Thomasson v. Premo et al

Filing 95

OPINION AND ORDER. For the reasons stated in this Opinion and Order, I GRANT Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment 82 and DISMISS Mr. Thomasson's claims with prejudice. Signed on 06/02/2017 by Judge Michael W. Mosman. (rs)

U I E S A E DS RC C U T
NT D T T S I TI T O R
F RT EDS RC O O E O
O H I TI T F R G N
E G N D VS O
U E E I II N

J R I HT OM S O ,
E EM A H A S N

N 6 4 v078 O
o : - -18-M
. 1c

Pi i,
l nf
a tf

OI I NA DO D R
PNO N R E

v
.
J F P EM ,tl
E F R Oe a,
.
D edn.
e na s
f
t
M SM NJ
O A,.,

M To a o b ns w ci s g n D ena sb hetdoaee v lin
r h ms n r gt ol m aa s e dn, o r a t l gdi a os
.
s i
a
it f
t t le
l
ot
o h cni t n r h. D edn fe a M in o S m ay ug e [2 ag nta
fi ost i a i t e na si d o o fr u m Jd mn 8] ru gh
s tuo l g s f
t l
t
r
t , i
t
te a e ietjd mnite fvr n o o M To a o’ ci s M To a o
hyr nt doug e nh rao o b h f r h ms n l m r h ms n
e tl
t
i
t
.
s s a . .
s
rsoddn pot n 8]adD edn rpe[0 Frhraost e b o,
epnei opsi [7 n e na se i 9] oteesnstd e wI
io
,
f
t ld .
a
l
G A TD edn’ M in o S m ay ug e [2
R N e na s o o fr u m Jd mn 8]
f
t
t
r
t .
B C G O N
A K R U D
M To a oi ai m e ev g sn new hh O gnDp t e o
r h ms ns nn a s i ae ec i te r o ea mn f
.
s
t rn
t
t
e
r t
Cr c os O O) Hi cr n y osdn a sp mxfci i F r a nea
o ein( D C es u e l huei “ue a”al yn l i ud n
rt
.
rt
r
it
od
r
are e b we O gn n F r a u unt a I et eCr c osC ma. M
g mn e en r o ad l i pr a o n n r a o ein o pc r
e t t
e
od s t
t st
rt
t .

1 OI I NA DO D R
– PNO N R E

To a oi o “ls Mng mn stsnF r aad s rs th ci s es e i
h ms ns n C e aae e ”t ui l i , n a aeu, el m hi h dn
s
o
t a
od
l
a
l
s i riot n o 2 hu a a
ot ys a o fr 3 or dy
la
li
s
.
P ot M To a o’t n et F r a h ws osdn d i s a v sg gin
r ro r h ms n r s ro l i , e a huei a m irie er a o
i
.
s s af
od
nt t
et
aa r oi O gn H ci s ews osdh e o 2 dy b o hrc vd n ie f
t psnn r o el m h a huete fr 6 as e r eee e a oc o
i
e .
a
r
fe
i
t
ha n o Fbu y 321 W l M To a o de n d p e h hrc vd h
e ig n era 1 04 he r h ms n os o i u ta eee ete
r
r ,
. i .
s
t st t
i
n ieh bivstws e c nbcuetws drset ao ei mt Ae dy a e
oc e eeei a d i e easi a ad sdo n h n ae f w asf r
t ,
l
fi t
e
tr
.
t
h ha n M To a o wsrn e et F r a
i e ig r h ms n a t s r do l i .
s r , .
s
a fr
od
Teesn bh d M To a o’s ynd i s a v sg gin rrn et a
hraos e n r h ms n t ia m irie er ao ot s ro
i
.
s sa
nt t
et
af
st pne i y nF r ar n ai u it s ae Rg d s oteesn M
t e e tna i l i a o ts e nh cs ea l s fhraos r
a
i tr
od e t s
i
.
re
, .
To a o ci sh D edn hv v l e h Fu en A ed e poeu l u
h ms nl mta e na s aei a d i or e h mn mn rcdr de
s a
t f
t
ot
s t t
t
a
poe r h b () uigi i s i r cn n mn w hu ep nin()aigo
rcs i t y 1 p t h n ot y of e e i o
s gs
t n m la
i
t t t x aa o 2fl t
l t ,
in
po d h mw h dqa n ie f ha n ad 3t n eigi t F r aw hua
rv ei i aeu e o c oa e ig n ()r s r n h mo l i i o
i
t
t t
r ,
a fr
od t t
ha n I adin M To a o ci sh tern e hs mee h acstte
e ig n d t , r h ms nl mta ht s r ai pddi ce oh
r .
io .
s a
t
af
s
s
cus eas h de n hv acst O gn a m e a i F r a w c v l e h
or bcue e os o ae ce o r o l w a rl n l i , h hi a si
t
t
s
e
ti s
o d i ot s
cni t n r h.
ost i a i t
tuo l g s
M To a o seso o sv aid iua cne ette rgnDp t e o
r h ms n ekt h d ee ln v l onc doh O o ea mn f
.
s
l
r
id s
t
e
r t
Cr c osib frh aee vot n o h cni t n r h. Se f a yh b ns
o einl l otel gdili s fi ost i a i t pci l, e r g
rt
ae
l
ao
s tuo l g s
i cl
i
ci s g n () e P m teSp i ednoa O gnt ePsn()C l eS
l m aa s 1J f r o h ue n ne f n r o St r o 2 oe .
a
it
f e ,
rt
t
e
a i ,
lt
P e,h D e o o Cr c os sh O g nDp t e o Cr c os()Du Yne a
e r te i c r f o ein ate r o ea mn f o ein 3 og acy
ts
rt
rt
e
r t
rt ,
,
m me oteScr yTra Mng mn U iaa O gnSt Psnad 4 M he F
e b fh eut h t aae e n tt n r o t e r o n () i a .
r
i
e
t
e
a i ,
c l
G w,h A i a D e o o Cr c osth O gnDpt e o Cr c os B h
o e te s s n i c r f o ein ate r o ea mn f o ein o
r
st t r t
rt
e
r t
rt . t
ci sr bog aa sa fuid iu s nh r e oaad f cl aat
l m a ruh g n l orn v a ite p sn n oi acpc y
a
e
t it l
idl
i r l
fi
i.

2 OI I NA DO D R
– PNO N R E

L G LS A D R
E A T N A D
S m ay ug e i poe“ temvnso sh te i n gn n d p e so
u m jd mn s rp i h oa h wta h es o eu ei u at
r
t
rf
t
t r
i st
aym e afcadh mvni e iet jd mna amt ol w Fd R C.P
n a rla nte oa s nt do ug e s ae fa. e . i .
ti t
t tl
t
tr
” .
v
5(.Teni bre fr mt n os m ayug e i otemv g a yodnf
6 ) hi tl udn oa o o fr u m jd mn s nh o n p ttie iy
a
ia
i
r
t
i
r
t
te bec oa eu esu o m e afc C o xCr v C rt 47US3733
h asne f gn ni e f a rla.e t op . a e , 7 .. 1 2
i s
ti t l e
.
tt
,
(96 Octabreisiid h bre s f tte o- o n p tt d mnr e
18) neh udns as e te udn ht oh nn mv g a yo e os a,
.
t
tf ,
is
i r
tt
truhh pouin f v ecltdnFd.C.P5( () tate r m n a
hogte rdc o oe dnei ei e R i . 6 )1 h h ee a s
t
i
s
. v
c , t r
i
“eu esufrrl C o x 47USa34 Te o- o n p t my or y pnh
gn ni e ot a” e t , 7 ..t 2 h nn mv g a y a n e uote
i s
i. l e
.
i
r
tl
p a n aea osB no v L d Rs J n Vn r , 3F d 0414 ( hC. 95
l d gl gin r sn. i a oe o t e ue 5 . 14 09 9 i 19)
ei l t , i
n
i
t
3
,
t r
(t gFd R C.P 6 ) o“nupr d o e u ocn uoyt e e s Hradz
ci e . i 5( ) r uspo e cn c r r oc sr st mn, enne
in .
v
e,
t
jt e
l
a
t”
vSae b MdIc 33F d 1711 ( hC. 03 A raoa e ob ad
. pc as e n , 4 . 10 12 9 i 20) l esnb du s n
l
. .
3
,
t r
. l
l
t
if ecso e r w fo tea srt b v wdnhl h mtao b tte on rnet b d nr mhfc a o e i eitei t o fvr l oh nn
e
a
t e
e
g
s
ae
mv g a y M ss t E cIds C,L..Zn hRd Cr 45US5457 18)
o n p t a uh a l . nu o t v e t a o op 7 .. 7 8 (96
i
r. t i e
. . d
i
i
.,
,
.
DS U S O
I C SI N
M To a o b ns w ci s g n D edn.I Ci I M To a o
r h ms n r gt ol m aa s e na s n l m, r h ms n
.
s i
a
it f
t
a
.
s
aeeta D edn v l e h poeu l u poesih ud teFu en
l gsh e na si a di rcdr de rcsr t ne h or e h
l
t f
t ot s
a
gs
r
t t
A ed e .I Ci I M To a o aeet a D edn v l e h Fs Fu had
mn mn n l mI r h ms nl gs ht e na si a di it or, n
t
a , .
s l
f
t ot s r, t
Fu en A ed e r h b f l go rv ei w h ce t air yw hm e a o
or e h mn mn i t ya i t po d h m i acs o l a i a rl n
t t
t gs
in
i
t
s
b r t ti s
O gna,h ey brc n hs ce tte or. D edn agehyr e iet
r ol w e b os uigi acs oh cus e na srute a nt do
e
tr
t t
s
t
f
t
e tl
s m ayug e o b hl m bcue M To a o hsae t so tate v l e
u m jd mn n o ci s eas r h ms n afld o h w h hy i a d
r
t
t a
.
s
i
t
ot
h cni t n r h. Ee ite i aa u d p e s owe ete v l e M
i ost i a i t vn fh es fc a i u at h h hyi a d r
s tuo l g s
r
tl st
tr
ot
.
To a o’ cni t n r h,D edn agete a e iet qaf d m u t Fr
h ms n ost i a i t e na sru hyr nt do ui ei mn y o
s s tuo l g s f
t
e tl
li
i.
teesn epie b o, f dh D e a sr e iet s m ayug e o b h
hraos x a d e wIi ta e n n a nt do u m jd mn n o
ln l
n t f d t e tl
r
t
t

3 OI I NA DO D R
– PNO N R E

ci s BcueD edn a e iet s m ayug e otem i otel m I o
l m eas e na sr nt do u m jd mn nh et fh ci s d
a .
f
t e tl
r
t
rs
a ,
n cn d we ete a e iet qaf d m u t
o os e h h hyr nt do ui ei mn y
t ir tr
e tl
li
i.
I
.

Poe ua DePoe V lt n
rcdr u rcs i a os
l
s oi

M To a o age D edn v l e h poeu l u poe r h b ()
r h ms nrus e na si a d i rcdr de rcs i t y 1
.
s
f
t ot
s
a
s gs
p t gi i s i r cn n mnfr 6 asw huep nt n r dqa n ie f
ui h mn ot y of e e o 2 dy i o x aa o oaeu e oc oa
tn
la
i
t
t t l i
t t
ha n ad 2sn n h mo psnnF rd we hr m ni s i riot n
e ig n () ed gi t a r oi l ia h e ee a sn ot ys a o
r ,
i
i
o , r
i
la
li .
D edn agehyr e iet s m ayjd mn o t slm ne b hho e
e na srute a nt do u m
f
t
e tl
r ug e n h ciud o ter s
t
i a
r t
i
bcue M To a o hsaet so te v l e a r e el e y n rs e h ud
eas r h ms n afldo h whyi a d po c di r i e t i e ne
.
s
i
ot
t t b t t e, t r
r
teDePoe C uete o ud stl w SeL F u v No ,:2C -03-I21
h u rcs l si l r ne t ea. e al r. o h 2 - V067S 04
s a
sf
ra
e
t
1
,
W 1318a* (.O M. 521)“ h DePoe C ue fh Fu en
L 263 t 3 D r a 2 04( Te u rcs l s ote or e h
,
. r ,
s a
t t
A ed e po c l e yn rssh as e h ud teluete o ud stl w
mn mn r e si r i e t ta r ei e ne h c si l r ne t ea.
t t t bt t e
ti tr
r
a
sf
ra
”
(t g hpe v Mnevl , 0 F d 0216 ( hC. 03. Frhf l w g
ci Capl. adrl 76 . 15 02 9 i 21) ote o oi
in
l
ie
3
,
t r
)
l n
raos M To a o hsaet so taD edn v l e ai e y n rsc a d
esn r h ms n afldo h wh e na si a d l r i e tr t
, .
s
i
tf
t ot
b t t e ee
ud teDePoe C uete o ud s tl w Asc IG A T u m yug e
ne h u rcs l si l r ne t ea. s uh R N s m a jd mn
r
s a
sf
r a
,
r
t
i D edn’ao o Ci I
n e na sfvr n l m.
f
t
a
ADePoe V l i nA sn Fo teC uete
. u rcs i a o ri g r m h l s I l
s ot
i
a
sf
TeDePoe C uente “os o po ceey hne nh cn t n o
h u rcs l sii l de n r e v cag ite odi s f
s a
sf
t tt r
io
cn n mn hv g sb a i av si pcote r oe” Sn n.Cne 55US
of e e a n a us na de e ma nh psn. ad v onr 1 ..
i
t i
t tl r
t
i r
i
,
4248 19)ca o o ie)selo Wk sn.As n 55US2921 20)
7 7 (95(tin mtd e a
,
it
t ;
s ii o v ui, 4 .. 0 2 (05
ln
t
,
( Th Cni t nte de n g eieo l e yn rsi ao igrn et mr
“ ]e ost i i l os o i r t ai r i e tn v d t s ro o
[
tuo sf
t v s
bt t e
in af
e
av s cn t n ocn n mn” it n mtd. S n n a n i“os ocn r
de e odi s f of e e. ca o o ie) t d gl e t de n of a
r
io
i
t (ti
t ) a i o,
t e
l e yn rsi f eo fo te odin o dg e f of e e od al cn m a d
i r i e tnr d mr mh cn t s r er ocn n mn r n i o e pt
bt t e
e
io
e
i
t i ry t l e
b a r o sn ne L F u, 04 W 1318a* selo ad , 1 USa40
y psn e ec ” al r 21 L 263 t 3 e a Sn n 55 ..t 8
i
t .
e
,
;
s
i

4 OI I NA DO D R
– PNO N R E

(x a igh teDePoe C ue cn r nl e yn rsi f eo fo st ain
epi nta h u rcs l s “of s oi r i e t nr d mr mt e c o
ln
t
s a
e
bt t e
e
a t
tknw h tec m a sn ne moe ”(tin mtd( t n qot nm k
ae i i h[ i i l e eci psd ca o o ie)i e a u a o a s
tn
r n] t
. it
t
n r l ti
r
o ie) “ A ln ate odin o dg e f of e e t w cte r oei
mtd. [ ] og s h cn t s r er ocn n mn o h hh psn s
t )
s
io
e
i
t
i
i r
sb c dsw h te e eci psd pni ..h Dercs C ue os oii e
u e ei i i h sn ne moe uo h m.te u Poe l s de n nt l
jt
tn
t
s a
t sf
sb cai m e t a mnb psn u ot sou cl v s h”Capl 76F dt
u e nn a ’ r t e y r o a hri tjdi oei t hpe , 0 . a
jt
ts e
t
i
t ie
i a r g.
l
3
16 (u ig o ay v Hy e 47US2622 17)
03 qo n Mn ne. a ms, 2 .. 3 4 (96.
t
t
,
)
A r oe srn et am x m m eut fci oa r o w hmr bres m
psn ’t s r o ai u scr yal y r psn i o udno e
i r af
i
it
i
t
e
cn t ni “i ite o m l ms rag o cs d”h at emy moe n n i e
odi ss w h h nr a i i orne f u oyta st ai ps ad o t l
io
tn
l t
t
t a
t sf
a u poe v lin Sn na48ca o o ie) T ss o eas eei“fi oe
de rcs i a o ad , 7 (tin mtd h is bcue vnfl en n
s ot .
i t
it
t . i
i
psnsmc mr d areb ta i ao e” uhi u s ne d n te s vs
r oi uh o i g a e hn n n h, sc c c m acs o o h me e
i
e s e l
tr
r t
t
l
i pc e Fu en A e mnl e y n rs Mah m.Fn 47US2525 17)
m ia a or e h mn e i r i e t ecu v ao, 2 .. 1 2 (96
l t
t t
d t b t t e.
,
( T n e b weist in..r mdfr v i y fesn ad f nno e omr
“r s r e enni t s. a ae o a a e oraos n o eiv v n o
a fs t
tuo
e
rt
t
l
e
taifr e p dt n at wa wu [ bss vist in scr y r h s e ad
hnno md r ii s s o h o d] e e e ni t a eut ote a t n
e co
t l
t r
tuo l
i
fy
w f e fhi m e ) seloO m. Wk eoa 41US28 4-6 18)ao ig
e a ote n a. ; e a l v a nkn, 6 .. 3 254 (93(dp n
lr
t”
s i
i
,
t
Mah m frn r a t n e ad x a igh “n n a hs oui ae xe a o..
ecu oi et er s r n epi nta a i m e a njsfb epct n.
t st a f s
ln
t
t
til
ti
tah wl ena e tdn n p t urSt” S ma y e pr y lc mni
h e i bic c a i ay ai l t e. i i r , mo r p e e n
t
l
r re
rc a a )
ll t
a a
t
a m irie ergin os oi e cni t a u poe v lin My.B di
d i s a v sg a o de n t l ost e de rcs i a o a v a w
nt t
et
t sf tu
s ot .
l n,
19F d 5 55 9 C. 97
0 . 57 6 ( h i 19)
3 ,
t r
.
H eud Mah m,ad , i , nMy,tslata M To a o’ ci s
e , ne ecu Sn nO m ada ii c rh r h ms n l m
r
r
i l
e
t .
s s a
gonei h p c mni a m irie ergin nt n et F r a o o s n n
ruddni l e e n d i s a v sg a o adr s ro l i d n,t d g
s a
t
nt t
et
af
od
t ai
a n r eo hlv oa ost in de rcs v lin Acr n y D edn a
l e i t teee f cni t a u poe i a o cod g , e na sr
o,s
l
tuo l
s ot .
il
f
t e
e ietjd mna amtr fa o Ci I n htertate v l e M
nt doug e s ae ol w n l m o te hoyh hyi a d r
tl
t
t
a
t
ot
.

5 OI I NA DO D R
– PNO N R E

To a o’ Fu en A ed e poeu lde rcsr h s m y ylc gi i
h ms n or e h mn mn rcdr u poe i t i p b p i h mn
s s t t
t
a
s gs l
an
a m irie ergin ntet n eigi t F r a
d i s a v sg a o adhnr s r n h mo l i .
nt t
et
a fr
od
B S t Ce e L e y n rs
. t e ra d i r It e s
a- t
bt e t
Ud c t ni u s ne stsmyraeie y n rs taa e ie t
ne e a c c m acs t e a c t l r i e t h r nt d o
r ri r t , a
e
b t t e s t e tl
po c o bteDePoe C ue Sn n 55USt 8-4 St c a die yn rs
r ein yh u rcs l s ad , 1 .. 438 t e r t l r i e t
tt
s a .
i
a
. a- e e bt t es
as wetet ei psstp aadinia h dh oten a i r a otte
r e hnh st “ moe a i l n s i cn a s p nhi m enet noh
i
a
yc
gf t r i
t
li
od ayn dn o psni. I a44 I sc css h DePoe C ueeu e
r n ic e s f r ol e d t 8 n uh ae te u rcs l srq rs
ir i t
i
f” .
.
,
s a
i
“ i m m rcdrs.tisrtatet e ra dihi n abr i arg e ”
m i u poeu ..onu h h st c t r ts o r t r y boa d
n
e
e t
a- e e g
t i al
t.
Mah m, 7 USa26ca o o ie) n ra qot n m k o ie)
ecu 42 ..t 2 (tin mtd( t n u a o a s mtd
it
t i e l ti
r
t .
“Th es oig s nad o d e m i we ea r o h dhpstp aad
[]e i n s l t d fr e r i n h h psn a sii a i l n
r
ne a r
t ng t r i
r
yc
s nia adh aa s . .eu e cs b cs fc b fccn d a o ” hpe , 0
i i cn nta n y s . rq rs ae y ae a ya os e t n Capl 76
gf t
t li
i
, t
t i ri .
l
F dt 04ca o o ie)i en qot nm k o ie) Tee fcss n a
. a16 (tin mtd( t a u a o a s mtd hts oue o “n
3
it
t
n r l ti
r
t .
t
ea ia o ote adh cue bte r o’ caegd c o r a vtte a c
x m t n fh h s p asd yh psn hlne ainet eoh bs
ni
r i
i s l
t
li
i
cn t n ol e s psn. Mce v Dp k, 5F d 1 52 9 C. 96( t n
odi s fi a a r oe” i hl. un 7 . 57 2 ( h i 19)i e a
io
f
i r t l
i
3 ,
t r
nr l
qot nm k o ie)
u a o a s mtd
ti
r
t .
TeN t C c t aie iidh em k sbsd nad , o d e m igwe e
h i h i u hsdnf etr a e, ae oSn n fr e r i n h h
n ri
t
e rr
i
t n
tr
a adh i a p aadinia i r aotte r n yn dn o psni.
h s pst i l n s i cn net noh od a ic e s f r ol e
r i
yc
g f t li
ir i t
i
f
Capl 76F dt 04Fs cus os e“ h h te odin ocn n mn
hpe , 0 . a16 it or cn d we e h cn t s f of e e
l
3
. r, t
ir
tr
io
i
t
mrrdhs cn t ni psd pnn a sn n oosic t n y of e e
i o toe odi s moe uoi m ei aa gu d ri a cn n mn
r e
io
t
l
s eo r
i
t
st g ”I a16-5i en qot nm k o ie) T ssy cl aa - tn v
ei s d t 046 ( t a u a o a s mtd h itp a y fci es e
tn . .
n r l ti
r
t . i
il
tn i
iq rtarq rs bd oe dne o e o mh c ma t e n y s Se ad n 55
nu yh eu e a oy f v ect p fr te o p a v aa s. e Sn i, 1
i
t i
i
r
ri
li
l
USa458 (odc n aa - tn v aa s s o p ighi m eis e n o s e
..t 8-6cnuig fci es e n y i c ma nten a sn d ad ui
t
tn i
l
r
t
i
td
te hlne cn t n. Sc dcusokth “u t n ni es y fh cn t n
h caegd odi s e n or lo ate dri adn nt ote odi s
l
io ) o , t
ao
t i
io

6 OI I NA DO D R
– PNO N R E

ocn n mn”Capl 76F dt 05 T r telo a we ete hnen
f of e e. hpe , 0 . a16 h d hyokt h h h cagi
i
t
l
3
. i,
tr
cn n mn wu “ e tb a e te u t n fte r oe ssn ne I
of e e o di va yf c h dri o[ psn ’ e ec ” d
i
t l n i l ft
ao
h i r] t . .
M To a o agetatei m acs u on n h p c mni
r h ms nrush h c cu s ne sr ud gi l e e n
.
s
t
r
t
r i s a
t
a m irie erginha n adrn et F r aw ea p aad asd s nia
d i s a v sg a o e ig nt s ro l i e t i l n cue ai i cn
nt t
et , r ,
af
od r y c
gf t
h dh i r a otte r n yn dn o psni.A aeu, eas h ws o
a s pnet noh od a ic e s f r ol e s rs tbcue e a n
r i
li
ir i t
i
f
l
t
a odd o e u poe, erusD edn’ c osid e h st c a die y
f re s m de rcs h age e na sain h e di t e r t l r
f
s
f
t t
n r s a- e e bt
i e s adi a d fi DePoe R h. A epie b o, f dh M To a o
n r t n v l e o h u rcs i t s x a d e wIi ta r h ms n
t es
ot
s
s gs
ln l
n t .
s
hsaet so h s yn d i s a v sg gin nt n et F r anoe at e
afldo h wi t i a m irie er a o adr s ro l i ivkd st
i
sa
nt t
et
af
od
ac a die yn rsrq r g o e u poes Asc h ws oe iet s m de
r t l r i e teui s m de rcs s uh e a n nt do o e u
e e bt t e
in
.
,
t tl
poe b o toe c os cu e Acr n y D edn a e iet s m ay
rcs e r hs ain ocr d cod g, e na sr nt do u m
s fe
t
r.
il f
t e tl
r
jd mno Ci I netehoyh te vl e D edns u poe r h bsd n
ug e n l m ud hterta hyia d e na ’ de rcs i t ae o
t
a
r
t
ot
f
t
s gs
at e ra die yn rs
st c t l r i e t
a - e e b t t e.
1 A ii rt eSgea o
. dmnta v ergt n
s i
i
I gn a “d i s a v sg ginn n oi e de n i pc e po c d
n ee l a m irie er a oi ad ft l os o m ia a r e e
r,
nt t
et
sf
t l t
tt
l e yn rs” e ao.Fac , 4 F d 0117 ( hC. 03 Fr x m ea
i r i e t Sr n v rn s 35 . 17 08 9 i 20) oea p,
b t t e. r
i
3
,
t r
.
l
r a v y r ftynic l ay ergin os o ii e,noe l e yn rs
et e b es i d i i r sg a o de n,nt l ivk ai r i e t
li l i a
s pn
et
t sf
b t t e.
Sn n 55USa46epi ntaa 0dyt d n ivk aie yn rs; e a o
ad , 1 ..t 8 (x a igh 3-a syi o noe l r i e t sel
i
ln
t
a d t
b t t e)
s
R hrsn.Rne , 9 F d 6 62 9 C. 00(x a igh fte dy o
i ado v un s 54 . 66 7 ( h i 21)epi nta i en as f
c
l
3 ,
t r
ln
tf
sg gini n cni t a a p aadinia h dh i r a o t te r n y
er a o d o ost e nt i l n s i cn a s p net n o h od a
et
d t tu
yc
gf t r i
li
ir
ic e s f r ol e B aid i t drinns a o oanr a y a h odin
n dn o psni ) u nne ne u t iio t n r bo ml h s cn t s
i t
i
f. t
fi
ao
li
l r
io
my as a a p aadinia h dh. Se Wk sn 55USa24 Ide
a cue nt i l n s i cn a s p e ii o, 4 ..t 2 ned
yc
gf t r i
ln
.
,

7 OI I NA DO D R
– PNO N R E

cn t nta wu o e w ei a teE h A ed e wu i ps a a p aad
odi sh o dt ri v l eh i t mn mn o d moe nt i l n
io
t l h s ot
gh
t l
yc
s nia h dh . Kea v H l 8 F d 0318 ( hC. 96
i i cn a s p enn. a , 3 . 18 09 9 i 19)
gf t r i1
l
3
,
t r
.
I L F u, oea p,h Cu h dh ai m ewows osd n d i s a v
n al r fr x m e i or e ta nn a h a hue i a m irie
e
l ts
t l t
t
nt t
sg gin o 8 dy w hua e ig wihi a d nO gneut nd n
er a o fr 6 as i o ha n hc v l e a r o rg a o i o
et
t t
r ,
ot
e
li , d t
ep ine ntp aadinia h dh c ma d o h od ay n dn o h l en
xe ec a a i l n s i cn a s p o p e t te r n ic e s f i i i
r
yc
gf t r i
r
ir i t
sf
psn 21 W 1318a* JdeS mn ae h h d g nhfc ta M LF u s
r o 04 L 263 t 5 ug i o bsd i o i otea sh r al r
i .
, .
s ln
t t .
e’
sg ginws oid i t adh cn t n o h s yn d i s a v sg ginw e
er a o a n ne ne nte odi s fi t i a m irie er a o e
et
t fi
io
sa
nt t
et
r
r a v y o m.I
et e nr a d
li l
l .
S ma yh e M To a o hs oaee fc fo w c oe o d oc d h
i i r, e, r h ms n a n l gda sr m h h n cu cn uei
ll r .
s
tl
t
i
l
l
s
p c mni a m irie ergin ost e a a p aadinia h dh, uh
l e e n d i s a v sg a o cni td nt i l n s i cn a s psc
a
t
nt t
et
tu
yc
gf t r i
taiivkd st c a di r i e s Ud teit hpe fc r M To a o
h tnoe at e r t l e yn r t ne hfsCapl a o r h ms n
t
a - e e bt t e.
r
r
l t, .
s
hs ostda so ugs te c acn t ni a m irie erginw en l a e
a n t e fc t sge h a u odi s n d i s a v sg a o e i o rb
ta
t
t
t l io
nt t
et
r te l
c ma doh od ay odin o psni. Ud te eodhpe fc r h
o p ette r n cn t s f r ol e ne h scnCapl a o te
r
ir
io
i
f
r
l t,
drinwset e so. H wsn ot y of e e fr 8 as w cir a v y
ut
a o ar a v y hr e ai s i r cn n mn o 2 dy h hset e
li l
t
la
i
t
, i
li l
so ad oln eog bi e tivk aie yn rs F a yud teh da o
hr n n og nuh yt l onoe l r i e t i l, ne ht r fc r
t
t
sf
b t t e. nl
r
i
t,
te i n e dneo h wh M To a o’ p c mni a m irie ergin
h es o v ect so t t r h ms n l e e n d i s a v sg a o
r
i
a .
s s a
t
nt t
et
e eddhln h fiic c a o Acr n y D edn a e iet s m ay
x neteeg o h na e t n cod g, e na sr nt do u m
t
t
s r ri .
il f
t e tl
r

1

I m esieo ee c sgeig h te odint w c i m ei s i r cn n mna sb c d
a snt t rsa h ugs n ta h cn t so h h n a sn ot y of e e r u e e
iv
r
t
t
io
i
t
la
i
t e jt
o e lat poon pyh o c p ifrhi m ead s uh h ue f ot y of e e i e my
f nedo rfud sco g a el oten a, n asc te s os i r cn n mn t l a
t
l il r
t
,
la
i
t sf
i pc e nE h A ed e v linSeR z.Txs 17S C 14 (07(ry,.d sn n) a s
m ia a i t mn mn i a o e u v ea, 3 . t 26 21) B e J i e ig Dv
l t
gh
t ot .
i
.
er , s t ; i
v Aa , 3 S C 28 (05( end J cnuig( su ig [ h h mno wog b e edde m
. y a 15 . t 17 21) Kney . ocr n) d cs n “]e u a t l ruh y x net s
l
.
,,
r
i s
t
l
t
t
r
oiot n ;A xKz s, o eTa Da 15Y eL. ou 20213 (06( cu igee c
fs a o” l o nk Wr hn e h, 2 a . Fr m 3 3-3 21)r on n rsa h
li ) e
i i s
t
l J
,
e t
r
rg d ghi pc s i r cn n mn hs n r oe ad o n “ so d o e s o upsta
ea i te ma s ot y of e e a o psn s n n igi hu c m a n srr eh
rn
t la
i
t
i r
t
t l
i
t
‘ c c a o i s i r cue ] ee eaebin reu ec o p e s ni ns ote pe ac oa
i a e t nn ot y as ssv e xc a o or r ne f r xt gl e, rh apa ne f n
n r ri
la
[
r
rt
cr
e ii l s
r
au mnll e iid iu swo a p v u y enre f n sc i ns ”ca o o ie) B t ss
c e e ai ns nn v a h hd r i s be f oay uhl e ’(tin mtd. u h i
t
t l s
idl
e ol
e
l s it
t ) ti
n tea otead Se Wk sn.As n 55USa242 (o ntaln- r s i r cn n mn
o hl w fhln e ii o v ui, 4 ..t 2-5 n igh og e m ot y of e e
t
.
ln
t
t
t
t
la
i
t
i e i n ucni t n ) e a oH t v F ny 47US6865 17)epi ntas i r
t l s o nost i a; el u o. i e, 3 .. 7 8 (98(x a igh ot y
sf t
tuo l s s t
n
,
ln
t la
cn n mn w l afr o pn h e sb ct s u n ud E h A ed e s nad ”s oi e
of e e , he “o m f u s mn u e o c t y ne i t mn mn t d s i n t l
i
t i
i
t j t ri
r gh
t a r,
t sf
ucni t n )
nost i a.
tuo l

8 OI I NA DO D R
– PNO N R E

jd mno tel mh p t g M To a oi a m irie ergin o 2 dy
ug e n h ci ta ui r h ms nn d i s a v sg a o fr 8 as
t
a
t tn .
s
nt t
et
w hua e igi a di poeu l u poe r h ud teFu en A ed e .
i o ha n v l e h rcdr de rcs i t ne h or e h mn mn
t t
r
ot s
a
s gs
r
t t
t
2 Ha n
. er g
i
M To a o agetate e ig e c vdw li a m irie ergin
r h ms nrush h ha n hree e hen d i s a v sg a o
.
s
t
r
i
i
nt t
et
wsndqa. B, eas M To a o ws o e iet de rcsfri b es yn
aiaeu e u bcue r h ms n a n nt do u poe o h r ft i
t
t
.
s
t tl
s
si a
a m irie ergina epie aoeh ws oe iet a e r gtl Tu
d i s a v sg a o s x a d bv e a n nt do h a n aa. hs
nt t
et ,
ln
,
t tl
i
l
,
a m irie r rcdr e o tah aee ocr dt h ha n cnos v ate
d i s a v o poeu lr r h el gs cu e ate e ig an e e sh
nt t
a rs t l
r
r
t r
bs fr v lin fh Fu en A ed e ’ DePoe C ue
a s oai a o ote or e h mn mns u rcs l s
i
ot
t t
t
s a .
Ee i M To a o hd h w ta hs odini a m irie ergin
vnf r h ms n a so n h i cn t sn d i s a v sg a o
.
s
t
io
nt t
et
cni td ntp aadinia h dh, ntui pc e a r e el e yn rs
ost e a a i l n s i cn a s padhs m ia d po c di r i e t
tu
yc
gf t r i
l t
t t b t t e,
h hsaet so h ws oa odd h m i a de rcsrq rd u n h
e afldo h w e a n f re te i m u poe eu e dr g i
i
tf
n l
s i
i s
a m irie ergin e ig “ Du poe rq rs rcdr po c os eo a
d i s a v sg a o ha n [ ]e rcs eu e poeu l r ein b r
nt t
et
r .
s i
a tt
fe
psnn a cn e er e oa r e el e yn rs” ue n ne, Ms Cr Is
r oi m e a b dp vd f po c di r i e t Spr t dn a. o. n.
i
t
i
t t b t t e.
ie t
s r t
,
W p e.Hl, 7 US4543 18)B oi a mso y p o dten a w h
a o v i 42 .. 4 5 (95 u f cl u n “ rv ehi m e i
ll
l
,
. t fi s t l
i
t t
s m n ie fh cags g n h m n a opr n yo rsnh v wtte r o
o e oc ote h e aa s i ad n po u tt p e i i soh psn
t
r
it
ti
e t s e
i
oi acagd Bue.Yt 31F d 2318 ( hC. 03(tin mtd( t n
f cl h e ” rc v i , 5 . 18 27 9 i 20)ca o o ie)i e a
fi
r .
s
3
,
t r
it
t
nr l
qot nm k o ie) I adinoi a mshv “o e v ec”o uprte
u a o a s mtd. n d t , f cl u ae s m e dnet spo h r
ti
r
t )
i o fi s t
i
t i
ud l n dcinomv ai m en a m irie ergin Hl 42US t 5-6
ne y g e s t oe nn a i o d i s a v sg a o i , 7 .. 455
ri
io
t t
nt t
et . l
a
( Thr ea qeinswe ete i ay v eciteeodh cu spo te
“ ]ee vn us oi h h h es n e dnenhrcrta o d upr h
[
l t t
tr r
i
t l
t
cn u o ”
oc s n)
l i ..
M To a o age h ws opo ddwi m i ade rcs bcue n h
r h ms nrus e a n rv e
.
s
t i
t i m u poe eas ao e
h n l
s
tr
i m e n m wswt n n i n ie f e ig A aeu, erus ews nb t
n a ’ a e a rt o h oc o ha n s rs th age h a ua e o
ts
ie
s t
r .
l
l
p snfc o m e a w nset poeiincne D edn cnee h mtk
r e a s r a rl i e so rv h noec e na s ocdt s i ae
e t t
ti t s
s
. f
t
i s

9 OI I NA DO D R
– PNO N R E

ocr db te sttero wsie oteeodth ha n M To a o age
cu e u hyt eh e r af d nh rcr ate e ig r h ms nrus
r, t
a
r
x
r . .
s
tai n tu Rg d s ayorp c e o bi e i n a ui e aea o fr de
h s o re ea l s tpg h a r r yt l s o sf c n l gin oa u
t t .
r e,
a il r
sf t
fi t l t
poe v lin M To a o de n aee ed n aedh han otah d n
rcs i a o r h ms n os o l g h i o t nte e i rh ei o
s ot . .
s
tl
d tt
rg
t
d t
rc v ay oc oteesn frisg gin Mrf d mnl, e os oaee
ee e n n ie fhraos o h er a o
i
t
s e t . o u a e a yh de n l g
en
tl
tl
tahtog te e ig ocws oi edd o h mtl ad e os oepi wy e
h ehuh h ha n n iea n n ne fri aa, n h de n x a h h
t
t
r
t
tt
l
t ln
ws nb t p snha n oi a w h fc o w nseate e ig
a ua eo r e e ig f cl i a s r i e s h ha n
l
e t r
fi s t
t
t s t
r .
D edn hv a o rv e s m e dn eo uprte dcinolc M
e na s ael po dd o e v e ct spo h r e s t p e r
f
t
s
i
i
t i io
a
.
To a oi o d i s a v sg gin—ewste u e oaivt a oi o psn
h ms nn a m irie er a o h a h sb c f nnei t nn a r o
s t
nt t
et
jt
s gi t
i
gn’ cnp ayo ae s f m meate r o a a td Rg d s o we e h
ag os rct hv at f e b th psn s ue ea l s f h h i
s
i
a
r
i
sl .
re
tr s
p tia oi p no sa t s f m me wsreh aeeiv v mni a os rc
ai pinnl t a u at f e b atu i l gdno e e n cnp ay
rc t
a
sl a
r
, sl
l
t
i
i “o e v ec” o uprte lc mn Tu M To a o hsae t so fc
s s m e dnet spo h p e e . hs r h ms n afld o h wa s
i
t
a
t
, .
s
i
t
fo w c auy o did ews oa odd m i a de rcs ah a m irie
r m h h jr cu f h a n f re i m u poe ti d i s a v
i
l n
tf
n l
s s
nt t
sg gin e igso d e ae en nt d o u poe aa. Acr n y D edn
er a o ha n hu h hv be e ie t de rcs tl cod g, e na s
et
r , l
tl
s l
il f
t
a e iet s m ayug e otehoyh te fldofod M To a o de
r nt do u m jd mn nhterta hyaet a r r h ms n u
e tl
r
t
t
i
f
.
s
poe wete gv h m n ie f ha ntan md n h i m e
rcs hnhy aei a oc o a e igh a e ao e n a.
s
t
r
t
tr
t
3 Tas r oF rd
. r n et l i a
f
o
F a y M To a o aee h iv u ayrn et F r a ost e a
i l , r h ms nl gsi no n rt s ro l i cni td
nl .
s l
s lt
af
od
tu
dp vin fi poeu l u poe r h. Se f a y M To a o age h ws
er a o o h rcdr de rcs i t pci l, r h ms nrus e a
it
s
a
s gs
i cl .
s
e iet a r t n e ha n bfr h ws e t F r a
nt do p - as r e ig eo e asn o l i .
tl
er f
r
e
t
od
Bcue M To a o ws oe iet a r t n e ha n ud teDePoe
eas r h ms n a n nt do p - as r e ig ne h u rcs
.
s
t tl
er f
r
r
s
C uete, s x a e aoe h ci cno y rcei h ws nt do u poe
l si l a epi d bv t sl m a n poedf e a e iet de rcs
a
sf
ln
,i a
l
tl
s
bsd n st c a die yn rs Se ad 55USa438 selo Wk sn 55
ae o at e r t l r i e t e Sn n 1 ..t 8-4 e a
a - e e b t t e.
i
;
s ii o, 4
ln
USa212 Ide a huh n e, M To a sn pe sol g tah cn t n o
..t 2-2 ned l og uc a r h m so apa t aee h i odi s f
.
,t
lr .
r
l
t s io

1 –OI I NA DO D R
0 PNO N R E

cn n mni F r a ost e ntp aadinia h dh i c masno r n y
of e e n l i cni t a a i l n s i cn a s pn o p iot od a
i
t
od
tu
yc
gf t r i
r
ir
ic e s f r ol eadhs hy m ia a r e el e yn rs Se f a y M
n dn o psni, ntu tei pce po c di r i ee. pci l, r
i t
i
f
,
l t
t t bt t t
i cl .
To a o agetah ws osdn ee l out nnO gnb i F r a e a
h ms nrush e a huei gn a pp a oi r o u n l i h hs
s
t
r
li
e , t
od
be a indo nl gd sp mx psn we h sed 2 hus dyn ot y
en s get a aee “ue a” r o h e e pns 3 or a ai s i r
s
l
r
i , r
la
iot n M To a o aeet s odi oic c a o hs en moe fr n
s a o r h ms nl gsh cn t n fna e t n a bei psd o a
li . .
s l
i
io
r ri
id i t p id fi ead erusts a h admrrsiiehnwaa O gn
ne ne e o ot m n h ageii h se n o ert ta h n r o
fi r
,
r r
e tcv
t
e
i m e o d e xe et edr Fr e m eh aee h p id f of e e ws
n a cu b epc do nu. u h o, el gsi e o ocn n mn a
t l
t
e tr r
l
s r
i
t
e edd pnit n et F r a
x ne uo h r s ro l i .
t
s af
od
Te pciter ud w c M To a o bssi ci i uc a Fr x m e
h se f hoy ne h h r h ms n ae h l ms n e. oea p,
ic
r i
.
s
s a
lr
l
h my e ru gh h cn t n ocn n mni F r ar h sei c masnoh
e a b ag nta i odi s f of e e n l i a a h n o p iotte
i
t s io
i
t
od e r r
r
cn t n ocn n mntao ei m ei F r a xe ec Taci,nte, o d
odi s f of e e h t rn a sn l i ep ine h l m i l cu
io
i
t t h
t
od
r . t a i sf l
n b md aa spsn f cli O gnh wv, easte a n rsos lfr
o e ae g n r o oi a n r o o ee bcuehyr o epn b o
t
it i
fi s
e ,
r
e t
ie
M To a o’ cn t n ocn n mni F r a nete n r a Cr c osC ma.
r h ms n odi s f of e e n lo d ud hI et e o ein o pc
.
s s io
i
t
i
r
t st
rt
t
Se e St§ 2 25 21) I o e wrsso di cn t n ocn n mni F r a
e Rv t. 41 4 (04 nt r od hu h odi s f of e e n l i
. a
.
.
h
, l s io
i
t
od
v l ei cni t n r h, emsb n al m g n te rp oi a i F r a
i a h ost i a i t h u r g c i aa s h poe f cl n l i .
ot s t u o l g s
ti
a
it
r fi s
od
Sl M To a o cu p u b ci t ah ws nt do o e u poe
tl r h ms n o d l s l l mht e a e iet s m de rcs
i, .
s
l ai y a
tl
s
b o h t n et F r a netehoyh D edn ke h wu ep ine
e r i r s ro l i ud hterta e na s n w e o d xe ec
fe s af
od
r
t f
t
l
r
cn t n ocn n mnte tacni t a a p aadi i cnh dh i
odi s f of e e h eh ost e nt i l n s nia a s pn
io
i
t r t tu
yc
gf t r i
c masnoi cn t n ocn n mni O gn Ide t ssh ci M To a o
o p iot h odi s f of e e n r o ned h itel m r h ms n
r
s io
i
t
e .
,i
a
.
s
se s omki h A eddC m anad pot no u m yug e .
e mt ae n i mne o p i n opsi t s m a jd mn
s
l t
io
r
t
I od t d e m ewe e M To a o’t n ei psd ntp aad
n re o e r i h h r h m sn r s r moe a a i l n
r
t n
tr .
s s af
yc
s nia h dh o h mnet n o h od ayn dn o psni tah ep ine
i i cn a s p ni i r a ot te r nric e s f r ol eh e xe ecd
gf t r i
li
i
i t
i
f t
r
i O gnImsap te h ea o ao ei Capl Teita orq rsmt
nr o
e , u p yhtr fc r dp dn hpe . hfsfc reu e e o
t l
e ts t
l
r t
i

1 –OI I NA DO D R
1 PNO N R E

d e m ewe ete odin os i riot nnF r amrrh cn t ni psd
e r i h h h cn t s f ot ys a oi l i i ote odi s moe
t n
tr
io
la
li
od r
io
uoi m ei aa gust g T b sr,ts n e h w algust g”r
pnn a sn n oos ei s o e u ii uc a o “noos ei s a
t
l
tn .
e
lr
a
tn
e
d ie ud t se. Se f a y ts oc a we eI hu lo as mast g o
e nd ne h ts pci l , i n l r h h so dokti i r ei s f
f
ri t
ic l i
t e
tr
l
l tn
s i r cn n mni F r a r i i r eigi O gnI o onet as et s
ot y of e e n l i o s mast sn r o d n edo n w h
la
i
t
od
l tn
e .
t
ri
qeinh wv, eas M To a o hsae t aeea s h w gh h cn t n
us o o ee bcue r h ms n afldol gfc soi ta i odi s
t ,
r
.
s
i
l
t
n t s io
ocn n mna a p a ad oe s nia h dh ud e h sea o
f of e e r t i l n ps ai i cn a s p ne i e cn i
i
t e yc
gf t r i
rtr
r.
M To a o mks oc sr a eiosh n psn i O gnwu b
r h ms n ae cn uoy s r nta o r oe n r o o d e
.
s
l
st
t
i r
e
l
sb c doh e r m y a h n rsiie odin tah ep inei F r a nta
u e ette x e e h s adert cn t s h e xe ecsn l i adh
jt
t l r
tcv
io
t
r
od
t
cn n mn ud C s Mng mnstssn alsf a oi O gn B toe
of e e ne l e aae e t ui o c si t nn r o u hs
i
t
r o
ta
t a i ci
e . t
cn uoy sein a n spo e w ha s Fr x m e M To a o d n ceo
oc sr a r osr o upr d i fc. oea p, r h ms ni o i t
l
st
e t
t t t
l .
s
d tt
O gnt u srg a oso p i e gv nnte s o nnue f ot ys a oi
r o st e eut n r oc s oe i gh ue r o-s os i riot nn
e
a t , li ,
li
r
la
li
O gn W l h my eee ot ys a o i n uei O gn h er s m y oa s
r o
e . he e a biv s i riot n s o sdn r o te a i p n fc
i
l
la
li
t
e , r e l
t
t sb a i eh bi. Tte x nt t e eeete odin ocn n mni
o us na ta ee oh e e h h bivsh cn t s f of e e n
t tt t l f
tt a
l
io
i
t
s i riot nnO gnrls rsiie r ee tate odini F r ah aa
ot ys a oi r o a e ert osv ehnh cn t sn l i , e g n
la
li
e
e s tcv
r
io
od
i
fldol g aya souprtabi. Tte x n I hu c ma M To a o’
aet aee n fc t spo h ee oh e e so d o p e r h ms n
i
l
t
t t lf
tt
l
r .
s s
cn t n ocn n mni s i riot notepsn snF r ah hsaet
odi s f of e e n ot ys a ot o rr oe i l i , e afldo
io
i
t la
li
h i r
od
i
aee n fc t spo a ag mnta h isb c dotp acn t ni c masn
l g aya s o upr nru e h e s u e et a i l odi sn o p io
l
t
t
t t
jt
yc
io
r
t o e F r an a s A od g ,h er n fc t so ta M To a o’
ot r l i i m e c r n y e a oa so h w h r h ms n
h od
t. c i l t r e
t
t .
s s
cn t n ocn n mna a p ao h si c masnoh cn t ni aa gu
odi s f of e e r t i l r a hn o p iotte odi sn n oos
io
i
t e yc
r
r
io
l
st g
ei s
tn .
Ud te eodCaplfc rIokth drin ni es y f M
ne h scn hpe a o lo ate ut adn nt o r
r
l t,
ao
t i
.
To a o’ cn n mni s i riot no e r iewe ete a a p ao h s
h ms n of e e n ot ys a ot d e m
s s i
t la
li
t n h h hyr t i l r a h
tr
e yc
r.
M To a o age h s yn s i riot ns ehpid i t I rs mt smas
r h ms nrusi t i ot ys a oi p asne ne p u eh en
.
s
sa
la
li
r
f i. e
i

1 –OI I NA DO D R
2 PNO N R E

hi ua a oa a i w c h wl eeundo ee l out n M To a o a o
es n w e f d en h h e i brtret gn app a o r h ms nl
r
t
i
l
r
li . .
s s
stsh hiiotd o 2 hu a a I g ew h M Toa ota O gn r o
t eta ess a fr 3 or dy ar i r h msnh r o psn
a
t
le
s
.
e t .
s
t e
i
oi a my ae wdi s m de rcs bfrt n eigi t F r afhy n w
f cl a hv o e h m o e u poe eo r s r n h mo l i ite ke
fi s
s
e a fr
od
tah ws o go ene ne sb c do ot ys a o w huay u poe i
h e a g nt bid i t y u e et s i riot n i o n de rcs n
t
i
f il j t
la
li
t t
s
F r a B te i n e dneo uprali taoi a i O gn n w r hu hv
l i . u h es o v ect spo c mh f cl n r o ke oso d ae
od
t r
i
t a
t fi s
e
l
ko nh M To a o’ C s Mng mnca i cinwu bid i t o w hu
n wta r h ms n l e aae e lsf a o o d ene ne r i o
t .
s s o
t si t
l
fi
t t
s m de rcs a oddo M To a o
o e u poe f ret r h ms n
sf
.
s.
Ide a eh i po dd y M To a o so stesoe e o ce e o h
ned n x b rv e b r h ms n h w ala n p id rv w fi
it i
.
s
t
r i i
s
c sf a oi C s Mng mnhs cu e s c h aiei F r a Te e o c
l si t nn l e aae e a ocr di e er vdn l i . h p id
a i ci
o
t
r n
r
od
r i
rv w we h wsl wdo rsne dneo h bh focr d bus mn sf r
e e, h e e a a o et p e v ec ni ea, cu e ao i o h a e
i
r
l
e t i
s l
r
t x t t
h aiei F r a T s v ec cn a c h a einh h s yn ot ys a oi
er vdn l i . h e dne o rdt i s r ota i t i s i r iot ns
r
od
i i
t i s s st
t sa
la
li
id i t bcuet h w h h s ys c ay ne p id rv w
ne ne easisos a i t i a ul ud e o ce e.
fi
tt s a
tl
r r i i
F a yatteh d hpe fc r M To a o ci sir es d e a be
i l , soht r Capl a o r h ms nl m h e ae a hs en
nl
i
l t, .
s a
sl
t
e eddic h t n et F rd adhs ht n ea e ete u t n fisn ne
x ne s ei r s ro l ia ntu ter s rf c dh dri o h e ec
t
n s af
o ,
,
a f ft
ao
s t .
T spo h ci, M To a o p n t a oue fo te r oi F r ah sts
o upr i l m r h ms n o t o dc mn r mh psnn l i ta t e
t s a
.
s
is
t
i
od t a
h r es d esFbu y 823 D edn ageh h r es dt hs ocagd n
i e ae a i era 2 09 e na sruta i e ae ae a n hne ad
sl
t
r ,
. f
t
t sl
t
te aahd dc rinr mh P iy M ae oteOie fO ed Ifr a o ad
hyt ce a e a t fo te oc a g fh f c o f ne no min n
t
l ao
l
n r
f
f r
t
Sn neC mut n wot e ta M To a o’r es d ee a s ue 823
e ec o p a o h sts h r h ms n e ae a r m nJn 2 06
t
ti ,
a
t .
s sl
t
i
, .
O gnRv e St e 41 4 w c gv n O eo’ p tia o ite n r a
r o e sd t u § 2 25 h h oe s r gn ai pin nhI et e
e
i
at
. , i
r
s rc t
t st
Cr c osC ma,t eta O gnwlm nijr dt n v M To a o frh
o ein o pc stsh r o i a t nus c o oe r h ms n ote
rt
t a
t e
l i a i ii
r .
s
proe oe e uigir es o poa o o p o, ri d cagfo cs d O
upss ff c a n h e ae n rbin r a l oh i h er m u oy r
ft t
sl
t
re
s s r
t . .
Rv St§ 2 25A. V usc 3 21) Asc O gns epn b fr e r i n
e t. 41 4 r I sbe (04 s uh r oirsos l o d e m ig
. a
.
t
.
.
, e
ie
t n
M To a o’r es d en F r a Tte x n F r a a m c c a dh d e ts
r h ms n e ae a, o lo d oh e e l i hs i a ut t s a, i
.
s sl
t t
i.
t t od
slle i t i

1 –OI I NA DO D R
3 PNO N R E

n cn oigadhsauy o d ocn ue ae s e o a ou e fo F r ah
o o r l , ntu jr cu n oc d bsd ol n dc mn r m l i ta
t t ln
,
l t l
ly
t
od t
M To a o’r es d e a be e edd s rs t fit n e
r h ms n e ae a hs en x ne a aeu o h r s r
.
s sl
t
t
l
s a f.
A erv w g h Caplfc r Iidh M To a o’t n et F r a
f re ei te hpe a o, f ta r h m sn r s ro l i
t
i n
l ts n t .
s s af
od
w hua r t n e ha n d n v l ei poeuade rcsr h ud te
i o p - as r e i gi o i a h rcdr u poe i t ne h
t t er f
r
d t ot s
l
s gs
r
Fu en A ed e bcue e a n so nhtht n eivkd st c a die y
or e h mn mn eas h hs o h wt ater s rnoe at e r t l r
t t
t
t
af
a- e e bt
i e s Acr n y D edn a e iet s m ayug e ot shoy fibi
n r t cod g, e na sr nt do u m jd mn nh ter ol it
t e.
il f
t e tl
r
t
i
aly
frCi I
o l m.
a
I
I
.

Acst teC u s
ce o h or
s
t

M To a o’scn ci i gonei h a einh h ic c a oi
r h ms n eodl ms ruddn i s r ota i na e t nn
.
s s
a
s st
t s r ri
F r as me n h cni t n r hoacst te or i O gn Se f a yh
l i ii pd gi ost i a i t f ce o h cus n r o pci l , e
od
i s tuo l g
s
t
e .
i cl
age h ws nb t fe w c ici s n u n al m etdo l e21 s yn
rus e a ua eoi t oi ll m ic d g ci r a t aa -03t i
l
l
v a , li
a
le
t
a
d c l ay ergin ot et-w dy ad ci r ado rp tta wsm s g
i i i r sg a o fr wny o as n al met t poe yh a i i
s pn
et
t
a le
r
t
sn
a e h wse ae fo d c l ay ergin I adin M To a o ci s ews
f r e ar esdr mi i i r sg a o n d t , r h ms nl m h a
t
l
s pn
et .
io .
s a
ua eo b ct am in oe es n f i e n hba csta ws ed gnh
nb t o e o o o fr x n o o t m o a aes aeh a pn nit s
l
jt
t
t i
t
i
i
Cu. H age D edn a rsos lfrt si a o bcuehyi erc m edd
or erus e na sr epn b o h v lin easte e h eo mne
t
f
t e
ie
i ot
tr
h t n et F r a r easte d n efrel gd rvin ote n r a
i r s ro l i o bcuehyi o no aee po s s fhI et e
s af
od
d t
c l
io
t st
Cr c osC ma tah ci seu ete ed gni t n t esr h m nis ce
o ein o pc h el mrq rsh sn nist i
rt
t t
a
i
i
t u o o nu e a t n acs
e
ia
s
t neelg m e a iteee igni t n
o eddea a rl nhrc v ist i .
l ti s
i n tuo
D edn mvfr u m yug e o M .To a o’ acst-or ci o
e na s oe os m a jd mn n r h ms n ce - cusl m n
f
t
r
t
s s
so t a
sv agons Fs D edn ageh h hs ce t O gnea m e a. B
ee l rud it e na sruta e a acs o r olg a rl y
r
. r, f
t
t
s
e
l ti s
rg a o M To a o cn ekea m e a ad s s ner mn a lg a i a s
eut n r h ms n a selg a rl n a i acfo i m eea s s n
li , .
s
l tis
st
t
l st t
truh o epnec d e et air y or n oaayO gnDp t e o
hog cr sodnei c do l a cod a rt n r o ea mn f
r
rt
br
it
e
r t

1 –OI I NA DO D R
4 PNO N R E

Cr c osal y2 Acr n y hyt eh h cno h wa amt ol w h h ws
o einfci . cod g, e stta e an so, s ae fa, a e a
rt
it
ilt
a t
t
tr
tt
dn d ce tte or. Scn D edn ageh aa - necu n cn ueh
e e acs oh cus eod e na sruta fcf d o d o oc dta
i
s
t
, f
t
t ti r l t l
t
h sf rdhtp o p jd e ee ayot e n ce - -or ci. Se f a yh
e u e teye f r u c ncs rt st a acst cusl m pci l,i
fe
e i
s
a
so t a
i cl s
poe yl ms oteye fci t w c h r ht acs cust ce adi
rp t ci i n htp o l mo h hi i to ce or aahs n h
r a
t
a
i sg
s t t ,
s
ia l yo b ct a av s y rqe frx n o ot mi n sf c n y r u cl
nbi t o e o n de a ’ eus oe es n fi es o ui e l p jdi.
it
jt
rr s
t
t i
t fi t e i a
F a y D edn age M To a o cnoso tate cue h i uy easte
i l, e na sru r h ms n an h w h hy asdi n r bcueh e
nl f
t
.
s
t
t
sj
r
a n fc soighy a ayno e e w hh acstl r ym e a.I o e
r oa s h w te hd niv v mn i i ce oi a a rl nt r
e
t
n
l
t t s
s b r ti s
h
wrsh hs udh wog e na s
od e asete rn d edn.
,
f
t
M To a o ci s e a ae p d o izl wir yeor snO gno o
r h ms nl m h hst m e t utiea l a rsu ei r ot n
.
s a
t t
l
br
c
e
aa. Se f a yh sts e a “ rtnh O gnt e e tnaya l r ymn
vl pci l, et e h hs wt te r o st pnei l wi a ay
i
i cl
a
ie
e
a
i tr
br
t ms n hsi e g n rsos a e y rsos oaog e o ot m p tl
i e ad a e h o oepne d ae epne f ln p id fi e ai
tr t
, l d
r
, ra
dc mn ojsteae heoa ou e. Fr e h stsh h cnoc m e
ou e s ru hfc se f dc mn” u h, et eta e an o pt
t
t
t
t
tr
a
t
t
le
c m a tfri ci sw hute e oaeaa i a woskoldeb i O gn
o pi s o h l m i o h h p f lg s s n hi n w ga en r o
ln
s a
t t
l
l st t
e
l
e
l w F a yh a es h h cno“hp d ema nf lg m e a w huacst
a. i l, e s r ta e an sea i en gu ea a rl i o ce o
nl
st t
t
rz
i l l ti t t
s
te ok po ddnO gns ]a l r y Frhf l w gesn Iidhs
h bos rv ei r o [ cl wi a . ote o oi raos f tee
i
e
i
br ”
l n
, n
aea oso enui e t poeD edn v l e M To a o’ cni t n r h
l gint bisf c n o rv e na si a d r h ms n ost i a i t
l t
fi t
f
t ot
.
s s tuo l g
t acste or, ntu D edn a e iet s m ayug e o Ci I
o ce h cusadhs e na sr nt do u m jd mn n l mI
s
t
, f
t e tl
r
t
a .
Ic c a dn v u s ae fna e acni t n r ht acste or i
na e t id i a hv a ud mnl ost i a i to ce h cusn
r re i d l
t
tuo l g
s
t
od tlia teea t ote d e in r hlne h cn t n ote cn n mn
re oi g ehlgl y fh r e n o ocaegte odi s fh r of e e,
r t t
i
i tt
l
io
i
i
t
ad r o oi a cnoaie i e e w h h rt m s o rp eeadc mn. e
n psn f cl an c v yn r r i te ae p t p a lg ou e sSe
i
fi s
t t l tf e t i t t
er
l
t
2

Tee vnrg a o sts
hr ea eut nt e
l t li a :
O gnn a sr m u o stfcie( a adee l my ce O gnearsa h
r oi m efo o -ft ealisst n fd a a acs r olg ee c
e
t
t - a it t e
r)
s e
l
r
m e a ad s s ner m s gei m eea a i a shog cr sodnei c do
a rl n a i acfo a indn a lg s s n truh o epnec d e et
ti s
st
s
t
l st t
r
rt
air y or n o oa O gn o ein fci. Rqe s ol wir y ev efo
l a cod a r f n r o cr c oa al y eus fra l a s i sr m
br
it
e
r t l it
t
br r c
O gnn a sn u o st fcie wl e rcse whesnb diec
r o i m ei o -ft e alis i b poe d i raoa ei gne
e
t
t -a
it
l
s t
l l
.

O A m.R211903() 21)
r d i . 9-3-056(07
.
n
.

1 –OI I NA DO D R
5 PNO N R E

L w v Csy 58US333035 19) B “ psn y e ne n po d
ei . ae, 1 .. 4 5 5 (96 u a r o ss m ed o rv e
s
, ,
. t i
t
t i
mx m m r vn p m lv oacs ” Rd ge v Co , 6 F d 1617 ( hC.
a u oee o i a ee f ce. or uz. ok 19 . 17 19 9 i
i
t l l
s
i
3
,
t r
19) I m e mso y efoddhto “ aakh r e ecsd el oc l e l,
99 n a s u n b a reteo st t cte sn ne i c y r oa rl
.
t
t l
f
l ot
i t , rt
lt a y
adn ret caegte odin ote cn n mn”L w , 1 USa345 I
ni od o hlneh cn t s fh r of e e . ei 58 ..t 5-5 n
r
l
io
i
i
t
s
.
fc cuseon eh “] p r e oay hr i gig aat is m y n ote
a, or rcg zta [ ma mn f no e lia n cpc ysi p oe fh
t
t
i
ti i t
t
t t
i
l
ic e a(n p fc y ost in ) osqecs fovt n nic c a o ”I
n dnlad e el cni t a cneune ocn c o adna e t n d
i t
r t
tuo l
ii
r ri . .
Ai m e hln n h acstte or i a aiu ral yms poe e
nn a caeg gi ce oh cus n p t l fc t u rv h
t l i s
s
t
rc a i
i
t
sf rd n a u i uy w c rq rsi t “e os a ta[ s nnio ulg
u e a “c a n r ” h heu e h m o d mnr e h h] of v osea
fe
tl j , i
i
tt t i
r l
l
ci h s be fur e o ws e g mee” yh psn I a33selo oe v
l m a ] enrs a d r a b ni pdd bte r o d t 5 e a Jns.
a
[
tt
i
i . .
;
s
B ns 33F d 1 96 9 C. 04(oc n ghia l yoi a o pi o d ed
l a, 9 . 98 3 ( h i 20)cne i tenbi t fe c m a t r e n
a
3
,
t r
rn
it
l
ln
f
aa sa h g. Aa u t so taa nnio ulg ci hs enrs a dif a
g n ca e flr o h wh “of v osea l m a be fur e”sal
it
r)
i e
t
r l
l a
tt
t
tte ce t cu ci. ei, 33&..
oh acs o or l mL w a 5 n4
s
t a
st
Fr e ten a ms“e os a ta tel gd hr o igiteir y r
u h ,hi m e u d mnr eh h aee so c m snhl a o
tr
t
t
tt t
l
t n
br
lg a i ac por mid e h e oso u u aeaci. I a31 H myfr
ea s s ne rg h e di f r t pr e lg l m d t 5 e a o
l st
a n r s ft
s
l a ” .
.
,
ea p, h wh a o pi wsi m sd oflrt si y tcn arq r mnta
x m eso ta c m a t a d i e fr a u o as aeh c eu e e h
l
t
ln
s s
i e tf
il i
t t
h cu n hv ko n bu g ete e c n e ite r o’lg ai acfcie
e o d o ae n w ao,i nh d i ec s nh psn ea ss nealis
l t
t v
fi i
i s l st
it .
I S ma yh my h wh h ws s m d yiaeuc s fhl wir yt ee fe
d i i r, e a so ta e a “ y i b ndqa e otea l a ”o vni
. ll
t
t e
i
br
l
a o pi o a “ ga y c oa e a mtah sf rd I Ui al “ce t cu
c m a t n n a ub ainb h ”h e u e . d l m e, acs o or
ln
r l t
l r
t
fe” . t ty
s
t
ci s ruhaa spsn f cl msb jde w h te e rnarb c funr.
l m bog g n r o oi a u e ugd i i h d e tl ur oTre v
a
t it i
fi s t
tn
f ei
i
S e , 8 US7 8 (97 we ‘ psneut n m n n o i m e cni t n
al 42 .. 8 9 18) h ea r o rg a o i p g g n n a s ost i a
fy
,
, r
i
li
ii
t ’ tuo l
r h i viiiir snb r a do lgi a pn o c i e s’ Hre v Pe o
i t s a dftse oa yet t ae t m e eo g a n r t” apr. r m ,
gs l
a
l le
i t
l i l t e.
N 6 3 v007 O21 W 1030 a* (.O M. 821)o rcn dr inn
o : - -09-M, 04 L 397 t 7 D r a 2 04 n eos ea oi
. 1c
,
. r ,
,
i t
pr N 6 3C -09-M, 04 W 3161 D O Ag421) Acr n ya oc
a , o : - V007 O21 L 888 (. r u , 04 cod g, p iy
t . 1
. .
.
il
l

1 –OI I NA DO D R
6 PNO N R E

tacuei m et ep ine r a v y ht e ynee igh rea m e a i
h assn a so xe ec aet e s rd ai rc v te lg a rl s
t
t
r
li l o l
in i
l ti s
cni t nl acp b weiirinl r a d oe t m e eo g ai e s Sed
ost i a y ce a e hntsa oayet t lgi a pn o c n r t ei
tuo l
tl
t l le
i t
l i l t e.
.
H e M To a o’ df u y ce igO gna lg m e a de n r eo
e , r h ms n ii l acs n r ol wea a rl os o i t
r .
s s fct
s
e
l ti s
ts
teeeoa ost in v lin Te a r a doi m s g rp ti n oeetd
hlv f cni t a i a o h cs et t h i i p e ys o nr a
l
t u o l ot .
e le
s sn o r
t
le
t caeg gisn n n o o e w e hl g gi cn t n ocn n mn Sc a
o hln n h e ec g rt ri cae i h odi s f of e e . uh
l i s t i
h s ln n s i o
i
t
cs q t s m ya on t oe fhs ic e acneune ocn c o ad
ae uei p , mu s o n otoe n dnl osqecs f ovt n n
, i
l
t
i t
ii
ic c a o S ma yh c m a t bubn ua eo b ct aeusfr x n o o
na e t n i i r,i o pi ao e g nb t o e o rqe oe es n f
r ri .
ll s
ln
t i
l
jt
t
t i
t mi h hba cs de n cni t a i uyh r etteeeoa ost in
i eni aes ae os o ost e n n rta i sohlv f cni t a
s
t tu
j
ts
l
tuo l
v lin M To a o cu s lpru h hba pi o s te i n e dneh h
i a o r h ms n o d tl u ei aes et n o h es o v ecta i
ot . .
s
l i
s s
ti ,
r
i
t s
ci ws mee
l m ai pdd
a
.
Te n r m n gl gin e e o M To a o’ aea o tah ws nb
h o ye a i aea o cn r n r h ms n l gin h e a ua e
l
in l t
ts
.
s sl t
t
l
t fe ci frwah aee ws nl g cn n mni d c l a sg gin Sc a
oi al m o h el gs a aiea of e e ni i i r er a o uh
l
a
t l
l l i
t s pn y e t .
ci sudi a cn t n ocn n mn caeg frw c M To a o wu hv
l m onsn “odi s f of e e ” hlne o h h r h ms n o d ae
a
io
i
t l ,
i
.
s
l
a ost in r ht acste or fre e. B M To a o hs oso nh h
cni t a i to ce h cus ord s u r h ms n a n h wta i
tuo l g
s
t
rs t .
s
t
t s
acst cus o u ut sl mws c a y mee
ce o or t pr e h ci a a uli pdd
s
t
s i a
tl
.
O gneut n po dfr mca s f r u o sti m et rc vlg
r o rg a os rv e oa ehn m o o -ft en a soee eea
e
li
i
i
t -a
t
i
l
a i ac o O gna.Se r A m.R211903() 21) W l M To a o
s s ne n r ol w e O d i . 9-3-056( 07
st
e
.
n
. he r h ms n
i .
s
aee h cn c d e tna ei O gnh de n poie n e dne fwo e
l gs e o a e pne ir sn r o e os o rvd ay v ec o h h
l
tt
i t i
e ,
t
i
cn c d n we H eh i ic drqe s h h apa t hv snttea l r y
o a e ad hn i x bsn ueeus ta e pe so ae e ohl wi a
tt
. s it l
t t
r
t
br
i F r a ow c hrc vdepneida nteeus dm e a w e oaaa e
nl i ,
o d t h h eee e rsossn cighrqe e a rl e n vlb
i
i
it
t
ti s r t i l
otah cu o yeus m e a r a do F r aa. H po ds o v ect so
rh e o d n rqe a rl et t l i l w e rve n e dneo h w
t
l l
t ti s l e
od
i
i
hf l wdO gn pou s o o -ft e n a soee eO gna m e a.
e o o e r o’ rcr fr u o st i m et rc v r ol w a rl
l
e s
e
t -a
t
i
e
ti s
Acr n ybcueD edn hv so n M To a o hd m hd orc v g h
cod g, eas e na s ae h w r h ms n a a e o free i te
il
f
t
.
s
t
in

1 –OI I NA DO D R
7 PNO N R E

cni t nl- q rd s s nead eas M To a o hs oso n hs
ost i a y eu e a i ac n bcue r h ms n a n h w toe
tuo l r i
st ,
.
s
t
poeu sw e oaaa eoh m D edn a e ietjd mna amt ol w n
rcdr e n vlb t i, e na sr nt doug e s ae fa o
e r t i l
f
t e tl
t
tr
toesus
hsi e
s .
C N L SO
O C UI N
Frhraost e aoeIG A TD e dn’ M in o S m ay ug e [2
oteesnstd bv
a
, R N e na s o o fr u m Jd mn 8]
f
t
t
r
t
adDSMS M To a o’ ci sw h r u c
n I I S r h ms n l m i p jd e
.
s s a
t e i.
II S O D R D
T S O R E E.
D T Dh 2d dy f ue21
A E ts n
i
a oJn 07
,
.

/ M he W Ms a_____
s i a . o mn____
/ c l
MC A L W M SM N
IHE . O A
C e U tdStsDt cJde
h f ne t e irt ug
i
i
a
si

1 –OI I NA DO D R
8 PNO N R E