Johnson v. Jondy Chemical, Inc.

Filing 16

Opinion re Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim 10 , Order regarding Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim 10 . I GRANT Jondys Motion to Dismiss 10 and dismiss without prejudice. Mr. Johnson has thirty days to file an amended complaint or these claims will be dismissed. Signed on 04/13/2017 by Judge Michael W. Mosman. (rs)

Download PDF
I T EU I E S A E DS RC C U T N H NT D T T S I TI T O R F RT EDS RC O O E O O H I TI T F R G N P R L N D VS O O T A D I II N T D SJ H S N O D . O N O, v . N 3 6 v074 O o : - -13-M . 1c Pi i, l nf a tf OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E J N YC EM C L, N. O D H I A SI C , D edn e na. f t M SM NJ O A,., Pi i Td Jhsn“M Jhsn se D ednJnyCe ia, nopr e l nf od ono ( r ono” ud e na od h m l Icro td a tf . ) f t cs a (Jny frwogut m a o ae n f el m Jny o mvsoi m s w o M “od” o rnf e i t nl g gi ci s od n w oet d i t o f r ) l r ni l i v a . s s . Jhsn f el m Se f a yJny mvs oi m shs ci s ruhud teF m y ono’ i ci s pci l , od oe t d i toel m bog ne h a i s v a . i cl s s a t r l ad Md a LaeA (FM A adh O gnF m yLaeA ( O L ” Frhraos e n e c ev c “ L ” nte r o a i ev c “ F A. oteesns il t ) e l t ) t fr b o, od’ M inoD m s o Flrt St aCi [0i G A T D o h e wJny o ot i i fr a u o t e l m 1]s R N E. t l s t s s i e a a B C G O N A K R U D M Jhsnwre a aidpne cn a o/ a se o fr od fr ee l e s r ono okd s nneedn o rc r s ep sn oJny osv aya . t t t l r r r p ot 21 l ig n oe t g uo O gn O M c 1 21 M Jhsnl wo r ro 05 i n ad p a n o f r o n a h 9 05 r ono f t i ,v ri t e . r , , . e Kn cyad w lte, od po o di t Ws r Rg n S e Mng, f li e e uk n heh eJny r m e h mo e en e oa a s aae a u- m t , , i r t t i l l r lt s a e psin M Jhsn o mne f li e m o mn w h od o Ar 121 O a r d ot . r ono c m ecd u- m e p y e i Jny n pl, 05 n li io . lt l t t i . Jn 921 M Jhsnicv e h hd ac ta wu rq r srey Otad e r ue, 05 r ono d oe d e a cne h o deu e ug . nh a o , . s r r t l i r t t solte a e h shd e h srey o Sp me 221 adno md od o h hr y h e t, e ceu di ug fr e e b , 05 nifr e Jny fi t r fr l s r t r , s 1 OI I NA DO D R – PNO N R E cn t nncst frra mn d e f ceu d ra mn ad ee i frev prunt odi , ee i ot t e, a oshd e t t e, n ncst olae u a o io sy e t t l e t sy s t tat a mn O J y 421 Jny no md M Jhsnh i wse m a n h mr mi h r t e . n u 2 05 odifr e r onota t at i t gi fo h te t l , , . t r ni s psin w hit m a o e eie nAgs3 21 M Jhsn ne wnte ug y n ot , i h e i t nf c v o uu 1 05 r ono ud e h sre o i o t s r ni f t t , . . r t r Sp me 221 adee et a mnfr prx m e fu wes o oigh srey e e b , 05 n rc vdr t e oapo al or ekf l w te ug . t r , i e t i ty l n r M Jhsni dh l wu o Ags3 21 ae n v lin oteFM A r ono fet sa s t n uu 0 06 l g gi a os fh . l i i t , ,li ot L, v lin oteO L,wogud cag b ah f o rc ad r m sr e op.O i a os fh F A rnf i h e r c ocn a, n po i oy s pe n ot l s r, e t t s t l Dc me 2 21 Jnyi d M inoD m s ek goi m s M Jhsn ci s ne ee b 9 06 od fe a o ot i i se nt d i r ono’ l m ud r , , l t s s i s s . s a r teFM A nteO L. h L ad h F A L G LS A D R E A T N A D We rv w g m inoi m s h cu ms“ce a fc aaea osnh hne ei a o ot d i, e or u acp l a u l ginite i n t s st t t tl tll t c m a t sre n cnreh p a nsnhl h msfvrb tte o mv g a y o pi atu ad os utel d gitei t o ao l oh nn o n p t ” ln t ei g t ae i r. K eev E P , 9 F d 0817 ( hC. 05 A orne n acplg cn u os s n v . S N 33 . 16 02 9 i 20) cu ed o ce ea oc s n a i l 3 , t r . t t t l li tu bcue[ h ab eet s fh e mn oa as oainspo e b m e oc sr re eas “]r da rca otel e s f cue f c o upr d y e cn uoy t e r il e t t , t r l st mn, o osf c ” sco vIb , 5 US6268 20) T sr v am ino t e e sd n uie Ahr t. qa 56 .. 6 7 (09 o uv e o o t a t t f . f l , . i t d m s oflrt st al m ne Fd a R e fC i Poeu 1()6 “ c m a t ms i i fra u ot e ci ud ee l u o i l rcdr 2b ) a o pi u s s i e a a r r l v e (, ln t cni sf c nfc a mt, ce e atu t ‘ a al moeetai p u b oi o a ui e a u ae acp d sre ost ci t ri h sl s l nt t n fi t t l t r t , te a lf t a i e s fc’ I (u ige A.Cr v T o b , 5 US5450 20) Ala ntao e ae ” d qo n Bl t op . w m y 50 .. 4 7 (07. p d gh f r . . t l l . l , ) ei t fs o ylb s n cn u os o“nkd sein ] dv d ffr efc aehne e ’ wl n “ e ad oc s n” r‘ae a r o[ ’ eo o‘u h a u nac mn ” i l al li st s i tr tl t l n sf c I (u ig w m y 50USa5557 W l al nf de n net mk o uie d qo n T o b , 5 ..t 5 5) he pi i os o edo ae t f . . t l , . i a tf t d ae fc aaea osth p a n s g tel gin msb sf c n y pcit g e ei da u l gin atel d gt e h aea os u e ui e l se f oi tl tll t ei a, l t t fi t ic v te e na “ i n ie otel m nte rud o w cirs.e E csn.Pru, h d edn f r oc” fh ci adh gons n h hte s e r ko v ads f t a t a i tS i 51US8 9 (07(ecr m(t g w m y 50USa55 5 .. 9 3 20) p u a )ci T o b , 5 ..t 5) , r i in l . Fd a R e fC i Poeu 1 po dsh a orso dre g eevt a ed ee l u o i l rcdr 5 rv eta cu hu f l i laeo mn a r l v e i t t l ey v c m a t wejsc s rq rs Fd R C.P1( () Asc we a ord m ss o pi “ hnuie oeu e ” e . i . 5 )2 s uh hn cu i i e a ln t i . . v a . , t s s 2 OI I NA DO D R – PNO N R E c m a t oflrt st al m“ aeo mn so d e rn d u e te ord e m e o pi fra u ot e ci,l vt a ed hu b g t ‘n s h cu e r i s ln i e a a e l ae ls t t n tatel gin ftefc cn s n w hh caegdla n cu n ps b crte h h aea o o o ra s ost t i te hlne p d g o d o o i y u h t l t h t ie t l ei l t sl e d i ec ’ DS o.Yl wFe hSs Ic, 5 F d 5 68 9 C. 92(u ig e c ny ” eo v e o r g y, n 97 . 65 5 ( h i 19) qo n fi . t l it . . 2 , t r t She e Dt b C vSr e Fr tr C , 0 F d 3310 ( hC. 96.f cr br i r. o . ev l un ue o 86 . 19 41 9 i 18) I i si . -Wl i . 2 , t r ) a ed e wu bf i,h cu ne n g nlaeo mn I mn mn o d e ul te or ed o r tevt a ed d t l te t t a . . DS U S O I C SI N Jny rush M Jhsnws eea “i b e p ye arq rdot e n od ageta r ono a nv n e g l m oe” seu et st a t . r li e l i a i e e nel m ne b hh FM A nteO L.Acr n yJny otta M n r r c ci ud o te L adh F A cod g , od pssh r tf e a r t il i t . Jhsn FM A n O L i e eec ci smsb d m sdIwl drs b hl mi ono’ s L ad F An r rnel m u ei i e tf a t s s . i ad s o ci sn l e t a tr adhn drs we e M Jhsn a a old ci frelt n nee h st e un nte ad s h h r ono hsl p al m or aa o ud i e t u. e tr . s e a tii r t r at I . Itr rneu dr h F i a d Md a LaeA n f ec nete am y n ei l ev c ee l c t Oe fh proe oteFM Aste ie m oesoaeesnb lae o n ote upss fh L i “ nt e p yettkraoa eevfr o tl l l md araos 2 USC§ 61b 2 T s v t s ups teFM Amkst u a f fr e c esn ” 9 ... 20() ) o e eh proe h il . (. r i , L aei“n wu o l l ay m oeti e e w hrs a, r ey h ee ie f rh ae pt ee ieayih n e p y on r r i,er no dnte x c o otet m o x c , n r t l r t f e t ti rs t t rs g po dd ne[ eFM A” d § 65 )1 rv e ud t i rh L ] I 21( () . . a . M Jhsn fsci freeaee “ L I e e ne E p y e t m a o r ono’ itl m ori l gs FM A n r r c ” m o mn e i t n . sr a lf l tf e . l t r ni rs t gr m n m oe ee i n oae p nt ee iei FM Aev g er eo ci eui fo a e p ye x cig rt m igo x c h ln l rs t t r s s L laei si t al m v s a frFM An r rneSeBce e v A. W Al e Ic 29F d 1212 ( hC. 01 o L i e e c e ah dr. m . ii s n , 5 . 11 14 9 i 20) tf e . l rn , . 3 , t r . T m ni ai e e nel mal nf ms poeh “1 h wsl i e oteFM A o a t n nn r r c ci, pi i u rvta () e a e g lfrh ia tf e a a tf t t ib L' s po c os()i e p y ws oe d y h FM A() ews nt doev ud te r ein 2 h m oe a cv e b te L, 3 h a e ietlae ne h tt , s l r r tl r FM A() e rv e sf c nn ie fii e ttklaead 5 h e p y dn di L, 4 h po dd ui e oc o h n n oaeev n ()i m oe e e h m i fi t t s tt , s l r i FM A eett w c h ws nt d Sne v CyfN wo , 5 F d 7 78 9 C. L bn i o h h e a e ie ” adr . i o e pr 67 . 72 7 ( h i fs i tl . s t t 3 , t r 21) qo n Bre v L Ic, 7 F d 7 47 7 C. 06. n ret b a “i b 01(u ig unt. FW n 42 . 41 7 ( h i 20) I od o e n e g l t t . 3 , t r ) r li e e p ye adhs s bsteitl mnoa FM An r rnel m h e p yems m oe ” ntu e a ihhfse e f n L i e e c ci, e m oe u: l , tl r e t tf e a t l t 3 OI I NA DO D R – PNO N R E ()H v be e p yd y h e p y frtes1 mn s ad 1 a e en m oe bte m oe oala 2 o h1 n [] l l r t t, () H v be e p yd o ala 1 5 hu o s v edr g h 1– o h 2 a e en m oe fr t es , 0 or f e i u n te 2 mn [] l t 2 s rc i t p id m e al p cd gh c m ec mn oteev.. ad e oi mdt y r e nte o mne e fhlae., n r ie e i t () Hv be] m oe a a wrse we 5 o mr e p ye a e p yd 3[ ae en e p yd t okt h e 0 r o m oes r m oe l i r e l e l b te m oe w h 7 me ota wrse.. y h e p y i i 5 i s fh okt.. l r tn l t i 2 CFR§ 2 10 ) 9 ... 85 1(. . a A M Jhsn ea e p y e o Ar 121 h hd obe e p yd oala s r ono bgn m o mn n pl, 05 e a n en m oe frtes . l t i , t l t t e emn swe h wsno md fit m a o o J y 421 we h t m a o ws w v o h hn e aifr e o h e i t n n u 2 05 hni e i t n a l t s r ni l , ; s r ni e eie nAgs3 21 o we h pooelaewso e n nSp me 221 f c v o uu 1 05 r hni rpsdev at bg o e e b , 05 ft t , ; s i t r . Bcue ei n bc m a “i b e p ye u i Ar 121 Jnyrush M eas h d o eo e n e g l m oe” nl pl, 06 od ageta r d t li e l t i , t . Jhsn lae ot a mn ws opo c d yh FM Aadh eo, e os oad an ono’ evfrr t e a n r e e bte L, nte fr h de n n cno s e t t tt r e t t p a fc sf c nst a FM An r rnel m l da s ui e t e n L i e e c ci. e t fi t a tf e a M Jhsnepns yru gh s m cus ae e taa e p ye a hv r ono rsod b ag nta o e or hv h dh n m oe cn ae . i t t l t l po c dFM Aev wete m oe mks “r e g it rqe fr o-i bi r ee tt L lae hnh e p ye ae a p -i bi eus o ps e g it l elily t tlily [ L ]ev ” eea.Boka Sn rLigCts Ic, 6 F d 2917 (1 C. FM Alae Prd v rod e e o i n m . n 66 . 16 22 1 h i . l i v y, . 3 , t r 21) Tai a e p ye a m ni a FM An r rnel m vnhuhh e p yea 02 h s n m oe cn a t n n L i e e c ci eetogte m oe t . t, l ia tf e a l , tei e fe m a o ws oa “i b e p ye w hepctte w v mn ht m ot i t n a n n e g l m oe” i rse oht e e o h r ni , t li e l t t l- t e p y e rq r mn I M Jhsnrush bcue ac t a mni aogd w-u m o mn eu e e. d r ono ageta eas cne r t e s ln r no l t i t .. t re t , a t poe, ewu hv bc m e g lfrFM Aev dr git a mn adhsh “r rcs h o d ae eo el i e o s l ib L lae u n h r t e, ntu i p i se t , s e e g it rqe fr h] o-i bi [ L ]ev”s r e e I l i l y eus o[ s ps e g it FM Alaei po c d d i bi t i tlily tt. . A ai tl o t eeasesn g— ateFM A r e s rqe frev md b s nni p n Prd ’rao n t th ia i, i h L po c aeus olae ae y tt t aie g l e p ye olaeh wl cua e bc m gl i e—e udsm At ssu nni b m oefrevta i ocrf r eo i e g l p sae e sh i e li e l t l t n ib r . i s hs op v u y en drse bteN t C c t rh Dt co O gnI hoeo dp a n r i s be ad sd yh i h i u ote irt f r o cost ao t e ol e n ri si e , t Prd h e Nv te s aIics b o,eea my rmy oa od M Jhsnee eea e. ee h e, s d u e w rd a o a n f r r ono ri. r r ls s s l P tf . lf 1 Ud 2 CFR§ 2 10b “]e 2mn s n m oe mshv be e p yd yh e p y ne n ne 9 ... 85 1() [ h 1 o h a e p ye u ae en m oe bte m oe ed o r . ,t t l t l l r t b cneu v mn s H wv, M Jhsn os oaeeh h p o e p y e a aidpne e osc ie o h ” o ee r ono de n l gta i r r m o mn s nneedn t t. r . tl t si l t t cn a o/ a se o bgn h 1- o h c u. o rc r s ep sn ea te 2 mn ac a t t l r t rl 4 OI I NA DO D R – PNO N R E Prdhda e u qecn e fc, n ud s n nte ors p ia o otoe eeaa r h n u oc t a sad net d gh cu’ apcin fhs t r i , re t ra i t l t fc wl e e f i Prd ’ apcin e. neea tel nf bgn m o mn w hh a s i b h pu n eeas p ia o h eI Prd ,h pi i ea e p y e i te t l l l l t r a tf l t t d edni O oe 20 I a17 I Jn 20 tel nf n i ete e na tasews e na n c b 08 d t 21 n ue 09 h pi i of dh d edn h h a f t t r . . . , a tf ti f t t p ga w h de a il eNv me 20 adwu btk gFM Aev uo diey f r nn i a u d ena oe b 09 n o d ea n e t t t t r l i L lae pn e v o l r te h d d H wv, h wsi dnSp me 20 I Sewu hv be e p yd o h c l I o ee se af ei e e b 09 d h o d ae en m oe fr i. . r r t r .. l l t e emn s—ntu a “i b e p ye i O oe 20 oemn p ot h w v o h adhs n e g l m oe”— c b 09 n o h r ro e l t li e l n t r , t i r a i p e FM Aev I a17 n.h cu h dh bcueh pi i wu hv be nc a d L lae d t 22. Te or e ta eastel nf o d ae en ti t . . 5 t l t a tf l a “i b e p ye p ot we h FM Aev wso o mne n tu e g l ote a n e g l m oe” r ro hn e li e l i r L lae at c m ec ad hsl i e nh d e ib t o h a i p e FM Aev h laews r e e eetog sewse m a d r ro f e nc a d L lae e ev a po c d vnhuh h at i t p ot r ti t , r tt r ne i bc m gl i eI a17 Acr n yud Prd ,ts m a rlo M Jhsn FM A eo i e g l d t 25 cod g , ne eea iii m e at r ono’ n i b. . . il r ti . s L i e e nel mh h wse m a d eo h bc m a “i b e p ye ud teFM A n r r c ci ta e at i t b r e ea e n e g l m oe” ne h tf e a t r ne f e li e l r L. Jny nepneageta eeai uaaigo M Jhsn Teiic o od i rsos rush Prd s nvl t r ono h dt t n , , t in . . s ni , acr nt Jny sh tel nfi Prd wu hv be a “i b e p ye we h cod go od ita h pi i n eea o d ae en n e g l m oe” hn e i , t a tf l li e l r laewsoo mne we a h e M Jhsnwu n hv be a “i b e p ye ev atc m ec, h es e, r ono o d o ae en n e g l m oe” r r . l t li e l we h laewsoc m ec—nSp me 221 T siic o t Jny sipsien hni ev at o mneo e e b , 05 h dt t n o od i d ot i s t r . i s ni , , s iv dc igwe e M Jhsn astdocu s t a FM An r rnel m Acr nt ed i n h h r ono hst e r o dt e n L i e e c ci. cod go tr . a , l a, tf e a i JnyPrd ’i ep tin fh FM A rv e a r e g l pi i rd so y wete od eeasn rr a o ote L po ds p -i b l nf er s n hnh , t et i e l i e a tf e l pi i’ a i p elae ot a mnbg sf r e eo e a “i b e p ye l nf s nc a devfrr t e e n a e h bc ms n e g l m oe ” a tf ti t e t i t li e l . Iid od’rao n e oeu y ofts c m ec mn olae w h f Jny esn gr nos cn a “o mne e fev” i n s i r l le t t “o mne e ot a mn”Tea rcg zsh a e p ye a c m eclae o c m ec mn fr t e. hl weon eta n m oe cn o mneev fr t e t i t l t a mnada r o mneevfr upss fh FM Aeetog b h o mne e s r t e nl ec m eclae o proe ote L, vnhuh o c m ec mn e t t t t a frh s m md acn t n n b h cu dr g n cn gos bec Se 9CFR§ r ote a e e c odi ad o ocr u n oe o iuu asne e 2 ... e i l io t i t . 85 1()“ n m oe my e n o– L laetht m h oseme te 2 mn 2 10d( A e p ye a b o nn FM Aev atei e e r h e sh 1– o h . l t t e g it rq r mn adnh ee, n pr o oteevtkn oa FM Aqaf n l i l y eu e e, nita vn ay oin fhlaeae fr n L –uiy g i bi i t t t t li rao a ete m oe me tel i l y eu e e wu b FM Aev ” Acr n y esnf rh e p ye e sh e g it rq r mn o d e L lae) cod g, t l t i bi i t l .. il 5 OI I NA DO D R – PNO N R E “o mne e olaei n snn mu w h c m ec mnot a mn bcueh c m ec mn fev”s o yoy os i “o mne e fr t e ” easte t t t t e t fr eid a swe oe o mnelae neteFM Aadhlt m e id a swe o m n c e hn n c m ecsev udrh r it L nteae e l n c e hn tr r y i t a e p yewl e nb t wr “ o mne e olae is a so d eed s n m oe i b ua eo ok C m ec mn fev ”n ed hu bra a l l l . t , t , l “o mne e oFM Alae c m ec mn f L ev ” t . Spoefr x m e h a e p yea i pig n x net a mnp idn i e ups oea p, a n m oe nc a n a e eddr t e e o of s , ltt l , ti t t e t r , ti h e p y tah wl ea n a e eddev oasnew h s s rade r d e i m oe h e i btk g n x nelae f bec i a e t t n r un a. s l r t l i t t ta t t Dr ghrqe elae ts nc a dh te m oe wlmetel i l y u nteeus dev ii a i p eta h e p ye i e h e g it i t , ti t t l l t i bi rq r mn i.bc m a “i b e p ye a d ie b 2 CFR§ 2 10 ) Te eu e e s—e eo e n e g l m oe” s e nd y 9 ... 85 1(. h i t ., li e l f . a e p yehn o mnet a mn cno wr ad e n h lae Dr gh e p ye m oete c m ecsr t e, an ok n bg si ev u nte m oe s l e t t , i s . i l ’ cn gos bec te m oe me te w v mn rq r mnad eo e a “i b o iuu asne h e p ye e sht e e o heu e e n bc ms n e g l t , l t l- t i t li e r tt l , ti s l r s e p ye 2 Ud teea s h e p ye a fo tei e e of di e p y o h m oe ” ne hsfc, e m oe hd r mht m h n i e h m oe fi l . a i p elaea r e ei e sitalae easte m oe hd sf c nifr a o nc a dev po c dn r tnh ev bcueh e p y a “ui e no min ti t , tt t e t l r fi t t ..oesnb d e m eta teFM A. apidtteevrqe.I § 2 33b .t raoa y e r i [ t h l t n h] L .. p [ ]ohlaeeus”d 85 0() le t . . . Tai te m oe ke tet t n s p a s fh e p ye rqe elae n cu, h s h e p y n wh s radt d e ote m oe seus dev ad o d t, l r a o t l ’ t l fo toe a sraoa y e r ieh teFM A p ido pr o otalae r mhs d e esnb d e m ta h t, l t n t L apet a oin fh ev l t t . Acr n yaye m a o oav s e p y e dcin s rs t fh e p yeno n cod g, n t i t n r de e m o mn e s a aeu ote m oeivk g il r ni r l t io l l i t s r e elaewu c a l bi o bh f fh e p y frFM An r rne h po c dev o dr t i it n ea ote m oe o i tt l e e aly l l r L i e e c3 tf e . Te fr tea taa e p ye t a mnc m ecs r e g it i. h h eo,hfc h n m oe sr t e o mne p -i bi ., e r e t t l ’ e t e l i l y—et t a mnc m ecs s o- L lae—os o i ad fte, ate m oe sih i r t e o mne a nnFM Aev de n,n n oi l b h e p ye r t n e t t sf r l ’ gs sbeun FM Aevfrh s mt a mndr gh s m cn gos bec Te o- L usqe t L lae ote a er t e u nte a e o iuu asne h nnFM A e t i t . 2 Ud t sa u sea o h e p ye my ui otr ud s o bc m g n e g l e p ye sc a ne h fc a cn i te m oe a rnn oe hr efr eo i a “l i e m oe ” uh s r i tl r, l t h l n ib l , m i u hu yeu e e s Se 9CFR§ 2 10 )2 Fr upss e, o ee ii uncsayo i m m or rq r mn. e 2 ... 85 1( () o proe h eh wv,ts nee rt n l i t . a . r r s ad stoe ud sn ei dr shs hr ei d a e l tl . 3 Se f a y h e p ye a a FM An r rnel mwete e p y t m a ste m oe i pci l, e m oe hs n L i e e c ci hnh “ m oe e i t [ e p ye n i cl t l tf e a l r r ne h l ] od t ao hv go co md eh e p yew hih u FM Aev ” eea 66F dt 25 T s re o v d a nt ac m oa ta m oe i r t l L lae Prd , 6 . a17 h r i i t t l t gf . 3 . i cn u o a o su etate m oe wu b alt poeh o e ncsayl mn frFM A oc s nl a ms h h e p ye o d e beo rvtet r ee r e e s o li s s t l l h s e t L i e e ne e Sne , 5 F dt 7 n r r c Se adr 67 . a78 tf e . s 3 . 6 OI I NA DO D R – PNO N R E lae a g ewy o r e e FM Aevfrh s mt a mn adh po c dFM Aev ev cni at po c d L lae ote a er t e, nte r e e v tt e t tt L lae c m ecsote ate m oe bc msl i e o mne nh dy h e p ye eo e e g l l i b. Tu M Jhsn n of n Jny fincst frra mn cu hvivkd hs r ono i n iy g od o h ee i ot t e, o d aenoe , . , ti s sy e t l FM A r e elae o we h wso eo e n e g l e p ye o Ar 121 ee L po c devfr hn e at bc m a “i b m oe” n pl, 06 vn tt li e l i , tog h bgnra mn o Sp me 221 w l h wsni b.T d s M Jhsn huh e eat t e n e e b , 05 he e aie g l o o o r ono e t t r , i li e , . nesol gtao oaon Jn 921 h ws w eh h cnet a mn wu e ed edt aeeh n rrud ue, 05 e a a a ta i ac r t e o d x n l t , r t s re t l t u ia e Ar 121 adh h t a mn wu a oeu eev a e Ar 121 M nlf r pl, 06 nta i r t e o dl rq rlaef r pl, 06 r t t i , t se t l s i t i . . Jhsnlo edt aeeh h cneet s ee i t Jny raenie ,h Jny a ono a nesol gta e ovydh ncst o od o l ra v y a od hd s l t i sy ,t t ltt “ui e ifr a o..oesnb d e m etateFM A p ido M Jhsn lae sf c n no min.t raoa y e r i ”h h fi t t l t n t L apet r ono’ ev l . s rqe. 9CFR§ 2 33b I i go ft M Jhsn a po d aa u bs t spo eus 2 ... 85 0() f n oda h r ono cn rv e fc a a so upr t . ., i, . i tl i t sc a cn i h my e b t st al m o FM An r rne uh sea o e a b a eot e ci fr L i e e c r, l a a tf e . A cr n yldh wv, M Jhsn C m a tasaso o gt gi tte s u e l p , o ee r ono’ o pi flf hr f ei h moh rt e r . s ln l r t tn r h u ie , ups b, cn i ds ie aoe TeC m a t m e id a sh M a e n k yb o i esea o ec bd bv h o pi e l n c eta r t r l l t sl r r . l n r y it t . Jhsneus devt bg o Sp me 221 TeC m a t os oid a ta M ono rqe elaeo e n n e e b , 05 h o pi de n n c eh r t i t r . ln t it t . Jhsn ovydo od h ncst frev a e Ar 121 nr ostn c e n n wy ono cneet Jnyi ee i olaef r pl, 06 o deiid a i ay a s sy t i , it tah wu nelaef rAr 121 Bcuellael gdnh C m a t cu e h e o d edev a e pl, 06 eas a ev aeeite o pi ocr d t l t i . l l ln r b o Ar 121 ii n po c d yh FM A e r pl, 06 ts o r e e bte L. fe i , t tt Acr n y M Jhsnws oa e g l e p ye neteFM At n p ndr g cod g, r ono a n nl i e m oe ud h il . t ib l r L aay o t u n i i h lae—e h nv c m ecdFM Aev bcue ewsni b t d s Te fr I i ev i. e ee o mne s ., r L lae eas h aie g l o o o h eo, li e . r e d m si FM An r rnel m B ai u r e aoe ts o i e o M Jhsno i i h s s s L i e e c ci. u sl s a d bv ii ps b fr r onot tf e a t l tt , sl . a edi c m a t n aeea sh wu ivkteFM A po c os Te fr I mn h o pi adl gfc ta o dnoeh s ln l t t l L ’ r ein h eo, s tt . r e d m s M Jhsn FM A n r rnel mw hup jd e i i r ono’ s s . s L - t f ec ci i o r u c Iee a t t e i. 7 OI I NA DO D R – PNO N R E I I . Itr rneu dr h Oeo F i LaeA n f ec nete rg n am y ev c ee l t M Jhsn scn ci aee “ F A n r rne TeO L i O gn aa ge r ono’ eodl ml gs O L I e e c ” h F As r o’ n ou . s a l tf e . e s l tteFM A n “hl e os udoh e e ps b i amnetai cn s n w h n oh L ad sa b cnrette x n o i en an h s ost t i ay l t t t sl r t ie t s ma po s n ote FM A”O Rv St§ 5 A 8() Tu al m oi e e ne i i r rvi s fh[ L ] r e t. 69. 62 hs ci frn r r c l io . . . a 1 . , a tf e ud teO L l g yee b s nn r rnel m neteFM AC maeA boe... ne h F Aa e rs m e ai e e c ci ud h r rl l tf e a r L. o pr mrs vJB Hn Tas, n ,N 3 2 C –14– U21 W 557 a*0 D O Fb1 21) u rnp Ic o : – V070 H, 04 L 836 t 1 (. r e 3 04 t . . . 1 , . . , (s ntel mn fr nO L i e e nel m w hSne , 5 F dt 7 (s nte lt gh e e s oa F An r r c ci ) i adr 67 . a78lt gh ii e t tf e a ,t s 3 ii s m e mn fr nFM An r rnel m B tei e ns neteO L a df e ta a el e s oa e t L i e e c ci ) u ht mie ud h F Ar i e n hn tf e a . t l r e fr t toe neteFM A Se f a ya e p ye eo e a “i b e p ye ud teO L hs ud h r L. pci l , n m oe bc ms n e g l m oe” ne h F A i cl l li e l r ote 8 h a oe p y e,n ed fh oeyarq r mnud teFM A O Rv nh 10 dy f m o mn is a ote n e eu e e ne h t l t t - r i t r L. r e . . St§ 5 A 5()2 C .. 85 1( () t. 69. 61 9 . R§ 2 10 )1 a 1 ; F . a . N w h ad gh so ee p y e rq r mn ud teO L, od seso o i s n nte hr r m o mn eu e e s ne h F AJny ekt t tt i t l t i t r d m s M Jhsn O L i e e nel m nh s m gon suhfrFM Ai m s i i r ono’ F An r r c ci ote a e rud og o s s . s tf e a t L d ia s s l— ta M Jhsnws oa “i b e p ye we h lae o mne Se f a yJny h r ono a n n e g l m oe” hni ev c m ecd pci l , od t . t li e l s . i cl ageta M Jhsnws oe p yd o 10 as eo te a o w c h lae rush r ono a n m oe fr 8 dy b r h d e n h hi ev t . t l fe t i s c m ecdadh eo, M Jhsn an si y hfse mn oa O L i e e ne o mne nte fr r ono cno as teitl e f n F An r r c , r e . t tf r e t tf e ci. e O Rv St§ 5 A 5() )rq r gh t b “i b ” n m oe neso e l mSe r e t. 69. 61 a( ui ta o e e g l a e p ye edt b a . . a 1 ( e in t li e l e p yd o 10 as A boe 21 W 557 a*0rq r gh te e p ye b m oe fr 8 dy; mrs , 04 L 836 t 1 ( ui ta h “ m oe[e l ) , e in t l ] e g lfrO L' po c ost se a O L i e e nel m l i e o F A r ein”o ek n F An r r c ci ) ib s tt tf e a . I rsos M Jhsnrush Prd ’rin e hu b e eddon ue nepne r ono ageta eeasa oa so d e x netic d , . t t l l t l i e e nel m ud teO L. M Jhsnrush is e edd eea wu g ei n r r c ci s ne h F A r ono ageta f o x ne Prd o di h m tf e a r . t t , l v a r e ei e si O L laet m igr mi p -i bi rqe fr o-i bi po c dn r tn F Aev s m fo h r e g it eus o ps e g it tt t e e n s elily t tlily lae eea 66F dt 22 eea hs obe ad se btet e or o O gnb I ev Prd , 6 . a17 Prd a n en dr sd yh st cus f r o u . 3 . t e a t e , t bivteO gnSp m Cu wu rcg z Prd ’ apcinoh O L.Fs eeeh r o ur e or o deon e eeas p ia otte F A it l e e t l i l t r, 8 OI I NA DO D R – PNO N R E Prd ’ h d gs ostn w hhtxoteO L,w c rq rsh e p ye n ret b eeas o i i cn s t i tee fh F A h heu ete m oe i od o e ln ie t t i i l , r e g l t b e p yd o“8 dyi mdt y eo te a o w c te O L]ev l i e o e m oe fr 10 as m e al b r h d e n h h h [ F Alae i b, l ie f e t i wu c m ec . O Rv St§ 5 A 5()e pa s de) Tu tet u a i p eta o d o mne ” r e t. 69. 61( mhs add hs h st e nc a sh l . . a 1 i . , a t ti t t te a o w c a e p ye o mne O L laes e r ia v o e g it adh h d e n h h n m oe c m ecs F Aevi d e m t e fl i l y nte t i l t ni i bi , st emks oe rne bue g it atei e hrqe i md Scn Iidh t u ae n r e c ao l i l ytht mteeus s ae eod f ta at fe t i bi t . , n t Prd ’rin e e s evte q tb proe oteO L bcue n m oe womks eeasa oa h ps eh eua e upss fh F A eas a e p ye h ae t l l r i l l a r e g lrqe fr o-i b lae hu hv a r e ei e sitaps e g l p -i b eus o ps e g l ev so d ae po c dn r tnh o-i b eli e t tli e l tt t e t tli e O L lae O e w ee p y swu b a ett m a nn l i e m oes s d e F Aev t ri , m oe o d e b oe i t o-i b e p ye a ai c . h s l r l l r ne egl l rt rs t fh reus dev adwu b a eoi u vnpo d ghs e p ye w hh eu ote rqe elae n o d e b t c c me rv i toe m oes i te l i t l l r t in l t laehy r e iet ud teO L.e O Rv St§ 5 A 8() po d gh te evte a nt do ne h F A e r e t. 69. 62(rv i ta h e tl r S . . a 1 in t O L b cnre s ma y oh FM A Prd , 6 F dt 25“Thi ep tinh F A e os udi i r tte L ) eea 66 . a17 ( ]en rr a ota t ll ; 3 [ t et t [e na ] re wu ..rs a te ups oteFM A y e mt g m oe t e m a d edn ugs o d. fur eh proe fh f t l tt L b p ii e p y sol i t r tn l r i ne s ftate m oe p c vswl ed L. ;O A m.R890903 ( E g l t fh h e p y e e e i ne FM A) r d i . 3-0-20“l i e a t l r ri l ” . n ib e p ye myaeO L laefr] e os et cn t n...Te fr I o e ed m oes a tk F Aev[oas iu ha h odi ..” h eo, n w x n l r l io ) r e t Prd ’rin eo oeteO L.H wv, sw h M Jhsn FM Al mPrd de eeasa oa t cv h F A o ee a i r ono’ t l r r t . s L ci,eea os a n ncsal po d h m n ri. o ee r y rv ei ay ee t si i lf Jny sesh Prd i uaaigo M Jhsn neteO L bcueilae o od a r ta eea s nvl t r ono ud h F A eas h evfr st t in . r s t a mnc m ecd eo h ws m oe fr 8 dy adhs M Jhsnws oe g l r t e o mne b r e a e p yd o 10 as ntu r ono a n l i e e t fe l , , . tib we h lae o mne Aa, od i se n o r hd m s, mtkn cn a s hni ev c m ecd g nJny n ek g ui ti i a i ae y oft s . i , i tg s sl s l le “o mne t a mn w h c m ecdO L lae c m ecdr t e ” i “o mne F Aev ” e t t . AteO L it b cnrei amnecn s n w hh FM AIid 9CFR§ sh F Aso e os udn an ost t i te L, f 2 ... t r ie t n 85 1()—rv igh e p ye cn eo el i e u n nnFM Aev cn s n 2 10d po d ta m oes a bc m e g l dr g o- L lae—ost t . in t l ib i ie w hh O L.Se r Rv St§ 5 A 8() Te fr a e p ye a b o nn O L i te F A e O e t. 69. 62 h eo, n m oe cn e n o- F A t . . a 1 . r e l laetht m h me teO L e g it rq r mn, adnh ee, n pr o ote ev atei e e e sh F Al i l y eu e e s“nita vn ay oin fh t i bi i t t t t laeae fr n O L ]qaf n rao a ete m oe me tel i l y eu e e evtkn oa [ F A–uiy gesnf rh e p ye e sh e g it rq r mn li t l t i bi i t 9 OI I NA DO D R – PNO N R E wu b[ F Alae 2 CFR§ 2 10d Tu cn ay o od’ ag mn, o d e O L ]ev ” 9 ... 85 1() hs o r t Jny ru e s l . . . , tr s t “o mne t a mn i n snn mu w h c m ecdO L lae c m ecdr t e ”s o yoy os i “o mne F Aev ” e t t t . M Jhsn os onet hv epcl rqe e O L lae e O A m.R89 r ono de n edo ae x it eus d F Aev Se r d i . 3. t li y t . . n 0905()“ h e p yes orq rdo pc y h teeusifrO L lae ) 0-201( Te m oei n eu et se f ta hrqe s o F Aev.. l t i i t t ” H wv,o bi O L po c os M Jhsn edt hvifr e Jny h h lae o ee t o a F A r ein r ono neso aeno md odta i ev r tn tt , . t s t i fi t t wu b e ed gog tat e yi dy 4 otah po dd sf c n no min o o d e x n nlne hn wn - x as rh e rv e “ui e ifr a o fr l t i r ts [od]oesnb d e m etateO L apet h rqe. 9CFR§ 2 33b5 Jnyt raoa y e r i ”h h F A p idoi eus 2 ... 85 0() l t n t l s t . . TeC m a t os oaeeh M Jhsnno md odtah laewu ls h o pi de n l gta r onoifr e Jnyh i ev o da ln tl t . t s l t lnetat e yi dy Te fr Jnyi n ko tah laewu,na, e og hn wn - x as h eo, od d o n wh i ev o d fc b r ts . r e d t t s li t e ed gn a e o frw c h wsO L -i b.Te n qeine t ad s te i x n ni o p id o h h e a F A l i e h o y us ol to dr s hn s t i t r i egl l t f e, , we eteO L ’ so et mie oe g it a e swe e ud tea sl gdJny h h h F A hr ri e nfrl i l y f c h h, ne hfc aee od tr s t l i bi ft tr r t l , hd ui e ifr a o t d e m e h te F A p ido M Jhsn laeeus Sed a sf c n no min o e r i ta h O L apet r ono’ evrqe. ei fi t t t n t l . s t . Iid od d n. f Jnyi o n d t TeC m a tsi n w hepctte ei o M Jhsnno m g od o h h o pi ise i rse oh d as f r onoifr i Jny fi ln lt t t tl . n s ncst frra mn A aeu ot s bec adeonigh cnet a mn v yI o ee i ot t e. s rs t fh asne n rcg z ta ac r t e s a , d sy e t l i , in t re t r n f dh Jny a sf c nifr a ot raoa y e r ieh M Jhsn lae o i ta od hd ui e no minoesnb d e m ta r ono’ ev tn t fi t t l t n t . s wu b e edd olnetat e yi dy I W lIeon eh M Jhsn o d e x ne frog hn wn s as d he rcg zta r ono’ l t r t x . .i i t . s t a mnd ,na,a frog tat e yi dy t e y iht b p c e— i ps hc r t e i i fc ls olne hn wn - x as—wn - g o e r i t s o-o e t d t t r ts te t es h t c c a o ot a mnln h os osp y h ncsay no min o mt f dh Jny a ut n fr t e eg de n up te ee r ifr a o fr eoi ta od l li e t t t l s t n t raoa y e r ie p oti t m a o o M Jhsn h h t a mn wu e edn a esnb d e m d r rot e i t n f r ono ta i r t e o d x ni o l t n, i s r ni . , t se t l t t 4 M Jhsn ea e nl i e moe ud teO L o Sp me 2 21 t e yi dy a e h lae r ono bc m a e g l e pye ne h F A n e e b 8 05 wn - x asf ri ev . ib l r t r , , ts t s frra mnc m ecd ot t e o mne e t . 5 BcueO Rv St§ 5 A 6 ( N ie fev”adh O gnA m irieR e a se w hepc eas r e t. 69. 5“ oc olae nte r o d i sa v u sr i n i rse . . a 1 t ) e ntt l e lt t t t teeu e e s ee ayo ie m oe n ieh teO L apet aie e p ye laeIid 9 o hrq r mn ncs rt g e p y s octa h F A p iso g n m oe sev f 2 i t s v l r t t l v l ’ , n CFR§ 2 33b sn rr a o o teFM A ostn w hh O L.e O Rv St§ 5 A 8() ... 85 0() i ep tin f h . ’ t et L cn s t i te F A e r e t. 69. 62 ie t S . . a 1 . 1 –OI I NA DO D R 0 PNO N R E 6 p id o w c h wsl i e neteO L. Bsd pnh n ie M Jhsnl gdIid e o fr h h e a e g l ud h F A ae uote oc r ono aee f r i ib r t . l , n taJny i n, oso d aeraoa y e r ieta M Jhsnwso eo eO L h od d o nr hu hv esnb d e m dh r ono at bc m F A t d t l , l t n t . e g l dr girqe elaeI l i e u n h eus dev d ib i s t . . H wv, easii ps b fr M Jhsnol gfc ta wu b n h mw h o ee bcuets o i e o r onot aeea sh o d r gi i i r sl . l t t l i tn O L ’ po c osIi m s M Jhsn O L i e e nel mw hup jd e F A r ein d i r ono’ F An r r c ci i o r u c s tt , s s . s tf e a t t e i. I. I I Ptn ar a a o c im u drbt teFM A n O L o t l e l t nl s ne oh h e i ti i a L ad F A M Jhsn t ot u r ci srtld FM A n r rne ad O L r ono’ w st oyl m a ie “ L I e e c” n “ F A . s at a et tf e I e e ne rseie .H wv,w h b hl m te a aea os felt n n r r c ”epc v y o ee i i o ci s h er l gin or aa o 7 tf e , t l r tn t a , r el t tii . Bcueelt ns sp a cue f c o udr o st e ad od o y mvsoi m s easr aa oi a ea t as oain n e b ht u s n Jny n oet d i tii re t t at , l s s M Jhsn i e e nel m ad s n we er M Jhsnlo u uselt nho e r ono’ n r r c ci s dr s g h h . s tf e a , ei t r ono a pr er aa oter s . s s tii i wl e r iewe e h sl m nist u r ci s See. X L v A wyCr, 4 i d em l t n h h etl a t nst oyl m e . , i i . m a op 37 tr i ia at a . , g n u . F d 1513 ( hC. 03( s nu h gFM An r rne n r aa o ci s Rgr v . 12 16 9 i 20) dt g s n 3 , t r ii i i L i e e c adelt nl m; oe . tf e tii a ) s O Ta E c Cnu e Co ,N 3 0 C –37 A, 02 W 1317a*0 D O My r r l l . os mr op o : – V13– C21 L 652 t 2 (. r a . i e s . . 1 , . 821) dt g s n O L i e e ne n r aa o ci s , 02( s nu h g F An r r c adelt nl m. ii i i tf e tii a ) Ud teFM A e m a o rs t gr m n m oe ae p nt ee ie rtie ne h r L, r i t neui fo a e p yet m igo x c o ul t ni ln l t t rs iz h FM Aev a M Jhsnl gs e g er eo ci frn r rnen r aa o i s L lae—s r ono aee h e— vsi t al m oi e e c o elt n . l r i s a t f e , t tii . SeBce e, 5 F dt 14 R aa o otete hn i we “n m oei pn hd e ah dr 29 . a12 elt n nh o r ad s hn a e p yes u se l 3 . tii , h , l i fr po n u a f p ccs y h e p y .X L , 4 F dt 16e pa sn r ia. o ops g n wu r t e b te m oe”i i 37 . a13 ( mhs i o g l i l l ai l r n u 3 i i n) Bcue M Jhsnmks o uhl gin h hs ostd ci frelt n nete eas r ono ae n sc aea os e a n t e al m or aa o ud h . l t , ta a tii r FM A L. 6 A huhI oeon eh teie hotaJny a a ns ot s o i l ys nacd we c ma d l og d rcg zta hl l odh od’ w ee fh ps bi i ehne hn o p e t , i t ki t s r s i s it , r t te L t mieb tee pr po m y ewe M Jhsn e n nt a mnadec n e g it o h FM Ai e n yht mo l rx i b e r ono bg n gr t e n rah gl i l y l , a it t n . ii e t i i bi ud teO L. ne h F A r 7 Ud M Jhsn FM Al mh ci sh “ e na' a ot m a n Jhsn ost e wlu ne r ono’ r . s L ci, el mta Dedns c fe i t g ono cni td if a a t f t t r ni tu ll i e e ne n r aa o ud FM A Ud h O L ci, e sesh “ e na' dnl fO L n r r c adelt n ne tf e tii r L. ne i F Al mh a r ta D edns e ao F A ” r s a st t f t i lae n r aa r d cagii v lin f O Rv St§ 69.8 ” n “ ] aeu o D edns ev adelt yi h esni a o o[ r e t. ] 5 A 3 ad[ s rs t f e na' ti o s r ot . . a 1, a l f t i e e ne n r aa r d cag Jhsn u e d a ae ” n r r c adelt yi h e ono sf r d mgs tf e ti o s r , fe . 1 –OI I NA DO D R 1 PNO N R E A O L r aa o ci o yr e we r aa o rs tfo aid iu n F Aelt nl m n ass hnelt neusr m nn v a tii a l i tii l idl “ q r n] bute rvin o[ eO L ] O Rv St§ 5 A 8()seRgr 21 i u[ gao h po s s ft F A” r e t. 69. 32 e oe , 02 n ii t io h . . . a 1 ; s W 1317a*0 M Jhsnmks ol ginr a doi iq r g bute rvin L 652 t 2 r ono ae n aea oset t h mnui ao h po s s , . . l t le in t io oteO L, n a aeu, e a n std ci frelt n neteO L. fh F Aad s rs th hs o t e al m or aa o ud h F A l ta a tii r M Jhsn os oapat b pru gelt nho e nr a h aee fc r ono de n pe o e u i r aa oter s o hs el gda s . t r s n tii i, l t sf c nt str aa o ci s nee h st e Te fr aI m rn n Jny M in ui e ot eelt nl m ud i e t u. h eo, s a g t g od’ o o fi t a tii a r t r at r e ai s t t D m sh FM A n r rne n O L -n r rnel m M Jhsn oog m nis o i i te L - t f ec ad F A t f ec ci s r ono nlne a t n s s I ee I ee a , . r ia ayt u r ci s n st oyl m at a . C N L SO O C UI N Frhraost e aoeIG A T od’ M inoD m s o Flrt St a oteesnstd bv a , R N Jnys o ot i i fr a u o t e t s s i e a Ci [0 M Jhsn os oaee ui e fc t d mnr e eno md od tah l m 1] r ono de n l g sf c n a so e os a hifr e Jny h i a . . tl fi t t tt t s laewu b e ed gn a e o oe g it ud e h st e M Jhsnlo os o ev o d e x n ni o p id fl i l y ne i e t u. r ono a de n l t i t r i bi r t r at . s t aee ui e fc frmt f dh Jny esnb d e m eta M Jhsn lae l g sf c n a s o eoi ta od raoa y e r i dh r ono’ ev l fi t t n t l t n t . s wu,na, e x n ni o p id fl i l y nee h st e AI ec bdn ra r o d fc b e ed gn a e o oe g it ud i e t u. s ds iei g t li t t i t r i bi r t r at r ee d a aoedpn n o M Jhsn c m u cin w h od o oaon Jn 2 21 ei bv eed g n r ono’ o mn a os i Jny n rrud ue 4 05 tl , i . s it t , , oaayi e ewe h kolde fi cni o adisbeunt m a o M Jhsn rt nt m b eni n w g o h od in n h usqe e i t n r ono t s e s t s t r ni , . my e b t d mnr e od’ a a ns w hepctteeg o h lae n h a b a eo e os a Jny w ee i rse ohln h fi ev adi l tt s r s t t t s s sbeune g it fr pr o otalae Tu h my e b t st al m oi e e ne usqe l i l y oa oin fh ev hs e a b a eot e ci frn r r c t i bi t t . l a a tf e ud teFM A h O L, r o.TeC m a t 1 h wv, os oaee ui e fc fr ne h r L, e F Ao b h h o pi [] o ee de n l g sf c n a s o t t ln , r tl fi t t mt f d M Jhsnl i e e.Acr n yIG A T od’ M inoD m s 1] n eoi r ono e g l h e cod g, R N Jny o ot i i [0ad n . ib r il s t s s d m sw hup jd e M Jhsn at r dyt fe n mne c m a t rhs ci s i i i o r u c r ono hsht asoi a a edd o pi oteel m s s t t e i. . iy l ln a wl ei m sd i bd ie l s s . / / / / 1 –OI I NA DO D R 2 PNO N R E D T Dh 1 h dy fAr, 07 A E ts 3 i t a o pl21 i . / M he W Ms a s i a . o mn / c l MC A L W M SM N IHE . O A C e U tdStsDt cJde h f ne t e irt ug i i a si 1 –OI I NA DO D R 3 PNO N R E

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?