea ote L .. h pi o fr r afe o oao oe b ,
l
ti
i
l
t
r
21 adtws e e o oao M c 1 21 Te co pr n awt f
03 ni a dn d n r bu a h 4 04 h a f uig r o
,
i
t r ,
.
t
s
i
mna u adiig n rc v gr m teL Cmny olg s v ei
ad ms n bl adee i fo h L oe frea e i s n
,
ln
in
l rc
cneinh ei , ost e a rahfh d edn’ u tteL C
onc ote w hcni td b c ote e na s d yoh L.
t
r t
tu
e
f
t t
Acr nttel ginitee a g ps D B t ekt h dD edn l b
cod goh aea osnhs p ar h r o seso o e na si l
i
l t
r a , . t
l f
t ae
ud ahoy fea m p c cfr 1cu nteL Co e r r a os pw hD B t
ne ter olg a r t e o() as gh L t s eaet nh i r o
r
l l ai
i
v
li i t . t
dr gh cu e fh ud l n ainn M to a Cu y ()ersn nteL Cn
u nte or ote ne y g c oi u n mh on ; 2rp e igh L i
i
s
ri t
l
t
e t
apa ntet e orjde od tad qaf dD edtfo rp sn nteL C
peigh st cu ug s re h i ui e e nasr mer e igh L;
l
a- t
’
r t s li
f n
e t
ad 3rp sn nteL Cn ek g wt f mna ut rv w h st cu jde
n ()er e igh L i se n a r o ad ms o e e tet e or ug s
e t
i
i
i
a- t
’
od tad qaf dD edn fo rp sn nteL C
re h i ui e e na sr mer e igh L.
r t s li
f
t
e t
D B t an pru aea m p cc ci bsd nh ud l n cnu o
r o cno u e lg a r tel m ae ote ne y g odc f
. t
t s
l l ai a
ri
t
cu nteL Co eeaet nh w hD B t sl gdn a g p 3 I h rsos
as gh L t sv r a os p i r o a aeei p ar h 3 ni epne
i
r li i t . t
l
r a
.
s
t D edn’ M infrS m a Jd mn h epcl stdh tel ginfo
o e na s o os o u m y ug e , e x it t eta h aea osr m
f
t
t
r
t
li y a
t
l t
p arp 3 r a d n t d mgs Se f a y hyrte a aetah ci e
a g h 3et o yo a ae pci l , e a h d mgsh el md
r a
le l
.
i cl t
e
t
a
rs tdr mh aee dlyt s m igr m h J nI e s Are e.Ii n wo
eue fo tel gdi oa yt m fo te o t n r t g mn ts o to
l
l
s l e n
i te
e t
l e o D B to hnei m d n age h toel gin a n wh bs fr
a fr r o t cag h i adruta hs aea osr o te a s oa
t
. t
s n
t
l t
e
i
ng gnel mn n ote s vs
e iec ci i ad f h me e
l
a
l .
Rg d g hr m n gl gin D B tse il seso hneiter o
ea i tee a i aea os r o e na y ekt cag h hoy f
rn
i n l t , . t s tl
s
te aer m nfcsd nibi frh ae d ofcoi e s tae s d ewe
h csfo oe oue ol it otelg cni fn r t h xt b en
aly
le
lt t e
t ie t
D edn adh L Ch aee yette d qaf a oi st cu,o nfcs g
e na s nte L ta l gd ldoh r i ui cinnt e or t oe ou n
f
t
tl l
i s li t
a
t
i
o a sh D edn to o bh f fh L Cfete w eiqaf d H n wl gs
n c ta e na sok n ea ote L at hy e d ui e e o aee
t t f
t
l
r
r s li .
l
te o- sui cin c w eneedna s f e iec frw c D edn so d
h ps d qaf a o a s e idpne c o ng gne o h h e na s hu
t i li t
t r
t t
l
,
i
f
t
l

4 OI I NA DO D R
- PNO N R E

b h dib.I g enh as a tatel gini p arps 7 n 3 cu spo a
e e l l ar ite brc h h aea osn a g h 3 ad 8 o d upr
l ae
e
t t t
l t
r a
l
t
ci fr rfs oa ng gne Se d a51epi ntateg v mn o po s oa
l m o po s n e iec eI t 6 (x a igh h“r a e” f rf s n
a
ei l l
.
.
ln
t
a
ei l
ng gnel mita“onefldn oewyo e o m ones b gini
e iec ci ssh cus aei sm at p fr cus ’ o ia osn
l
a
t
li
r
l l t
acrac w hh s nad oteeac m u t” B , s x a e b o,D B t
codne i tet d s f hlg o mn y. u a epi d e w r o’
t
a r
l
i ) t
ln l
. ts
aea os ntea snhrcr fit spo aea m p cc ci.
l gin adhfc iteeoda o upr lg a r t el m
l t
t
l
t
l l ai a
Fs tel gini p arps 7 n 3 cu spo ahoyh D edn w e
it h aea osn a g h 3 ad 8 o d upr terta e na s e
r,
l t
r a
l
t
t f
t r
ng gni fl go e o mh r b ginor mvte s vsr mh cs a ete
e ie nai t p fr te o ia ot e oeh me efo te aef rhy
l t in
r
i l t
l
t
w eiqaf dr mh ud l nlia o Ud t shoy D B twu hvt a e
e d ui e fo te ne y gi gin ne h ter r o o d aeo s r
r s li
ri t t .
ri
, . t
l
st
ta D edn w e b g et r ueoer e teL Cnt apaoteiqaf a o
h e na s e o ia doe st rpsn h L ii pe fh d ui cin
t f
t r l t
f
e t
s
l
s li t
od ad usqe fig f wt fmnaut rv wh od. Terx fh
re n sbeun i n oa r o admsoe e te re h cu ote
r
tl
i
i
r
m p cc ci,hn wu s mr mD fna s b ah f d y y o iu go
a r t el m e o dt fo e edn’ r c oa u b cn n nt
l ai a t , l e
t e
t
t i
rp snteL Cf r hy a a rfs oao ia o n lnet d s D B twu
er e h L a ete hd po s n b gin o og o o o r o o d
e t
t
ei l l t
r
. . t
l
a o aeo h wh L Cws a ae btab ah
l hvt so te L a d mgd yh r c
s
t e .
H e D B t a n aee o po dd fc soigh D edn hd n
e, r o hs o l gd r rv e a s h w ta e na s a a
r . t
tl
i
t
n t f
t
o ia ot rcste s vsr mh apaotei n oawt f mna u b h ek g
b ginoeue h me efo te pe rhfig f r o ad ms o se n
l t
l
l
l
i
, t
i
t oe unht acu’ d qaf a o od. D B t a a o o l gdh D edn
o v trterl orsi ui cin re r o hsl n aeeta e na s
r
i
t s li t
r . t
s tl
t f
t
a ei amnetacn aeetew hs f h L C Te a n aea os ra sfr
c dn an h o rvndh i e o te L. h er ol gin ofc, o
t
r t t
s
r e
l t
t
ea p,o h w h teL Ce m a dt r a os pw hD edn b o apa nte
x m e so ta h L t i t i et nh i e na s e r peigh
lt
t
r n e s li i t f
t fe
l
d qaf a o od, rh te L d e e D edn n t ap ate re Ii a o o
i ui cin re ota h L Ci c d e na s o o pelh od. tsl n
s li t
r
t
rt
f
t t
r
s t
raoa ei p tif teL Ci s w huspoiga s
esnb s m yon rh L d o i o upr n fc.
l
l
e
d
t t
t
t
Sp al tel gini p arps 7ad 8 o d upra hoy fibi
ea t y h aea osn a g h 3 n 3 cu spo ter ol it
r e,
l t
r a
l
t
aly
bsd n n seinh D edn po ddeaav eoh L Cetdoh apaad
ae o a a r ota e na s rv elg d ctte L r a tte pe n
st
t f
t
i
l i
le
l
tewt fmna uta ws oi acrac w hh s nad ote rfs o Te
h r o ad msh a n n codne i tet d s fh po s n h
i
t
t
t
a r
ei .

5 OI I NA DO D R
- PNO N R E

L C d mgs hn wu bteeafe icr d u nte pe adwt fmna u
L’ a ae te o d ehlg es nu e dr gh apa n r o ad ms
s
, , l
l
r
i
l
i
poed g B D B t a n aee taegg gnh apao wt fmna u
rce ns u r o hs o l gd h na nite pe r r o ad ms
i . t . t
tl
t
i
l
i
poe s mh w ost e aa u t p fr cus ’lg o ia osn codnew h
rcs o eo cni td flr o e o m onesea b gini acrac i
s
tu
i e
r
l
l l t
t
tetnad oteeac m u t H a o a n aee o po dd n fc t so ta
h s d s fhlg o mn y el h o l gd r rv e aya so h wh
a r
l
i.
s s tl
i
t
t
te s mh w aendqa l aav ew headoh apao wt fmna u I
hy o eo gviaeu eel d c i rg tte pe r r o ad ms n
t g
i t
r
l
i
.
o e wrs D B t a n aee o po dda so upra h w gh D edn
t r od r o hs o l gd r rv e fc t spo soi ta e na s
h
, . t
tl
i
t
t
n t f
t
b ahd d yadh eo, e an pru am p cc ci ud t shoy
r ce a u, nte fr h cno u e a r t el m ne h ter
e
t
r e
t s
l ai a
ri
.
C N L SO
O C UI N
IG A Tn a adD N i p tD B t M in o Rcn d a o [3 B, o
R N i p t n E Yna r o’ o o fr eos e t n 5] u fr
r
r . ts t
i ri
. t
teesnstd bv ID N D B t rq st a edmjd mnadl w i t
hraost e aoe E Y r o’ eut o mn yug e n a o h mo
a
,
. ts e
t
l
poed nilg m p cc ci bsd n h aea osn a g ps 33 ad 8 f
rce o h ea a r t el m ae o tel gini p ar h 3 7 n 3 o
s l l ai a
l t
r a
, ,
h C m at
i o pi .
s
ln
II S O D R D
T S O R E E.
D T Dh 1 dy f ue21
A E t s s a oJn 07
i
t
,
.

/ M he W Ms a_____
s i a . o mn____
/ c l
MC A L W M SM N
IHE . O A
C e U tdStsDt cJde
h f ne t e irt ug
i
i
a
si

6 OI I NA DO D R
- PNO N R E